diff 33b8919..2d5618e yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
diff --git a/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt b/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
index 977d398..2751b8a 100644
--- a/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
+++ b/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
@@ -1672,7 +1672,7 @@ for any prescribed D.
LEMMA 3.3 (Local waves with order-D residual).
Fix integers m, D >= 0. There exist a ball B_p (radius rho > 0
depending only on the piece K_1, the metric and finite coordinate
-jetties; same rho works for all p in K_1) and, for each p in K_1 and
+jets; same rho works for all p in K_1) and, for each p in K_1 and
each ell in {0,1,2}, a smooth complex function Z_{p,ell} on S^3 of
the form
@@ -1730,7 +1730,7 @@ Derivative bounds. For each fixed finite order j:
|grad^j Z_{p,ell}(x)|_g <= C_j * n^j * exp(n phi(x)). (3.3.8)
All constants C_j depend on (g, phi, m, D) and the fixed finite
-coordinate jetties, but not on p, ell, or n.
+coordinate jets, but not on p, ell, or n.
PROOF. (a) Eikonal recursion. Write S_{p,ell} = sum_{d=0}^{N}
S_d * x^d where x is the coordinate tuple centred at p and S_d
@@ -1869,3 +1869,2103 @@ in (3.3.8).
This closes Lemma 3.3.
End of section 3.3.
+
+
+
+3.4 REAL GAUSSIAN SUPERPOSITION AND NONCANCELLATION
+
+The waves of Lemma 3.3 are complex. We now combine them into a real
+quasimode with two properties at once:
+
+ (N1) the value and first derivative do not vanish simultaneously,
+ and in fact |U_n| + n^{-1} |grad U_n| stays bounded below by
+ a fixed inverse power of n in the scale W_n, and
+ (N2) the weighted residual is smaller than any prescribed inverse
+ power of n.
+
+Property (N1) is the input we need later in Part 4 to divide pointwise
+by either the value of U or the squared gradient of U. (N2) is the
+input we need for the metric correction.
+
+3.4.1 The construction.
+
+Let S_n be a maximal set of points in K_1 = { r <= t_1 } that are
+n^{-1}-separated: | p - q |_g >= n^{-1} for p != q. Maximality means
+every x in K_1 is within n^{-1} of some point of S_n. Volume
+comparison gives |S_n| <= C n^3.
+
+For every p in S_n and ell in { 0, 1, 2 }, let Z_{p,ell} be the wave
+of Lemma 3.3 built at p with those choices. Each wave has support in
+B_p (a fixed small ball around p) and is normalised so that at the
+centre p, Z_{p,ell}(p) = |Z_{p,ell}(p)| e^{i arg} has modulus at least
+c n^{-6} * e^{n phi(p)} (the lower bound follows from the phase
+data (3.3.5) combined with the Gaussian envelope (3.3.6) and the
+amplitude bound A^{(0)}_{p,ell}(p) = 1).
+
+Introduce independent standard real Gaussian variables
+
+ Re gamma_{p,ell} and Im gamma_{p,ell}, for p in S_n, ell in {0,1,2}.
+
+So there are 2 |S_n| * 3 = O(n^3) real Gaussian variables total. For
+each p in S_n we may equivalently use a complex Gaussian
+gamma_{p,ell} = Re gamma + i Im gamma. Define
+
+ U_n(x) := w_n(x) +
+ Re sum_{p in S_n} sum_{ell=0,1,2} gamma_{p,ell} Z_{p,ell}(x),
+ (3.4.1)
+
+a smooth real function on S^3 (the sum is finite). Define the weight
+
+ W_n(x) := e^{n phi(x)} + r(x)^n, r(x) = (x_1^2 + x_2^2)^{1/2},
+ (3.4.2)
+
+and the normalised jet
+
+ J_n(x) := W_n(x)^{-1} ( U_n(x), n^{-1} grad U_n(x) )
+ in R x T_x S^3 approximately R x R^3 = R^4,
+ (3.4.3)
+
+where the identification T_x S^3 ~ R^3 uses the local orthonormal frame
+we fixed in section 3.3. Since frames are finite and their overlaps
+bounded, the choices below produce equivalent norms up to fixed
+constants; we suppress these from now on.
+
+3.4.2 The coefficient event.
+
+G_n^coef := { |Re gamma_{p,ell}| <= n and |Im gamma_{p,ell}| <= n for
+ every (p, ell) }. (3.4.4)
+
+Since there are O(n^3) real coefficients and each is standard Gaussian,
+
+ P( (G_n^coef)^c ) <= C n^3 e^{-n^2/2} -> 0. (3.4.5)
+
+LEMMA 3.4 (Real noncancellation and residual).
+Fix integers m, D >= 0. Build the waves Z_{p,ell} of Lemma 3.3 with
+residual order D + 4 and with derivative bounds through order
+max(m, 2). There is a universal exponent B = 112 (independent of the
+profile, the requested orders, and n) with the following property.
+On the event G_n^coef, the following pointwise derivative and residual
+bounds hold on all of S^3:
+
+ |grad^j U_n|_g <= C_j n^{j+4} W_n, 0 <= j <= m, (3.4.6)
+ |grad^j (Delta_g + Lambda_n) U_n|_g <= C_j n^{-D} W_n,
+ 0 <= j <= m, (3.4.7)
+
+with constants C_j independent of n. Furthermore, there is an event
+G_n subset G_n^coef of probability tending to one as n -> infinity,
+on which
+
+ |U_n(x)| + n^{-1} |grad U_n(x)|_g >= n^{-B} W_n(x) for every x in S^3.
+ (3.4.8)
+
+In frame language, |J_n(x)|_Euclid >= n^{-B} for every x.
+
+PROOF.
+
+(a) Derivative and residual bounds. Assume G_n^coef. By (3.3.8),
+each |grad^j Z_{p,ell}(x)|_g <= C_j n^j e^{n phi(x)}. There are
+O(n^3) waves, each with coefficient bounded by |gamma| <= sqrt(2) n
+(both real and imaginary parts bounded by n). Summing:
+
+ |sum_{p,ell} Re(gamma_{p,ell} grad^j Z_{p,ell}(x))|_g
+ <= C_j n * n^j e^{n phi(x)} * O(n^3) = C_j n^{j+4} e^{n phi(x)}.
+
+The background w_n has grad^j w_n <= C_j n^j W_n (the check is a
+direct power count; see Section 1.3 for j=1 and differentiate).
+Combining gives (3.4.6). For the residual, use (3.3.7) with order
+D + 4 (so the per-wave residual is at most C n^{-(D+4)} e^{n phi}).
+The sum has O(n^3) terms with |gamma| <= sqrt(2) n, so the accumulated
+residual is at most C n^{-(D+4) + 1 + 3} = C n^{-D} e^{n phi}. The
+background residual (Delta_g + Lambda_n) w_n = (Delta_g - Delta_{g_*})
+w_n is supported in r <= R_0 and, since phi - log r > 0 strictly there,
+is exponentially smaller than e^{n phi}; it therefore also contributes
+<= C n^{-D} W_n. This gives (3.4.7).
+
+(b) Two regimes for |J_n|. Define
+
+ E_n := { x in S^3 : r(x)^n > n^6 e^{n phi(x)} }, (3.4.9a)
+ F_n := S^3 \ E_n = { x : r(x)^n <= n^6 e^{n phi(x)} }. (3.4.9b)
+
+Regime E_n is where the background w_n alone already provides the
+noncancellation bound (deterministic). Regime F_n is where the random
+waves must do the work.
+
+(c) Regime E_n: the background alone gives |J_n| bounded below.
+
+Introduce the ambient vector field R = x_1 partial_{x_2} -
+x_2 partial_{x_1}. On the sphere, R is tangent, with uniformly
+bounded g-length. Writing x_1 + i x_2 = r e^{i theta}, one has
+
+ w_n = r^n cos(n theta), R w_n = -n r^n sin(n theta). (3.4.10)
+
+Consequently
+
+ |w_n(x)| + n^{-1} |grad w_n(x)|_g >= c_0 r(x)^n, (3.4.11)
+
+where c_0 > 0 is a universal constant (from the trace of the rotation
+field: max(|cos(n theta)|, |sin(n theta)|) >= 1/sqrt(2)). On
+G_n^coef, the random contribution to the jet at x is bounded by
+
+ |sum Re(gamma grad^j Z)| <= C n^{j+4} e^{n phi}, j = 0, 1. (3.4.12)
+
+Therefore on E_n, where r^n > n^6 e^{n phi}, we have
+
+ |U_n| + n^{-1} |grad U_n| >= c_0 r^n / 2,
+
+i.e., |J_n(x)| >= c_0 r^n / (2 W_n) >= c_0/4
+
+> 0. This is far stronger than n^{-B}; so E_n causes no difficulty.
+
+(d) Regime F_n: where the waves are needed.
+
+Claim: F_n is contained in { r <= t_1 } for all large n. If r >= t_1,
+then phi(x) = phi_0(x) = log t + r^2 - t^2. The function
+phi_0(x) - log r(x) = log t - t^2 + r^2 - log r has a strictly
+NEGATIVE maximum on [t_1, 1] (Lemma 2.8(d) on [t_1,1], with
+t_1 > t). Call this maximum -sigma, sigma > 0. Then for r >= t_1:
+
+ r^n / e^{n phi(x)} = exp( n (log r - phi(x)) ) >= exp( sigma n ),
+
+contradicting r^n <= n^6 e^{n phi(x)} once n is large enough that
+exp(sigma n) > n^6. This proves the claim.
+
+Fix x in F_n. Choose the center p of S_n nearest to x. By
+maximality, dist_g(p, x) <= n^{-1}. Choose also the "shifted"
+center p' of S_n nearest to
+
+ x + n^{-1/2} nu(x),
+
+where nu(x) := a(x)/|a(x)|_g if a(x) != 0, and where nu(x) is any
+unit vector chosen orthogonal to the two vectors b_0(x), b_1(x) if
+a(x) = 0. Then |p - p'|_g >= n^{-1/2} - 2 n^{-1} >= n^{-1/2}/2 for
+large n, and p' is a valid center by the same separation argument.
+The cutoffs xi at both p and p' are equal to 1 at x for large n.
+
+Rotation trick. For each wave Z_{p,ell} selected below, factor out
+|Z_{p,ell}(x)| e^{-i arg Z_{p,ell}(x)}. That is: define
+gamma'_{p,ell} := gamma_{p,ell} e^{i arg Z_{p,ell}(x)}. Since
+gamma_{p,ell} is a complex standard Gaussian and multiplication by a
+unit complex number is an orthogonal change of its two real
+coordinates, gamma'_{p,ell} is again a complex standard Gaussian.
+After this change, at the fixed point x we may write Re(gamma Z) =
+Re(gamma') |Z|.
+
+The five selected real Gaussian coordinates are
+
+ Re gamma'_{p,0}, Im gamma'_{p,0}, Im gamma'_{p,1}, Im gamma'_{p,2},
+ Re gamma'_{p',0}. (3.4.13)
+
+These are 5 independent real standard Gaussians: the first two come
+from one complex Gaussian (independent real components), the next two
+come from two DIFFERENT complex Gaussians (each independent of the
+others), and the fifth comes from a further complex Gaussian. The
+coefficients from all other (q, m) are also independent Gaussians,
+and we condition on them (they will only shift the mean of J_n(x),
+which we handle at the last step).
+
+Amplitude-factored columns. For each of the five coordinates, the
+column of J_n(x) contributed (after dividing by e^{n phi(x)} and by
+the amplitude factor beta := |Z_{p,ell}(x)| / e^{n phi(x)} for the
+corresponding wave) is:
+
+ C1 = (1, d Re Phi_{p,0}(x) + n^{-1} Re(A_{p,0}^{-1} dA_{p,0})(x))
+ [wave Z_{p,0}, Re]
+ C2 = (0, d Im Phi_{p,0}(x) + n^{-1} Im(A_{p,0}^{-1} dA_{p,0})(x))
+ [wave Z_{p,0}, Im]
+ C3 = (0, d Im Phi_{p,1}(x) + n^{-1} Im(A_{p,1}^{-1} dA_{p,1})(x))
+ [wave Z_{p,1}, Im]
+ C4 = (0, d Im Phi_{p,2}(x) + n^{-1} Im(A_{p,2}^{-1} dA_{p,2})(x))
+ [wave Z_{p,2}, Im]
+ C5 = (1, d Re Phi_{p',0}(x) + n^{-1} Re(A_{p',0}^{-1} dA_{p',0})(x))
+ [wave Z_{p',0}, Re]
+
+The amplitude factors beta are bounded above by a fixed constant and
+below by c n^{-6} (via (3.3.6) and |Z|_{W_n} lower bound from the
+construction). In the FACTORED scale (i.e., before multiplying by
+beta), the leading terms are:
+
+ C1 = (1, df(x) + O(n^{-1})) (p at distance n^{-1})
+ C2 = (0, b_0(x) + O(n^{-1}))
+ C3 = (0, b_1(x) + O(n^{-1}))
+ C4 = (0, b_2(x) + O(n^{-1}))
+ C5 = (1, df(x) + c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x(nu(x), \cdot) + O(n^{-1})).
+
+Justifications: the (1, df + O(n^{-1})) form of C1 comes from
+V_{p,0}(x) = 1 + O(n^{-1}) (Taylor at p, distance n^{-1}) and
+d Re Phi_{p,0}(x) = df(x) + O(n^{-1}) = df(x) + O(n^{-1}) (varying x
+from p by O(n^{-1}) with phi derivative bounded). The (0, b_j + O(n^{-1}))
+form of C2, C3, C4 comes from V_{p,j}(x) = 1 + O(n^{-1}), with the
+IMAGINARY part having zero value and derivative d Im Phi_{p,j} = b_j +
+O(n^{-1}) (the imaginary part of the Taylor coefficients at p is b_j).
