diff b1f9bc4..56bc728 imaginary_quadratic_modularity_v2.txt
diff --git a/imaginary_quadratic_modularity_v2.txt b/imaginary_quadratic_modularity_v2.txt
index 989862f..f08e79c 100644
--- a/imaginary_quadratic_modularity_v2.txt
+++ b/imaginary_quadratic_modularity_v2.txt
@@ -65,12 +65,12 @@ maketitle
Abstract:
We prove that every elliptic curve over an imaginary quadratic field is
-modular: it is realized by an automorphic representation of $GL_2$ of the
+modular: it is realized by an automorphic representation of GL_2 of the
field with matching local parameters at every place and matching
-$L$-function. The method is a geometric form of Wiles's prime switch. A
+L-function. The method is a geometric form of Wiles's prime switch. A
single dihedral family of cyclic covers of a quadratic twist of the curve
produces four two-dimensional Galois representations, pairwise congruent
-modulo the primes $3$ and a large prime $p$, with an elliptic curve at one
+modulo the primes 3 and a large prime p, with an elliptic curve at one
end. Automorphy enters at that end through known results and is carried to
the original curve by three modularity-lifting steps, then descended from a
cyclotomic extension to the field itself. The complex-multiplication case is
@@ -83,81 +83,81 @@ tableofcontents
## The theorem
-Let $K$ be an imaginary quadratic number field and $E/K$ an elliptic curve.
-The modularity conjecture for $E$ asks for an automorphic representation of
-$GL_2(A_K)$ whose attached Galois representations are the cohomology of
-$E$. Concretely, at a place of good reduction this means that the Hecke
+Let K be an imaginary quadratic number field and E/K an elliptic curve.
+The modularity conjecture for E asks for an automorphic representation of
+GL_2(A_K) whose attached Galois representations are the cohomology of
+E. Concretely, at a place of good reduction this means that the Hecke
polynomial recovers the point count of the reduction; at a bad place it
means that the full local parameter, including inertia and monodromy, is
recovered; at the single complex place it means a fixed parameter dictated by
the Hodge decomposition. We prove that such a representation always exists.
-Throughout, $H^1(X)=H^1_{et}(X_{overlineoverline L}L,Q_l)$ for a variety over a
-number field $L$, with coefficients made explicit when they matter, and
-$G_L=Gal(overlineoverline L/L)$.L/L)$. The cyclotomic character is $eps_l$, normalized
-to have Hodge--Tate weight $-1$, so an elliptic curve has labeled
-Hodge--Tate weights $0,1$ on its $H^1$ and determinant $eps_l^{-1}$. For a
-regular algebraic cuspidal representation $pi$ of $GL_2(A_L)$ and an
-isomorphism $iota:overlineQ_ltoC$, we write $r_iota(pi)$ for the
-associated semisimple $l$-adic representation. The normalization of local
+Throughout, H^1(X)=H^1_{et}(X_{overlineoverline L}L,Q_l) for a variety over a
+number field L, with coefficients made explicit when they matter, and
+G_L=Gal(overlineoverline L/L).L/L). The cyclotomic character is eps_l, normalized
+to have Hodge--Tate weight -1, so an elliptic curve has labeled
+Hodge--Tate weights 0,1 on its H^1 and determinant eps_l^{-1}. For a
+regular algebraic cuspidal representation pi of GL_2(A_L) and an
+isomorphism iota:overlineQ_ltoC, we write r_iota(pi) for the
+associated semisimple l-adic representation. The normalization of local
Langlands used on the cohomological side is
-$rec^T_{L_v}(pi_v)=rec_{L_v}(pi_v ⊗ |det|_v^{-1/2})$; see
+rec^T_{L_v}(pi_v)=rec_{L_v}(pi_v ⊗ |det|_v^{-1/2}); see
Section~sec:conv.
-Let $K$ be an imaginary quadratic field and $E/K$ an elliptic curve. There is
-an isobaric automorphic representation $pi_E$ of $GL_2(A_K)$ with trivial
-central character and weight zero such that for every prime $l$ and every
-isomorphism $iota:overlineQ_ltoC$,
+Let K be an imaginary quadratic field and E/K an elliptic curve. There is
+an isobaric automorphic representation pi_E of GL_2(A_K) with trivial
+central character and weight zero such that for every prime l and every
+isomorphism iota:overlineQ_ltoC,
[
r_iota(pi_E)simeq H^1_{et}(E_{overlineoverline K}K,overlineQ_l).
]
-At every finite place $vnmid l$ the Frobenius-semisimplified
+At every finite place vnmid l the Frobenius-semisimplified
Weil--Deligne parameter of the right side equals
-$rec_{K_v}(pi_{E,v} ⊗ |det|_v^{-1/2})$, and the unitary parameter at
-the complex place is $zmapstodiag(z/|z|,overlineoverline z/|z|)$.z/|z|)$. In particular
-every local factor agrees, so $L(E/K,s)=L(pi_E,s-tfrac12)$. If $E$ has no
-complex multiplication then $pi_E$ is cuspidal; if $E$ has complex
+rec_{K_v}(pi_{E,v} ⊗ |det|_v^{-1/2}), and the unitary parameter at
+the complex place is zmapstodiag(z/|z|,overlineoverline z/|z|).z/|z|). In particular
+every local factor agrees, so L(E/K,s)=L(pi_E,s-tfrac12). If E has no
+complex multiplication then pi_E is cuspidal; if E has complex
multiplication it is an automorphic induction of a Hecke character, or an
-isobaric sum when the CM field equals $K$.
+isobaric sum when the CM field equals K.
The phrase ``with matching local parameters at every place'' together with
-the equality of $L$-functions is exactly what modularity means: the Hasse
---Weil $L$-function of the curve, an arithmetic object counting points over
-all finite fields, is the $L$-function of an automorphic form, an analytic
+the equality of L-functions is exactly what modularity means: the Hasse
+--Weil L-function of the curve, an arithmetic object counting points over
+all finite fields, is the L-function of an automorphic form, an analytic
object with a functional equation and a spectral meaning.
## Why it is hard
-Over $Q$, the modularity of every elliptic curve was completed by
+Over Q, the modularity of every elliptic curve was completed by
Wiles--Taylor and Breuil--Conrad--Diamond--Taylor. A central tool is
modularity lifting. One knows automorphy of a residual Galois
-representation $overlineoverline r$,r$, and one proves that every lift $r$ of
-$overlineoverline r$r$ with the right local behavior is also automorphic; applied to
-the Galois representation of $E$ this gives modularity of $E$. Lifting
-theorems require residual hypotheses, and Wiles's $3$--$5$ switch handles
-curves for which the residual representation of $E$ itself is unsuitable, by
+representation overlineoverline r,r, and one proves that every lift r of
+overlineoverline rr with the right local behavior is also automorphic; applied to
+the Galois representation of E this gives modularity of E. Lifting
+theorems require residual hypotheses, and Wiles's 3--5 switch handles
+curves for which the residual representation of E itself is unsuitable, by
passing through a resolvent auxiliary curve whose own modularity is already
known.
Over an imaginary quadratic field three new difficulties appear.
[label=(arabic*)]
-item The relevant cohomology of Bianchi modular forms sits in more than one
+ The relevant cohomology of Bianchi modular forms sits in more than one
degree, so constructing Galois representations and running a patching or
deformation argument both require extra work. Harris--Soudry--Taylor,
Taylor, Harris--Lan--Taylor--Thorne, Scholze, and Calegari--Geraghty supply
these constructions, and potential modularity over CM fields is available
(Allen--Calegari--Caraiani--Gee--Helm--Le Hung--Newton--Scholze--Taylor
--Thorne). But potential modularity may enlarge the field, whereas we must
-stay over $K$.
-item The known lifting theorem in the small characteristics available for
+stay over K.
+ The known lifting theorem in the small characteristics available for
starters --- Caraiani--Newton --- imposes residual conditions and local
-conditions that $E$ itself need not satisfy. Their theorem already gives
+conditions that E itself need not satisfy. Their theorem already gives
modularity for a positive proportion of curves, and for all curves when
-$X_0(15)(K)$ has rank zero, but not for all curves.
-item There is no obvious resolvent auxiliary curve directly attached to
-$E$ in the way Wiles's auxiliary curve is attached over $Q$.
+X_0(15)(K) has rank zero, but not for all curves.
+ There is no obvious resolvent auxiliary curve directly attached to
+E in the way Wiles's auxiliary curve is attached over Q.
Our contribution is to remove the restriction on the curve and on the
@@ -167,24 +167,24 @@ chain are simultaneous eigenspaces of one geometric object.
## The geometric prime switch
-Fix a non-CM elliptic curve $E/K$ and write it as $y^2=h(x)$ with origin the
-point at infinity $O$. Fix an odd integer $n=3p$, where $p>100$ is a prime
-chosen (via Serre's open image theorem) so that the image of $G_K$ on $E[p]$
-contains $SL_2(F_p)$. Put $F=K(mu_n)$. For $t$ in a nonempty Zariski-open
-subset $UsubsetA^1_K$ we build a genus-$n$ cyclic cover
+Fix a non-CM elliptic curve E/K and write it as y^2=h(x) with origin the
+point at infinity O. Fix an odd integer n=3p, where p>100 is a prime
+chosen (via Serre's open image theorem) so that the image of G_K on E[p]
+contains SL_2(F_p). Put F=K(mu_n). For t in a nonempty Zariski-open
+subset UsubsetA^1_K we build a genus-n cyclic cover
[
C_n(t)→ B_t
]
-of the quadratic twist $B_t:h(t)y^2=h(x)$ of $E$, branched at two points,
-carrying an involution $w$ that inverts the deck rotations. For each
-character $theta$ of the rotation group $mu_n$, the $theta$-eigenspace
+of the quadratic twist B_t:h(t)y^2=h(x) of E, branched at two points,
+carrying an involution w that inverts the deck rotations. For each
+character theta of the rotation group mu_n, the theta-eigenspace
[
V_theta=H^1(C_n(t))_theta
]
in integral cohomology is a rank-two compatible system with determinant
-$eps_l^{-1}$ and labeled Hodge--Tate weights $0,1$. Choose characters
-$eta$ of order $3$ and $psi$ of order $p$, and put $chi=etapsi$ of
-order $3p$. The point of the construction is the chain of congruences
+eps_l^{-1} and labeled Hodge--Tate weights 0,1. Choose characters
+eta of order 3 and psi of order p, and put chi=etapsi of
+order 3p. The point of the construction is the chain of congruences
{V_eta}_{H^1(A)}
equiv pmod{p} V_chi
@@ -192,43 +192,42 @@ order $3p$. The point of the construction is the chain of congruences
equiv pmod{p} {V_1}_{H^1(B_t)},
each congruence being an equality of semisimplified residual Galois
-representations. The order-$p$ part of a character becomes trivial modulo
-$p$, and the order-$3$ part becomes trivial modulo $3$, so the primary
-factors $eta,psi,chi$ collapse onto their neighbours. The order-three
-system $V_eta$ is $H^1$ of an elliptic curve $A/F$, while $V_1$ is $H^1$ of
-the twist $B_t$.
-
-Automorphy enters at the left. The prime $5$ is used only to certify that
-the auxiliary elliptic curve $A$ is modular: $A$ is chosen (through the same
-one-parameter family) with a large mod-$5$ image and non-CM, so the
+representations. The order-p part of a character becomes trivial modulo
+p, and the order-3 part becomes trivial modulo 3, so the primary
+factors eta,psi,chi collapse onto their neighbours. The order-three
+system V_eta is H^1 of an elliptic curve A/F, while V_1 is H^1 of
+the twist B_t.
+
+Automorphy enters at the left. The prime 5 is used only to certify that
+the auxiliary elliptic curve A is modular: A is chosen (through the same
+one-parameter family) with a large mod-5 image and non-CM, so the
elliptic-curve starting theorem of Caraiani--Newton applies. Automorphy then
propagates rightwards along (intro:chain) by three applications of the
-Caraiani--Newton lifting theorem, at primes $p,3,p$ respectively. At the end
-we know $H^1(B_t)$ is automorphic; because $B_t$ is a quadratic twist of
-$E$, twisting by the corresponding Hecke character gives automorphy of
-$H^1(E)$. Finally we descend the automorphic form from the cyclotomic field
-$F$ to the original field $K$, and handle the CM case separately.
+Caraiani--Newton lifting theorem, at primes p,3,p respectively. At the end
+we know H^1(B_t) is automorphic; because B_t is a quadratic twist of
+E, twisting by the corresponding Hecke character gives automorphy of
+H^1(E). Finally we descend the automorphic form from the cyclotomic field
+F to the original field K, and handle the CM case separately.
Two geometric specializations of the cover family make this work.
-
-item At one degeneration the Jacobian of the cover has compact-type limit
-$E^n$. Because $E^n$ is a product of copies of $E$, its cohomology --- and
+ At one degeneration the Jacobian of the cover has compact-type limit
+E^n. Because E^n is a product of copies of E, its cohomology --- and
hence the cohomology of every eigenspace --- has its reduction type (good
-ordinary, good supersingular, or totally multiplicative) read off from $E$.
+ordinary, good supersingular, or totally multiplicative) read off from E.
A local-constancy argument over the local field of coefficients transfers
this to all nearby fibers at once. This gives simultaneous local conditions
-on all four systems for one choice of $t$.
-item At the other degeneration explicit vanishing cycles cut out opposite
+on all four systems for one choice of t.
+ At the other degeneration explicit vanishing cycles cut out opposite
unipotent elements on each nontrivial eigenspace. These unipotents give
absolute irreducibility of the residual representations and produce
-suitable Frobenius elements, without any assumption that $E$ and its
+suitable Frobenius elements, without any assumption that E and its
conjugate are independent. They are also what forces the auxiliary curve to
be non-CM.
A Hilbert-irreducibility argument over the restriction of scalars
-$Res_{K/Q}U$ then finds a single rational point $t$ satisfying prescribed
+Res_{K/Q}U then finds a single rational point t satisfying prescribed
local conditions together with the residual hypotheses for both conjugates
-of $K$ at once. This gives decomposed genericity at every place above a
+of K at once. This gives decomposed genericity at every place above a
split rational prime.
We emphasize what is genuinely new here relative to Caraiani--Newton: the
@@ -249,8 +248,8 @@ relating elliptic curves and automorphic forms over imaginary quadratic
fields are due to Grunewald--Helling--Mennicke, Cremona, and
Cremona--Whitley.
-Over $Q$, Wiles and Taylor--Wiles proved modularity of semistable curves and
-Breuil--Conrad--Diamond--Taylor of all curves. Wiles's $3$--$5$ switch
+Over Q, Wiles and Taylor--Wiles proved modularity of semistable curves and
+Breuil--Conrad--Diamond--Taylor of all curves. Wiles's 3--5 switch
introduced the idea that a residual representation failing the initial
hypotheses can be replaced by one coming from an auxiliary elliptic curve
with prescribed torsion and local behavior. For imaginary quadratic fields,
@@ -264,12 +263,12 @@ Allen--Calegari--Caraiani--Gee--Helm--Le Hung--Newton--Scholze--Taylor--Thorne
and, for genus-one curves over quadratic extensions of totally real fields,
to Boxer--Calegari--Gee--Pilloni. Allen--Khare--Thorne gave residual
modularity results in small characteristic and deduced modularity for a
-positive proportion of curves over each CM field not containing $zeta_5$.
+positive proportion of curves over each CM field not containing zeta_5.
Caraiani--Newton gave a lifting theorem allowing small coefficient primes and
ramified CM fields, and deduced modularity of all curves over imaginary
-quadratic $K$ with $X_0(15)(K)$ of rank zero, of $100%$ of curves ordered by
-height over each such $K$ not containing $zeta_5$, and under residual-image
-hypotheses in characteristic $3$ or $5$. Our Theorem~thm:main removes
+quadratic K with X_0(15)(K) of rank zero, of 100% of curves ordered by
+height over each such K not containing zeta_5, and under residual-image
+hypotheses in characteristic 3 or 5. Our Theorem~thm:main removes
the last restrictions; the Caraiani--Newton lifting theorem and modularity
criterion remain essential inputs.
@@ -279,7 +278,7 @@ multiplication constructions of Tautz--Top--Verberkmoes, in Ellenberg's work
on endomorphism algebras of Jacobians, and in Mestre's constructions. Darmon
studied congruences removing prime-power parts of monodromy and a conditional
modularity argument by successive lifts for rigid local systems. The
-difference operator $2-zeta-zeta^{-1}$ in the monodromy computation is the
+difference operator 2-zeta-zeta^{-1} in the monodromy computation is the
same one appearing in rank-two monodromy studied by Darmon--Mestre. Taylor's
use of auxiliary abelian varieties with real multiplication is a
higher-dimensional form of the prime switch.
@@ -290,22 +289,22 @@ Section~sec:conv fixes conventions. Sections~sec:geom and
sec:mono build the cover family and compute its integral homology and
monodromy. Section~sec:sys constructs the four rank-two systems and
their congruences. Section~sec:inputs states the automorphy inputs in
-the precise form used and reduces the remaining work to conditions on $t$.
+the precise form used and reduces the remaining work to conditions on t.
Section~sec:local produces the local reduction conditions. Section
-sec:res produces a single $t$ satisfying all residual and local
+sec:res produces a single t satisfying all residual and local
conditions at once. Section~sec:auto runs the three lifts, descends to
-$K$, and treats the CM case.
+K, and treats the CM case.
# Conventions
-We write $eps_l$ for the cyclotomic character with Hodge--Tate weight $-1$.
+We write eps_l for the cyclotomic character with Hodge--Tate weight -1.
A bar over a characteristic-zero representation denotes the semisimplification
of the reduction of a chosen stable lattice; this semisimplification is
independent of the lattice. An elliptic curve thus has labeled Hodge--Tate
-weights $0,1$ on $H^1$ and determinant $eps_l^{-1}$.
+weights 0,1 on H^1 and determinant eps_l^{-1}.
