diff b34550f..b1f9bc4 yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
diff --git a/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt b/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
index 6acb851..5d733a3 100644
--- a/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
+++ b/yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
@@ -576,7 +576,7 @@ finitely many coordinate cubes P_1, ..., P_J with pairwise
disjoint interiors, closure(P_j) contained in that
neighbourhood and in U, and cutoffs chi_j in C_c^infinity(P_j)
taking values in [0, 1], such that chi_j = 1 on an open core
-C_j \Subset P_j and
+C_j Subset P_j and
mu( union_j C_j ) >= (1/2) * mu(U) . (2.3)
@@ -596,11 +596,11 @@ argument; the other follows.
LEMMA 2.3 (Periodic averaging in a patch).
Let y = (y_1, y_2) : U -> R^2 be a smooth submersion on a
-neighborhood of a compact set K \subset U. Let E subset R^2 be
+neighborhood of a compact set K subset U. Let E subset R^2 be
periodic with respect to a full lattice (e.g. Z^2), have
boundary of two-dimensional measure zero in a period cell, and
occupy a fraction p of the cell in the usual sense.
-Given a compact set C \Subset U and a finite positive measure mu
+Given a compact set C Subset U and a finite positive measure mu
on U with smooth density, we have
lim_{N -> infinity} mu({ x in C : N y(x) in E }) = p mu(C). (2.4)
@@ -676,7 +676,7 @@ Let phi be a smooth real function on a neighbourhood of
closure(Omega), STRICT on closure(Omega) with nonvanishing
gradient there. Fix small constants 0 < eps_p <= 1/3 and
eps > 0. There is a smooth strict function psi
-supp(psi - phi) \Subset Omega, |psi - phi|_{C^0(Omega)} < eps,
+supp(psi - phi) Subset Omega, |psi - phi|_{C^0(Omega)} < eps,
|a_psi - a_phi|_{point} <= eps_p |a_phi| on closure(Omega),
whose FULL region U subset Omega satisfies
@@ -687,7 +687,7 @@ small.
PROOF.
Step 1: Local product structure. At any point p with a_phi(p)
-!= 0, choose a strict unit vector v_p \perp a_phi(p) in T_p M.
+!= 0, choose a strict unit vector v_p perp a_phi(p) in T_p M.
The strict inequality (2.1) at p gives a strict margin m_p > 0
for H_phi(a_phi, a_phi) + H_phi(v_p, v_p) restricted to a small
neighbourhood. A local flow-box construction gives a smooth
@@ -695,7 +695,7 @@ coordinate function s on a small neighbourhood of p with
ds(a_phi) = 0 and ds(v_p) = 0. (The intersection of the two
kernels is a line in T_p M; extend to a local first integral s
of a_phi that vanishes on that line.) On a small neighbourhood
-of p, the line a_phi^\perp \cap ker ds remains strict with a
+of p, the line a_phi^perp cap ker ds remains strict with a
positive margin, uniformly over a slightly smaller compact
neighbourhood.
@@ -729,8 +729,8 @@ O(N^{-1}). The Hessian correction lies entirely in the ds_j
direction: it vanishes on ker ds_j.
Step 3: Strictness survives. By (2.11), a unit vector v_N in
-the line a_{psi_N}^\perp \cap ker ds_j converges uniformly to
-the old strict line a_phi^\perp \cap ker ds_j. The leading
+the line a_{psi_N}^perp cap ker ds_j converges uniformly to
+the old strict line a_phi^perp cap ker ds_j. The leading
Hessian correction vanishes on v_N (because v_N is in ker ds_j),
and its value on a_{psi_N} is O(N^{-2}) because
ds_j(a_{psi_N}) = O(N^{-1}). The remainder of the Hessian is
@@ -740,28 +740,28 @@ phi (which does not occur on the patch by hypothesis a_phi != 0),
the argument is not applied.
