diff 7e35b30..b34550f sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
diff --git a/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt b/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
index aa2f488..e36f74f 100644
--- a/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
+++ b/sharp_matrix_lieb_thirring_v2.txt
@@ -19,211 +19,211 @@
% Section 8 from equality to pointwise matrix relations
% Section 9 fixed channels, the profile, complex W, attainability
% =====================================================================
-\documentclass[11pt]{article}
-\usepackage[T1]{fontenc}
-\usepackage{lmodern}
-\usepackage[margin=1.07in]{geometry}
-\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools}
-\usepackage{mathrsfs}
-\usepackage{microtype}
-\usepackage{hyperref}
-\newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section]
-\newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition}
-\newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma}
-\theoremstyle{remark}
-\newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark}
-\newcommand{\R}{\mathbb R}
-\newcommand{\C}{\mathbb C}
-\newcommand{\HS}{\mathrm{HS}}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\tr}{tr}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\Tr}{Tr}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\Sym}{Sym}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\sech}{sech}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\diag}{diag}
-\DeclareMathOperator{\op}{op}
-\numberwithin{equation}{section}
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
\allowdisplaybreaks[2]
-\title{Equality cases in the sharp one-dimensional\\[2pt]
-matrix Lieb--Thirring inequality\\[6pt]\large a complete proof}
-\author{}
-\date{}
+# Equality cases in the sharp one-dimensional\\[2pt]
+matrix Lieb--Thirring inequality\\[6pt]\large a complete proof
+
+
+
-\begin{document}
\maketitle
-\begin{abstract}
+Abstract:
We classify all equality cases in the sharp one-dimensional Lieb--Thirring
inequality, for every finite matrix size and every exponent
$1/2<\gamma<3/2$. For a measurable Hermitian positive semidefinite
-potential $W$ with $\int_\R\tr(W^{\gamma+1/2})<\infty$, equality holds
+potential $W$ with $\int_\R\tr(W^{\gamma+1/2})<∞$, equality holds
exactly when, in one constant unitary basis, $W$ is a direct sum of scalar
one-bound-state solitons and zero channels, with independent scales and
centres. Every step is proved here.
-\end{abstract}
+
\tableofcontents
% =====================================================================
-\section{The problem, the answer, and the idea}\label{sec:intro}
+# The problem, the answer, and the idea
% =====================================================================
-\subsection{What is being estimated}
+## What is being estimated
Fix an integer $m\ge1$ (the number of internal ``channels''). A
-\emph{potential} is a measurable function $W:\R\to\C^{m\times m}$ whose
+potential is a measurable function $W:\R\to\C^{m\times m}$ whose
values are Hermitian and positive semidefinite. Think of $-\Delta$ acting
on vector-valued functions $\psi:\R\to\C^m$, and of $W$ as a position
dependent multiplication operator. The Schr\"odinger operator
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:Ham}
- H_W=-\frac{d^2}{dx^2}-W
-\end{equation}
+
+ H_W=-(d^2)/(dx^2)-W
+
is unbounded below when $W$ is large, but it has only finitely many
-negative eigenvalues below any fixed level (Lemma~\ref{lem:spectral}).
+negative eigenvalues below any fixed level (Lemma~lem:spectral).
Write $\lambda_j(H_W)$ for the eigenvalues, counted with multiplicity, and
for $1/2<\gamma<3/2$ set
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:moment}
+
\Tr(H_W)_-^\gamma
- =\sum_{\lambda_j(H_W)<0}\bigl|\lambda_j(H_W)\bigr|^\gamma .
-\end{equation}
+ =\sum_{\lambda_j(H_W)<0}|\lambda_j(H_W)|^\gamma .
+
Here $\tr$ is the unnormalised trace on $\C^{m\times m}$, and $W^p$ is
defined by spectral calculus.
-\subsection{The inequality and its constant}
+## The inequality and its constant
The sharp Lieb--Thirring inequality in one dimension is
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:sharp}
+
\Tr(H_W)_-^\gamma
- \le C_\gamma\int_\R\tr\bigl(W(x)^p\bigr)\,dx,
+ \le C_\gamma\int_\R\tr(W(x)^p)\,dx,
\qquad p=\gamma+\tfrac12,
-\end{equation}
+
with the explicit constant
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:Cgamma}
+
C_\gamma
- =\Bigl(\frac{\gamma-1/2}{\gamma+1/2}\Bigr)^{\gamma-1/2}
- \frac{\Gamma(\gamma+1)}{\sqrt\pi\,\Gamma(\gamma+3/2)} .
-\end{equation}
+ =((\gamma-1/2)/(\gamma+1/2))^{\gamma-1/2}
+ (\Gamma(\gamma+1))/(\sqrt\pi\,\Gamma(\gamma+3/2)) .
+
The inequality itself is due to Lieb and Thirring and, in this matrix
-form, to the companion paper \cite{MLT}. The new content here is the
-\emph{equality} statement, proved together with the inequality so that
+form, to the companion paper [cite]. The new content here is the
+equality statement, proved together with the inequality so that
both rest on the same estimates.
-\subsection{The answer}
+## The answer
Set
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:r}
- r=\frac{1}{\gamma-1/2}>1 .
-\end{equation}
+
+ r=(1)/(\gamma-1/2)>1 .
+
The extremal potentials are built from the single scalar profile
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:profile}
- w(x)=(r+1)a^2\,\sech^2\!\bigl(r\,a\,(x-x_0)\bigr),
+
+ w(x)=(r+1)a^2\,\sech^2\!(r\,a\,(x-x_0)),
\qquad a>0,\ x_0\in\R ,
-\end{equation}
+
which has exactly one negative eigenvalue, namely $-a^2$, and saturates
-\eqref{eq:sharp} by itself.
+(eq:sharp) by itself.
-\begin{theorem}[Equality classification]\label{thm:main}
+[Equality classification]
Let $m\ge1$, $1/2<\gamma<3/2$, $p=\gamma+\tfrac12$, and let $W$ be a
measurable Hermitian positive semidefinite potential with
-$\int_\R\tr(W^p)<\infty$. Then \eqref{eq:sharp} holds. Moreover,
-equality holds if and only if there are an integer $k\in\{0,\dots,m\}$,
-a constant unitary matrix $U$, positive numbers $a_1,\dots,a_k$, and real
-centres $x_1,\dots,x_k$ such that, for almost every $x$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:classification}
- W(x)=U\,\diag\bigl(w_1(x),\dots,w_k(x),0,\dots,0\bigr)\,U^* ,
+$\int_\R\tr(W^p)<∞$. Then (eq:sharp) holds. Moreover,
+equality holds if and only if there are an integer $k\in\{0,...,m\}$,
+a constant unitary matrix $U$, positive numbers $a_1,...,a_k$, and real
+centres $x_1,...,x_k$ such that, for almost every $x$,
+
+ W(x)=U\,\diag(w_1(x),...,w_k(x),0,...,0)\,U^* ,
\qquad
- w_j(x)=(r+1)a_j^2\,\sech^2\!\bigl(r a_j (x-x_j)\bigr).
-\end{equation}
+ w_j(x)=(r+1)a_j^2\,\sech^2\!(r a_j (x-x_j)).
+
The case $k=0$ means $W=0$. Each nonzero channel carries exactly one
negative eigenvalue $-a_j^2$, so every extremal potential has at most $m$
negative eigenvalues counted with multiplicity. The scales $a_j$ and
centres $x_j$ are independent, and coincident profiles are allowed.
-\end{theorem}
-\subsection{The idea of the proof}
+
+## The idea of the proof
The proof has six moves. We state them now so the reader knows where
each later section is going.
-\begin{enumerate}
-\item[(1)] \emph{Linearise the spectrum.} Approximate finitely many
+
+\item[(1)] Linearise the spectrum. Approximate finitely many
negative eigenfunctions by smooth compactly supported trial functions and
arrange them as the rows of a matrix $U(x)$. A lower triangular matrix
$C$ keeps the rows in successive spans; this is what makes the energies
$\ell_i^2$ appear in order. This is the standard trial-function step of
the inequality.
-\item[(2)] \emph{Build an action.} For a diagonal matrix $K$ of trial
+\item[(2)] Build an action. For a diagonal matrix $K$ of trial
root-energies, define the energy
$\mathcal E_K(A)=\int(\|A'\|_{\HS}^2+\tr(K^2AA^T)-\tr((AA^T)^q))$. It is
the trial-function energy written in matrix language.
-\item[(3)] \emph{Insert a matrix path.} A symmetric path $B(x)$ running
+\item[(3)] Insert a matrix path. A symmetric path $B(x)$ running
from $K$ at the left end of the interval to $-K$ at the right end turns
the action into a square plus a boundary term (complete the square):
\[
- \mathcal E_K(A)=\text{(boundary)}+\int\bigl(\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2-F(A,B)\bigr).
+ \mathcal E_K(A)=(boundary)+\int(\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2-F(A,B)).
\]
The boundary term produces exactly $b_\sigma\sum\ell_i^{2\gamma}$.
-\item[(4)] \emph{Keep the defect.} Equality forces the square
+\item[(4)] Keep the defect. Equality forces the square
$\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2$ and an algebraic defect
$\Phi_K(A,B)=\|[B,K^2]\|_{\op}^2+\|K^2-B^2-(AA^T)^r\|_{\op}^2$ to vanish.
The trace engine of Section~4 is what makes the coefficient of $\Phi_K$
uniform in the number of rows. This uniformity is essential because the
number of negative eigenvalues is not known in advance to be finite.
-\item[(5)] \emph{Pass to a limit.} The number of rows may grow without
+\item[(5)] Pass to a limit. The number of rows may grow without
bound while the number $m$ of columns stays fixed. The fixed column
count bounds the tail rows by the small energies, giving strong pointwise
convergence and exact algebraic relations in the limit.
-\item[(6)] \emph{Solve the leftover ODE.} The limit relations force the
+\item[(6)] Solve the leftover ODE. The limit relations force the
channel subspaces to be constant in $x$. On each channel a matrix
Riccati equation reduces to a scalar equation whose only bounded
-solutions are the profiles \eqref{eq:profile}. This yields
-Theorem~\ref{thm:main}, and a direct factorization check proves that every
+solutions are the profiles (eq:profile). This yields
+Theorem~thm:main, and a direct factorization check proves that every
listed potential attains equality.