-For a regular algebraic cuspidal representation $pi$ of $GL_2(A_L)$ over a
-CM field and $iota:overlineQ_ltoC$, the representation $r_iota(pi)$ is
+For a regular algebraic cuspidal representation pi of GL_2(A_L) over a
+CM field and iota:overlineQ_ltoC, the representation r_iota(pi) is
semisimple. We use the Tate-normalized local comparison
rec^T_{L_v}(pi_v):=rec_{L_v}(pi_v ⊗ |det|_v^{-1/2}),
@@ -314,10 +313,10 @@ with geometric-Frobenius reciprocity. The algebraic weight coming from
trivial coefficients is called weight zero. At a complex place the generic
weight-zero parameter, in unitary normalization, is
- z⟼diag(z/|z|,overlineoverline z/|z|),z/|z|),qquad |z|=(zoverlineoverline z)^z)^{1/2}.
+ z⟼diag(z/|z|,overlineoverline z/|z|),z/|z|), |z|=(zoverlineoverline z)^z)^{1/2}.
-Its Tate-normalized parameter has Hodge types $(1,0)$ and $(0,1)$. If the
-finite parameters realize an elliptic curve $E$, then
+Its Tate-normalized parameter has Hodge types (1,0) and (0,1). If the
+finite parameters realize an elliptic curve E, then
L(E/L,s)=L(pi,s-tfrac12).
@@ -326,93 +325,93 @@ For a local field, a Galois representation is potentially crystalline
if it becomes crystalline after a finite extension, and is potentially
ordinary of weight zero if after a finite extension it has an invariant line
on which inertia acts by an unramified character and a quotient on which
-inertia acts by $eps_l^{-1}$ times an unramified character; this is the
-Hodge--Tate ordering $(0,1)$. Local fields used to verify these properties may
+inertia acts by eps_l^{-1} times an unramified character; this is the
+Hodge--Tate ordering (0,1). Local fields used to verify these properties may
be enlarged independently at different places.
-A continuous representation $overlineoverline r:G_Lr:G_LtoGL_2(overlineF_l)$ over a
-number field $L$ is decomposed generic if there is a rational prime
-$qne l$ splitting completely in $L$ such that for every $vmid q$ it is
-unramified at $v$ and the Frobenius eigenvalues $alpha_v,beta_v$ satisfy
-$alpha_v/beta_vne q$ and $beta_v/alpha_vne q$ in $overlineF_l$. Our
-construction will take $qequiv1pmod l$, so it suffices to have
-$alpha_vnebeta_v$ at every $vmid q$.
+A continuous representation overlineoverline r:G_Lr:G_LtoGL_2(overlineF_l) over a
+number field L is decomposed generic if there is a rational prime
+qne l splitting completely in L such that for every vmid q it is
+unramified at v and the Frobenius eigenvalues alpha_v,beta_v satisfy
+alpha_v/beta_vne q and beta_v/alpha_vne q in overlineF_l. Our
+construction will take qequiv1pmod l, so it suffices to have
+alpha_vnebeta_v at every vmid q.
# A cyclic-cover family and its two degenerations
-Fix an imaginary quadratic field $K$, a non-CM elliptic curve $E/K$ written
-$E:y^2=h(x)$ with $h$ a separable cubic, and the origin $O=[0:1:0]$ at
-infinity. Fix an odd integer $nge3$ for the moment. We build a family of
-cyclic covers of quadratic twists of $E$ and identify two boundary fibers.
-At the first the Jacobian becomes a product of copies of $E$; at the second
+Fix an imaginary quadratic field K, a non-CM elliptic curve E/K written
+E:y^2=h(x) with h a separable cubic, and the origin O=[0:1:0] at
+infinity. Fix an odd integer nge3 for the moment. We build a family of
+cyclic covers of quadratic twists of E and identify two boundary fibers.
+At the first the Jacobian becomes a product of copies of E; at the second
the cover acquires nodes whose vanishing cycles give explicit monodromy. All
degenerations here are over a characteristic-zero parameter curve.
## The family, its dihedral symmetry, and geometric connectedness
-For $t$ with $h(t)ne0$ put
+For t with h(t)ne0 put
- B_t:quad h(t)y^2=h(x),qquad R_t=(t,1),qquad S_t=[n]R_t,
+ B_t: h(t)y^2=h(x), R_t=(t,1), S_t=[n]R_t,
-the $y$-coordinate normalized so that $R_t$ is the point $(t,1)$ on the
-twist. Let $UsubsetA^1_k$ over $ksupset K(mu_n)$ be the open set where
-$O,R_t,-R_t,S_t,-S_t$ are pairwise distinct. This is nonempty: over the double
-cover $t=x(R)$ parametrized by $Rin E$, the map
-$B_{x(R)}to E$, $(x,y)mapsto(x,y(R)y)$, identifies $R_t$ with the moving
-point $R$, and each excluded equality forces $R$ to be torsion, hence excludes
-only finitely many points. We may delete further finitely many points of $U$
+the y-coordinate normalized so that R_t is the point (t,1) on the
+twist. Let UsubsetA^1_k over ksupset K(mu_n) be the open set where
+O,R_t,-R_t,S_t,-S_t are pairwise distinct. This is nonempty: over the double
+cover t=x(R) parametrized by Rin E, the map
+B_{x(R)}to E, (x,y)mapsto(x,y(R)y), identifies R_t with the moving
+point R, and each excluded equality forces R to be torsion, hence excludes
+only finitely many points. We may delete further finitely many points of U
whenever a statement requires it.
-For each divisor $m>1$ of $n$ there is a smooth proper family of
-geometrically connected genus-$m$ curves $cC_mto U$. It is the
-normalization of the smooth proper elliptic family $Bto U$ in the
+For each divisor m>1 of n there is a smooth proper family of
+geometrically connected genus-m curves cC_mto U. It is the
+normalization of the smooth proper elliptic family Bto U in the
function-field extension described fiberwise by the Kummer equation
- Y^m=f_t(Z),qquad
- div(f_t)=(S_t)-(-S_t)-n(R_t)+n(-R_t),qquad f_t(O)=1.
+ Y^m=f_t(Z),
+ div(f_t)=(S_t)-(-S_t)-n(R_t)+n(-R_t), f_t(O)=1.
The family carries an involution
w:(Z,Y)⟼(-Z,Y^{-1})
-and, over a field containing $mu_m$, rotations
-$u_zeta:(Z,Y)mapsto(Z,zeta Y)$ with $wu_zeta w=u_{zeta^{-1}}$. For
-$dmid m$ the map $Ymapsto Y^{m/d}$ exhibits $C_{m,t}to C_{d,t}$; for $d=1$
-the quotient is $B_t$.
+and, over a field containing mu_m, rotations
+u_zeta:(Z,Y)mapsto(Z,zeta Y) with wu_zeta w=u_{zeta^{-1}}. For
+dmid m the map Ymapsto Y^{m/d} exhibits C_{m,t}to C_{d,t}; for d=1
+the quotient is B_t.
Proof.
On an elliptic curve a degree-zero divisor is principal if and only if its
-sum in the group law is $O$. The divisor in (geom:kummer) has sum
-$S_t-(-S_t)-nR_t+n(-R_t)=2S_t-2nR_t=O$, so it cuts out a rational function,
-pinned down by $f_t(O)=1$. Working over $k(U)$ and spreading out gives such a
-function on the family. Its divisor changes sign under $Zmapsto-Z$, so
-normalizing at $O$ yields
+sum in the group law is O. The divisor in (geom:kummer) has sum
+S_t-(-S_t)-nR_t+n(-R_t)=2S_t-2nR_t=O, so it cuts out a rational function,
+pinned down by f_t(O)=1. Working over k(U) and spreading out gives such a
+function on the family. Its divisor changes sign under Zmapsto-Z, so
+normalizing at O yields
f_t(-Z)=f_t(Z)^{-1}.
-This also shows $f_t$ has no vertical divisor: every fiber component is
+This also shows f_t has no vertical divisor: every fiber component is
preserved by inversion, so its valuation is its own negative. Hence the
prescribed disjoint sections are the whole divisor.
-The valuation of $f_t$ at $S_t$ is $1$, so the Kummer extension has degree
-$m$ even geometrically: it is totally ramified at $S_t$ and $-S_t$ and
-unramified elsewhere, because the remaining nonzero valuations $pm n$ are
-divisible by $m$. Riemann--Hurwitz gives $2g(C_{m,t})-2=2(m-1)$, so $g=m$.
-The same local computation shows the normalization is smooth over $U$: a
-zero or pole of order divisible by $m$ drops out of the Kummer equation, and
-at a section of order $pm1$ one takes a root of an 'etale unit and obtains
-the $m$th-root cover of a transverse parameter. Normalization is finite here,
-so the resulting family is proper. Equation~(geom:inverse) gives $w$,
+The valuation of f_t at S_t is 1, so the Kummer extension has degree
+m even geometrically: it is totally ramified at S_t and -S_t and
+unramified elsewhere, because the remaining nonzero valuations pm n are
+divisible by m. Riemann--Hurwitz gives 2g(C_{m,t})-2=2(m-1), so g=m.
+The same local computation shows the normalization is smooth over U: a
+zero or pole of order divisible by m drops out of the Kummer equation, and
+at a section of order pm1 one takes a root of an 'etale unit and obtains
+the mth-root cover of a transverse parameter. Normalization is finite here,
+so the resulting family is proper. Equation~(geom:inverse) gives w,
and the quotient statements follow from the Kummer equations.
-We pull this family back to the open set of $E$ where $R$ moves and
-$O,pm R,pm[n]R$ are distinct; the base elliptic curve there is the constant
-curve $E$. We write $C_{m,R}$ for the fiber and $f_R$ for its normalized
-function. The normalization at $O$ makes the pullback identification exact:
-it introduces no scalar into $Y^m=f_R$.
+We pull this family back to the open set of E where R moves and
+O,pm R,pm[n]R are distinct; the base elliptic curve there is the constant
+curve E. We write C_{m,R} for the fiber and f_R for its normalized
+function. The normalization at O makes the pullback identification exact:
+it introduces no scalar into Y^m=f_R.
## Separating colliding sections
@@ -420,70 +419,70 @@ The two boundary parameters we use are
R=O,
qquadandqquad
- R=R_*,quad [n]R_*in E[2]∖{O},
- quad O,pm R_*,[n]R_* distinct.
+ R=R_*, [n]R_*in E[2]∖{O},
+ O,pm R_*,[n]R_* distinct.
-The second exists after extending scalars and will be used over $C$.
+The second exists after extending scalars and will be used over C.
-In the constant-$E$ family, blow up the surface at the collision point over
+In the constant-E family, blow up the surface at the collision point over
either boundary parameter in (geom:boundary) and normalize the result in
-$Y^m=f_R$. This is a regular semistable model near that parameter. Its
-special fiber has $m$ geometric nodes over the node of the blown-up elliptic
+Y^m=f_R. This is a regular semistable model near that parameter. Its
+special fiber has m geometric nodes over the node of the blown-up elliptic
surface, each with smoothing parameter of order one in a base parameter. The
component over the exceptional projective line is a geometrically connected
rational curve.
Proof.
-At $R=O$ use parameters $r$ on the parameter curve and $z$ on $E$, both with
-the same tangent coordinate at $O$. The sections $R,-R,[n]R,-[n]R$ have
-first-order equations $z=r,-r,nr,-nr$; their strict transforms meet the
-exceptional line at $1,-1,n,-n$, and the node joining that line to the main
-component is at $∞$. At $R_*$ only $[n]R$ and $-[n]R$ collide, with
+At R=O use parameters r on the parameter curve and z on E, both with
+the same tangent coordinate at O. The sections R,-R,[n]R,-[n]R have
+first-order equations z=r,-r,nr,-nr; their strict transforms meet the
+exceptional line at 1,-1,n,-n, and the node joining that line to the main
+component is at ∞. At R_* only [n]R and -[n]R collide, with
distinct tangent slopes, so one blowup separates them from each other and from
the node.
-The involution $Zmapsto-Z$ preserves both components of each blown-up
-fiber, so by (geom:inverse) the valuation of $f_R$ on each component is
+The involution Zmapsto-Z preserves both components of each blown-up
+fiber, so by (geom:inverse) the valuation of f_R on each component is
zero; no horizontal divisor section passes through the node. Since the
-surface is regular, $f_R$ is a unit there, and an $m$th root exists 'etale.
-The node downstairs has local equation $xy=b$, so its $m$ lifts have the same
-equation and smoothing parameter $b$ rather than a higher power. At the
+surface is regular, f_R is a unit there, and an mth root exists 'etale.
+The node downstairs has local equation xy=b, so its m lifts have the same
+equation and smoothing parameter b rather than a higher power. At the
separated sections the normalization is smooth as in Lemma~geom:family.
On the exceptional line the cover is ramified exactly at the two sections of
-multiplicities $pm1$, is connected, and has genus zero by Riemann--Hurwitz.
+multiplicities pm1, is connected, and has genus zero by Riemann--Hurwitz.
[First degeneration]
-Suppose $k$ contains $mu_m$. At $R=O$ the special fiber of
-Lemma~geom:semistable is a rational curve meeting $m$ copies of $E$,
-each at one point, all defined over $k$. Rotations cyclically permute the
-elliptic components. The Jacobian family of $C_{m,R}$ extends to an abelian
-scheme on a Zariski neighborhood of $O$ in the parameter curve, with fiber
-$E^m$ at $O$.
+Suppose k contains mu_m. At R=O the special fiber of
+Lemma~geom:semistable is a rational curve meeting m copies of E,
+each at one point, all defined over k. Rotations cyclically permute the
+elliptic components. The Jacobian family of C_{m,R} extends to an abelian
+scheme on a Zariski neighborhood of O in the parameter curve, with fiber
+E^m at O.
Proof.
-Let $v=z/r$ on the exceptional line. Its normalized function is
+Let v=z/r on the exceptional line. Its normalized function is
f_{exc}(v)=(v-n)/(v+n)((v+1)/(v-1))^{n}.
-The divisor gives this up to a scalar; the section $Z=O$ meets the line at
-$v=0$ where the value is $1$, and since $n$ is odd (geom:exc) is also
-$1$ at $0$, so the scalar is $1$.
+The divisor gives this up to a scalar; the section Z=O meets the line at
+v=0 where the value is 1, and since n is odd (geom:exc) is also
+1 at 0, so the scalar is 1.
-On the main elliptic component $f_R$ has no divisor and is constant, equal to
-$f_{exc}(∞)=1$ at the node. Thus the cover of the main
-component is the disjoint union of the $m$ copies of $E$ indexed by
-$Yinmu_m$. On the exceptional line the substitution
-$Y'=Y((v-1)/(v+1))^{n/m}$ gives $Y'^m=(v-n)/(v+n)$; its $m$
-points over $v=∞$ are defined over $k$ and attach one to each elliptic
+On the main elliptic component f_R has no divisor and is constant, equal to
+f_{exc}(∞)=1 at the node. Thus the cover of the main
+component is the disjoint union of the m copies of E indexed by
+Yinmu_m. On the exceptional line the substitution
+Y'=Y((v-1)/(v+1))^{n/m} gives Y'^m=(v-n)/(v+n); its m
+points over v=∞ are defined over k and attach one to each elliptic
component.
The dual graph is a tree, so the fiber is of compact type: the
-identity-component Picard variety is the product $E^m$ of the component
-Jacobians. The marked point $(O,1)$ extends to a section through the smooth
+identity-component Picard variety is the product E^m of the component
+Jacobians. The marked point (O,1) extends to a section through the smooth
locus, and the relative Picard theorem for nodal curves of compact type makes
the Jacobian family an abelian scheme across this fiber (see
cite[Section~9.4, Theorem~1, and Section~9.2, Proposition~10]{BLR}). Shrinking
@@ -492,140 +491,140 @@ the parameter neighborhood removes the other singular fibers.
Proposition~geom:compact concerns an abelian scheme over an open subset
-of the characteristic-zero parameter curve $E_k$, and after completing $k$ it
+of the characteristic-zero parameter curve E_k, and after completing k it
is a family over that local field. No integral model of the Kummer cover in
-residue characteristic dividing $m$ is needed; the arithmetic reduction types
+residue characteristic dividing m is needed; the arithmetic reduction types
of nearby Jacobians are established separately.
## The second degeneration and its nodes
-Choose an oriented period basis $a,b$ of $E(C)$ and take $R_*=a/(2n)$, so
-$[n]R_*=a/2$ is a nonzero $2$-torsion point. The first-order equation below
-records why a loop about $R_*$ contributes one twist at each node.
+Choose an oriented period basis a,b of E(C) and take R_*=a/(2n), so
+[n]R_*=a/2 is a nonzero 2-torsion point. The first-order equation below
+records why a loop about R_* contributes one twist at each node.
-For $R_*=a/(2n)$ the special fiber of Lemma~geom:semistable consists
-of a connected unramified degree-$m$ cover $E'to E$ and a rational
-component, joined at $m$ distinct nodes. In analytic coordinates near each
-node the family has equation $XU=-2nt$, where $t=R-R_*$ is an additive local
+For R_*=a/(2n) the special fiber of Lemma~geom:semistable consists
+of a connected unramified degree-m cover E'to E and a rational
+component, joined at m distinct nodes. In analytic coordinates near each
+node the family has equation XU=-2nt, where t=R-R_* is an additive local
parameter.
Proof.
-Write $Q=a/2=[n]R_*$ and use additive coordinates $t=R-R_*$ and $z=Z-Q$. The
-colliding sections are $z=nt$ and $z=-nt$, the other divisor sections avoid
+Write Q=a/2=[n]R_* and use additive coordinates t=R-R_* and z=Z-Q. The
+colliding sections are z=nt and z=-nt, the other divisor sections avoid
this neighborhood, and
[
f_R=g(z,t),(z-nt)/(z+nt)
]
-with $g$ a unit. Taking a local $m$th root of $g$ and $V=Y/g^{1/m}$, the
+with g a unit. Taking a local mth root of g and V=Y/g^{1/m}, the
Kummer equation becomes
(z+nt)(V^m-1)=-2nt.
-For each $V=zetainmu_m$, $U=V^m-1$ is a local coordinate; setting
-$X=z+nt$ gives the asserted node equation. This is the local chart of the
-normalization of the blowup of Lemma~geom:semistable, with $X=0$ the
-exceptional component and $U=0$ the main component.
