diff 792edc3..7b9fc63 fujita_freeness_v2.txt
diff --git a/fujita_freeness_v2.txt b/fujita_freeness_v2.txt
index e69de29..02da8f4 100644
--- a/fujita_freeness_v2.txt
+++ b/fujita_freeness_v2.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,642 @@
+FUJITA'S FREENESS CONJECTURE
+A complete proof, written to be read from top to bottom
+
+CONTENTS
+ 0. What the theorem says, and why n+1 is exact
+ 1. A dictionary of the words used
+ 2. The plan in five steps
+ 3. Foundations: orders, discrepancies, thresholds, vanishing
+ 4. Step one: failure at a point forces a strict order inequality
+ 5. Step two: the best test exists
+ 6. Step three: every best test is centered at the point
+ 7. Step four and five: isolate one divisor, lift a nonzero value
+ 8. What is used where
+
+========================================================================
+0. WHAT THE THEOREM SAYS, AND WHY n+1 IS EXACTLY RIGHT
+========================================================================
+
+Throughout, X is a smooth connected projective variety over the complex
+numbers C, of dimension n at least 1, and L is an ample line bundle on X.
+
+The adjoint bundle is P = K_X + (n+1)L, where K_X is the canonical
+bundle and + means tensor product (equivalently, addition of divisors).
+
+THEOREM (the Fujita freeness conjecture).
+ K_X + (n+1)L is generated by its global sections.
+Equivalently: for every point x of X there is a global section s of
+K_X + (n+1)L with s(x) not equal to 0. That is what globally generated
+(also called spanned, or free) means.
+
+Connectedness is bookkeeping only: the statement applies to one
+connected component at a time. In dimension zero (a single point)
+every line bundle is generated.
+
+COROLLARY (all higher powers). K_X + mL is globally generated for every
+integer m >= n+1. Proof: put r = m-(n+1) and apply the theorem to the
+product X x P^r with the ample bundle L tensor O(1) on the P^r factor.
+The adjoint bundle there restricts to K_X + mL on each slice X x point,
+and a restriction of a globally generated bundle is globally generated.
+For r = 0 this is the theorem itself.
+
+WHY THE BOUND n+1 IS SHARP. Take X = P^n and L = O(1). Then
+K_X = O(-(n+1)), hence K_X+(n+1)L = O(0), the trivial bundle, which has
+the constant section 1, nowhere zero: globally generated. But
+K_X+nL = O(-1) has no nonzero sections at all. So the threshold is
+exactly n+1, and no smaller uniform twist works for all (X,L).
+
+WHY THE THEOREM IS NOT EASY. On P^n the canonical bundle is very
+negative, yet the twist repairs it. On a general X, K_X can be
+arbitrarily negative, X can be high-dimensional, and an ample L might
+itself have almost no sections. The hard part is to find ONE section
+that does not vanish at a PRESCRIBED point x, uniformly over all shapes
+and dimensions of X and all ample L. The proof converts failure at x
+into a sharp numerical contradiction, then lifts a nonzero value.
+
+Historical landmarks (orientation only, not used below): curves by
+Riemann-Roch; surfaces by Reider; threefolds by Ein-Lazarsfeld;
+fourfolds by Kawamata; fivefolds by Ye-Zhu. In arbitrary dimension,
+Angehrn-Siu gave a quadratic bound, then Helmke, Heier, Ghidelli-Lacini
+and Han improved toward linear. The proof below reaches n+1 exactly.
+
+========================================================================
+1. A DICTIONARY OF THE WORDS USED
+========================================================================
+
+Read the proof with this section as background; return to it as needed.
+
+projective variety: the common zero set of finitely many homogeneous
+ polynomials in some projective space, with its algebraic structure.
+ It is compact. Smooth means no corners or self-touching points: near
+ each point it looks like an open ball in C^n.
+
+dimension n: the number of independent complex directions at a smooth
+ point; C^n has dimension n.
+
+line bundle: a way to attach a one-dimensional complex vector space to
+ every point, varying algebraically. Two models: (a) a locally trivial
+ family of lines glued by transition functions; (b) the data of a
+ divisor D up to linear equivalence, written O(D). Tensor product is
+ written additively, O(D)+O(E)=O(D+E); the dual is O(-D).
+
+ample: positive enough. Equivalently some positive power L^k gives an
+ embedding of X into a projective space (L^k is very ample).
+
+section of a line bundle: a rule choosing a vector in the line over each
+ point, varying algebraically. The zero set of a nonzero section is a
+ divisor. H^0(X,L) is the vector space of all sections; its dimension is
+ h^0(X,L).