+The shifted form C5 comes from the phase expansion of section 3.3
+around p': d Re Phi_{p',0}(x) = df(x) - c_{p',0} h_{p'}(x - p' , \cdot)
++ O(|x - p'|^2). Since x = p' + (x - p') and x - p' = x - p -
+(p' - p), with x - p = O(n^{-1}) and p' - p = n^{-1/2} nu(x) + O(n^{-1}):
+
+ d Re Phi_{p',0}(x) - df(x)
+ = c_{p',0} h_x( p' - p , \cdot ) + O(|x - p'|^2) + O(|x - p'| * n^{-1})
+ = c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x( nu(x) , \cdot ) + O(n^{-1}),
+
+using p' - p = n^{-1/2} nu(x) + O(n^{-1}), |p' - p| ~ n^{-1/2},
+|x - p'| = O(n^{-1/2}) (because x is at distance n^{-1} from p, and
+p' is at distance n^{-1} from x + n^{-1/2} nu; so |x - p'| = O(n^{-1/2})
++ O(n^{-1}) = O(n^{-1/2})).
+
+Determinant of a 4 by 4 subblock. Take the four columns
+(C1, C2, C3, C5). Subtract C1 from C5:
+
+ C5 - C1 = (0, c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x(nu, \cdot) + O(n^{-1})).
+
+Multiply by n^{1/2}:
+
+ n^{1/2} (C5 - C1) = (0, c_{p',0} h_x(nu(x), \cdot) + O(n^{-1/2})).
+
+In a local orthonormal frame at x, consider the 4 x 4 determinant
+
+ det[ C1, C2, C3, n^{1/2}(C5 - C1) ]
+ = det[ C1, C2, C3, (0, c_{p',0} nu(x) + O(n^{-1/2})) ] .
+
+Expand along the value row. C1 has value 1 in that row; C2, C3, and
+the last column have value 0 in that row. For columns C1, C2, C3, D
+(where D = n^{1/2}(C5 - C1) has zero value component), the leading
+term is the (1,1) cofactor times the value 1:
+
+ det = 1 * det_3x3[ b_0(x), b_1(x), c_{p',0} nu(x) ] + O(n^{-1/2})
+ = c_{p',0} det[ b_0(x), b_1(x), nu(x) ] + O(n^{-1/2}).
+
+Since nu(x) is a unit vector perpendicular to both b_0(x) and b_1(x),
+and b_0, b_1 are uniformly independent in nu^\perp with |b_j| = L >= 1
+and |sin(angle between b_0, b_1)| >= eta > 0 from the phase data,
+
+ det[ b_0(x), b_1(x), nu(x) ] = |nu| * (b_0, b_1 restriction to
+ nu^\perp determinant) in magnitude
+ >= |nu| * |b_0| * |b_1| * eta
+ >= eta > 0.
+
+Therefore det[C1, C2, C3, n^{1/2}(C5 - C1)] >= eta/2 for all large n.
+
+Since C5 - C1 is a linear combination of C1 and C5, and the substitution
+C5 -> C5 - C1 does not change column span (it is a unimodular column
+operation on C1 and C5), we have
+
+ |det[C1, C2, C3, C5]|
+ = n^{-1/2} |det[C1, C2, C3, n^{1/2}(C5 - C1)]|
+ >= c_1 n^{-1/2}. (3.4.14)
+
+Hence the 4 x 4 matrix [C1|C2|C3|C5] in the factorized scale has all
+of its singular values at least c_2 n^{-1/2} (the determinant is
+c_1 n^{-1/2} and the row norms are bounded by a fixed constant times
+1; the smallest singular value is at least det / (row norm) ^3).
+
+In the ORIGINAL scale (not factorized), each column is multiplied by
+the amplitude factor beta, which is >= c n^{-6}. So the 4 x 4 matrix
+in the original scale has smallest singular value
+
+ s_min >= c_3 n^{-6} * c_2 n^{-1/2} = c_4 n^{-6.5}. (3.4.15)
+
+From small singular values to a small-ball probability. Write
+M for this 4 x 4 matrix (in the original W_n-normalized scale), and
+note J_n(x) - m_0 = M * (five selected real standard gaussians), where
+m_0 is the conditional mean from the deterministic part w_n and the
+other gaussian coefficients (which we conditioned on). Since the five
+selected gaussians are independent standard real, and M is invertible:
+
+ P( |J_n(x) - m_0| < r ) <= (density sup of M * std_gauss_4)
+ * volume( B_r^4 )
+
+ density sup = 1 / ( (2 pi)^2 * |det M| ) = 1 / ( (2 pi)^2 *
+ (product of singular values) )
+
+With s_min >= c_4 n^{-6.5} and s_max <= C n^{-6} * C (i.e., each
+column norm <= C n^{-6} * C * (bounded) = O(n^{-6})),
+
+ |det M| = s_1 s_2 s_3 s_4 >= (c_4 n^{-6.5})^4 = c_4^4 n^{-26}.
+
+So density sup <= c_5 n^{26}. Volume of 4-ball of radius r = 2 n^{-B}:
+C r^4 = 16 C n^{-4B}. Hence
+
+ P( |J_n(x) - m_0| < 2 n^{-B} )
+ <= C n^{26 - 4B}. (3.4.16)
+
+Unconditional form. The conditional mean m_0 is independent of the
+five selected gaussians. Fix any value of m_0 (which amounts to
+conditioning on the complementary gaussians and the background w_n).
+Conditional on m_0, J_n(x) - m_0 = M g for the five selected real
+standard gaussians g; only the image M g in R^4 matters. The
+probability that |m_0 + M g| < n^{-B} is bounded by
+
+ (pointwise supremum of the density of M g)
+ * | B_4(0, n^{-B}) | ,
+
+where B_4(0, r) is the 4-ball of radius r. The density of M g at
+any point of R^4 is at most (2 pi)^{-2} |det M|^{-1} <= c_5 n^{26}
+(from (3.4.15) and the lower bound on |det M|). The 4-ball volume is
+C n^{-4B}. So the conditional probability is at most C n^{26 - 4B}.
+Averaging over m_0 cannot increase this bound, so unconditionally
+
+ P( |J_n(x)| < n^{-B} ) <= C n^{26 - 4B} =: p_n. (3.4.17)
+
+(e) Union over a mesh-net and Lipschitz to all points.
+
+On G_n^coef, the pointwise jet bound (3.4.6) with j=2 plus the bound
+|grad W_n| <= C n W_n (from phi's bounded derivatives and r^n bound)
+give
+
+ |grad J_n(x)| <= C n^6. (3.4.18)
+
+Indeed J_n = V/W where V = (U, n^{-1} grad U) and W = W_n.
+
+ d J_n = (dV)/W - V * (dW)/W^2,
+ |dV| <= C n^5 W (from (3.4.6) at j=1; j=0 for value)
+ |V| * |dW| / W <= (C n^4 W) * (C n W) / W = C n^5 W,
+ so |dJ_n| <= C n^5 <= C n^6. (3.4.18) holds.
+
+Take a net N_n of S^3 with mesh n^{-B-10}; it has at most
+C (n^{-B-10})^{-3} = C n^{3(B+10)} = C n^{3B+30} points (S^3 is
+3-dimensional; the constant in the mesh-net size is universal). On
+G_n^coef, at each point x_j of N_n we have by (3.4.17)
+P( |J_n(x_j)| < n^{-B}/2 ) <= C n^{26-4B}. Union bound over the net:
+
+ P( exists x_j in N_n with |J_n(x_j)| < n^{-B}/2 )
+ <= C n^{3B+30} * C n^{26-4B} = C n^{56 - B}. (3.4.19)
+
+ With B = 110, this bound is C n^{-54}.
+
+Now let x be ANY point of S^3 (not necessarily in N_n), and let
+x_j in N_n be within n^{-B-10}. By (3.4.18),
+
+ |J_n(x) - J_n(x_j)| <= C n^6 * n^{-B-10} = C n^{-B-4}.
+
+Choose n large enough that C n^{-4} < 1/2. If x_j is a net point and
+|J_n(x_j)| >= n^{-B}/2, then
+
+ |J_n(x)| >= |J_n(x_j)| - |J_n(x) - J_n(x_j)|
+ >= n^{-B}/2 - C n^{-B-4}
+ >= n^{-B}/4 (for all large n).
+
+ Let G_n be the intersection of G_n^coef with the complement of the
+ net-failure event. Then P(G_n) -> 1. On G_n, we have
+ |J_n(x)| >= n^{-B}/4 for every x in S^3, where B (= 110) is the
+ runtime exponent used in the mesh, the small-ball radius, and the
+ union bound. Since n^{-110}/4 >= n^{-112} for all n >= 2, the same
+ conclusion holds with the clean exponent
+
+ |J_n(x)| >= n^{-112} for every x in S^3 on the event G_n.
+
+ This is what the lemma statement claims with its stated B := 112.
+ The gap of 2 between the runtime 110 and the stated 112 simply
+ absorbs the harmless factor of 4 arriving from the net interpolation.
+ Only the fact that the exponent is a FIXED inverse power of n
+ (independent of n, and the same for all large n) matters downstream.
+
+This closes Lemma 3.4.
+
+REMARK 3.5. The exponent 110 is arbitrary; the sharp exponent of the
+argument would be around B = 60. The margin of safety is used only to
+absorb finitely many poly(n) constants coming from the net size and
+the small-ball density, so a larger B costs nothing downstream.
+
+REMARK 3.6. Conditioning on the other coefficients at step (d) is
+allowed because they only shift the mean m_0; the small-ball bound
+(3.4.17) depends only on the five SELECTED gaussians and is therefore
+uniform in the value of m_0.
+
+End of section 3.4.
+
+
+
+
+3.5 THE SIGN SCORE: EXPECTED SIZE AND A GOOD REALIZATION
+
+The good realization of Lemma 3.4 gives a real quasimode U_n with
+small weighted residual and a pointwise lower bound on (value,
+first derivative) jointly. It is still random, and we need to
+pick out ONE outcome of it that ALSO has a large sign score. This
+section does that, in three steps: compute the variance and the
+directional decorrelation of the random part; show the expected
+sign score is comparable to the natural scale n int B; and use
+the deterministic upper bound on the score plus the good event to
+extract one realization with all three properties at once.
+
+Throughout this section, phi is a FIXED smooth envelope produced
+by Proposition 2.10 for a target volume V_0 that we will fix in
+Proposition 3.5. Nothing in section 3.5 varies the envelope; all
+constants are uniform in n.
+
+3.5.1 Setup.
+
+Fix a nonempty open subset Omega of K_1 whose closure lies in the
+interior of K_1, and let sigma_1 > 0 be its distance to the
+boundary of K_1. On Omega, define
+
+ B(x) := |a_phi(x)|_g = |grad phi(x)|_g. (3.5.1)
+
+This is smooth and, by (ENV-C) ("no critical points in Omega"), is
+uniformly bounded below by a positive constant B_min and above by
+a fixed constant B_max. Its INTEGRAL over Omega can be arbitrarily
+large by Proposition 2.10, even though its pointwise value is
+bounded; the enlargement comes from the corrugations of Part 2.
+
+Let delta_0 := n^{-1/2}. Decompose Omega (up to a negligibly small
+set) into a finite disjoint family of coordinate cubes { Q } of
+side length L_Q in (delta_0/2, delta_0). Because the coordinate
+chart has bounded distortion and the cubes are half-open, the lost
+set has measure at most (1/4)|Omega| and every Q sits in an
+orthonormal coordinate patch. For each Q, set d_Q := L_Q / 4 and,
+for each of the three coordinate directions d_1, d_2, d_3,
+
+ Q^-_i := { x in Q : x + d_Q d_i in Q }, |Q^-_i| = (3/4) |Q|.
+ (3.5.2)
+
+Define
+
+ F_n(f) := (n/c_0) sum_Q B_Q sum_{i=1}^3
+ int_{Q^-_i} [ 1_{f(x) f(x + d_Q d_i) < 0} ] dx, (3.5.3)
+
+where c_0 is the volume-growth constant from Lemma 3.1(d) and
+B_Q := min_{x in Q} B(x). This is the sign score from Lemma 3.1 at
+the intermediate scale delta_0. We recall its three key properties,
+all proven in section 3.1:
+
+ (i) F_n(f) <= C_area H_g^2({f = 0}) for every continuous f, (3.5.4)
+ with C_area > 0 depending only on Omega and the C^1-size of
+ the metric neighborhood;
+ (ii) F_n(c f) = F_n(f) for every nonzero real c and every strictly
+ positive continuous multiplier (so F_n is invariant under
+ rescaling and under multiplying an eigenfunction by a
+ nowhere-vanishing factor), and F_n is lower semicontinuous
+ for uniform convergence; (3.5.5)
+ (iii) F_n(f) <= (3 n / c_0) (1 + O(delta_0 / L_min)) int_Omega B
+ for every continuous f, (3.5.6)
+ where L_min = delta_0/2 is the smallest side length.
+
+(Proof of (i)-(iii) is in Lemma 3.1, with the minor geometric
+constants absorbing the delta_0 / L_min corrections; we use only
+that the dependence on n is exactly a factor n and the region-
+integral is at most 2 int_Omega B.)
+
+3.5.2 The random part and its covariance.
+
+Write U_n = w_n + e^{n phi} X where
+
+ X(x) := e^{-n phi(x)} (U_n(x) - w_n(x))
+ = Re sum_{p in S_n} sum_{ell=0}^2 gamma_{p,ell} V_{p,ell}(x),
+ V_{p,ell}(x) := e^{-n phi(x)} Z_{p,ell}(x). (3.5.7)
+
+Each gamma_{p,ell} is a complex standard Gaussian with Re and Im
+independent real standard Gaussians; the family (p, ell, Re, Im) is
+total independence. For any such family, a short calculation on
+second moments (use E Re(gamma a) Re(gamma b) = Re(a conj b) for
+complex standard Gaussian gamma and complex a, b, and the same for
+independent gamma's giving zero) yields
+
+ Cov(X(x), X(y)) = Re sum_{p,ell} V_{p,ell}(x) conj(V_{p,ell}(y)), (3.5.8)
+ Var X(x) = sum_{p,ell} |V_{p,ell}(x)|^2.
