diff 7b9fc63..a2e76f1 fujita_freeness_v2.txt
diff --git a/fujita_freeness_v2.txt b/fujita_freeness_v2.txt
index 02da8f4..a06993c 100644
--- a/fujita_freeness_v2.txt
+++ b/fujita_freeness_v2.txt
@@ -1,167 +1,111 @@
-FUJITA'S FREENESS CONJECTURE
-A complete proof, written to be read from top to bottom
-
-CONTENTS
-  0. What the theorem says, and why n+1 is exact
-  1. A dictionary of the words used
-  2. The plan in five steps
-  3. Foundations: orders, discrepancies, thresholds, vanishing
-  4. Step one: failure at a point forces a strict order inequality
-  5. Step two: the best test exists
-  6. Step three: every best test is centered at the point
-  7. Step four and five: isolate one divisor, lift a nonzero value
-  8. What is used where
-
-========================================================================
-0. WHAT THE THEOREM SAYS, AND WHY n+1 IS EXACTLY RIGHT
-========================================================================
-
-Throughout, X is a smooth connected projective variety over the complex
-numbers C, of dimension n at least 1, and L is an ample line bundle on X.
-
-The adjoint bundle is P = K_X + (n+1)L, where K_X is the canonical
-bundle and + means tensor product (equivalently, addition of divisors).
-
-THEOREM (the Fujita freeness conjecture).
-    K_X + (n+1)L is generated by its global sections.
-Equivalently: for every point x of X there is a global section s of
-K_X + (n+1)L with s(x) not equal to 0. That is what globally generated
-(also called spanned, or free) means.
-
-Connectedness is bookkeeping only: the statement applies to one
-connected component at a time. In dimension zero (a single point)
-every line bundle is generated.
-
-COROLLARY (all higher powers). K_X + mL is globally generated for every
-integer m >= n+1. Proof: put r = m-(n+1) and apply the theorem to the
-product X x P^r with the ample bundle L tensor O(1) on the P^r factor.
-The adjoint bundle there restricts to K_X + mL on each slice X x point,
-and a restriction of a globally generated bundle is globally generated.
-For r = 0 this is the theorem itself.
-
-WHY THE BOUND n+1 IS SHARP. Take X = P^n and L = O(1). Then
-K_X = O(-(n+1)), hence K_X+(n+1)L = O(0), the trivial bundle, which has
-the constant section 1, nowhere zero: globally generated. But
-K_X+nL = O(-1) has no nonzero sections at all. So the threshold is
-exactly n+1, and no smaller uniform twist works for all (X,L).
-
-WHY THE THEOREM IS NOT EASY. On P^n the canonical bundle is very
-negative, yet the twist repairs it. On a general X, K_X can be
-arbitrarily negative, X can be high-dimensional, and an ample L might
-itself have almost no sections. The hard part is to find ONE section
-that does not vanish at a PRESCRIBED point x, uniformly over all shapes
-and dimensions of X and all ample L. The proof converts failure at x
-into a sharp numerical contradiction, then lifts a nonzero value.
-
-Historical landmarks (orientation only, not used below): curves by
-Riemann-Roch; surfaces by Reider; threefolds by Ein-Lazarsfeld;
-fourfolds by Kawamata; fivefolds by Ye-Zhu. In arbitrary dimension,
-Angehrn-Siu gave a quadratic bound, then Helmke, Heier, Ghidelli-Lacini
-and Han improved toward linear. The proof below reaches n+1 exactly.
-
-========================================================================
-1. A DICTIONARY OF THE WORDS USED
-========================================================================
-
-Read the proof with this section as background; return to it as needed.
-
-projective variety: the common zero set of finitely many homogeneous
-  polynomials in some projective space, with its algebraic structure.
-  It is compact. Smooth means no corners or self-touching points: near
-  each point it looks like an open ball in C^n.
-
-dimension n: the number of independent complex directions at a smooth
-  point; C^n has dimension n.
-
-line bundle: a way to attach a one-dimensional complex vector space to
-  every point, varying algebraically. Two models: (a) a locally trivial
-  family of lines glued by transition functions; (b) the data of a
-  divisor D up to linear equivalence, written O(D). Tensor product is
-  written additively, O(D)+O(E)=O(D+E); the dual is O(-D).
-
-ample: positive enough. Equivalently some positive power L^k gives an
-  embedding of X into a projective space (L^k is very ample).
-
-section of a line bundle: a rule choosing a vector in the line over each
-  point, varying algebraically. The zero set of a nonzero section is a
-  divisor. H^0(X,L) is the vector space of all sections; its dimension is
-  h^0(X,L).
-
-globally generated (spanned, free): for every point x there is a section
-  not vanishing at x. Equivalently the sections define a regular map
-  X -> projective space, with no indeterminacy.
-
-canonical bundle K_X: the top exterior power of the cotangent bundle;
-  concretely the bundle of holomorphic n-forms. It can be very negative,
-  as on P^n.
-
-adjoint bundle: K_X + mL. The conjecture is that m = n+1 always gives
-  global generation.
-
-divisor: a formal finite integer combination of codimension-one
-  subvarieties. Effective means all coefficients are >= 0.
-
-log resolution: a birational map pi: Y -> X from a smooth Y on which the
-  preimage of a given divisor, plus all exceptional divisors, is a simple
-  normal crossing (SNC) divisor: locally a union of coordinate
-  hyperplanes. Existence in characteristic zero is the Hironaka theorem.
-
-exceptional divisor: a prime divisor on Y mapping to a positive-
-  codimension subset of X (it does not survive as a divisor downstairs).
-
-nef and big: nef means nonnegative on every curve; big means top self-
-  intersection grows like an ample bundle. Nef and big is positive enough
-  for vanishing theorems.
-
-Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing: the cohomological engine, stated in Section
-  3. It turns positivity into vanishing of higher cohomology, which lets
-  a section on a subvariety lift to the whole space.