+
+globally generated (spanned, free): for every point x there is a section
+ not vanishing at x. Equivalently the sections define a regular map
+ X -> projective space, with no indeterminacy.
+
+canonical bundle K_X: the top exterior power of the cotangent bundle;
+ concretely the bundle of holomorphic n-forms. It can be very negative,
+ as on P^n.
+
+adjoint bundle: K_X + mL. The conjecture is that m = n+1 always gives
+ global generation.
+
+divisor: a formal finite integer combination of codimension-one
+ subvarieties. Effective means all coefficients are >= 0.
+
+log resolution: a birational map pi: Y -> X from a smooth Y on which the
+ preimage of a given divisor, plus all exceptional divisors, is a simple
+ normal crossing (SNC) divisor: locally a union of coordinate
+ hyperplanes. Existence in characteristic zero is the Hironaka theorem.
+
+exceptional divisor: a prime divisor on Y mapping to a positive-
+ codimension subset of X (it does not survive as a divisor downstairs).
+
+nef and big: nef means nonnegative on every curve; big means top self-
+ intersection grows like an ample bundle. Nef and big is positive enough
+ for vanishing theorems.
+
+Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing: the cohomological engine, stated in Section
+ 3. It turns positivity into vanishing of higher cohomology, which lets
+ a section on a subvariety lift to the whole space.
+
+========================================================================
+2. THE PLAN OF THE PROOF IN FIVE STEPS
+========================================================================
+
+We argue by contradiction. Suppose P = K_X + (n+1)L is NOT generated at
+some point x. We derive a contradiction in five steps; each is fully
+proved later, and Section 8 lists exactly what is used where.
+
+STEP ONE (Section 4). Translate fails-at-x into a strict inequality on
+how fast sections of large mL vanish at x. Take a basis of H^0(X,mL),
+read off each section Taylor initial exponent at x, and average the
+total degrees. The normalized average has liminf strictly larger than
+n/(n+1). This is a clean statement about lattice points.
+
+STEP TWO (Section 5). Set up a minimization. Among all bases of
+H^0(X,mL) and all monomial tests v (weighted orders of vanishing with a
+log discrepancy A(v)), minimize the exponential average
+ (1/N_m) sum_i exp( A(v)/t - v(s_i)/m ), for a fixed t < n+1.
+Show the minimum is attained and that the discrepancy of every
+minimizing test lies in a fixed compact interval [a_star, a^*] with
+a_star > 0, uniformly in m and t. This uniformity is the technical
+heart of making the best test well defined.
+
+STEP THREE (Section 6). Show every minimizer is centered exactly at the
+point x. If a minimizing test had a positive-dimensional center W, a
+variation tangent to W would force a weighted tangential moment to be at
+most d/t, while a uniform restriction estimate plus a discrete
+Brunn-Minkowski inequality would force the same moment to be at least
+d/t with a strict margin. Contradiction.
+
+STEP FOUR (Section 7). A point-centered minimizer gives a rational
+supporting functional on finitely many polytopes of normalized section
+orders. From it we build an effective ideal and an SNC boundary B with a
+reduced divisor S over x on which the coefficient of B equals the log
+discrepancy, while every other divisor meeting S gets a strictly
+smaller coefficient.
+
+STEP FIVE (Section 7). Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing makes the restriction
+map H^0(T,O(D+S)) -> H^0(S,O_S(D+S)) surjective. A nonzero value in the
+fiber P|_x gives a nonzero section of O_S(D+S); lift it and descend to a
+section of P not vanishing at x. Contradiction.
+
+========================================================================
+3. FOUNDATIONS: ORDERS, DISCREPANCIES, THRESHOLDS, VANISHING
+========================================================================
+
+Notation throughout the proof. X, L, n are as in the theorem. Put
+ P = K_X + (n+1)L, R_j = H^0(X, jL), N_j = dim R_j.
+Ampleness gives the Hilbert asymptotic
+ N_j = (L^n / n!) j^n + O(j^(n-1)), with L^n a positive integer.
+
+All centers are CLOSED centers. So a divisor centered along a
+subvariety W is an admissible test at every point of W, not just at its
+generic point.
+
+WEIGHTED MONOMIAL ORDERS. Fix a smooth projective birational model
+pi: Y -> X and local regular coordinates adapted to the ENTIRE relative
+canonical divisor: every component of that divisor meeting the
+coordinate neighborhood is a coordinate hyperplane. Choose a subset
+E_1,...,E_r of the coordinate divisors and give them positive real
+weights u_1,...,u_r; all remaining coordinates get weight zero. The
+order of a germ is the least weight of a nonzero monomial in the local
+equations of the E_j, with coefficients in the remaining coordinates.