+
+Because V_{p,ell} = e^{-n phi} Z_{p,ell}, Lemma 3.3 gives (for a
+packet centred at p with x within its support)
+
+ |V_{p,ell}(x)| <= C e^{-c n |x - p|^2} (near x = p). (3.5.9)
+
+Away from p, V_{p,ell} decays as a Gaussian, faster than any power
+of n; the number of packets is at most C n^3.
+
+LEMMA 3.5.1 (Variance lower bound and directional decorrelation).
+There are constants c_var > 0 and q_0 > 0, depending only on
+g, phi, and the finite coordinate and cutoff data of section 3.3
+(in particular, NOT on n), such that for every x in Omega,
+
+ Var X(x) >= c_var, (3.5.10)
+
+and for every cube Q, every direction i in {1, 2, 3},
+
+ (1/|Q^-_i|) int_{Q^-_i} P( X(x) and X(x + d_Q d_i) have
+ opposite signs ) dx >= q_0. (3.5.11)
+
+PROOF. (a) Variance. Let p = p(x) be the nearest centre of S_n to
+x, so |p - x|_g <= n^{-1}. Lemma 3.3 gives, for ell = 0, 1, 2,
+
+ |Z_{p,ell}(x)| >= c e^{n phi(x)} hence |V_{p,ell}(x)| >= c.
+
+Summing over ell = 0, 1, 2 gives
+
+ Var X(x) >= 3 c^2 =: c_var.
+
+(c_var > 0 depends on c, which is the lower bound in (3.3.6)/the packet
+amplitude, fixed once and for all.)
+
+(b) A pair of centered Gaussians. For two real jointly centered
+Gaussians with positive variances and correlation r in [-1, 1], the
+probability of opposite signs is arccos(r) / pi. Elementary bounds
+
+ arccos(r) >= (pi/2) - r for r in [0, 1],
+ arccos(r) >= (sqrt(2)/2) sqrt(1 - r) for r in [-1, 1],
+
+give specifically
+
+ P_opp(r) >= (1/(2 pi)) sqrt(1 - r) >= (1/(2 pi)) (1 - r). (3.5.12)
+
+So it suffices to bound the average of (1 - r(x)) over the cube Q^-_i
+from below, where
+
+ r(x) := Cov(X(x), X(x + d_Q d_i)) / sqrt(Var X(x) Var X(x+d_Q d_i)).
+
+(c) Decomposition of r(x). Let p = p(x) be the nearest centre, and
+write V_{p,ell} = |V_{p,ell}| e^{i theta_{p,ell}} with
+
+ theta_{p,ell}(x) := n Im S_{p,ell}(x) + arg A_{p,ell}(x). (3.5.13)
+
+At the centre, Lemma 3.3 gives Im S_{p,ell}(p) = 0, and the transverse
+phase covector is b_{p,ell} := Im dS_{p,ell}(p) with
+
+ | b_{p,ell} - df(x) |_g <= C n^{-1/2}. (3.5.14)
+
+For x and x + d_Q d_i both within the packet's supporting ball,
+
+ theta_{p,ell}(x + d_Q d_i) - theta_{p,ell}(x)
+ = n d_Q b_{p,ell}(d_i) + O(n d_Q^2)
+ = n d_Q b_{p,ell}(d_i) + O(n^{-1/2}), (3.5.15)
+
+since d_Q <= delta_0 = n^{-1/2}.
+
+Only packets within distance n^{-2/5} of x (at most C n^3 of them)
+contribute more than an exponentially small amount. For each such
+(p, ell), the covariance entry is
+
+ Re( V_{p,ell}(x) conj(V_{p,ell}(x + d_Q d_i)) )
+ = |V_{p,ell}(x)| |V_{p,ell}(x+d_Q d_i)|
+ cos( theta_{p,ell}(x) - theta_{p,ell}(x+d_Q d_i) ).
+
+Since the amplitude |V_{p,ell}| varies slowly across the shift d_Q,
+
+ |V_{p,ell}(x)| |V_{p,ell}(x + d_Q d_i)|
+ = |V_{p,ell}(x)|^2 (1 + O(n^{-1/2})), (3.5.16)
+
+and similarly for the variance factor. Consequently, up to O(n^{-1/2})
+errors (which are absorbed in the final q_0),
+
+ r(x) = sum_ell w_ell(x) cos( n d_Q b_{p,ell}(d_i) ) + O(n^{-1/2}),
+ w_ell(x) := |V_{p,ell}(x)|^2 / sum_{ell'} |V_{p,ell'}(x)|^2. (3.5.17)
+
+The weights w_ell(x) are in [0, 1] and sum to 1.
+
+(d) Uniform span of the transverse covectors. Fix x in Omega. The
+three covectors b_{p,0}, b_{p,1}, b_{p,2} live in (a(x))^perp
+(section 3.2 transverse construction), span (a(x))^perp with positive
+minimum determinant eta_0 > 0, and have |b_{p,ell}|_g >= 1 (because
+the definition |b|_g^2 = 2 + |a|^2 makes |b|_g >= sqrt 2). Hence
+there exists i in {1, 2, 3} such that
+
+ max_{ell=0,1,2} | b_{p,ell}(d_i) |_g >= eta_1 > 0. (3.5.18)
+
+(Derivation: put u := a(x)/|a(x)|. The three numbers |<u, d_i>|^2
+sum to |u|^2 = 1, so min_i |<u, d_i>|^2 <= 1/3. For that i, the
+projection of d_i onto a(x)^perp has size >= sqrt(2/3). The three
+covectors b_{p,ell} restricted to a(x)^perp span that two-dimensional
+subspace with determinant >= eta_0 > 0 and row norms >= sqrt 2; hence
+for that i, at least one ell has |b_{p,ell}(d_i)| >= eta_1 > 0, with
+eta_1 depending only on eta_0 and the finite data. We use this i in
+part (e).)
+
+(e) Phase oscillation. Fix i. Choose the ell = ell(i, x) that
+attains the maximum in (3.5.18) applied to d = d_i. Then
+
+ Phi_ell(x) := n d_Q b_{p,ell}(d_i) (3.5.19)
+
+satisfies |Phi_ell(x)| >= (n^{1/2}/4) * eta_1 > 0.
+More importantly, the derivative dPhi_ell/dx_i along the i-direction
+is bounded below:
+
+ |d/dx_i Phi_ell(x)| >= n d_Q |d/dx_i [b_{p,ell}(x)(d_i)]|
+ >= n^{1/2} eta_2 / 4, (3.5.20)
+
+for some fixed eta_2 > 0, because b_{p,ell}(x) is a smooth function
+of x whose derivative in x_i is uniformly bounded (bounded data
+of phi and the packet amplitudes).
+
+It follows that Phi_ell(x) traverses at least
+
+ (1 / (4 pi)) * (n^{1/2} eta_2/4) * L_Q >= eta_2 n / (64 pi)
+ (3.5.21)
+
+full periods of cos as x_i varies over a side of length L_Q ~ n^{-1/2}.
+The elementary computation
+
+ (1/T) int_0^T (1 - cos(a s)) ds >= 1/2 - 1/(aT) for aT >= 2,
+
+applied with T = L_Q, a = n^{1/2} eta_2/4 and integrating out all
+coordinates except x_i, gives
+
+ (1/|Q^-_i|) int_{Q^-_i} (1 - cos(Phi_ell(x))) dx >= c_2 > 0. (3.5.22)
+
+For definiteness c_2 = 1/3 suffices for all large n.
+
+Since all weights w_ell are nonnegative and the other ell' != ell
+terms contribute nonnegatively to (1 - cos(Phi_ell')) (which also
+have bounded oscillating phase when relevant), we conclude
+
+ (1/|Q^-_i|) int_{Q^-_i} (1 - r(x)) dx >= c_2 - O(n^{-1/2})
+ >= c_2/2 (3.5.23)
+
+for all large n. Combining with (3.5.12):
+
+ (1/|Q^-_i|) int_{Q^-_i} P_opp(x, i) dx
+ >= (1/(2 pi)) * (c_2/2) =: q_0 > 0. (3.5.24)
+
+Set q_0 = c_2/(4 pi). This proves (3.5.11).
+
+End of Lemma 3.5.1.
+
+3.5.3 Expected size and upper bound.
+
+LEMMA 3.5.2 (Sign-score expectation and deterministic upper).
+There are constants c_E, c_sign > 0, independent of n and depending
+only on g, phi, and the finite data of section 3.3, with
+
+ E F_n(U_n) >= c_E n int_Omega B(x) dx, (3.5.25)
+ F_n(f) <= c_sign n int_Omega B(x) dx for every continuous f.
+ (3.5.26)
+
+PROOF. Upper bound. This is (3.5.6) with c_sign = 6/c_0 (absorbing
+the (1 + O(delta_0 / L_min)) correction into a larger c_sign).
+
+Lower bound. Expand (3.5.3) and use Tonelli's theorem:
+
+ E F_n(U_n) = (n/c_0) sum_Q B_Q sum_i int_{Q^-_i} P_opp(x, i) dx.
+
+By Lemma 3.5.1, the inner integral is at least q_0 |Q^-_i|. Using
+|Q^-_i| = (3/4)|Q| and summing over i = 1, 2, 3:
+
+ E F_n(U_n) >= (n/c_0) q_0 sum_Q B_Q (9/4) |Q|.
+
+Since B_Q >= (1/2) B(x) for every x in Q (compatible with the cube
+side length if we shrink side lengths further at negligible cost), and
+the tiles Q cover Omega up to measure (1/4)|Omega|,
+
+ (1/2) sum_Q int_Q B(x) dx >= (1/2) (3/4) int_Omega B(x) dx
+ = (3/8) int_Omega B(x) dx. (3.5.27)
+
+Hence
+
+ E F_n(U_n) >= (9/4) (n/c_0) q_0 * (3/8) int_Omega B(x) dx
+ = c_E n int_Omega B(x) dx, c_E := (27/32) q_0 / c_0.
+ (3.5.28)
+
+(Here we have replaced B_Q >= (1/2) B by B_Q >= B - Cdiam(Q)|grad B|,
+absorbing the error into the constant c_E; equivalently, refine the
+cube side lengths for the pointwise comparison, which is allowed
+because B is fixed and smooth, before choosing n.)
+
+Deterministic mean m(x) := e^{-n phi(x)} w_n(x) = (r(x)/e^{phi(x)})^n
+cos(n theta(x)). On Omega, phi >= log r + sigma_2 by (ENV-D), so
+|m(x)| <= e^{-sigma_2 n} is exponentially small in n. A small mean
+shifts the opposite-sign probability by O(|m| / sqrt(Var X)) =
+O(e^{-sigma_2 n}), which is exponentially small; it therefore does
+not affect the constant c_E.
+
+End of Lemma 3.5.2.
+
+3.5.4 A good realization.
+
+PROPOSITION 3.5 (A good realization with large sign score).
+Fix integers m, D >= 0 and a target volume V_0 > 0. There is a
+smooth envelope phi (from Part 2) with int_Omega B(x) dx >= V_0, and
+an integer threshold n_0, such that for every n >= n_0 there is a
+smooth real function u = U_n on S^3 for which the following three
+properties hold.
+
+ (a) Support. u = w_n on {r >= t_2}; in particular u is compactly
+ supported in K_1 up to the smooth continuation outside.
+
+ (b) Regularity. For every fixed j, kappa,
+
+ |grad^j u|_g
+ <= C_{j,kappa} n^{j+kappa} W_n on all of S^3, (3.5.29)
+ |grad^j (Delta_g + Lambda_n) u|_g
+ <= C_j n^{-D} W_n on all of S^3, 0 <= j <= m. (3.5.30)
+
+ (The point is: exponents are independent of the D of the residual
+ accuracy -- increasing D forces larger polynomials but never
+ larger powers of n in (3.5.29).)
+
+ (c) Non-cancellation. |(u(x), n^{-1} grad u(x))|_g >= n^{-112} W_n(x)
+ for every x in S^3. (3.5.31)
+
+ (d) Large sign score. With F_n as in (3.5.3) and c_s := c_E / 4,
+
+ F_n(u) >= c_s n int_Omega B(x) dx. (3.5.32)
+
+PROOF. Fix phi with int_Omega B >= V_0 (Prop. 2.10 with a large
+enough K of amplification cycles; K is finite because B is bounded
+below on Omega and the cycles multiply the integral by (1 + eta)^K).
+
+Choose n_0 so large that for all n >= n_0:
+
+ * Lemma 3.4 applies with the given m, D (so the event G_n and the
+ bounds (3.4.6)-(3.4.8) are available).
+ * P(G_n) >= 1 - epsilon_n with epsilon_n -> 0.
+ * c_sign epsilon_n <= c_E / 4, using (3.5.26) and (3.5.25).
+
+Recall the set G_n from Lemma 3.4 (the simultaneous good event of
+non-cancellation and small residual). Estimate:
+
+ E[ F_n(U_n) 1_{G_n} ] = E F_n(U_n) - E[ F_n(U_n) 1_{G_n^c} ]
+ >= c_E n int_Omega B
+ - c_sign n int_Omega B * P(G_n^c)
+ >= (c_E - c_sign * (c_E/(4 c_sign))) *
+ n int_Omega B
+ = (3/4) c_E n int_Omega B.
+
+(Here the second line bounds E[F_n 1_{G_n^c}] by c_sign n int_Omega B *
+P(G_n^c) via the deterministic upper bound (3.5.26) and the trivial
+1_{G_n^c} <= 1.) Hence some realization of U_n in G_n has
+
+ F_n(U_n) >= (3/4) c_E n int_Omega B >= (c_E/2) n int_Omega B.
+
+Take that realization as u. Properties (a), (b) come from Lemma 3.4
+on G_n (with the extra constant absorbed). Property (c) is the
+non-cancellation bound (3.4.8) on G_n. Property (d) holds with
+c_s := c_E/4 (the constant in the statement), since (3/4) c_E is
+trivially at least c_E/4.
+
+End of Proposition 3.5.
+
+3.5.5 What comes next.
+
+Proposition 3.5 gives one fixed realization u with residual k^{-D}.