-
-========================================================================
-2. THE PLAN OF THE PROOF IN FIVE STEPS
-========================================================================
-
-We argue by contradiction. Suppose P = K_X + (n+1)L is NOT generated at
-some point x. We derive a contradiction in five steps; each is fully
-proved later, and Section 8 lists exactly what is used where.
-
-STEP ONE (Section 4). Translate fails-at-x into a strict inequality on
-how fast sections of large mL vanish at x. Take a basis of H^0(X,mL),
-read off each section Taylor initial exponent at x, and average the
-total degrees. The normalized average has liminf strictly larger than
-n/(n+1). This is a clean statement about lattice points.
-
-STEP TWO (Section 5). Set up a minimization. Among all bases of
-H^0(X,mL) and all monomial tests v (weighted orders of vanishing with a
-log discrepancy A(v)), minimize the exponential average
-    (1/N_m) sum_i exp( A(v)/t - v(s_i)/m ),   for a fixed t < n+1.
-Show the minimum is attained and that the discrepancy of every
-minimizing test lies in a fixed compact interval [a_star, a^*] with
-a_star > 0, uniformly in m and t. This uniformity is the technical
-heart of making the best test well defined.
-
-STEP THREE (Section 6). Show every minimizer is centered exactly at the
-point x. If a minimizing test had a positive-dimensional center W, a
-variation tangent to W would force a weighted tangential moment to be at
-most d/t, while a uniform restriction estimate plus a discrete
-Brunn-Minkowski inequality would force the same moment to be at least
-d/t with a strict margin. Contradiction.
-
-STEP FOUR (Section 7). A point-centered minimizer gives a rational
-supporting functional on finitely many polytopes of normalized section
-orders. From it we build an effective ideal and an SNC boundary B with a
-reduced divisor S over x on which the coefficient of B equals the log
-discrepancy, while every other divisor meeting S gets a strictly
-smaller coefficient.
-
-STEP FIVE (Section 7). Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing makes the restriction
-map H^0(T,O(D+S)) -> H^0(S,O_S(D+S)) surjective. A nonzero value in the
-fiber P|_x gives a nonzero section of O_S(D+S); lift it and descend to a
-section of P not vanishing at x. Contradiction.
-
-========================================================================
-3. FOUNDATIONS: ORDERS, DISCREPANCIES, THRESHOLDS, VANISHING
-========================================================================
+A smooth complex projective variety X of dimension n has a canonical
+bundle K_X, the bundle of holomorphic n-forms; on projective space it is
+very negative. For an ample line bundle L and an integer m, the adjoint
+bundle is K_X + mL, with + denoting tensor product. Fujita's freeness
+conjecture, proved below, asserts that K_X + (n+1)L is generated by its
+global sections, meaning that for every point x of X some global section
+s satisfies s(x) not equal to 0. The same word means spanned: the
+sections determine a regular map to a projective space with no point left
+undetermined.
+
+Connectedness of X is bookkeeping, since the statement applies to one
+component at a time; in dimension zero every line bundle is generated.
+Once the case m = n+1 is known, every larger twist follows. Write
+r = m-(n+1) and apply the theorem on the product X x P^r with the ample
+bundle L tensor O(1) on the P^r factor. The adjoint bundle of that
+product is (K_X+mL) tensor O(n) on the P^r factor, so its restriction to
+a slice X x point is K_X+mL, and a restriction of a globally generated
+bundle is globally generated. For r = 0 the slice is X itself.
+
+The bound n+1 cannot be lowered. On P^n with L = O(1), the canonical
+bundle is O(-(n+1)), so K_X+(n+1)L is the trivial bundle, whose constant
+section 1 never vanishes. But K_X+nL is O(-1), which has no nonzero
+section at all. No uniform threshold below (n+1) can work for every pair
+(X,L). This also shows that the theorem cannot be proved by producing a
+section of L, or by any argument that first needs one.
+
+The difficulty is that one section has to avoid one prescribed point. A
+general ample bundle may have many sections vanishing there, or none; the
+canonical bundle may be arbitrarily negative; the dimension is unbounded.
+The strategy converts failure at x into a numerical contradiction, then
+lifts a nonzero value of the fiber at x to a genuine section.
+
+Some vocabulary, kept terse. A projective variety is the common zero
+locus of finitely many homogeneous polynomials in a projective space,
+equipped with its algebraic structure; it is compact, and smooth means
+that near each point it looks like an open ball in C^n. A line bundle
+attaches a complex line to every point, algebraically; the standard
+model is a divisor D, a finite integral combination of codimension-one
+subvarieties, written O(D), with O(D)+O(E) = O(D+E) and dual O(-D). A
+divisor is effective when all its coefficients are nonnegative. Ample
+means that some positive power embeds X into a projective space. A
+section is a vector in the line over each point, chosen algebraically;
+the zero set of a nonzero section is a divisor, and H^0(X,M) denotes the
+vector space of sections of a bundle M. Nef means nonnegative on every
+curve, big means that the top self-intersection grows like an ample
+bundle. A log resolution of a divisor D is a birational map pi: Y -> X
+from a smooth Y on which the preimage of D, together with all exceptional
+divisors, is a simple normal crossing divisor: locally a union of
+coordinate hyperplanes, which makes every local computation monomial.
+
+The argument has five stages. Failure of generation at x is first
+translated into a strict inequality for how fast sections of large mL
+vanish at x: the normalized mean order of a Taylor basis has lower limit
+strictly above n/(n+1), which is a statement about lattice points. Next,
+a finite-degree exponential average over bases and weighted orders is
+minimized for one fixed t below n+1; the minimum is attained, and the
+discrepancy of every minimizing order lies in a fixed compact interval
+away from zero, uniformly in the degree. Third, every minimizer is shown
+to be centered at the single point x: a positive-dimensional center would
+force a weighted tangential moment to be small by a first variation, and
+large by a uniform restriction estimate combined with Brunn-Minkowski.