+The log discrepancy of this test is
+ A(v) = sum_j u_j A(E_j),
+where for a prime divisor F on a model, A(F) = 1 + ord_F(K_{Y/X}) is
+the log discrepancy. A coordinate divisor absent from the relative
+canonical divisor has A = 1. The chosen test has a positive-support
+stratum; we use its closed image on X as the center. This adaptation
+condition is exactly what makes the displayed formula for A(v) correct.
+Positive multiples of a prime order are allowed, and scaling discrepancy
+by the same factor. Approximating real weights by positive rational
+weights on a fixed support approximates both the discrepancy and the
+orders of any fixed finite family of sections.
+
+LEMMA (local computation of a monomial order). A monomial order with
+fixed positive support can be computed in the Taylor ring at any smooth
+point of its open stratum. Its value is unchanged by replacing each
+positive-weight coordinate by a unit multiple, or by changing the
+complementary zero-weight coordinates.
+Proof. For a threshold c, the relevant ideal is generated by monomials
+in the positive-weight parameters of weight at least c, and these are
+preserved up to units. In the completed local ring the ideal is
+extended from a finite-colength monomial ideal in the positive-weight
+variables, hence primary to their intersection. Localization at the
+generic point of the stratum followed by contraction does not change
+membership, and completion is faithfully flat. So a coefficient that
+vanishes at the chosen point but not identically on the stratum is a
+nonzero series in the zero-weight variables; it does not raise the
+weighted order.
+
+LEMMA (SNC retraction). Let D_1,...,D_N be effective divisors on X and
+let Y -> X be a log resolution of their union, with SNC exceptional
+components E_j. For a positive multiple v of a prime-divisor order over
+Y set u_j = v(E_j). Then
+ v(D_i) = sum_j u_j ord_{E_j}(D_i), and A(v) >= sum_j u_j A(E_j).
+If some u_j is nonzero, the monomial order with these weights at the
+stratum containing the generic center of v has the same orders on the
+D_i, no larger discrepancy, and a closed center on X containing that of
+v.
+Proof. Each pulled-back divisor is locally a monomial times a unit,
+giving the first equality. The reduced SNC divisor is log canonical: a
+logarithmic volume form has at most a simple pole along each prime on a
+higher model. So the log discrepancy relative to Y is at least sum u_j;
+adding the order of K_{Y/X} gives the inequality and the claimed
+discrepancy of the monomial order. The stratum closure contains the
+generic center, so its image contains the original closed center.
+
+THRESHOLDS. For a coherent ideal a on a smooth variety, the local log
+canonical threshold at x is computed on a log resolution by
+ lct_x(a) = min over F with x in pi(F) and ord_F(a) > 0 of
+ A(F) / ord_F(a).
+The minimum is +infinity for the unit ideal, and 0 for the zero ideal.
+
+LEMMA (closed threshold loci). Let V be a smooth complex projective
+variety, S a complex algebraic variety, and a an ideal on V x S given
+locally by algebraic families of generators. For a real c, the locus
+ {(y,s) in V x S : lct_y(a_s) <= c}
+is Zariski closed, where a_s is the ideal generated by the restricted
+generators (no flatness required).
+Proof. The analytic semi-continuity of complex singularity exponents of
+Demailly-Kollar gives closedness in the classical topology, because
+phi = (1/2) log sum |g_i|^2 has e^phi locally Holder continuous and
+translation handles a moving marked point. Constructibility comes from
+stratifying: over the generic point of each component resolve the ideal,
+spread the resolution over a dense open, and the fiber maps are log
+resolutions with fixed orders and coefficients, so the threshold
+condition is a finite union of proper images (algebraic, proper, hence
+constructible); induction on the complement finishes. A subset that is
+constructible and classically closed is Zariski closed, since a Zariski
+open subset of an irreducible variety is classically dense.
+
+THEOREM (Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing). Let T be smooth projective over C.
+Let Delta be an effective rational SNC divisor with coefficients in
+[0,1), and let D be an integral divisor. If D - (K_T + Delta) is nef and
+big, then H^i(T, O_T(D)) = 0 for every i > 0.
+Equivalently, using Q = D - K_T - Delta and its rounding: if M is
+integral and B is an effective rational SNC divisor with M - B nef and
+big, then H^i(T, O_T(K_T + M - floor(B))) = 0 for i > 0. This is the
+form used below.
+
+LEMMA (descent). Let pi: T -> V be a proper birational morphism of
+smooth varieties, P_V a line bundle on V, and C an integral divisor on T
+whose positive part is exceptional. A section of pi^*P_V + C defines a
+regular section of P_V on V. If a prime F on T maps to a point x, the
+coefficient of C on F is zero, and the section is nonzero generically on
+F, then the descended section is nonzero at x.
