diff 626fd2d..b34550f log_abundance_threefolds_poschar_v2.txt
diff --git a/log_abundance_threefolds_poschar_v2.txt b/log_abundance_threefolds_poschar_v2.txt
index b58be23..4a5627e 100644
--- a/log_abundance_threefolds_poschar_v2.txt
+++ b/log_abundance_threefolds_poschar_v2.txt
@@ -1,46 +1,46 @@
-\documentclass[11pt]{article}
-\usepackage[T1]{fontenc}
-\usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
-\usepackage{lmodern}
-\usepackage[a4paper,margin=28mm]{geometry}
-\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools,mathrsfs}
-\usepackage{booktabs,array,enumitem}
-\usepackage{tikz-cd}
-\usepackage{microtype,needspace}
-\usepackage{xcolor}
-\usepackage[colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue!45!black,citecolor=blue!45!black,urlcolor=blue!45!black,bookmarksnumbered=true,bookmarksdepth=2]{hyperref}
-\numberwithin{equation}{section}
-\newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section]
-\newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma}
-\newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition}
-\newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary}
-\theoremstyle{definition}
-\newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition}
-\theoremstyle{remark}
-\newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark}
-\newcommand{\Q}{\mathbb Q}
-\newcommand{\Z}{\mathbb Z}
-\newcommand{\N}{\mathbb N}
-\newcommand{\cO}{\mathcal O}
-\newcommand{\cM}{\mathcal M}
-\newcommand{\C}{\mathbb C}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\Supp}{Supp}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\Pic}{Pic}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\ord}{ord}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\lct}{lct}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\Spec}{Spec}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\Div}{div}
-\setlist{nosep,topsep=4pt}
-\setlength{\emergencystretch}{1.5em}
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
\raggedbottom
-\title{Log abundance in numerical dimension one\\for threefolds in positive characteristic}
+# Log abundance in numerical dimension one\\for threefolds in positive characteristic
+
-\begin{document}
\maketitle
-\begin{abstract}
+Abstract:
Let $k$ be an algebraically closed field of characteristic $p>3$, and let
$(X,B)$ be a projective log canonical threefold pair over $k$ with
effective rational boundary $B$. If the log canonical divisor $K_X+B$ is
@@ -50,43 +50,43 @@ terminality nor $\Q$-factoriality is assumed for the original $X$. The technical
result of the companion paper: a certain kind of nef cycle cannot exist
on a smooth threefold. The contribution here is to build that cycle from
an arbitrary log canonical pair, controlling the boundary throughout.
-\end{abstract}
+
\tableofcontents
-\section*{Overview}
+# Overview
\addcontentsline{toc}{section}{Overview}
-This paper proves a case of the \emph{abundance conjecture} in algebraic
+This paper proves a case of the abundance conjecture in algebraic
geometry, in positive characteristic. The result is advanced, but the
shape of the argument can be described in ordinary language.
-\paragraph{The goal.}
-A \emph{threefold} is a space of dimension three; over the complex
+The goal.:
+A threefold is a space of dimension three; over the complex
numbers it looks locally like $\C^3$. To such a space and an effective
-\emph{boundary} divisor $B$ one associates the \emph{log canonical
-divisor} $K_X+B$, a bookkeeping object recording how differential forms
-twist. A divisor is \emph{nef} if it never meets a curve negatively;
+boundary divisor $B$ one associates the log canonical
+divisor $K_X+B$, a bookkeeping object recording how differential forms
+twist. A divisor is nef if it never meets a curve negatively;
think of it as a direction in which the space does not bend downward.
-We assume $K_X+B$ is nef and has \emph{numerical dimension} one. This
+We assume $K_X+B$ is nef and has numerical dimension one. This
means $K_X+B$ is positive in exactly one direction and numerically zero
in the other two.
Abundance predicts that some positive multiple of $K_X+B$ has enough
global sections to define a map to a curve. We prove exactly that: some
positive Cartier multiple of $K_X+B$ is globally generated, so $K_X+B$
-is \emph{semiample} and the associated map lands on a curve.
+is semiample and the associated map lands on a curve.
-\paragraph{Why this is hard.}
+Why this is hard.:
The hypothesis only says the divisor is not negative and is positive in
one direction. It does not by itself produce a single section upstairs.
-The proof must rule out a hidden bad case: \emph{maximal nef dimension}.
+The proof must rule out a hidden bad case: maximal nef dimension.
If that bad case occurred, the positive direction would be locally
invisible, so that no curve of degree zero would pass through a very
general point. The body of the paper derives a contradiction from this
assumption.
-\paragraph{The contradiction in one sentence.}
+The contradiction in one sentence.:
In the bad case one constructs a connected nef cycle $D$ on a smooth
projective threefold $V$, living near a log canonical component, with a
torsion normal bundle and a local relation between a power of the
@@ -97,9 +97,9 @@ $p$, while intersection with an ample divisor supplies a nonzero
integer-valued degree, and a $p$-divisible group admits no nonzero map
to $\Z$. Contradiction.
-\paragraph{A small dictionary.}
-\begin{center}
-\begin{tabular}{@{}ll@{}}
+A small dictionary.:
+
+{@{}ll@{}}
\toprule
Term & Plain meaning \\
\midrule
@@ -121,62 +121,62 @@ Cartier descent & Recovering data from its Frobenius pullback. \\
Formal neighborhood & The completion along a divisor, remembering its thickening. \\
Picard group & The group of line bundles up to isomorphism. \\
\bottomrule
-\end{tabular}
-\end{center}
-\paragraph{How the sections fit together.}
-Section~\ref{sec:introduction} states the theorem and the proof map.
-Section~\ref{sec:foundations} states the companion's cycle obstruction,
+
+
+How the sections fit together.:
+Section~sec:introduction states the theorem and the proof map.
+Section~sec:foundations states the companion's cycle obstruction,
records elementary numerical facts, and reduces the theorem to a
-terminal $\Q$-factorial pair. Section~\ref{sec:boundary} separates the
+terminal $\Q$-factorial pair. Section~sec:boundary separates the
boundary from the cycle using quantitative bend-and-break.
-Section~\ref{sec:isolation} isolates a single log canonical component by
+Section~sec:isolation isolates a single log canonical component by
a minimal model program that is trivial for the restored divisor.
-Section~\ref{sec:torsion} proves torsion on the full nonreduced Cartier
-thickening of that component. Section~\ref{sec:cycle} assembles the
+Section~sec:torsion proves torsion on the full nonreduced Cartier
+thickening of that component. Section~sec:cycle assembles the
prepared cycle and completes the proof.
Readers who want the shortest path can read
\[
-\text{Theorem~\ref{thm:main}}
-\longrightarrow
-\text{Proposition~\ref{prop:reduction}}
-\longrightarrow
-\text{Proposition~\ref{prop:separation}}
-\longrightarrow
-\text{Proposition~\ref{prop:isolation}}
-\longrightarrow
-\text{Proposition~\ref{prop:boundary-torsion}}
-\longrightarrow
-\text{Proposition~\ref{prop:prepared}}.
+Theorem~thm:main
+→
+Proposition~prop:reduction
+→
+Proposition~prop:separation
+→
+Proposition~prop:isolation
+→
+Proposition~prop:boundary-torsion
+→
+Proposition~prop:prepared.
\]
The intervening lemmas explain why each arrow is valid.
-\section{Introduction}
-\label{sec:introduction}
+# Introduction
-\subsection{The theorem}
-Throughout, a \emph{variety} is integral and separated of finite type
-over a field. A \emph{pair} $(X,B)$ has $X$ normal and $B$ an effective
+## The theorem
+
+Throughout, a variety is integral and separated of finite type
+over a field. A pair $(X,B)$ has $X$ normal and $B$ an effective
$\Q$-divisor with $K_X+B$ $\Q$-Cartier. We use the standard discrepancy
definitions of terminal, klt, dlt, and lc singularities; see
-\cite{KM}. For a nef $\Q$-Cartier divisor $L$ on a threefold, we say its
-\emph{numerical dimension} is one when, for an ample Cartier divisor
+[cite]. For a nef $\Q$-Cartier divisor $L$ on a threefold, we say its
+numerical dimension is one when, for an ample Cartier divisor
$H$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:numdim}
+
L H^2>0
-\qquad\text{and}\qquad
+\qquadand\qquad
L^2 H=0.
-\end{equation}
-\begin{theorem}\label{thm:main}
+
+
Let $k$ be an algebraically closed field of characteristic $p>3$. Let
$(X,B)$ be a projective log canonical threefold pair over $k$, where
$X$ is normal, $B$ is an effective $\Q$-divisor, and $K_X+B$ is
$\Q$-Cartier. If $K_X+B$ is nef and has numerical dimension one, then
$K_X+B$ is semiample.
-\end{theorem}
+
The boundary coefficients are arbitrary rationals allowed by log
canonicity. Neither terminality nor $\Q$-factoriality is assumed for the
@@ -189,43 +189,43 @@ on $C$ such that $m(K_X+B)\sim f^*A$ for some $m>0$. The target is a
curve because the numerical dimension is one; Stein factorization
produces $f$ from any globally generated pluricanonical multiple.
-\subsection{Background and context}
+## Background and context
Over the complex numbers, Miyaoka proved abundance for minimal
-threefolds of numerical dimension one \cite{Miyaoka}, and Kawamata gave
+threefolds of numerical dimension one [cite], and Kawamata gave
another proof and completed abundance for minimal threefolds
-\cite{Kawamata}. Keel, Matsuki, and McKernan established log abundance
-for log canonical threefold pairs \cite{KMM,KMMCorrection}.
+[cite]. Keel, Matsuki, and McKernan established log abundance
+for log canonical threefold pairs [cite].
-In positive characteristic, Keel's semiampleness criterion \cite{Keel}
-and the basepoint-freeness methods of Cascini, Tanaka, and Xu \cite{CTX}
+In positive characteristic, Keel's semiampleness criterion [cite]
+and the basepoint-freeness methods of Cascini, Tanaka, and Xu [cite]
provided the foundations. The threefold minimal model program was
-developed by Hacon--Xu \cite{HX}, Birkar \cite{Birkar}, and
-Birkar--Waldron \cite{BW} in characteristic greater than five, with log
-canonical and relative extensions by Waldron \cite{Waldron} and
-Hashizume--Nakamura--Tanaka \cite{HNT}, and the characteristic-five
-case by Hacon--Witaszek \cite{HW}.