-\end{enumerate}
-\subsection{Brief history}
+
+## Brief history
Lieb and Thirring introduced spectral moment inequalities for the kinetic
-energy of fermions \cite{LiebThirring1975,LiebThirring1976}. The sharp
+energy of fermions [cite]. The sharp
scalar endpoint $\gamma=1/2$ is due to Hundertmark--Lieb--Thomas
-\cite{HLT1998}, extended to operator-valued potentials by
-Hundertmark--Laptev--Weidl \cite{HLW2000}. The semiclassical constant is
+[cite], extended to operator-valued potentials by
+Hundertmark--Laptev--Weidl [cite]. The semiclassical constant is
sharp for $\gamma\ge3/2$; the relevant tools are the moment lifting of
-Aizenman--Lieb \cite{AizenmanLieb1978} and the operator-valued inequalities
-of Laptev--Weidl \cite{LaptevWeidl2000}. Benguria--Loss \cite{BenguriaLoss2000}
+Aizenman--Lieb [cite] and the operator-valued inequalities
+of Laptev--Weidl [cite]. Benguria--Loss [cite]
gave a commutation proof at $\gamma=3/2$. The one-state scalar profile
-\eqref{eq:profile} goes back to Keller \cite{Keller1961}; its role in the
+(eq:profile) goes back to Keller [cite]; its role in the
Lieb--Thirring problem is explained in \cite[Section~4]{LiebThirring1976}.
At the endpoint $\gamma=3/2$ the equality structure changes: Frank, Gontier
-and Lewin \cite{FrankGontierLewin2025} show that several bound states can
+and Lewin [cite] show that several bound states can
share a single scalar channel (KdV multisolitons). The strict inequality
$r>1$ used below is exactly what rules that out in the open interval.
% =====================================================================
-\section{Notation and the four constants}\label{sec:notation}
+# Notation and the four constants
% =====================================================================
Throughout,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:params}
+
\sigma=\gamma-\tfrac12\in(0,1),\qquad
p=1+\sigma=\gamma+\tfrac12,\qquad
r=\frac1\sigma>1,\qquad
q=r+1 .
-\end{equation}
+
Note the identities
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:identities}
+
2\sigma+1=2\gamma,\qquad rp=q=1+r .
-\end{equation}
+
Two constants recur:
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:Dconst}
+
D_\sigma=\frac{\sigma^\sigma}{(1+\sigma)^{1+\sigma}},
\qquad
b_\sigma=\int_{-1}^{1}(1-s^2)^\sigma\,ds .
-\end{equation}
-They are linked to \eqref{eq:Cgamma} by the beta integral:
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:Crelation}
- C_\gamma=\frac{D_\sigma}{b_\sigma}.
-\end{equation}
+
+They are linked to (eq:Cgamma) by the beta integral:
+
+ C_\gamma=(D_\sigma)/(b_\sigma).
+
We use the operator norm $\|\cdot\|_{\op}$ and the Hilbert--Schmidt norm
$\|A\|_{\HS}^2=\tr(A^*A)$. For real matrices $T$ also denotes transpose.
$\Sym_n$ is the space of real symmetric $n\times n$ matrices with inner
@@ -231,57 +231,57 @@ product $\tr(BH)$; the commutator is $[B,H]=BH-HB$. The identity matrix
or operator has the size forced by context.
% =====================================================================
-\section{Two elementary lemmas}\label{sec:prelim}
+# Two elementary lemmas
% =====================================================================
-\subsection{The spectrum is discrete and the form is closed}
+## The spectrum is discrete and the form is closed
The first lemma says we may freely talk about ``the'' negative eigenvalues,
even when $W$ is only measurable.
-\begin{lemma}[Spectral facts]\label{lem:spectral}
+[Spectral facts]
Let $p>1$ and let $W:\R\to\C^{m\times m}$ be measurable, Hermitian and
-positive semidefinite, with $\int_\R\tr(W^p)<\infty$. The quadratic form
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:form}
- h_W[\psi]=\int_\R\|\psi'\|^2-\int_\R\langle\psi,W\psi\rangle,
+positive semidefinite, with $\int_\R\tr(W^p)<∞$. The quadratic form
+
+ h_W[\psi]=\int_\R\|\psi'\|^2-\int_\R<\psi,W\psi>,
\qquad \psi\in H^1(\R;\C^m),
-\end{equation}
+
is closed and bounded below. Multiplication by $W^{1/2}$ is compact from
$H^1$ to $L^2$. The negative spectrum of $H_W$ consists of isolated
eigenvalues of finite multiplicity, accumulating at most at $0$. Every
eigenfunction lies in $H^1$ and solves $-\psi''-W\psi=\lambda\psi$ in
distributions.
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
+
+Proof.
Put $w=\|W\|_{\op}$. Then $0\le w^p\le\tr(W^p)$, so $w\in L^p(\R)$. The
one-dimensional Sobolev bound, applied to the vector $x\mapsto\|\psi(x)\|$,
-reads $\|\psi\|_\infty^2\le 2\|\psi\|_2\|\psi'\|_2$. Hence, by
+reads $\|\psi\|_∞^2\le 2\|\psi\|_2\|\psi'\|_2$. Hence, by
H\"older and Young,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:formbound}
- \int_\R\langle\psi,W\psi\rangle
+
+ \int_\R<\psi,W\psi>
\le 2^{1/p}\|w\|_p\|\psi'\|_2^{1/p}\|\psi\|_2^{2-1/p}
- \le \varepsilon\|\psi'\|_2^2
- +C_\varepsilon\|\psi\|_2^2 .
-\end{equation}
+ \le ε\|\psi'\|_2^2
+ +C_ε\|\psi\|_2^2 .
+
So a suitably shifted form norm is equivalent to the $H^1$ norm: the form
is closed and bounded below, and by polarization the potential term is
continuous on $H^1$.
Let $T\psi=W^{1/2}\psi$. For $R,L>0$ define the truncated multiplier
$T_{R,L}$ by keeping only $\{|x|\le R,\ w\le L\}$. By the compact
-embedding $H^1([-R,R])\hookrightarrow L^2([-R,R])$, each $T_{R,L}$ is
+embedding $H^1([-R,R])↪ L^2([-R,R])$, each $T_{R,L}$ is
compact, and
\[
\|(T-T_{R,L})\psi\|_2^2
\le C\,\bigl\|w\,\mathbf 1_{\{|x|>R\}\cup\{w>L\}}\bigr\|_p
\|\psi\|_{H^1}^2 .
\]
-The prefactor tends to zero as $R,L\to\infty$, so $T$ is a norm limit of
+The prefactor tends to zero as $R,L\to∞$, so $T$ is a norm limit of
compact operators, hence compact.
-Now fix $a>0$. If the spectral subspace of $H_W$ in $(-\infty,-a]$ were
+Now fix $a>0$. If the spectral subspace of $H_W$ in $(-∞,-a]$ were
infinite dimensional, it would contain an orthonormal sequence bounded in
-$H^1$ by \eqref{eq:formbound}. A subsequence converges weakly to zero in
+$H^1$ by (eq:formbound). A subsequence converges weakly to zero in
$H^1$, so its $T$-images converge strongly to zero; but for unit vectors
in that subspace $h_W[\psi]\ge-a\ge-\|T\psi\|_2^2$, forcing
$\|T\psi\|_2^2\ge a$, a contradiction. Thus every such subspace is finite
@@ -289,53 +289,53 @@ dimensional.
Finally test the weak form equation against smooth compactly supported
functions: this gives the stated distributional equation. Its potential
-term is locally integrable because $W\in L^p_{\mathrm{loc}}$ and $\psi$ is
+term is locally integrable because $W\in L^p_{loc}$ and $\psi$ is
locally bounded.
-\end{proof}
-\subsection{Young's inequality for matrices}
+
+## Young's inequality for matrices
This is the scalar inequality $yz-z^q\le D_\sigma y^p$ promoted to
matrices, together with its equality condition.
-\begin{lemma}[Trace Young inequality]\label{lem:young}
+[Trace Young inequality]
For positive semidefinite matrices $W,Z$ of the same finite size, put
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:youngdefect}
+
Y(W,Z)=D_\sigma\tr(W^p)-\tr(WZ)+\tr(Z^q).
-\end{equation}
+
Then $Y(W,Z)\ge0$, with equality if and only if $W=qZ^r$. Moreover
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:youngcoercive}
+
Y(W,Z)\ge\tfrac12\tr(Z^q)
-(2^{p-1}-1)D_\sigma\tr(W^p).
-\end{equation}
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
+
+
+Proof.
Maximise $z\mapsto yz-z^q$ over $z\ge0$ for fixed $y\ge0$. The maximum
$D_\sigma y^p$ is attained exactly at $y=qz^r$; this is the scalar Young
-inequality behind $D_\sigma$ in \eqref{eq:Dconst}. Choose an orthonormal
+inequality behind $D_\sigma$ in (eq:Dconst). Choose an orthonormal
eigenbasis $(v_j)$ of $Z$ with eigenvalues $z_j$, and set
-$y_j=\langle v_j,Wv_j\rangle$. By \eqref{eq:youngdefect} and the scalar
+$y_j=< v_j,Wv_j>$. By (eq:youngdefect) and the scalar
inequality,
\[
\tr(WZ)-\tr(Z^q)
=\sum_j (y_j z_j - z_j^q)
\le D_\sigma\sum_j y_j^p .
\]
-Because $t^p$ is strictly convex on $[0,\infty)$,
-$\sum_j y_j^p\le\sum_j\langle v_j,W^p v_j\rangle=\tr(W^p)$.
+Because $t^p$ is strictly convex on $[0,∞)$,
+$\sum_j y_j^p\le\sum_j< v_j,W^p v_j>=\tr(W^p)$.
Thus $Y(W,Z)\ge0$. Equality in the convexity step forces every $v_j$ to
lie in an eigenspace of $W$; equality in the scalar step then forces
$Wv_j=qz_j^r v_j$ for every $j$, i.e.\ $W=qZ^r$. This covers zero
eigenvalues as well.
-For \eqref{eq:youngcoercive}, apply the already proven $Y\ge0$ to the pair
+For (eq:youngcoercive), apply the already proven $Y\ge0$ to the pair
$(2W,Z)$ and expand:
$\tr(2WZ)\le\tfrac12\tr(Z^q)+2^{p-1}D_\sigma\tr(W^p)$, which rearranges
-to \eqref{eq:youngcoercive}.
-\end{proof}
+to (eq:youngcoercive).
+
% =====================================================================
-\section{The trace engine: an exact integrated deficit}\label{sec:trace}
+# The trace engine: an exact integrated deficit
% =====================================================================
The action estimate compares a matrix $N$ against its power $N^q$. The
@@ -346,96 +346,96 @@ is that it is an identity, not just an inequality, so a vanishing total
gap forces each square to vanish.
Throughout this section $0<\sigma<1$, $\beta=\sigma-\tfrac12$, and
-$p=1+\sigma$, $r=1/\sigma$, $q=1+r$ as in \eqref{eq:params}.
+$p=1+\sigma$, $r=1/\sigma$, $q=1+r$ as in (eq:params).
-\subsection{The normalisation constant}
+## The normalisation constant
Define $c_\sigma>0$ by
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:normalization}
+
c_\sigma^{-1}
- =\int_0^\infty t^\beta
- \bigl(t^{-1/2}-(t+1)^{-1/2}\bigr)\,dt .
-\end{equation}
+ =\int_0^∞ t^\beta
+ (t^{-1/2}-(t+1)^{-1/2})\,dt .