Step 4: Fullness on a fraction of the patch. Consider the
-symmetric form on a_phi^\perp:
+symmetric form on a_phi^perp:
- B = (1 + |a_phi|^2) Hess phi|_{a_phi^\perp} + Hess
- phi (a_phi, a_phi) * Id|_{a_phi^\perp} . (2.12)
+ B = (1 + |a_phi|^2) Hess phi|_{a_phi^perp} + Hess
+ phi (a_phi, a_phi) * Id|_{a_phi^perp} . (2.12)
By strictness of phi, at least one of the two eigenvalues of B
-is > 0. Choose an orthonormal frame (v, w) of a_phi^\perp with
-ker ds_j \cap a_phi^\perp = span(v); then the (v,v) entry of B
+is > 0. Choose an orthonormal frame (v, w) of a_phi^perp with
+ker ds_j cap a_phi^perp = span(v); then the (v,v) entry of B
is B_vv >= m > 0 for some patch-data m > 0, and the (w,w) entry
satisfies B_ww >= -M for some finite M. All entries of B are
bounded on P_j.
-Add the leading correction C(1 + |a_phi|^2) |ds_j|^2 (w^\flat
- ⊗ w^\flat) to B. This is a positive semidefinite
+Add the leading correction C(1 + |a_phi|^2) |ds_j|^2 (w^flat
+ ⊗ w^flat) to B. This is a positive semidefinite
rank-one addition aligned with w. If |B_vw| <= M', it suffices
to make the (w,w) entry exceed (M')^2 / m + m; then by the
Schur complement criterion B becomes positive definite on the
-whole a_phi^\perp. Since |ds_j|^2 has a positive minimum on
+whole a_phi^perp. Since |ds_j|^2 has a positive minimum on
the patch, one finite C suffices (independent of N).
Where chi_j = 1 and h''(N s_j) > 1 (i.e. N s_j is in E_h), the
-actual leading addition to psi_N's Hessian at a_phi^\perp is >=
+actual leading addition to psi_N's Hessian at a_phi^perp is >=
the addition above, so fullness holds. By Lemma 2.3, the set
of such points in C_j has mass at least (p_h/2) of mu(C_j) for
sufficiently large N.
@@ -882,8 +882,8 @@ where E_N is a remainder whose magnitude is bounded by
|E_N| <= C_P ( (chi + |grad chi|) f' + N^{-1} ) . (2.20)
-Here a^\sharp means the metric-dual of a covector, so <a^\sharp,
-v> = a(v) for every tangent vector v; d_R^\sharp is the vector
+Here a^sharp means the metric-dual of a covector, so <a^sharp,
+v> = a(v) for every tangent vector v; d_R^sharp is the vector
field dual to the covector d_R. See derivation below.
The remainder (2.20) comes from three sources: the terms
@@ -893,7 +893,7 @@ and the term (delta A / N) F(Ny) Hess chi. Since
|(F_1, F_2)| = f' in the radial annulus (and 0 elsewhere), each
term is bounded by the displayed combination.
-Note: the gradient correction q d_R^\sharp is perpendicular
+Note: the gradient correction q d_R^sharp is perpendicular
to a_psi, because dy(a_psi) = 0 and d_R = <e_R, dy> so
d_R(a_psi) = <e_R, dy(a_psi)> = 0. This orthogonality is what
gives the clean amplification in Step 4.
@@ -914,7 +914,7 @@ We need to bound |d_T(b_N)| from below. Two facts:
(i) |d_T(b_N)| = |dy(b_N)| because d_T is the projection of
dy onto the e_T direction, and d_R(b_N) = 0 removes the
e_R component.
- (ii) |a_N - a_psi| = |q d_R^\sharp + e_N| = O_P(f' + N^{-1})
+ (ii) |a_N - a_psi| = |q d_R^sharp + e_N| = O_P(f' + N^{-1})
by (2.18a, 2.18c). And |a_psi| has a positive
minimum |a|_min on P. So the projection of b_N / L_N
onto the orthogonal complement of a_psi in T_x P is
@@ -1008,13 +1008,13 @@ Step 3 (gist): The two regimes cover all of P. Both are strict
with a positive margin, uniformly in the patch.
Step 4: Amplification of the gradient. In the leading
-gradient formula (2.18a), reuse that q d_R^\sharp is
+gradient formula (2.18a), reuse that q d_R^sharp is
perpendicular to a_psi. So
- |a_{Phi_N}|^2 = |a_psi|^2 + q^2 |d_R^\sharp|^2
+ |a_{Phi_N}|^2 = |a_psi|^2 + q^2 |d_R^sharp|^2
+ 2 <a_psi, e_N> + |e_N|^2 .