+Fourth, a point-centered minimizer yields rational supporting data on
+finitely many polytopes of normalized section orders, from which an
+effective ideal and a normal-crossing boundary are built, with exact
+equality of boundary coefficient and log discrepancy on a reduced
+divisor over x and strict inequality on every neighbor. Fifth,
+Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing lifts a nonzero element of the fiber at x from
+that divisor, and descent turns the lift into a global section of
+K_X+(n+1)L not vanishing at x.
+
+Earlier work forms a ladder toward the sharp twist. Curves follow from
+Riemann-Roch. Surfaces follow from Reider's theorem. The threefold,
+fourfold, and fivefold cases are due to Ein-Lazarsfeld, Kawamata, and
+Ye-Zhu; Angehrn-Siu reached a quadratic bound in all dimensions, Helmke
+supplied multiplicity estimates for the centers in the vanishing
+argument, Heier combined the two, and Ghidelli-Lacini and Han pushed the
+bound toward linear. Kawamata's argument for threefolds and fourfolds is
+the closest relative of the local mechanism reused at the end.
+./kawamata-1997-alg-geom-9510004-fujita-3-and-4-folds.pdf
+Fujita's own reduction of the spannedness question to a discrepancy
+computation, in the remarks on the Ein-Lazarsfeld criterion, is the model
+for the isolation step.
+./fujita-1993-alg-geom-9311013-ein-lazarsfeld-criterion.pdf
+The fivefold case, with Ye and Zhu controlling centers of large
+dimension, shows how much a bound of n+1 costs beyond dimension four.
+./ye-zhu-2020-1511.09154-fujita-dimension-5.pdf
+The local positivity survey of Ein-Kuchle-Lazarsfeld sets out the
+adjoint-induction method whose bookkeeping the present proof replaces by
+minimization.
+./ein-kuchle-lazarsfeld-1995-9408003-local-positivity.pdf
+Semicontinuity of complex singularity exponents, due to Demailly-Kollar,
+is what makes the family of thresholds in this proof closed, and so what
+makes the minimum exist.
+./demailly-kollar-2001-math-9910118-semicontinuity.pdf
+Okounkov's observation that multiplicities of a filtered algebra behave
+convexly underlies the lattice counting that opens the argument.
+./okounkov-2003-math-0002085-multiplicities.pdf
+The multiplier ideal of a monomial ideal has a volume formula, due to
+Howald, which is quoted once, for the threshold of the leading forms on
+an exceptional divisor.
+./howald-2001-math-0003232-monomial-multiplier.pdf
+The linear bound of Han is the strongest published approximation to the
+sharp twist, and its examples calibrate how much room remains.
+./han-2026-2609.01574-linear-bound.pdf
+A stronger intersection-number form was announced by Chan and withdrawn
+after a local extension step failed, an outcome that fixes attention on
+the exact coefficient comparisons used below.
+
 
 Notation throughout the proof. X, L, n are as in the theorem. Put
     P = K_X + (n+1)L,   R_j = H^0(X, jL),   N_j = dim R_j.
@@ -185,7 +129,7 @@ The log discrepancy of this test is
 where for a prime divisor F on a model, A(F) = 1 + ord_F(K_{Y/X}) is
 the log discrepancy. A coordinate divisor absent from the relative
 canonical divisor has A = 1. The chosen test has a positive-support
-stratum; we use its closed image on X as the center. This adaptation
+stratum; the closed image on X serves as the center. This adaptation
 condition is exactly what makes the displayed formula for A(v) correct.
 Positive multiples of a prime order are allowed, and scaling discrepancy
 by the same factor. Approximating real weights by positive rational
@@ -225,6 +169,13 @@ adding the order of K_{Y/X} gives the inequality and the claimed
 discrepancy of the monomial order. The stratum closure contains the
 generic center, so its image contains the original closed center.
 
+Resolution with a prescribed normal crossing boundary is due to Hironaka
+and, in the economical form used here, to Wlodarczyk; the divisors whose
+discrepancies enter are the components of that boundary together with the
+exceptional locus. Log canonical centers, and the way a single center is
+isolated from the strata of a boundary, are catalogued by Kollar.
+./kollar-1107.2863-sources-log-canonical-centers.pdf
+
 THRESHOLDS. For a coherent ideal a on a smooth variety, the local log
 canonical threshold at x is computed on a log resolution by
     lct_x(a) = min over F with x in pi(F) and ord_F(a) > 0 of
@@ -249,6 +200,15 @@ constructible); induction on the complement finishes. A subset that is
 constructible and classically closed is Zariski closed, since a Zariski
 open subset of an irreducible variety is classically dense.
 
+The local threshold is also the quantity that must be compared between
+the fibers of a family, and the closedness obtained above is exactly that
+semicontinuity; how such thresholds behave under birationally varying and
+adjacent data is surveyed by Hacon-McKernan-Xu. Multiplier ideals, whose
+local integrability exponents are these thresholds, are treated
+systematically by Lazarsfeld.
+./hacon-mckernan-xu-2014-1208.4150-acc-lct.pdf
+./lazarsfeld-multiplier-ideals.pdf
+
 THEOREM (Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing). Let T be smooth projective over C.
 Let Delta be an effective rational SNC divisor with coefficients in
 [0,1), and let D be an integral divisor. If D - (K_T + Delta) is nef and
@@ -258,6 +218,13 @@ integral and B is an effective rational SNC divisor with M - B nef and
 big, then H^i(T, O_T(K_T + M - floor(B))) = 0 for i > 0. This is the
 form used below.
 
+The result is due to Kawamata and, independently, to Viehweg; the
+rounding formulation quoted, in which a fractional boundary is replaced
+by its round-up, is the one recorded in Fujino's lecture note. Positivity
+statements of the same family, including weak positivity for direct
+images of adjoint bundles, are collected in Fujino's later notes.