+
The integrand is $O(t^{\sigma-1})$ near $0$ and $O(t^{\sigma-2})$ near
-$\infty$, so the integral converges (this uses $0<\sigma<1$). A change of
+$∞$, so the integral converges (this uses $0<\sigma<1$). A change of
variable gives the scaling identity we will use constantly:
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:scaling}
- c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta
- \bigl(t^{-1/2}-(t+y)^{-1/2}\bigr)\,dt=y^\sigma,
+
+ c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta
+ (t^{-1/2}-(t+y)^{-1/2})\,dt=y^\sigma,
\qquad y\ge0 .
-\end{equation}
+
Indeed, substitute $t=yu$; the left side becomes
-$c_\sigma y^{\beta+1/2}\int_0^\infty u^\beta(u^{-1/2}-(u+1)^{-1/2})\,du
-=y^\sigma$ by \eqref{eq:trace:normalization} and $\beta+\tfrac12=\sigma$.
+$c_\sigma y^{\beta+1/2}\int_0^∞ u^\beta(u^{-1/2}-(u+1)^{-1/2})\,du
+=y^\sigma$ by (eq:trace:normalization) and $\beta+\tfrac12=\sigma$.
-\subsection{Statement of the engine}
+## Statement of the engine
-\begin{theorem}[Exact integrated trace deficit]\label{thm:trace}
+[Exact integrated trace deficit]
Let $n\ge1$ and let $B,V\in\C^{n\times n}$ be Hermitian. Suppose
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:symbol}
+
Y_s=(sI-B)^2,\qquad X_s=Y_s+V\ge bI\quad(s\in\R)
-\end{equation}
+
for some $b>0$. Define
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:resolvents}
+
R(t)=\frac1\pi\int_\R(X_s+tI)^{-1}\,ds,
\qquad
P(t)=t^{-1/2}I-R(t),\qquad t>0,
-\end{equation}
+
and
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:N}
- N=c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta P(t)\,dt .
-\end{equation}
+
+ N=c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta P(t)\,dt .
+
Then these integrals converge absolutely in matrix norm, $R(t)>0$, and
there are continuous Hermitian matrices $L(t)=R(t)^{-1}>0$ and $Z(t)$
with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:LZ}
+
V+tI=L^2+Z^2+i[B,Z],
\qquad
LZ+ZL+i[B,L]=0 .
-\end{equation}
+
If $N\ge0$, then
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:deficit}
- \begin{aligned}
+
+
\tr(NV)-\tr(N^q)
- =c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta\Bigl(
+ =c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta(
&\tr(RZ^2)\\
&+q\bigl\|R^{-1/2}-R^{1/2}(tI+N^r)^{1/2}\bigr\|_{\HS}^2
- \Bigr)\,dt .
- \end{aligned}
-\end{equation}
+ )\,dt .
+
+
In particular $\tr(NV)\ge\tr(N^q)$, and equality holds if and only if both
integrands vanish for every $t>0$.
-\end{theorem}
+
The hypothesis concerns the full symbol $X_s$; the perturbation $V$ itself
need not be positive. The proof has three parts: recover $L,Z$ from
half-line boundary values, evaluate a logarithmic determinant integral,
and complete a matrix square.
-\subsection{Step 1: half-line boundary maps}
-Quadratic growth of $X_s$ together with \eqref{eq:trace:symbol} gives an
+## Step 1: half-line boundary maps
+Quadratic growth of $X_s$ together with (eq:trace:symbol) gives an
integrable bound for $X_s^{-1}$, hence $R(t)>0$ and $R(t)=O(1)$ as
-$t\downarrow0$. Diagonalising $B$ gives the free identity
+$t↓0$. Diagonalising $B$ gives the free identity
$\frac1\pi\int_\R(Y_s+tI)^{-1}\,ds=t^{-1/2}I$. For $t\ge1$ both
$X_s+tI$ and $Y_s+tI$ dominate $c(s^2+t)I$ with $c>0$ independent of
$s,t$; the resolvent identity bounds the difference of inverses by
$C(s^2+t)^{-2}$. Consequently
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:Pbounds}
+
\|P(t)\|_{\op}=
- \begin{cases}
- O(t^{-1/2}), & t\downarrow0,\\
- O(t^{-3/2}), & t\to\infty,
- \end{cases}
-\end{equation}
-which proves convergence of $N$ in \eqref{eq:trace:N}.
-
-Fix $t>0$ and write $\nabla=\partial_x-iB$. Consider
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:ode}
+
+ O(t^{-1/2}), & t↓0,\\
+ O(t^{-3/2}), & t\to∞,
+
+
+which proves convergence of $N$ in (eq:trace:N).
+
+Fix $t>0$ and write $\nabla=∂_x-iB$. Consider
+
(-\nabla^2+V+tI)\psi=0 .
-\end{equation}
+
For each $v\in\C^n$ there is a unique $H^1$ solution on either half-line
with $\psi(0)=v$. The sesquilinear form
-$a_t(\phi,\psi)=\int(\langle\nabla\phi,\nabla\psi\rangle
-+\langle\phi,(V+tI)\psi\rangle)\,dx$ is coercive on $H^1(\R;\C^n)$, since
+$a_t(\phi,\psi)=\int(<\nabla\phi,\nabla\psi>
++<\phi,(V+tI)\psi>)\,dx$ is coercive on $H^1(\R;\C^n)$, since
its Fourier symbol $X_s+tI$ dominates $c_t(1+s^2)I$; zero extension gives
coercivity on the trace-zero subspaces of each half-line, and the Riesz
representation theorem supplies the unique weak solution. The equation
@@ -443,18 +443,18 @@ gives $\psi''\in L^2$, so $\psi\in H^2$, and both $\psi$ and $\psi'$
vanish at the infinite end.
Define the right and left boundary matrices $S,T$ by
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:boundary}
+
\nabla\psi(0+)=-Sv,\qquad \nabla\psi(0-)=Tv .
-\end{equation}
+
Integrating by parts gives
-$a_t(\psi_v,\psi_w)=\langle v,Sw\rangle$ on the right and
-$=\langle v,Tw\rangle$ on the left, so $S,T$ are Hermitian. Translation
+$a_t(\psi_v,\psi_w)=< v,Sw>$ on the right and
+$=< v,Tw>$ on the left, so $S,T$ are Hermitian. Translation
and uniqueness show $\nabla\psi=-S\psi$ throughout the right half-line
and $\nabla\psi=T\psi$ throughout the left half-line. Substituting into
-\eqref{eq:trace:ode} with arbitrary boundary data,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:riccati}
+(eq:trace:ode) with arbitrary boundary data,
+
V+tI=S^2+i[B,S]=T^2-i[B,T] .
-\end{equation}
+
Glue the two half-line solutions with the same boundary value $v$. The
result is continuous with derivative jump $-(S+T)v$, so
@@ -466,12 +466,12 @@ $e^{-isx}$ gives
\]
The inverse symbol is $O(s^{-2})$, so its Fourier inverse is continuous
and evaluation at zero is legitimate. Therefore
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:LZdef}
+
L:=\tfrac12(S+T)=R^{-1}>0,
\qquad Z:=\tfrac12(S-T)
-\end{equation}
-satisfy \eqref{eq:trace:LZ}: adding and subtracting the two halves of
-\eqref{eq:trace:riccati} gives the first equation, and the second holds
+
+satisfy (eq:trace:LZ): adding and subtracting the two halves of
+(eq:trace:riccati) gives the first equation, and the second holds
because $LZ+ZL=\tfrac12(S^2-T^2)$ and $i[B,L]=\tfrac i2[B,S+T]$. The
equation $LZ+ZL+i[B,L]=0$ determines $Z$ uniquely from $L>0$ (in an
eigenbasis of $L$ the map $Z\mapsto LZ+ZL$ multiplies the $(j,k)$ entry
@@ -481,105 +481,105 @@ Two consequences will be used. First, the diagonal of the second
relation gives $\tr Z=0$. Second, multiplying $i[R,B]=-(ZR+RZ)$ (the
$R$-conjugate of the second relation) into the trace of $R(V+tI)$ gives
the signed identity
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:RV}
- \tr\bigl(R(V+tI)\bigr)=\tr L-\tr(RZ^2),
-\end{equation}
+
+ \tr(R(V+tI))=\tr L-\tr(RZ^2),
+
where the sign comes from $i\,\tr(R[B,Z])=-2\tr(RZ^2)$.
-\subsection{Step 2: a logarithmic determinant integral}
+## Step 2: a logarithmic determinant integral
Define
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:F}
- F(t)=\frac{\tr V}{\sqrt t}
+
+ F(t)=(\tr V)/(\sqrt t)
-\frac1\pi\int_\R
- \log\frac{\det(X_s+tI)}{\det(Y_s+tI)}\,ds .
-\end{equation}
+ \log(\det(X_s+tI))/(\det(Y_s+tI))\,ds .
+
Both determinants are positive and the logarithmic ratio is
$O(|s|^{-2})$ at infinity; its $t$-derivative is the trace of a resolvent
difference with an integrable bound, locally uniform in $t>0$. Hence $F$
is continuously differentiable. The first relation in
-\eqref{eq:trace:riccati} factors the symbol,
+(eq:trace:riccati) factors the symbol,
\[
X_s+tI=(sI-B+iS)(sI-B-iS).
\]
If $u_j+iv_j$ are the eigenvalues of $B+iS$, counted with algebraic
multiplicity, then the square-integrability argument behind
-\eqref{eq:trace:ode} forces $v_j>0$, and
+(eq:trace:ode) forces $v_j>0$, and
$\det(X_s+tI)=\prod_j((s-u_j)^2+v_j^2)$. The denominator has the same
form with centres the eigenvalues of $B$ and widths $\sqrt t$.
Translations of individual logarithms only change symmetric-cutoff
integrals by $o(1)$ (the derivative
-$\frac{d}{da}\int_{-M}^M h(s-a)\,ds=h(M+a)-h(M-a)\to0$ uniformly for
+$(d)/(da)\int_{-M}^M h(s-a)\,ds=h(M+a)-h(M-a)\to0$ uniformly for
bounded $a$). Using the one-factor integral
-$\int_\R\log\frac{s^2+v^2}{s^2+w^2}\,ds=2\pi(v-w)$ for $v,w>0$, and
+$\int_\R\log(s^2+v^2)/(s^2+w^2)\,ds=2\pi(v-w)$ for $v,w>0$, and
$\sum_jv_j=\tr S=\tr L$, we obtain
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:Feval}
- F(t)=\frac{\tr V}{\sqrt t}-2\tr(L-\sqrt t I).
-\end{equation}
+
+ F(t)=(\tr V)/(\sqrt t)-2\tr(L-\sqrt t I).
+
Set
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:G}
+
G(t)=\tr(L-2\sqrt t I+tR).