-Since |d_R^\sharp| >= 1/2 and <= 2, |q| <= delta A f', and
+Since |d_R^sharp| >= 1/2 and <= 2, |q| <= delta A f', and
A >= |a_psi| / 2, the corrugation adds to |a_{Phi_N}|^2 at least
q^2 / 4 in magnitude on the annulus set (chi = 1, N y in E_F).
So
@@ -1058,7 +1058,7 @@ Under the hypotheses of Lemma 2.5, fix a small positive
C^0-budget eps > 0 for the cycle. There is a smooth function
Phi = Phi_N (N sufficiently large) such that:
- supp(Phi - psi) \Subset P ,
+ supp(Phi - psi) Subset P ,
|Phi - psi|_{C^0(P)} < eps ,
Phi is strict with nonvanishing gradient on closure(P),
integral_P |a_Phi| dV_g >= (1 + eta) integral_P |a_psi| dV_g, (2.25)
@@ -1344,7 +1344,7 @@ For 1/sqrt(2) < r <= 1, h is increasing, so the maximum of h on
(1/sqrt(2), 1] is attained at r = 1. Compute h(1) = log t + 1 - t^2.
For t in [1/5, 3/10], log t <= log(3/10) < -1.20 and 1 - t^2 <= 0.96,
so h(1) <= -0.24 < 0. Hence h < 0 on (1/sqrt(2), 1], in fact on
-(t, 1]. This gives (d). []\n\n\nEND_OF_LEMMA_2_8\n\n\n\nWe can now amplify phi_0 to profiles with arbitrarily large\ngradient integral.\n\n\nPROPOSITION 2.10 (Spherical profiles). There is a C^2 neighborhood\nU of g_* on S^3, and a constant c_u > 0, with the following property.\nFix 1/5 <= t <= 3/10. For every g in U, every T > 0, and every\neps > 0, there is a smooth function phi on S^3 such that\n\n (i) supp(phi - phi_0) is compactly contained in Omega;\n (ii) ||phi - phi_0||_{C^0(S^3)} < eps;\n (iii) phi is strict on { 0 < r <= 3/10 } with a UNIFORM\n strictness margin >= c_u > 0;\n (iv) the critical set of phi on { r <= 3/10 } is exactly the\n circle { r = 0 }; at each critical point, Hess_g phi is\n positive semidefinite of rank at least two;\n (v) phi > log r on { 0 < r < t }, and phi < log r on\n { t < r <= 1 };\n (vi) integral_Omega |grad_g phi|_g dV_g > T.\n\nPROOF. Choose U small enough that each g in U satisfies all of:\n\n * phi_0 is strict on { 0 < r <= 3/10 } for the metric g, with\n margin >= c_u. (By continuity in the C^2 metric topology from\n Lemma 2.8(b), which gives margin >= 1.64 for g = g_*.)\n * On Omega, the round metric g_* and g are uniformly comparable:\n K^{-1} g_* <= g <= K g_* for a fixed K < infinity.\n * The coordinate functions x1, x2, r, rho on Omega remain smooth\n and bounded away from critical points of phi_0.\n\nFix g in U. Start with phi^(0) := phi_0. For k = 1, 2, 3, ...,\napply Proposition 2.6 (One amplification cycle) inside Omega. Each\niteration produces phi^(k) with:\n\n - supp(phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)) compactly contained in Omega;\n - ||phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)||_{C^0(Omega)} < eps / 2^k;\n - integral_Omega |grad_g phi^(k)|_g dV_g\n >= (1 + eta) integral_Omega |grad_g phi^(k-1)|_g dV_g,\n where eta = p_h p_F g_0 / 256 is the SAME at every step;\n - phi^(k) remains strict on the patch (with a margin that we\n shrink from c_u to c_u/2; see the note at the end).\n\nLet K := the smallest integer with (1+eta)^K integral_Omega |grad_g phi_0|_g dV_g > T\nand also K >= 1. Define phi := phi^(K).\n\nVerification.\n\n(i) Each supp(phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)) is compactly inside Omega, and Omega\nis compactly in S^3 \\ { r = 0 }, so the total support of phi - phi_0\nis compactly inside Omega.