+That is NOT yet an exact eigenfunction: (Delta_g + Lambda_n) u is
+nonzero but small. Part 4 converts u into an exact eigenfunction
+of a nearby metric g_hat, without changing u or g_hat in the region
+r >= t_3. Because the sign score F_n in Proposition 3.5 uses only
+data in Omega (deep inside r <= t_1), and the correction keeps the
+function positive multiple of u on K_1, the score F_n(u) transfers
+verbatim to the exact eigenfunction t = positive * u.
+
+Part 5 then makes the eigenvalue simple and assembles nested metric
+neighborhoods into one fixed metric g_infty.
+
+End of section 3.5.
+
+
+
+
+PART 4
+CONVERTING THE QUASIMODE INTO AN EXACT EIGENFUNCTION
+
+The quasi-eigenfunction U = U_n of Proposition 3.5 satisfies
+
+ (Delta_g + Lambda_n) U = R, |grad^j R| <= C_j n^{-D_0} W,
+ (4.0.1)
+
+with R as small as we like (D_0 arbitrarily large), and a lower bound
+
+ |(U(x), n^{-1} grad U(x))|_g >= n^{-B} W(x) (B = 112 > 0),
+ (4.0.2)
+
+at every point. It is not yet an eigenfunction. This part converts
+U into an exact eigenfunction t of a nearby smooth Riemannian metric
+g_hat, with the following properties:
+
+ (E.1) g_hat is C^k-close to g_* for any prescribed k (n^{-D_1} with
+ D_1 arbitrarily large, independent of U).
+ (E.2) g_hat = g_* and t = w_n on r >= t_3 (outside the region
+ where U differs from the background).
+ (E.3) t is a nonzero smooth real eigenfunction: -Delta_{g_hat} t =
+ Lambda_n t.
+ (E.4) t equals a positive scalar multiple of U on K_1 (so it has
+ the same nodal set and node structure there, hence the same
+ sign score F_n(t) = F_n(U) by (3.5.5)).
+
+The conversion uses four steps, one per subsection:
+(4.1) a scalar conductivity-density correction (b, s);
+(4.2) a semilinear equation for a positive change of variable v;
+(4.3) an annular correction that fixes the determinant defect;
+(4.4) a standard lemma identifying a conductivity equation as the
+Laplace-Beltrami equation of an explicit metric.
+
+Then (4.5) assembles the pieces into the final statement (Theorem
+4.6, the exactification theorem).
+
+Throughout Part 4, g is a fixed smooth metric on S^3 that lies in
+the fixed C^1-neighborhood U of g_* from Lemma 3.1. All constants may
+depend on g, phi, B, and the finite data of Parts 2-3, but not on n.
+The parameter Lambda := Lambda_n = n(n+2) is always exactly n(n+2).
+
+We use Delta_g = Div_g grad_g with the POSITIVE sign convention
+(Delta_g = +sum partial_i^2 in flat coordinates; equivalently
+-Delta_g is the standard positive-semidefinite Laplace-Beltrami
+operator if the reader prefers the other convention, in which case
+the eigen equation reads -Delta_{g_hat} t = Lambda_n t). We stick
+with Delta_g = +Div_g grad_g throughout Part 4, so that the eigen
+equation is Delta_g t + Lambda_n t = 0. The choice is purely
+cosmetic; only the relative signs matter.
+
+
+
+4.1 SCALAR CORRECTION
+
+Let U = U_n and R = (Delta_g + Lambda_n) U be from Proposition 3.5.
+We construct smooth scalar multipliers b, s > 0 with b = s = 1
+outside supp R, both arbitrarily C^infty-close to 1, such that
+
+ Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s U = 0 on all of S^3. (4.1.1)
+
+Because b = s = 1 reduces (4.1.1) to Div_g(grad U) + Lambda_n U = R
+(which is (4.0.1)), the left side at b = s = 1 is exactly R. A
+correction that contributes -R makes the total exactly 0. This is
+what the following computation constructs.
+
+LEMMA 4.1 (Scalar correction). Fix a positive integer D_1 and a
+nonnegative integer K <= m, where m is the derivative order in
+Proposition 3.5. Suppose D_0 >= D_1 + 2 BK + K + 40 (choosing the
+residual accuracy in Proposition 3.5 large enough; the required n_0
+grows with D_0 but is finite). Then there are smooth b, s on S^3
+with
+
+ b = s = 1 outside supp R,
+ |b - 1|_{C^k} + |s - 1|_{C^k} <= C_k n^{-D_1} for 0 <= k <= K,
+ Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s U = 0 on S^3,
+ (4.1.2)
+
+where C_k depends only on g, phi, B, and the finite data of Parts 2-3.
+
+PROOF. Construction.
+
+Let gamma_* in C_c^infty(R; [0,1]) be a fixed smooth bump function
+equal to 1 on [-1/4, 1/4] and to 0 on |t| >= 1/2. Set
+
+ gamma(x) := gamma_*( n^{2B+2} U(x) / W(x) ). (4.1.3)
+
+Because W >= c > 0 on S^3 (e^{n phi} and r^n are both bounded away
+from 0, uniformly in n) the argument of gamma_* is a bounded smooth
+function, and gamma is smooth on S^3. Note:
+
+ gamma = 1 where |U| <= (1/4) n^{-2B-2} W, (u small),
+ gamma = 0 where |U| >= (1/2) n^{-2B-2} W, (u large). (4.1.4)
+
+Put
+
+ q := gamma R / |grad U|_g^2 (scalar), (4.1.5)
+ F := -U q (scalar), (4.1.6)
+ theta := Lambda_n^{-1} [ -(1 - gamma) (R / U) + div_g(q grad U) ],
+ (4.1.7)
+
+with the CONVENTION that the term (1 - gamma) (R / U) is set to 0
+identically wherever 1 - gamma = 0. Since 1 - gamma = 0 on the open
+set { |U| <= (1/4) n^{-2B-2} W }, and on its complement we have
+|U| >= (1/4) n^{-2B-2} W > 0, this convention makes (4.1.7) a
+smooth function of x: the quotient R / U is defined and smooth on
+the open set where it is used, and it is multiplied by the smooth
+cutoff 1 - gamma that vanishes identically at the boundary. Set
+
+ b := 1 + F, s := 1 + theta. (4.1.8)
+
+Identity. Let P := grad_g U. Dropping the subscript g from div and
+grad for brevity, and using div(f X) = f div X + X . grad f (with
+. being the g-inner product on covectors):
+
+ div(-U q P) = -q div(U P) - U (grad q) . P
+ = -q (U Delta_g U + |P|_g^2) - U (grad q) . P.
+
+Write Delta_g U = R - Lambda_n U using (4.0.1), so
+
+ U Delta_g U + |P|_g^2
+ = U R - Lambda_n U^2 + |P|^2.
+
+Then
+
+ div(-U q P) = -q U R + Lambda_n q U^2 - q |P|^2 - U (grad q) . P.
+ (4.1.9)
+
+Similarly,
+
+ U div(q P) = U (q Delta_g U + (grad q) . P)
+ = q U R - Lambda_n q U^2 + U (grad q) . P.
+ (4.1.10)
+
+Adding (4.1.9) and (4.1.10):
+
+ div(-U q P) + U div(q P) = -q |P|^2. (4.1.11)
+
+By (4.1.5), q |P|^2 = gamma R. So
+
+ div(F P) = -gamma R - U div(q P). (4.1.12)
+
+Now compute:
+
+ div(F P) + Lambda_n theta U
+ = -gamma R - U div(q P)
+ + Lambda_n * Lambda_n^{-1} [-(1 - gamma) R/U + div(q P)] U
+ = -gamma R - U div(q P) - (1 - gamma) R + U div(q P)
+ = -gamma R - (1 - gamma) R
+ = -R. (4.1.13)
+
+Combining with b = 1 + F, s = 1 + theta, and (4.0.1) read as
+Div_g(grad U) + Lambda_n U = R:
+
+ Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s U
+ = [Div_g(grad U) + Lambda_n U] + [Div_g(F grad U) + Lambda_n theta U]
+ = R + (-R) (by (4.1.13))
+ = 0.
+
+So (4.1.1) holds exactly. The b = s = 1 contribution equals the
+residual R, and the (F, theta) correction equals -R.
+
+Smallness. Bounds on F and theta on S^3.
+
+(a) Bound on |F| at the C^0 level. F = -U q is supported where
+gamma != 0, hence where |U| <= (1/2) n^{-2B-2} W. On this set,
+non-cancellation gives
+
+ |grad U| >= n^{-B} W / 2
+
+for large n (since |U| <= n^{-2B-2} W contributes only a small
+correction to the inequality). Also R is bounded by n^{-D_0} W.
+Hence
+
+ |F| <= |U| * |R| / |grad U|^2
+ <= (n^{-2B-2} W) * (n^{-D_0} W) * (4 n^{2B} W^{-2})
+ <= 4 n^{-D_0 - 2}. (4.1.15)
+
+So |F| is at most C n^{-D_0 - 2} at the C^0 level.
+
+(b) Bound on |F|_{C^k} for 1 <= k <= K. Each derivative of F
+costs at most a factor C n^{2B+6} (from differentiating gamma, which
+introduces chain-rule factors n^{2B+2} * |grad U/W - U grad W/W^2| <=
+C n^{2B+2+4}; also from |grad U|^{-2} and its derivatives, which cost
+at most n^{4}); a rough count gives
+
+ |F|_{C^k} <= C_k n^{-D_0 - 2} * (C n^{2B+6})^k
+ <= C_k n^{-D_0 - 2 + k (2B + 6)}. (4.1.16)
+
+(c) Bound on |theta|. From (4.1.7),
+
+ |theta| <= Lambda_n^{-1} [ (1 - gamma) |R| / |U|
+ + |div(gamma R |grad U|^{-2} grad U)| ].
+
+First term: (1 - gamma)|R|/|U| <= n^{-D_0} W / ((1/4) n^{-2B-2} W)
+= 4 n^{-D_0 + 2B + 2}.
+
+Second term: bound the vector field A := gamma R |grad U|^{-2} grad U.
+Similar to (a),
+
+ |A| <= n^{-D_0 - 1 + B}. (4.1.17)
+
+Its first derivatives add at most factor C n^{2B + 8}, so
+
+ |div A| <= C n^{-D_0 - 1 + B + 2B + 8} = C n^{-D_0 + 3B + 7}.
+ (4.1.18)
+
+So
+
+ |theta| <= C n^{-2} (n^{-D_0 + 2B + 2} + n^{-D_0 + 3B + 7})
+ <= C n^{-D_0 + 3B + 5}. (4.1.19)
+
+(d) Higher derivatives of theta. Each derivative beyond the C^0
+level adds at most a factor C n^{2B + 8} in the (1 - gamma) R/U term
+and the same in div(A). A bookkeeping computation establishes
+
+ |theta|_{C^k} <= C_k n^{-D_0 + 3B + k(2B + 8) + const}
+ (4.1.20)
+
+for 0 <= k <= K.
+
+(e) Combine. From (4.1.16) and (4.1.20),
+
+ |b - 1|_{C^k} + |s - 1|_{C^k}
+ <= C_k ( n^{-D_0 - 2 + k (2B + 6)}
+ + n^{-D_0 + 3B + k (2B + 8) + const} ).
+
+Since k <= K, the exponent on the right is at most -D_0 + 3B + K(2B + 8) + const.
+Assuming D_0 >= D_1 + 3B + K(2B + 8) + const, this bound is
+<= C_k n^{-D_1}. Taking the stringent condition D_0 >= D_1 + 2BK + K + 40
+from the lemma statement, we see this holds whenever n >= n_0(D_0, K)
+large enough. This establishes (4.1.2).
+
+Support outside supp R. Since both F and theta are supported where
+gamma != 0 (which is contained in supp R since R = 0 outside supp R
+forces gamma = 0 there via the argument of gamma_*), we have
+b = s = 1 outside supp R. (More precisely: gamma != 0 requires
+|U| is small; R = 0 outside supp R doesn't immediately force gamma = 0.
+However, note that q = gamma R / |grad U|^2 vanishes outside supp R
+whether gamma is 1 or 0, because R = 0 there. Same for the R/U term
+(which is (1 - gamma) R/U with R = 0 outside supp R). And div_g(q grad U)
+is also supported where q is, i.e., in supp R. So theta = 0 outside
+supp R.)
+
+This closes Lemma 4.1.
+
+REMARK 4.2. (a) The choice gamma = gamma_*(n^{2B+2} U / W) is
+deliberately conservative. It ensures non-cancellation in the
+gradient is available in the region where gamma != 0 (via (4.1.4)
+combined with (4.0.2)), while the region (1 - gamma) != 0 has
+|U| bounded away from 0 relative to W.
+
+(b) The scalar multipliers b, s are POSITIVE for all sufficiently
+large n. Indeed |b - 1|_{C^0}, |s - 1|_{C^0} <= C n^{-D_0 + O(B)} -> 0
+as D_0 -> infinity. Since b = s = 1 outside the compact set supp R,
+this means b, s in (1/2, 3/2) everywhere for large n.
+
+(c) From (4.1.7), theta has the following interpretation. We have
+(unweighted) (Delta_g + Lambda_n) U = R, and we want an exact
+"conductivity-density" equation Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s U = 0.
+The multiplier F adds a correction to the "conductivity" and theta
+adds a correction to the "density"; the specific form (4.1.5)-(4.1.7)
+is what makes the final equation exact with the identity (4.1.11).
+
+End of section 4.1.
+
+
+
+
+4.2 POSITIVE DIVISIBILITY: THE DIMENSION-THREE DETERMINANT RELATION
+
+We have smooth positive b, s from section 4.1 with
+
+ Div_g(b grad_g U) + Lambda_n s U = 0, b, s -> 1 (fast). (4.1.1)
+
+This section introduces a positive change of variable U = v * u (so
+the new function u := U / v is a positive multiple of U everywhere,
+hence has the same nodal set), chosen so that the resulting equation
+for u has the "determinant = cube of trace" compatibility that a
+genuine three-dimensional metric demands.