+For each V=zetainmu_m, U=V^m-1 is a local coordinate; setting
+X=z+nt gives the asserted node equation. This is the local chart of the
+normalization of the blowup of Lemma~geom:semistable, with X=0 the
+exceptional component and U=0 the main component.
-On the main component the limiting divisor is $n(-R_*)-n(R_*)$, whose
-unramified Kummer cover is governed by the $m$-torsion class
+On the main component the limiting divisor is n(-R_*)-n(R_*), whose
+unramified Kummer cover is governed by the m-torsion class
[
frac nm((-R_*)-(R_*))
- quad↔quad
+ ↔
-(2n)/(m)R_*=-(a)/(m)quadin E(C).
]
-This class has exact order $m$, so the cover is connected; being unramified of
-degree $m$ over an elliptic curve, it is itself an elliptic curve $E'$. The
-exceptional cover is rational by Lemma~geom:semistable, and its $m$
+This class has exact order m, so the cover is connected; being unramified of
+degree m over an elliptic curve, it is itself an elliptic curve E'. The
+exceptional cover is rational by Lemma~geom:semistable, and its m
attachments are exactly these nodes.
-The first degeneration gives a split product fiber $E^m$ together with a
+The first degeneration gives a split product fiber E^m together with a
neighborhood over which nearby smooth fibers can be compared to it; the
-second gives $m$ nodes of smoothing order one whose vanishing cycles we count
+second gives m nodes of smoothing order one whose vanishing cycles we count
next in a single integral basis.
# Integral homology and explicit monodromy
-Fix the complex elliptic curve $E$ and the constant-$E$ family of
-Section~sec:geom. Let $nge3$ be odd and $m>1$ divide $n$. Write
-$Gamma_m=mu_m$ and let $u:(Z,Y)mapsto(Z,e^{2pi i/m}Y)$ generate the deck
-group; throughout $Z[Gamma_m]$ is the group ring, not a cyclotomic integer
-ring. We build an integral basis permuted by $u$ and compute two monodromy
+Fix the complex elliptic curve E and the constant-E family of
+Section~sec:geom. Let nge3 be odd and m>1 divide n. Write
+Gamma_m=mu_m and let u:(Z,Y)mapsto(Z,e^{2pi i/m}Y) generate the deck
+group; throughout Z[Gamma_m] is the group ring, not a cyclotomic integer
+ring. We build an integral basis permuted by u and compute two monodromy
operators in that one basis. Their reduction on character spaces gives the
residual irreducibility used later.
## A basis from cutting the torus
-Choose an oriented period basis $a,b$ and identify the underlying oriented
-torus with $(R/Z)^2$, with $a$ horizontal and $b$ vertical. Consider the
+Choose an oriented period basis a,b and identify the underlying oriented
+torus with (R/Z)^2, with a horizontal and b vertical. Consider the
path of parameters
- R_s=(s)/(n)a,qquad 0<s<tfrac12,
+ R_s=(s)/(n)a, 0<s<tfrac12,
-whose branch points are $mp sa$. Let $I_s$ be the horizontal arc from $-sa$
-to $sa$ through $O$.
+whose branch points are mp sa. Let I_s be the horizontal arc from -sa
+to sa through O.
-For parameters (mon:path) the cover $C_{m,R_s}to E$ is trivial over
-$E∖ I_s$; it is obtained by cutting $m$ copies of $E$ along $I_s$ and
+For parameters (mon:path) the cover C_{m,R_s}to E is trivial over
+E∖ I_s; it is obtained by cutting m copies of E along I_s and
joining adjacent banks cyclically. Crossing the slit changes the sheet index by
-$pm1$ according to the crossing orientation and the initial indexing.
+pm1 according to the crossing orientation and the initial indexing.
Proof.
-For small $s$ enclose the colliding sections in a small disk about $O$. By
-Proposition~geom:compact the model at $R=O$ restricts outside that disk
-to $m$ disjoint copies of its complement. The inclusion
-$E∖int(D)into E∖ I_s$ is a homotopy
-equivalence, so the unramified cover of $E∖ I_s$ is trivial. As $s$
-varies in $(0,1/2)$ the arcs $I_s$ move by isotopy and the cover's
+For small s enclose the colliding sections in a small disk about O. By
+Proposition~geom:compact the model at R=O restricts outside that disk
+to m disjoint copies of its complement. The inclusion
+E∖int(D)into E∖ I_s is a homotopy
+equivalence, so the unramified cover of E∖ I_s is trivial. As s
+varies in (0,1/2) the arcs I_s move by isotopy and the cover's
topological type is constant. The monodromy around either branch point is a
-generator of $Gamma_m$, since its valuation in $f_R$ is $pm1$. This gives
+generator of Gamma_m, since its valuation in f_R is pm1. This gives
the stated gluing.
-On each sheet let $a_i$ be the horizontal loop at height $1/2$ and $b_i$ the
-vertical loop at position $1/2$, $iinZ/mZ$. They avoid the slit, meet once
+On each sheet let a_i be the horizontal loop at height 1/2 and b_i the
+vertical loop at position 1/2, iinZ/mZ. They avoid the slit, meet once
on their common sheet, and are oriented so that
- < a_i,b_j>=delta_{ij},qquad
+ < a_i,b_j>=delta_{ij},
< a_i,a_j>=< b_i,b_j>=0,
-and $u$ sends $a_i,b_i$ to $a_{i+1},b_{i+1}$.
+and u sends a_i,b_i to a_{i+1},b_{i+1}.
-The cycles $a_i,b_i$ form an integral symplectic basis of
-$H_1(C_{m,R_s},Z)$. Consequently, for every smooth fiber,
+The cycles a_i,b_i form an integral symplectic basis of
+H_1(C_{m,R_s},Z). Consequently, for every smooth fiber,
H_1(C_m,Z)simeqZ[Gamma_m]^2,
- qquad H^1(C_m,Z)simeqZ[Gamma_m]^2.
+ H^1(C_m,Z)simeqZ[Gamma_m]^2.
-After comparison, $H^1_{et}(C_m,Z_l)$ is free of rank two over
-$Z_l[Gamma_m]$ for every prime $l$, including $lmid m$.
+After comparison, H^1_{et}(C_m,Z_l) is free of rank two over
+Z_l[Gamma_m] for every prime l, including lmid m.
Proof.
-The genus is $m$, so $H_1$ has rank $2m$. By (mon:intersection) the
-$2m$ displayed classes are independent and span a sublattice with unimodular
-pairing; if its index in $H_1$ were $d$, the intersection determinant would
-differ by $d^2$, but both are $1$, so $d=1$. The deck action gives the first
+The genus is m, so H_1 has rank 2m. By (mon:intersection) the
+2m displayed classes are independent and span a sublattice with unimodular
+pairing; if its index in H_1 were d, the intersection determinant would
+differ by d^2, but both are 1, so d=1. The deck action gives the first
isomorphism.
The dual of a regular module is regular: the coefficient-of-identity pairing
-$Z[Gamma_m]timesZ[Gamma_m]toZ$, $(x,y)mapsto[1](xy)$, is perfect and,
+Z[Gamma_m]timesZ[Gamma_m]toZ, (x,y)mapsto[1](xy), is perfect and,
with the pullback action on the dual, identifies
-$Hom_{Z}(Z[Gamma_m],Z)$ with $Z[Gamma_m]$. This proves the
-cohomological assertion without dividing by $m$. Topological local
+Hom_{Z}(Z[Gamma_m],Z) with Z[Gamma_m]. This proves the
+cohomological assertion without dividing by m. Topological local
triviality transports the result through the smooth parameter open, and
comparison gives the 'etale statement.
The compact-type degeneration gives a second view: the Jacobian extends to an
-abelian scheme with special fiber $E^m$ on which $Gamma_m$ permutes the
+abelian scheme with special fiber E^m on which Gamma_m permutes the
factors regularly, and the integral homology of that fiber is the regular
module twice. The slit construction makes this concrete by identifying cycles
that continue toward the other degeneration.
@@ -633,43 +632,43 @@ that continue toward the other degeneration.
## Vanishing cycles and a common monodromy basis
-Let $sto1/2$ in (mon:path). The branch points meet at $a/2$ while the
+Let sto1/2 in (mon:path). The branch points meet at a/2 while the
slit fills all but a shrinking gap in the horizontal circle. Take a small disk
-about $a/2$ containing both branch points; its boundary has $m$ closed lifts
-$delta_i$, the neck circles at the $m$ nodes of Lemma~geom:collision,
+about a/2 containing both branch points; its boundary has m closed lifts
+delta_i, the neck circles at the m nodes of Lemma~geom:collision,
hence the vanishing cycles.
After a cyclic indexing of the lifts,
- [delta_i]=pm(a_i-a_{i+1}),qquad iinZ/mZ,
+ [delta_i]=pm(a_i-a_{i+1}), iinZ/mZ,
-or the same formula with $i-1$ in place of $i+1$.
+or the same formula with i-1 in place of i+1.
Proof.
Arrange the boundary circle to cross the slit transversely twice. A lifted
boundary circle has its upper arc on one sheet and its lower arc on an adjacent
-sheet; index the upper sheet by $i$, so the lower is $i+1$ or $i-1$ by
-Lemma~mon:slit. The circle is disjoint from every $a_j$, and crosses the
+sheet; index the upper sheet by i, so the lower is i+1 or i-1 by
+Lemma~mon:slit. The circle is disjoint from every a_j, and crosses the
two corresponding vertical loops once each with opposite signs and no other
-$b_j$. These intersections determine its class in the integral symplectic basis
+b_j. These intersections determine its class in the integral symplectic basis
of Proposition~mon:integral, giving (mon:delta).
[Monodromy transvections]
-In one integral basis $a_i,b_i$ as above, the geometric monodromy of the
-constant-$E$ family contains operators $T_a,T_b$ with
+In one integral basis a_i,b_i as above, the geometric monodromy of the
+constant-E family contains operators T_a,T_b with
T_a(a_j)&=a_j,&
T_a(b_j)&=b_j+sigma_a(2a_j-a_{j-1}-a_{j+1}),
T_b(b_j)&=b_j,&
T_b(a_j)&=a_j+sigma_b(2b_j-b_{j-1}-b_{j+1}),
-where $sigma_a,sigma_bin{1,-1}$ are independent of $j$. Equivalently,
-their off-diagonal entries in the free $Z[Gamma_m]$-module are
-$sigma_a(2-u-u^{-1})$ and $sigma_b(2-u-u^{-1})$. The geometric monodromy of the
-family over $U$ contains these actions under the pullback identification.
+where sigma_a,sigma_bin{1,-1} are independent of j. Equivalently,
+their off-diagonal entries in the free Z[Gamma_m]-module are
+sigma_a(2-u-u^{-1}) and sigma_b(2-u-u^{-1}). The geometric monodromy of the
+family over U contains these actions under the pullback identification.
Proof.
@@ -677,39 +676,39 @@ The Picard--Lefschetz formula for a positively oriented loop about a
semistable fiber is the product of the Dehn twists at its nodes (see
cite[Expos'e~XV]{SGA7II}). Every node has smoothing order one by
(geom:node), so every twist has exponent one. The vanishing cycles are
-disjoint, so their mutual intersection pairings vanish, and a class $gamma$
+disjoint, so their mutual intersection pairings vanish, and a class gamma
maps to
gamma⟼gamma+sigmasum_i<gamma,delta_i>[delta_i]
-with one sign $sigma$ fixed by the intersection convention. Substituting
-(mon:delta) gives zero on the $a_j$ and, up to the sign,
+with one sign sigma fixed by the intersection convention. Substituting
+(mon:delta) gives zero on the a_j and, up to the sign,
(a_j-a_{j+1})-(a_{j-1}-a_j)=2a_j-a_{j-1}-a_{j+1}
-on $b_j$, proving (mon:Ta). Replacing the horizontal path by
-$R_s=(s/n)b$ gives (mon:Tb), initially in the basis from the vertical
+on b_j, proving (mon:Ta). Replacing the horizontal path by
+R_s=(s/n)b gives (mon:Tb), initially in the basis from the vertical
slit.
It remains to compare the two bases, since separate triangular matrices in
unrelated bases would not suffice. Choose both starting parameters close to
-$O$. The horizontal loop at $y=1/2$ and the vertical loop at $x=1/2$ avoid one
-fixed small disk about $O$ and both short slits. Outside this disk the covering
-extends across $R=O$ as $m$ disjoint sheets; trivialize it over a small simply
-connected parameter disk containing $O$ and use this trivialization to label the
+O. The horizontal loop at y=1/2 and the vertical loop at x=1/2 avoid one
+fixed small disk about O and both short slits. Outside this disk the covering
+extends across R=O as m disjoint sheets; trivialize it over a small simply
+connected parameter disk containing O and use this trivialization to label the
lifts of the two fixed loops. Parallel transport between the starting
-parameters then identifies both sets of $a_i,b_i$ with the same basis. There is
-no monodromy ambiguity from looping $O$, because the sheet trivialization
-extends over $O$. A different initial labeling only imposes a common cyclic
+parameters then identifies both sets of a_i,b_i with the same basis. There is
+no monodromy ambiguity from looping O, because the sheet trivialization
+extends over O. A different initial labeling only imposes a common cyclic
shift, leaving (mon:Ta)--(mon:Tb) unchanged.
Both loops therefore give these operators in a single geometric monodromy
-group. Pullback along the open parameter curve of $Eto U$ maps its fundamental
-group into that of $U$, so the operators occur in the latter image too, and
+group. Pullback along the open parameter curve of Eto U maps its fundamental
+group into that of U, so the operators occur in the latter image too, and
deleting further finitely many points does not remove them.
-The operator $2-u-u^{-1}$ is the cyclic difference operator coming from the
+The operator 2-u-u^{-1} is the cyclic difference operator coming from the
adjacent-sheet vanishing classes. The next section uses the integral module of
Proposition~mon:integral to specialize rotation characters, and the two
matrices above to keep the resulting residual representations irreducible.
@@ -724,97 +723,97 @@ congruences even at primes dividing the covering degree.
## Standing setup
-Return to the imaginary quadratic field $K$ and a non-CM elliptic curve $E/K$.
+Return to the imaginary quadratic field K and a non-CM elliptic curve E/K.
By Serre's open image theorem cite[S4.4, Th'eor`eme~3]{SerreOpenImage}
-choose a prime $p>100$ such that the image of $G_K$ on $E[p]$ contains
-$SL_2(F_p)$, and set
+choose a prime p>100 such that the image of G_K on E[p] contains
+SL_2(F_p), and set
- n=3p,qquad F=K(mu_n).
+ n=3p, F=K(mu_n).
-Both $K/Q$ and $Q(mu_n)/Q$ are abelian, so $F/Q$ is abelian; $F$ is a CM
+Both K/Q and Q(mu_n)/Q are abelian, so F/Q is abelian; F is a CM
field, since complex conjugation is central with totally real fixed field and
-$F$ has no real embedding (it contains $K$). Moreover
+F has no real embedding (it contains K). Moreover
zeta_5notin F.
-Indeed $Q(mu_n)$ is unramified at $5$, so the ramification index of $F$ at
-$5$ is at most $[K:Q]=2$, whereas a field containing $Q(zeta_5)$ has
-ramification index divisible by $4$ at $5$.
+Indeed Q(mu_n) is unramified at 5, so the ramification index of F at
+5 is at most [K:Q]=2, whereas a field containing Q(zeta_5) has
+ramification index divisible by 4 at 5.
-Apply Lemma~geom:family with this $n$: let $UsubsetA^1_K$ be its
-parameter open and $B_t$ the quadratic twist of $E$. We shrink $U$ whenever a
+Apply Lemma~geom:family with this n: let UsubsetA^1_K be its
+parameter open and B_t the quadratic twist of E. We shrink U whenever a
smooth proper model of one of the finitely many families is needed. Until
-Section~sec:res the point $tin U(K)$ is arbitrary.
+Section~sec:res the point tin U(K) is arbitrary.
## Character spaces
-Fix an embedding $overlineQintoC$ and put $M=Q(mu_n)$. For each prime
-$l$ choose $j_l:overlineQintooverlineQ_l$ and an isomorphism
-$iota_l:overlineQ_ltoC$ whose composite with $j_l$ is the fixed complex
+Fix an embedding overlineQintoC and put M=Q(mu_n). For each prime
+l choose j_l:overlineQintooverlineQ_l and an isomorphism
+iota_l:overlineQ_ltoC whose composite with j_l is the fixed complex
embedding. Every rotation character is a homomorphism
-$theta:mu_n(F)to M^times$. For the fiber $C_n=C_n(t)$ define
+theta:mu_n(F)to M^times. For the fiber C_n=C_n(t) define
V_{theta,l}=bigl{xin H^1_{et}(C_{n,overlineoverline F}F,overlineQ_l):
u^*x=j_l(theta(u))x for all uinmu_n(F)bigr},
-where $u$ denotes the deck transformation with multiplier $u$. All deck
-transformations are defined over $F$, so these are $G_F$-representations; write
-$V_theta$ for the system of realizations. In any congruence at $l$ all
-characters use the same $j_l$, which is essential when comparing reductions.
+where u denotes the deck transformation with multiplier u. All deck
+transformations are defined over F, so these are G_F-representations; write
+V_theta for the system of realizations. In any congruence at l all
+characters use the same j_l, which is essential when comparing reductions.
-For every $tin U(K)$ and every rotation character $theta$, the system
-$V_{theta,l}$ satisfies:
+For every tin U(K) and every rotation character theta, the system
+V_{theta,l} satisfies:
[label=(arabic*)]
-item it is semisimple of dimension two with determinant $eps_l^{-1}$;
-item at every place of $F$ above $l$ it is potentially semistable with
-labeled Hodge--Tate weights ${0,1}$;
-item there is a finite set of places $S$ of $F$, independent of $l$, such
-that $V_{theta,l}$ is unramified outside $S$ at places of residue
-characteristic $ne l$, with Frobenius characteristic polynomial the image under
-$j_l$ of a polynomial in $M[T]$ independent of $l$.
+ it is semisimple of dimension two with determinant eps_l^{-1};
+ at every place of F above l it is potentially semistable with
+labeled Hodge--Tate weights {0,1};
+ there is a finite set of places S of F, independent of l, such
+that V_{theta,l} is unramified outside S at places of residue
+characteristic ne l, with Frobenius characteristic polynomial the image under
+j_l of a polynomial in M[T] independent of l.