-\end{equation}
+
Both $F,G\ge0$: for $G$ apply $\lambda-2\sqrt t+t/\lambda\ge0$ to the
positive eigenvalues $\lambda$ of $L$; for $F$ use
-\eqref{eq:trace:Feval} with $\tr V=\tr(L^2+Z^2)-nt$ (the trace of the
-first relation in \eqref{eq:trace:LZ}) to get
+(eq:trace:Feval) with $\tr V=\tr(L^2+Z^2)-nt$ (the trace of the
+first relation in (eq:trace:LZ)) to get
$F(t)=t^{-1/2}\tr((L-\sqrt t I)^2+Z^2)\ge0$. Combining
-\eqref{eq:trace:RV} and \eqref{eq:trace:Feval} yields the identity
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:FG}
+(eq:trace:RV) and (eq:trace:Feval) yields the identity
+
\tr(PV)=F+G+\tr(RZ^2),
-\end{equation}
-with every term on the right nonnegative. By \eqref{eq:trace:Pbounds},
+
+with every term on the right nonnegative. By (eq:trace:Pbounds),
$F$, $G$, and $\tr(RZ^2)$ are integrable against $t^\beta dt$, and
$t^{\beta+1}F(t)$ vanishes at both ends. Differentiating
-\eqref{eq:trace:F} and using \eqref{eq:trace:Feval}--\eqref{eq:trace:G},
+(eq:trace:F) and using (eq:trace:Feval)--(eq:trace:G),
\[
F'(t)=-\frac{\tr V}{2t^{3/2}}+\tr P(t),
\qquad
tF'(t)=-\tfrac12F(t)-G(t).
\]
Integration by parts with the vanishing endpoint limits gives
-$\int_0^\infty t^\beta G\,dt=\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta F\,dt$; since
+$\int_0^∞ t^\beta G\,dt=\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta F\,dt$; since
$\sigma=1/r$ and $\int F=r\int G$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:weighted}
- \tr(NV)=q\,c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta G(t)\,dt
- +c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta\tr(RZ^2)\,dt .
-\end{equation}
-\subsection{Step 3: the noncommutative square}
+ \tr(NV)=q\,c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta G(t)\,dt
+ +c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta\tr(RZ^2)\,dt .
+
+
+## Step 3: the noncommutative square
For a positive semidefinite matrix $D$, set
\[
- F_0(t,D)=\frac{\tr D}{\sqrt t}
- -2\tr\bigl((tI+D)^{1/2}-\sqrt t I\bigr).
+ F_0(t,D)=(\tr D)/(\sqrt t)
+ -2\tr((tI+D)^{1/2}-\sqrt t I).
\]
For a scalar eigenvalue $d\ge0$ the summand is
$\int_0^d(t^{-1/2}-(t+y)^{-1/2})\,dy$; Tonelli's theorem and
-\eqref{eq:trace:scaling} give
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:F0}
- c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta F_0(t,D)\,dt=\frac1p\tr(D^p).
-\end{equation}
+(eq:trace:scaling) give
+
+ c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta F_0(t,D)\,dt=\frac1p\tr(D^p).
+
Now expand the Hilbert--Schmidt square without any commutation (the cross
factors $R^{-1/2}R^{1/2}$ cancel, and cyclicity handles the rest):
-\begin{align}
+
\mathcal D_D(t)
&=\bigl\|R^{-1/2}-R^{1/2}(tI+D)^{1/2}\bigr\|_{\HS}^2 \notag\\
- &=\tr\bigl(R^{-1}+R(tI+D)-2(tI+D)^{1/2}\bigr) \notag\\
+ &=\tr(R^{-1}+R(tI+D)-2(tI+D)^{1/2}) \notag\\
&=G(t)-\tr(P(t)D)+F_0(t,D).
- \label{eq:trace:square}
-\end{align}
-All three terms are integrable by \eqref{eq:trace:Pbounds},
-\eqref{eq:trace:FG}, and \eqref{eq:trace:F0}. Integrating
-\eqref{eq:trace:square} with weight $t^\beta$ and using
+
+
+All three terms are integrable by (eq:trace:Pbounds),
+(eq:trace:FG), and (eq:trace:F0). Integrating
+(eq:trace:square) with weight $t^\beta$ and using
$c_\sigma\int t^\beta P= N$ gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:trace:duality}
- c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta G\,dt
+
+ c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta G\,dt
=\tr(ND)-\frac1p\tr(D^p)
- +c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta\mathcal D_D\,dt .
-\end{equation}
+ +c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta\mathcal D_D\,dt .
+
When $N\ge0$ choose $D=N^r$. Since $rp=q$, the first two terms equal
-$\bigl(1-\tfrac1p\bigr)\tr(N^q)=\tr(N^q)/q$. Substituting into
-\eqref{eq:trace:weighted} proves \eqref{eq:trace:deficit}. Both integrands
-in \eqref{eq:trace:deficit} are nonnegative, so equality forces them to
+$(1-\tfrac1p)\tr(N^q)=\tr(N^q)/q$. Substituting into
+(eq:trace:weighted) proves (eq:trace:deficit). Both integrands
+in (eq:trace:deficit) are nonnegative, so equality forces them to
vanish for almost every $t$, hence by continuity for every $t>0$.
Finally, if $B$ and $V$ commute the symbol condition implies $V\ge bI$;
@@ -587,188 +587,188 @@ simultaneous diagonalisation gives $R(t)=(tI+V)^{-1/2}$, $N=V^\sigma$,
$Z=0$, and both remainders vanish, as scalar equality requires.
% =====================================================================
-\section{The field and the connecting path}\label{sec:field}
+# The field and the connecting path
% =====================================================================
To run the complete-the-square step of the action estimate we need two
objects: a symmetric matrix field $M_\delta$ that mimics the power
$(K^2-B^2)^\sigma$ near values that matter, and a symmetric path $B(x)$
running from $K$ to $-K$ that solves an ODE of the form
-$\varepsilon B'=M_\delta(B)-AA^T$. This section constructs both. Set
+$ε B'=M_\delta(B)-AA^T$. This section constructs both. Set
$\delta>0$ and recall $\beta=\sigma-\tfrac12$, and let $c_\sigma$ be the
-constant of \eqref{eq:trace:normalization}.
+constant of (eq:trace:normalization).
-\subsection{A scalar building block}
+## A scalar building block
On $y\ge0$, define
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:f}
- f_\delta(y)=\frac{c_\sigma}{\pi}\int_0^\infty t^\beta
- \Bigl(\frac1{t+\delta}-\frac1{t+\delta+y}\Bigr)\,dt,
-\end{equation}
+
+ f_\delta(y)=(c_\sigma)/(\pi)\int_0^∞ t^\beta
+ (\frac1{t+\delta}-\frac1{t+\delta+y})\,dt,
+
and extend to $y<0$ by the tangent line $f_\delta'(0)y$. For $y\ge0$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:fderivative}
+
f_\delta'(y)=a_\sigma(y+\delta)^{\beta-1},
\qquad
- a_\sigma=\frac{c_\sigma}{\pi}\int_0^\infty
- \frac{u^\beta}{(1+u)^2}\,du>0 .
-\end{equation}
+ a_\sigma=(c_\sigma)/(\pi)\int_0^∞
+ (u^\beta)/((1+u)^2)\,du>0 .
+
Both integrals converge because $-\tfrac12<\beta<\tfrac12$. Thus $f_\delta$
is $C^1$, strictly increasing, and concave on $y\ge0$; the tangent
extension makes it $C^1$ on all of $\R$ and lets the functional calculus
below accept arguments with negative eigenvalues.
Set
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:Q}
+
Q_s(B)=s^2I-2sB+K^2,
-\end{equation}
+
and
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:M}
- M_\delta(B)=\lim_{R\to\infty}\int_{-R}^{R}
- \bigl(f_\delta(Q_s(B))-f_\delta(s^2)I\bigr)\,ds,
+
+ M_\delta(B)=\lim_{R\to∞}\int_{-R}^{R}
+ (f_\delta(Q_s(B))-f_\delta(s^2)I)\,ds,
\qquad B\in\Sym_n,
-\end{equation}
+
where the symmetric cutoff cancels the leading odd term
$-2sf_\delta'(s^2)B$. The scalar counterpart is
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:mu}
- \mu_\delta(z)=\int_\R\bigl(f_\delta(s^2+z)-f_\delta(s^2)\bigr)\,ds,
+
+ \mu_\delta(z)=\int_\R(f_\delta(s^2+z)-f_\delta(s^2))\,ds,
\qquad z\in\R .
-\end{equation}
-\begin{proposition}[Regularised field]\label{prop:field}
-The limit \eqref{eq:field:M} exists locally uniformly, and
+
+[Regularised field]
+The limit (eq:field:M) exists locally uniformly, and
$M_\delta:\Sym_n\to\Sym_n$ is locally Lipschitz with symmetric values.
There is a $C^1$ function $J_\delta:\Sym_n\to\R$, $J_\delta(0)=0$, with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:primitive}
- dJ_\delta(B)[H]=-\tr\bigl(M_\delta(B)H\bigr).
-\end{equation}
+
+ dJ_\delta(B)[H]=-\tr(M_\delta(B)H).
+
The scalar function $\mu_\delta$ is locally Lipschitz and strictly
increasing with $\mu_\delta(0)=0$, and for $z\ge0$
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:mupositive}
+
\mu_\delta(z)=(z+\delta)^\sigma-\delta^\sigma .
-\end{equation}
+
For every real unit vector $e$ and every standard basis vector $e_i$,
-\begin{align}
+
e^{\mathsf T}M_\delta(B)e
- &\le\mu_\delta\bigl(e^{\mathsf T}K^2e-(e^{\mathsf T}Be)^2\bigr),
- \label{eq:field:direction}\\
- Be_i=ye_i\quad&\Longrightarrow\quad
+ &\le\mu_\delta(e^{\mathsf T}K^2e-(e^{\mathsf T}Be)^2),
+ \\
+ Be_i=ye_i\quad&⇒\quad
M_\delta(B)e_i=\mu_\delta(k_i^2-y^2)\,e_i .
- \label{eq:field:coordinate}
-\end{align}
+
+
For every diagonal sign matrix $S$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:equivariance}
+
M_\delta(SBS)=S\,M_\delta(B)\,S .
-\end{equation}
+
Finally,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:endpoints}
+
J_\delta(-K)-J_\delta(K)
=\sum_{i=1}^n\int_{-k_i}^{k_i}\mu_\delta(k_i^2-s^2)\,ds
- \;\longrightarrow\;
+ \;→\;
b_\sigma\sum_{i=1}^n k_i^{2\sigma+1}
- \quad(\delta\downarrow0).
-\end{equation}
-\end{proposition}
+ \quad(\delta↓0).
+
-\begin{proof}
-\emph{Matrix calculus bound.} If $h$ is Lipschitz on an interval
+
+Proof.
+Matrix calculus bound. If $h$ is Lipschitz on an interval
containing the spectra of Hermitian $X,Y$, then
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:HS}
- \|h(X)-h(Y)\|_{\HS}\le\operatorname{Lip}(h)\,\|X-Y\|_{\HS}.