+developed by Hacon--Xu [cite], Birkar [cite], and
+Birkar--Waldron [cite] in characteristic greater than five, with log
+canonical and relative extensions by Waldron [cite] and
+Hashizume--Nakamura--Tanaka [cite], and the characteristic-five
+case by Hacon--Witaszek [cite].
For abundance itself, Xu--Zhang proved nonvanishing for terminal minimal
-threefolds in characteristic greater than five \cite{XZ}, and Witaszek
+threefolds in characteristic greater than five [cite], and Witaszek
obtained klt nonvanishing and abundance in nef dimension at most two in
-that range \cite{Witaszek}. Zheng Xu proved nonvanishing for
+that range [cite]. Zheng Xu proved nonvanishing for
pseudoeffective log canonical divisors on projective lc threefold pairs
in characteristic greater than three, together with abundance in nef
dimension at most two \cite[Theorems~1.4 and~1.8]{XuNonvanishing}, and
-later proved abundance in numerical dimension two \cite{XuNuTwo}.
+later proved abundance in numerical dimension two [cite].
The case left open, and treated here, has numerical dimension one and
maximal nef dimension three.
-The companion paper \cite{Companion} treats terminal threefolds whose
+The companion paper [cite] treats terminal threefolds whose
nef canonical divisor has numerical dimension one. Its proof isolates a
stronger structural fact: a certain connected nef cycle cannot exist on
-a smooth threefold. We state this \emph{cycle obstruction} in
-Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction}, with all its hypotheses. The present paper
+a smooth threefold. We state this cycle obstruction in
+Theorem~thm:obstruction, with all its hypotheses. The present paper
constructs such a cycle from a log canonical pair with arbitrary rational
boundary; the obstruction is an essential input, not reproved here.
-\subsection{The proof strategy}
+## The proof strategy
After an uncountable field extension and a crepant birational change, we
may suppose the underlying variety is terminal and $\Q$-factorial.
@@ -233,10 +233,10 @@ Nonvanishing then gives a nonzero effective Cartier divisor
$N_0\sim m(K_X+B)$. We assume for contradiction that the nef dimension
of $N_0$ is three. The new difficulty, compared with the companion, is to
obtain a relation for a power of the canonical bundle near a component of
-this \emph{log} canonical divisor, controlling both the boundary and the
+this log canonical divisor, controlling both the boundary and the
exceptional divisors of a resolution.
-Proposition~\ref{prop:separation} handles the boundary. It proves
+Proposition~prop:separation handles the boundary. It proves
$B N_0 H=0$ and shows that every boundary component is either contained
in $\Supp N_0$ or disjoint from it. If the intersection were positive,
complete-intersection curves would have arbitrarily small ratios of
@@ -249,7 +249,7 @@ its log canonical threshold along $N_0$, obtaining a coefficient-one
component on a dlt model. A partial MMP, trivial for the resulting full
log canonical class, makes that component disjoint from the rest of the
divisor. Reduced-boundary adjunction and surface abundance
-\cite{Tanaka,Posva} then yield torsion on a Cartier multiple of the
+[cite] then yield torsion on a Cartier multiple of the
component, and the companion's extension argument passes from the reduced
surface to the full nonreduced Cartier thickening.
@@ -259,60 +259,60 @@ boundary. A finite separable cover removes the prime-to-$p$ part of the
pluricanonical exponent. A connected component of the pulled-back Cartier
divisor, divided by the gcd of its multiplicities, has exactly the
numerical, torsion, and canonical properties forbidden by
-Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction}. This contradiction completes the proof.
+Theorem~thm:obstruction. This contradiction completes the proof.
-Figure~\ref{fig:proof-map} records the structure.
+Figure~fig:proof-map records the structure.
-\begin{figure}[ht]
+[ht]
\centering
\small
-\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=small,row sep=large]
-& \text{lc pair }(X,B),\ N_0\sim m(K_X+B),\ n(N_0)=3
- \arrow[dl,"\text{reduce to terminal}"']
- \arrow[dr,"\text{boundary separation}"'] & \\
-\begin{gathered}\text{terminal }\Q\text{-factorial }(X,B)\\N_0\text{ nef, }\nu=1,\ n=3\end{gathered}
- \arrow[d,"\text{isolation}"']
-&& \begin{gathered}B N_0 H=0\\ \Supp B\subset \Supp N_0\sqcup P_{\mathrm{out}}\end{gathered}
- \arrow[d,"\text{torsion}"] \\
-\begin{gathered}\text{isolated }(Y,S_Y)\\S_Y\perp\text{other components}\end{gathered}
- \arrow[dr,"\text{dlt modification}"] &&
-\begin{gathered}f^*S_Y\text{ torsion on Cartier thick }M\\ \cO_M(M)\text{ torsion}\end{gathered}
+[column sep=small,row sep=large]
+& lc pair (X,B),\ N_0\sim m(K_X+B),\ n(N_0)=3
+ \arrow[dl,"reduce to terminal"']
+ \arrow[dr,"boundary separation"'] & \\
+terminal \Q-factorial (X,B)\\N_0 nef, \nu=1,\ n=3
+ \arrow[d,"isolation"']
+&& B N_0 H=0\\ \Supp B\subset \Supp N_0\sqcup P_{out}
+ \arrow[d,"torsion"] \\
+isolated (Y,S_Y)\\S_Y\perpother components
+ \arrow[dr,"dlt modification"] &&
+f^*S_Y torsion on Cartier thick M\\ \cO_M(M) torsion
\arrow[dl] \\
-& \text{prepared cycle }(V,D)\ \Rightarrow\ \text{contradiction with Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction}} &
-\end{tikzcd}
-\caption{The maximal-nef-dimension assumption produces the forbidden
-cycle, contradicting the companion obstruction.}
-\label{fig:proof-map}
-\end{figure}
+& prepared cycle (V,D)\ ⇒\ contradiction with Theorem~thm:obstruction &
+
+Caption: The maximal-nef-dimension assumption produces the forbidden
+cycle, contradicting the companion obstruction.
+
+
+
+# The cycle obstruction and the initial reductions
-\section{The cycle obstruction and the initial reductions}
-\label{sec:foundations}
We first state precisely the input taken from the companion paper
-\cite{Companion}. We then reduce Theorem~\ref{thm:main} to the task of
+[cite]. We then reduce Theorem~thm:main to the task of
constructing the forbidden cycle. Boundaries are effective
$\Q$-divisors, and canonical divisors on birational models are chosen
compatibly. Restrictions and intersections of $\Q$-Cartier divisors are
computed using Cartier multiples.
-\subsection{The obstruction supplied by the companion}
+## The obstruction supplied by the companion
For a nef divisor $L$ over an uncountable algebraically closed field,
-its \emph{nef dimension} $n(L)$ is the dimension of the target of its
+its nef dimension $n(L)$ is the dimension of the target of its
nef reduction. In dimension three we use only the following
characterization: $n(L)=3$ if and only if no curve of $L$-degree zero
-passes through a very general point, where \emph{very general} means
+passes through a very general point, where very general means
outside a countable union of proper closed subsets. These properties and
the existence of the nef reduction are recalled in
\cite[Definition~2.1 and Theorem~2.2]{XuNuTwo}. Numerical dimension and
nef dimension need not agree; both appear below.
-\begin{theorem}[Cycle obstruction of \cite{Companion}]\label{thm:obstruction}
+[Cycle obstruction of [cite]]
Let $k$ be an uncountable algebraically closed field of characteristic
$p>3$. There do not exist a smooth projective threefold $V$, a very
ample Cartier divisor $H_V$, and a nonzero effective Cartier divisor
$D=\sum_\alpha m_\alpha D_\alpha$ satisfying all of the following:
-\begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\roman*)}]
+[label=(\roman*)]
\item the $D_\alpha$ are distinct prime divisors, $m_\alpha\in\Z_{>0}$,
the support of $D$ is connected with simple normal crossings, and
$\gcd_\alpha m_\alpha=1$;
@@ -325,21 +325,21 @@ D H_V^2>0,\qquad D^2 H_V=0,\qquad n(D)=3;
scheme $D$ is torsion;
\item for some integer $b\ge0$ and integers $b_\alpha$, there is an
isomorphism on a neighborhood of $\Supp D$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:canonical-cycle}
-\omega_V^{\otimes p^b}\simeq
-\cO_V\Bigl(\sum_\alpha b_\alpha D_\alpha\Bigr).
-\end{equation}
-\end{enumerate}
-\end{theorem}
-
-Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction} is the structural statement proved in
+
+\omega_V^{ ⊗ p^b}\simeq
+\cO_V(\sum_\alpha b_\alpha D_\alpha).
+
+
+
+
+Theorem~thm:obstruction is the structural statement proved in
\cite[Sections~3--6]{Companion} for the data of its Proposition~2.1. The
end of Section~2 of that paper retains only $V$, $D$, $H_V$, the torsion
order, and the local canonical relation. Under these hypotheses its
Sections~3--5 prove Corollary~5.4, and its Proposition~6.8 gives the
contradiction. Hence the obstruction applies to any cycle with the
displayed properties; in particular, the construction below may start
-from a \emph{log} canonical divisor with boundary.
+from a log canonical divisor with boundary.
For orientation, the companion uses the torsion normal line and the
local canonical relation to control differential forms on the completion
@@ -352,25 +352,25 @@ all its input data for a log canonical pair.
The canonical relation also implies an intersection identity used later
in the companion. A rational section realizing
-\eqref{eq:canonical-cycle} has global divisor
+(eq:canonical-cycle) has global divisor
$\sum b_\alpha D_\alpha+E$ with $\Supp E$ disjoint from $\Supp D$. Since
$D|_{D_\alpha}\equiv0$, for every Cartier divisor $A$ on $V$ we get
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:canonical-intersection}
+
K_V D A=0.
-\end{equation}
-\subsection{Elementary numerical facts}
+
+## Elementary numerical facts
The next observation converts zero intersection numbers into restrictions
that are numerically trivial.