Proof.
The rank-two regular module of Proposition~mon:integral, followed by
-comparison between singular and $l$-adic cohomology, gives $dim V_{theta,l}=2$.
+comparison between singular and l-adic cohomology, gives dim V_{theta,l}=2.
-Let $<,,>$ be the cup-product pairing on $H^1(C_n)$ into
-$overlineQ_l(-1)$. It pairs the $theta$-space perfectly with the
-$theta^{-1}$-space, and the involution $w$, defined over $F$ and preserving cup
+Let <,,> be the cup-product pairing on H^1(C_n) into
+overlineQ_l(-1). It pairs the theta-space perfectly with the
+theta^{-1}-space, and the involution w, defined over F and preserving cup
product, exchanges them. Thus
[
- [x,y]_theta=< x,w^*y>,qquad x,yin V_{theta,l},
+ [x,y]_theta=< x,w^*y>, x,yin V_{theta,l},
]
-is a perfect $G_F$-equivariant pairing into $overlineQ_l(-1)$, alternating
-because $< y,w^*x>=< w^*y,x>=-< x,w^*y>$. A
+is a perfect G_F-equivariant pairing into overlineQ_l(-1), alternating
+because < y,w^*x>=< w^*y,x>=-< x,w^*y>. A
perfect alternating pairing on a two-dimensional space trivializes the
-determinant against the target line, so $det V_{theta,l}=eps_l^{-1}$.
+determinant against the target line, so det V_{theta,l}=eps_l^{-1}.
-For the Hodge numbers, fix an embedding of $F$ into $C$ and let $a_theta$ be
-the multiplicity of $theta$ in the holomorphic differentials of the resulting
-curve. The holomorphic involution gives $a_theta=a_{theta^{-1}}$, and the
+For the Hodge numbers, fix an embedding of F into C and let a_theta be
+the multiplicity of theta in the holomorphic differentials of the resulting
+curve. The holomorphic involution gives a_theta=a_{theta^{-1}}, and the
Hodge decomposition together with complex conjugation identifies the dimension
-of the full $theta$-space with $a_theta+a_{theta^{-1}}$. As this dimension is
-two, $a_theta=1$ for every embedding and character; the comparison theorems
-then give labeled weights $0,1$. Potential semistability comes from semistable
+of the full theta-space with a_theta+a_{theta^{-1}}. As this dimension is
+two, a_theta=1 for every embedding and character; the comparison theorems
+then give labeled weights 0,1. Potential semistability comes from semistable
reduction and the semistable comparison theorem for smooth proper varieties
[cite], and passes to character summands.
-Outside a finite set $C_n$ has good reduction and the rotations extend to its
+Outside a finite set C_n has good reduction and the rotations extend to its
smooth proper model; smooth proper base change gives unramifiedness. The
-projector onto the $theta$-space is
-$e_theta=tfrac1nsum_{uinmu_n(F)}j_l(theta(u))^{-1}u^*$, used only in
+projector onto the theta-space is
+e_theta=tfrac1nsum_{uinmu_n(F)}j_l(theta(u))^{-1}u^*, used only in
characteristic zero. The Lefschetz trace formula for a rotation composed with a
-positive power of Frobenius shows the trace on $H^1(C_n)$ is independent of
-$l$; applying the projector gives traces in $M$ compatible under the $j_l$.
+positive power of Frobenius shows the trace on H^1(C_n) is independent of
+l; applying the projector gives traces in M compatible under the j_l.
Together with the known determinant this gives the common characteristic
polynomial.
-Finally $H^1(C_n)$ is the first cohomology of its Jacobian, so Faltings'
+Finally H^1(C_n) is the first cohomology of its Jacobian, so Faltings'
semisimplicity theorem cite[S5, Satz~3]{Faltings} makes it a semisimple
-$G_F$-representation. Extension of scalars and passage to a stable summand
+G_F-representation. Extension of scalars and passage to a stable summand
preserve semisimplicity.
@@ -825,12 +824,12 @@ the order-three character the involution produces a genus-one quotient rather
than only an abstract rank-two summand.
-If $theta$ has order $m>1$ dividing $n$, the system $V_theta$ is realized by
-the corresponding character space in $H^1(C_m)$. For the trivial character,
-$V_{1,l}simeq H^1_{et}(B_{t,overlineoverline F}F,overlineQ_l)$. Let
-$D_t=C_3(t)/< w>$ and $A_t=Jac(D_t)$. Then $D_t$ has genus one,
-$A_t$ is an elliptic curve over $F$, and for either nontrivial order-three
-character $eta$ there are $G_F$-equivariant isomorphisms
+If theta has order m>1 dividing n, the system V_theta is realized by
+the corresponding character space in H^1(C_m). For the trivial character,
+V_{1,l}simeq H^1_{et}(B_{t,overlineoverline F}F,overlineQ_l). Let
+D_t=C_3(t)/< w> and A_t=Jac(D_t). Then D_t has genus one,
+A_t is an elliptic curve over F, and for either nontrivial order-three
+character eta there are G_F-equivariant isomorphisms
[
V_{eta,l}simeq H^1_{et}(A_{t,overlineoverline F}F,overlineQ_l)
qquadfor every l.
@@ -838,74 +837,74 @@ character $eta$ there are $G_F$-equivariant isomorphisms
Proof.
-The quotient $C_nto C_m$ sends $Y$ to $Y^{n/m}$. Pullback is injective on
+The quotient C_nto C_m sends Y to Y^{n/m}. Pullback is injective on
rational cohomology since its composite with the trace is multiplication by the
-degree, and its image is the fixed space of the kernel of $mu_ntomu_m$; the
-rank computation identifies the order-$m$ character summand with
-$V_{theta,l}$. The same argument for $C_nto B_t$ identifies the trivial
+degree, and its image is the fixed space of the kernel of mu_ntomu_m; the
+rank computation identifies the order-m character summand with
+V_{theta,l}. The same argument for C_nto B_t identifies the trivial
character space.
-On $H^1(C_3)$ the trivial rotation space is $H^1(B_t)$, where $w$ acts by
-$[-1]^*=-1$, and $w$ exchanges the two nontrivial rotation spaces, each of
+On H^1(C_3) the trivial rotation space is H^1(B_t), where w acts by
+[-1]^*=-1, and w exchanges the two nontrivial rotation spaces, each of
dimension two. Their direct sum therefore contains a two-dimensional
-$w$-invariant subspace. Rational cohomology of a finite quotient is the
-invariant space, so $H^1(D_t)simeq H^1(C_3)^{w=1}$ has dimension two: $D_t$ has
-genus one and its Jacobian $A_t$ is an elliptic curve, with or without an
-$F$-rational point. Projection of $x+w^*x$ onto the $eta$-space is $x$, so this
-projection is a $G_F$-equivariant isomorphism from the invariant space to
-$V_{eta,l}$. Finally $H^1(D_t)simeq H^1(Jac(D_t))$ depends on no choice of
+w-invariant subspace. Rational cohomology of a finite quotient is the
+invariant space, so H^1(D_t)simeq H^1(C_3)^{w=1} has dimension two: D_t has
+genus one and its Jacobian A_t is an elliptic curve, with or without an
+F-rational point. Projection of x+w^*x onto the eta-space is x, so this
+projection is a G_F-equivariant isomorphism from the invariant space to
+V_{eta,l}. Finally H^1(D_t)simeq H^1(Jac(D_t)) depends on no choice of
geometric base point, since translations act trivially on cohomology.
## Evaluation of the integral group ring
-A character projector carries the denominator $n$ and cannot by itself give a
-congruence at $3$ or $p$. Instead we use the integral freeness of
+A character projector carries the denominator n and cannot by itself give a
+congruence at 3 or p. Instead we use the integral freeness of
Proposition~mon:integral: evaluating a free group-ring module at a
character yields a lattice before reduction, and two characters with equal
residual values then yield equal residual representations.
-Fix $tin U(K)$ and a prime $l$. Let $L/Q_l$ be a finite extension containing
-$j_l(M)$, with ring of integers $cO$, maximal ideal $mathfrak m$,frakm$, and residue
-field $k$. For a rotation character $theta$ the module
+Fix tin U(K) and a prime l. Let L/Q_l be a finite extension containing
+j_l(M), with ring of integers cO, maximal ideal mathfrak m,frakm, and residue
+field k. For a rotation character theta the module
[
mathcal T_calT_theta
=H^1_{et}(C_{n,overlineoverline F}F,Z_l) ⊗ _{Z_l[mu_n],,j_ltheta}cO
]
-is a free rank-two $G_F$-stable lattice realizing $V_{theta,l}$ after
-extension to $overlineQ_l$. If $j_ltheta$ and $j_ltheta'$ have the same
-reduction as characters $mu_nto k^times$, then
-$mathcal T_calT_theta/mathfrak mfrakmmathcal T_calT_thetasimeq
-mathcal T_calT_{theta'}/mathfrak mfrakmmathcal T_calT_{theta'}$ as $k[G_F]$-modules.
+is a free rank-two G_F-stable lattice realizing V_{theta,l} after
+extension to overlineQ_l. If j_ltheta and j_ltheta' have the same
+reduction as characters mu_nto k^times, then
+mathcal T_calT_theta/mathfrak mfrakmmathcal T_calT_thetasimeq
+mathcal T_calT_{theta'}/mathfrak mfrakmmathcal T_calT_{theta'} as k[G_F]-modules.
Proof.
By Proposition~mon:integral and comparison,
-$H^1_{et}(C_{n,overlineoverline F}F,Z_l)simeqZ_l[mu_n]^2$ as group-ring modules,
+H^1_{et}(C_{n,overlineoverline F}F,Z_l)simeqZ_l[mu_n]^2 as group-ring modules,
and the Galois action commutes with the group ring because the rotations are
-defined over $F$. Tensoring by evaluation at $j_ltheta$ gives a free rank-two
-$cO$-module with continuous Galois action; in characteristic zero the group
+defined over F. Tensoring by evaluation at j_ltheta gives a free rank-two
+cO-module with continuous Galois action; in characteristic zero the group
algebra is semisimple and its quotient by character evaluation is the
-corresponding summand, so the rational representation is $V_{theta,l}$. After
+corresponding summand, so the rational representation is V_{theta,l}. After
reduction the tensor product becomes
-$H^1_{et}(C_{n,overlineoverline F}F,Z_l) ⊗ _{Z_l[mu_n],bartheta}k$, which
-depends only on the residual evaluation $bartheta$. This holds without
-assuming $l$ prime to $n$.
+H^1_{et}(C_{n,overlineoverline F}F,Z_l) ⊗ _{Z_l[mu_n],bartheta}k, which
+depends only on the residual evaluation bartheta. This holds without
+assuming l prime to n.
-Choose a primitive character $chi$ of order $n=3p$ with primary decomposition
-$chi=psieta$, $ord(psi)=p$, $ord(eta)=3$. For a system $V_theta$ write
-$overlineoverline V_V_{theta,l}$ for the semisimplified reduction of a stable lattice,
-scalars extended to $overlineF_l$; this is independent of the lattice.
+Choose a primitive character chi of order n=3p with primary decomposition
+chi=psieta, ord(psi)=p, ord(eta)=3. For a system V_theta write
+overlineoverline V_V_{theta,l} for the semisimplified reduction of a stable lattice,
+scalars extended to overlineF_l; this is independent of the lattice.
-For every $tin U(K)$,
+For every tin U(K),
overlineoverline V_V_{eta,p}simeqoverlineoverline V_V_{chi,p},
- qquad
+
overlineoverline V_V_{chi,3}simeqoverlineoverline V_V_{psi,3},
- qquad
+
overlineoverline V_V_{psi,p}simeqoverlineoverline V_V_{1,p},
holding with the elliptic-curve realizations of Proposition~sys:elliptic
@@ -913,25 +912,25 @@ at the two ends.
Proof.
-A root of unity of $l$-power order reduces to $1$ in characteristic $l$. Thus
-$chi$ and $eta$ agree modulo $p$, $chi$ and $psi$ agree modulo $3$, and
-$psi$ and $1$ agree modulo $p$. Lemma~sys:integral gives the three
+A root of unity of l-power order reduces to 1 in characteristic l. Thus
+chi and eta agree modulo p, chi and psi agree modulo 3, and
+psi and 1 agree modulo p. Lemma~sys:integral gives the three
congruences, and the rational isomorphisms with smaller covers and elliptic
curves in Proposition~sys:elliptic preserve semisimplified reduction even
-if their natural integral pullbacks have index divisible by $l$.
+if their natural integral pullbacks have index divisible by l.
-The direction is now fixed: automorphy will pass from $V_eta$ to $V_chi$ at
-$p$, to $V_psi$ at $3$, and to $V_1$ at $p$. The congruences place no
-condition on $t$; the local and residual arguments choose one $t$ for which all
+The direction is now fixed: automorphy will pass from V_eta to V_chi at
+p, to V_psi at 3, and to V_1 at p. The congruences place no
+condition on t; the local and residual arguments choose one t for which all
three lifts apply.
# Automorphy inputs
The congruences of Corollary~sys:congruences tie the cohomology of the
-auxiliary elliptic curve $A$ to that of the twist $B_t$ of $E$. To turn them
+auxiliary elliptic curve A to that of the twist B_t of E. To turn them
into automorphy we use two results of Caraiani--Newton, stated here in the
-exact form needed, and then isolate what the parameter $t$ must still
+exact form needed, and then isolate what the parameter t must still
satisfy. All references to [cite] use the numbering of its third arXiv
version.
@@ -940,46 +939,46 @@ introduced in Section~sec:conv.
We also record the automorphic condition paired with potential ordinarity of
Galois representations in the convention of Section~sec:conv. It is
-called $iota$-ordinarity of weight zero and is the ordinary Hecke
+called iota-ordinarity of weight zero and is the ordinary Hecke
condition used in cite[Theorem~5.2]{CN}. It is imposed at a sufficiently deep
level, so it allows ramified finite-order characters. We obtain it only for
quadratic twists of Steinberg, via the local computation of
cite[Lemma~6.1.3(4)]{CN}.
[Caraiani--Newton lifting, specialized form]
-Let $L$ be a CM number field and $l$ an odd prime other than $5$. Let
-$r:G_LtoGL_2(overlineQ_l)$ be continuous, unramified outside finitely many
-places, with determinant $eps_l^{-1}$. Suppose that:
+Let L be a CM number field and l an odd prime other than 5. Let
+r:G_LtoGL_2(overlineQ_l) be continuous, unramified outside finitely many
+places, with determinant eps_l^{-1}. Suppose that:
[label=(roman*)]
-item $r$ is potentially semistable with labeled Hodge--Tate weights $0,1$ at
-every $vmid l$;
-item $overlineoverline r$r$ is decomposed generic;
-item $overlineoverline r|_r|_{G_{L(zeta_l)}}$ is absolutely irreducible.
+ r is potentially semistable with labeled Hodge--Tate weights 0,1 at
+every vmid l;
+ overlineoverline rr is decomposed generic;
+ overlineoverline r|_r|_{G_{L(zeta_l)}} is absolutely irreducible.
Suppose there are a cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic representation
-$pi$ of $PGL_2(A_L)$ and an isomorphism $iota:overlineQ_ltoC$ with
-$r_iota(pi)barsimeqoverlineoverline r$.r$. At each $vmid l$ assume one of:
+pi of PGL_2(A_L) and an isomorphism iota:overlineQ_ltoC with
+r_iota(pi)barsimeqoverlineoverline r.r. At each vmid l assume one of:
[label=(arabic*)]
-item both local Galois representations are potentially crystalline; one is
+ both local Galois representations are potentially crystalline; one is
potentially ordinary of weight zero if and only if the other is; and
-$rec_{L_v}(pi_v)$ has zero monodromy;
-item neither local Galois representation is potentially crystalline, and
-$pi$ is $iota$-ordinary of weight zero at $v$.
+rec_{L_v}(pi_v) has zero monodromy;
+ neither local Galois representation is potentially crystalline, and
+pi is iota-ordinary of weight zero at v.
-Then $rsimeq r_iota(Pi)$ for a cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic
-representation $Pi$ of $PGL_2(A_L)$.
+Then rsimeq r_iota(Pi) for a cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic
+representation Pi of PGL_2(A_L).
This is the sufficient-hypothesis specialization of cite[Theorem~5.2]{CN}.
-Its inverse-cyclotomic determinant hypothesis permits $l=3$, including residual
-image $SL_2(F_3)$ cite[Remark~5.2.2]{CN}. No residual adequacy is assumed.
-Our three applications below have $l=3$ or $l=p>100$.
+Its inverse-cyclotomic determinant hypothesis permits l=3, including residual
+image SL_2(F_3) cite[Remark~5.2.2]{CN}. No residual adequacy is assumed.
+Our three applications below have l=3 or l=p>100.
[Elliptic starting point]
-Let $L$ be a CM number field not containing $zeta_5$ and let $A/L$ be a non-CM
-elliptic curve. If its mod-$5$ representation is decomposed generic and is
-absolutely irreducible on $G_{L(zeta_5)}$, then $H^1(A)$ is realized by a
-cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic representation of $PGL_2(A_L)$.
+Let L be a CM number field not containing zeta_5 and let A/L be a non-CM
+elliptic curve. If its mod-5 representation is decomposed generic and is
+absolutely irreducible on G_{L(zeta_5)}, then H^1(A) is realized by a
+cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic representation of PGL_2(A_L).
This is cite[Theorem~6.1 and Lemma~6.1.3]{CN}, dualizing the Tate-module
@@ -989,40 +988,40 @@ genericity in dimension two are preserved by duality.
For the comparison after modularity of an elliptic curve is known, we use:
[Compatibility for modular elliptic curves]
-Let $D/L$ be a non-CM elliptic curve over a CM field $L$. Suppose a regular
-algebraic cuspidal representation $pi$ realizes $H^1(D)$ at one coefficient
-prime. Then $pi$ has weight zero and trivial central character, realizes
-$H^1(D)$ at every coefficient prime and every coefficient isomorphism, and
+Let D/L be a non-CM elliptic curve over a CM field L. Suppose a regular
+algebraic cuspidal representation pi realizes H^1(D) at one coefficient
+prime. Then pi has weight zero and trivial central character, realizes
+H^1(D) at every coefficient prime and every coefficient isomorphism, and
[
iotaWD(H^1(D,overlineQ_l)|_{G_{L_v}})^{Fss}
- simeqrec^T_{L_v}(pi_v)qquad(vnmid l).