\n\n(ii) ||phi - phi_0||_{C^0} <= sum_{k=1}^K ||phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)||\n < sum_k eps / 2^k < eps.\n\n(iii) Iterated Proposition 2.6 preserves strictness with margin\n>= c_u/2 (we shrink the guaranteed margin inside the support of the\ncorrugation). Outside Omega, phi = phi_0 which is strict with\nmargin >= c_u by choice of U. So a uniform margin c_u/2 holds.\n\n(iv) Because Omega is disjoint from { r = 0 }, on { r = 0 } we have\nphi = phi_0. By Lemma 2.8(c), Hess_g phi = Hess_g phi_0 at r = 0 is\nPSD rank two. On { r <= 3/10 } \\ Omega, phi = phi_0 whose gradient\nvanishes only at r = 0. On Omega, Proposition 2.6 gives nonvanishing\ngradient. So the critical set of phi in { r <= 3/10 } is exactly\n{ r = 0 }.\n\n(v) Because supp(phi - phi_0) is inside Omega, which sits at\n1/20 < r < 1/8, we have phi = phi_0 on { 0 < r < 1/20 } and on\n{ 1/8 < r <= 1 }. By Lemma 2.8(d), phi_0 already satisfies (v) on\nthese regions. On the "gap" { 1/20 <= r <= 1/8 }, phi differs from\nphi_0. Shrink eps -- which is a free parameter -- so that eps is\nstrictly smaller than min( min_{1/20<=r<=1/8}(phi_0 - log r),\nmin_{1/20<=r<=1/8}(log r - phi_0) ). Both minima are positive by\nLemma 2.8(d). Then the C^0 bound ||phi - phi_0|| < eps preserves\nthe sign of phi - log r everywhere, so (v) continues to hold. If\nthe original eps was larger, just use the smaller value -- this only\nmakes (ii) easier.\n\n(vi) integral_Omega |grad_g phi|_g dV_g\n >= (1+eta)^K integral_Omega |grad_g phi_0|_g dV_g > T,\n by construction of K. In fact integral_Omega |grad_g phi_0|_g dV_g\n is bounded below by a fixed positive constant (Lemma 2.8(b) and\n K-invariance of the metrics), so K can be chosen finite.\n\n []\n\nNOTE. The strictness margin drops from c_u (for phi_0) to c_u/2\n(after corrugation). This is why we advertise c_u/2 as the working\nconstant in (iii). Downstream in Part 3 only a POSITIVE margin is\nneeded; no specific value of c_u enters the wave construction.\n\nEND OF SECTION 2.7 AND PART 2.\nP2END wc -l yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
+(t, 1]. This gives (d). []nnnEND_OF_LEMMA_2_8nnnnWe can now amplify phi_0 to profiles with arbitrarily largengradient integral.nnnPROPOSITION 2.10 (Spherical profiles). There is a C^2 neighborhoodnU of g_* on S^3, and a constant c_u > 0, with the following property.nFix 1/5 <= t <= 3/10. For every g in U, every T > 0, and everyneps > 0, there is a smooth function phi on S^3 such thatnn (i) supp(phi - phi_0) is compactly contained in Omega;n (ii) ||phi - phi_0||_{C^0(S^3)} < eps;n (iii) phi is strict on { 0 < r <= 3/10 } with a UNIFORMn strictness margin >= c_u > 0;n (iv) the critical set of phi on { r <= 3/10 } is exactly then circle { r = 0 }; at each critical point, Hess_g phi isn positive semidefinite of rank at least two;n (v) phi > log r on { 0 < r < t }, and phi < log r onn { t < r <= 1 };n (vi) integral_Omega |grad_g phi|_g dV_g > T.nnPROOF. Choose U small enough that each g in U satisfies all of:nn * phi_0 is strict on { 0 < r <= 3/10 } for the metric g, withn margin >= c_u. (By continuity in the C^2 metric topology fromn Lemma 2.8(b), which gives margin >= 1.64 for g = g_*.)n * On Omega, the round metric g_* and g are