-\begin{lemma}\label{lem:surface-nef}
+
Let $T$ be an integral projective surface, $H$ an ample Cartier divisor,
and $P$ a nef $\Q$-Cartier divisor on $T$. If $P H=0$, then
$P\equiv0$. Moreover, a nonzero effective Cartier divisor on $T$ has
positive intersection with $H$.
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
For any integral curve $C\subset T$, a sufficiently large multiple of
$H$ has an effective Cartier member $E$ containing $C$; the effective
one-cycle of $E$ has positive coefficient along $C$. Every component of
@@ -378,18 +378,18 @@ that cycle has nonnegative $P$-degree, while $PE=0$, so $PC=0$. This
proves the first assertion. The second is positivity of the ample degree
of each component of the effective one-cycle of a nonzero Cartier
divisor.
-\end{proof}
+
In particular, if $N$ is a nonzero effective nef Cartier divisor on a
projective threefold and $N^2H=0$ for an ample Cartier divisor $H$, then
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:restriction-zero}
-N|_T\equiv0\qquad\text{for every prime component }T\text{ of }N.
-\end{equation}
+
+N|_T\equiv0\qquadfor every prime component T of N.
+
Indeed, writing $N=\sum a_T T$ with $a_T>0$, the nonnegative numbers
$NHT$ have positive-coefficient sum $N^2H=0$, so each $NHT=0$, and
-Lemma~\ref{lem:surface-nef} gives $N|_T\equiv0$.
+Lemma~lem:surface-nef gives $N|_T\equiv0$.
-\subsection{Reduction to a terminal underlying variety}
+## Reduction to a terminal underlying variety
We use three results of Xu for projective lc threefolds in characteristic
greater than three: nonvanishing for a pseudoeffective log canonical
@@ -402,20 +402,20 @@ are available in this range, including characteristic five
use projective resolution of threefolds preserving the regular locus,
and resolution of divisor supports preserving their complement on a
regular variety; the required forms are recalled from
-\cite{CPFirst,CP,CJS} in \cite[Section~2.1]{Companion}.
+[cite] in \cite[Section~2.1]{Companion}.
+
-\begin{proposition}\label{prop:reduction}
-To prove Theorem~\ref{thm:main} it suffices to rule out the following
+To prove Theorem~thm:main it suffices to rule out the following
data: an uncountable algebraically closed field $k$ of characteristic
$p>3$, a terminal $\Q$-factorial projective threefold $X$, an lc pair
$(X,B)$, and a nonzero effective Cartier divisor
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:N0}
+
N_0\sim m(K_X+B),\qquad m\in\Z_{>0},
-\end{equation}
+
such that $mK_X$ and $mB$ are Cartier, and $N_0$ is nef with
$\nu(N_0)=1$ and $n(N_0)=3$.
-\end{proposition}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
First extend the field to an uncountable algebraically closed one.
Integrality and normality persist, and a log resolution with its
discrepancy computation shows the base-changed pair is still lc. The
@@ -462,38 +462,38 @@ Relabel this pair as $(X,B)$. By nonvanishing
effective representative $N_0$; it is nonzero because $K_X+B$ is not
numerically trivial. Increasing the multiple makes $N_0$, $mK_X$, and
$mB$ Cartier, as required.
-\end{proof}
-From now until the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:main} we work with the data
-of Proposition~\ref{prop:reduction}. Fix a very ample divisor $H$ on $X$.
-Then $N_0H^2>0$, $N_0^2H=0$, and \eqref{eq:restriction-zero} holds. The
+
+From now until the proof of Theorem~thm:main we work with the data
+of Proposition~prop:reduction. Fix a very ample divisor $H$ on $X$.
+Then $N_0H^2>0$, $N_0^2H=0$, and (eq:restriction-zero) holds. The
next task is to establish the same numerical triviality on the boundary
components.
-\section{Separating the boundary from the log canonical cycle}
-\label{sec:boundary}
+# Separating the boundary from the log canonical cycle
-The numerical relation $N_0\sim m(K_X+B)$ controls the \emph{log}
-canonical divisor, whereas Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction} needs a relation
-for a power of the \emph{canonical} bundle. The gap is the boundary $B$.
+
+The numerical relation $N_0\sim m(K_X+B)$ controls the log
+canonical divisor, whereas Theorem~thm:obstruction needs a relation
+for a power of the canonical bundle. The gap is the boundary $B$.
We now show that the boundary contributes only components of the cycle or
divisors entirely disjoint from it. The argument uses maximal nef
dimension and quantitative bend-and-break, and does not involve the MMP.
-\begin{proposition}[Boundary separation]\label{prop:separation}
+[Boundary separation]
Let $X$ be a normal $\Q$-factorial projective threefold over an
uncountable algebraically closed field, and let $B$ be an effective
$\Q$-divisor. Suppose $N$ is a nonzero effective nef Cartier divisor with
$\nu(N)=1$, $n(N)=3$, and $N\sim_{\Q}a(K_X+B)$ for some rational $a>0$.
Then for every ample Cartier divisor $H$ one has
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:boundary-zero}
+
B N H=0.
-\end{equation}
+
Consequently $N$ is numerically trivial on each prime component of $B$,
and every such component is either contained in $\Supp N$ or disjoint
from $\Supp N$.
-\end{proposition}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
Replace $H$ by a very ample multiple. The number $BNH$ is nonnegative.
If it were positive, then $B$ has a component on which $N$ is not
numerically trivial, and the identity
@@ -509,13 +509,13 @@ points, and a general member of the second avoids them. Bertini on the
smooth open then gives the integral curve. Its intersection numbers are
\[
NC_l=u_l v_l\,NH^2,\qquad
--K_XC_l=u_l v_l\bigl(-K_XH^2-lK_XNH\bigr),
+-K_XC_l=u_l v_l(-K_XH^2-lK_XNH),
\]
so
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:bend-ratio}
-\frac{NC_l}{-K_XC_l}
-=\frac{NH^2}{-K_XH^2-lK_XNH}\longrightarrow0,
-\end{equation}
+
+(NC_l)/(-K_XC_l)
+=(NH^2)/(-K_XH^2-lK_XNH)→0,
+
and $-K_XC_l>0$ for large $l$.
The quantitative bend-and-break theorem of Jovinelly, Lehmann, and Riedl
@@ -525,7 +525,7 @@ canonical degree, and any nef Cartier test divisor. In dimension three it
supplies, through every closed point of $C_l$, a rational curve $\Gamma$
with
\[
-0\le N\Gamma\le4\,\frac{NC_l}{-K_XC_l}.
+0\le N\Gamma\le4\,(NC_l)/(-K_XC_l).
\]
Fix $l$ so large that the right-hand side is less than one. Since $N$ is
Cartier, it follows that $N\Gamma=0$.
@@ -541,30 +541,30 @@ subset of $X$. Over the uncountable field this open contains a closed
point outside the countable union excluded by $n(N)=3$. The curve
$\Gamma$ through that point is a curve of $N$-degree zero through a very
general point, contradicting $n(N)=3$. This proves
-\eqref{eq:boundary-zero}.
+(eq:boundary-zero).
Write $B=\sum b_T T$ with $b_T>0$. All numbers $NHT$ are nonnegative, so
-\eqref{eq:boundary-zero} gives $NHT=0$ for each $T$, and
-Lemma~\ref{lem:surface-nef} gives $N|_T\equiv0$. If $T$ is not a
+(eq:boundary-zero) gives $NHT=0$ for each $T$, and
+Lemma~lem:surface-nef gives $N|_T\equiv0$. If $T$ is not a
component of $N$, the canonical section of $\cO_X(N)$ restricts to a
nonzero section on the integral surface $T$. Were $T\cap\Supp N$
nonempty, its zero scheme would be a nonzero effective Cartier divisor on
$T$, with positive ample degree, contradicting $N|_T\equiv0$. Hence the
two supports are disjoint.
-\end{proof}
-Apply Proposition~\ref{prop:separation} to $N_0$ and set
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:Pout}
-P_{\mathrm{out}}=
-\bigcup_{\substack{T\text{ a prime component of }B\\T\not\subset\Supp N_0}}T.
-\end{equation}
+
+Apply Proposition~prop:separation to $N_0$ and set
+
+P_{out}=
+∪_{\substack{T a prime component of B\\T\not\subset\Supp N_0}}T.
+
This is a closed subset disjoint from $\Supp N_0$. Thus
-$\Supp B\subset\Supp N_0\cup P_{\mathrm{out}}$ is a union of two disjoint
+$\Supp B\subset\Supp N_0\cup P_{out}$ is a union of two disjoint
closed sets. We keep this separation while isolating one component of
$N_0$ in the next section.
-\section{Isolating a log canonical component}
-\label{sec:isolation}
+# Isolating a log canonical component
+
The effective divisor $N_0$ may have several intersecting components. We
now make one of them disjoint from the others while keeping the pullback
@@ -573,65 +573,65 @@ raise the boundary to a log canonical threshold, lower the coefficient of
one component, and run an MMP that is trivial for the restored log
canonical divisor. The resulting nefness forces the desired disjointness.
-\begin{proposition}\label{prop:isolation}
+
Let $k$ be an algebraically closed field of characteristic $p>3$. Let $X$
be a terminal $\Q$-factorial projective threefold, let $(X,B)$ be log
canonical with rational boundary, and let $0\ne N_0\sim m(K_X+B)$ be an
effective nef Cartier divisor, with $m$ a positive integer. Assume $N_0$
is numerically trivial on each component of its support, and every
component of $B$ is contained in or disjoint from $\Supp N_0$. Let
-$P_{\mathrm{out}}$ be the union of the latter components and put
+$P_{out}$ be the union of the latter components and put
\[
-U_X=X_{\mathrm{reg}}\setminus\bigl(\Supp N_0\cup P_{\mathrm{out}}\bigr).
+U_X=X_{reg}∖(\Supp N_0\cup P_{out}).
\]
Then there exist a projective $\Q$-factorial klt threefold $Y$ birational
to $X$, a rational boundary $G_Y$, an effective nef $\Q$-Cartier divisor
$N_Y$, and a prime divisor $S_Y$ with the following properties.