+ simeqrec^T_{L_v}(pi_v)(vnmid l).
]
-If $D$ has potentially multiplicative reduction at $vmid l$, then $pi$ is
-$iota$-ordinary of weight zero there.
+If D has potentially multiplicative reduction at vmid l, then pi is
+iota-ordinary of weight zero there.
This is cite[Lemma~6.1.3]{CN}. For the intermediate systems, which need not
come from elliptic curves, we use the general existence and good-place
-compatibility of $r_iota(pi)$ from [cite], together with Varma's
-equality of the underlying semisimplified Weil representations at $vnmid l$
+compatibility of r_iota(pi) from [cite], together with Varma's
+equality of the underlying semisimplified Weil representations at vnmid l
cite[Theorem~1]{Varma}. The local analysis of Section~sec:local supplies
the extra facts needed in Theorem~aut:lift.
-We can now state what remains for a single parameter $tin U(K)$. By
+We can now state what remains for a single parameter tin U(K). By
Proposition~sys:properties, the determinant and Hodge--Tate conditions
-hold for every $t$. At places above $3p$ we will make the Jacobian of
-$C_n(t)$ potentially good ordinary, potentially good with all Newton slopes
-$1/2$, or potentially totally toric, according to the reduction type of $E$.
+hold for every t. At places above 3p we will make the Jacobian of
+C_n(t) potentially good ordinary, potentially good with all Newton slopes
+1/2, or potentially totally toric, according to the reduction type of E.
This makes all four systems respectively potentially crystalline and
potentially ordinary, potentially crystalline but not potentially ordinary, or
not potentially crystalline. Section~sec:local obtains these from
-nonempty local open conditions on $t$. Section~sec:res then picks a
+nonempty local open conditions on t. Section~sec:res then picks a
parameter in those opens for which the residual hypotheses hold. The pairs
-$(m,l)=(3,5),(3,p),(p,3)$ give the elliptic starting point and the first two
-lifts; the last lift uses the large mod-$p$ image of $E$. The two conjugates of
-$K$ must be treated together to get decomposed genericity. Once these
+(m,l)=(3,5),(3,p),(p,3) give the elliptic starting point and the first two
+lifts; the last lift uses the large mod-p image of E. The two conjugates of
+K must be treated together to get decomposed genericity. Once these
properties hold, Section~sec:auto carries automorphy along the three
-congruences and descends to $K$.
+congruences and descends to K.
# Prescribing the local reduction type
@@ -1035,30 +1034,30 @@ two-dimensional systems.
## Finite torsion controls the reduction
-Throughout, a local field is a finite extension of $Q_ell$; here $ell$ is
-the residue characteristic of the base field, and $d$ is an auxiliary prime
-different from $ell$. For an abelian variety $A$ write
-$V_d(A)=T_d(A) ⊗ _{Z_d}Q_d$.
+Throughout, a local field is a finite extension of Q_ell; here ell is
+the residue characteristic of the base field, and d is an auxiliary prime
+different from ell. For an abelian variety A write
+V_d(A)=T_d(A) ⊗ _{Z_d}Q_d.
[Local constancy of finite torsion]
-Let $L$ be a local field, $X$ a smooth $L$-variety, $mathcal AcalAto X$ an
-abelian scheme. For $x_0in X(L)$ and $Nge1$ there is an analytic
-neighborhood $mathcal N$calN$ of $x_0$ in $X(L)$ such that
-$mathcal A_x[N](calA_x[N](overlineoverline L)L)simeqmathcal A_calA_{x_0}[N](overlineoverline L)$L)$ as
-$G_L$-modules for all $xinmathcal N$.calN$.
+Let L be a local field, X a smooth L-variety, mathcal AcalAto X an
+abelian scheme. For x_0in X(L) and Nge1 there is an analytic
+neighborhood mathcal NcalN of x_0 in X(L) such that
+mathcal A_x[N](calA_x[N](overlineoverline L)L)simeqmathcal A_calA_{x_0}[N](overlineoverline L)L) as
+G_L-modules for all xinmathcal N.calN.
Proof.
-Since $X$ has characteristic zero, $mathcal A[N]$calA[N]$ is finite 'etale over
-$X$; equivalently, full level-$N$ structures form a finite 'etale torsor
-under the constant group $GL_{2g}(Z/NZ)$, with $g$ the relative dimension.
-Take a finite Galois extension $L'/L$ splitting the fiber at $x_0$. The inverse
+Since X has characteristic zero, mathcal A[N]calA[N] is finite 'etale over
+X; equivalently, full level-N structures form a finite 'etale torsor
+under the constant group GL_{2g}(Z/NZ), with g the relative dimension.
+Take a finite Galois extension L'/L splitting the fiber at x_0. The inverse
function theorem for an 'etale morphism gives, through each point of the fiber,
-a local section over a neighborhood of $x_0$ in $X(L')$; shrinking, these
+a local section over a neighborhood of x_0 in X(L'); shrinking, these
sections enumerate every point of every nearby fiber. Intersecting finitely
many Galois conjugates and shrinking again keeps the neighborhood Galois-stable
and preserves the Galois permutations; the level-group action is preserved the
-same way. Restricting to $X(L)$ identifies the fibers as Galois sets with
+same way. Restricting to X(L) identifies the fibers as Galois sets with
level-group action, hence the torsion modules.
@@ -1067,83 +1066,83 @@ polynomial. For the second step we use the full Tate module, which
keeps both toric and lattice parts of the semistable representation.
[Finitely many semistable Frobenius polynomials]
-Fix a local field $L$ with residue field of cardinality $Q$, an integer
-$gge1$, and a prime $d$ different from the residue characteristic. For a
-semistable abelian variety $A/L$ of dimension $g$ let
-$P_A(T)=det(T-Frob_Lmid V_d(A))$ for any lift of arithmetic Frobenius.
-Then $P_A(T)inZ[T]$, is independent of the lift and of $d$, and ranges over
-a finite set depending only on $g,Q$. It determines the toric rank of $A$; if
+Fix a local field L with residue field of cardinality Q, an integer
+gge1, and a prime d different from the residue characteristic. For a
+semistable abelian variety A/L of dimension g let
+P_A(T)=det(T-Frob_Lmid V_d(A)) for any lift of arithmetic Frobenius.
+Then P_A(T)inZ[T], is independent of the lift and of d, and ranges over
+a finite set depending only on g,Q. It determines the toric rank of A; if
that rank is zero it also determines the Newton polygon of the good reduction.
Proof.
-Let $r$ be the toric rank. The semistable filtration identifies the graded
-pieces of $V_d(A)$ with the rational Tate module of a rank-$r$ torus, the
-rational Tate module of a $(g-r)$-dimensional abelian variety with good
-reduction, and a rank-$r$ lattice cite[Expos'e IX]{SGA7I}. The character
+Let r be the toric rank. The semistable filtration identifies the graded
+pieces of V_d(A) with the rational Tate module of a rank-r torus, the
+rational Tate module of a (g-r)-dimensional abelian variety with good
+reduction, and a rank-r lattice cite[Expos'e IX]{SGA7I}. The character
lattice of the torus and the lattice quotient act through finite unramified
-characters, so the arithmetic Frobenius eigenvalues on those pieces are $Q$
+characters, so the arithmetic Frobenius eigenvalues on those pieces are Q
times roots of unity and roots of unity respectively; the middle piece has the
-$2(g-r)$ eigenvalues of an abelian variety over $F_Q$, all of complex absolute
-value $Q^{1/2}$.
+2(g-r) eigenvalues of an abelian variety over F_Q, all of complex absolute
+value Q^{1/2}.
Each graded piece has an integral characteristic polynomial independent of
-$d$: for the toric and lattice pieces this follows from the finite-order
+d: for the toric and lattice pieces this follows from the finite-order
integral actions and the toric Tate twist, for the abelian piece it is the
usual finite-field Frobenius polynomial. Inertia acts trivially on the graded
pieces, so the product is independent of the Frobenius lift. Every root has
-absolute value at most $Q$, so the coefficient of $T^{2g-j}$ has absolute value
-at most $binom{2g}{j}Q^j$; integral polynomials of fixed degree with these
+absolute value at most Q, so the coefficient of T^{2g-j} has absolute value
+at most binom{2g}{j}Q^j; integral polynomials of fixed degree with these
bounds are finite in number.
-Exactly $r$ roots have absolute value $1$, exactly $r$ have absolute value
-$Q$, and the rest have $Q^{1/2}$; as $Q>1$ these three values distinguish $r$.
-If $r=0$, semistability is good reduction and the normalized valuations of the
-roots of $P_A$ are the Newton slopes.
+Exactly r roots have absolute value 1, exactly r have absolute value
+Q, and the rest have Q^{1/2}; as Q>1 these three values distinguish r.
+If r=0, semistability is good reduction and the normalized valuations of the
+roots of P_A are the Newton slopes.
[Local constancy of the semistable type]
-Let $L_0$ be a local field, $X$ a smooth $L_0$-variety, $mathcal AcalAto X$ an
-abelian scheme of relative dimension $g$. For $x_0in X(L_0)$ there exist a
-finite extension $L/L_0$ and an analytic neighborhood $mathcal NcalNsubset
-X(L_0)$ of $x_0$ such that for every $xinmathcal N$,calN$, $mathcal A_x$calA_x$ is
-semistable over $L$ with the same toric rank as $mathcal A_calA_{x_0}$ over $L$,
-and if $mathcal A_calA_{x_0}$ has good reduction over $L$ then $mathcal A_x$calA_x$ has
-the same Newton polygon over $L$.
-
-In particular, if $mathcal A_calA_{x_0}simeq E_0^g$, every nearby fiber has, after
+Let L_0 be a local field, X a smooth L_0-variety, mathcal AcalAto X an
+abelian scheme of relative dimension g. For x_0in X(L_0) there exist a
+finite extension L/L_0 and an analytic neighborhood mathcal NcalNsubset
+X(L_0) of x_0 such that for every xinmathcal N,calN, mathcal A_xcalA_x is
+semistable over L with the same toric rank as mathcal A_calA_{x_0} over L,
+and if mathcal A_calA_{x_0} has good reduction over L then mathcal A_xcalA_x has
+the same Newton polygon over L.
+
+In particular, if mathcal A_calA_{x_0}simeq E_0^g, every nearby fiber has, after
the same finite extension, the same one of: good ordinary reduction; good
-reduction with all Newton slopes $1/2$; semistable reduction of toric rank $g$.
+reduction with all Newton slopes 1/2; semistable reduction of toric rank g.
Proof.
-Choose an odd prime $d$ different from the residue characteristic and a finite
-$L/L_0$ over which $mathcal A_calA_{x_0}$ is semistable with rational $d$-torsion.
-Lemma~loc:torsion after base change to $L$ shows nearby fibers also have
-rational $d$-torsion over $L$.
-
-Nearby fibers are semistable over $L$. Indeed, an inertia element acts on their
-$d$-adic Tate module as $1+dB$ with $B$ integral, so each eigenvalue $lambda$
-satisfies $v_d(lambda-1)ge1$, $v_d(d)=1$. By the local monodromy theorem
-$lambda$ is a root of unity; for odd $d$ the only such root of unity with
-$v_d(lambda-1)ge1$ is $1$ (a root with nontrivial prime-to-$d$ part has
-$v_d(lambda-1)=0$, and a primitive $d^a$th root has
-$v_d(lambda-1)=1/(d^{a-1}(d-1))<1$). Thus inertia acts unipotently and
+Choose an odd prime d different from the residue characteristic and a finite
+L/L_0 over which mathcal A_calA_{x_0} is semistable with rational d-torsion.
+Lemma~loc:torsion after base change to L shows nearby fibers also have
+rational d-torsion over L.
+
+Nearby fibers are semistable over L. Indeed, an inertia element acts on their
+d-adic Tate module as 1+dB with B integral, so each eigenvalue lambda
+satisfies v_d(lambda-1)ge1, v_d(d)=1. By the local monodromy theorem
+lambda is a root of unity; for odd d the only such root of unity with
+v_d(lambda-1)ge1 is 1 (a root with nontrivial prime-to-d part has
+v_d(lambda-1)=0, and a primitive d^ath root has
+v_d(lambda-1)=1/(d^{a-1}(d-1))<1). Thus inertia acts unipotently and
Grothendieck's criterion gives semistability cite[Expos'e IX]{SGA7I}.
-Let $mathcal P$calP$ be the finite set of Lemma~loc:frob for dimension $g$
-and residue cardinality of $L$; choose $j$ with reduction mod $d^j$ injective
-on $mathcal P$.calP$. A second application of Lemma~loc:torsion gives, on a
-smaller neighborhood, $mathcal A_x[d^j](calA_x[d^j](overlineoverline L)L)simeq
-mathcal A_calA_{x_0}[d^j](overlineoverline L)$L)$ as $G_L$-modules, so the full Frobenius
-polynomials are congruent mod $d^j$ and hence equal. Lemma~loc:frob now
+Let mathcal PcalP be the finite set of Lemma~loc:frob for dimension g
+and residue cardinality of L; choose j with reduction mod d^j injective
+on mathcal P.calP. A second application of Lemma~loc:torsion gives, on a
+smaller neighborhood, mathcal A_x[d^j](calA_x[d^j](overlineoverline L)L)simeq
+mathcal A_calA_{x_0}[d^j](overlineoverline L)L) as G_L-modules, so the full Frobenius
+polynomials are congruent mod d^j and hence equal. Lemma~loc:frob now
gives the assertions on toric rank and Newton polygon; pull the neighborhood
-back to $X(L_0)$.
+back to X(L_0).
-For the final assertion, choose $L$ so $E_0$ has good or split multiplicative
-reduction. In the good case $E_0$ is ordinary or supersingular, the latter with
-slopes $1/2$; in the multiplicative case $E_0^g$ has toric rank $g$. Enlarging
-$L$ to rationalize $d$-torsion preserves these, so the argument applies.
+For the final assertion, choose L so E_0 has good or split multiplicative
+reduction. In the good case E_0 is ordinary or supersingular, the latter with
+slopes 1/2; in the multiplicative case E_0^g has toric rank g. Enlarging
+L to rationalize d-torsion preserves these, so the argument applies.
## Monodromy of a totally toric abelian variety
@@ -1155,155 +1154,155 @@ consequence of the valuation pairing in toric uniformization, and we treat the
residue characteristic as well, through Kummer extensions.
-Let $L/Q_ell$ be finite and $A/L$ an abelian variety of dimension $g$ that
-acquires semistable reduction of toric rank $g$ after a finite extension. For
-every prime $d$ the monodromy operator on the Weil--Deligne representation of
-$H^1_{et}(A_{overlineoverline L}L,Q_d)$ has rank $g$; for $d=ell$ the
+Let L/Q_ell be finite and A/L an abelian variety of dimension g that
+acquires semistable reduction of toric rank g after a finite extension. For
+every prime d the monodromy operator on the Weil--Deligne representation of
+H^1_{et}(A_{overlineoverline L}L,Q_d) has rank g; for d=ell the
Weil--Deligne representation is the one attached to the potentially semistable
-representation by $ell$-adic Hodge theory.
+representation by ell-adic Hodge theory.
Proof.
-Monodromy rank is unchanged by finite extension, so assume $A$ has split toric
-uniformization $A^{an}simeq(Gm^g)^{an}/Λ$ with
-$ΛsimeqZ^g$ rational over $L$. In bases the periods form a matrix
-$(q_{ij})in(L^times)^{gtimes g}$, and the valuation pairing is nondegenerate:
+Monodromy rank is unchanged by finite extension, so assume A has split toric
+uniformization A^{an}simeq(Gm^g)^{an}/Λ with
+ΛsimeqZ^g rational over L. In bases the periods form a matrix
+(q_{ij})in(L^times)^{gtimes g}, and the valuation pairing is nondegenerate:
(v_L(q_{ij}))_{1le i,jle g} is nonsingular.
This is the toric case of the monodromy pairing cite[Expos'e
IX]{SGA7I}; its de Rham realization is in [cite].
-For $dneell$ the same pairing describes the monodromy map from the lattice
-quotient to the toric subspace, and nondegeneracy gives rank $g$. We prove rank
-$g$ for $d=ell$. Toric uniformization gives an exact sequence
+For dneell the same pairing describes the monodromy map from the lattice
+quotient to the toric subspace, and nondegeneracy gives rank g. We prove rank
+g for d=ell. Toric uniformization gives an exact sequence
0→Q_ell(1)^g→ V_ell(A)
→Q_ell^g→0,
-whose extension classes are the Kummer classes of the $q_{ij}$; it is
-semistable by [cite]. Let $L_{ur}$ be the maximal
-unramified subfield and $D_{st}$ Fontaine's functor. Monodromy is zero
-on the two outer terms, so it induces $nu:D_{st}(Q_ell^g)to
-D_{st}(Q_ell(1)^g)$. Frobenius on the two spaces is $sigma$ and
-$ell^{-1}sigma$ with $sigma$ the Frobenius of $L_{ur}/Q_ell$, so
-$Nvarphi=ellvarphi N$ makes $kernusubset L_{ur}^g$
-$sigma$-stable.
-
-Suppose $nu$ has rank $<g$. Galois descent gives nonzero
-$a=(a_j)inQ_ell^gcapkernu$. Pull (loc:tate) back along the line
-spanned by $a$ in its trivial quotient: the result is a semistable extension of
-$Q_ell$ by $Q_ell(1)^g$ with zero monodromy, hence crystalline. By
-Kummer theory the Bloch--Kato crystalline subspace $H_f^1(L,Q_ell(1))$ is the
+whose extension classes are the Kummer classes of the q_{ij}; it is
+semistable by [cite]. Let L_{ur} be the maximal
+unramified subfield and D_{st} Fontaine's functor. Monodromy is zero
+on the two outer terms, so it induces nu:D_{st}(Q_ell^g)to
+D_{st}(Q_ell(1)^g). Frobenius on the two spaces is sigma and
+ell^{-1}sigma with sigma the Frobenius of L_{ur}/Q_ell, so
+Nvarphi=ellvarphi N makes kernusubset L_{ur}^g
+sigma-stable.