-\end{equation}
+
+ \|h(X)-h(Y)\|_{\HS}\leLip(h)\,\|X-Y\|_{\HS}.
+
Indeed, take eigenbases $e_i$ of $X$ and $v_j$ of $Y$; the mixed entries
-of $h(X)-h(Y)$ and of $X-Y$ are $(h(\lambda_i)-h(\nu_j))\langle e_i,v_j\rangle$
-and $(\lambda_i-\nu_j)\langle e_i,v_j\rangle$; square the scalar Lipschitz
+of $h(X)-h(Y)$ and of $X-Y$ are $(h(\lambda_i)-h(\nu_j))< e_i,v_j>$
+and $(\lambda_i-\nu_j)< e_i,v_j>$; square the scalar Lipschitz
inequality and sum.
-\emph{Convergence of the field.} On a bounded set of $B$'s the spectrum
+Convergence of the field. On a bounded set of $B$'s the spectrum
of $E_s(B)=-2sB+K^2$ lies in $[-a|s|,a|s|]$ for all large $|s|$. For
$h_s(y)=f_\delta(s^2+y)-f_\delta(s^2)-f_\delta'(s^2)y$,
-\eqref{eq:field:fderivative} gives
-$\sup_{|y|\le a|s|}|h_s'(y)|=O(|s|^{2\beta-3})$. By \eqref{eq:field:HS},
+(eq:field:fderivative) gives
+$\sup_{|y|\le a|s|}|h_s'(y)|=O(|s|^{2\beta-3})$. By (eq:field:HS),
\[
f_\delta(Q_s(B))-f_\delta(s^2)I=-2s f_\delta'(s^2)B+T_s(B),
\]
where $\|T_s(B)\|_{\HS}$ and the local Lipschitz constant of $T_s$ are
$O(|s|^{2\beta-2})$ (include $f_\delta'(s^2)K^2$ in $T_s$ for the size
-bound, and apply \eqref{eq:field:HS} to $h_s(E_s(B))$ using
+bound, and apply (eq:field:HS) to $h_s(E_s(B))$ using
$E_s(B_1)-E_s(B_2)=-2s(B_1-B_2)$). Since $2\beta-2<-1$, these remainders
are integrable at infinity; the odd term cancels at each symmetric cutoff,
-and on bounded $s$-intervals \eqref{eq:field:HS} applies directly to
+and on bounded $s$-intervals (eq:field:HS) applies directly to
$f_\delta$. This gives the stated convergence and regularity.
-\emph{Primitive.} Let $g_\delta'=f_\delta$. Trace differentiation gives
+Primitive. Let $g_\delta'=f_\delta$. Trace differentiation gives
$d\,\tr(g_\delta(X))[H]=\tr(f_\delta(X)H)$ (true for polynomials by
cyclicity, then for $g_\delta$ by $C^1$ approximation on compact spectral
intervals). For $s\ne0$ the function
\[
- B\mapsto\frac{\tr\bigl(g_\delta(Q_s(B))-g_\delta(K^2)\bigr)}{2s}
+ B\mapsto(\tr(g_\delta(Q_s(B))-g_\delta(K^2)))/(2s)
+f_\delta(s^2)\tr B
\]
-has differential $-\tr\bigl((f_\delta(Q_s(B))-f_\delta(s^2)I)H\bigr)$; at
+has differential $-\tr((f_\delta(Q_s(B))-f_\delta(s^2)I)H)$; at
$s=0$ the differential is constant in $B$ and also has a primitive. Hence
the negative of each finite-cutoff field has vanishing integral around
every closed piecewise smooth curve in $\Sym_n$, i.e.\ it is a gradient.
Local uniform convergence passes this to $-M_\delta$, and path integration
-from $0$ defines $J_\delta$, proving \eqref{eq:field:primitive}.
+from $0$ defines $J_\delta$, proving (eq:field:primitive).
-\emph{Scalar bounds and profile.} For bounded $z$, the integrand in
-\eqref{eq:field:mu} and its Lipschitz constant in $z$ are $O(|s|^{2\beta-2})$
+Scalar bounds and profile. For bounded $z$, the integrand in
+(eq:field:mu) and its Lipschitz constant in $z$ are $O(|s|^{2\beta-2})$
at infinity, so $\mu_\delta$ is locally Lipschitz and absolutely
convergent; strict increase and $\mu_\delta(0)=0$ follow from $f_\delta$.
-For $z\ge0$, Tonelli applied to \eqref{eq:field:f} gives
+For $z\ge0$, Tonelli applied to (eq:field:f) gives
\[
- \mu_\delta(z)=c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta
- \bigl((t+\delta)^{-1/2}-(t+\delta+z)^{-1/2}\bigr)\,dt,
+ \mu_\delta(z)=c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta
+ ((t+\delta)^{-1/2}-(t+\delta+z)^{-1/2})\,dt,
\]
-which the scaling identity \eqref{eq:trace:scaling} evaluates as
-\eqref{eq:field:mupositive}.
+which the scaling identity (eq:trace:scaling) evaluates as
+(eq:field:mupositive).
-\emph{Direction and coordinate.} For fixed $a,z$, translations under a
+Direction and coordinate. For fixed $a,z$, translations under a
symmetric cutoff are legitimate:
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:shift}
- \lim_{R\to\infty}\int_{-R}^{R}
- \bigl(f_\delta((s-a)^2+z)-f_\delta(s^2)\bigr)\,ds=\mu_\delta(z),
-\end{equation}
+
+ \lim_{R\to∞}\int_{-R}^{R}
+ (f_\delta((s-a)^2+z)-f_\delta(s^2))\,ds=\mu_\delta(z),
+
because $F_z(s)=f_\delta(s^2+z)$ is even and $F_z'(s)=O(|s|^{2\beta-1})\to0$,
so the difference of shifted and unshifted cutoffs is bounded by
$|a|^2\sup_{R-|a|\le u\le R+|a|}|F_z'(u)|\to0$. Concavity of $f_\delta$
in an eigenbasis of $Q_s(B)$ gives
$e^{\mathsf T}f_\delta(Q_s(B))e\le f_\delta(e^{\mathsf T}Q_s(B)e)$, whose
scalar argument is $(s-e^{\mathsf T}Be)^2+e^{\mathsf T}K^2e-(e^{\mathsf T}Be)^2$.
-Integrating with \eqref{eq:field:shift} gives
-\eqref{eq:field:direction}; if $Be_i=ye_i$, the functional calculus is
-exact on $e_i$, giving \eqref{eq:field:coordinate}. Since $SK^2S=K^2$,
-conjugation inside the integral gives \eqref{eq:field:equivariance}.
-
-\emph{Endpoints.} On diagonal arguments, \eqref{eq:field:primitive} and
-\eqref{eq:field:coordinate} read
-$dJ_\delta(\diag(b_1,\dots,b_n))=-\sum_i\mu_\delta(k_i^2-b_i^2)\,db_i$.
+Integrating with (eq:field:shift) gives
+(eq:field:direction); if $Be_i=ye_i$, the functional calculus is
+exact on $e_i$, giving (eq:field:coordinate). Since $SK^2S=K^2$,
+conjugation inside the integral gives (eq:field:equivariance).
+
+Endpoints. On diagonal arguments, (eq:field:primitive) and
+(eq:field:coordinate) read
+$dJ_\delta(\diag(b_1,...,b_n))=-\sum_i\mu_\delta(k_i^2-b_i^2)\,db_i$.
Integrating from $K$ to $-K$ gives the first equality in
-\eqref{eq:field:endpoints}. For $z\ge0$, $0\le\mu_\delta(z)\le z^\sigma$
+(eq:field:endpoints). For $z\ge0$, $0\le\mu_\delta(z)\le z^\sigma$
and $\mu_\delta(z)\to z^\sigma$; dominated convergence and the substitution
$s=k_iu$ give $\int_{-k_i}^{k_i}(k_i^2-s^2)^\sigma ds=b_\sigma k_i^{2\sigma+1}$,
hence the limit.
-\end{proof}
-\subsection{Positive values of the field}
+
+## Positive values of the field
The next proposition is the only place where the sign of an argument of
$M_\delta$ matters. It says that if $M_\delta(B)$ is itself a positive
matrix (as it will be once it equals $AA^{\mathsf T}$), the whole symbol
$Q_s(B)$ is positive definite and the trace engine applies.
-\begin{proposition}[Positive values of the field]\label{prop:field-pos}
+[Positive values of the field]
If $M=M_\delta(B)\ge0$, then
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:field:posbounds}
+
Q_s(B)\ge0\ (s\in\R),
\qquad 0\le M\le\kappa^{2\sigma}I .
-\end{equation}
+
Set $V=K^2-B^2+\delta I$. Then $(sI-B)^2+V=Q_s(B)+\delta I\ge\delta I$,
-and with $R(t)$ and $N$ as in \eqref{eq:trace:resolvents}--\eqref{eq:trace:N}
+and with $R(t)$ and $N$ as in (eq:trace:resolvents)--(eq:trace:N)
one has $N=M+\delta^\sigma I$. In particular the hypotheses of
-Theorem~\ref{thm:trace} hold with this $B$ and $V$.
-\end{proposition}
+Theorem~thm:trace hold with this $B$ and $V$.
+
-\begin{proof}
-By \eqref{eq:field:direction} and strict increase of $\mu_\delta$,
+Proof.
+By (eq:field:direction) and strict increase of $\mu_\delta$,
positivity of $M$ forces $e^{\mathsf T}K^2e\ge(e^{\mathsf T}Be)^2$ for every
unit $e$. Completing the scalar square,
\[
@@ -776,112 +776,112 @@ unit $e$. Completing the scalar square,
+e^{\mathsf T}K^2e-(e^{\mathsf T}Be)^2\ge0,
\]
so $Q_s(B)\ge0$ as a Hermitian matrix on $\C^n$. Also
-$M\le\mu_\delta(\kappa^2)I\le\kappa^{2\sigma}I$ by \eqref{eq:field:direction}
-and \eqref{eq:field:mupositive}.
+$M\le\mu_\delta(\kappa^2)I\le\kappa^{2\sigma}I$ by (eq:field:direction)
+and (eq:field:mupositive).
-Write $Y_s=(sI-B)^2$. By diagonalisation of $B$ and \eqref{eq:field:shift},
-the scalar subtraction $f_\delta(s^2)I$ in \eqref{eq:field:M} may be
+Write $Y_s=(sI-B)^2$. By diagonalisation of $B$ and (eq:field:shift),
+the scalar subtraction $f_\delta(s^2)I$ in (eq:field:M) may be
replaced by $f_\delta(Y_s)$. Since $Q_s(B)$ and $Y_s$ are both positive,
-\eqref{eq:field:f} gives their difference under $f_\delta$ as a Stieltjes
+(eq:field:f) gives their difference under $f_\delta$ as a Stieltjes
integral
\[
- \frac{c_\sigma}{\pi}\int_0^\infty t^\beta
- \Bigl((Y_s+(t+\delta)I)^{-1}-(Q_s(B)+(t+\delta)I)^{-1}\Bigr)\,dt .