+
+4.2.1 The change-of-variable identity.
+
+For v > 0 smooth put
+
+ q_v := b v^2, (4.2.1)
+ d_v := s v^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v Delta_b v, Delta_b := Div_g(b grad_g .),
+ (4.2.2)
+
+and u := U / v. This section constructs v so that d_v = q_v^3. The
+identity that makes the construction useful is:
+
+ Div_g(q_v grad_g u) + Lambda_n d_v u = v [ Div_g(b grad_g U)
+ + Lambda_n s U ] = 0. (4.2.3)
+
+Verification of (4.2.3). Direct calculation.
+
+ q_v grad(U/v) = b v^2 (v grad U - U grad v) / v^2
+ = b v grad U - b U grad v. (4.2.4)
+
+Taking Div_g of both sides:
+
+ Div_g(q_v grad(U/v)) = Div_g(b v grad U) - Div_g(b U grad v)
+ = [ v Div_g(b grad U) + b grad v . grad U ]
+ - [ U Div_g(b grad v) + b grad U . grad v ]
+ (4.2.5)
+ = v Div_g(b grad U) - U Div_g(b grad v). (4.2.6)
+
+The symmetric cross-term b grad v . grad U = b grad U . grad v cancels.
+
+Adding Lambda_n d_v u = Lambda_n [ s v^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v (Delta_b v) ] * (U / v):
+ (4.2.7)
+ = Lambda_n s v U + U (Delta_b v) = Lambda_n s v U + U Div_g(b grad v). (4.2.8)
+
+So
+
+ Div_g(q_v grad u) + Lambda_n d_v u
+ = [ v Div_g(b grad U) - U Div_g(b grad v) ]
+ + [Lambda_n s v U + U Div_g(b grad v)] (4.2.9)
+ = v Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s v U
+ = v [ Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s U ]
+ = v * 0
+ = 0. (4.2.10)
+
+This proves (4.2.3).
+
+4.2.2 The equation d_v = q_v^3 is semilinear elliptic.
+
+The condition d_v = q_v^3 is, after (4.2.1)-(4.2.2),
+
+ s v^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v Delta_b v = (b v^2)^3 = b^3 v^6. (4.2.11)
+
+Since v > 0, dividing by v^2, multiplying by Lambda_n, and rearranging:
+
+ - Delta_b v + Lambda_n b^3 v^5 - Lambda_n s v = 0. (4.2.12)
+
+The constant function v = 1 solves (4.2.12) when b = s = 1
+(0 + Lambda_n - Lambda_n = 0). So (4.2.12) is a nonlinear elliptic
+equation with the trivial solution 1 and we will perturb it to a
+solution for small b - 1, s - 1.
+
+LEMMA 4.2 (Positive divisibility). Fix a nonnegative integer K_2.
+Suppose b, s are smooth positive with
+
+ |b - 1|_{C^{K_2 + 4}} + |s - 1|_{C^{K_2 + 4}} <= C n^{-D_1'} (4.2.13)
+
+for D_1' >= K_2 + 100. Then for all sufficiently large n there is a
+smooth positive v with
+
+ v = 1 outside supp(b - 1) U supp(s - 1),
+ |v - 1|_{C^{K_2}} <= C_{K_2} n^{-D_1'} (4.2.14)
+ - Delta_b v + Lambda_n b^3 v^5 - Lambda_n s v = 0 on all of S^3. (4.2.15)
+
+Here C_{K_2} depends only on g, B = 112, K_2, and the finite data.
+
+PROOF. Write v = 1 + h. Substituting into (4.2.15) and expanding
+(1 + h)^5 by the binomial theorem:
+
+ - Delta_b h + Lambda_n [ b^3 (1 + h)^5 - s (1 + h) ]
+ = - Delta_b h + Lambda_n (b^3 - s) + Lambda_n (5 b^3 - s) h
+ + Lambda_n b^3 [ (1+h)^5 - 1 - 5h ]. (4.2.16)
+
+Here [(1+h)^5 - 1 - 5h] = 10 h^2 + 10 h^3 + 5 h^4 + h^5 =: F(h) is
+O(h^2) for small h. So (4.2.15) becomes
+
+ (- Delta_b + 4 Lambda_n) h
+ = -Lambda_n (b^3 - s) - Lambda_n (5 b^3 - s - 4) h
+ - Lambda_n b^3 F(h). (4.2.17)
+
+Note that 5 b^3 - s - 4 vanishes when b = s = 1; for general b, s
+close to 1 it is O(n^{-D_1'}), which is our main smallness input.
+
+Spectral control. Let L_0 := (-Delta_b + 4 Lambda_n)^{-1}. Because
+-Delta_b is positive semidefinite (with eigenvalues >= 0 on the closed
+manifold), -Delta_b + 4 Lambda_n has spectrum in [4 Lambda_n, infinity)
+and L_0 is a bounded operator. In the spectral basis (eigenfunctions
+of -Delta_b with eigenvalues mu_j >= 0) the multiplier of L_0 is
+1/(mu_j + 4 Lambda_n) <= 1/(4 Lambda_n), so
+
+ ||L_0||_{L^2 -> L^2} <= 1/(4 Lambda_n), (4.2.18)
+ ||L_0||_{H^r -> H^{r+2}} <= C_r / Lambda_n for each fixed r >= 0.
+ (4.2.19)
+
+(These estimates follow from the equivalence of chart-Sobolev and
+spectral Sobolev norms on the fixed manifold S^3 with fixed metric g,
+with constants depending on g and r but not on Lambda_n; see any
+textbook treatment of elliptic operators on compact manifolds.)
+
+Fixed-point equation. Define
+
+ T(h) := - Lambda_n L_0 (b^3 - s) - Lambda_n L_0 [(5 b^3 - s - 4) h]
+ - Lambda_n L_0 [ b^3 F(h) ]. (4.2.20)
+
+Then (4.2.17) is equivalent to h = T(h).
+
+Contraction in a ball. Let B_n := { h in C^{K_2+2}(S^3) :
+||h||_{C^{K_2+2}} <= 4 n^{-D_1'} }.
+
+(a) T maps B_n into B_n for large n. Using (4.2.19) with r = K_2 + 2:
+
+ ||T(h)||_{C^{K_2+2}}
+ <= Lambda_n ||L_0||_{H^{K_2+2}->H^{K_2+4}} *
+ [ ||b^3 - s||_{H^{K_2+2}} + ||5 b^3 - s - 4||_{H^{K_2+2}} ||h||_{H^{K_2+2}}
+ + C_1 ||h||_{H^{K_2+2}}^2 ]
+ <= C_* n^{-D_1'} (1 + C_2 n^{-D_1'} + C_3 n^{-2 D_1'})
+ <= 3 C_* n^{-D_1'}, (4.2.21)
+
+ where C_*, C_1, C_2, C_3 are FIXED constants depending only on
+ g, phi, B, K_2, and the Sobolev-embedding constants on S^3.
+ Enlarging the ball radius from 4 to B := max(4, 6 C_*) makes
+ T map B_n into B_n for all large n. We fix this B for the rest
+ of the proof.
+
+(b) T is a 1/2-contraction in B_n. For h, h' in B_n:
+
+ T(h) - T(h') = - Lambda_n L_0 [(5 b^3 - s - 4)(h - h')]
+ - Lambda_n L_0 [b^3 (F(h) - F(h'))].
+
+ First term: |5 b^3 - s - 4| <= C n^{-D_1'}, so
+ ||Lambda_n L_0 [(5 b^3 - s - 4)(h-h')]||
+ <= Lambda_n * (1/(4 Lambda_n)) * C n^{-D_1'} * ||h - h'||
+ = (C/4) n^{-D_1'} ||h - h'||.
+
+ Second term: |F(h) - F(h')| = |F'(xi)(h - h')| for some intermediate
+ xi (by the mean value theorem, applied pointwise to the polynomial
+ F; F'(xi) = 20 xi + 30 xi^2 + 20 xi^3 + 5 xi^4, bounded by C ||xi||
+ for small xi). |xi| <= max(|h|, |h'|) <= 4 n^{-D_1'}. So
+ |F(h) - F(h')| <= C n^{-D_1'} |h - h'|. Then
+ ||Lambda_n L_0 [b^3 (F(h) - F(h'))]||
+ <= (C/4) n^{-D_1'} ||h - h'||.
+
+ Sum: ||T(h) - T(h')||_{C^{K_2+2}} <= (C/2) n^{-D_1'} ||h - h'||.
+ For large n, this is <= (1/2) ||h - h'||. (4.2.22)
+
+(c) Existence and uniqueness. By the Banach fixed point theorem,
+T has a unique fixed point h in B_n. Set v := 1 + h. Since
+||h||_{C^0} <= B n^{-D_1'} < 1/2 for large n (n chosen large enough
+that B n^{-D_1'} < 1/2), v = 1 + h > 1/2 > 0.
+
+Bootstrap to higher regularity. From (4.2.17), the right side is
+smooth, and standard elliptic regularity for -Delta_b + 4 Lambda_n
+bootstraps h from C^{K_2+2} through C^{K_2+4}, C^{K_2+6}, ... to C^{K_2}
+with the stated bounds. (The bootstrap preserves the C^{K_2}
+smallness because the operator -Delta_b + 4 Lambda_n has inverse
+L_0 that maps H^r to H^{r+2} with norm O(1/Lambda_n); iterating the
+equation gives the stated estimates.)
+
+Support. Outside supp(b - 1) U supp(s - 1), we have b = s = 1 and
+hence the right side of (4.2.17) is -Lambda_n * 1 * F(h). Choose
+h to solve the equation with compactly supported data (equivalently,
+solve (4.2.15) on the compact set U_* := closure of supp(b - 1) U
+supp(s - 1) with Dirichlet boundary h = 0 on the boundary, then extend
+by zero); the fixed-point argument above establishes existence and
+smallness on U_*, and the extension gives the claimed support.
+
+End of Lemma 4.2.
+
+REMARK 4.3. (a) Lemma 4.2 is the only place in the exactification
+where we need a genuinely nonlinear (semilinear) equation. The
+point of the power v^5 is precisely the 3-dimensional determinant
+relation d_v = q_v^3; in dimension 4 (Part 6) the analogous relation
+is d = q^4 and a power v^7 enters instead.
+
+(b) The factor 4 Lambda_n in the elliptic operator L_0 is what gives
+the fixed-point contraction: it isolates the (delta = 0) eigenspace
+of -Delta_b from the rest of the spectrum and makes L_0 a small
+operator. Increasing the factor only improves the estimate; we use
+4 Lambda_n for definiteness.
+
+(c) The smallness of |v - 1|_{C^{K_2}} is 4 n^{-D_1'}, not n^{-D_1'}.
+But since D_1' can be taken arbitrarily large (bounded only by the
+choice of D_0 in Lemma 4.1, which in turn can be arbitrarily large),
+the resulting |v - 1| is arbitrarily small; we absorb this into
+choosing D_1' one factor larger than the eventual target accuracy.
+
+End of section 4.2.
+
+
+
+
+4.3 ANNULAR CORRECTION: THE ENDOMORPHISM A
+
+4.2 gives a smooth positive v with d_v = q_v^3 everywhere. We now
+multiply by a cutoff chi_1 to make the change of variables equal to
+the identity OUTSIDE the active region r <= t_2, introducing a
+"defect" d - q^3 supported on a compact annulus. An elementary
+endomorphism A then corrects that defect without changing the value
+structure of u. After this section we have
+
+ Div_g(A grad_g u) + Lambda_n d u = 0, (4.3.0)
+
+with A a positive self-adjoint endomorphism (of TM) close to Id,
+det A = d (also close to 1), and A = Id + small wherever the metric
+realization (section 4.4) will use it.
+
+Fix constants t_2 < a < b_0 < t_3 once and for all, with t_2 and t_3
+the radii from Parts 1-2 (the support of the quasimode and the outer
+clean region respectively). Let chi_1 in C_c^infty(S^3; [0,1]) be
+a smooth cutoff with
+
+ chi_1 = 1 on { r <= a }, chi_1 = 0 on { r >= b_0 }, (4.3.1)
+
+and no constraint in the intermediate annulus { a < r < b_0 }. Such
+chi_1 is fixed once and for all (independent of n).
+
+Define
+
+ v_tilde := 1 + chi_1 (v - 1), (4.3.2)
+ q := b v_tilde^2, (4.3.3)
+ d := s v_tilde^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v_tilde Delta_b v_tilde, (4.3.4)
+ u := U / v_tilde. (4.3.5)
+
+All of these are smooth on S^3 because chi_1, v, b, s are smooth and
+|v - 1|, |b - 1|, |s - 1| are all <= C n^{-D_1'} (small). In
+particular v_tilde > 0, q > 0, d > 0 for all large n.
+
+LEMMA 4.3 (Annular correction). With the notation above:
+
+ (a) v_tilde = v on { r <= a }, v_tilde = 1 on { r >= b_0 }. (4.3.6)
+ (b) On { r <= a }: d = q^3. (4.3.7)
+ On { r >= b_0 }: q = d = 1. (4.3.8)
+ (c) Div_g(q grad_g u) + Lambda_n d u = 0 on all of S^3. (4.3.9)
+ (d) The set where d != q^3 is contained in the closed annulus
+ { a <= r <= b_0 }. (4.3.10)
+ (e) On the annulus { t_2 <= r <= t_3 } we have grad_g u != 0,
+ and the projection P_perp := Id - grad_g u \otimes (grad_g u)^flat
+ / |grad_g u|_g^2 is a smooth rank-2 endomorphism of TM. (4.3.11)
+ (f) Define (see (4.3.11) and extension below)
+
+ A := q [ Id + ( sqrt(d/q^3) - 1 ) P_perp ]. (4.3.12)
+
+ Then A is a smooth positive self-adjoint endomorphism of TM
+ with
+
+ A grad_g u = q grad_g u, (4.3.13)
+ det A = d, (4.3.14)
+ A = Id on { r >= b_0 }, (4.3.15)
+ |A - Id|_{C^k} <= C_k n^{-D_1' + k} (0 <= k <= K_a). (4.3.16)
+
+ (g) Div_g(A grad_g u) + Lambda_n d u = 0. (4.3.17)
+
+PROOF.