+
+Suppose nu has rank <g. Galois descent gives nonzero
+a=(a_j)inQ_ell^gcapkernu. Pull (loc:tate) back along the line
+spanned by a in its trivial quotient: the result is a semistable extension of
+Q_ell by Q_ell(1)^g with zero monodromy, hence crystalline. By
+Kummer theory the Bloch--Kato crystalline subspace H_f^1(L,Q_ell(1)) is the
kernel of the valuation map cite[Example~3.9]{BlochKato}, and applying this in
-each coordinate gives $sum_j a_j v_L(q_{ij})=0$ for $1le ile g$, contrary to
-(loc:val). Hence $N$ has rank $g$ on $V_ell(A)$, and dualizing gives rank
-$g$ on $H^1_{et}(A_{overlineoverline L}L,Q_ell)$.
+each coordinate gives sum_j a_j v_L(q_{ij})=0 for 1le ile g, contrary to
+(loc:val). Hence N has rank g on V_ell(A), and dualizing gives rank
+g on H^1_{et}(A_{overlineoverline L}L,Q_ell).
## Open conditions on the original parameter
-Return to $E/K$, the odd integer $n=3p$, and $F=K(mu_n)$. By
-Proposition~geom:compact the Jacobian of the constant-$E$ cover $C_n$
-extends over a neighborhood of $O$ in the parameter curve $E$, with fiber
-$E^n$ at $O$, so Proposition~loc:const applies at every finite completion
-of $F$. The next statement re-expresses the resulting neighborhoods in the
-original parameter $tin UsubsetA^1_K$, to combine with Hilbert
+Return to E/K, the odd integer n=3p, and F=K(mu_n). By
+Proposition~geom:compact the Jacobian of the constant-E cover C_n
+extends over a neighborhood of O in the parameter curve E, with fiber
+E^n at O, so Proposition~loc:const applies at every finite completion
+of F. The next statement re-expresses the resulting neighborhoods in the
+original parameter tin UsubsetA^1_K, to combine with Hilbert
irreducibility.
-For every place $v_0mid3p$ of $K$ there is a nonempty open
-$Ω_{v_0}subset U(K_{v_0})$ with the following property. Suppose
-$tin U(K)$ lies in $Ω_{v_0}$ for all $v_0mid3p$, and set
-$J_t=Jac(C_{n,t})$. At each place $vmid3p$ of $F$, $J_t$ has the same one of
-the following potential reduction types as $E^n$:
+For every place v_0mid3p of K there is a nonempty open
+Ω_{v_0}subset U(K_{v_0}) with the following property. Suppose
+tin U(K) lies in Ω_{v_0} for all v_0mid3p, and set
+J_t=Jac(C_{n,t}). At each place vmid3p of F, J_t has the same one of
+the following potential reduction types as E^n:
[label=(arabic*)]
-item good ordinary reduction;
-item good reduction with all Newton slopes $1/2$;
-item semistable reduction of toric rank $n$.
+ good ordinary reduction;
+ good reduction with all Newton slopes 1/2;
+ semistable reduction of toric rank n.
-For each $v$ the extensions giving these properties may be chosen in advance,
-independently of $t$ in the opens.
+For each v the extensions giving these properties may be chosen in advance,
+independently of t in the opens.
Proof.
-Fix $v_0mid3p$. For each $vmid v_0$ apply Proposition~loc:const to the
-extended Jacobian family over $F_v$ at the point $O$ of its parameter curve,
-obtaining a neighborhood of $O$ in $E(F_v)$ and a fixed finite extension of
-$F_v$ on which the reduction type holds. The inverse images of these finitely
-many neighborhoods in $E(K_{v_0})$ intersect in a neighborhood of $O$.
-
-Choose $R_0ne O$ in this intersection, close to $O$ and avoiding the finitely
-many excluded parameters and the ramification points of $x:EtoPbf^1$. The
+Fix v_0mid3p. For each vmid v_0 apply Proposition~loc:const to the
+extended Jacobian family over F_v at the point O of its parameter curve,
+obtaining a neighborhood of O in E(F_v) and a fixed finite extension of
+F_v on which the reduction type holds. The inverse images of these finitely
+many neighborhoods in E(K_{v_0}) intersect in a neighborhood of O.
+
+Choose R_0ne O in this intersection, close to O and avoiding the finitely
+many excluded parameters and the ramification points of x:EtoPbf^1. The
inverse function theorem gives a nonempty neighborhood
-$Ω_{v_0}subset U(K_{v_0})$ of $x(R_0)$ and an analytic lift
-$R(t)=(t,y(t))in E(K_{v_0})$, $y(t)^2=h(t)$, in the chosen intersection;
-shrink so $y(t)ne0$ and all excluded parameters are avoided.
-
-The map $B_tto E$, $(x,y)mapsto(x,y(t)y)$, is an isomorphism over
-$K_{v_0}$ carrying $(t,1)$ to $R(t)$; it sends the defining function of $C_n(t)$
-to that of the constant-$E$ cover (their divisors agree and both are $1$ at
-$O$), so it identifies the covers and Jacobians at every $vmid v_0$. The
+Ω_{v_0}subset U(K_{v_0}) of x(R_0) and an analytic lift
+R(t)=(t,y(t))in E(K_{v_0}), y(t)^2=h(t), in the chosen intersection;
+shrink so y(t)ne0 and all excluded parameters are avoided.
+
+The map B_tto E, (x,y)mapsto(x,y(t)y), is an isomorphism over
+K_{v_0} carrying (t,1) to R(t); it sends the defining function of C_n(t)
+to that of the constant-E cover (their divisors agree and both are 1 at
+O), so it identifies the covers and Jacobians at every vmid v_0. The
reduction conclusions follow from the choice of neighborhoods; do this
-independently at the finitely many $v_0mid3p$.
+independently at the finitely many v_0mid3p.
## Local representations of the character summands
-For a prime $ell$ and rotation character $theta$, let $V_{theta,ell}$ be
-the $ell$-adic realization of Proposition~sys:properties. Recall from
+For a prime ell and rotation character theta, let V_{theta,ell} be
+the ell-adic realization of Proposition~sys:properties. Recall from
Section~sec:conv that an ordinary filtration of weight zero has an
-unramified character on its line and $eps_ell^{-1}$ times an unramified
+unramified character on its line and eps_ell^{-1} times an unramified
character on its quotient, after a finite extension; in the ordinary case below
the line is preserved already before the extension.
-Choose $t$ satisfying Proposition~loc:opens. Let $vmid3p$ be a place of
-$F$ of residue characteristic $ell$. Then simultaneously for every rotation
-character $theta$:
+Choose t satisfying Proposition~loc:opens. Let vmid3p be a place of
+F of residue characteristic ell. Then simultaneously for every rotation
+character theta:
[label=(arabic*)]
-item if $E$ has potentially good ordinary reduction at $v$, then
-$V_{theta,ell}|_{G_{F_v}}$ is potentially crystalline and potentially
-ordinary of weight $0$;
-item if $E$ has potentially good supersingular reduction at $v$, then
-$V_{theta,ell}|_{G_{F_v}}$ is potentially crystalline and not potentially
-ordinary of weight $0$;
-item if $E$ has potentially multiplicative reduction at $v$, then the monodromy
-of $V_{theta,d}|_{G_{F_v}}$ has rank one for every coefficient prime $d$,
-including $d=ell$; in particular $V_{theta,ell}|_{G_{F_v}}$ is not
+ if E has potentially good ordinary reduction at v, then
+V_{theta,ell}|_{G_{F_v}} is potentially crystalline and potentially
+ordinary of weight 0;
+ if E has potentially good supersingular reduction at v, then
+V_{theta,ell}|_{G_{F_v}} is potentially crystalline and not potentially
+ordinary of weight 0;
+ if E has potentially multiplicative reduction at v, then the monodromy
+of V_{theta,d}|_{G_{F_v}} has rank one for every coefficient prime d,
+including d=ell; in particular V_{theta,ell}|_{G_{F_v}} is not
potentially crystalline.
Proof.
-Choose a finite $L/F_v$ on which $J_t$ has the reduction of
+Choose a finite L/F_v on which J_t has the reduction of
Proposition~loc:opens. In the two good-reduction cases, crystalline
-comparison makes $H^1_{et}(J_{t,overlineoverline L}L,Q_ell)$, and each character
-summand, crystalline over $L$.
+comparison makes H^1_{et}(J_{t,overlineoverline L}L,Q_ell), and each character
+summand, crystalline over L.
If the reduction is ordinary, the connected--'etale sequence of the ordinary
-$ell$-divisible group, dualized to $H^1$, gives a filtration with an
-unramified sub and a quotient that is $eps_ell^{-1}$ times unramified. This
+ell-divisible group, dualized to H^1, gives a filtration with an
+unramified sub and a quotient that is eps_ell^{-1} times unramified. This
filtration is functorial, hence stable under the rotations, and restricts to
-each $V_{theta,ell}$. By Proposition~sys:properties this summand has
-dimension two and labeled Hodge--Tate weights $0,1$; the unramified part is
-weight $0$ and the quotient weight $1$, so both parts are one-dimensional,
+each V_{theta,ell}. By Proposition~sys:properties this summand has
+dimension two and labeled Hodge--Tate weights 0,1; the unramified part is
+weight 0 and the quotient weight 1, so both parts are one-dimensional,
giving the required ordinary filtration. After a finite Galois extension, the
-weight-zero line is determined by its inertia action, since $eps_ell$ has
-infinite image on inertia; conjugation by $G_{F_v}$ preserves it, so it descends
+weight-zero line is determined by its inertia action, since eps_ell has
+infinite image on inertia; conjugation by G_{F_v} preserves it, so it descends
to the original decomposition group.
-If all slopes are $1/2$, every summand has that slope, and slopes are
-unchanged by finite extension. An ordinary filtration of weight $0$ would give
+If all slopes are 1/2, every summand has that slope, and slopes are
+unchanged by finite extension. An ordinary filtration of weight 0 would give
a crystalline rank-one subrepresentation of parallel Hodge--Tate weight zero,
whose slope is forced to be zero by weak admissibility, contradiction. So no
potential ordinary filtration exists.
-If $J_t$ has potential toric rank $n$, Lemma~loc:toric gives monodromy of
-rank $n$ on the $2n$-dimensional $H^1$ at every coefficient prime. Monodromy
-commutes with rotations, so preserves the $n$ two-dimensional summands; since
-$N^2=0$, each summand has rank at most one, the ranks sum to $n$, and there are
-$n$ summands, so every rank is one. Nonzero monodromy survives finite extension
+If J_t has potential toric rank n, Lemma~loc:toric gives monodromy of
+rank n on the 2n-dimensional H^1 at every coefficient prime. Monodromy
+commutes with rotations, so preserves the n two-dimensional summands; since
+N^2=0, each summand has rank at most one, the ranks sum to n, and there are
+n summands, so every rank is one. Nonzero monodromy survives finite extension
and excludes potential crystallinity.
@@ -1316,125 +1315,125 @@ Section~sec:local. To get decomposed genericity we must control every
place above a split rational prime, so we specialize the two conjugate
parameter families together.
-Throughout, $K,E,p,n,F,U$ are as in Section~sec:sys, so $p>100$, $n=3p$,
-$F=K(mu_n)$. The pairs of covering degree and residual characteristic needing
+Throughout, K,E,p,n,F,U are as in Section~sec:sys, so p>100, n=3p,
+F=K(mu_n). The pairs of covering degree and residual characteristic needing
geometric monodromy are
- (m,ell)=(3,p),quad(3,5),quad(p,3).
+ (m,ell)=(3,p),(3,5),(p,3).
-In each pair $ellnmid m$, so residual cohomology decomposes into
+In each pair ellnmid m, so residual cohomology decomposes into
rotation-character spaces after extending its finite coefficient field.
## Consequences of the two monodromy transformations
For each pair in (res:pairs) the geometric monodromy of
-$H^1(C_m,overlineF_ell)$ on every nontrivial rotation-character space is
+H^1(C_m,overlineF_ell) on every nontrivial rotation-character space is
absolutely irreducible, its image contains opposite nonidentity root
unipotents on that space, and one element of the geometric monodromy acts
regular semisimply on all these nontrivial character spaces simultaneously.
-These statements also hold for the conjugate family over $K$.
+These statements also hold for the conjugate family over K.
Proof.
Work first with homology; duality transfers the conclusions. On the character
-space with generator eigenvalue $lambdainoverlineF_ell^times$ the
+space with generator eigenvalue lambdainoverlineF_ell^times the
transformations of Theorem~mon:transvections are
[
- T_a=1&sigma c_lambda0&1,qquad
- T_b=1&0tau c_lambda&1,qquad
+ T_a=1&sigma c_lambda0&1,
+ T_b=1&0tau c_lambda&1,
c_lambda=2-lambda-lambda^{-1},
]
-with $sigma,tauin{1,-1}$. Since $c_lambda=-(lambda-1)^2/lambda$, it is
-nonzero when $lambdane1$. The two matrices have different unique invariant
+with sigma,tauin{1,-1}. Since c_lambda=-(lambda-1)^2/lambda, it is
+nonzero when lambdane1. The two matrices have different unique invariant
lines, even over the algebraic closure, so their common representation is
absolutely irreducible.
-The product $T_aT_b^k$ has determinant one and trace
+The product T_aT_b^k has determinant one and trace
2+sigmatau,k,c_lambda^2.
In odd characteristic a determinant-one matrix is regular semisimple exactly
-when its trace is neither $2$ nor $-2$. If $m=3$ then
-$lambda+lambda^{-1}=-1$, so $c_lambda=3$ for both nontrivial characters; take
-$k=2$, so the two possible traces in (res:trace) are $20$ and $-16$.
-Modulo $5$ these are $0$ and $4$, and modulo $p>100$ they are $20$ and $-16$;
-in neither case do they equal $pm2$.
-
-For $m=p$ and $ell=3$ take $k=1$; failure of regular semisimplicity would
-force $c_lambda^2=4$ or $-4$, since $c_lambdane0$ and the excluded traces are
-$pm2$. Over $F_3$ the elements $4$ and $-4$ are $pm1$, so
-$c_lambda^2=pm1$; equivalently $c_lambda=pm1$ or $pm i$. Multiplying
-$c_lambda=2-lambda-lambda^{-1}$ through by $lambda^2$ gives, in each case, a
-degree-four polynomial over $F_3$ satisfied by $lambda$. Hence
-$lambda$ has degree $dle4$ over $F_3$ and its order divides
-$3^d-1le80$, contradicting the fact that its order is the prime $p>100$.
+when its trace is neither 2 nor -2. If m=3 then
+lambda+lambda^{-1}=-1, so c_lambda=3 for both nontrivial characters; take
+k=2, so the two possible traces in (res:trace) are 20 and -16.
+Modulo 5 these are 0 and 4, and modulo p>100 they are 20 and -16;
+in neither case do they equal pm2.
+
+For m=p and ell=3 take k=1; failure of regular semisimplicity would
+force c_lambda^2=4 or -4, since c_lambdane0 and the excluded traces are
+pm2. Over F_3 the elements 4 and -4 are pm1, so
+c_lambda^2=pm1; equivalently c_lambda=pm1 or pm i. Multiplying
+c_lambda=2-lambda-lambda^{-1} through by lambda^2 gives, in each case, a
+degree-four polynomial over F_3 satisfied by lambda. Hence
+lambda has degree dle4 over F_3 and its order divides
+3^d-1le80, contradicting the fact that its order is the prime p>100.
Thus the same product works in this case too.
The transformations come from loops in the constant-elliptic-curve parameter
space, which by Theorem~mon:transvections is a pullback of the family over
-$U$; its monodromy image lies in the geometric monodromy over $U$. Duality
+U; its monodromy image lies in the geometric monodromy over U. Duality
preserves absolute irreducibility, nonidentity unipotents, and regular
semisimplicity, giving the cohomological claims. The geometric argument works
-for every complex elliptic curve, hence for the conjugate of $E$.
+for every complex elliptic curve, hence for the conjugate of E.
## The original elliptic curve and its conjugate
The trivial character needs a separate argument, because the geometric family
-varies only a quadratic twist of $E$; its large residual image was built into
-$p$. The count below needs no independence hypothesis between $E$ and its
+varies only a quadratic twist of E; its large residual image was built into
+p. The count below needs no independence hypothesis between E and its
conjugate.
-For every $tin U(K)$ the representation $overlineoverline V_V_{1,p}$ is absolutely
-irreducible on $G_{F(zeta_p)}$ and decomposed generic over $F$.
+For every tin U(K) the representation overlineoverline V_V_{1,p} is absolutely
+irreducible on G_{F(zeta_p)} and decomposed generic over F.
Proof.
-Let $Gamma$ be the image of $G_K$ on $E[p]$. Since $F/K$ is abelian, the image
-of $G_F$ contains $[Gamma,Gamma]$. As $Gamma$ contains $SL_2(F_p)$ and this
-group is perfect for $p>3$, its commutator subgroup is $SL_2(F_p)$ (one
+Let Gamma be the image of G_K on E[p]. Since F/K is abelian, the image
+of G_F contains [Gamma,Gamma]. As Gamma contains SL_2(F_p) and this
+group is perfect for p>3, its commutator subgroup is SL_2(F_p) (one
inclusion from perfectness, the other from the determinant). The determinant is
-trivial on $G_F$ because $mu_psubset F$, so
+trivial on G_F because mu_psubset F, so
rho_{E,p}(G_F)=SL_2(F_p).
-The same equality holds for the conjugate $E^c$, $c$ the nontrivial automorphism
-of $K/Q$, because $F/Q$ is normal.
+The same equality holds for the conjugate E^c, c the nontrivial automorphism
+of K/Q, because F/Q is normal.
