diff 6d37dde..33b8919 chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
diff --git a/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt b/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
index 3224219..8482407 100644
--- a/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
+++ b/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
@@ -354,7 +354,7 @@ either alone.
p-1 pure stabilizer
* compute the H-exponent of E_{p-1}: > p^2 + 2 (Part H.2)
* compute the H-exponent of T(B_p) where T is the exact transfer
- functor T(V) = L_{K(p-1)}( E_{p-1} ^ V ): <= p^2 + 2 (Part H.4)
+ functor T(V) = L_{K(p-1)}( E_{p-1} ^ V ): <= p^2 + 2 (Part H.3.c)
* argue that a retraction of i_{p,X} would force
exp_H(E_{p-1}) <= exp_H(T(B_p)), contradicting the two bounds.
@@ -1055,11 +1055,18 @@ F.6 The p = 5 case spelled out
At p = 5:
d = 38, h = 4, h^2 = 16,
d h^2 = 608.
- a = 5, a^2 + 2 = 27.
- Filtration of x^{16} at height 5: 2*16 = 32 >= 27, so x^{16} = 0.
- Filtration of x^{16} at height 6 would be 32 vs 38 >= a^2 + 2 for
- a = 6, so 32 < 38, no contradiction. This is exactly why the
- height-six statement is NOT part of Corollary 1.
+ a = p = 5, a^2 + 2 = 27.
+
+The upper vanishing (Part F.5) applies at height 5. The unit image of
+x^{16} has filtration 2*16 = 32, and 32 >= 27, so the class is ZERO in
+pi_608 B_5.
+
+Compare at height 6 (a = p+1 = 6). The zero tail there starts at
+a^2 + 2 = 38, NOT at 27. Filtration 32 < 38, so this argument does NOT
+show vanishing at height 6 for p = 5. This is exactly why the height-6
+statement is not part of Corollary 1: the argument for Theorem 2 needs
+p >= 7, and at p = 5 the class x^{16} does not stay in the zero tail
+one height higher.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART G. ASSEMBLING THE KERNEL THEOREMS
@@ -1195,7 +1202,7 @@ The exponent exp_H(V) measures the smallest number of copies of the
finiteness invariant. Theorem 3 says:
exp_H(E_{p-1}) > m (Part H.2)
- exp_H(T(B_p)) <= m (Part H.4)
+ exp_H(T(B_p)) <= m (Part H.3.c)
And a retraction of i_{p,X} would force exp_H(E_{p-1}) <= exp_H(T(B_p)).
This is a contradiction, and it proves the same nonretraction that
@@ -1354,8 +1361,8 @@ Why (sketch). Three ingredients:
(2) FINITE TESTS vanish. The Amitsur cosimplicial construction on
B_h in C_h, composed with the exact functor F(V_0, -) for a
finite p-local V_0, has E_2 page (from the ordinary cooperation
- calculation of section E.3) H^s_{cts}(G_h; pi_q(E_h ^ D V_0)).
- Proposition E.1 makes this
+ calculation, Hovey 2004 Theorem 4.11) H^s_{cts}(G_h;
+ pi_q(E_h ^ D V_0)). Proposition E.1 makes this
zero for s >= h^2+2 = m. Using the already-known finite
exponent c, the tested-image part of the finite-page bound
(Lemma H.3.0(v), converse form) gives:
@@ -1446,9 +1453,9 @@ Why (sketch). The proof has three sub-steps.
Wrap-up. Sub-step 2 gives freeness on field-valued points of
R = pi_0 D / m_t pi_0 D. Sub-step 3 gives a class z-bar in R with
Trace(z-bar) = 1. Lift to z_0 in pi_0 D, set v = Sum_g g(z_0). Then
- v - 1 in m_t pi_0 D. Since pi_*D is flat over (E_t)_* (Lemma
- the mixed-cooperation flatness (pi_*D is flat over (E_t)_* through
- the first factor), the localizing map D -> D'
+ v - 1 in m_t pi_0 D. The mixed-cooperation flatness says pi_*D is
+ flat over (E_t)_* through the first factor; therefore the
+ localizing map D -> D'
identifies pi_0 D' with the m_t-adic completion of pi_0 D. At each
finite adic stage the telescoping element w_j = Sum_{k=0}^{j-1}
(1-v)^k satisfies v w_j = 1 - (1-v)^j = 1 mod m_t^j. The w_j's
@@ -1473,8 +1480,7 @@ H.4 Assembling the exponent contradiction
COROLLARY H.4.1. i_{h,X} = i_{p,X} has no homotopy retraction.
-Why. Suppose i_{p,X} admitted a retraction r. The key square is (Part
-H.4):
+Why. Suppose i_{p,X} admitted a retraction r. The key square is:
S --eta_S^{(p)}--> B_p
| |