+ (c_\sigma)/(\pi)\int_0^∞ t^\beta
+ ((Y_s+(t+\delta)I)^{-1}-(Q_s(B)+(t+\delta)I)^{-1})\,dt .
\]
For fixed $B,\delta$ both inverted matrices are bounded below by
$c(1+t+s^2)I$, and their difference is $K^2-B^2$, so the resolvent
identity bounds the integrand by $Ct^\beta(1+t+s^2)^{-2}$; integrating in
-$s$ gives $C't^\beta(1+t)^{-3/2}$, integrable on $(0,\infty)$. Fubini
+$s$ gives $C't^\beta(1+t)^{-3/2}$, integrable on $(0,∞)$. Fubini
therefore applies and yields
\[
- M=c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta
- \bigl((t+\delta)^{-1/2}I-R(t)\bigr)\,dt .
+ M=c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta
+ ((t+\delta)^{-1/2}I-R(t))\,dt .
\]
-Subtracting this from \eqref{eq:trace:N} and using \eqref{eq:trace:scaling}
+Subtracting this from (eq:trace:N) and using (eq:trace:scaling)
gives $N=M+\delta^\sigma I$.
-\end{proof}
-\subsection{The connecting path}
+
+## The connecting path
The final object of this section walks $B$ from $K$ to $-K$ while tracking a
prescribed density $AA^{\mathsf T}$. This is where topology enters: a
nonlinear equation for $C$ must be solved, and the only obstruction would
be a parity count of zeros.
-\begin{proposition}[Connecting path]\label{prop:path}
-Let $\Omega=(x_-,x_+)$ be bounded and let $U\in H^1_0(\Omega;\R^{n\times d})$,
-$n,d\ge1$, satisfy $\int_\Omega UU^{\mathsf T}\,dx=I_n$. For every
-$\delta,\varepsilon>0$ there are a real lower triangular matrix
-$C_\varepsilon\in\R^{n\times n}$ and a path
-$B_\varepsilon\in C^1(\overline\Omega;\Sym_n)$ such that, with
-$A_\varepsilon=C_\varepsilon U$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:path:ode}
- \varepsilon B_\varepsilon'
- =M_\delta(B_\varepsilon)-A_\varepsilon A_\varepsilon^{\mathsf T},
- \qquad B_\varepsilon(x_-)=K,\quad B_\varepsilon(x_+)=-K,
-\end{equation}
+[Connecting path]
+Let $Ω=(x_-,x_+)$ be bounded and let $U\in H^1_0(Ω;\R^{n\times d})$,
+$n,d\ge1$, satisfy $\int_Ω UU^{\mathsf T}\,dx=I_n$. For every
+$\delta,ε>0$ there are a real lower triangular matrix
+$C_ε\in\R^{n\times n}$ and a path
+$B_ε\in C^1(\overlineΩ;\Sym_n)$ such that, with
+$A_ε=C_ε U$,
+
+ ε B_ε'
+ =M_\delta(B_ε)-A_ε A_ε^{\mathsf T},
+ \qquad B_ε(x_-)=K,\quad B_ε(x_+)=-K,
+
and
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:path:bounds}
- \sup_{x\in\overline\Omega}\|B_\varepsilon(x)\|_{\op}\le\kappa,
+
+ \sup_{x\in\overlineΩ}\|B_ε(x)\|_{\op}\le\kappa,
\qquad
- \sup_{0<\varepsilon\le1}\|C_\varepsilon\|_{\HS}<\infty,
-\end{equation}
-the second bound for fixed $\delta,K,\Omega$.
-\end{proposition}
+ \sup_{0<ε\le1}\|C_ε\|_{\HS}<∞,
+
+the second bound for fixed $\delta,K,Ω$.
+
-\begin{proof}
-\emph{A cutoff and a homotopy.} Use the continuous representative of $U$.
+Proof.
+A cutoff and a homotopy. Use the continuous representative of $U$.
Choose a smooth nonnegative compactly supported cutoff $\chi$ on $\Sym_n$
equal to $1$ on $\{B:\|B\|_{\op}\le\kappa\}$ and invariant under conjugation
by diagonal sign matrices (averaging over the finite sign group produces
one). The truncated field $\widehat M=\chi M_\delta$ is bounded and
-globally Lipschitz. Fix $\varepsilon>0$. For $C$ lower triangular and
+globally Lipschitz. Fix $ε>0$. For $C$ lower triangular and
$\theta\in[0,1]$, the equation
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:path:homotopy}
- \varepsilon B'=\theta\widehat M(B)-(CU)(CU)^{\mathsf T},
+
+ ε B'=\theta\widehat M(B)-(CU)(CU)^{\mathsf T},
\qquad B(x_-)=K,
-\end{equation}
-has a unique $C^1$ solution on $\overline\Omega$; define the continuous
+
+has a unique $C^1$ solution on $\overlineΩ$; define the continuous
endpoint map $\Phi(C,\theta)=B(x_+)+K\in\Sym_n$.
-\emph{Sign symmetry.} Let $\mathcal G$ be the group of diagonal sign
+Sign symmetry. Let $\mathcal G$ be the group of diagonal sign
matrices, acting by $C\mapsto SC$ on lower triangular matrices and by
conjugation on $\Sym_n$. Equivariance of the field and uniqueness of the
ODE give
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:path:equivariance}
+
\Phi(SC,\theta)=S\,\Phi(C,\theta)\,S .
-\end{equation}
-\emph{Three facts about the zero set.}
-(i) \emph{Compactness.} At a zero, integrating \eqref{eq:path:homotopy}
-gives $CC^{\mathsf T}=2\varepsilon K+\theta\int_\Omega\widehat M(B(x))\,dx$,
+
+Three facts about the zero set.
+(i) Compactness. At a zero, integrating (eq:path:homotopy)
+gives $CC^{\mathsf T}=2ε K+\theta\int_Ω\widehat M(B(x))\,dx$,
so the zeros lie in a bounded set and their joint set in
-$\R^{n\times n}_{\text{low}}\times[0,1]$ is compact. For
-$0<\varepsilon\le1$ this also gives the uniform bound
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:path:Cbound}
+$\R^{n\times n}_{low}\times[0,1]$ is compact. For
+$0<ε\le1$ this also gives the uniform bound
+
\|C\|_{\HS}^2\le2\tr K
- +n|\Omega|\sup_{B\in\Sym_n}\|\widehat M(B)\|_{\op}.
-\end{equation}
-(ii) \emph{Freeness.} No row of $C$ can vanish at a zero. Otherwise the
-reflection changing only row $i$ would fix $C$; by \eqref{eq:path:equivariance}
-and ODE uniqueness $Be_i=ye_i$ throughout, and \eqref{eq:field:coordinate}
-gives $\varepsilon y'=\theta\chi(B(x))\mu_\delta(k_i^2-y^2)$ with $y(x_-)=k_i$.
+ +n|Ω|\sup_{B\in\Sym_n}\|\widehat M(B)\|_{\op}.
+
+(ii) Freeness. No row of $C$ can vanish at a zero. Otherwise the
+reflection changing only row $i$ would fix $C$; by (eq:path:equivariance)
+and ODE uniqueness $Be_i=ye_i$ throughout, and (eq:field:coordinate)
+gives $ε y'=\theta\chi(B(x))\mu_\delta(k_i^2-y^2)$ with $y(x_-)=k_i$.
Uniqueness forces $y\equiv k_i$, contradicting $y(x_+)=-k_i$. Thus
$\mathcal G$ acts freely on the zero set.
-(iii) \emph{One regular orbit at $\theta=0$.} There
-$\Phi(C,0)=2K-\varepsilon^{-1}CC^{\mathsf T}$. Its lower triangular zeros
-are exactly $C=\diag(d_1,\dots,d_n)$ with $d_i=\pm\sqrt{2\varepsilon k_i}$:
-the first row of $CC^{\mathsf T}=2\varepsilon K$ fixes $|d_1|$ and forces the
+(iii) One regular orbit at $\theta=0$. There
+$\Phi(C,0)=2K-ε^{-1}CC^{\mathsf T}$. Its lower triangular zeros
+are exactly $C=\diag(d_1,...,d_n)$ with $d_i=\pm√(2ε k_i)$:
+the first row of $CC^{\mathsf T}=2ε K$ fixes $|d_1|$ and forces the
rest of the first column to vanish, and induction proceeds. These $2^n$
zeros form one sign orbit. At each, the derivative in a lower triangular
-direction $H$ has diagonal entries $-2\varepsilon^{-1}d_iH_{ii}$ and lower
-off-diagonal entries $-\varepsilon^{-1}d_jH_{ij}$ ($i>j$), an isomorphism
-$\R^{n\times n}_{\text{low}}\to\Sym_n$.
+direction $H$ has diagonal entries $-2ε^{-1}d_iH_{ii}$ and lower
+off-diagonal entries $-ε^{-1}d_jH_{ij}$ ($i>j$), an isomorphism
+$\R^{n\times n}_{low}\to\Sym_n$.
-\emph{Continuation by parity.} Suppose there were no zero at $\theta=1$.
+Continuation by parity. Suppose there were no zero at $\theta=1$.
Compactness and freeness give a bounded invariant open set
-$O\subset\R^{n\times n}_{\text{low}}$ containing the projection of every
+$O\subset\R^{n\times n}_{low}$ containing the projection of every
zero, with closure where all rows are nonzero, and a positive lower bound
-for $\|\Phi\|_{\HS}$ on $(\partial O\times[0,1])\cup(\overline O\times\{1\})$.
+for $\|\Phi\|_{\HS}$ on $(∂ O\times[0,1])\cup(\overline O\times\{1\})$.
Reparametrise $\theta$ to agree with the initial map on an initial collar
and retain this gap; extend $F$ constantly past both ends, smooth by
convolution, splice to the initial map on a smaller collar, and average in
@@ -893,14 +893,14 @@ Freeness allows equivariant perturbations with arbitrary target directions:
at $C_0\in\overline O$ choose a ball whose sign translates are disjoint and
a bump $b$ supported there with $b(C_0)=1$; then
$V_H(C)=\sum_S b(SC)SHS$ is equivariant with $V_H(C_0)=H$. Finitely many
-such maps $V_1,\dots,V_N$ span $\Sym_n$ at every point. Let $h\ge0$ be
+such maps $V_1,...,V_N$ span $\Sym_n$ at every point. Let $h\ge0$ be
smooth, vanish near $0$, and positive off the collar, and set
$\Psi_\alpha=\Psi+h(\theta)\sum_j\alpha_jV_j$. For small $\alpha$ the gap
persists; at a zero with $0<\theta<1$ the full differential in
$(C,\theta,\alpha)$ is onto (parameter directions span the target where
$h>0$; the $C$-differential is the above isomorphism where $h=0$). Hence
the interior zero set is a smooth manifold, and Sard's theorem
-\cite{Sard1942} applied to projection onto the parameter ball gives
+[cite] applied to projection onto the parameter ball gives
arbitrarily small $\alpha$ for which $0$ is a regular value.
