diff edd5c36..512f5ff exp_decay_two_dim_on_v2.txt
diff --git a/exp_decay_two_dim_on_v2.txt b/exp_decay_two_dim_on_v2.txt
index dc22011..56b9812 100644
--- a/exp_decay_two_dim_on_v2.txt
+++ b/exp_decay_two_dim_on_v2.txt
@@ -15,8 +15,6 @@ sigma_x . sigma_y is the Euclidean inner product, and Z_{G,b}^{(n)}
normalizes the total mass to one. No boundary spin is fixed and no
external field is present. Expectation is written < . >_{G,b}^{(n)}.
-The central assertion is the following.
-
Main result. For every n >= 3 and every beta < infinity there are
constants A = A(n,beta) < infinity and m = m(n,beta) > 0 such that, for
every finite nearest-neighbour subgraph G of Z^2, every strength array
@@ -47,51 +45,6 @@ correlation-length asymptotics, and uniqueness of infinite-volume Gibbs
states are separate questions, and the constants may deteriorate as
beta tends to infinity.
-Three quantitative inputs drive the decay.
-
-The first is a fourth-order rotation inequality on a finite graph with
-prescribed boundary spins. Rotations of the spins about two distinct
-axes generate, to second order, a rotation about their commutator axis.
-A fourth variation of the partition function in the two noncommuting
-directions isolates this effect: after a family of test functions is
-summed, the part that could be large is a nonnegative square, and the
-response is bounded by a normalized Hilbert-Schmidt norm together with
-boundary-local error terms. The estimate allows arbitrary fixed
-boundary spins and requires no positivity of the response form.
-
-The second input is a uniform annular twist estimate. On a square
-annulus whose inner and outer boundary layers are pinned to directions
-separated by an angle t, a signed family of Fourier modes makes the
-commutator field large, of order log N on an annulus of inner radius N.
-The quadratic response then gains a factor (log N)^2 against a total
-error of order log N, so the pinned partition function Z(t) has a
-one-sided curvature bound of order 1 / log N. Integrating from a
-maximum of the positive periodic function Z gives Z(pi) / Z(0) >=
-1 - O_beta( 1 / log N ), uniformly in the retained graph and the
-strengths.
-
-The third input is a bond-percolation argument on the sign of one spin
-component. Conditioning on the spin amplitudes exposes, in each
-component, an Ising sign system on equal-sign bonds, with the
-Edwards-Sokal and Wolff representation. The Fortuin-Kasteleyn-Ginibre
-association inequalities give monotonicity of the bond law in the
-amplitudes and under pinning. The spin correlation equals an
-amplitude-weighted connection probability, pinning cannot decrease the
-probability of an increasing bond event, and the annular estimate
-identifies the pinned annulus-crossing probability with 1 - Z(pi)/Z(0),
-which is small. A coarse-grained sum over open paths converts the
-suppressed annular crossings into exponential decay of the connection
-probability and hence of the two-point function.
-
-The three-component case underlies the general one. For n > 3 a
-block-coordinate spherical disintegration writes sigma_x = (rho_x s_x,
-v_x) with v_x in R^{n-3}; conditional on all v_x the directions s_x
-have exactly the three-component Gibbs law with strengths
-b_{xy} rho_x rho_y in [0,beta], so the uniform estimate survives the
-projection, and the full correlation equals n times a first-coordinate
-correlation by coordinate symmetry. Free-boundary limits follow from
-the volume-independence of the estimate.
-
Continuous symmetry forces the two-point function of the classical
O(n) model to decay in two dimensions, but the rate is the whole
question. Mermin and Wagner proved the absence of long-range order for
@@ -161,7 +114,7 @@ correlation as an amplitude-weighted connectivity.
./campbell-chayes-1998-isotropic-o3-wolff.pdf
-The estimate concerns a finite graph with arbitrary fixed
+The estimate holds on a finite graph with arbitrary fixed
boundary spins. Let G = (V,E) be a finite graph, oriented edge by edge
as e = (x,y), with strengths 0 <= b_e <= beta. Fix a set P of pinned
vertices and arbitrary spins s_x in S^2 for x in P; at the remaining
@@ -637,10 +590,10 @@ The directional block of U factors exactly as
+ P_j M_{phi^{(j)}} F
diag( ( exp(2 pi i p_j / 16N) - 1 ) / r_p ).
-With ||P_j||_op <= 1, ||Delta_j phi||_inf <= C/N, and the last diagonal
-factor has operator norm at most C/N, since |p_j| <= r_p. With
-||F||_op = 16N this gives ||U_j||_op <= C, hence ||U||_op <= C after the
-two directions are combined.
+The operator norms ||P_j||_op <= 1 and ||Delta_j phi||_inf <= C/N hold, and
+the last diagonal factor has operator norm at most C/N, since |p_j| <= r_p.
+With ||F||_op = 16N this gives ||U_j||_op <= C, hence ||U||_op <= C after
+the two directions are combined.
The contribution of the group is T_group = U diag(r_p^{-1}) U^*. The
finite-matrix inequality ||A D B||_HS <= ||A||_op ||D||_HS ||B||_op gives
@@ -801,8 +754,8 @@ increasing functions of t. The decomposition
has nonnegative terms by induction and by the one-coordinate case. This
proves both assertions.
-The next inequalities are the Ising and plane-rotator cases of the
-method of Ginibre. Their restricted scope matters: no such inequality
+The Ising and plane-rotator cases of the method of Ginibre supply the
+required inequalities. Their restricted scope matters: no such inequality
for the full vector-spin law is assumed.
Edge-correlation lemma. In either the free Ising or the free planar
@@ -917,9 +870,9 @@ keep uniform reference measures and the same edge interactions. Bonds
are sampled by the same rule p_e 1{tau_x = tau_y}.
Pinning-comparison proposition. For the three-component free spin law on
-any finite graph with nonnegative strengths, and bonds sampled as above,
-pinning any set of spins to s_* cannot decrease the probability of any
-increasing bond event A.
+any finite graph with nonnegative strengths, and bonds sampled by the same
+rule, pinning any set of spins to s_* cannot decrease the probability of
+any increasing bond event A.
Proof. For 0 < eps < 1 condition the free system on r_x >= 1 - eps and
tau_x = 1 for every x in B. Conditional on r and eta, the probability of