diff f6bf760..6fbd3ac sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
diff --git a/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt b/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
index 187d5cc..78f2a87 100644
--- a/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
+++ b/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
% =====================================================================
% Equality cases in the sharp one-dimensional matrix Lieb--Thirring
-% inequality: a complete, self-contained proof.
+% ineuality: a complete, self-contained proof.
%
% This file is written to be read straight through. Each technical
% object is introduced with a plain sentence saying what it is for,
@@ -11,11 +11,11 @@
% Road map:
% Section 1 the problem, the answer, and the idea of the proof
% Section 2 notation and the four constants
-% Section 3 two elementary lemmas (spectrum, Young inequality)
+% Section 3 two elementary lemmas (spectrum, Young ineuality)
% Section 4 the trace engine: an exact integrated deficit identity
% Section 5 the field and the connecting path (existence)
% Section 6 the finite-interval action estimate
-% Section 7 the sharp inequality itself
+% Section 7 the sharp ineuality itself
% Section 8 from equality to pointwise matrix relations
% Section 9 fixed channels, the profile, complex W, attainability
% =====================================================================
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@
allowdisplaybreaks[2]
# Equality cases in the sharp one-dimensional[2pt]
-matrix Lieb--Thirring inequality[6pt]large a complete proof
+matrix Lieb--Thirring ineuality[6pt]large a complete proof
@@ -54,7 +54,7 @@ maketitle
Abstract:
We classify all equality cases in the sharp one-dimensional Lieb--Thirring
-inequality, for every finite matrix size and every exponent
+ineuality, for every finite matrix size and every exponent
1/2<gamma<3/2. For a measurable Hermitian positive semidefinite
potential W with int_Rtr(W^{gamma+1/2})<∞, equality holds
exactly when, in one constant unitary basis, W is a direct sum of scalar
@@ -88,12 +88,12 @@ for 1/2<gamma<3/2 set
Here tr is the unnormalised trace on C^{mtimes m}, and W^p is
defined by spectral calculus.
-## The inequality and its constant
-The sharp Lieb--Thirring inequality in one dimension is
+## The ineuality and its constant
+The sharp Lieb--Thirring ineuality in one dimension is
Tr(H_W)_-^gamma
le C_gammaint_Rtr(W(x)^p),dx,
- p=gamma+tfrac12,
+ p=gamma+1/2,
with the explicit constant
@@ -101,9 +101,9 @@ with the explicit constant
=((gamma-1/2)/(gamma+1/2))^{gamma-1/2}
(Gamma(gamma+1))/(sqrtpi,Gamma(gamma+3/2)) .
-The inequality itself is due to Lieb and Thirring and, in this matrix
+The ineuality itself is due to Lieb and Thirring and, in this matrix
form, to the companion paper [cite]. The new content here is the
-equality statement, proved together with the inequality so that
+equality statement, proved together with the ineuality so that
both rest on the same estimates.
## The answer
@@ -120,7 +120,7 @@ which has exactly one negative eigenvalue, namely -a^2, and saturates
(eq:sharp) by itself.
[Equality classification]
-Let mge1, 1/2<gamma<3/2, p=gamma+tfrac12, and let W be a
+Let mge1, 1/2<gamma<3/2, p=gamma+1/2, and let W be a
measurable Hermitian positive semidefinite potential with
int_Rtr(W^p)<∞. Then (eq:sharp) holds. Moreover,
equality holds if and only if there are an integer kin{0,...,m},
@@ -145,7 +145,7 @@ negative eigenfunctions by smooth compactly supported trial functions and
arrange them as the rows of a matrix U(x). A lower triangular matrix
C keeps the rows in successive spans; this is what makes the energies
ell_i^2 appear in order. This is the standard trial-function step of
-the inequality.
+the ineuality.
[(2)] Build an action. For a diagonal matrix K of trial
root-energies, define the energy
E_K(A)=|A'|_{HS}^2+tr(K^2AA^T)-tr((AA^T)^q)). It is
@@ -154,7 +154,7 @@ the trial-function energy written in matrix language.
from K at the left end of the interval to -K at the right end turns
the action into a square plus a boundary term (complete the square):
[
- E_K(A)=(boundary)+calE_K(A)=(boundary)+int(|A'-BA|_{HS}^2-F(A,B)).