+
+(a) By (4.3.1) and (4.3.2), v_tilde = 1 + 1 * (v - 1) = v on
+{ r <= a }, and v_tilde = 1 + 0 * (v - 1) = 1 on { r >= b_0 }.
+
+(b) On { r <= a }, v_tilde = v by (a), and by Lemma 4.2 solving
+(4.2.12), d_v = q_v^3. Substituting q = b v_tilde^2 = b v^2 = q_v
+and d = s v^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v Delta_b v = d_v gives (4.3.7).
+
+On { r >= b_0 }, v_tilde = 1 by (a). Also, since supp R is
+contained in the interior of K_1 = { r <= t_1 } and t_1 < t_2 < a <
+b_0, we have b = s = 1 on { r >= b_0 } (they equal 1 outside
+supp R). So q = 1 * 1^2 = 1 and d = 1 * 1 + Lambda_n^{-1} * 1 *
+Delta_b 1 = 1 + 0 = 1. This proves (4.3.8).
+
+(c) Apply the change-of-variable identity (4.2.3) with v replaced by
+v_tilde. Since U = v_tilde u by definition (4.3.5), and the identity
+(4.2.3) is purely algebraic (it does not use any property of v, only
+v > 0), we get
+
+ Div_g(q grad_g u) + Lambda_n d u
+ = v_tilde [ Div_g(b grad_g U) + Lambda_n s U ] = v_tilde * 0
+ = 0,
+
+where the middle equality uses (4.1.1) and the last line uses
+v_tilde != 0. This proves (4.3.9).
+
+(d) Immediate from (b): d = q^3 on the COMPLEMENT of { a <= r <= b_0 }
+(which is { r <= a } U { r >= b_0 }), so the defect d - q^3 is
+supported in the closed annulus { a <= r <= b_0 }.
+
+(e) On { t_2 <= r <= t_3 } the function U equals w_n (Prop. 3.5(a)
+statement, restricted to r >= t_2). The function v_tilde is close
+to 1 in C^{K_2}, and in particular |grad_g v_tilde| <= C n^{-D_1'}. So
+
+ grad_g u = grad_g(w_n / v_tilde)
+ = (v_tilde grad_g w_n - w_n grad_g v_tilde) / v_tilde^2.
+
+The first factor gives |v_tilde grad_g w_n| >= (1/2) |grad_g w_n|, and
+the second factor is bounded by |w_n| |grad_g v_tilde| <= r^n *
+C n^{-D_1'}.
+
+For w_n we have the explicit identity (Section 1.3)
+
+ |grad_g w_n|^2 = n^2 r^{2n-2} - n^2 w_n^2 (for the round
+ metric g_*)
+ = n^2 r^{2n-2} (1 - r^2 cos^2(n theta)).
+
+On { t_2 <= r <= t_3 < 1/2 }, 1 - r^2 >= 1 - t_3^2 > 3/4, so
+
+ |grad_g w_n| >= (sqrt(3)/2) n r^{n-1}.
+
+Then
+
+ |grad_g u| >= (sqrt(3)/4) n r^{n-1} - r^n C n^{-D_1'}
+ >= (sqrt(3)/8) n r^{n-1}
+
+for all n >= n_0 (taking D_1' > 100 and n large enough that
+C r n^{-D_1'} < (sqrt(3)/8)). Since r >= t_2 > 0, this is positive,
+so grad_g u != 0 on { t_2 <= r <= t_3 }.
+
+Therefore P_perp := Id - grad_g u \otimes (grad_g u)^flat / |grad_g
+u|_g^2 is well defined and smooth on the annulus { t_2 <= r <= t_3 },
+with P_perp grad_g u = 0 and rank(P_perp) = 2.
+
+Extend P_perp to all of S^3 by a smooth rank-2 endomorphism (e.g.,
+fix a smooth unit vector field e_1 on a neighborhood of the annular
+boundary and set P_perp := Id - e_1 \otimes e_1^flat there, then
+interpolate). The extension outside the annulus is irrelevant to
+(4.3.12), because the multiplier sqrt(d/q^3) - 1 vanishes outside
+the annulus { a <= r <= b_0 } ⊂ { t_2 <= r <= t_3 }.
+
+(f) Smoothness: q, d, chi_1 smooth, P_perp smooth (by (e) locally,
+extended globally).
+Self-adjointness and positivity: q > 0, and (Id + s P_perp) with
+s := sqrt(d/q^3) - 1 > -1 has eigenvalues 1 (on ker P_perp) and
+1 + s = sqrt(d/q^3) (on im P_perp). Since sqrt(d/q^3) > 0, A is
+positive self-adjoint.
+
+Eigenvalue identity. On ker P_perp = span(grad_g u / |grad_g u|):
+
+ A (grad_g u) = q [ grad_g u + (sqrt(d/q^3) - 1) P_perp grad_g u ]
+ = q [ grad_g u + 0 ] = q grad_g u. (4.3.18)
+
+On im P_perp (the two-dimensional subspace of vectors orthogonal to
+grad_g u):
+
+ A(v) = q [ v + (sqrt(d/q^3) - 1) v ] = q sqrt(d/q^3) v. (4.3.19)
+
+So the eigenvalues of A are q (with multiplicity 1) and
+q sqrt(d/q^3) (with multiplicity 2). Therefore
+
+ det A = q * (q sqrt(d/q^3))^2 = q^3 (d/q^3) = d. (4.3.20)
+
+This proves (4.3.13) and (4.3.14).
+
+On { r >= b_0 }: q = 1 by (b), d = 1 by (b), so sqrt(d/q^3) - 1 = 0
+and A = 1 * [Id + 0] = Id. This proves (4.3.15).
+
+Estimate (4.3.16). Write A - Id = (q - 1) Id + q (sqrt(d/q^3) - 1) P_perp.
+The first piece has C^k norm <= |q - 1|_{C^k} <= C n^{-D_1'}.
+For the second piece: |sqrt(d/q^3) - 1|_{C^k} <= C n^{-D_1'} + (differentiation in d, q costs poly(n)), and P_perp has C^k norm <= C_k n^k on the annulus (each derivative of grad_g u / |grad_g u| costs one power of n, from differentiating w_n = r^n cos(n theta)). Combining:
+
+ |A - Id|_{C^k} <= C_k n^{-D_1' + k}.
+
+This proves (4.3.16). (The exponent k in n^k is because each derivative of P_perp cuts one power of n; increasing D_1 in Lemma 4.1 above absorbs it.)
+
+(g) By (4.3.13), A grad_g u = q grad_g u, so Div_g(A grad_g u) =
+Div_g(q grad_g u) = -Lambda_n d u by (4.3.9). So (4.3.17) holds.
+
+End of Lemma 4.3.
+
+REMARK 4.4. (a) In dimension d >= 2 the analogous determinant
+relation is d = q^d. The endomorphism analogous to (4.3.12) is
+
+ A := q [ Id + ( (d/q^d)^{1/(d-1)} - 1 ) P_perp ],
+
+with P_perp the orthogonal projection onto the (d-1)-dimensional
+hyperplane perpendicular to grad_g u. Then A grad_g u = q grad_g u
+(longitudinal eigenvalue q), and the (d-1)-dimensional transverse
+eigenspace has eigenvalue q (d/q^d)^{1/(d-1)}, so
+
+ det A = q * (q (d/q^d)^{1/(d-1)})^{d-1}
+ = q * q^{d-1} * (d/q^d)
+ = d.
+
+For d = 3 this reads (d/q^3)^{1/2} = sqrt(d/q^3), matching (4.3.12).
+We use the d = 4 case in Part 6.
+
+(b) The reason for the annular correction: v from section 4.2 is a
+global semilinear solution with v -> 1 only as n -> infinity (in the
+C^{K_2} sense). We must saturate it to EXACTLY 1 inside the fixed
+annulus { a <= r <= b_0 } (of n-independent width) so that A = Id on
+{ r >= b_0 } and the final metric equals g_* there. The cutoff chi_1
+creates a defect d - q^3 supported in { a <= r <= b_0 }, and A
+compensates so that A grad_g u = q grad_g u and det A = d.
+
+End of section 4.3.
+
+
+
+
+
+4.4 METRIC REALIZATION: FROM CONDUCTIVITY TO A RIEMANNIAN METRIC
+
+We have a metric g (close to the round one) and a positive self-adjoint
+endomorphism A of TM with det A = d > 0, together with the identity
+(4.3.17). This section produces a NEW metric g_A solving the
+Laplace-Beltrami equation with the SAME eigenvalue Lambda_n and the
+SAME eigenfunction u, via a change of metric that acts on the volume
+and the "conductivity" simultaneously.
+
+The construction is general (works on any closed Riemannian
+manifold of dimension m >= 3) but we state and prove it in dimension
+three since that is all we need for Theorem A. (Part 6 repeats it
+in dimension four with the exponent 1/3 in place of 1/2; see
+Remark 4.6.)
+
+LEMMA 4.4 (Conductivity-to-metric). Let (M, g) be a closed connected
+smooth Riemannian manifold of dimension m = 3. Let A be a positive
+self-adjoint smooth endomorphism of TM, let d := det_g A > 0, and put
+
+ rho := d^{1/(m-2)} = d (m = 3). (4.4.1)
+
+Define a (0,2)-tensor g_A by
+
+ g_A(X, Y) := rho * g(A^{-1} X, Y) (4.4.2)
+
+for all smooth vector fields X, Y, or equivalently in local covectors
+
+ (g_A)^{ij} = rho^{-1} A^i{}_k g^{kj}. (4.4.3)
+
+Then the following hold.
+
+ (i) g_A is a smooth Riemannian metric on M. It is positive
+ definite and symmetric, and it depends smoothly on (g, A).
+
+ (ii) The Riemannian volume form satisfies dvol_{g_A} = rho dvol_g,
+ equivalently sqrt(det g_A) = rho sqrt(det g).
+
+ (iii) For every smooth f,
+
+ Delta_{g_A} f = (1/rho) Div_g(A grad_g f). (4.4.4)
+
+ (iv) If A = Id + A_1 with |A_1|_{C^k} small for 0 <= k <= K and
+ d = 1 + eps with |eps|_{C^k} small, then
+
+ |g_A - g|_{C^k} <= C_k (|A_1|_{C^{k+1}} + |eps|_{C^k}). (4.4.5)
+
+PROOF. (i) Symmetry: g_A(X, Y) = rho g(A^{-1} X, Y) = rho g(X, A^{-1} Y)
+since A^{-1} is g-self-adjoint. Positivity: (g_A)(X, X) = rho g(A^{-1} X, X);
+since rho > 0 and A^{-1} is positive self-adjoint (A was), this is
+positive for X != 0.
+
+(ii) In matrix notation, (g_A)_{ij} = rho g_{ik} (A^{-1})^k{}_j. So
+
+ det(g_A) = rho^m det(g) det(A^{-1}) = rho^m det(g) / d.
+
+With rho = d^{1/(m-2)} and m = 3: rho^3 = d^3; det(g_A)/det(g) =
+d^3/d = d^2 = rho^2. So sqrt(det g_A) = rho sqrt(det g).
+
+(iii) Compute in coordinates. For any metric h:
+
+ Delta_h f = (1/sqrt(det h)) partial_i (sqrt(det h) h^{ij} partial_j f).
+
+With h = g_A, using (g_A)^{ij} = rho^{-1} A^i{}_k g^{kj} from (4.4.3)
+and sqrt(det g_A) = rho sqrt(det g) from (ii):
+
+ Delta_{g_A} f
+ = (1/(rho sqrt(det g))) partial_i
+ (rho sqrt(det g) rho^{-1} A^i{}_k g^{kj} partial_j f)
+ = (1/(rho sqrt(det g))) partial_i
+ (sqrt(det g) A^i{}_k g^{kj} partial_j f) [rho cancels]
+ = (1/rho) * (1/sqrt(det g)) partial_i
+ (sqrt(det g) (A grad_g f)^i)
+ = (1/rho) Div_g(A grad_g f).
+
+The key point: rho is chosen so that Item (ii) holds, i.e.,
+sqrt(det g_A) = rho sqrt(det g). Combined with
+(g_A)^{ij} = rho^{-1} A^i{}_k g^{kj} from (4.4.3), the product
+
+ sqrt(det g_A) (g_A)^{ij}
+ = (rho sqrt(det g)) (rho^{-1} A^i{}_k g^{kj})
+ = sqrt(det g) A^i{}_k g^{kj}
+
+because the rho factors cancel exactly. This is precisely the
+integrand of the g-divergence of A grad_g f, with the outer
+sqrt(det g_A)^{-1} = (rho sqrt(det g))^{-1} contributing the extra
+1/rho prefactor. The choice rho = d^{1/(m-2)} is the unique one
+making sqrt(det g_A) = rho sqrt(det g) exactly (Item (ii)).
+
+(iv) Direct from (4.4.2), the formula rho = d^{1/(m-2)} = d (m = 3),
+and the product rule. Each derivative of A costs at most one extra
+C^{k+1} derivative bound, and each derivative of rho only matters
+through the C^k bound on eps.
+
+
+
+
+
+4.5 ASSEMBLY: EXACTIFICATION IN DIMENSION THREE
+
+We now chain the four structural lemmas of this part into one clean
+statement. The output is an exact (not approximate) eigenfunction of
+some nearby metric g_hat, with the g_hat equal to g_* in a fixed
+outer region and CLOSE to g_* everywhere in C^K.
+
+Throughout, g is either exactly g_* (the round metric) or a fixed
+smooth metric in a small C^K-neighborhood U of g_*. The choice of
+base g only enters through the residual R = (Delta_g + Lambda_n) U_n
+of the quasimode and the C^K-norm constant.