-Consider the joint image $JsubsetSL_2(F_p)timesSL_2(F_p)$ of $G_F$ on
-$E[p]$ and $E^c[p]$; both projections are surjective. In $SL_2(F_p)$ there
-are exactly $p^2$ matrices of trace $2$: writing
-$(a&bc&d)$, trace and
-determinant give $d=2-a$ and $bc=-(a-1)^2$; $a=1$ yields $2p-1$ choices of
-$(b,c)$, and each of the other $p-1$ values of $a$ yields $p-1$ choices, for a
-total $p^2$. Negating gives the same count for trace $-2$.
+Consider the joint image JsubsetSL_2(F_p)timesSL_2(F_p) of G_F on
+E[p] and E^c[p]; both projections are surjective. In SL_2(F_p) there
+are exactly p^2 matrices of trace 2: writing
+(a&bc&d), trace and
+determinant give d=2-a and bc=-(a-1)^2; a=1 yields 2p-1 choices of
+(b,c), and each of the other p-1 values of a yields p-1 choices, for a
+total p^2. Negating gives the same count for trace -2.
-The order of $SL_2(F_p)$ is $p(p^2-1)$, and each projection of $J$ has
-equal-sized fibers, so the proportion of $J$ whose image in at least one factor
-has trace $pm2$ is at most
+The order of SL_2(F_p) is p(p^2-1), and each projection of J has
+equal-sized fibers, so the proportion of J whose image in at least one factor
+has trace pm2 is at most
[
2cdot(2p^2)/(p(p^2-1))=(4p)/(p^2-1)<1.
]
-Hence some element of $G_F$ acts regular semisimply on both $E[p]$ and
-$E^c[p]$.
+Hence some element of G_F acts regular semisimply on both E[p] and
+E^c[p].
-Take a finite Galois extension of $Q$ containing $F$ and the fields of these
-two residual actions. Conjugation by $G_Q$ either preserves or exchanges the
+Take a finite Galois extension of Q containing F and the fields of these
+two residual actions. Conjugation by G_Q either preserves or exchanges the
two curves and conjugates their residual matrices, so the chosen element and all
-its conjugates act regular semisimply on the representation of $E$. Chebotarev
-gives rational primes $q$ splitting completely in $F$ with this property at
-every $vmid q$ of $F$. Excluding $p$ and the finitely many bad primes and using
-$mu_psubset F$, these satisfy $qequiv1pmod p$; distinct Frobenius
+its conjugates act regular semisimply on the representation of E. Chebotarev
+gives rational primes q splitting completely in F with this property at
+every vmid q of F. Excluding p and the finitely many bad primes and using
+mu_psubset F, these satisfy qequiv1pmod p; distinct Frobenius
eigenvalues give the ratio condition of decomposed genericity.
-The curve $B_t$ is a quadratic twist of $E$; twisting multiplies residual
+The curve B_t is a quadratic twist of E; twisting multiplies residual
matrices by scalar signs, preserving absolute irreducibility and eigenvalue
ratios. Excluding the finitely many primes ramified in this twist leaves the
-same Chebotarev argument. Since $zeta_pin F$ and the dual of $E[p]$ gives the
-residual $H^1$-realization, Proposition~sys:elliptic proves both claims for
-$overlineoverline V_V_{1,p}$.
+same Chebotarev argument. Since zeta_pin F and the dual of E[p] gives the
+residual H^1-realization, Proposition~sys:elliptic proves both claims for
+overlineoverline V_V_{1,p}.
## Simultaneous specialization
@@ -1445,118 +1444,118 @@ Frobenius properties above a rational prime; restriction of scalars puts the two
conjugate families in one finite cover.
-Let $W$ be a nonempty open subset of $A^d_Q$, $D/Q$ finite Galois, and $H$ a
-finite quotient of $pi_1(W)$ through which the constant-field map factors as
-$pi_1(W)surj HsurjGal(D/Q)$. Prescribe nonempty open subsets of $W(Q_r)$
-for finitely many rational primes $r$. Then there is $xin W(Q)$ in all these
-opens for which the specialization $s_x:G_Qto H$ is surjective; for this $x$,
+Let W be a nonempty open subset of A^d_Q, D/Q finite Galois, and H a
+finite quotient of pi_1(W) through which the constant-field map factors as
+pi_1(W)surj HsurjGal(D/Q). Prescribe nonempty open subsets of W(Q_r)
+for finitely many rational primes r. Then there is xin W(Q) in all these
+opens for which the specialization s_x:G_Qto H is surjective; for this x,
s_x(G_D)=ker(HtoGal(D/Q)).
Proof.
-The quotient $H$ defines a connected finite 'etale Galois cover of $W$.
+The quotient H defines a connected finite 'etale Galois cover of W.
Hilbert irreducibility with weak approximation gives a rational point in the
prescribed opens whose fiber is connected cite[Proposition~3.3.1 and
Theorem~3.5.3]{SerreHilbert}. Connectedness of the Galois fiber is equivalent to
-surjectivity of $s_x$ (geometric connectedness is not required). The composite
-of $s_x$ with $HtoGal(D/Q)$ is the restriction map on absolute Galois
-groups, so an element of the displayed kernel has a preimage in $G_D$.
+surjectivity of s_x (geometric connectedness is not required). The composite
+of s_x with HtoGal(D/Q) is the restriction map on absolute Galois
+groups, so an element of the displayed kernel has a preimage in G_D.
-Let $S_K$ be a finite set of finite places of $K$ containing all places above
-$3p$ and, for each $v_0in S_K$, prescribe a nonempty open
-$Ω_{v_0}subset U(K_{v_0})$. There is a single $tin U(K)$ in every
-$Ω_{v_0}$ such that, over $F=K(mu_{3p})$:
+Let S_K be a finite set of finite places of K containing all places above
+3p and, for each v_0in S_K, prescribe a nonempty open
+Ω_{v_0}subset U(K_{v_0}). There is a single tin U(K) in every
+Ω_{v_0} such that, over F=K(mu_{3p}):
[label=(arabic*)]
-item for each $(m,ell)$ in (res:pairs) and each character $theta$ of
-order $m$, the representation $overlineoverline V_V_{theta,ell}$ is absolutely
-irreducible on $G_{F(zeta_ell)}$ and decomposed generic;
-item the representation $overlineoverline V_V_{1,p}$ has the same two properties;
-item the elliptic curve $A_t=Jac(C_3(t)/< w>)$ is non-CM.
+ for each (m,ell) in (res:pairs) and each character theta of
+order m, the representation overlineoverline V_V_{theta,ell} is absolutely
+irreducible on G_{F(zeta_ell)} and decomposed generic;
+ the representation overlineoverline V_V_{1,p} has the same two properties;
+ the elliptic curve A_t=Jac(C_3(t)/< w>) is non-CM.
-In particular, with the opens above $3p$ taken from Proposition~loc:opens,
-this $t$ also satisfies all conclusions of Corollary~loc:chars.
+In particular, with the opens above 3p taken from Proposition~loc:opens,
+this t also satisfies all conclusions of Corollary~loc:chars.
Proof.
-Put $W=Res_{K/Q}U$, an open subset of $A^2_Q$ since $UsubsetA^1_K$. Choose
-finite Galois $D/Q$ containing $F$ and $zeta_ell$ for every residual
-characteristic in (res:pairs). Let $c$ be the nontrivial automorphism of
-$K/Q$ and write $U^c$, $cC_m^c$ for the conjugate parameter open and family.
-Then $W_Dsimeq U_Dtimes(U^c)_D$. For all three pairs pull back the finite
-local system $H^1(C_m,F_ell)$ from the first factor and $H^1(C_m^c,F_ell)$
+Put W=Res_{K/Q}U, an open subset of A^2_Q since UsubsetA^1_K. Choose
+finite Galois D/Q containing F and zeta_ell for every residual
+characteristic in (res:pairs). Let c be the nontrivial automorphism of
+K/Q and write U^c, cC_m^c for the conjugate parameter open and family.
+Then W_Dsimeq U_Dtimes(U^c)_D. For all three pairs pull back the finite
+local system H^1(C_m,F_ell) from the first factor and H^1(C_m^c,F_ell)
from the second.
-Their joint monodromy has finite image on $pi_1(W_D)$. Take, in $pi_1(W)$, the
-normal core of the common kernel; it is open normal, contained in $pi_1(W_D)$,
-and the resulting finite quotient $H$ records every listed action and has
-quotient $Gal(D/Q)$.
+Their joint monodromy has finite image on pi_1(W_D). Take, in pi_1(W), the
+normal core of the common kernel; it is open normal, contained in pi_1(W_D),
+and the resulting finite quotient H records every listed action and has
+quotient Gal(D/Q).
-Over $C$ a loop in one parameter factor acts trivially on local systems pulled
+Over C a loop in one parameter factor acts trivially on local systems pulled
back from the other, so the geometric monodromy of Lemma~res:geom is
-available independently in both factors. For each pair $(m,ell)$ choose an
-element $h_{m,ell}$ of the geometric monodromy image that is regular semisimple
+available independently in both factors. For each pair (m,ell) choose an
+element h_{m,ell} of the geometric monodromy image that is regular semisimple
on every nontrivial character space of both factors (product of the two factor
-loops from the lemma); it maps trivially to $Gal(D/Q)$. The quotient also
+loops from the lemma); it maps trivially to Gal(D/Q). The quotient also
contains the individual opposite unipotents on every character space.
The local conditions are compatible with restriction of scalars: for a prime
-$r$, $W(Q_r)=prod_{v_0mid r}U(K_{v_0})$, so the $Ω_{v_0}$ give
-nonempty open subsets of $W(Q_r)$ for finitely many $r$ (at unprescribed
+r, W(Q_r)=prod_{v_0mid r}U(K_{v_0}), so the Ω_{v_0} give
+nonempty open subsets of W(Q_r) for finitely many r (at unprescribed
factors impose no condition). Apply Lemma~res:finite: it gives
-$xin W(Q)$, i.e. $tin U(K)$, satisfying all local conditions and inducing a
-surjection $G_Qsurj H$. Over $D$ this point has coordinates $(t,t^c)$; smooth
+xin W(Q), i.e. tin U(K), satisfying all local conditions and inducing a
+surjection G_Qsurj H. Over D this point has coordinates (t,t^c); smooth
proper base change identifies the specialized local systems with the residual
-cohomology of $C_m(t)$ and $C_m^c(t^c)$.
+cohomology of C_m(t) and C_m^c(t^c).
By (res:kernel) every geometric monodromy element used above is the image
-of an element of $G_D$. The opposite unipotents therefore survive on each
-specialized character space over $G_D$, proving its absolute irreducibility; as
-$G_Dsubset G_{F(zeta_ell)}$, this also holds on the latter group. Because
-$ellnmid m$, taking rotation eigenspaces commutes with reduction after
+of an element of G_D. The opposite unipotents therefore survive on each
+specialized character space over G_D, proving its absolute irreducibility; as
+G_Dsubset G_{F(zeta_ell)}, this also holds on the latter group. Because
+ellnmid m, taking rotation eigenspaces commutes with reduction after
adjoining the character values, so these spaces are reductions of
-$V_{theta,ell}$; the rational identifications and independence of
+V_{theta,ell}; the rational identifications and independence of
semisimplified reduction of Section~sec:sys show they give exactly
-$overlineoverline V_V_{theta,ell}$, even when the system is defined using $C_n$.
+overlineoverline V_V_{theta,ell}, even when the system is defined using C_n.
-For decomposed genericity fix $(m,ell)$ and a preimage $gin G_D$ of
-$h_{m,ell}$. An element $sigmain G_Q$ preserves or exchanges $C_m(t)$ and
-$C_m^c(t^c)$ according to its restriction to $K$, and permutes rotation characters
-through its action on roots of unity; so $sigma gsigma^{-1}$ on a character
-space of the first cover is conjugate to $g$ on some character space of one of
+For decomposed genericity fix (m,ell) and a preimage gin G_D of
+h_{m,ell}. An element sigmain G_Q preserves or exchanges C_m(t) and
+C_m^c(t^c) according to its restriction to K, and permutes rotation characters
+through its action on roots of unity; so sigma gsigma^{-1} on a character
+space of the first cover is conjugate to g on some character space of one of
the two covers. Regular semisimplicity was imposed on all these spaces, so it
holds for every conjugate.
-The kernel of the surjection $G_Qsurj H$ defines a finite Galois extension of
-$Q$ containing $D$. Chebotarev applied to the conjugacy class of $h_{m,ell}$
-gives rational primes $q$ whose Frobenius class is that class; they split
-completely in $D$ because $h_{m,ell}$ is trivial on $D$. Discard $q=ell$ and
+The kernel of the surjection G_Qsurj H defines a finite Galois extension of
+Q containing D. Chebotarev applied to the conjugacy class of h_{m,ell}
+gives rational primes q whose Frobenius class is that class; they split
+completely in D because h_{m,ell} is trivial on D. Discard q=ell and
the finitely many primes where curves or residual representations ramify. For
-every $vmid q$ of $F$ the Frobenius is represented by a conjugate of the
+every vmid q of F the Frobenius is represented by a conjugate of the
selected element and acts regular semisimply on each character space; the
-residue degree is one since $q$ splits in $F$, and $qequiv1pmodell$ since
-$zeta_ellin D$. Hence the ratio of the two Frobenius eigenvalues differs from
-$q$ in characteristic $ell$, at every $vmid q$: this is decomposed genericity.
-A different $q$ may be used for each pair. Assertion (2) follows from
+residue degree is one since q splits in F, and qequiv1pmodell since
+zeta_ellin D. Hence the ratio of the two Frobenius eigenvalues differs from
+q in characteristic ell, at every vmid q: this is decomposed genericity.
+A different q may be used for each pair. Assertion (2) follows from
Lemma~res:triv.
-To exclude CM for $A_t$: for $(m,ell)=(3,p)$ the specialization places two
-opposite nonidentity unipotents in the residual image of $V_{eta,p}$, which by
-Proposition~sys:elliptic is the residual cohomology of $A_t$ (both are
+To exclude CM for A_t: for (m,ell)=(3,p) the specialization places two
+opposite nonidentity unipotents in the residual image of V_{eta,p}, which by
+Proposition~sys:elliptic is the residual cohomology of A_t (both are
irreducible, so their common semisimplification is the representation itself).
-If $A_t$ had CM, all its endomorphisms would be defined over an extension of $F$
+If A_t had CM, all its endomorphisms would be defined over an extension of F
of degree at most two; over that extension the characteristic-zero Galois image
lies in the commutative centralizer of the CM algebra, so its reduction is
abelian, and the full residual image would have an abelian normal subgroup of
-index at most two. Each opposite unipotent has odd prime order $p$, so both
+index at most two. Each opposite unipotent has odd prime order p, so both
would lie in that abelian subgroup; but
[
1&a0&11&0b&1
ne1&0b&11&a0&1
- qquad(abne0),
+ (abne0),
]
a contradiction. This proves (3). Finally, choosing the prescribed opens as in
Proposition~loc:opens, the Hilbert specialization was made inside them, so
@@ -1565,9 +1564,9 @@ the local conclusions of Corollary~loc:chars also hold.
# Propagation of automorphy, descent, and the CM case
-Fix $tin U(K)$ from Proposition~res:special, taking the local opens of
-Proposition~loc:opens, and write $B=B_t$. The four systems
-$V_eta,V_chi,V_psi,V_1$ have the congruences of
+Fix tin U(K) from Proposition~res:special, taking the local opens of
+Proposition~loc:opens, and write B=B_t. The four systems
+V_eta,V_chi,V_psi,V_1 have the congruences of
Corollary~sys:congruences, the local properties of
Corollary~loc:chars, and the residual properties of
Section~sec:res. We first explain how automorphy at one coefficient prime
@@ -1576,19 +1575,19 @@ gives what is needed at the next.
## Coefficient primes and local automorphic conditions
-Suppose a weight-zero regular algebraic cuspidal representation $pi$ of
-$GL_2(A_F)$ realizes one member of the compatible system $V_theta$. Then it
+Suppose a weight-zero regular algebraic cuspidal representation pi of
+GL_2(A_F) realizes one member of the compatible system V_theta. Then it
realizes every member, with the coefficient embeddings fixed in
Section~sec:sys.
Proof.
Outside a finite set and away from the coefficient prime, the characteristic
-polynomial of Frobenius on $V_theta$ is independent of that prime, as an
+polynomial of Frobenius on V_theta is independent of that prime, as an
algebraic polynomial with the fixed embeddings of character values; the
-good-place characteristic polynomials of $r_iota(pi)$ have the same
+good-place characteristic polynomials of r_iota(pi) have the same
compatibility. Equality at the original prime identifies the polynomials at
-every other prime. Both representations are semisimple: for $V_theta$ this is
+every other prime. Both representations are semisimple: for V_theta this is
Faltings' theorem as in Proposition~sys:properties, and automorphic Galois
representations are semisimple. Chebotarev and Brauer--Nesbitt give the
isomorphism.
@@ -1599,28 +1598,28 @@ recover it by applying Varma's comparison at a different coefficient prime,
where it applies directly.
-Suppose a weight-zero regular algebraic cuspidal representation $pi$ of
-$PGL_2(A_F)$ realizes $V_theta$. Let $lin{3,p}$ and $vmid l$, with
-$J_t=Jac(C_n(t))$.
+Suppose a weight-zero regular algebraic cuspidal representation pi of
+PGL_2(A_F) realizes V_theta. Let lin{3,p} and vmid l, with
+J_t=Jac(C_n(t)).
[label=(roman*)]
-item If $J_t$ has potentially good reduction at $v$, then
-$rec_{F_v}(pi_v)$ has zero monodromy.
-item If $J_t$ has semistable reduction of toric rank $n$ at $v$, then $pi_v$
-is a quadratic or trivial twist of Steinberg and $pi$ is $iota_l$-ordinary of
-weight zero at $v$.
+ If J_t has potentially good reduction at v, then
+rec_{F_v}(pi_v) has zero monodromy.
+ If J_t has semistable reduction of toric rank n at v, then pi_v
+is a quadratic or trivial twist of Steinberg and pi is iota_l-ordinary of
+weight zero at v.
Proof.
-Choose a coefficient prime $a$ different from the residue characteristic $l$.
-Lemma~auto:transport identifies $r_{iota_a}(pi)$ with $V_{theta,a}$.
+Choose a coefficient prime a different from the residue characteristic l.
+Lemma~auto:transport identifies r_{iota_a}(pi) with V_{theta,a}.