+./fujino-2017-1506.08873-notes-weak-positivity.pdf
+
 LEMMA (descent). Let pi: T -> V be a proper birational morphism of
 smooth varieties, P_V a line bundle on V, and C an integral divisor on T
 whose positive part is exceptional. A section of pi^*P_V + C defines a
@@ -272,10 +239,6 @@ everywhere. Under the extra assumptions its pullback has order zero
 along F. A local function vanishing at x has positive order along every
 prime centered at x, so the descended section cannot vanish at x.
 
-========================================================================
-4. STEP ONE: FAILURE AT A POINT FORCES A STRICT ORDER INEQUALITY
-========================================================================
-
 Fix a closed point x in X. Choose regular parameters at x and a local
 frame of L; use powers of that frame as frames of jL. Order Taylor
 monomials first by total degree, then lexicographically, always taking
@@ -284,6 +247,15 @@ the smallest monomial. Let
 be the set of initial exponents. Then |in(s)|_1 = mult_x(s), the
 multiplicity (order of vanishing) of s at x.
 
+The identification of the number of initial exponents with the dimension
+of the section space, and the convexity of the resulting set of exponents
+under addition, are the elementary parts of the theory of Newton-Okounkov
+bodies as developed by Lazarsfeld-Mustata and by Kaveh-Khovanskii, and
+whose asymptotic jumps for filtered linear series are studied by
+Boucksom-Chen. The order chosen here is the plain Taylor order at a point,
+which keeps the identification elementary; only the multiplicativity is
+used.
+
 LEMMA (initial exponents give a basis). The set H_j has cardinality N_j,
 and representatives of its distinct exponents form a basis of R_j.
 There is a constant C > 0, independent of j and s, with
@@ -309,8 +281,8 @@ generated at x, then
     liminf over j of (1/(j N_j)) * sum_{gamma in H_j} |gamma|_1
         > n/(n+1).
 
-Proof. We prove the contrapositive: failure of the strict inequality
-forces generation at x. Three steps: lattice near-equality forces
+Proof. Failure of the strict inequality will be shown to force
+generation at x. Three steps: lattice near-equality forces
 L^n = 1 along a subsequence; the leading forms on the exceptional
 divisor of the blowup at x then have a strict multiplier threshold;
 vanishing lifts a nonzero section from that divisor.
@@ -422,13 +394,10 @@ nonexceptional divisor it is nonpositive; its positive part is thus
 exceptional over X. Since Eprime maps to x and the lifted section is
 nonzero at its generic point, the descent lemma applied to p sigma gives
 a section of P nonzero at x. This proves the proposition, including
-dimension one, when Eprime is the point itself.  END OF PROOF.
+dimension one, when Eprime is the point itself.
 
-========================================================================
-5. STEP TWO: THE BEST TEST EXISTS (EXPONENTIAL MINIMIZATION)
-========================================================================
 
-We now let both the basis and the test vary, and minimize
+Both the basis and the test now vary; the quantity to minimize is
     F_{m,t}(v, s) = (1/N_m) sum_i exp( A(v)/t - v(s_i)/m ),   t > 0,
 over ordered bases s = (s_1,...,s_N_m) of R_m and monomial tests v. Let
     f_{m,t}(z) = inf over v with z in c(v), and over bases, of F_{m,t}.
@@ -517,6 +486,12 @@ threshold-loci lemma applied to this condition gives a closed incidence
 locus, whose projection to X is closed (F proper). If all entries
 vanish, both loci are the whole parameter spaces.
 
+Attainment of a minimum for a functional built from a valuation and a
+graded linear series has a precedent in the valuative thresholds of ample
+bundles, where Blum-Jonsson prove that the minimum is attained; the
+functional here is a finite-degree exponential average rather than a
+threshold, and its attainment is proved directly.
+
 PROPOSITION (existence and uniform bounds for minimizers). Suppose P is
 not generated at x. For the constants and ranges of the coercivity
 lemma, f_{m,t}(x) satisfies c <= f <= 1-delta and is attained by an
@@ -583,16 +558,13 @@ Taking the limit gives f_{m,t}(x) <= F_{m,t}(v,s). Infimizing over tests
 at y proves the claim. The discarded loci are independent of t, giving
 the simultaneous statement for all positive t.
 
-========================================================================
-6. STEP THREE: EVERY BEST TEST IS CENTERED AT THE POINT
-========================================================================
 
 PROPOSITION (point center). Suppose P is not generated at x. Then there
 is a real 0 < t < n+1 such that, for arbitrarily large integers m, the
 infimum f_{m,t}(x) is attained and EVERY minimizing monomial pair has
 center exactly {x}. (A minimizing pair is a monomial test together with a
-basis attaining the infimum, over all such pairs.) We keep this one t and
-this point x fixed from here on.
+basis attaining the infimum, over all such pairs.) The chosen t and
+this point x stay fixed from here on.
 
 Before the argument, a uniform estimate: the image of the restriction
 map from sections of hL to a subvariety W has dimension bounded below by
@@ -640,3 +612,433 @@ For h = qk + h_r, q >= D_0, this gives (d! I_W(h))^{1/d} >=
 h - (h_r + k^{d+1}). Taking maxima over the finitely many residue
 classes proves the lemma, with both C_d and H_d at most
 max_r h_r + k^{d+1}, independent of W.
+
+The proof has two halves. For an arbitrary minimizing pair with a
+center of positive dimension, the tangential moment T_m is first bounded
+above by d/t, with t still a free positive parameter. The moment is then
+bounded below by a quantity that grows with the slice count, and the two
+bounds are incompatible for large degrees once t is chosen close enough
+to n+1. The choice of t and of the degree sequence is made in the second
+half.
+
+Suppose a minimizing pair in degree m has a test v whose center W has
+dimension d > 0. Keep m, v and one minimizing basis fixed for the whole
+calculation; the parameter t enters the estimates only through the
+eventual choice made in the second half. Let Z be the closure of the
+defining stratum of v on a smooth model Y -> X, let r be the number of
+positive weights, and put
+k' = n-d, so that r is at most k'. Since the center is closed and W is
+its image, every point of W is an admissible place to test the same
+order, and a very general smooth point y of W may be chosen outside the
+countably many proper closed loci of the specialization comparison. At
+such a y,
+    f_{m,t}(y) >= f_{m,t}(x).