+ E_K(A)=(boundary)+E_K(A)=(boundary)+int(|A'-BA|_{HS}^2-F(A,B)).
]
The boundary term produces exactly b_sigmasumell_i^{2gamma}.
[(4)] Keep the defect. Equality forces the square
@@ -176,20 +176,20 @@ listed potential attains equality.
## Brief history
-Lieb and Thirring introduced spectral moment inequalities for the kinetic
+Lieb and Thirring introduced spectral moment ineualities for the kinetic
energy of fermions [cite]. The sharp
scalar endpoint gamma=1/2 is due to Hundertmark--Lieb--Thomas
[cite], extended to operator-valued potentials by
Hundertmark--Laptev--Weidl [cite]. The semiclassical constant is
sharp for gammage3/2; the relevant tools are the moment lifting of
-Aizenman--Lieb [cite] and the operator-valued inequalities
+Aizenman--Lieb [cite] and the operator-valued ineualities
of Laptev--Weidl [cite]. Benguria--Loss [cite]
gave a commutation proof at gamma=3/2. The one-state scalar profile
(eq:profile) goes back to Keller [cite]; its role in the
Lieb--Thirring problem is explained in cite[Section~4]{LiebThirring1976}.
At the endpoint gamma=3/2 the equality structure changes: Frank, Gontier
and Lewin [cite] show that several bound states can
-share a single scalar channel (KdV multisolitons). The strict inequality
+share a single scalar channel (KdV multisolitons). The strict ineuality
r>1 used below is exactly what rules that out in the open interval.
% =====================================================================
@@ -198,8 +198,8 @@ r>1 used below is exactly what rules that out in the open interval.
Throughout,
- sigma=gamma-tfrac12in(0,1),
- p=1+sigma=gamma+tfrac12,
+ sigma=gamma-1/2in(0,1),
+ p=1+sigma=gamma+1/2,
r=frac1sigma>1,
q=r+1 .
@@ -266,7 +266,7 @@ embedding H^1([-R,R])↪ L^2([-R,R]), each T_{R,L} is
compact, and
[
|(T-T_{R,L})psi|_2^2
- le C,bigl|w,mathbf 1_bf1_{{|x|>R}cup{w>L}}bigr|_p
+ le C,bigl|w,1_bf1_{{|x|>R}cup{w>L}}bigr|_p
|psi|_{H^1}^2 .
]
The prefactor tends to zero as R,Lto∞, so T is a norm limit of
@@ -286,18 +286,18 @@ term is locally integrable because Win L^p_{loc} and psi is
locally bounded.
-## Young's inequality for matrices
-This is the scalar inequality yz-z^qle D_sigma y^p promoted to
+## Young's ineuality for matrices
+This is the scalar ineuality yz-z^qle D_sigma y^p promoted to
matrices, together with its equality condition.
-[Trace Young inequality]
+[Trace Young ineuality]
For positive semidefinite matrices W,Z of the same finite size, put
Y(W,Z)=D_sigmatr(W^p)-tr(WZ)+tr(Z^q).
Then Y(W,Z)ge0, with equality if and only if W=qZ^r. Moreover
- Y(W,Z)getfrac12tr(Z^q)
+ Y(W,Z)ge1/2tr(Z^q)
-(2^{p-1}-1)D_sigmatr(W^p).
@@ -305,10 +305,10 @@ Then Y(W,Z)ge0, with equality if and only if W=qZ^r. Moreover
Proof.
Maximise z|-> yz-z^q over zge0 for fixed yge0. The maximum
D_sigma y^p is attained exactly at y=qz^r; this is the scalar Young
-inequality behind D_sigma in (eq:Dconst). Choose an orthonormal
+ineuality behind D_sigma in (eq:Dconst). Choose an orthonormal
eigenbasis (v_j) of Z with eigenvalues z_j, and set
y_j=< v_j,Wv_j>. By (eq:youngdefect) and the scalar
-inequality,
+ineuality,
[
tr(WZ)-tr(Z^q)
=sum_j (y_j z_j - z_j^q)
@@ -323,7 +323,7 @@ eigenvalues as well.