-\begin{enumerate}
+
\item The pair $(Y,G_Y)$ is log canonical, $S_Y$ has coefficient one in
-$G_Y$, and $s:=\operatorname{mult}_{S_Y}N_Y$ is positive. For every
+$G_Y$, and $s:=mult_{S_Y}N_Y$ is positive. For every
rational $\delta>0$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-nef}
+
K_Y+G_Y\sim_{\Q}\tau N_Y
-\qquad\text{and}\qquad
-K_Y+G_Y-\delta S_Y\ \text{is nef},
-\end{equation}
+\qquadand\qquad
+K_Y+G_Y-\delta S_Y\ is nef,
+
for $\tau>0$ specified at the end.
\item The divisor $N_Y$ is numerically trivial on every component of its
support, and every component of $G_Y$ is contained in or disjoint from
$\Supp N_Y$.
\item The divisor $S_Y$ is disjoint from every other component of $N_Y$
and from $\Supp(G_Y-S_Y)$. In particular,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-local}
+
N_Y=sS_Y,\quad G_Y=S_Y,\quad
K_Y+S_Y\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,S_Y
-\end{equation}
+
on a neighborhood of $S_Y$, and $S_Y|_{S_Y}\equiv0$.
\item The birational correspondence identifies $U_X$ with an open subset
of $Y$. On a smooth projective common resolution $q:V_0\to X$,
$r:V_0\to Y$ that is an isomorphism over this open,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-pullbacks}
+
q^*N_0=r^*N_Y,
-\end{equation}
+
and the same equality holds after passing to a further common resolution.
-\end{enumerate}
+
One may take $\tau=m^{-1}+\lambda$, where
$\lambda=\lct_{(X,B)}(N_0)\ge0$.
-\end{proposition}
-\begin{proof}
-\emph{A coefficient-one component over $\Supp N_0$.}
+
+Proof.
+A coefficient-one component over $\Supp N_0$.
On a log resolution of $(X,B+N_0)$ the log canonical threshold is the
minimum of the finitely many ratios
\[
-\frac{a(E,X,B)}{\operatorname{ord}_E(N_0)}
-\qquad\bigl(\operatorname{ord}_E(N_0)>0\bigr),
+(a(E,X,B))/(ord_E(N_0))
+\qquad(ord_E(N_0)>0),
\]
where $a(E,X,B)$ is the log discrepancy and the divisors considered
include the strict transforms of the components of $N_0$. Thus $\lambda$
is finite and rational, possibly zero, and $(X,B+\lambda N_0)$ is log
canonical. There is a log canonical place $E$ of this pair with
-$\operatorname{ord}_E(N_0)>0$.
+$ord_E(N_0)>0$.
Take a projective crepant $\Q$-factorial dlt modification
$\mu:(W,G)\to(X,B+\lambda N_0)$ with every extracted divisor of
@@ -640,19 +640,19 @@ coefficient one \cite[Theorem~2.27]{XuNuTwo}. Set
N=\mu^*N_0,\qquad \tau=m^{-1}+\lambda.
\]
The relation
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-restored}
+
K_W+G\sim_{\Q}\tau N
-\end{equation}
+
holds since $\mu$ is crepant. The divisor $N$ is nef and numerically
trivial on every component of its support: a curve in that support maps
to a point or to a curve in $\Supp N_0$, and the projection formula
finishes.
-\emph{Support separation on $W$.}
+Support separation on $W$.
Every component of $G$ is contained in or disjoint from $\Supp N$. For
strict transforms of components of $B$ this is the hypothesis, while
components coming from $\lambda N_0$ are contained in the support. An
-extracted divisor has center in $\Supp N_0\cup P_{\mathrm{out}}$, since
+extracted divisor has center in $\Supp N_0\cup P_{out}$, since
$X$ is klt and the boundary vanishes outside this union; its irreducible
center lies in one of these two disjoint closed sets. In the first case
its order on $N_0$ is positive, so it is contained in $\Supp\mu^*N_0$; in
@@ -664,26 +664,26 @@ $\lfloor G\rfloor$ containing this center. The preceding separation gives
$S\subset\Supp N$. This covers $\lambda=0$ as well; it does not require
all components of $N$ to occur in $G$.
-\emph{The modification is an isomorphism off the support.}
+The modification is an isomorphism off the support.
The map $\mu$ has no exceptional divisors outside
-$\Supp N_0\cup P_{\mathrm{out}}$, and a projective small birational
+$\Supp N_0\cup P_{out}$, and a projective small birational
morphism to a $\Q$-factorial variety is an isomorphism. To see the latter,
push down a relatively ample Cartier divisor. A Cartier multiple of its
pushdown pulls back to the same multiple upstairs, since there are no
exceptional divisors; it has degree zero on every contracted curve,
contradicting relative ampleness if such a curve existed.
-\emph{The partial MMP.}
-Choose a rational $\epsilon>0$ small enough that
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-effective}
-G-\epsilon S\ge0,\qquad \tau N-\epsilon S\ge0.
-\end{equation}
-Apply the partial MMP with lowered boundary $G-\epsilon S$ and restoration
-divisor $\epsilon S$, in the form of
+The partial MMP.
+Choose a rational $ε>0$ small enough that
+
+G-ε S\ge0,\qquad \tau N-ε S\ge0.
+
+Apply the partial MMP with lowered boundary $G-ε S$ and restoration
+divisor $ε S$, in the form of
\cite[Proposition~2.21, Definition~2.23, and Lemma~2.24]{XuNuTwo}. Its
-steps are $(K_W+G-\epsilon S)$-negative and $(K_W+G)$-trivial. The lowered
+steps are $(K_W+G-ε S)$-negative and $(K_W+G)$-trivial. The lowered
pair is dlt and its log canonical divisor is pseudoeffective by
-\eqref{eq:isolation-restored} and \eqref{eq:isolation-effective}, so the
+(eq:isolation-restored) and (eq:isolation-effective), so the
required termination is supplied by \cite[Theorem~1.5]{XuNonvanishing}.
The threefold MMP package used here, including in characteristic five, is
recalled in \cite[Section~2.3]{Companion}.
@@ -694,13 +694,13 @@ restored divisor minus $\delta$ times the transform of $S$ for every small
rational $\delta>0$. We track $S$, the pullbacks of $N$, and support
separation through the steps, and then exclude the fiber alternative.
-\emph{Tracking.}
+Tracking.
Write $W_i\dashrightarrow W_{i+1}$ for a step, with transforms
$G_i,N_i,S_i$. The equality $K_{W_i}+G_i\sim_{\Q}\tau N_i$ persists by
pushforward, so the contracted ray $R_i$ satisfies
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-ray}
+
N_i\cdot R_i=0,\qquad S_i\cdot R_i>0.
-\end{equation}
+
Thus $S_i$ cannot be the exceptional divisor of a divisorial step: the
negativity lemma would then give a contracted curve of negative
$S_i$-degree. Hence $S$ survives throughout the MMP.
@@ -709,17 +709,17 @@ Let $a:T\to W_i$ and $b:T\to W_{i+1}$ be a common resolution of a step.
The divisor $F=a^*N_i-b^*N_{i+1}$ is $b$-exceptional. If a curve on $T$ is
contracted by $b$, its image on $W_i$ is a point or is a curve contracted
to the common target, so $F$ has degree zero on every such curve by
-\eqref{eq:isolation-ray}. Applying the negativity lemma to $F$ and $-F$
+(eq:isolation-ray). Applying the negativity lemma to $F$ and $-F$
gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:isolation-step-pullback}
+
a^*N_i=b^*N_{i+1}.
-\end{equation}
+
This covers divisorial contractions and flips. The same argument for the
full log divisors gives
$a^*(K_{W_i}+G_i)=b^*(K_{W_{i+1}}+G_{i+1})$, so the restored pair stays
log canonical.
-Equation~\eqref{eq:isolation-step-pullback} preserves nefness and
+Equation~(eq:isolation-step-pullback) preserves nefness and
numerical triviality on the support. For the latter, lift a curve in
$\Supp N_{i+1}$ to a curve on $T$ dominating it. Its image on $W_i$ lies
in $\Supp N_i$ or is a point, because the inverse image of the support of
@@ -730,9 +730,9 @@ disjoint from $\Supp N_i$ has strict transform on $T$ disjoint from
$a^*N_i$, hence from $b^*N_{i+1}$, and since it maps onto its image on
$W_{i+1}$, the transformed component is disjoint from $\Supp N_{i+1}$.
-\emph{The open complement is preserved.}
+The open complement is preserved.
Every contracted curve has negative degree against the effective divisor
-$\tau N_i-\epsilon S_i$, so lies in $\Supp N_i$. A connected
+$\tau N_i-ε S_i$, so lies in $\Supp N_i$. A connected
positive-dimensional projective fiber contains a curve through each of its
closed points, so a fiber meeting the complement of $\Supp N_i$ consists
of a single point and does not meet the support. Properness and normality
@@ -741,103 +741,103 @@ subset of its target. For a flip, this open in the target is
$\Q$-factorial, being isomorphic to the corresponding open of $W_i$, so
the new small morphism is also an isomorphism over it.
-\emph{No Mori fiber output.}
-The effective representative $\tau N_i-\epsilon S_i$ persists on each
-model, as does $\tau N_i-tS_i$ for every rational $0<t\le\epsilon$. A
+No Mori fiber output.
+The effective representative $\tau N_i-ε S_i$ persists on each
+model, as does $\tau N_i-tS_i$ for every rational $0<t\leε$. A
curve in a fiber through a general point outside this effective support has
nonnegative degree, whereas the driving divisor of a Mori fiber
contraction is negative on every contracted curve. This rules out the
fiber alternative for the lowered class and for every smaller
perturbation of the restored class.
-\emph{The output model.}
+The output model.
Let $Y$ be the resulting model. The partial-MMP conclusion gives
-\eqref{eq:isolation-nef} for some rational $0<\delta<\epsilon$. Negative
+(eq:isolation-nef) for some rational $0<\delta<ε$. Negative
MMP steps preserve the $\Q$-factorial dlt pair with lowered boundary, so
-$(Y,G_Y-\epsilon S_Y)$ is dlt. Its $\Q$-factorial underlying variety $Y$
+$(Y,G_Y-ε S_Y)$ is dlt. Its $\Q$-factorial underlying variety $Y$
is then klt: every place of zero log discrepancy for a dlt pair has center
in the reduced boundary, and removing that effective $\Q$-Cartier
boundary strictly increases the discrepancy. Dlt preservation here is
used for the lowered boundary; for the restored boundary we use the
crepant comparison just proved.