+Proof. View the section as a rational section of P_V on the common
+function field. Its orders at all nonexceptional primes are
+nonnegative, because the coefficients of C there are nonpositive. So it
+is regular in codimension one on the normal variety V, hence
+everywhere. Under the extra assumptions its pullback has order zero
+along F. A local function vanishing at x has positive order along every
+prime centered at x, so the descended section cannot vanish at x.
+
+========================================================================
+4. STEP ONE: FAILURE AT A POINT FORCES A STRICT ORDER INEQUALITY
+========================================================================
+
+Fix a closed point x in X. Choose regular parameters at x and a local
+frame of L; use powers of that frame as frames of jL. Order Taylor
+monomials first by total degree, then lexicographically, always taking
+the smallest monomial. Let
+ H_j = { in(s) : 0 != s in R_j } inside Z_{>=0}^n
+be the set of initial exponents. Then |in(s)|_1 = mult_x(s), the
+multiplicity (order of vanishing) of s at x.
+
+LEMMA (initial exponents give a basis). The set H_j has cardinality N_j,
+and representatives of its distinct exponents form a basis of R_j.
+There is a constant C > 0, independent of j and s, with
+ mult_x(s) <= C j for every nonzero s in R_j.
+Moreover H_j + H_q is contained in H_{j+q}.
+Proof. Taylor expansion is injective on R_j: a section with zero germ
+vanishes on a nonempty open set, hence on the integral variety X. Each
+monomial coefficient ranges over a one-dimensional space. Successively
+select a smallest initial monomial and eliminate its coefficient from
+the remaining vectors; this produces a basis with distinct initials, and
+any linear combination has the initial of its first nonzero summand.
+That proves the cardinality claim. For the multiplicity bound, choose a
+fixed sufficiently ample multiple kL, and general members of its linear
+system through x cut out a curve smooth at x and not contained in the
+divisor of a prescribed nonzero section of jL. Local intersection
+multiplicity bounds mult_x(s) by the degree of that divisor on the
+curve, at most j k^(n-1) L^n. In dimension one this is just the degree
+bound for an effective divisor on X. Finally the monomial order is
+multiplicative, so initial exponents add under products of sections.
+
+PROPOSITION (ordinary-order alternative). If P = K_X+(n+1)L is not
+generated at x, then
+ liminf over j of (1/(j N_j)) * sum_{gamma in H_j} |gamma|_1
+ > n/(n+1).
+
+Proof. We prove the contrapositive: failure of the strict inequality
+forces generation at x. Three steps: lattice near-equality forces
+L^n = 1 along a subsequence; the leading forms on the exceptional
+divisor of the blowup at x then have a strict multiplier threshold;
+vanishing lifts a nonzero section from that divisor.
+
+Put V = L^n. The number of nonnegative integral points of total degree
+at most r is binom(r+n, n). Filling points in order of increasing total
+degree, and using N_j = V j^n / n! + O(j^(n-1)), gives
+ liminf (1/(j N_j)) sum_{gamma in H_j} |gamma|_1
+ >= V^(1/n) * n/(n+1).
+Indeed the last occupied degree for the N_j smallest lattice points is
+V^(1/n) j + O(1), and summing total degree over these points gives mean
+degree V^(1/n) n j/(n+1) + O(1). Since V is a positive integer, V^(1/n)
+is at least 1, so if the strict inequality of the proposition fails,
+then necessarily V = 1 and equality holds along a subsequence.
+
+Let Delta = {u in R^n : u >= 0, |u|_1 <= 1}. Along the equality
+subsequence, every fixed open ball with closure in the interior of Delta
+meets j^{-1} H_j for all large j. (Compare H_j with the N_j smallest
+lattice points T_j. If such a ball were missed, at least c_1 j^n points
+of T_j of degrees at most (1-c_2) j would be absent; each replacement
+outside T_j has degree at least j-O(1); the remaining replacements
+cannot lower the degree sum, so the normalized mean would exceed the
+minimum by a fixed amount, contradicting equality.)
+
+Choose a rational t with n < t < n+1 and put c = (1/t,...,1/t), a
+point in the interior of Delta. Choose finitely many small balls with
+closures in that interior such that any choice of one point per ball has
+convex hull containing c in its interior. For one large degree j on the
+subsequence, choose initial exponents gamma_nu in H_j, one per ball after
+scaling by 1/j. The rational polytope Q = conv{gamma_nu / j} contains c
+in its interior. Its slice {|u|_1 = n/t} has rational points p_1,...,p_b
+whose convex hull contains c in its relative interior (in dimension one
+that slice is the single point c).