uniformly comparable:n K^{-1} g_* <= g <= K g_* for a fixed K < infinity.n * The coordinate functions x1, x2, r, rho on Omega remain smoothn and bounded away from critical points of phi_0.nnFix g in U. Start with phi^(0) := phi_0. For k = 1, 2, 3, ...,napply Proposition 2.6 (One amplification cycle) inside Omega. Eachniteration produces phi^(k) with:nn - supp(phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)) compactly contained in Omega;n - ||phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)||_{C^0(Omega)} < eps / 2^k;n - integral_Omega |grad_g phi^(k)|_g dV_gn >= (1 + eta) integral_Omega |grad_g phi^(k-1)|_g dV_g,n where eta = p_h p_F g_0 / 256 is the SAME at every step;n - phi^(k) remains strict on the patch (with a margin that wen shrink from c_u to c_u/2; see the note at the end).nnLet K := the smallest integer with (1+eta)^K integral_Omega |grad_g phi_0|_g dV_g > Tnand also K >= 1. Define phi := phi^(K).nnVerification.nn(i) Each supp(phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)) is compactly inside Omega, and Omeganis compactly in S^3 { r = 0 }, so the total support of phi - phi_0nis compactly inside Omega.nn(ii) ||phi - phi_0||_{C^0} <= sum_{k=1}^K ||phi^(k) - phi^(k-1)||n < sum_k eps / 2^k < eps.nn(iii) Iterated Proposition 2.6 preserves strictness with marginn>= c_u/2 (we shrink the guaranteed margin inside the support of thencorrugation). Outside Omega, phi = phi_0 which is strict withnmargin >= c_u by choice of U. So a uniform margin c_u/2 holds.nn(iv) Because Omega is disjoint from { r = 0 }, on { r = 0 } we havenphi = phi_0. By Lemma 2.8(c), Hess_g phi = Hess_g phi_0 at r = 0 isnPSD rank two. On { r <= 3/10 } Omega, phi = phi_0 whose gradientnvanishes only at r = 0. On Omega, Proposition 2.6 gives nonvanishingngradient. So the critical set of phi in { r <= 3/10 } is exactlyn{ r = 0 }.nn(v) Because supp(phi - phi_0) is inside Omega, which sits atn1/20 < r < 1/8, we have phi = phi_0 on { 0 < r < 1/20 } and onn{ 1/8 < r <= 1 }. By Lemma 2.8(d), phi_0 already satisfies (v) onnthese regions. On the "gap" { 1/20 <= r <= 1/8 }, phi differs fromnphi_0. Shrink eps -- which is a free parameter -- so that eps isnstrictly smaller than min( min_{1/20<=r<=1/8}(phi_0 - log r),nmin_{1/20<=r<=1/8}(log r - phi_0) ). Both minima are positive bynLemma 2.8(d). Then the C^0 bound ||phi - phi_0|| < eps preservesnthe sign of phi - log r everywhere, so (v) continues to hold. Ifnthe original eps was larger, just use the smaller value -- this onlynmakes (ii) easier.nn(vi) integral_Omega |grad_g phi|_g dV_gn >= (1+eta)^K integral_Omega |grad_g phi_0|_g dV_g > T,n by construction of K. In fact integral_Omega |grad_g phi_0|_g dV_gn is bounded below by a fixed positive constant (Lemma 2.8(b) andn K-invariance of the metrics), so K can be chosen finite.nn []nnNOTE. The strictness margin drops from c_u (for phi_0) to c_u/2n(after corrugation). This is why we advertise c_u/2 as the workingnconstant in (iii). Downstream in Part 3 only a POSITIVE margin isnneeded; no specific value of c_u enters the wave construction.nnEND OF SECTION 2.7 AND PART 2.nP2END wc -l yau_nodal_smooth_counterexamples_v2.txt
(t, 1]. This closes Lemma 2.8(d). []
@@ -1685,7 +1685,7 @@ derivatives of zeta in the shell rho/2 < |x - p| < rho.