For such $\alpha$ the zero set in $O\times[0,1]$ is a compact smooth
@@ -914,21 +914,21 @@ boundary point. A compact one-dimensional manifold is a finite union of
circles and closed intervals, which cannot have exactly one boundary point.
Contradiction. Hence $\Phi(\cdot,1)$ has a zero.
-\emph{Removing the cutoff.} For the resulting path and any real unit $e$,
-put $y=e^{\mathsf T}Be$. Whenever $|y|>\kappa$, \eqref{eq:field:direction}
+Removing the cutoff. For the resulting path and any real unit $e$,
+put $y=e^{\mathsf T}Be$. Whenever $|y|>\kappa$, (eq:field:direction)
gives $e^{\mathsf T}M_\delta(B)e\le\mu_\delta(e^{\mathsf T}K^2e-y^2)<0$.
-Since $\chi\ge0$ and $(CU)(CU)^{\mathsf T}\ge0$, \eqref{eq:path:ode} implies
+Since $\chi\ge0$ and $(CU)(CU)^{\mathsf T}\ge0$, (eq:path:ode) implies
$y'\le0$ there. Both endpoints lie in $[-\kappa,\kappa]$; an excursion
above $\kappa$ cannot start from $\kappa$ while $y$ is nonincreasing, and an
excursion below $-\kappa$ cannot return to $-\kappa$ while $y$ is
nonincreasing. So $\|B(x)\|_{\op}\le\kappa$ for all $x$, which forces
-$\chi(B)=1$ and hence \eqref{eq:path:ode} with the untruncated field.
-Equation~\eqref{eq:path:Cbound} supplies the remaining bound in
-\eqref{eq:path:bounds}.
-\end{proof}
+$\chi(B)=1$ and hence (eq:path:ode) with the untruncated field.
+Equation~(eq:path:Cbound) supplies the remaining bound in
+(eq:path:bounds).
+
% =====================================================================
-\section{The finite-interval action estimate}\label{sec:action}
+# The finite-interval action estimate
% =====================================================================
This is the central estimate. It turns the trial functions into a
@@ -937,95 +937,95 @@ data are from the two algebraic equality relations. The uniformity of the
coefficient $c_*$ in the row count is what will later allow an
a-priori-infinite eigenvalue list.
-Fix positive integers $n,d$, a bounded interval $\Omega=(x_-,x_+)$, and a
-diagonal $K=\diag(\ell_1,\dots,\ell_n)$ with $0<\ell_i\le\kappa$. For
-$A\in H^1_0(\Omega;\R^{n\times d})$ set $\rho=AA^{\mathsf T}$ and
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:energy}
- \mathcal E_K(A)=\int_\Omega
- \bigl(\|A'\|_{\HS}^2+\tr(K^2\rho)-\tr(\rho^q)\bigr)\,dx .
-\end{equation}
+Fix positive integers $n,d$, a bounded interval $Ω=(x_-,x_+)$, and a
+diagonal $K=\diag(\ell_1,...,\ell_n)$ with $0<\ell_i\le\kappa$. For
+$A\in H^1_0(Ω;\R^{n\times d})$ set $\rho=AA^{\mathsf T}$ and
+
+ \mathcal E_K(A)=\int_Ω
+ (\|A'\|_{\HS}^2+\tr(K^2\rho)-\tr(\rho^q))\,dx .
+
For pointwise values $A\in\R^{n\times d}$ and $B\in\Sym_n$, define the
algebraic defect
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:defect}
+
\Phi_K(A,B)=\min\Bigl\{1,\;
\|[B,K^2]\|_{\op}^2+\bigl\|K^2-B^2-(AA^{\mathsf T})^r\bigr\|_{\op}^2
\Bigr\}.
-\end{equation}
+
Thus $\Phi_K=0$ encodes the two relations $[B,K^2]=0$ and
$\rho=(K^2-B^2)^\sigma$, while $A'-BA=0$ is the first-order relation.
-\begin{theorem}[Quantitative action estimate]\label{thm:action}
+[Quantitative action estimate]
Let $0<\sigma<1$ and $\kappa>0$. There is $c_*=c_*(\sigma,\kappa)>0$ with
-the following property. For $n,d,\Omega,K$ as above, suppose
-$U\in H^1_0(\Omega;\R^{n\times d})$ satisfies
-$\int_\Omega UU^{\mathsf T}\,dx=I_n$. For every $\eta>0$ there exist a
+the following property. For $n,d,Ω,K$ as above, suppose
+$U\in H^1_0(Ω;\R^{n\times d})$ satisfies
+$\int_Ω UU^{\mathsf T}\,dx=I_n$. For every $\eta>0$ there exist a
real lower triangular $C\in\R^{n\times n}$ and a path
-$B\in C^1(\overline\Omega;\Sym_n)$ with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:endpointB}
+$B\in C^1(\overlineΩ;\Sym_n)$ with
+
B(x_-)=K,\qquad B(x_+)=-K,\qquad
- \sup_{x\in\overline\Omega}\|B(x)\|_{\op}\le\kappa,
-\end{equation}
+ \sup_{x\in\overlineΩ}\|B(x)\|_{\op}\le\kappa,
+
such that, for $A=CU$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:bound}
+
\mathcal E_K(A)\ge b_\sigma\sum_{i=1}^n\ell_i^{2\gamma}
- +\int_\Omega\Bigl(\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2+c_*\Phi_K(A,B)\Bigr)\,dx-\eta .
-\end{equation}
-The constant $c_*$ is independent of $n,d,\Omega,U$ and of
+ +\int_Ω(\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2+c_*\Phi_K(A,B))\,dx-\eta .
+
+The constant $c_*$ is independent of $n,d,Ω,U$ and of
$\min_i\ell_i$.
-\end{theorem}
+
The proof has two ingredients. The first is a constraint lemma, obtained
-by feeding the trace engine (Proposition~\ref{prop:field-pos} plus
-Theorem~\ref{thm:trace}) into a penalty. The second completes the square
-along the path of Proposition~\ref{prop:path}; the boundary term there is
+by feeding the trace engine (Proposition~prop:field-pos plus
+Theorem~thm:trace) into a penalty. The second completes the square
+along the path of Proposition~prop:path; the boundary term there is
exactly $J_\delta(-K)-J_\delta(K)$, which tends to
$b_\sigma\sum\ell_i^{2\gamma}$. We prove the constraint lemma first.
-\subsection{The nonlinear term is controlled by the defect}
-For $0<\delta\le1$, recall the field $M_\delta$ of Section~\ref{sec:field}
-and the function $F(A,B)=\tr(\rho^q)-\tr\bigl((K^2-B^2)\rho\bigr)$,
+## The nonlinear term is controlled by the defect
+For $0<\delta\le1$, recall the field $M_\delta$ of Section~sec:field
+and the function $F(A,B)=\tr(\rho^q)-\tr((K^2-B^2)\rho)$,
$\rho=AA^{\mathsf T}$.
-\begin{lemma}[Constraint estimate]\label{lem:constraint}
+[Constraint estimate]
The constant $c_*(\sigma,\kappa)>0$ can be chosen so that whenever
$0<\delta\le1$, $\|B\|_{\op}\le\kappa$, and $M_\delta(B)=AA^{\mathsf T}$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:constraint-bound}
+
F(A,B)+c_*\Phi_K(A,B)\le E_{n,\delta},
\qquad
E_{n,\delta}
- =n\bigl(\delta\kappa^{2\sigma}+\delta^\sigma(\kappa^2+\delta)\bigr)
+ =n(\delta\kappa^{2\sigma}+\delta^\sigma(\kappa^2+\delta))
+\delta^{2\sigma}.
-\end{equation}
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
-Write $\rho=M_\delta(B)\ge0$. By Proposition~\ref{prop:field-pos},
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:positive-symbol}
+
+
+Proof.
+Write $\rho=M_\delta(B)\ge0$. By Proposition~prop:field-pos,
+
Q_s:=s^2I-2sB+K^2\ge0\ (s\in\R),
\qquad 0\le\rho\le\kappa^{2\sigma}I .
-\end{equation}
+
Put $V=K^2-B^2+\delta I$. With $R(t)$, $N$, $c_\sigma$ from
-\eqref{eq:trace:resolvents}--\eqref{eq:trace:N}, Proposition~\ref{prop:field-pos}
+(eq:trace:resolvents)--(eq:trace:N), Proposition~prop:field-pos
also gives $N=\rho+\delta^\sigma I$. Since
$(sI-B)^2+V=Q_s+\delta I\ge\delta I$ and $N\ge0$,
-Theorem~\ref{thm:trace} applies and supplies $L(t)=R(t)^{-1}>0$ and
+Theorem~thm:trace applies and supplies $L(t)=R(t)^{-1}>0$ and
Hermitian $Z(t)$ with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:LZ}
+
V+tI=L^2+Z^2+i[B,Z],\qquad LZ+ZL+i[B,L]=0,
-\end{equation}
+
and the exact identity
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:trace-deficit}
+
\Delta:=\tr(NV)-\tr(N^q)
- =c_\sigma\int_0^\infty t^\beta\Bigl(\tr(RZ^2)
- +q\bigl\|R^{-1/2}-R^{1/2}(tI+N^r)^{1/2}\bigr\|_{\HS}^2\Bigr)\,dt\ge0 .
-\end{equation}
+ =c_\sigma\int_0^∞ t^\beta(\tr(RZ^2)
+ +q\bigl\|R^{-1/2}-R^{1/2}(tI+N^r)^{1/2}\bigr\|_{\HS}^2)\,dt\ge0 .
+
Here the matrices may be complex Hermitian although $A,B$ are real; $i$ is
the imaginary unit.
-\emph{A dimension-free bound from $[1,2]$.} On $1\le t\le2$ one has
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:Rbounds}
+A dimension-free bound from $[1,2]$. On $1\le t\le2$ one has
+
a_\kappa I\le R(t)\le A_\kappa I:
-\end{equation}
+
for the upper bound use $Q_s\ge0$ on a bounded interval and
$Q_s\ge\tfrac12s^2I$ for $|s|\ge\max\{1,4\kappa\}$; for the lower bound
restrict to $|s|\le1$ where $Q_s+(\delta+t)I\le(4+2\kappa+\kappa^2)I$.
@@ -1036,171 +1036,171 @@ The two integrands control $\|Z(t)\|_{\HS}^2$ and $\|L(t)-H_t\|_{\HS}^2$
(use $\tr(RZ^2)=\tr(ZRZ)$ and
$R^{-1/2}-R^{1/2}H_t=R^{1/2}(L-H_t)$). Averaging over $[1,2]$ gives some
$t$ in that interval with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:smallsquares}
+
\|Z(t)\|_{\op}+\|L(t)-H_t\|_{\op}\le C_1\sqrt\Delta,
-\end{equation}
+
$C_1=C_1(\sigma,\kappa)$; when $\Delta=0$ take a point where both
nonnegative integrands vanish.