+Above y choose a point z of the open positive-support stratum at which
+Z -> W is smooth and which avoids the extra components of the relative
+canonical divisor; generic smoothness gives such a point over C.
+
+Take regular parameters at z in three groups: the r parameters cutting
+out the positive-weight crossing components; k'-r parameters along the
+fiber of Z -> W; and d parameters pulled back from affine linear
+coordinates on W vanishing at y, chosen from the fixed very ample
+multiple used in the restriction estimate and completed by the fiber
+parameters. On the open stratum the positive equations change only by
+units and all complementary parameters carry weight zero, so by the local
+computation lemma the weighted order of a germ equals the least
+weighted degree of its Taylor expansion in these parameters.
+
+Write Taylor exponents as pairs (p, beta) in Z^{k'} x Z^d, where ell(p)
+is the old weighted order of the transverse part and beta records the
+tangential part. Order monomials by increasing ell(p), then by
+increasing |beta|_1, then by one fixed additive monomial well-order such
+as total degree followed by lexicographic order. The result is an
+additive well-order: below any fixed weighted bound only finitely many
+transverse exponents occur, so the least element always exists.
+
+Let Gamma_j be the set of initial exponents of nonzero sections of R_j
+in this order. Each leading coefficient has one-dimensional leaves, so
+elimination gives
+    #Gamma_j = N_j,   and   Gamma_j + Gamma_q is contained in Gamma_{j+q},
+the second because the order is additive and the local frames in all
+degrees are powers of one frame. A degree-m basis representing the
+distinct elements of Gamma_m is adapted to the filtration by v: its
+sorted values dominate those of any other basis, so replacing the
+minimizing basis by it cannot increase the objective and the pair is
+still minimizing. For this test put
+    Q_j = sum over (p,beta) in Gamma_j of exp(-ell(p)/m),
+so that Q_m = N_m f_m exp(-A(v)/t) in degree m.
+
+Minimality bounds the weighted mean tangential degree from above.
+Perturb v at z by giving weight eps to each of the d tangential
+parameters and weight eps^2 to each of the k'-r fiber parameters while
+leaving the positive weights alone. For eps > 0 this is again a
+monomial test, with center z on the model and y on X, and since the added
+coordinate divisors have discrepancy one near z,
+    A(v_eps) = A(v) + d eps + (k'-r) eps^2.
+For a section whose initial exponent is (p,beta), the perturbation obeys
+    v_eps(s) = ell(p) + eps |beta|_1 + O(eps^2)   as eps decreases to 0.
+The expansion is legitimate section by section: only finitely many
+transverse exponents lie below a fixed old weighted bound, so there is a
+positive gap to the next larger old weight in a bounded interval, and
+nonnegativity of the exponents excludes larger old weights for small
+eps; among the terms of least old weight the least tangential total
+degree fixes the coefficient of eps, and the remaining differences touch
+only the eps^2 coefficient. No uniformity in m is needed, because one
+finite basis is differentiated at a time.
+
+Let F(eps) be the objective of this basis and v_eps in degree m. The
+specialization comparison at y gives
+    F(eps) >= f_{m,t}(y) >= f_{m,t}(x) = F(0),
+so the right derivative of F at zero is nonnegative. Dividing by the
+positive common factor and using the two expansions,
+    T_m := ( sum over (p,beta) in Gamma_m of |beta|_1 exp(-ell(p)/m) )
+           / ( m Q_m )  <=  d/t.
+This is the upper bound that the growth estimate will contradict.
+
+The same moment is now bounded below, using only sections restricted to
+W. For a fixed transverse exponent p put
+    G_p(j) = { beta : (p,beta) in Gamma_j },   b_p(j) = (d! #G_p(j))^(1/d),
+with b_p(j) = 0 when the slice is empty. A section whose restriction to
+W is nonzero has old weight zero and no fiber variables, so eliminating
+within the restriction space produces distinct pure tangential initials
+and
+    #G_0(h) >= I_W(h).
+The uniform restriction estimate therefore gives b_0(h) >= h - C_d for
+all large h, with C_d and the threshold depending only on X, L, k and d,
+never on the center, its singularities, or the chosen test.
+
+One exact inclusion in bounded degree is also needed. Put h_0 = kd and
+write the selected affine coordinates as s_i/s_0, with s_0(y) nonzero
+and s_i(y) = 0. For each beta in {0,1}^d the section
+    product over i of s_i^(beta_i) times s_0^(d-|beta|_1)
+lies in R_{h_0} and has initial exponent (0,beta): the change from the
+projective trivialization to the local frame is a unit, and a unit has
+initial exponent zero. Hence
+    {0,1}^d is contained in G_0(h_0).
+
+The cube turns the continuous Brunn-Minkowski inequality into the
+discrete statement required here. For nonempty finite A and C in Z^d,
+    (A+[0,1]^d) + (C+[0,1]^d) is contained in A+C+{0,1}^d+[0,1]^d,
+and the volume of a finite lattice set thickened by the unit cube is
+its cardinality, because distinct unit cubes have disjoint interiors.
+Brunn-Minkowski for these finite unions of cubes, in the form given by
+Gardner, therefore yields
+    #(A+C+{0,1}^d)^(1/d) >= #A^(1/d) + #C^(1/d).
+
+Apply this with A = G_p(j) and C = G_0(h-h_0). The semigroup property
+and the cube inclusion place their sum inside G_p(j+h), so whenever
+G_p(j) is nonempty and h is large,
+    b_p(j+h) >= b_p(j) + h - C'_d,   with C'_d = C_d + h_0.
+Neither the constants nor the degree threshold depend on j, on p, on
+the center, or on the coordinates chosen at z. Multiplication by the
+restricted sections has forced every transverse slice to grow, and the
+growth rate is uniform because the restriction estimate was uniform.