Initial data for phases. Let z_0, z_1, z_2 be the three complex
vectors at p defined in (3.2) of the phase data section: z_ell =
a(p) + i b_ell where a = grad phi(p), b_0, b_1 are linearly
-independent vectors in a^\perp of length L(p) = sqrt(1 + |a(p)|^2),
+independent vectors in a^perp of length L(p) = sqrt(1 + |a(p)|^2),
and b_2 = b'_0 is the "shifted" phase imaginary part corresponding
to real part a(p) + delta * nu(p) with delta = n^{-1/2} and nu(p) a
unit vector with a(p) = |a(p)| * nu(p) at noncritical points and
@@ -1981,7 +1981,7 @@ is exponentially smaller than e^{n phi}; it therefore also contributes
(b) Two regimes for |J_n|. Define
E_n := { x in S^3 : r(x)^n > n^6 e^{n phi(x)} }, (3.4.9a)
- F_n := S^3 \ E_n = { x : r(x)^n <= n^6 e^{n phi(x)} }. (3.4.9b)
+ F_n := S^3 E_n = { x : r(x)^n <= n^6 e^{n phi(x)} }. (3.4.9b)
Regime E_n is where the background w_n alone already provides the
noncancellation bound (deterministic). Regime F_n is where the random
@@ -2085,7 +2085,7 @@ beta), the leading terms are:
C2 = (0, b_0(x) + O(n^{-1}))
C3 = (0, b_1(x) + O(n^{-1}))
C4 = (0, b_2(x) + O(n^{-1}))
- C5 = (1, df(x) + c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x(nu(x), \cdot) + O(n^{-1})).
+ C5 = (1, df(x) + c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x(nu(x), cdot) + O(n^{-1})).
Justifications: the (1, df + O(n^{-1})) form of C1 comes from
V_{p,0}(x) = 1 + O(n^{-1}) (Taylor at p, distance n^{-1}) and
@@ -2095,13 +2095,13 @@ form of C2, C3, C4 comes from V_{p,j}(x) = 1 + O(n^{-1}), with the
IMAGINARY part having zero value and derivative d Im Phi_{p,j} = b_j +
O(n^{-1}) (the imaginary part of the Taylor coefficients at p is b_j).
The shifted form C5 comes from the phase expansion of section 3.3
-around p': d Re Phi_{p',0}(x) = df(x) - c_{p',0} h_{p'}(x - p' , \cdot)
+around p': d Re Phi_{p',0}(x) = df(x) - c_{p',0} h_{p'}(x - p' , cdot)
+ O(|x - p'|^2). Since x = p' + (x - p') and x - p' = x - p -
(p' - p), with x - p = O(n^{-1}) and p' - p = n^{-1/2} nu(x) + O(n^{-1}):
d Re Phi_{p',0}(x) - df(x)
- = c_{p',0} h_x( p' - p , \cdot ) + O(|x - p'|^2) + O(|x - p'| * n^{-1})
- = c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x( nu(x) , \cdot ) + O(n^{-1}),
+ = c_{p',0} h_x( p' - p , cdot ) + O(|x - p'|^2) + O(|x - p'| * n^{-1})
+ = c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x( nu(x) , cdot ) + O(n^{-1}),
using p' - p = n^{-1/2} nu(x) + O(n^{-1}), |p' - p| ~ n^{-1/2},
|x - p'| = O(n^{-1/2}) (because x is at distance n^{-1} from p, and
@@ -2111,11 +2111,11 @@ p' is at distance n^{-1} from x + n^{-1/2} nu; so |x - p'| = O(n^{-1/2})
Determinant of a 4 by 4 subblock. Take the four columns
(C1, C2, C3, C5). Subtract C1 from C5:
- C5 - C1 = (0, c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x(nu, \cdot) + O(n^{-1})).
+ C5 - C1 = (0, c_{p',0} n^{-1/2} h_x(nu, cdot) + O(n^{-1})).
Multiply by n^{1/2}:
- n^{1/2} (C5 - C1) = (0, c_{p',0} h_x(nu(x), \cdot) + O(n^{-1/2})).
+ n^{1/2} (C5 - C1) = (0, c_{p',0} h_x(nu(x), cdot) + O(n^{-1/2})).
In a local orthonormal frame at x, consider the 4 x 4 determinant
@@ -2131,11 +2131,11 @@ term is the (1,1) cofactor times the value 1:
= c_{p',0} det[ b_0(x), b_1(x), nu(x) ] + O(n^{-1/2}).
Since nu(x) is a unit vector perpendicular to both b_0(x) and b_1(x),
-and b_0, b_1 are uniformly independent in nu^\perp with |b_j| = L >= 1
+and b_0, b_1 are uniformly independent in nu^perp with |b_j| = L >= 1
and |sin(angle between b_0, b_1)| >= eta > 0 from the phase data,
det[ b_0(x), b_1(x), nu(x) ] = |nu| * (b_0, b_1 restriction to
- nu^\perp determinant) in magnitude
+ nu^perp determinant) in magnitude
>= |nu| * |b_0| * |b_1| * eta
>= eta > 0.