diff f0945ea..33b8919 yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
diff --git a/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt b/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt index b6c83f1..977d398 100644 --- a/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt +++ b/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt @@ -1822,28 +1822,27 @@ We want each of these to be at most -D - 1 (then the residual bound (3.3.7) follows by the extra exp(n phi) factor, with C = 2 or so). Choosing J = D + m + 1, K = 2D + 3m + 6 and N_phi = K + J + 1 gives - (E): 2 + m - (K + J + 1 - m)/2 <= 2 + m - (K - m)/2 - (J+1)/2 - = 2 + m - D - 2m - 3 - (J+1)/2 + O(1/n) - <= -D - 1 (for J >= 2D + 2m + 4). Actually direct: - since K > 2D + 2m, (K - m)/2 > D + m/2, so - 2 + m - (K - m)/2 - (J+1)/2 < 2 + m - (D + m/2) - (D+m+2)/2 - = 2 + m - D - m/2 - (D+m)/2 - 1 = 1 + m/2 - 3D/2 - 3m/2 - = 1 - 3D/2 - m, which is <= -D - 1 when D + m >= 2 (always - since D, m >= 0). Good. - - (R): (1 - j) + m - (K + J - j - m)/2 <= -D - 1 for every - 0 <= j <= J: since (K + J - m) - j >= K + J - m - J = K - m - and RHS - D - 1 requires (1-j) + m - (K+J-j-m)/2 >= - (1-j) - (J-j)/2 + m - (K-m)/2. The first group - (1-j) - (J-j)/2 = 1 - j - J/2 + j/2 = 1 - J/2 - j/2, - minimized at j = J, giving value 1 - J. So R <= 1 - J + - m - (K-m)/2 <= -D - 1 as long as J >= D + m + 2 - - (K-m)/2. With J = D + m + 1 and (K-m)/2 >= D + m + 3, - R <= 1 - J + m - D - m - 3 = -J - D - 2 = -2D - m - 3, - <= -D - 2. Good. - - (G): -J + m - (K-m)/2 <= -(D + m + 1) + m - (D + m + 3) - = -2D - m - 4 <= -D - 1. Good. + (E): = 2 + m - (N_phi - m)/2 + = 2 + m - (3D + 3m + 8)/2 (N_phi = 3D+4m+8) + = -3D/2 - m/2 - 2 (simplify) + <= -D - 1 (since -D/2 - m/2 - 1 <= 0 whenever D,m >= 0). + Good. + + (R): for 0 <= j <= J, + = (1 - j) + m - (K - m)/2 - (J - j)/2 (exact split) + = -D - 2 - j - (J - j)/2 (K - m = 2D+2m+6) + = -3D/2 - m/2 - 5/2 - j/2 (J = D+m+1) + <= -3D/2 - m/2 - 5/2 (j >= 0) + <= -D - 1 (since -D/2 - m/2 - 3/2 <= 0 when D,m >= 0). + The maximal R occurs at j = 0 and equals -3D/2 - m/2 - 5/2, + which is <= -D - 2 for all D, m >= 0. + Good. + + (G): = -J + m - (K - m)/2 + = -(D+m+1) + m - (D+m+3) (K-m = 2D+2m+6) + = -2D - m - 4 (simplify) + <= -D - 1 (since -D - m - 3 <= 0 when D,m >= 0). + Good. (e) Cutoff errors. The support of any derivative of zeta lies in the shell rho/2 < |x - p| < rho, where dist_g(p, x) >= rho/2 is