Varma's local-global compatibility identifies the underlying semisimplified
Weil representations of its local Weil--Deligne parameter and
-$rec^T_{F_v}(pi_v)$ cite[Theorem~1]{Varma}; we use this for the Weil
+rec^T_{F_v}(pi_v) cite[Theorem~1]{Varma}; we use this for the Weil
representations first, not assuming equality of monodromy operators.
In the potentially good case, pass to an extension where the Jacobian has good
-reduction. All Frobenius eigenvalues on its $H^1$, hence on the character
+reduction. All Frobenius eigenvalues on its H^1, hence on the character
summand, have complex absolute value the square root of the residue
cardinality; taking a positive power of Frobenius shows this also before the
extension. A rank-two Weil--Deligne representation with nonzero monodromy has
@@ -1629,17 +1628,17 @@ value, so the automorphic parameter has zero monodromy. The Tate twist in
(eq:tate) does not change this.
In the totally toric case, Corollary~loc:chars gives nonzero monodromy on
-$V_{theta,a}$, so its semisimplified Weil representation is a sum of two
-characters differing by the norm. Under local Langlands for $GL_2$ the only
+V_{theta,a}, so its semisimplified Weil representation is a sum of two
+characters differing by the norm. Under local Langlands for GL_2 the only
possibilities are the special parameter with nonzero monodromy and the
zero-monodromy parameter of a one-dimensional local representation; the latter is
not generic, and every local component of a cuspidal representation is generic.
-So $pi_v$ is a twist of Steinberg, and trivial central character makes the
+So pi_v is a twist of Steinberg, and trivial central character makes the
twisting character have square one.
The local computation in the proof of cite[Lemma~6.1.3(4)]{CN}, invoking
cite[Lemma~5.6]{Geraghty}, shows a quadratic twist of Steinberg is
-$iota_l$-ordinary of weight zero. It uses only the stated local representation
+iota_l-ordinary of weight zero. It uses only the stated local representation
and trivial central character, so it applies also when the quadratic character is
ramified: the ordinary condition is imposed at a deep level, and a finite-order
twist multiplies normalized Hecke eigenvalues by units.
@@ -1648,28 +1647,28 @@ twist multiplies normalized Hecke eigenvalues by units.
## The three lifts
-The elliptic curve $B/F$ is modular: $H^1(B)$ is realized by a cuspidal
-weight-zero regular algebraic representation of $PGL_2(A_F)$.
+The elliptic curve B/F is modular: H^1(B) is realized by a cuspidal
+weight-zero regular algebraic representation of PGL_2(A_F).
Proof.
-The order-three system $V_eta$ is $H^1(A)$ for the elliptic curve $A/F$ of
+The order-three system V_eta is H^1(A) for the elliptic curve A/F of
Proposition~sys:elliptic. It is non-CM by Proposition~res:special,
-its mod-$5$ representation is decomposed generic and absolutely irreducible
-over $F(zeta_5)$ by the $(m,l)=(3,5)$ part of that proposition, and
-$zeta_5notin F$ by (sys:nozeta). So Theorem~aut:seed supplies a
-cuspidal weight-zero representation of $PGL_2(A_F)$ realizing $V_eta$.
+its mod-5 representation is decomposed generic and absolutely irreducible
+over F(zeta_5) by the (m,l)=(3,5) part of that proposition, and
+zeta_5notin F by (sys:nozeta). So Theorem~aut:seed supplies a
+cuspidal weight-zero representation of PGL_2(A_F) realizing V_eta.
Apply Theorem~aut:lift in the order
{@{}cccc@{}}
-toprule
+
Input & Coefficient prime & Lifted & Residual input
-midrule
-$V_eta$ & $p$ & $V_chi$ & $(m,l)=(3,p)$
-$V_chi$ & $3$ & $V_psi$ & $(m,l)=(p,3)$
-$V_psi$ & $p$ & $V_1$ & $H^1(B)bmod p$
-bottomrule
+
+V_eta & p & V_chi & (m,l)=(3,p)
+V_chi & 3 & V_psi & (m,l)=(p,3)
+V_psi & p & V_1 & H^1(B)bmod p
+
In each row Corollary~sys:congruences identifies the residual
@@ -1693,7 +1692,7 @@ Theorem~aut:lift holds at every place above the coefficient prime.
The theorem thus applies in all three rows. Its conclusion preserves cuspidality,
weight zero, and trivial central character, so each row feeds the next, and the
-last gives automorphy of $V_1=H^1(B)$.
+last gives automorphy of V_1=H^1(B).
## Descending to the original field
@@ -1702,48 +1701,48 @@ The character adjustment in the next argument identifies the descended
representation with the prescribed one.
-Let $L'/L$ be a cyclic extension of prime degree between CM fields and
-$r:G_LtoGL_2(overlineQ_l)$ continuous with absolutely irreducible restriction
-to $G_{L'}$. If this restriction is realized by a cuspidal weight-zero regular
-algebraic representation $Pi$ of $GL_2(A_{L'})$, then $r$ is realized by a
-cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic representation of $GL_2(A_L)$.
+Let L'/L be a cyclic extension of prime degree between CM fields and
+r:G_LtoGL_2(overlineQ_l) continuous with absolutely irreducible restriction
+to G_{L'}. If this restriction is realized by a cuspidal weight-zero regular
+algebraic representation Pi of GL_2(A_{L'}), then r is realized by a
+cuspidal weight-zero regular algebraic representation of GL_2(A_L).
Proof.
-For $sigmainGal(L'/L)$ the representations $Pi^sigma$ and $Pi$ have the
+For sigmainGal(L'/L) the representations Pi^sigma and Pi have the
same good-place Hecke polynomials, since the Galois representation extends to
-$G_L$; by strong multiplicity one $Pi$ is Galois invariant, and the cyclic
-base-change theorem gives a cuspidal $pi$ of $GL_2(A_L)$ with base change
-$Pi$ [cite]. Every archimedean place is complex, so
-local extensions are trivial and $pi$ is regular algebraic of weight zero.
+G_L; by strong multiplicity one Pi is Galois invariant, and the cyclic
+base-change theorem gives a cuspidal pi of GL_2(A_L) with base change
+Pi [cite]. Every archimedean place is complex, so
+local extensions are trivial and pi is regular algebraic of weight zero.
Good-place compatibility and Chebotarev give
-$(r_iota(pi)|_{G_{L'}})^{ss}simeq r|_{G_{L'}}$. The right side is
+(r_iota(pi)|_{G_{L'}})^{ss}simeq r|_{G_{L'}}. The right side is
absolutely irreducible, so the left restriction is already irreducible and
isomorphic to it. After choosing this isomorphism the two representations agree
-on $G_{L'}$; at $gin G_L$ their matrices differ by a scalar (same conjugation on
-the absolutely irreducible $G_{L'}$-representation), and Schur's lemma makes
-these scalars a character $delta:Gal(L'/L)tooverlineQ_l^times$ with
-$r_iota(pi)simeq r ⊗ delta$. The finite-order Hecke character
-$delta^{-1}$ removes the discrepancy, preserving cuspidality and weight zero,
+on G_{L'}; at gin G_L their matrices differ by a scalar (same conjugation on
+the absolutely irreducible G_{L'}-representation), and Schur's lemma makes
+these scalars a character delta:Gal(L'/L)tooverlineQ_l^times with
+r_iota(pi)simeq r ⊗ delta. The finite-order Hecke character
+delta^{-1} removes the discrepancy, preserving cuspidality and weight zero,
with Galois-twisting compatibility at good places and hence everywhere by
Chebotarev.
-Since $F/K$ is abelian, choose a tower from $K$ to $F$ with cyclic prime-degree
-steps; each intermediate field is abelian over $Q$ and contains the imaginary
-quadratic $K$, hence is CM. The representation $H^1(B,overlineQ_p)$ stays
-absolutely irreducible over $F$ because its residual representation is
+Since F/K is abelian, choose a tower from K to F with cyclic prime-degree
+steps; each intermediate field is abelian over Q and contains the imaginary
+quadratic K, hence is CM. The representation H^1(B,overlineQ_p) stays
+absolutely irreducible over F because its residual representation is
absolutely irreducible there. Apply Lemma~auto:descent down the tower to
-Proposition~auto:overF: this gives automorphy of $B/K$. Finally $B$ is the
-quadratic twist of $E$ by $h(t)$, so twisting the automorphic representation by
-the same quadratic Hecke character gives a cuspidal weight-zero $pi_E$
-realizing $H^1(E)$.
+Proposition~auto:overF: this gives automorphy of B/K. Finally B is the
+quadratic twist of E by h(t), so twisting the automorphic representation by
+the same quadratic Hecke character gives a cuspidal weight-zero pi_E
+realizing H^1(E).
## Local parameters and the CM case
-For non-CM $E$, Theorem~aut:compat shows $pi_E$ has trivial central
-character, realizes $H^1(E)$ at every coefficient prime, and has the required
+For non-CM E, Theorem~aut:compat shows pi_E has trivial central
+character, realizes H^1(E) at every coefficient prime, and has the required
Frobenius-semisimplified Weil--Deligne parameter at each finite place (choosing
a coefficient prime different from the residue characteristic). At infinity a
cuspidal representation is generic, so the archimedean classification with
@@ -1751,21 +1750,21 @@ weight-zero infinitesimal character gives exactly (eq:inf); the
finite-dimensional alternative is not generic. Equations (eq:tate) and
(eq:Lshift) give the stated normalization.
-Suppose now $E$ has complex multiplication by an imaginary quadratic $M$. Its
-endomorphisms are defined over $KM$ (their faithful action on invariant
-differentials has eigenvalues in $M$ fixed by $G_{KM}$). The main theorem of
+Suppose now E has complex multiplication by an imaginary quadratic M. Its
+endomorphisms are defined over KM (their faithful action on invariant
+differentials has eigenvalues in M fixed by G_{KM}). The main theorem of
complex multiplication expresses the two one-dimensional constituents of
-$H^1(E)|_{G_{KM}}$ as realizations of algebraic Hecke characters with infinity
+H^1(E)|_{G_{KM}} as realizations of algebraic Hecke characters with infinity
types given by the CM type [cite].
-If $Mnotsubset K$, Galois exchanges the two characters and $H^1(E)$ is induced
-from either over $KM/K$; automorphic induction gives the required representation
-of $GL_2(A_K)$. If $M=K$, use the isobaric sum of the two characters. In either
-case normalize by $|det|^{1/2}$ so the Tate-normalized parameter realizes
-$H^1(E)$; complex multiplication and local class field theory, together with
+If Mnotsubset K, Galois exchanges the two characters and H^1(E) is induced
+from either over KM/K; automorphic induction gives the required representation
+of GL_2(A_K). If M=K, use the isobaric sum of the two characters. In either
+case normalize by |det|^{1/2} so the Tate-normalized parameter realizes
+H^1(E); complex multiplication and local class field theory, together with
local compatibility of quadratic automorphic induction in the first case, give
the finite parameters and infinity types. Their central character is trivial:
-the determinant of $H^1(E)$ is $eps_l^{-1}$, so undoing the Tate normalization
+the determinant of H^1(E) is eps_l^{-1}, so undoing the Tate normalization
gives determinant one, hence trivial central character.
In both the CM and non-CM cases the finite factors also agree for the
@@ -1781,25 +1780,25 @@ same special Weil--Deligne parameter at every coefficient prime. This completes
the proof of Theorem~thm:main.
{99}
-bibitem{ArthurClozel} J.~Arthur and L.~Clozel, Simple Algebras, Base Change, and the Advanced Theory of the Trace Formula, Ann. of Math. Stud. 120, Princeton Univ. Press, 1989.
-bibitem{Bianchi} L.~Bianchi, Sui gruppi di sostituzioni lineari con coefficienti appartenenti a corpi quadratici immaginar^{i}, Math. Ann. 40 (1892), 332--412.
-bibitem{BCDT} C.~Breuil, B.~Conrad, F.~Diamond, R.~Taylor, On the modularity of elliptic curves over $Q$: wild 3-adic exercises, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 14 (2001), 843--939.
-bibitem{BLR} S.~Bosch, W.~L"utkebohmert, M.~Raynaud, N'eron Models, Ergeb. Math. Grenzgeb. 21, Springer, 1990.
-bibitem{CN} A.~Caraiani and J.~Newton, On the modularity of elliptic curves over imaginary quadratic fields, preprint arXiv:2301.10509v3 (2025).
-bibitem{ColemanIovita} R.~Coleman and A.~Iovita, The Frobenius and monodromy operators for curves and abelian varieties, Duke Math. J. 97 (1999), 171--215.
-bibitem{Faltings} G.~Faltings, Endlichkeitss"atze f"ur abelsche Variet"aten "uber Zahlk"orpern, Invent. Math. 73 (1983), 349--366.
-bibitem{Geraghty} D.~Geraghty, Modularity lifting theorems for ordinary Galois representations, Math. Ann. 373 (2019), 1341--1427.
-bibitem{HLTT} M.~Harris, K.-W.~Lan, R.~Taylor, J.~Thorne, On the rigid cohomology of certain Shimura varieties, Res. Math. Sci. 3 (2016), Paper No. 37.
-bibitem{LanglandsBC} R.~Langlands, Base Change for $GL(2)$, Ann. of Math. Stud. 96, Princeton Univ. Press, 1980.
-bibitem{Scholze} P.~Scholze, On torsion in the cohomology of locally symmetric varieties, Ann. of Math. 182 (2015), 945--1066.
-bibitem{SerreHilbert} J.-P.~Serre, Topics in Galois Theory, 2nd ed., Res. Notes Math. 1, A K Peters, 2008.
-bibitem{SerreOpenImage} J.-P.~Serre, Propri'et'es galoisiennes des points d'ordre fini des courbes elliptiques, Invent. Math. 15 (1972), 259--331.
-bibitem{SGA7I} A.~Grothendieck, M.~Raynaud, D.~S.~Rim, Groupes de monodromie en g'eom'etrie alg'ebrique I (SGA 7 I), Lecture Notes in Math. 288, Springer, 1972.
-bibitem{SGA7II} P.~Deligne, N.~Katz (eds.), Groupes de monodromie en g'eom'etrie alg'ebrique II (SGA 7 II), Lecture Notes in Math. 340, Springer, 1973.
-bibitem{ShimuraCM} G.~Shimura and Y.~Taniyama, Complex Multiplication of Abelian Varieties and Its Applications to Number Theory, Publ. Math. Soc. Japan 6, Math. Soc. Japan, 1961.
-bibitem{Tsuji} T.~Tsuji, $p$-adic 'etale cohomology and crystalline cohomology in the semi-stable reduction case, Invent. Math. 137 (1999), 233--411.
-bibitem{Varma} I.~Varma, Local-global compatibility for regular algebraic cuspidal automorphic representations when $ellne p$, Forum Math. Sigma 12 (2024), Paper No. e21.
-bibitem{BlochKato} S.~Bloch and K.~Kato, $L$-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives, in The Grothendieck Festschrift I, Progr. Math. 86, Birkh"auser, 1990, 333--400.
+ J.~Arthur and L.~Clozel, Simple Algebras, Base Change, and the Advanced Theory of the Trace Formula, Ann. of Math. Stud. 120, Princeton Univ. Press, 1989.
+ L.~Bianchi, Sui gruppi di sostituzioni lineari con coefficienti appartenenti a corpi quadratici immaginar^{i}, Math. Ann. 40 (1892), 332--412.
+ C.~Breuil, B.~Conrad, F.~Diamond, R.~Taylor, On the modularity of elliptic curves over Q: wild 3-adic exercises, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 14 (2001), 843--939.
+ S.~Bosch, W.~L"utkebohmert, M.~Raynaud, N'eron Models, Ergeb. Math. Grenzgeb. 21, Springer, 1990.
+ A.~Caraiani and J.~Newton, On the modularity of elliptic curves over imaginary quadratic fields, preprint arXiv:2301.10509v3 (2025).
+ R.~Coleman and A.~Iovita, The Frobenius and monodromy operators for curves and abelian varieties, Duke Math. J. 97 (1999), 171--215.
+ G.~Faltings, Endlichkeitss"atze f"ur abelsche Variet"aten "uber Zahlk"orpern, Invent. Math. 73 (1983), 349--366.
+ D.~Geraghty, Modularity lifting theorems for ordinary Galois representations, Math. Ann. 373 (2019), 1341--1427.
+ M.~Harris, K.-W.~Lan, R.~Taylor, J.~Thorne, On the rigid cohomology of certain Shimura varieties, Res. Math. Sci. 3 (2016), Paper No. 37.
+ R.~Langlands, Base Change for GL(2), Ann. of Math. Stud. 96, Princeton Univ. Press, 1980.
+ P.~Scholze, On torsion in the cohomology of locally symmetric varieties, Ann. of Math. 182 (2015), 945--1066.
+ J.-P.~Serre, Topics in Galois Theory, 2nd ed., Res. Notes Math. 1, A K Peters, 2008.
+ J.-P.~Serre, Propri'et'es galoisiennes des points d'ordre fini des courbes elliptiques, Invent. Math. 15 (1972), 259--331.
+ A.~Grothendieck, M.~Raynaud, D.~S.~Rim, Groupes de monodromie en g'eom'etrie alg'ebrique I (SGA 7 I), Lecture Notes in Math. 288, Springer, 1972.
+ P.~Deligne, N.~Katz (eds.), Groupes de monodromie en g'eom'etrie alg'ebrique II (SGA 7 II), Lecture Notes in Math. 340, Springer, 1973.
+ G.~Shimura and Y.~Taniyama, Complex Multiplication of Abelian Varieties and Its Applications to Number Theory, Publ. Math. Soc. Japan 6, Math. Soc. Japan, 1961.
+ T.~Tsuji, p-adic 'etale cohomology and crystalline cohomology in the semi-stable reduction case, Invent. Math. 137 (1999), 233--411.
+ I.~Varma, Local-global compatibility for regular algebraic cuspidal automorphic representations when ellne p, Forum Math. Sigma 12 (2024), Paper No. e21.
+ S.~Bloch and K.~Kato, L-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives, in The Grothendieck Festschrift I, Progr. Math. 86, Birkh"auser, 1990, 333--400.