For (eq:youngcoercive), apply the already proven Yge0 to the pair
(2W,Z) and expand:
-tr(2WZ)letfrac12tr(Z^q)+2^{p-1}D_sigmatr(W^p), which rearranges
+tr(2WZ)le1/2tr(Z^q)+2^{p-1}D_sigmatr(W^p), which rearranges
to (eq:youngcoercive).
@@ -332,13 +332,13 @@ to (eq:youngcoercive).
% =====================================================================
The action estimate compares a matrix N against its power N^q. The
-classical inequality is tr(NV)getr(N^q) under a symbol condition, but
+classical ineuality is tr(NV)getr(N^q) under a symbol condition, but
equality analysis needs the exact size of the gap. The engine below gives
that gap as an integral of two manifestly nonnegative squares. The point
-is that it is an identity, not just an inequality, so a vanishing total
+is that it is an identity, not just an ineuality, so a vanishing total
gap forces each square to vanish.
-Throughout this section 0<sigma<1, beta=sigma-tfrac12, and
+Throughout this section 0<sigma<1, beta=sigma-1/2, and
p=1+sigma, r=1/sigma, q=1+r as in (eq:params).
## The normalisation constant
@@ -358,7 +358,7 @@ variable gives the scaling identity we will use constantly:
Indeed, substitute t=yu; the left side becomes
c_sigma y^{beta+1/2}int_0^∞ u^beta(u^{-1/2}-(u+1)^{-1/2}),du
-=y^sigma by (eq:trace:normalization) and beta+tfrac12=sigma.
+=y^sigma by (eq:trace:normalization) and beta+1/2=sigma.
## Statement of the engine
@@ -455,17 +455,17 @@ result is continuous with derivative jump -(S+T)v, so
e^{-isx} gives
[
v=frac1{2pi}int_R(X_s+tI)^{-1},ds,(S+T)v
- =tfrac12R(t)(S+T)v .
+ =1/2R(t)(S+T)v .
]
The inverse symbol is O(s^{-2}), so its Fourier inverse is continuous
and evaluation at zero is legitimate. Therefore
- L:=tfrac12(S+T)=R^{-1}>0,
- Z:=tfrac12(S-T)
+ L:=1/2(S+T)=R^{-1}>0,
+ Z:=1/2(S-T)
satisfy (eq:trace:LZ): adding and subtracting the two halves of
(eq:trace:riccati) gives the first equation, and the second holds
-because LZ+ZL=tfrac12(S^2-T^2) and i[B,L]=tfrac i2[B,S+T]. The
+because LZ+ZL=1/2(S^2-T^2) and i[B,L]=tfrac i2[B,S+T]. The
equation LZ+ZL+i[B,L]=0 determines Z uniquely from L>0 (in an
eigenbasis of L the map Z|-> LZ+ZL multiplies the (j,k) entry
by L_{jj}+L_{kk}>0), which also proves continuity of Z(t).
@@ -529,7 +529,7 @@ t^{beta+1}F(t) vanishes at both ends. Differentiating
[
F'(t)=-frac{tr V}{2t^{3/2}}+tr P(t),
- tF'(t)=-tfrac12F(t)-G(t).
+ tF'(t)=-1/2F(t)-G(t).
]
Integration by parts with the vanishing endpoint limits gives
int_0^∞ t^beta G,dt=sigmaint_0^∞ t^beta F,dt; since
@@ -570,7 +570,7 @@ c_sigmaint t^beta P= N gives
+c_sigmaint_0^∞ t^betaD_D,dt .
When Nge0 choose D=N^r. Since rp=q, the first two terms equal
-(1-tfrac1p)tr(N^q)=tr(N^q)/q. Substituting into
+(1-1/p)tr(N^q)=tr(N^q)/q. Substituting into
(eq:trace:weighted) proves (eq:trace:deficit). Both integrands
in (eq:trace:deficit) are nonnegative, so equality forces them to
vanish for almost every t, hence by continuity for every t>0.