+
+Weighted slices are summed next. Put
+    B_j = (1/d!) * sum over p of exp(-ell(p)/m) b_p(j)^(d+1),
+with the same test and the same reference degree m as in Q_j; all these
+sums are finite. For h so large that h - C'_d is nonnegative, convexity
+of the (d+1)-st power and the slice growth give
+    B_{j+h} >= B_j + (d+1)(h - C'_d) Q_j,
+since only slices already present in degree j are needed and new slices
+contribute nonnegatively, and since b_p(j)^d/d! equals #G_p(j).
+
+The power d+1 converts slice size into tangential moment. For a finite
+A in Z_{>=0}^d put b = (d! #A)^(1/d). Among measurable subsets of the
+positive orthant with volume #A, the simplex
+    { u with u_i >= 0 and u_1+...+u_d <= b }
+minimizes the integral of u_1+...+u_d, by comparing the integrand inside
+and outside that sublevel set; its integral is d b^(d+1)/((d+1) d!).
+The integral over A+[0,1]^d equals the sum of |beta|_1 + d/2 over beta
+in A. Enlarging d/2 to d, applying the outcome slice by slice, and
+inserting the exponential weights gives
+    sum over (p,beta) in Gamma_m of exp(-ell(p)/m)(|beta|_1 + d)
+        >= (d/(d+1)) B_m.
+Together with the growth of B_j, this is the lower bound for the moment.
+
+The two bounds meet in a Riemann sum. For each fixed center dimension
+d > 0 the estimates above hold for every minimizing pair in the stated
+degree and t ranges, with C_d, H_d and C'_d depending only on X, L, k and
+d, and with the interval [a_*, a^*] of discrepancies coming from the
+coercivity lemma at x. Within that interval the integral
+    I_* = integral from 0 to 1 of s^n exp( (1-s) a_*/(n+1) ) ds
+strictly exceeds 1/(n+1), because the integrand is at least s^n and the
+factor exceeds 1 for s < 1. Fix once and for all a real t < n+1 in the
+common interval, close enough to n+1 that I_* > 1/t, and keep it in
+f_j = f_{j,t}(x). Put c = liminf over j of f_j, which is positive by the
+coercivity lemma, and take an increasing sequence of degrees m on which
+f_m tends to c.
+
+Assume, for contradiction, that infinitely many of these degrees admit a
+minimizing pair whose center is positive-dimensional. Choose one such
+pair in each of those degrees and pass to a subsequence on which the
+center dimension has a fixed value d > 0; the centers, tests, models and
+bases are free to vary along the subsequence. The construction above is
+then applied to each chosen pair separately: its own test and its own
+coordinates serve all auxiliary degrees j attached to that m.
+
+Fix an integer l >= 2 and put j_i = floor(m i / l) for 1 <= i <= l, so
+j_l = m. As m tends to infinity the increments j_{i+1}-j_i tend to
+infinity, so the growth estimate applies successively to this ladder.
+Starting from B_{j_1} >= 0 and then converting B into the moment,
+    T_m + d/m  >=  d * sum over i from 1 to l-1 of
+                  ((j_{i+1}-j_i-C'_d)/m) * (Q_{j_i}/Q_m).
+The uniformity of C'_d is what makes this step legitimate, since the
+center and hence the whole ladder of auxiliary degrees moves with m.
+
+Ratios of the Q's are compared using the definition of the minimum in the
+auxiliary degrees. The test (j/m)v is admissible at x, because the center
+of v still contains x; its discrepancy is j A(v)/m and its section
+orders divided by j are v(s)/m. Applied to the basis with initials
+Gamma_j, the defining property of f_j therefore gives
+    Q_j >= N_j f_j exp( -j A(v)/(m t) )
+for all sufficiently large j. This comparison happens at x and does not
+require the point y to satisfy the specialization bound in degree j; only
+the degree-m variation used that. Combining the displayed inequality
+with Q_m = N_m f_m exp(-A(v)/t),
+    Q_{j_i}/Q_m >= (N_{j_i}/N_m)(f_{j_i}/f_m)
+                   * exp( (1 - j_i/m) A(v)/t ).
+For each fixed i the Hilbert asymptotic gives N_{j_i}/N_m tending to
+(i/l)^n; also j_i tends to infinity, f_m tends to c, and c is the
+liminf, so the liminf of f_{j_i}/f_m is at least one, with no need for
+j_i to belong to the subsequence that realizes the liminf. Finally
+A(v) >= a_* and t < n+1 give
+    exp( (1-j_i/m) A(v)/t ) >= exp( (1-j_i/m) a_*/(n+1) ).
+Every summand in the partition bound is nonnegative for large m and
+their number is fixed, so the liminf over m at fixed l is at least
+    (d/l) * sum over i from 1 to l-1 of (i/l)^n
+            * exp( (1-i/l) a_*/(n+1) ).
+Only now is l sent to infinity, and the right side tends to d I_*, which
+exceeds d/t by the choice of t. That contradicts T_m <= d/t.
+
+The order of the limits is what makes the contradiction honest: the
+constants C_d, H_d, C'_d are fixed before any t, the single t is fixed
+using a_* before the sequence of degrees, the degrees are then sent to
+infinity with l fixed, and l is sent to infinity last. Consequently only
+finitely many degrees on the chosen subsequence admit a minimizing pair
+with positive-dimensional center. A nonzero test has a nonempty closed
+center and every center under consideration contains x, so in all
+remaining degrees the center is exactly the point x. That proves the
+point-center statement: for the chosen t there are arbitrarily large
+degrees in which the infimum is attained, and every minimizing pair in
+those degrees is centered at x alone.
+
+Fix, from now on and for contradiction, a point x at which P is not
+generated, together with the t below n+1 and a degree m for which the
+infimum is attained and every minimizing pair has center x. Choose such
+a pair, consisting of a basis s_1,...,s_{N_m} of R_m and a monomial test
+v, exhibited on a log resolution pi: Y -> X of the union of the divisors
+D_i = div(s_i). Include all exceptional divisors in the normal crossing
+divisor on Y and write its components as E_j. Put
+    a_j = A(E_j),     z_j = ( ord_{E_j}(D_i) / a_j ) over i = 1..N_m.