-\emph{Nefness isolates $S_Y$.}
+Nefness isolates $S_Y$.
Let $T\ne S_Y$ be a component of $N_Y$. Numerical triviality of $N_Y|_T$
-and \eqref{eq:isolation-nef} make $-S_Y|_T$ nef. On the other hand
+and (eq:isolation-nef) make $-S_Y|_T$ nef. On the other hand
$S_Y|_T$ is an effective $\Q$-Cartier divisor; if it were nonzero, its
intersection with an ample Cartier divisor on the integral projective
surface $T$ would be positive, contradicting anti-nefness. Hence
-$S_Y\cap T=\varnothing$. Each other component of $G_Y$ is either such a
+$S_Y\cap T=∅$. Each other component of $G_Y$ is either such a
component of $N_Y$ or is disjoint from its support. This proves the stated
-separation and the local identities \eqref{eq:isolation-local}. The
+separation and the local identities (eq:isolation-local). The
equality $N_Y|_{S_Y}\equiv0$ gives $S_Y|_{S_Y}\equiv0$.
-\emph{The common open.}
+The common open.
All models share the open $U_X$. Resolve the graph of the correspondences
among them, keeping this smooth open unchanged, to obtain $V_0$.
-Composing \eqref{eq:isolation-step-pullback} with $N=\mu^*N_0$ proves
-\eqref{eq:isolation-pullbacks}, and pullback preserves the equality on any
+Composing (eq:isolation-step-pullback) with $N=\mu^*N_0$ proves
+(eq:isolation-pullbacks), and pullback preserves the equality on any
further common resolution.
-\end{proof}
+
For adjunction we replace the isolated log canonical pair by a dlt pair.
The klt property of $Y$ ensures that every divisor extracted below belongs
to the total transform of $S_Y$.
-\begin{corollary}\label{lem:dlt-boundary}
-With the notation of Proposition~\ref{prop:isolation}, there is a
+
+With the notation of Proposition~prop:isolation, there is a
projective crepant $\Q$-factorial dlt modification
-$f:(Y_d,\Sigma)\to(Y,S_Y)$ such that $\Sigma$ is reduced,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:dlt-support}
-\Supp\Sigma=\Supp f^*S_Y,
-\end{equation}
-and $f$ is an isomorphism off $S_Y$. On a neighborhood of $\Sigma$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:dlt-local}
-K_{Y_d}+\Sigma\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,f^*S_Y.
-\end{equation}
-Moreover $f^*S_Y$ is numerically trivial on each component of $\Sigma$,
+$f:(Y_d,Σ)\to(Y,S_Y)$ such that $Σ$ is reduced,
+
+\SuppΣ=\Supp f^*S_Y,
+
+and $f$ is an isomorphism off $S_Y$. On a neighborhood of $Σ$,
+
+K_{Y_d}+Σ\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,f^*S_Y.
+
+Moreover $f^*S_Y$ is numerically trivial on each component of $Σ$,
and $Y_d$ shares the open $U_X$ with $X$ and $Y$.
-\end{corollary}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
The pair $(Y,S_Y)$ is log canonical, since $G_Y\ge S_Y$ and $(Y,G_Y)$ is
log canonical. Take a crepant dlt modification extracting only log
-canonical places. Its boundary $\Sigma$ consists of the strict transform
+canonical places. Its boundary $Σ$ consists of the strict transform
of $S_Y$ and its exceptional divisors, all of coefficient one. Every
extracted divisor has center in $S_Y$: outside $S_Y$ the pair is the klt
variety $Y$. Such a divisor has positive order on $S_Y$, which proves
-\eqref{eq:dlt-support}. There are no exceptional divisors off $S_Y$, and
+(eq:dlt-support). There are no exceptional divisors off $S_Y$, and
the small-morphism argument of the preceding proof shows $f$ is an
isomorphism there.
-Crepancy and \eqref{eq:isolation-local} give \eqref{eq:dlt-local}. Every
-curve in $\Sigma$ maps to a point or to a curve in $S_Y$, where $S_Y$ is
+Crepancy and (eq:isolation-local) give (eq:dlt-local). Every
+curve in $Σ$ maps to a point or to a curve in $S_Y$, where $S_Y$ is
numerically trivial, so the projection formula gives the numerical
-assertion. Under the identification of Proposition~\ref{prop:isolation},
+assertion. Under the identification of Proposition~prop:isolation,
$U_X$ is disjoint from $S_Y$ and hence is unchanged by $f$.
-\end{proof}
-\section{Torsion on the full boundary cycle}
-\label{sec:torsion}
-The reduced dlt boundary $\Sigma$ of Corollary~\ref{lem:dlt-boundary} is a
+# Torsion on the full boundary cycle
+
+
+The reduced dlt boundary $Σ$ of Corollary~lem:dlt-boundary is a
surface pair to which adjunction and surface abundance apply. The
-prepared-cycle obstruction, however, needs torsion on the \emph{effective
-Cartier divisor} including its multiplicities. We first give the
+prepared-cycle obstruction, however, needs torsion on the effective
+Cartier divisor including its multiplicities. We first give the
extension argument that passes from the reduced surface to the possibly
nonreduced Cartier thickening.
-\begin{lemma}[{\cite[Lemma~2.4]{Companion}}]\label{lem:torsion}
+[{\cite[Lemma~2.4]{Companion}}]
Let $T$ be a normal projective threefold over an algebraically closed
field of characteristic $p>0$, and let $E$ be a nonzero effective Cartier
divisor on $T$. Suppose $E$ is numerically trivial on every integral
component of its support. If
\[
-\cO_T(E)|_{E_{\mathrm{red}}\setminus Z}
-\simeq\cO_{E_{\mathrm{red}}\setminus Z}
+\cO_T(E)|_{E_{red}∖ Z}
+\simeq\cO_{E_{red}∖ Z}
\]
for a finite set $Z$ of closed points, then $\cO_E(E)$ is torsion.
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
We reproduce the proof because both the finite exceptional set and the
nonreduced divisor occur in our application. Replace $Z$ by
$Z\cap\Supp E$. At $z\in Z$ write $R=\cO_{T,z}$, with maximal ideal
@@ -845,7 +845,7 @@ $\mathfrak m$, and let $t_z$ be a local equation of $E$. Normality gives
\[
H^1_{\mathfrak m}(R)=0,
\qquad
-\ell_R\bigl(H^2_{\mathfrak m}(R)\bigr)<\infty.
+\ell_R(H^2_{\mathfrak m}(R))<∞.
\]
The second assertion uses the dimension-three hypothesis. Present $R=A/I$
with $A$ regular local of dimension $n$, essentially of finite type over
@@ -854,7 +854,7 @@ most two, hence Cohen--Macaulay. Catenarity gives
$\dim A_{\mathfrak q}-\dim R_{\mathfrak p}=n-3$ for a prime
$\mathfrak q$ above $\mathfrak p$, so the Auslander--Buchsbaum formula
gives projective dimension $n-3$ over $A_{\mathfrak q}$. Thus
-$\operatorname{Ext}^{n-2}_A(R,A)$ is supported only at the closed point.
+$Ext^{n-2}_A(R,A)$ is supported only at the closed point.
It is a finite module, hence of finite length, and local duality gives the
assertion for $H^2_{\mathfrak m}(R)$.
@@ -862,48 +862,48 @@ Choose $j\ge1$ such that $t_z^{j-1}$ annihilates $H^2_{\mathfrak m}(R)$
at every $z\in Z$; a single $j$ works because $Z$ is finite. For every
integer $u$, restriction sequences give a commutative diagram
\[
-\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=small]
+[column sep=small]
0\arrow[r]&\cO_T((u-j)E)\arrow[r]\arrow[d]
&\cO_T(uE)\arrow[r]\arrow[d,equal]
&\cO_{jE}(uE)\arrow[r]\arrow[d]&0\\
0\arrow[r]&\cO_T((u-1)E)\arrow[r]
&\cO_T(uE)\arrow[r]
&\cO_E(uE)\arrow[r]&0.
-\end{tikzcd}
+
\]
In local trivializations the left vertical map is multiplication by
$t_z^{j-1}$. Local cohomology with support in the finite set $Z$ is the
direct sum of the corresponding local groups. The vanishing of the ambient
$H^1_Z$ makes the connecting maps from the $H^1_Z$ of the rightmost terms
to the ambient $H^2_Z$ injective. Naturality and the choice of $j$ give
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:torsion-obstruction-zero}
-H^1_Z\bigl(T,\cO_{jE}(uE)\bigr)
-\longrightarrow H^1_Z\bigl(T,\cO_E(uE)\bigr)
-\quad\text{is zero for every }u\in\Z.
-\end{equation}
+
+H^1_Z(T,\cO_{jE}(uE))
+→ H^1_Z(T,\cO_E(uE))
+\quadis zero for every u\in\Z.
+
The same $j$ works for every twist: locally the invertible sheaves in the
diagram are free of rank one, and the annihilating map is still
multiplication by $t_z^{j-1}$.
-Fix this thickening $jE$. The ideal of $E_{\mathrm{red}}\setminus Z$ in
-$jE\setminus Z$ is nilpotent. Lift a chosen generator of
-$\cO_T(E)|_{E_{\mathrm{red}}\setminus Z}$ to local generating sections on
-a finite open cover of $jE\setminus Z$. On overlaps the lifts differ by
+Fix this thickening $jE$. The ideal of $E_{red}∖ Z$ in
+$jE∖ Z$ is nilpotent. Lift a chosen generator of
+$\cO_T(E)|_{E_{red}∖ Z}$ to local generating sections on
+a finite open cover of $jE∖ Z$. On overlaps the lifts differ by
sections in that nilpotent ideal times the line bundle. For $u=p^e$
sufficiently large, their $u$th tensor powers agree: in local frames this
is the identity $(a+b)^{p^e}=a^{p^e}+b^{p^e}$ with $b^{p^e}=0$. They
therefore glue to a generator
\[
-s_j\in H^0\bigl(jE\setminus Z,\cO_{jE}(uE)\bigr).