+
+Write each p_l as a rational convex combination of the gamma_nu / j and
+choose sections s_nu with those initials. If t = a/b in lowest terms,
+choose Q_0 divisible by a and by every denominator; then products of Q_0
+sections give sections r_1,...,r_b of j Q_0 L. Put h = j Q_0 / t, a
+positive integer by construction. Their initial exponents beta_l satisfy
+ r_l in H^0(X, h t L), beta_l = j Q_0 p_l, |beta_l|_1 = n h.
+Thus conv{beta_l / h} contains the all-ones vector 1 in relative
+interior inside the hyperplane {|u|_1 = n}.
+
+Let p: B = Bl_x X -> X be the blowup, E the exceptional divisor
+(P^{n-1} for n>1; for n=1 take p the identity and E = x). Removing
+the common order n h from the pullbacks of the r_l gives a subsystem of
+ H = p^*(h t L) - n h E
+with base ideal b. Its restriction to E is generated, in local frames,
+by the leading homogeneous forms g_l of the r_l, each of degree n h.
+CLAIM. lct_z(E, b|_E) > 1/h for every z in E. (For n=1 the restricted
+ideal is the unit ideal.)
+
+For n > 1, replace the g_l by their initial monomials z^{beta_l}. On the
+chart of E where z_k != 0 their exponents are obtained by omitting
+coordinate k. Projection from the hyperplane |u|_1 = n is an affine
+isomorphism, so the normalized exponent polytope contains the all-ones
+vector in ordinary interior. Hence for every nonzero u in R_{>=0}^{n-1},
+ (1/h) min_l <u, beta_l^(k)> < sum_i u_i.
+For a prime order over this chart use its values on the coordinates as
+u. The left side is the order of the monomial ideal over h; the right
+side is at most the log discrepancy (SNC inequality of the retraction
+lemma). So the monomial ideal is klt at coefficient 1/h; computing its
+threshold on a log resolution gives a strict threshold > 1/h at every
+point. (If u=0 the order is 0 and the discrepancy is positive.)
+
+Transfer to the original forms by an algebraic degeneration. Only
+finitely many monomials occur; choose an integral weight w making the
+lex initial of each g_l its unique smallest-weight term. The forms
+ g_{l,lambda}(z) = lambda^{-<w,beta_l>} g_l(lambda^{w_1} z_1, ...)
+have polynomial coefficients in lambda with monomial special fiber.
+They define an algebraic family of ideals on E x A^1. By the closed-
+threshold-loci lemma, the locus where the fiber threshold is <= 1/h is
+closed; its image in A^1 is closed (E is proper) and misses 0. For some
+nonzero parameter the threshold exceeds 1/h everywhere on E. Every
+nonzero fiber is a diagonal automorph of the original forms, so the
+claim holds for the g_l.
+
+It remains to lift from E. The blowup formula gives
+ p^*P - (K_B + E) - H/h = (n+1-t) p^*L.
+Take a projective log resolution sigma: T -> B of E and b, with strict
+transform Eprime and b O_T = O_T(-G). Eprime is not a component of G
+(the restricted system is not identically zero). Set
+ D_T = K_T + sigma^*(p^*P - K_B - E) - floor(G/h),
+an integral divisor. Then
+ D_T - K_T - {G/h} = (n+1-t)(p sigma)^*L + (sigma^*H - G)/h.
+The first summand is nef and big; the second is nef, since sigma^*H - G
+is globally generated. The fractional boundary has SNC support. By
+Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing, H^1(T, O_T(D_T)) = 0.
+
+Let sigma_E: Eprime -> E be the induced morphism. Adjunction identifies
+the restriction of D_T + Eprime with
+ sigma_E^* (p^*P |_E) + K_{Eprime/E} - floor(G|_{Eprime}/h).
+Indeed Eprime + Supp(G) is SNC, each component restricts with
+multiplicity one, distinct components cannot restrict to the same prime,
+so taking floors commutes with restriction; and the generators on
+Eprime generate O_{Eprime}(-G|_{Eprime}), the pullback of the
+restricted ideal. The strict threshold implies
+ K_{Eprime/E} - floor(G|_{Eprime}/h) >= 0,
+an effective correction. The first bundle is trivial with fiber P_x. A
+nonzero vector in that fiber, times the canonical section of the
+effective correction, gives a section on Eprime nonzero at its generic
+point. The exact sequence for Eprime and the vanishing lift it to a
+section of D_T + Eprime.
+
+Relative to sigma^* p^* P, the correction of this lifted bundle is
+ C_T = K_{T/B} - sigma^* E + Eprime - floor(G/h).