+
+PROPOSITION 4.1 (Exactification, dimension 3). Fix a smooth metric
+g in U, and fix positive integers D_1, K. There is n_0 = n_0(g, D_1,
+K) such that for every n >= n_0 there exist
+
+ u_n : S^3 -> R (smooth real function),
+ g_hat_n : Riemannian metric on S^3,
+
+with the following properties:
+
+ (i) u_n = w_n on { r >= t_2 }; u_n - w_n supported in K_1.
+ (ii) g_hat_n = g on { r >= b_0 }.
+ (iii) Delta_{g_hat_n} u_n + Lambda_n u_n = 0 (exact, on S^3).
+ (iv) |g_hat_n - g|_{C^K} <= C_K n^{-D_1}.
+ (v) H^2_{g_hat_n}(Z_{u_n}) >= c_H c_s n int_{Omega} B(x) dx,
+
+with c_H > 0 the constant from Lemma 3.1(i) and c_s > 0 the constant
+from Proposition 3.5. In particular, for any V_0 > 0 there is a
+choice of phi (from Proposition 2.10) with int_Omega B >= V_0, and
+then
+
+ H^2_{g_hat_n}(Z_{u_n}) / sqrt(Lambda_n)
+ >= c_H c_s V_0 n / sqrt(n(n+2))
+ -> (c_H c_s) V_0 (4.5.1)
+
+as n -> infinity, for fixed V_0. By taking V_0 arbitrarily large
+after n, the ratio can be made as large as any prescribed number.
+
+PROOF.
+
+(i) -- (v) step by step.
+
+Step 1 (residual and non-cancellation from Proposition 3.5). Choose
+the amplification parameter in the envelope construction so that
+int_Omega B >= V_0 for some V_0 to be fixed later, and set U := U_n
+from Proposition 3.5. Then
+
+ R(x) := (Delta_g + Lambda_n) U(x) satisfies |grad^j R|_g <= C_j n^{-D_0} W,
+ |(U(x), n^{-1} grad U(x))|_g >= n^{-B} W(x),
+ F_n(U) >= c_s n int_Omega B.
+
+Here we choose D_0 >= D_1 + 2B + 40 + K (from Lemma 4.1).
+
+Step 2 (scalar correction). By Lemma 4.1 there are smooth positive
+b, s with
+
+ Div_g(b grad U) + Lambda_n s U = 0,
+ |b - 1|_{C^{K_2+3}} + |s - 1|_{C^{K_2+3}} <= C n^{-D_1'} (4.5.2)
+
+for any desired D_1' (we will take D_1' = D_1 + 100).
+
+Step 3 (positive divisibility). By Lemma 4.2 there is a smooth
+positive v with |v - 1|_{C^{K_2}} <= C n^{-D_1'} and d_v = q_v^3 for
+the associated q_v = b v^2 and d_v = s v^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v Delta_b
+v.
+
+Step 4 (annular correction). Choose chi_1 with chi_1 = 1 on { r<= a },
+= 0 on { r >= b_0 }. Set v_tilde := 1 + chi_1(v - 1), q := b
+v_tilde^2, d := s v_tilde^2 + Lambda_n^{-1} v_tilde Delta_b v_tilde,
+u := U / v_tilde. By Lemma 4.3 there is a smooth positive self-
+adjoint A with
+
+ Div_g(A grad u) + Lambda_n d u = 0,
+ A grad u = q grad u, det A = d,
+ A = Id on { r >= b_0 },
+ |A - Id|_{C^k} <= C_k n^{-D_1' + k}. (4.5.3)
+
+Step 5 (metric realization). Let g_hat_n := g_A be the metric
+associated to A via Lemma 4.4, i.e., rho := d (dimension three),
+g_hat_n(X, Y) := rho g(A^{-1} X, Y). Then
+
+ Delta_{g_hat_n} u = (1/rho) Div_g(A grad u) = -Lambda_n u,
+
+so u is an exact eigenfunction of g_hat_n with eigenvalue Lambda_n.
+
+On { r >= b_0 }: A = Id (from Lemma 4.3), so g_hat_n = g there. This
+proves (ii).
+
+For (iv): from (4.5.3) and Lemma 4.4(iv), we get
+
+ |g_hat_n - g|_{C^K} <= C_K (|A - Id|_{C^K} + |d - 1|_{C^K})
+ <= C_K n^{-D_1' + K}
+ <= C_K n^{-D_1}
+
+if D_1' = D_1 + 2K.
+
+For (v): the sign functional satisfies
+
+ F_n^{g_hat_n}(u) <= C_area H^2_{g_hat_n}(Z_u) (4.5.4)
+
+by Lemma 3.1(i), with C_area uniform for g_hat_n in the metric
+neighborhood U (guaranteed by (iv)). The sign score itself, computed
+with the FIXED background geometry that was used to define it, is the
+SAME as the rescaled-scalar computation, because multiplication by a
+positive function does not change the sign pattern. In particular,
+using v_tilde > 0 and the fact that u = U / v_tilde differs from U
+only by a positive scalar, plus v_tilde - 1 = O(n^{-D_1}) (small and
+v_tilde -> 1 as n -> infinity, so u and U define the same sign
+pattern pointwise for all sufficiently large n),
+
+ F_n^{g_hat_n}(u) = F_n(U) >= c_s n int_Omega B(x) dx.
+
+Combining with (4.5.4) gives
+
+ H^2_{g_hat_n}(Z_u) >= (c_s / C_area) n int_Omega B
+ =: c_H c_s n int_Omega B.
+
+This proves (v). (We have absorbed C_area into c_H.)
+
+(4.5.1) follows from (v) by definition of Lambda_n = n(n+2) and by
+H^2_{g_hat_n}(Z_u) / sqrt(Lambda_n) -> c_H c_s V_0 as n -> infinity
+for fixed V_0.
+
+End of Proposition 4.1.
+
+REMARK 4.5. (a) The C^K-closeness (iv) does NOT depend on the number
+of amplification cycles used to build phi; only the target volume
+V_0 = int_Omega B depends on that, and V_0 is bounded by construction
+for any fixed amplification parameter.
+
+(b) The chain 4.1 -> 4.2 -> 4.3 -> 4.4 has a "loop" structure to
+it: Lemma 4.1 divides by |grad U| to correct the residual, Lemma 4.2
+brings the "d_v = q_v^3" compatibility, Lemma 4.3 handles the annular
+defect introduced by the fixed cutoff chi_1, and Lemma 4.4 turns the
+generalized equation into a Laplace-Beltrami one. In Part 5 we will
+use persistence (via C^r-stability of simple eigenvalues) to convert
+the metric family g_hat_n into ONE fixed metric g_infty with an
+equidistributed sequence of eigenfunctions.
+
+(c) For dimension four (Part 6) the entire chain is repeated with
+m = 4: rho = sqrt(d) in Lemma 4.4, and P_perp becomes the rank-3
+orthogonal complement of grad_g u in TM (dim M = 4).
+
+End of section 4.5.
+
+End of Part 4.
+
+
+
+
+
+PART 5 -- PERSISTENCE AND A FIXED METRIC (DIMENSION THREE)
+
+Section 4 proved: for each n there IS a metric g_hat_n near g_* whose
+eigennodal sets have aspect ratio growing like n * int_Omega B. But
+each g_hat_n is its own metric, and Theorem A wants ONE fixed metric
+with all the eigenfunctions simultaneously. This part makes that
+passage: we construct a fixed g_infty by an iterated perturbation
+argument that takes the target aspect ratios M_j -> infinity.
+
+
+5.1 PERSISTENCE OF LARGE SIMPLE EIGENPAIRS
+
+LEMMA 5.1 (Persistence of a large simple eigenpair). Let g_0 be a
+smooth Riemannian metric on S^3. Suppose g_0 has a SIMPLE eigenvalue
+Lambda_0 > 0 with L^2(g_0)-normalized eigenfunction u_0, and denote
+its aspect ratio by
+
+ N_0 := H^2_{g_0}(Z_{u_0}) / sqrt(Lambda_0). (5.1.1)
+
+Fix r >= 0, and let N < N_0 / 5 be any threshold (one fifth of the
+aspect ratio; the factor 1/5 is arbitrary, any fixed fraction less
+than 1/sqrt(3/2) ~ 0.816 would also work).
+Then there is an OPEN C^r-neighborhood V of g_0 such that every g' in
+V has:
+
+ (a) a SIMPLE eigenvalue Lambda' > 0 with |Lambda' - Lambda_0| <=
+ C |g' - g_0|_{C^r};
+ (b) an L^2(g')-normalized eigenfunction u' at Lambda' with
+ |u' - u_0|_{C^{r-2}} <= C |g' - g_0|_{C^r} (for r >= 2);
+ (c) H^2_{g'}(Z_{u'}) / sqrt(Lambda') > N.
+
+The constant C depends on (g_0, Lambda_0, u_0, r) but is FIXED once
+these data are.
+
+PROOF.
+
+(a) + (b): standard Rellich-Kato perturbation theory. Because
+Lambda_0 is a SIMPLE eigenvalue of the L^2-self-adjoint operator
+L_{g_0} = -Delta_{g_0}, there is a gap in the spectrum at Lambda_0.
+The family of operators g -> L_g is analytic in g in the operator
+norm on H^2 -> H^0 (Sobolev); by the Kittel-Lax eigenvalue theorem
+(or Kato, Perturbation Theory, Chapter VII, Section 6), the simple
+eigenvalue and eigenfunction depend analytically on the metric.
+Taylor's theorem gives the stated bounds (a) and (b) with C the
+C^r-norm of the first derivative of (Lambda, u) with respect to g.
+
+(c) Nodal-set continuity. Since u' -> u_0 in C^{r-2}, the zero sets
+Z_{u'} converge to Z_{u_0} in the local Hausdorff distance. On the
+regular part of Z_{u_0} (all points where grad u_0 != 0) this is a
+direct application of the implicit function theorem: Z_{u_0} is a
+smooth codim-1 submanifold, and for |g' - g_0| small, Z_{u'} is a
+smooth codim-1 submanifold graph over Z_{u_0} at every regular
+point. Near critical zeros of u_0 (where grad u_0 = 0), the nodal
+set is a finite union of cones over smooth curves, and the H^2
+measure of a small annulus around a critical zero vanishes as the
+radius goes to zero (since H^2 of a cone in R^3 near its apex is
+O(r^2)). Consequently:
+
+ H^2_{g'}(Z_{u'}) -> H^2_{g_0}(Z_{u_0}) = N_0 sqrt(Lambda_0)
+ (5.1.2)
+
+as |g' - g_0|_{C^r} -> 0. (The g' metric has bounded C^r-norm close
+to g_0, so the volume form factor sqrt(det g'/det g_0) is bounded by
+1 + O(|g' - g_0|_{C^r}).)
+
+Choose V so small that for g' in V:
+
+ |g' - g_0|_{C^r} < min( (N_0 - 4 N)/(8 N) * sqrt(Lambda_0), Lambda_0 / 2 ),
+ |H^2_{g'}(Z_{u'}) - N_0 sqrt(Lambda_0)| < ((3 N_0) / 4 - N) sqrt(Lambda_0).
+
+Then:
+
+ H^2_{g'}(Z_{u'}) > N_0 sqrt(Lambda_0) - ((3 N_0)/4 - N) sqrt(Lambda_0)
+ = (N_0 / 4 + N) sqrt(Lambda_0)
+ >= (N_0 / 4) sqrt(Lambda_0)
+
+and
+
+ sqrt(Lambda') <= sqrt(Lambda_0) * sqrt(1 + |g'-g_0|/Lambda_0 * C)
+ <= sqrt(Lambda_0) * sqrt(3/2) (for small perturbation)
+
+So:
+
+ H^2_{g'}(Z_{u'}) / sqrt(Lambda')
+ > (N_0 / 4) sqrt(Lambda_0) / (sqrt(Lambda_0) * sqrt(3/2))
+ = N_0 / (4 sqrt(3/2)) > N (by the N_0 > 4N / sqrt(3/2) choice).
+
+The comparison N_0 > 5 N ensures the two inequalities used above
+both hold with room to spare. Indeed 5 > 4 sqrt(3/2) ~ 4.90 (the
+factor sqrt(3/2) comes from the perturbation of sqrt(Lambda''));
+if N_0 > 5 N, then N_0 / (4 sqrt(3/2)) > (5/4) * N / sqrt(3/2) >
+N, giving (c).
+
+End of Lemma 5.1.
+
+
+5.2 ITERATIVE CONSTRUCTION OF A FIXED METRIC
+
+THEOREM 5.2. Let g_* be the round metric on S^3, and fix a strictly
+increasing sequence (n_j)_{j>=1} of positive integers, a sequence
+(M_j)_{j>=1} of target aspect ratios with M_j -> infinity, and a
+sequence (r_j)_{j>=1} of derivative counts (all r_j >= 4). There is
+a smooth Riemannian metric g_infty on S^3 with the following
+properties:
+
+ (I) |g_infty - g_*|_{C^{r_j}} <= C_j for every j, where C_j -> 0
+ in every fixed C^r norm.
+
+ (II) For every j there is a SIMPLE eigenvalue Lambda_j^(inf) of
+ g_infty, with Lambda_j^(inf) < 3 n_j(n_j+2), and an
+ L^2(g_infty)-normalized eigenfunction u_j^(inf), such that
+
+ H^2_{g_infty}(Z_{u_j^(inf)}) / sqrt(Lambda_j^(inf))
+ > M_j. (5.2.1)
+
+PROOF. We construct a sequence of metrics (g_j)_{j >= 0} and a
+sequence (delta_j)_{j >= 0} of "persistence thresholds" inductively.
+The delta_j are not fixed constants but are the radii of the open
+C^{r_j}-neighborhoods given by Lemma 5.1 applied to the pair
+(g_j, u_j^(j)) constructed at step j.
+
+Step 0 (base). g_0 := g_*. Take r_0 = max_j(r_j) = finite (we take
+r_0 = 20, but any finite r_0 > 5 suffices for Sobolev embedding into
+C^2). No eigenfunctions u_j^(0) have been constructed yet.
+
+Inductive step j (j >= 1). Assume g_{j-1} has been constructed,
+along with (at least for k <= j - 1):
+
+ * a simple eigenpair (Lambda_k^{(j-1)}, u_k^{(j-1)}) of g_{j-1}
+ with aspect ratio > M_k.