@@ -588,7 +588,7 @@ objects: a symmetric matrix field M_delta that mimics the power
(K^2-B^2)^sigma near values that matter, and a symmetric path B(x)
running from K to -K that solves an ODE of the form
ε B'=M_delta(B)-AA^T. This section constructs both. Set
-delta>0 and recall beta=sigma-tfrac12, and let c_sigma be the
+delta>0 and recall beta=sigma-1/2, and let c_sigma be the
constant of (eq:trace:normalization).
## A scalar building block
@@ -604,7 +604,7 @@ and extend to y<0 by the tangent line f_delta'(0)y. For yge0,
a_sigma=(c_sigma)/(pi)int_0^∞
(u^beta)/((1+u)^2),du>0 .
-Both integrals converge because -tfrac12<beta<tfrac12. Thus f_delta
+Both integrals converge because -1/2<beta<1/2. Thus f_delta
is C^1, strictly increasing, and concave on yge0; the tangent
extension makes it C^1 on all of R and lets the functional calculus
below accept arguments with negative eigenvalues.
@@ -670,7 +670,7 @@ containing the spectra of Hermitian X,Y, then
Indeed, take eigenbases e_i of X and v_j of Y; the mixed entries
of h(X)-h(Y) and of X-Y are (h(lambda_i)-h(nu_j))< e_i,v_j>
and (lambda_i-nu_j)< e_i,v_j>; square the scalar Lipschitz
-inequality and sum.
+ineuality and sum.
Convergence of the field. On a bounded set of B's the spectrum
of E_s(B)=-2sB+K^2 lies in [-a|s|,a|s|] for all large |s|. For
@@ -826,11 +826,11 @@ A cutoff and a homotopy. Use the continuous representative of U.
Choose a smooth nonnegative compactly supported cutoff chi on Sym_n
equal to 1 on {B:|B|_{op}lekappa} and invariant under conjugation
by diagonal sign matrices (averaging over the finite sign group produces
-one). The truncated field widehatwidehat M=M=chi M_delta is bounded and
+one). The truncated field Mhat=M=chi M_delta is bounded and
globally Lipschitz. Fix ε>0. For C lower triangular and
thetain[0,1], the equation
- ε B'=thetawidehatwidehat M(B)-(CU)(CU)^M(B)-(CU)(CU)^{T},
+ ε B'=thetaMhat(B)-(CU)(CU)^M(B)-(CU)(CU)^{T},
B(x_-)=K,
has a unique C^1 solution on overlineoverlineΩ;Ω; define the continuous
@@ -846,13 +846,13 @@ ODE give
Three facts about the zero set.
(i) Compactness. At a zero, integrating (eq:path:homotopy)
-gives CC^{T}ε K+thetaint_Ωwidehatwidehat M(B(x))M(B(x)),dx,
+gives CC^{T}ε K+thetaint_ΩMhat(B(x))M(B(x)),dx,
so the zeros lie in a bounded set and their joint set in
R^{ntimes n}_{low}times[0,1] is compact. For
0<εle1 this also gives the uniform bound
|C|_{HS}^2le2tr K
- +n|Ω|sup_{BinSym_n}|widehatwidehat M(B)M(B)|_{op}.
+ +n|Ω|sup_{BinSym_n}|Mhat(B)M(B)|_{op}.
(ii) Freeness. No row of C can vanish at a zero. Otherwise the
reflection changing only row i would fix C; by (eq:path:equivariance)
@@ -878,7 +878,7 @@ for |Phi|_{HS} on (∂ Otimes[0,1])cup(overlineoverline OOtimes{1}).
Reparametrise theta to agree with the initial map on an initial collar
and retain this gap; extend F constantly past both ends, smooth by
convolution, splice to the initial map on a smaller collar, and average in
-the form Psi(C,theta)=frac1{|G|}calG|sum_S SPsi_0(SC,theta)S to
+the form Psi(C,theta)=frac1{|G|}G|sum_S SPsi_0(SC,theta)S to
get a smooth equivariant approximation Psi still equal to the initial map
on the collar and close enough to preserve the gap.