+Its coefficient on Eprime is zero, and on every other sigma-
+nonexceptional divisor it is nonpositive; its positive part is thus
+exceptional over X. Since Eprime maps to x and the lifted section is
+nonzero at its generic point, the descent lemma applied to p sigma gives
+a section of P nonzero at x. This proves the proposition, including
+dimension one, when Eprime is the point itself. END OF PROOF.
+
+========================================================================
+5. STEP TWO: THE BEST TEST EXISTS (EXPONENTIAL MINIMIZATION)
+========================================================================
+
+We now let both the basis and the test vary, and minimize
+ F_{m,t}(v, s) = (1/N_m) sum_i exp( A(v)/t - v(s_i)/m ), t > 0,
+over ordered bases s = (s_1,...,s_N_m) of R_m and monomial tests v. Let
+ f_{m,t}(z) = inf over v with z in c(v), and over bases, of F_{m,t}.
+Here c(v) is the closed center. Positive rescaling of v is allowed:
+approximating its positive weights by rational weights preserves the
+center and approximates the orders of finitely many sections and the
+discrepancy. So the same infimum is obtained using positive multiples of
+prime-divisor orders.
+
+LEMMA (order bound). If the center of v contains x, then every nonzero
+section s satisfies
+ v(s) <= A(v) mult_x(s).
+In particular, for s in R_m, 0 <= v(s)/A(v) <= C m, with C from the
+initial-exponent lemma.
+Proof. For an effective divisor with local equation g of multiplicity
+r > 0 at a smooth point, lct_x(g) >= 1/r. (Weierstrass preparation: on
+a small polydisc g is a unit times a monic degree-r polynomial in one
+coordinate; for any c < 1/r Holder bounds the integral of |g|^{-2c} by
+products of finite one-variable integrals, so Fubini gives local
+integrability.) Computing the threshold on a log resolution gives the
+bound v(s) <= A(v) mult_x(s) for prime orders whose center contains x,
+and rational approximation gives it for monomial tests.
+
+LEMMA (uniform sublevel bounds). Suppose P is not generated at x. Then
+there are numbers 0 < t_0 < n+1, c > 0, 0 < delta < 1, 0 < a_star <=
+a^* < infinity, and an integer m_0 such that for every m >= m_0 and
+every t in [t_0, n+1],
+ c <= f_{m,t}(x) <= 1 - delta.
+Moreover any pair centered with image containing x and with
+F_{m,t}(v,s) <= 1 - delta/2 satisfies a_star <= A(v) <= a^*. All these
+constants are independent of m and t in the stated ranges.
+Proof. By the ordinary-order alternative there is epsilon > 0 with
+ (1/(m N_m)) sum_{gamma in H_m} |gamma|_1 >= n/(n+1) + 3 epsilon
+for all large m. Choose t_0 < n+1 so close that n/t_0 <=
+n/(n+1) + epsilon. Take a basis with distinct ordinary initials and use
+v = lambda * ord_x, the ordinary point order, with A(ord_x) = n (for
+n=1 this is the order of the point). The linear coefficient at
+lambda = 0 is at most -2 epsilon uniformly in m and t; by the
+multiplicity bound the quantities n/t - mult_x(s_i)/m are uniformly
+bounded, so the quadratic remainder is O(lambda^2). A fixed small
+lambda gives F_{m,t} <= 1 - delta for a fixed delta > 0.
+
+Next a uniform supply of low-order jets. Choose k with kL very ample
+and sections s_0,...,s_n of kL with s_0(x) != 0 and z_i = s_i/s_0
+regular parameters. For each residue class mod k choose a fixed large
+b_r in that class with b_r L globally generated and tau_r in
+H^0(X, b_r L) nonzero at x. Write m = qk + b_r. For |alpha|_1 <= q the
+sections tau_r s_0^{q-|alpha|} s_1^{alpha_1}...s_n^{alpha_n} have germs
+equal to a common unit times z^alpha in a local frame of mL. Let
+ r_m = min(q, floor(m/(2(n+1)))).
+Their jets for |alpha|_1 <= r_m are linearly independent modulo order
+> m/(2t). For large m, r_m is at least a fixed positive multiple of m,
+so Hilbert asymptotics give a constant 0 < kappa < 1 with
+ codim { s in R_m : mult_x(s) > m/(2t) } >= kappa N_m.
+By the order bound the subspace { s : v(s) > m a/(2t) } sits inside
+this one, where a = A(v). Thus at least kappa N_m vectors of any basis
+(adapted or not) have v(s_i) <= m a/(2t), so
+ F_{m,t}(v,s) >= kappa exp( a/(2t) ) >= kappa exp( a/(2(n+1)) ).