+s_j\in H^0(jE∖ Z,\cO_{jE}(uE)).
\]
-Let $s$ be its restriction to $E\setminus Z$. The obstruction to extending
+Let $s$ be its restriction to $E∖ Z$. The obstruction to extending
$s$ over $E$ is the image of the obstruction to extending $s_j$ over
-$jE$. Equation~\eqref{eq:torsion-obstruction-zero}, applied to the exact
+$jE$. Equation~(eq:torsion-obstruction-zero), applied to the exact
sequences for sections with support in $Z$, kills that image, so $s$
extends to a section of $\cO_E(uE)$.
This extended section has no zeros. On each integral projective surface
-component $F$ of $E_{\mathrm{red}}$ it is nonzero because it is a generator
+component $F$ of $E_{red}$ it is nonzero because it is a generator
off $Z$. If its restriction to $F$ vanished anywhere, its zero scheme would
be a nonempty effective Cartier divisor on $F$, with positive intersection
with an ample divisor, contradicting the numerical triviality of
@@ -911,39 +911,39 @@ $\cO_F(uE)$. The argument uses only integrality of $F$, not normality.
The section is thus a generator on the reduction, and then on $E$, since
an element invertible modulo a nilpotent ideal is invertible. Hence
$\cO_E(uE)\simeq\cO_E$.
-\end{proof}
+
We apply this lemma to the reduced dlt model obtained by isolation. Recall
that $s$ is the multiplicity of $S_Y$ in $N_Y$ and $\tau>0$ satisfies
$K_Y+G_Y\sim_{\Q}\tau N_Y$.
-\begin{proposition}\label{prop:boundary-torsion}
+
For the projective crepant dlt modification
-$f:(Y_d,\Sigma)\to(Y,S_Y)$ of Corollary~\ref{lem:dlt-boundary}, there is a
+$f:(Y_d,Σ)\to(Y,S_Y)$ of Corollary~lem:dlt-boundary, there is a
positive Cartier multiple $M$ of $f^*S_Y$ such that
\[
-\Supp M=\Sigma,
-\qquad M|_{\Sigma_i}\equiv0\ \text{for every component }\Sigma_i,
-\qquad \cO_M(M)\text{ is torsion}.
+\Supp M=Σ,
+\qquad M|_{Σ_i}\equiv0\ for every component Σ_i,
+\qquad \cO_M(M) is torsion.
\]
-\end{proposition}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
The relations furnished by isolation are
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:adjunction-input}
-K_{Y_d}+\Sigma\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,f^*S_Y
-\quad\text{on a neighborhood of }\Sigma,
-\qquad f^*S_Y|_{\Sigma_i}\equiv0.
-\end{equation}
-Let $\sigma:\Sigma'\to\Sigma$ be the finite $S_2$-ification; it is
-unchanged away from a finite set $Z\subset\Sigma$
+
+K_{Y_d}+Σ\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,f^*S_Y
+\quadon a neighborhood of Σ,
+\qquad f^*S_Y|_{Σ_i}\equiv0.
+
+Let $\sigma:Σ'\toΣ$ be the finite $S_2$-ification; it is
+unchanged away from a finite set $Z\subsetΣ$
\cite[Proposition~2.14]{XuNuTwo}. Reduced-boundary adjunction gives an
-effective rational divisor $\Delta'$ such that $(\Sigma',\Delta')$ is a
+effective rational divisor $\Delta'$ such that $(Σ',\Delta')$ is a
projective semi-log-canonical surface pair and
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:slc-adjunction}
-K_{\Sigma'}+\Delta'
-\sim_{\Q}\sigma^*((K_{Y_d}+\Sigma)|_\Sigma)
-\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,\sigma^*(f^*S_Y|_\Sigma).
-\end{equation}
+
+K_{Σ'}+\Delta'
+\sim_{\Q}\sigma^*((K_{Y_d}+Σ)|_Σ)
+\sim_{\Q}\tau s\,\sigma^*(f^*S_Y|_Σ).
+
We use adjunction in the form of \cite[Lemma~2.19]{XuNuTwo}; see also
\cite[Section~2.5]{Companion}. The $S_2$-ification is needed because the
reduced boundary need not satisfy $S_2$. Its codimension-one
@@ -952,30 +952,30 @@ includes the conductor with coefficient one, so the normalized pair is
log canonical. These are the semi-log-canonical conditions needed for
surface abundance.
-The surface $\Sigma'$ is projective because it is finite over $\Sigma$.
-The last class in \eqref{eq:slc-adjunction} is numerically trivial, by
-\eqref{eq:adjunction-input} and the projection formula for curves.
+The surface $Σ'$ is projective because it is finite over $Σ$.
+The last class in (eq:slc-adjunction) is numerically trivial, by
+(eq:adjunction-input) and the projection formula for curves.
Posva's abundance theorem for projective semi-log-canonical surfaces in
-positive characteristic makes $K_{\Sigma'}+\Delta'$ semiample
+positive characteristic makes $K_{Σ'}+\Delta'$ semiample
\cite[Theorem~3.1]{Posva}. A semiample numerically trivial rational line
bundle is $\Q$-linearly trivial: a globally generated Cartier multiple
defines a morphism contracting every curve, hence constant on each
connected component, whose line bundle is trivial there.
Since $\tau s$ is positive and rational, clearing denominators in
-\eqref{eq:slc-adjunction} yields a positive Cartier multiple $M$ of
-$f^*S_Y$ with $\sigma^*\cO_\Sigma(M)$ trivial. In particular
+(eq:slc-adjunction) yields a positive Cartier multiple $M$ of
+$f^*S_Y$ with $\sigma^*\cO_Σ(M)$ trivial. In particular
\[
-\cO_{Y_d}(M)|_{\Sigma\setminus Z}\simeq\cO_{\Sigma\setminus Z}.
+\cO_{Y_d}(M)|_{Σ∖ Z}\simeq\cO_{Σ∖ Z}.
\]
-The divisor $M$ is effective, its reduction is $\Sigma$, and it is
+The divisor $M$ is effective, its reduction is $Σ$, and it is
numerically trivial on every component of its support. Applying
-Lemma~\ref{lem:torsion} on the normal projective threefold $Y_d$ proves
+Lemma~lem:torsion on the normal projective threefold $Y_d$ proves
torsion on the full Cartier scheme $M$.
-\end{proof}
-\section{Construction of the prepared cycle}
-\label{sec:cycle}
+
+# Construction of the prepared cycle
+
We combine the isolated boundary with the original log canonical section.
The boundary supplies a divisor with torsion normal line; the section
@@ -984,26 +984,26 @@ prime-to-$p$ part of the canonical exponent. This is the preparation of
\cite[Sections~2.7--2.8]{Companion}, keeping the support of the original
boundary throughout.
-\begin{proposition}\label{prop:prepared}
-Let $(X,B,N_0)$ be the data of Proposition~\ref{prop:reduction} in the
+
+Let $(X,B,N_0)$ be the data of Proposition~prop:reduction in the
maximal-nef-dimension case. Then there exist a smooth projective threefold
$V$, a very ample divisor $H_V$, and a nonzero effective Cartier divisor
\[
D=\sum_\alpha m_\alpha D_\alpha
\]
-having all the properties of Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction}. In particular
+having all the properties of Theorem~thm:obstruction. In particular
its support is connected with simple normal crossings,
$\gcd_\alpha(m_\alpha)=1$, and $\cO_D(D)$ is torsion.
-\end{proposition}
-\begin{proof}
-Equation~\eqref{eq:restriction-zero} and Proposition~\ref{prop:separation}
-give the hypotheses of Proposition~\ref{prop:isolation}. Choose its
+
+Proof.
+Equation~(eq:restriction-zero) and Proposition~prop:separation
+give the hypotheses of Proposition~prop:isolation. Choose its
isolated model $(Y,G_Y,N_Y,S_Y)$ and the reduced dlt modification
-$f:(Y_d,\Sigma)\to(Y,S_Y)$ of Corollary~\ref{lem:dlt-boundary}. Let $M$ be
+$f:(Y_d,Σ)\to(Y,S_Y)$ of Corollary~lem:dlt-boundary. Let $M$ be
the positive Cartier multiple of $f^*S_Y$ supplied by
-Proposition~\ref{prop:boundary-torsion}.
+Proposition~prop:boundary-torsion.
-\emph{The canonical section and its support.}
+The canonical section and its support.
Let $V_0$ be a smooth projective common resolution of $X$ and $Y_d$,
dominating the intervening models. Write
\[
@@ -1011,114 +1011,114 @@ q:V_0\to X,\qquad h_0:V_0\to Y_d,\qquad r=f\circ h_0:V_0\to Y.
\]
These models share the open
\[
-U_X=X_{\mathrm{reg}}\setminus(\Supp N_0\cup P_{\mathrm{out}}),
+U_X=X_{reg}∖(\Supp N_0\cup P_{out}),
\]
-with $P_{\mathrm{out}}$ the union of boundary components disjoint from
+with $P_{out}$ the union of boundary components disjoint from
$\Supp N_0$. Choose the common resolution to be an isomorphism over this
open; projective resolution and resolution of divisor supports in
-dimension three permit this \cite{CP,CJS}. The pullback equalities
+dimension three permit this [cite]. The pullback equalities
through the partial MMP give
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:cycle-common-pullbacks}
+
q^*N_0=r^*N_Y.
-\end{equation}
+
The integer $m$ satisfies $N_0\sim m(K_X+B)$, with $mK_X$ and $mB$
Cartier. It gives a rational section $\theta$ of
-$\omega_{V_0}^{\otimes m}$ with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:log-canonical-section}
-\operatorname{div}(\theta)
+$\omega_{V_0}^{ ⊗ m}$ with
+
+div(\theta)
=q^*N_0+m(K_{V_0}-q^*K_X)-m\,q^*B.
-\end{equation}
+
The right side is an integral divisor linearly equivalent to $mK_{V_0}$.