@@ -1020,7 +1020,7 @@ A dimension-free bound from [1,2]. On 1le tle2 one has
a_kappa Ile R(t)le A_kappa I:
for the upper bound use Q_sge0 on a bounded interval and
-Q_sgetfrac12s^2I for |s|gemax{1,4kappa}; for the lower bound
+Q_sge1/2s^2I for |s|gemax{1,4kappa}; for the lower bound
restrict to |s|le1 where Q_s+(delta+t)Ile(4+2kappa+kappa^2)I.
These constants depend on kappa alone. Also
|N|_{op}lekappa^{2sigma}+1, so H_t=(tI+N^r)^{1/2} and L(t) are
@@ -1119,7 +1119,7 @@ For any tau>0 choose ε so the supremum in
(eq:act:penalty) is at most E_{n,delta}+tau. Substituting into
(eq:act:identity),
- E_K(A_ε)calE_K(A_ε)
+ E_K(A_ε)E_K(A_ε)
ge{}&J_delta(-K)-J_delta(K)-|Ω|(E_{n,delta}+tau)
&+int_Ω(|A_ε'-B_ε A_ε|_{HS}^2
+c_*Phi_K(A_ε,B_ε)),dx .
@@ -1134,11 +1134,11 @@ delta; no bound uniform in delta is needed.
% =====================================================================
-# The sharp inequality itself
+# The sharp ineuality itself
% =====================================================================
Before turning to equality we record that the action estimate already
-gives the sharp bound (eq:sharp); this is the inequality half of
+gives the sharp bound (eq:sharp); this is the ineuality half of
Theorem~thm:main.
[Sharp spectral bound]
@@ -1188,7 +1188,7 @@ is real symmetric and positive semidefinite; the constant unitary matrix
conjugates widetilde W to W ⊕ overlineoverline W.W. Hence
tr(widetilde W^p)=2tr(W^p) and
Tr(H_{widetilde W})_-^gamma=2Tr(H_W)_-^gamma (conjugation identifies
-the spectra of H_W and H_{overlineoverline W}W). Applying the real inequality
+the spectra of H_W and H_{overlineoverline W}W). Applying the real ineuality
to widetilde W and dividing by two proves (eq:bound:sharp).
@@ -1245,7 +1245,7 @@ is required.
## Finite spectral approximations and vanishing errors
-Let n_j=j when I= NbbN and n_j=|I|calI| when
+Let n_j=j when I= NbbN and n_j=|I|I| when
I is finite. Choose 0<xi_j<1/j with
ell_{j,i}:=(k_i^2-xi_j)^{1/2}>0 (1le ile n_j),
@@ -1306,7 +1306,7 @@ integral errors and T_j tend to zero.
A uniform bound on A_j will also be needed. The coercive estimate
(eq:youngcoercive) gives
- Y(W,Z_j)getfrac12tr(Z_j^q)-(2^{p-1}-1)D_sigmatr(W^p),
+ Y(W,Z_j)ge1/2tr(Z_j^q)-(2^{p-1}-1)D_sigmatr(W^p),
and since Z_j is mtimes m, scalar H"older gives
|A_j|_{HS}^{2q}=(tr Z_j)^qle m^{q-1}tr(Z_j^q). With
@@ -1318,11 +1318,11 @@ For fixed iinI, the coefficients (C_j)_{il}, lle i, are
bounded as jto∞. Choose a bounded interval J_i so large that
[
(int_{J_i}phi_l(x)phi_s(x)^T,dx)_{l,s=1}^{i}
- getfrac34 I_i,
+ ge3/4 I_i,
]
possible because the full Gram matrix is the identity. By
(eq:comp:form) the corresponding Gram matrix of the u_{j,l} is at
-least tfrac12 I_i for large j, so
+least 1/2 I_i for large j, so
[
frac12sum_{lle i}(C_j)_{il}^{,2}
leint_{J_i}|(A_j)_{i,·}|^2,dx
@@ -1486,7 +1486,7 @@ Proof.
Fix vinR^m. From (eq:rig:blocksquare),
|(G_alpha v)'|lekappa|G_alpha v| almost everywhere, and G_alpha v
is locally absolutely continuous. If it vanishes at x_0, integration and
-Gronwall's inequality, first right and then left of x_0, show it vanishes
+Gronwall's ineuality, first right and then left of x_0, show it vanishes
everywhere; hence ker G_alpha(x) is constant, including off the original
full-measure set.