+This gives the lower bound c = kappa and bounds a above on the sublevel
+set. Finally F >= exp(-C a) by the order bound and multiplicity bound;
+choosing a_star small enough that exp(-C a_star) > 1 - delta/2, no
+sublevel pair has a < a_star. Enlarging the upper bound if needed gives
+a^* >= a_star.
+
+LEMMA (closed realizability loci). Fix m with N_m > 0 and a decreasing
+list alpha_1 >= ... >= alpha_{N_m} >= 0 of rationals. The set of points
+z in X for which some ordered basis and some prime-divisor order v with
+z in c(v) satisfy v(s_i)/A(v) >= alpha_i (all i) is Zariski closed.
+There is also a closed incidence locus in the product of X with the
+complete flag variety of R_m, recording realizability by bases adapted
+to a given flag.
+Proof. Let F be the projective flag variety; a flag has subspaces
+U_i of dimensions i and base ideals b_i, by evaluation after twisting by
+-mL. If the list holds, the flag spanned by the first i basis vectors
+satisfies v(b_i) >= alpha_i A(v) (because the list is decreasing);
+conversely these inequalities imply the list for every adapted basis.
+If some alpha_i > 0, choose M making M/alpha_i integral for each
+positive entry and set a_alpha = sum_{alpha_i>0} b_i^{M/alpha_i}. The
+simultaneous inequalities are equivalent to v(a_alpha) >= M A(v). A
+divisorial witness with center containing z exists iff
+ lct_z(X, a_alpha) <= 1/M,
+since the local threshold is computed by a component on a log
+resolution. The universal subbundles on F give algebraic families of
+generators on X x F, hence for the powers and sum; the closed-
+threshold-loci lemma applied to this condition gives a closed incidence
+locus, whose projection to X is closed (F proper). If all entries
+vanish, both loci are the whole parameter spaces.
+
+PROPOSITION (existence and uniform bounds for minimizers). Suppose P is
+not generated at x. For the constants and ranges of the coercivity
+lemma, f_{m,t}(x) satisfies c <= f <= 1-delta and is attained by an
+ordered basis of R_m and a nonzero real-weight monomial test on a
+projective log resolution of the basis divisors. Every minimizing test
+has a_star <= A(v) <= a^*. The same bounds hold eventually along every
+minimizing sequence, so a_star is uniformly positive.
+
+Proof. Only attainment remains. Fix m,t in range and take divisorial
+pairs whose objective decreases to f_{m,t}(x); eventually they lie in
+the sublevel set. Order each basis by decreasing normalized values and
+pass to a subsequence with A(v_b) -> a in [a_star, a^*] and
+q_{b,i} = v_b(s_{b,i})/A(v_b) -> q_i. This is possible since
+0 <= q_{b,i} <= C m. The limit list is decreasing and
+ f_{m,t}(x) = (1/N_m) sum_i exp( a/t - a q_i/m ).
+At least one q_i is positive, else the right side is exp(a/t) > 1,
+contradicting f <= 1 - delta.
+
+Choose decreasing nonnegative rational lists alpha^(k) increasing
+componentwise to (q_i), strictly below q_i whenever q_i > 0. Each list
+is satisfied by all sufficiently late pairs. By the closed-realizability
+lemma the flags admitting a witness at x for alpha^(k) form a nonempty
+closed subset F_k of the flag variety; these are nested, so projectivity
+gives a flag in their intersection. Fix a basis s_1,...,s_{N_m} adapted
+to this flag. Resolve the divisors of these sections on one smooth
+projective model Y -> X, including exceptional divisors in the SNC
+support. For each large k, choose a witness for the fixed flag and
+alpha^(k) on a common smooth model dominating Y. Retracting to the fixed
+SNC model (retraction lemma) preserves all section orders, does not
+increase discrepancy, and has center on X containing x. Normalize to
+discrepancy one; it satisfies tilde_v_k(s_i) >= alpha_i^(k).
+
+There are finitely many SNC strata and components on Y. Pass to a
+subsequence using the same stratum component, coordinate divisors indexed
+by a fixed set J. Their normalized weights belong to the compact simplex
+ { (u_j) : u_j >= 0, sum_j A(E_j) u_j = 1 }.
+All A(E_j) are positive since X is smooth. Pass to a limit of the
+weights; some u_j may become zero. Take the component of the remaining
+positive-support intersection that contains the old stratum component;
+its closure contains the old center, so its image still contains x. The
+limit is a nonzero monomial test tilde_v of discrepancy one, and section
+orders are linear in the weights, so tilde_v(s_i) >= q_i for all i.
+
+Set v = a tilde_v. Comparing with the limit objective,
+ F_{m,t}(v,s) <= (1/N_m) sum_i exp( a/t - a q_i/m ) = f_{m,t}(x).