Put $E_0=\Supp q^*N_0$. Every prime component in
-\eqref{eq:log-canonical-section} is contained in $E_0$ or disjoint from
+(eq:log-canonical-section) is contained in $E_0$ or disjoint from
it. For $q^*B$ this is boundary separation on $X$. For a $q$-exceptional
divisor, its irreducible center lies in
\[
-X\setminus U_X
-=\Supp N_0\cup P_{\mathrm{out}}\cup\operatorname{Sing}X.
+X∖ U_X
+=\Supp N_0\cup P_{out}\cupSingX.
\]
A terminal threefold is regular in codimension two, so
-$\operatorname{Sing}X$ is finite \cite[Lemma~2.3]{Companion}. The center
+$SingX$ is finite \cite[Lemma~2.3]{Companion}. The center
is thus contained in $\Supp N_0$ or disjoint from it, and taking inverse
images gives the assertion.
Let $F_0$ be the union of the components of
-$\operatorname{div}(\theta)$ outside $E_0$. Then
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:cover-closed-set}
-Z_0:=E_0\cup\Supp\operatorname{div}(\theta)=E_0\sqcup F_0.
-\end{equation}
+$div(\theta)$ outside $E_0$. Then
+
+Z_0:=E_0\cup\Suppdiv(\theta)=E_0\sqcup F_0.
+
The disjointness is the point: components of $q^*N_0$ can cancel in
-\eqref{eq:log-canonical-section}, so we retain all of $E_0$ when choosing
+(eq:log-canonical-section), so we retain all of $E_0$ when choosing
the open set preserved by the resolution below.
-\emph{Removing the prime-to-$p$ exponent.}
+Removing the prime-to-$p$ exponent.
Write $m=p^b m'$ with $b\ge0$ and $(m',p)=1$. Choose a nonzero rational
-generator $\eta$ of $\omega_{V_0}^{\otimes p^b}$ and write
+generator $\eta$ of $\omega_{V_0}^{ ⊗ p^b}$ and write
$\theta=u\eta^{m'}$ with $u\in k(V_0)^\times$. Adjoin one root $v$ of
$v^{m'}=u$ and normalize $V_0$ in the resulting field. This is a finite
separable cover, possibly of degree less than $m'$. Over
-$V_0\setminus\Supp\operatorname{div}(\theta)$ it is an integral component
+$V_0∖\Suppdiv(\theta)$ it is an integral component
of the torsor of $m'$th roots of the invertible section $\theta$, a
description independent of $\eta$. Since $m'$ is invertible in $k$, that
torsor is finite \'etale.
Resolve the normalization and the total inverse image of $Z_0$,
-preserving the regular \'etale open over $V_0\setminus Z_0$. We obtain a
+preserving the regular \'etale open over $V_0∖ Z_0$. We obtain a
smooth projective threefold and a generically finite separable morphism
$\pi:V\to V_0$ for which the total pullback support of $N_0$ has simple
normal crossings. The morphisms comparing divisors are
\[
-\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=large,row sep=large]
+[column sep=large,row sep=large]
V\arrow[r,"\pi"] &V_0\arrow[r,"q"]\arrow[d,"h_0"']&X\\
&Y_d\arrow[r,"f"']&Y.
-\end{tikzcd}
+
\]
Here $q,h_0,f$ are birational and $\pi$ is generically finite and
separable. Set $\rho=q\circ\pi$ and $h=h_0\circ\pi$. By
-\eqref{eq:cycle-common-pullbacks},
+(eq:cycle-common-pullbacks),
$\rho^*N_0=(f\circ h)^*N_Y$, while the Cartier divisor of
-Proposition~\ref{prop:boundary-torsion} pulls back as $h^*M$.
+Proposition~prop:boundary-torsion pulls back as $h^*M$.
The rational section $v\eta$ is a section of
-$\pi^*\omega_{V_0}^{\otimes p^b}$. The determinant of the differential is
+$\pi^*\omega_{V_0}^{ ⊗ p^b}$. The determinant of the differential is
a nonzero section of the rational line
-$\omega_V\otimes\pi^*\omega_{V_0}^{-1}$, denoted $J_\pi$; it is nonzero at
+$\omega_V ⊗ \pi^*\omega_{V_0}^{-1}$, denoted $J_\pi$; it is nonzero at
the generic point by separability. Consequently
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:canonical-root-section}
+
\psi=(v\eta)\,J_\pi^{p^b}
-\quad\text{is a rational section of }
-\omega_V^{\otimes p^b}.
-\end{equation}
-Both factors are invertible on $\pi^{-1}(V_0\setminus Z_0)$: the first is
+\quadis a rational section of
+\omega_V^{ ⊗ p^b}.
+
+Both factors are invertible on $\pi^{-1}(V_0∖ Z_0)$: the first is
a root of an invertible section, the second the Jacobian of an \'etale
-morphism. Hence $\operatorname{div}(\psi)$ is supported on
-$\pi^{-1}(Z_0)$. By \eqref{eq:cover-closed-set} each of its prime
+morphism. Hence $div(\psi)$ is supported on
+$\pi^{-1}(Z_0)$. By (eq:cover-closed-set) each of its prime
components lies in $\Supp\rho^*N_0$ or is disjoint from that support.
-\emph{A connected primitive Cartier divisor.}
+A connected primitive Cartier divisor.
Put $M_V=h^*M$ and choose a connected component $C$ of $\Supp M_V$. Since
$M$ is a positive multiple of $f^*S_Y$ and $S_Y$ is disjoint from the
other components of $N_Y$, the set $C$ is also a connected component of
$\Supp\rho^*N_0$. Write the part of $M_V$ supported on $C$ as
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:primitive-cycle}
+
aD,\qquad D=\sum_\alpha m_\alpha D_\alpha,
-\qquad a=\gcd_{D_\alpha\subset C}\operatorname{mult}_{D_\alpha}(M_V).
-\end{equation}
+\qquad a=\gcd_{D_\alpha\subset C}mult_{D_\alpha}(M_V).
+
The divisor $D$ is Cartier because $V$ is smooth, its multiplicities are
positive with gcd one, and its support is connected with simple normal
crossings.
Every curve in $\Supp M_V$ maps under $h$ to a point or to a curve in
-$\Sigma$. The projection formula and Proposition~\ref{prop:boundary-torsion}
+$Σ$. The projection formula and Proposition~prop:boundary-torsion
therefore make $M_V$ numerically trivial on every component of its
support. Near $C$ we have $M_V=aD$, so $D|_{D_\alpha}\equiv0$ for every
$\alpha$. A curve not contained in $\Supp D$ has nonnegative intersection
with $D$ by effectivity, while a curve in the support has intersection
zero. Hence $D$ is nef, and every very ample $H_V$ satisfies
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:primitive-intersections}
+
D H_V^2>0,\qquad D^2 H_V=0.
-\end{equation}
+
Torsion survives on the entire Cartier scheme. Choose $t>0$ with
$\cO_M(tM)\simeq\cO_M$. The pullback divisor $M_V$ is scheme-theoretically
@@ -1127,21 +1127,21 @@ of $M$, which is nonzero since $V$ is integral and $h$ is dominant.
Pulling back the trivialization gives
$\cO_{M_V}(tM_V)\simeq\cO_{M_V}$, with no flatness assumption on $h$.
Restricting along $D\subset M_V$ and using $M_V=aD$ near $C$ gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:primitive-torsion}
+
\cO_D(t\,a\,D)\simeq\cO_D.
-\end{equation}
+
Hence $\cO_D(D)$ is torsion.
-The section $\psi$ of \eqref{eq:canonical-root-section} has, on a
+The section $\psi$ of (eq:canonical-root-section) has, on a
neighborhood $W$ of $C$, divisor supported on $D$: its other components are
disjoint from $C$ and can be removed from that neighborhood. Thus there are
integers $b_\alpha$ with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:prepared-canonical-relation}
-\omega_V^{\otimes p^b}|_W
-\simeq\cO_W\Bigl(\sum_\alpha b_\alpha D_\alpha\Bigr).
-\end{equation}
-\emph{Numerical proportionality and very general points.}
+\omega_V^{ ⊗ p^b}|_W
+\simeq\cO_W(\sum_\alpha b_\alpha D_\alpha).
+
+
+Numerical proportionality and very general points.
It remains to show no $D$-trivial curve passes through a very general
point of $V$. Put $N_V=\rho^*N_0$. It is a nonzero nef divisor,
numerically trivial on every component of its support by the projection
@@ -1149,12 +1149,12 @@ formula. Since $\Supp D$ is contained in that support,
\[
N_V H_V^2>0,\qquad N_V^2H_V=N_V D H_V=0.
\]
-Together with \eqref{eq:primitive-intersections}, the Hodge index theorem
+Together with (eq:primitive-intersections), the Hodge index theorem
gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:cycle-proportionality}
+
D\equiv cN_V,
-\qquad c=\frac{D H_V^2}{N_V H_V^2}>0.
-\end{equation}
+\qquad c=(D H_V^2)/(N_V H_V^2)>0.
+
We verify this is numerical equivalence on every curve, not only on a
fixed hyperplane section, following \cite[Section~2.8]{Companion}.
@@ -1178,7 +1178,7 @@ positive-square class $e$, so $d-cn$ is numerically zero. The projective
surjection $\widetilde T\to T$ supplies an integral curve dominating
$\Gamma$: take the closure of a closed point of the fiber over the generic
point of $\Gamma$. The projection formula then gives
-$(D-cN_V)\cdot\Gamma=0$. This proves \eqref{eq:cycle-proportionality}.
+$(D-cN_V)\cdot\Gamma=0$. This proves (eq:cycle-proportionality).
Finally let $Z_i\subset X$ be the countably many proper closed subsets
excluded by the nef reduction of $N_0$. Remove from $V$ the
@@ -1186,142 +1186,142 @@ non-quasi-finite locus of $\rho$ and all sets $\rho^{-1}(Z_i)$. These are
proper closed subsets, since $\rho$ is dominant and generically finite,
and their complement contains very general points because $k$ is
uncountable. Every curve through a point of this complement maps to a
-curve on $X$. If it were $D$-trivial, then \eqref{eq:cycle-proportionality}
+curve on $X$. If it were $D$-trivial, then (eq:cycle-proportionality)
and the projection formula would make its image $N_0$-trivial, contradicting
-maximal nef dimension. All properties of Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction} are
+maximal nef dimension. All properties of Theorem~thm:obstruction are
now established.