@@ -1553,7 +1553,7 @@ B_0=D'D^{-1} with q=r+1,
Fix a nonzero block and the matrix B_0. Orthogonally diagonalise the
symmetric B_0(x_*) at one point. The right side of the Riccati equation is
a polynomial in B_0, so uniqueness of the matrix ODE preserves the
-diagonal form. The strict inequality in (eq:rig:active) places each
+diagonal form. The strict ineuality in (eq:rig:active) places each
initial diagonal entry b_j(x_*) in (-alpha,alpha), and the scalar
equation b_j'=r(b_j^2-alpha^2) has the unique solution with that value
@@ -1590,14 +1590,14 @@ widetilde W, so the real result gives a constant unitary V with
quadalmost everywhere,
]
each f_j a profile (eq:rig:profiles) or zero. Let P be the
-projection onto the first summand and widehatwidehat P=V^*PV.P=V^*PV. Since P
+projection onto the first summand and Phat=V^*PV.P=V^*PV. Since P
commutes with W ⊕ overlineoverline W,W, we have
-(f_i-f_j)widehatwidehat P_P_{ij}=0 almost everywhere, so widehatwidehat P_P_{ij}=0
+(f_i-f_j)Phat_P_{ij}=0 almost everywhere, so Phat_P_{ij}=0
whenever f_i,f_j are not equal almost everywhere. Partition the indices
into groups of identical functions (including the zero function). On each
group the diagonal potential is a scalar multiple of the identity, so any
constant orthonormal basis of the intersection of that coordinate group with
-ranwidehatwidehat PP diagonalises it. Transporting these bases by
+ranPPhat diagonalises it. Transporting these bases by
V gives a constant unitary basis of C^m in which W has the asserted
profiles. This proves necessity for complex Hermitian W.
@@ -1615,7 +1615,7 @@ H^1(R). Since w,w' are bounded, direct differentiation gives
QQ^*&=-∂_x^2+a^2+(r-1)a^2sech^2!(ra(x-x_0))ge a^2,
-the last inequality because r>1. The equation Qpsi=0 has the
+the last ineuality because r>1. The equation Qpsi=0 has the
one-dimensional L^2 solution space
[
ker Q=spanbigl{sech^{1/r}(ra(x-x_0))bigr},
@@ -1656,7 +1656,7 @@ Mathematical Research Letters 7 (2000), no.~2--3, 195--203.
Rupert L. Frank, David Gontier and Mathieu Lewin,
-Optimizers for the finite-rank Lieb--Thirring inequality,
+Optimizers for the finite-rank Lieb--Thirring ineuality,
American Journal of Mathematics 147 (2025), no.~2, 503--560.
@@ -1673,13 +1673,13 @@ no.~4, 719--731.
Joseph B. Keller,
-Lower bounds and isoperimetric inequalities for eigenvalues of the
+Lower bounds and isoperimetric ineualities for eigenvalues of the
Schr"odinger equation,
Journal of Mathematical Physics 2 (1961), no.~2, 262--266.
Ari Laptev and Timo Weidl,
-Sharp Lieb--Thirring inequalities in high dimensions,
+Sharp Lieb--Thirring ineualities in high dimensions,
Acta Mathematica 184 (2000), no.~1, 87--111.
@@ -1690,13 +1690,13 @@ Physical Review Letters 35 (1975), no.~11, 687--689.
Elliott H. Lieb and Walter E. Thirring,
-Inequalities for the moments of the eigenvalues of the Schr"odinger
-Hamiltonian and their relation to Sobolev inequalities,
+Ineualities for the moments of the eigenvalues of the Schr"odinger
+Hamiltonian and their relation to Sobolev ineualities,
in Studies in Mathematical Physics: Essays in Honor of Valentine
Bargmann, Princeton University Press, 1976, 269--303.
-Sharp one-dimensional Lieb--Thirring inequalities for matrix
+Sharp one-dimensional Lieb--Thirring ineualities for matrix
potentials, companion preprint, 2026.