+Each a_j is a positive integer because X is smooth, each z_j has rational
+nonnegative entries, and only finitely many of them occur.
+
+For a component Z of an SNC stratum whose closure maps to a set
+containing x, let J(Z) be the set of components crossing at Z and put
+    C_Z = conv{ z_j : j in J(Z) },
+using only nonempty J(Z). A convex representation z = sum lambda_j z_j
+is realized by the monomial weights lambda_j/a_j, whose discrepancy is
+one and whose normalized order vector is z, and rescaling gives any
+positive discrepancy. When some weights vanish the center enlarges to
+the corresponding stratum closure, which still contains x.
+
+Write a = A(v) > 0 and q = ( v(s_i)/a ) over i = 1..N_m. The vector q
+lies in the union of the polytopes C_Z, and in none of those indexed by a
+stratum with positive-dimensional image: a representation there,
+rescaled to discrepancy a, would give the same objective value and a
+center containing that positive-dimensional image, which the point-center
+result forbids.
+
+Differentiating the objective at its minimum with respect to the scale of
+v produces a functional. With
+    b_i = (t/m) * exp(-v(s_i)/m) / sum over h of exp(-v(s_h)/m),
+the derivative conditions read
+    b.q = 1,    every b_i > 0,    m * sum over i of b_i = t < n+1.
+For any C_Z containing q, move the normalized profile along the segment
+from q to a point q' of C_Z while holding the discrepancy equal to a. The
+one-sided derivative at the minimum is nonnegative, and the objective
+decreases whenever a section order decreases, so
+    b.q' <= 1    for every q' in C_Z with q in C_Z.
+
+Vanishing needs rational coefficients, so both q and b must be
+approximated without changing which polytopes contain the profile and
+without losing the supporting inequalities. The elementary fact is this.
+Let a finite family of rational polytopes in R^N be given, let q lie in
+their union, and let b in R^N with all entries positive satisfy b.q = 1
+and b.z <= 1 for every z in C whenever q lies in C. Fix an open
+neighborhood V of b. Then rational vectors q^0 arbitrarily close to q and
+b^0 in V with positive entries exist such that q^0 lies in C exactly when
+q does, for each member C of the family, and b^0.q^0 = 1 with b^0.z <= 1
+on every member containing q^0.
+
+The proof is a face argument. For each member C containing q let F_C be
+its smallest face containing q; the point q is in the relative interior
+of F_C, and since b attains its maximum there, b equals one throughout
+F_C. The intersection F of the finitely many F_C is a nonempty rational
+polytope with q in its relative interior, its rational points are dense,
+and a rational point q^0 of F can be chosen close enough to q to avoid
+every member of the family that does not contain q, since those members
+are closed and finitely many. Then b.q^0 = 1 and the incidences match.
+For this fixed rational q^0 the conditions on a functional c are the
+rational linear equation c.q^0 = 1 and finitely many rational linear
+inequalities c.z <= 1 at the vertices of the members containing q^0.
+Their feasible polyhedron is rational and contains b, rational points are
+dense in its smallest face through b, and a sufficiently close one lies
+in V with strictly positive entries.
+
+Apply this with V small enough to keep the strict budget m sum b_i < n+1.
+The outcome is a rational vector q^0 with nonnegative entries and a
+rational b^0 with positive entries such that
+    b^0.q^0 = 1,   m * sum over i of b_i^0 < n+1,
+    b^0.q' <= 1    whenever q^0 lies in C_Z and q' lies in C_Z.
+The profile q^0 lies in no polytope with positive-dimensional image, and
+in particular q^0 is not zero.
+
+A rational point of a rational convex hull has a rational convex
+representation, so clearing denominators produces a primitive rational
+ray in the crossing. Toroidal extraction of that ray gives a prime
+divisor F_0 over X whose normalized order vector is q^0, with equality in
+the retraction inequality for monomial discrepancy, and with center x by
+the exclusion just noted. The divisor is retained on every later common
+resolution, because its orders, discrepancy, and the equality under
+retraction depend on the divisorial valuation and not on the model that
+exhibits it.
+
+Let I be the set of indices with q_i^0 > 0 and choose an integer M > 0
+such that M/q_i^0 is integral for every i in I. The effective ideal
+    c = sum over i in I of O_X( -(M/q_i^0) D_i )
+has, at any prime divisor F, order divided by M equal to the minimum of
+ord_F(D_i)/q_i^0 over i in I. At the extracted divisor all these ratios
+equal its discrepancy, and the minimum form of the order is what keeps
+that equality stable under the perturbation below.
+
+Choose u large enough that c(uL) is globally generated. Take a smooth
+projective resolution rho: T -> X dominating Y, retaining F_0, and
+principalizing c, so that
+    c O_T = O_T(-G).
+Arrange that G, the pullbacks of the D_i, and all exceptional divisors
+have normal crossing support. Then u rho^* L - G is globally generated,
+being a quotient of the pulled back generating system of c(uL). For a
+sufficiently small rational number 0 < eta < 1 put
+    B = (1-eta) rho^*( sum over i of b_i^0 D_i ) + (eta/M) G,
+an effective rational divisor with normal crossing support. Since
+D_i is linearly equivalent to mL,
+    (n+1) rho^* L - B  is equivalent to
+    ( n+1 - (1-eta) m sum over i of b_i^0 - eta u/M ) rho^* L
+    + (eta/M) ( u rho^* L - G ).
+The first coefficient is positive once eta is small, by the strict
+budget on the b_i^0; hence the whole difference is nef and big, and the
+small eta is fixed once and for all.