-\end{proof}
-\begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:main}]
-Theorem~\ref{thm:obstruction} contradicts Proposition~\ref{prop:prepared}.
+
+Proof. [Proof of Theorem~thm:main]
+Theorem~thm:obstruction contradicts Proposition~prop:prepared.
The maximal-nef-dimension case is therefore impossible. By
-Proposition~\ref{prop:reduction}, it remains to apply abundance in nef
+Proposition~prop:reduction, it remains to apply abundance in nef
dimension at most two \cite[Theorem~1.8]{XuNonvanishing}. This gives
semiampleness, and faithful descent along the algebraic closure extension
gives it over the original field.
-\end{proof}
-\begin{thebibliography}{BCE+02}
+
+{BCE+02}
\small
-\setlength{\itemsep}{3pt}
-\setlength{\parsep}{0pt}
+
+
\bibitem[Bir16]{Birkar}
-Caucher Birkar, \emph{Existence of flips and minimal models for 3-folds in char~$p$},
-Ann. Sci. \'Ec. Norm. Sup\'er. (4) \textbf{49} (2016), no.~1, 169--212.
+Caucher Birkar, Existence of flips and minimal models for 3-folds in char~$p$,
+Ann. Sci. \'Ec. Norm. Sup\'er. (4) 49 (2016), no.~1, 169--212.
\bibitem[BW17]{BW}
Caucher Birkar and Joe Waldron,
-\emph{Existence of Mori fibre spaces for 3-folds in char~$p$},
-Adv. Math. \textbf{313} (2017), 62--101.
+Existence of Mori fibre spaces for 3-folds in char~$p$,
+Adv. Math. 313 (2017), 62--101.
\bibitem[CTX15]{CTX}
Paolo Cascini, Hiromu Tanaka and Chenyang Xu,
-\emph{On base point freeness in positive characteristic},
-Ann. Sci. \'Ec. Norm. Sup\'er. (4) \textbf{48} (2015), no.~5, 1239--1272.
+On base point freeness in positive characteristic,
+Ann. Sci. \'Ec. Norm. Sup\'er. (4) 48 (2015), no.~5, 1239--1272.
\bibitem[CJS13]{CJS}
Vincent Cossart, Uwe Jannsen and Shuji Saito,
-\emph{Canonical embedded and non-embedded resolution of singularities for excellent two-dimensional schemes},
+Canonical embedded and non-embedded resolution of singularities for excellent two-dimensional schemes,
arXiv:0905.2191, version~2, February~18, 2013; first posted 2009.
\bibitem[CP08]{CPFirst}
Vincent Cossart and Olivier Piltant,
-\emph{Resolution of singularities of threefolds in positive characteristic. I. Reduction to local uniformization on Artin--Schreier and purely inseparable coverings},
-J. Algebra \textbf{320} (2008), no.~3, 1051--1082.
+Resolution of singularities of threefolds in positive characteristic. I. Reduction to local uniformization on Artin--Schreier and purely inseparable coverings,
+J. Algebra 320 (2008), no.~3, 1051--1082.
\bibitem[CP09]{CP}
Vincent Cossart and Olivier Piltant,
-\emph{Resolution of singularities of threefolds in positive characteristic II},
-J. Algebra \textbf{321} (2009), no.~7, 1836--1976.
+Resolution of singularities of threefolds in positive characteristic II,
+J. Algebra 321 (2009), no.~7, 1836--1976.
\bibitem[HW22]{HW}
Christopher Hacon and Jakub Witaszek,
-\emph{The minimal model program for threefolds in characteristic~5},
-Duke Math. J. \textbf{171} (2022), no.~11, 2193--2231.
+The minimal model program for threefolds in characteristic~5,
+Duke Math. J. 171 (2022), no.~11, 2193--2231.
\bibitem[HX15]{HX}
Christopher D.~Hacon and Chenyang Xu,
-\emph{On the three dimensional minimal model program in positive characteristic},
-J. Amer. Math. Soc. \textbf{28} (2015), no.~3, 711--744.
+On the three dimensional minimal model program in positive characteristic,
+J. Amer. Math. Soc. 28 (2015), no.~3, 711--744.
\bibitem[HNT20]{HNT}
Kenta Hashizume, Yusuke Nakamura and Hiromu Tanaka,
-\emph{Minimal model program for log canonical threefolds in positive characteristic},
-Math. Res. Lett. \textbf{27} (2020), no.~4, 1003--1054.
+Minimal model program for log canonical threefolds in positive characteristic,
+Math. Res. Lett. 27 (2020), no.~4, 1003--1054.
\bibitem[JLR26]{JLR}
Eric Jovinelly, Brian Lehmann and Eric Riedl,
-\emph{Optimal bounds in Bend-and-Break},
-Forum Math. Pi \textbf{14} (2026), e16, 1--4.
+Optimal bounds in Bend-and-Break,
+Forum Math. Pi 14 (2026), e16, 1--4.
\bibitem[Kaw92]{Kawamata}
-Yujiro Kawamata, \emph{Abundance theorem for minimal threefolds},
-Invent. Math. \textbf{108} (1992), 229--246.
+Yujiro Kawamata, Abundance theorem for minimal threefolds,
+Invent. Math. 108 (1992), 229--246.
\bibitem[Kee99]{Keel}
Se\'an Keel,
-\emph{Basepoint freeness for nef and big line bundles in positive characteristic},
-Ann. of Math. (2) \textbf{149} (1999), no.~1, 253--286.
+Basepoint freeness for nef and big line bundles in positive characteristic,
+Ann. of Math. (2) 149 (1999), no.~1, 253--286.
\bibitem[KMM94]{KMM}
Sean Keel, Kenji Matsuki and James McKernan,
-\emph{Log abundance theorem for threefolds},
-Duke Math. J. \textbf{75} (1994), no.~1, 99--119.
+Log abundance theorem for threefolds,
+Duke Math. J. 75 (1994), no.~1, 99--119.
\bibitem[KMM04]{KMMCorrection}
Sean Keel, Kenji Matsuki and James McKernan,
-\emph{Corrections to: ``Log abundance theorem for threefolds''},
-Duke Math. J. \textbf{122} (2004), no.~3, 625--630.
+Corrections to: ``Log abundance theorem for threefolds'',
+Duke Math. J. 122 (2004), no.~3, 625--630.
\bibitem[KM98]{KM}
J\'anos Koll\'ar and Shigefumi Mori,
-\emph{Birational Geometry of Algebraic Varieties},
+Birational Geometry of Algebraic Varieties,
Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, vol.~134, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1998; with the collaboration of C.~H.~Clemens and A.~Corti.
\bibitem[Miy88]{Miyaoka}
-Yoichi Miyaoka, \emph{Abundance conjecture for 3-folds: case $\nu=1$},
-Compositio Math. \textbf{68} (1988), no.~2, 203--220.
+Yoichi Miyaoka, Abundance conjecture for 3-folds: case $\nu=1$,
+Compositio Math. 68 (1988), no.~2, 203--220.
\bibitem[OAI26]{Companion}
OpenAI,
-\emph{Abundance in numerical dimension one for terminal threefolds in positive characteristic},
+Abundance in numerical dimension one for terminal threefolds in positive characteristic,
OpenAI Math Release preprint,
-\href{https://github.com/openai/math/blob/main/preprints/Abundance-in-numerical-dimension-one-for-terminal-threefolds-in-positive-characteristic-September-24-2026/paper.pdf}{OAI preprint}, 2026.
+OAI preprint, 2026.
\bibitem[Pos23]{Posva}
-Quentin Posva, \emph{Abundance for slc surfaces over arbitrary fields},
-\'Epijournal G\'eom. Alg\'ebrique \textbf{7} (2023), article no.~5, 23~pp.
+Quentin Posva, Abundance for slc surfaces over arbitrary fields,
+\'Epijournal G\'eom. Alg\'ebrique 7 (2023), article no.~5, 23~pp.
\bibitem[Tan16]{Tanaka}
Hiromu Tanaka,
-\emph{Abundance theorem for semi log canonical surfaces in positive characteristic},
-Osaka J. Math. \textbf{53} (2016), no.~2, 535--566.
+Abundance theorem for semi log canonical surfaces in positive characteristic,
+Osaka J. Math. 53 (2016), no.~2, 535--566.
\bibitem[Wal18]{Waldron}
-Joe Waldron, \emph{The LMMP for log canonical 3-folds in characteristic $p>5$},
-Nagoya Math. J. \textbf{230} (2018), 48--71.
+Joe Waldron, The LMMP for log canonical 3-folds in characteristic $p>5$,
+Nagoya Math. J. 230 (2018), 48--71.
\bibitem[Wit21]{Witaszek}
Jakub Witaszek,
-\emph{On the canonical bundle formula and log abundance in positive characteristic},
-Math. Ann. \textbf{381} (2021), no.~3--4, 1309--1344.
+On the canonical bundle formula and log abundance in positive characteristic,
+Math. Ann. 381 (2021), no.~3--4, 1309--1344.
\bibitem[XZ19]{XZ}
Chenyang Xu and Lei Zhang,
-\emph{Nonvanishing for 3-folds in characteristic $p>5$},
-Duke Math. J. \textbf{168} (2019), no.~7, 1269--1301.
+Nonvanishing for 3-folds in characteristic $p>5$,
+Duke Math. J. 168 (2019), no.~7, 1269--1301.
\bibitem[Xu24]{XuNonvanishing}
Zheng Xu,
-\emph{Note on the three-dimensional log canonical abundance in characteristic $>3$},
-Nagoya Math. J. \textbf{255} (2024), 694--723.
+Note on the three-dimensional log canonical abundance in characteristic $>3$,
+Nagoya Math. J. 255 (2024), 694--723.
\bibitem[Xu26]{XuNuTwo}
-Zheng Xu, \emph{Abundance for threefolds in positive characteristic when $\nu=2$},
-Compositio Math. \textbf{162} (2026), no.~9, 2065--2099.
+Zheng Xu, Abundance for threefolds in positive characteristic when $\nu=2$,
+Compositio Math. 162 (2026), no.~9, 2065--2099.
+
+
-\end{thebibliography}
-\end{document}