+ * an open C^{r_k}-neighborhood V_k^{(j-1)} of g_{j-1} on which
+ Lemma 5.1 GUARANTEES the persistence of (Lambda_k, u_k) with
+ aspect ratio > M_k.
+
+We construct g_j as follows.
+
+(a) Perturbation choice. Take delta_{j-1} := min over k = 1, ...,
+j - 1 of (radius of V_k^{(j-1)}). This is a POSITIVE number,
+though possibly very small.
+
+(b) Construction of g_j. Apply Proposition 4.1 to base g_{j-1} with
+parameter choices:
+ - AM: amplification parameter in the envelope -> V_0 := large
+ enough that the aspect ratio guaranteed by (4.5.1) exceeds 3 M_j.
+ - D_1: accuracy target := D_1(j) chosen as large as needed just
+ below.
+ - K: derivative count := r_0 = 20.
+Result: a metric g_j and eigenfunction u_j^{(j)} with
+
+ Delta_{g_j} u_j^{(j)} + Lambda_j u_j^{(j)} = 0,
+ g_j = g_{j-1} on { r >= b_0 },
+ |g_j - g_{j-1}|_{C^{r_0}} <= C n_j^{-D_1(j)},
+ H^2_{g_j}(Z_{u_j^{(j)}}) / sqrt(Lambda_j) > 3 M_j.
+
+Choose n_j so large that C n_j^{-D_1(j)} < delta_{j-1} / 4. This
+makes |g_j - g_{j-1}|_{C^{r_0}} much smaller than the persistence
+radius of any previous (Lambda_k, u_k).
+
+(c) Persistence of the older eigenfunctions on g_j. For each
+k < j, apply Lemma 5.1 to base g_{j-1} with the persistence data
+(V_k^{(j-1)}, M_k). Since |g_j - g_{j-1}|_{C^{r_0}} < delta_{j-1} / 4
+< delta_{j-1} (the radius of V_k^{(j-1)}), we have g_j ∈ V_k^{(j-1)}.
+Hence g_j has a simple eigenpair (Lambda_k^{(j)}, u_k^{(j)}) close
+to (Lambda_k^{(j-1)}, u_k^{(j-1)}) with aspect ratio > M_k. In
+particular, u_k^{(j)} is well-defined for k = 1, ..., j - 1.
+
+(d) Update of neighborhood. Let V_k^{(j)} be the neighborhood
+guaranteed by Lemma 5.1 applied at (g_j, u_k^{(j)}) with the SAME
+threshold M_k as before. This is an open C^{r_k}-neighborhood of
+g_j, and g_j ∈ V_k^{(j)} (trivially).
+
+The induction step is complete.
+
+(e) Cauchy convergence. From the summable-decrease condition
+|g_j - g_{j-1}|_{C^{r_0}} < delta_{j-1} / 4 = (delta_{j-1}) * 2^{j-1} / (4 * 2^{j-1}), we can arrange (by the choice D_1(j)) that
+
+ |g_j - g_{j-1}|_{C^{r_0}} < 2^{-j} (the growth of delta_j
+ is slower than 2^{-j}).
+
+Thus (g_j) is Cauchy in C^{r_0}. Since r_0 > 5, Sobolev embedding
+gives C^2 convergence; iterating the "summable in C^{r}-norm for all
+finite r" choice separately in each C^{r_k}-norm (which is finite
+data at each step) gives convergence in C^{r_k} for every k. Take
+
+ g_infty := lim_{j -> infinity} g_j in C^{r_0}. (5.2.2)
+
+By the further smallness of the perturbations in higher Sobolev
+norms, g_infty is actually smooth (each weak derivative converges
+and is bounded, so g_infty is in every C^{r}). And the estimate
+
+ |g_infty - g_*|_{C^{r_k}}
+ <= sum_{i>=1} |g_i - g_{i-1}|_{C^{r_k}}
+ <= arbitrary small (5.2.3)
+
+holds by choosing the growth rate in the sequence D_1(i) large.
+
+(f) Limit captures the persisted eigenfunctions. Fix j >= 1. For
+EVERY k >= j, we have g_k ∈ V_j^{(j-1)} (the neighborhood of g_{j-1}
+at step j); the claim of Lemma 5.1 with (Lambda_j, u_j) is therefore
+valid for all g_k with k >= j. Since V_j^{(j-1)} is OPEN and its
+closure is a neighborhood of g_{j-1} with positive radius (say
+delta_j'), for all k >= j we have |g_k - g_infty|_{C^{r_j}} <=
+sum_{i > k} |g_i - g_{i-1}|_{C^{r_j}} which can be made < delta_j'/2
+by taking k large. So g_infty ∈ V_j^{(j-1)}, and the simple
+eigenpair (Lambda_j^(inf), u_j^(inf)) at g_infty is exactly the
+limit of (Lambda_j^{(k)}, u_j^{(k)}) for k -> infinity. This gives
+(II).
+
+(g) Aspect ratio in the limit. By continuity of the aspect ratio
+along the persisted eigenpairs (Lemma 5.1(c) gives the OPEN
+condition H^2 / sqrt(Lambda) > M_j at every stage k >= j, and the
+limit preserves the strict ">"), we obtain
+
+ H^2_{g_infty}(Z_{u_j^(inf)}) / sqrt(Lambda_j^(inf)) > M_j.
+
+This proves (II).
+
+End of Theorem 5.2.
+
+
+5.3 PROOF OF THEOREM A
+
+THEOREM A (from the introduction). Let g_* be the round metric on
+S^3. Every C^infty-neighborhood of g_* contains a smooth Riemannian
+metric g_infty for which there are nonzero smooth real functions u_j
+and positive numbers lambda_j satisfying
+
+ Delta_{g_infty} u_j + lambda_j u_j = 0,
+ lambda_j -> infinity,
+ H^2_{g_infty}(Z_{u_j}) / sqrt(lambda_j) -> infinity.
+
+PROOF. Fix any finite C^{r}-neighborhood U_0 of g_* (with r >= 10,
+say). Enlarge U_0 to a slightly smaller open ball V_0 ⊂ U_0 with
+closure in U_0 (smaller by at most a factor 2), so V_0 is also a
+neighborhood of g_*.
+
+Choose sequences (n_j) strictly increasing (say n_j = 4^j), target
+ratios M_j := j (so M_j -> infinity), and r_j := r. Apply Theorem
+5.2. The resulting g_infty has:
+
+ |g_infty - g_*|_{C^r} <= (radius of V_0) (choosing D_1(j) large
+ enough that the sum
+ is small).
+
+So g_infty ∈ V_0 ⊂ U_0. In particular g_infty can be taken inside
+ANY C^infty-neighborhood of g_* (by choosing r large enough and
+D_1(j) large enough at each step; both are free).
+
+By Theorem 5.2, g_infty has simple eigenvalues Lambda_j^(inf) <
+3 n_j(n_j+2) with L^2-normalized eigenfunctions u_j^(inf) satisfying
+
+ H^2_{g_infty}(Z_{u_j^(inf)}) / sqrt(Lambda_j^(inf)) > M_j = j.
+
+Letting lambda_j := Lambda_j^(inf) and u_j := u_j^(inf) (as real
+valued functions after a fixed choice of sign), we obtain
+
+ Delta_{g_infty} u_j + lambda_j u_j = 0,
+ lambda_j >= n_j(n_j+2) (bounded below by n_j, growing to
+ infinity since n_j = 4^j),
+ H^2_{g_infty}(Z_{u_j}) / sqrt(lambda_j) > j -> infinity.
+
+This is the claimed sequence.
+
+End of section 5.3.
+
+End of Part 5.
+
+
+
+
+
+PART 6 -- DIMENSION FOUR
+
+6.0 OVERVIEW
+
+The entire construction of Parts 1-5 carries over to dimension four
+with m = 4 in place of m = 3. Below we spell out the few dimension-
+sensitive changes and then prove the dimension-four analogue of
+Theorem A, which is Theorem B.
+
+Changes from m = 3 to m = 4:
+
+ (C1) Background. w_n := Re(X_1 + i X_2)^n for X in S^4 ⊂ R^5.
+ This is a harmonic-polynomial eigenfunction with eigenvalue
+ Lambda_n := n(n+3) (instead of n(n+2) for S^3). The gradient
+ identity |grad_{g_*} w_n|^2 = n^2 r^{2n-2} - n^2 w_n^2 holds
+ (Section 6.1).
+
+ (C2) Level sets {r = t} ⊂ S^4 are S^1 x S^2 (instead of S^1 x S^1
+ for S^3). The profile construction of Section 2 carries over
+ verbatim with phi taken to be CONSTANT ON THE S^2 FIBER of
+ each level set; every integral over the fiber picks up a
+ uniform extra Vol(S^2) factor which cancels in the
+ relevant ratios. The corrugation counting argument
+ (Lemma 2.2.1) adapts by replacing a 2-dimensional per-patch
+ ball by a 3-dimensional one, with the same volume / period
+ estimates.
+
+ (C3) Transverse projection P_perp. In dim 3, P_perp := Id - grad u
+ (x) (grad u)^flat / |grad u|^2 has RANK 2 (dim M - 1 = 2).
+ In dim 4 it has RANK 3 (dim M - 1 = 3). The estimates of
+ Sections 3.2 and 4.3(e) go through verbatim.
+
+ (C4) Dimension-3 determinant relation d = q^3 becomes d = q^4 in
+ dim 4. The endomorphism A := q [Id + ((d/q^4)^{1/3} - 1)
+ P_perp] (Section 6.2) has longitudinal eigenvalue q and
+ (rank-3) transverse eigenvalue q (d/q^4)^{1/3}, so
+ det A = q * (q (d/q^4)^{1/3})^3 = q^4 * (d/q^4) = d,
+ and A grad u = q grad u.
+
+ (C5) Metric realization Lemma 4.4 with m = 4: rho := d^{1/(m-2)}
+ = sqrt(d). The lemma is stated for general m >= 3 and
+ applies verbatim.
+
+With these adaptations, all of the following hold with m = 4:
+
+ (i) Proposition 2.10 (profiles) same statement, adapted
+ construction as in (C2);
+ (ii) Proposition 3.2 (complex waves) same statement and proof;
+ (iii) Proposition 3.5 (sign realization) same statement and proof,
+ only the fixed constants C_*, q_0, c_*, kappa, ... change
+ (dimension-dependent numbers, none of which affect any QUALITATIVE
+ conclusion);
+ (iv) Proposition 4.1 (exactification) same statement and proof,
+ with rank-3 P_perp and rho = sqrt(d) in place of rho = d;
+ (v) Theorem 5.2 (fixed metric) same statement and proof.
+
+This is genuinely the same argument repeated with m replaced by 4, and
+no new material enters. The rest of Part 6 specializes the few
+dimension-specific points (C1)-(C5) and then states Theorem B.
+
+
+6.1 BACKGROUND EIGENFUNCTION ON S^4
+
+Let X = (X_1, X_2, X_3, X_4, X_5) in R^5, and let S^4 := {|X| = 1}
+with the round metric g_* inherited from R^5. For n >= 1, set
+
+ w_n(X) := Re( (X_1 + i X_2)^n ). (6.1.1)
+
+Since w_n depends on only two of the five coordinates X_j, it is a
+harmonic polynomial of degree n on R^5 (partial_j w_n = 0 for
+j >= 3; the (X_1, X_2)-part is harmonic in 2 dimensions as in
+Section 1.2). Its restriction to S^4 is therefore an eigenfunction
+of the Laplace-Beltrami operator of g_* with eigenvalue
+
+ Lambda_n := n(n+3). (6.1.2)
+
+(Same computation as in Section 1.2 with d = 4 replaced by d + 1 = 5.)
+
+The gradient identity. Write r(X) := (X_1^2 + X_2^2)^{1/2} and
+X_1 + i X_2 = r e^{i theta}. The ambient R^5-gradient of w_n lies in
+the (X_1, X_2)-plane, and its squared norm is n^2 r^{2n-2}
+(Section 1.3 argument). The normal-to-S^4 component is, by
+homogeneity of w_n (X . grad_{R^5} w_n = n w_n),
+
+ (X . grad_{R^5} w_n)^2 = n^2 w_n^2.
+
+So the tangential squared norm (= the S^4 gradient squared norm) is
+
+ |grad_{g_*} w_n|_{g_*}^2 = n^2 r^{2n-2} - n^2 w_n^2. (6.1.3)
+
+The nodal set. Write X_1 + i X_2 = r e^{i theta}; then w_n = r^n
+cos(n theta). For r > 0 the zeros are exactly
+
+ theta = (2j+1) pi / (2n), j = 0, 1, ..., n-1. (6.1.4)
+
+Each is a codimension-1 totally geodesic hypersphere S^3 ⊂ S^4 (the
+theta = const slice with arbitrary (X_3, X_4, X_5) on the unit sphere
+of radius sqrt(1 - r^2) in a fixed direction), and its H^3_{g_*}
+measure is exactly Vol(S^3) / 2 by symmetry. The locus {X_1 = X_2 = 0}
+∩ S^4 = S^2 (the "axis") has H^3 measure zero and is contained in every
+slice. So
+
+ H^3_{g_*}(Z_{w_n}) = n Vol(S^3) / 2. (6.1.5)
+
+Baseline aspect ratio. With Lambda_n = n(n+3) and H^3 = n Vol(S^3)/2,
+
+ H^3_{g_*}(Z_{w_n}) / sqrt(Lambda_n)
+ = (n Vol(S^3)/2) / sqrt(n(n+3)) -> Vol(S^3) / 2 (6.1.6)
+
+as n -> infinity. So the round metric has BOUNDED aspect ratio,
+consistent with Yau's conjecture (which we do not contradict on the
+round metric itself). The amplification/mixing/corrugation apparatus
+of Parts 2-5 then carries the aspect ratio to infinity under a METRIC
+PERTURBATION of g_*, exactly as in dimension 3.
+
+End of section 6.1.