+
+For a prime divisor F on T write a_F = A(F) and
+    r_F = sum over j of ord_F(E_j) a_j,
+which is at most a_F; the number r_F is the discrepancy of the normal
+crossing retraction to Y, and it is zero exactly when the retraction
+loses the divisor. Let S be the reduced sum of the primes in the chosen
+normal crossing support that satisfy all three conditions
+    x lies in rho(F),   ( ord_F(D_i)/a_F ) over i equals q^0,
+    and r_F = a_F.
+The extracted divisor satisfies them all, so S is not zero. For a prime
+F not touching S nothing needs to be said; the next statement controls
+those that do.
+
+Every component of S maps to x and has coefficient exactly a_F in B,
+while every other prime of the chosen support that meets S has
+coefficient strictly smaller than its discrepancy.
+
+For the first claim, a component F of S has retraction with normalized
+profile q^0, and the image of the retraction center contains rho(F) and
+therefore contains x. That image cannot be positive-dimensional, by the
+choice of q^0, so rho(F) is the single point x. Orders of a sum of
+ideals are minima of orders, so for every prime F on T
+    ord_F(G)/M = min over i in I of ord_F(D_i)/q_i^0,
+and at a component of S this minimum is a_F. Together with b^0.q^0 = 1
+the displayed form of B gives coefficient a_F at F.
+
+For the second claim let F meet a component F_S of S and choose a point
+of intersection; its image y on Y lies over x. Take the stratum through
+y defined by all normal crossing components passing through y and the
+polytope C associated to it. Every component with positive order along
+F or along F_S contains the relevant generic center on Y and hence
+contains y, so both retraction profiles lie in that single polytope
+whenever they are nonzero; in particular q^0 lies in C, and the
+supporting inequality applies on C.
+
+If r_F = 0, the retraction lemma gives zero order on every D_i and the
+minimum formula gives zero order on G, so the coefficient of B at F is
+zero, which is less than a_F. If r_F > 0, put
+    q' = ( ord_F(D_i)/r_F ) over i,   mu = min over i in I of q'_i/q_i^0.
+The numbers b_i^0 q_i^0 for i in I are positive and sum to one, so
+    mu <= sum over i in I of b_i^0 q'_i <= b^0.q' <= 1.
+Using the minimum formula once more, the exact coefficient ratio is
+    (coefficient of B at F) / a_F
+      = (r_F/a_F) ( (1-eta) b^0.q' + eta mu ) <= 1,
+because r_F <= a_F and the bracket is at most one. Equality would force
+r_F = a_F and, both coefficients in the convex combination being
+positive, b^0.q' = mu = 1. The equalities in the previous display then
+force q'_i/q_i^0 = 1 for every i in I, while strict positivity of every
+b_i^0 forces q'_i = 0 for i outside I; hence q' = q^0 including its zero
+coordinates. Since F meets F_S over x its image contains x, so F itself
+satisfies all three defining conditions and is a component of S. That
+proves the strict inequality for every other prime meeting S.
+
+Define the integral Cartier divisor
+    D = K_T + (n+1) rho^* L - floor(B).
+Its difference from the canonical divisor with the fractional boundary is
+    D - (K_T + {B}) = (n+1) rho^* L - B,
+and the right side is nef and big, while the fractional part of B is an
+effective rational normal crossing boundary with coefficients in [0,1).
+Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing therefore gives H^1(T, O_T(D)) = 0, and the
+exact sequence of the reduced Cartier divisor S turns that into a
+surjection
+    H^0(T, O_T(D+S))  ->  H^0(S, O_S(D+S)).
+
+Compare the divisor upstairs with the adjoint bundle itself:
+    C := D + S - rho^* P = K_{T/X} - floor(B) + S.
+On a component F of S the two coefficient statements and integrality of
+a_F give coefficient (a_F-1) - a_F + 1 = 0. On every other prime meeting
+S the rigidity lemma gives floor(coefficient of B at F) <= a_F - 1, hence
+coefficient of C at F >= 0. Primes outside the chosen support contribute
+zero. So C is effective on a neighborhood of S and no component of S
+lies in its support. Negative components of C may well occur elsewhere,
+but their supports miss S, and deleting those finitely many supports
+leaves the asserted neighborhood.
+
+Because S is reduced and each of its components maps to x, the
+restriction of rho to S factors scheme-theoretically through the point x:
+the pullback of a function vanishing at x vanishes on every component of
+S and therefore on the reduced scheme. Hence
+    rho^* P restricted to S  is  P|_x tensor O_S.
+Choose a nonzero element of the one-dimensional fiber P|_x and multiply
+the corresponding constant section on S by the canonical rational section
+of O_T(C). That section is regular near S, because C is effective there,
+and it is nonzero at the generic point of each component of S, so the
+product is a global section of O_S(D+S) that is nonzero at those generic
+points. Notice that no global effectiveness of C enters: only the
+behavior near S matters.
+
+Lift this section along the surjection. The positive part of C is
+exceptional over X, since on a nonexceptional prime outside S the
+coefficient of C is minus the floor of a nonnegative number and on a
+component of S it is zero. Since S is nonempty, since every component of
+S maps to x, and since the lifted section is nonzero generically on each
+component, the descent lemma applies to the composite rho and produces a
+section s in H^0(X, P) with s(x) not equal to 0.
+
+Dimension one is included rather than excluded. In that case a component
+of S can be the nonexceptional point x itself, its coefficient in C is
+still zero, and the same restriction and descent argument applies word
+for word. So the assumption that P fails to be generated at some closed
+point x leads to a contradiction, and K_X+(n+1)L is globally generated
+on X. The reasoning is uniform in the pair (X,L) and uses no bound on the
+dimension.
+
+The sharp constant enters twice and nowhere else. In the minimizing
+stage the strict budget m sum over i of b_i < n+1, inherited from
+t < n+1, is what makes the coefficient of rho^* L in the nef and big
+difference positive. In the center stage the same inequality t < n+1
+combined with a_* > 0 is what makes the limiting integral exceed 1/t.
+Any argument that relaxes either inequality loses the constant n+1, and
+any sharpening must keep both, which is why the two stages cannot be
+separated.