+The reverse inequality holds by definition of the infimum, so this pair
+attains it. The discrepancy bounds for all minimizers and eventually for
+minimizing sequences follow from the uniform sublevel bounds. END PROOF.
+
+LEMMA (specialization comparison). Fix m with N_m > 0 and a closed
+irreducible W in X containing x. At a very general closed point y of W,
+for every t > 0,
+ f_{m,t}(y) >= f_{m,t}(x).
+Proof. There are countably many rational lists as in the closed-
+realizability lemma. For each, intersect its closed locus with W and
+discard it if the intersection is proper in W; the complement contains
+very general closed points. For any remaining y, every such list
+realized at y is realized at x. Take a test and basis at y, reorder so
+q_i = v(s_i)/A(v) is decreasing, a = A(v) > 0. Approximate (q_i) from
+below by rational lists; each is realized at x, and after scaling to
+discrepancy a gives an objective at x at most
+ (1/N_m) sum_i exp( a/t - a alpha_i^(b)/m ).
+Taking the limit gives f_{m,t}(x) <= F_{m,t}(v,s). Infimizing over tests
+at y proves the claim. The discarded loci are independent of t, giving
+the simultaneous statement for all positive t.
+
+========================================================================
+6. STEP THREE: EVERY BEST TEST IS CENTERED AT THE POINT
+========================================================================
+
+PROPOSITION (point center). Suppose P is not generated at x. Then there
+is a real 0 < t < n+1 such that, for arbitrarily large integers m, the
+infimum f_{m,t}(x) is attained and EVERY minimizing monomial pair has
+center exactly {x}. (A minimizing pair is a monomial test together with a
+basis attaining the infimum, over all such pairs.) We keep this one t and
+this point x fixed from here on.
+
+Before the argument, a uniform estimate: the image of the restriction
+map from sections of hL to a subvariety W has dimension bounded below by
+a function of h alone, uniform over all W of a fixed dimension.
+
+Fix k with kL very ample and embed X by its complete system. For an
+integral d-dimensional closed W in X put
+ I_W(h) = dim image( R_h -> H^0(W, hL|_W) ).
+
+LEMMA (uniform restriction estimate). For each 1 <= d <= n there are
+constants C_d, H_d depending only on (X,L,k,d) with
+ (d! I_W(h))^{1/d} >= h - C_d for all h >= H_d,
+for EVERY integral d-dimensional closed W in X.
+Proof. Set D_0 = k^d. The degree of W in the fixed embedding is
+D = (kL)^d . W = k^d (L^d . W) >= D_0, since L^d . W is a positive
+integer. A general linear projection gives a finite morphism
+pi: W -> P^d of degree D, with separable generic fiber (characteristic
+zero). Write K = C(P^d), E = C(W). Choose a nonzero linear coordinate
+s_0 of the projection; all points of the geometric generic fiber lie in
+s_0 != 0. Select D_0 distinct such points. Over an algebraic closure of
+K, affine linear forms separate any two of them; for each selected
+point, multiplying at most D_0 - 1 such forms gives a polynomial
+vanishing at the others and not at that one. Homogenizing with s_0 gives
+ambient degree-D_0 forms whose normalized values span the functions on
+these D_0 points.
+
+Let V_{D_0} be the space of ambient degree-D_0 forms. Restriction and
+division by s_0^{D_0} give a K-linear map V_{D_0} (x) K -> E of rank at
+least D_0 (check rank after extending scalars, where the evaluation
+argument applies). Choose ambient degree-D_0 forms F_1,...,F_{D_0} whose
+normalized images F_i/s_0^{D_0} are K-independent; they can be chosen
+among a fixed monomial spanning set, their coefficients not depending on
+elements of K. For q >= D_0, multiply each F_i by a monomial basis of
+forms of degree q - D_0 in the projection coordinates. The products
+restrict to independent sections on W (a relation, divided by s_0^q,
+would contradict K-independence; the base forms then vanish on P^d).
+They are restrictions of sections in R_{qk}, so
+ I_W(qk) >= D_0 binom(q - D_0 + d, d),
+hence (d! I_W(qk))^{1/d} >= k(q - D_0) = qk - k^{d+1}. To cover all
+degrees, choose once and for all an integer h_r in each residue class r
+mod k with h_r L globally generated; there is a section of h_r L not
+identically zero on any W, and multiplication by it injects the
+degree-qk restriction space into the degree-(qk + h_r) one (W integral).
+For h = qk + h_r, q >= D_0, this gives (d! I_W(h))^{1/d} >=
+h - (h_r + k^{d+1}). Taking maxima over the finitely many residue
+classes proves the lemma, with both C_d and H_d at most
+max_r h_r + k^{d+1}, independent of W.