-\emph{Reading off the defect.} Suppose $\Delta\le1$ and use this $t$. The
-first relation of \eqref{eq:act:LZ} gives
+Reading off the defect. Suppose $\Delta\le1$ and use this $t$. The
+first relation of (eq:act:LZ) gives
$V-N^r=(L^2-H_t^2)+Z^2+i[B,Z]$, whose norm is $\le C_2\sqrt\Delta$ by the
-bounds above and \eqref{eq:act:smallsquares}. The second relation gives
+bounds above and (eq:act:smallsquares). The second relation gives
$\|[B,L]\|_{\op}\le2\|L\|_{\op}\|Z\|_{\op}$, and
$[B,V]=[B,L^2]+[B,Z^2]+i[B,[B,Z]]$ has the same bound. Thus
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:Vcoercivity}
+
\|V-N^r\|_{\op}+\|[B,V]\|_{\op}\le C_3\sqrt\Delta .
-\end{equation}
+
Now $N=\rho+\delta^\sigma I$ commutes with $\rho$, and $y\mapsto y^r$ is
Lipschitz on $[0,\kappa^{2\sigma}+1]$ because $r>1$, so
$\|N^r-\rho^r\|_{\op}\le C_4\delta^\sigma$. Since $[B,V]=[B,K^2]$ and
-$\delta\le\delta^\sigma$, \eqref{eq:act:Vcoercivity} yields
+$\delta\le\delta^\sigma$, (eq:act:Vcoercivity) yields
\[
\|[B,K^2]\|_{\op}^2+\|K^2-B^2-\rho^r\|_{\op}^2\le C_5(\Delta+\delta^{2\sigma}).
\]
Choosing $c_*>0$ small (also $c_*\le1$), for $\Delta\le1$
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:coercivity}
+
c_*\Phi_K(A,B)\le\Delta+\delta^{2\sigma},
-\end{equation}
+
and for $\Delta>1$ this holds because $\Phi_K\le1$.
-\emph{Relating $\Delta$ to $F$.} Expand $N$ and $V$:
+Relating $\Delta$ to $F$. Expand $N$ and $V$:
\[
F(A,B)=-\Delta+\tr(\rho^q)-\tr(N^q)+\delta\tr\rho+\delta^\sigma\tr V .
\]
Since $N=\rho+\delta^\sigma I$ and $r>1$,
$\tr(\rho^q)\le\tr(N^q)$; also
$\tr\rho\le n\kappa^{2\sigma}$ and $V\le(\kappa^2+\delta)I$. Adding
-\eqref{eq:act:coercivity} proves \eqref{eq:act:constraint-bound}.
-\end{proof}
-
-\subsection{The penalty limit and the proof of the action estimate}
-\begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:action}]
-Fix $0<\delta\le1$. Proposition~\ref{prop:path} gives, for every
-$0<\varepsilon\le1$, a lower triangular $C_\varepsilon$ and a path
-$B_\varepsilon$ with the endpoints and norm bound of
-\eqref{eq:act:endpointB} such that, for $A_\varepsilon=C_\varepsilon U$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:path}
- \varepsilon B_\varepsilon'
- =M_\delta(B_\varepsilon)-A_\varepsilon A_\varepsilon^{\mathsf T}.
-\end{equation}
-For fixed $\delta,K,\Omega,U$ the matrices $C_\varepsilon$ are bounded
-uniformly in $0<\varepsilon\le1$. Suppress the subscript and write
+(eq:act:coercivity) proves (eq:act:constraint-bound).
+
+
+## The penalty limit and the proof of the action estimate
+Proof. [Proof of Theorem~thm:action]
+Fix $0<\delta\le1$. Proposition~prop:path gives, for every
+$0<ε\le1$, a lower triangular $C_ε$ and a path
+$B_ε$ with the endpoints and norm bound of
+(eq:act:endpointB) such that, for $A_ε=C_ε U$,
+
+ ε B_ε'
+ =M_\delta(B_ε)-A_ε A_ε^{\mathsf T}.
+
+For fixed $\delta,K,Ω,U$ the matrices $C_ε$ are bounded
+uniformly in $0<ε\le1$. Suppress the subscript and write
$u_\delta(A,B)=\|M_\delta(B)-AA^{\mathsf T}\|_{\HS}^2$. Since
$A\in H^1_0$, $B\in C^1$, and $M_\delta$ has the primitive $J_\delta$ of
-\eqref{eq:field:primitive}, the product and chain rules for absolutely
-continuous functions and \eqref{eq:act:path} give, almost everywhere,
-\begin{align*}
- \bigl(J_\delta(B)+\tr(A^{\mathsf T}BA)\bigr)'
+(eq:field:primitive), the product and chain rules for absolutely
+continuous functions and (eq:act:path) give, almost everywhere,
+
+ (J_\delta(B)+\tr(A^{\mathsf T}BA))'
&=2\tr((A')^{\mathsf T}BA)
- -\tr\bigl((M_\delta(B)-AA^{\mathsf T})B'\bigr)\\
- &=2\tr((A')^{\mathsf T}BA)-\varepsilon^{-1}u_\delta(A,B).
-\end{align*}
+ -\tr((M_\delta(B)-AA^{\mathsf T})B')\\
+ &=2\tr((A')^{\mathsf T}BA)-ε^{-1}u_\delta(A,B).
+
Completing the square in the action and integrating, using $A=0$ at both
endpoints, gives the exact formula
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:identity}
+
\mathcal E_K(A)
=J_\delta(-K)-J_\delta(K)
- +\int_\Omega\Bigl(\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2-F(A,B)
- +\varepsilon^{-1}u_\delta(A,B)\Bigr)\,dx .
-\end{equation}
+ +\int_Ω(\|A'-BA\|_{\HS}^2-F(A,B)
+ +ε^{-1}u_\delta(A,B))\,dx .
-\emph{Penalty limit.} The continuous representative of $U$ is bounded on
-$\overline\Omega$; the bounds on $C_\varepsilon$ and $\|B_\varepsilon\|_{\op}$
-place all pairs $(A_\varepsilon(x),B_\varepsilon(x))$ in one compact set
+
+Penalty limit. The continuous representative of $U$ is bounded on
+$\overlineΩ$; the bounds on $C_ε$ and $\|B_ε\|_{\op}$
+place all pairs $(A_ε(x),B_ε(x))$ in one compact set
$\mathcal K_\delta\subset\R^{n\times d}\times\Sym_n$ with
$\|B\|_{\op}\le\kappa$, on which $F,\Phi_K,u_\delta$ are continuous.
-Lemma~\ref{lem:constraint} then implies
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:act:penalty}
- \limsup_{\varepsilon\downarrow0}\sup_{(A,B)\in\mathcal K_\delta}
- \bigl(F(A,B)+c_*\Phi_K(A,B)-\varepsilon^{-1}u_\delta(A,B)\bigr)
+Lemma~lem:constraint then implies
+
+ limsup_{ε↓0}\sup_{(A,B)\in\mathcal K_\delta}
+ (F(A,B)+c_*\Phi_K(A,B)-ε^{-1}u_\delta(A,B))
\le E_{n,\delta}.
-\end{equation}
-Otherwise some sequence $\varepsilon_j\downarrow0$ and pairs in the
+
+Otherwise some sequence $ε_j↓0$ and pairs in the
compact set make the expression at least $E_{n,\delta}+\tau$, $\tau>0$;
-boundedness of $F+c_*\Phi_K$ would force $u_\delta=O(\varepsilon_j)$, and a
+boundedness of $F+c_*\Phi_K$ would force $u_\delta=O(ε_j)$, and a
convergent subsequence would give a limit pair with $u_\delta=0$ and
-$F+c_*\Phi_K\ge E_{n,\delta}+\tau$, contradicting Lemma~\ref{lem:constraint}.
-
-For any $\tau>0$ choose $\varepsilon$ so the supremum in
-\eqref{eq:act:penalty} is at most $E_{n,\delta}+\tau$. Substituting into
-\eqref{eq:act:identity},
-\begin{align*}
- \mathcal E_K(A_\varepsilon)
- \ge{}&J_\delta(-K)-J_\delta(K)-|\Omega|(E_{n,\delta}+\tau)\\
- &+\int_\Omega\Bigl(\|A_\varepsilon'-B_\varepsilon A_\varepsilon\|_{\HS}^2
- +c_*\Phi_K(A_\varepsilon,B_\varepsilon)\Bigr)\,dx .
-\end{align*}
-By \eqref{eq:field:endpoints} the endpoint term exceeds
+$F+c_*\Phi_K\ge E_{n,\delta}+\tau$, contradicting Lemma~lem:constraint.
+
+For any $\tau>0$ choose $ε$ so the supremum in
+(eq:act:penalty) is at most $E_{n,\delta}+\tau$. Substituting into
+(eq:act:identity),
+
+ \mathcal E_K(A_ε)
+ \ge{}&J_\delta(-K)-J_\delta(K)-|Ω|(E_{n,\delta}+\tau)\\
+ &+\int_Ω(\|A_ε'-B_ε A_ε\|_{\HS}^2
+ +c_*\Phi_K(A_ε,B_ε))\,dx .
+
+By (eq:field:endpoints) the endpoint term exceeds
$b_\sigma\sum\ell_i^{2\gamma}$ up to an error going to $0$ with $\delta$,
-and $|\Omega|E_{n,\delta}\to0$ as $\delta\downarrow0$. First choose
+and $|Ω|E_{n,\delta}\to0$ as $\delta↓0$. First choose
$\delta$ so that both are below $\eta/2$, then $\tau$ with
-$|\Omega|\tau<\eta/2$, then the required $\varepsilon$. This proves
-\eqref{eq:act:bound}. All compactness arguments are made after fixing
+$|Ω|\tau<\eta/2$, then the required $ε$. This proves
+(eq:act:bound). All compactness arguments are made after fixing
$\delta$; no bound uniform in $\delta$ is needed.
-\end{proof}
+
% =====================================================================
-\section{The sharp inequality itself}\label{sec:bound}
+# The sharp inequality itself
% =====================================================================
Before turning to equality we record that the action estimate already
-gives the sharp bound \eqref{eq:sharp}; this is the inequality half of
-Theorem~\ref{thm:main}.
+gives the sharp bound (eq:sharp); this is the inequality half of
+Theorem~thm:main.
+
+[Sharp spectral bound]
+Every potential in Theorem~thm:main satisfies
-\begin{proposition}[Sharp spectral bound]\label{prop:sharp}
-Every potential in Theorem~\ref{thm:main} satisfies
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:bound:sharp}
- \Tr(H_W)_-^\gamma\le\frac{D_\sigma}{b_\sigma}\int_\R\tr(W^p).
-\end{equation}
-\end{proposition}
+ \Tr(H_W)_-^\gamma\le(D_\sigma)/(b_\sigma)\int_\R\tr(W^p).
-\begin{proof}
+
+
+Proof.
First suppose $W$ is real symmetric. Choose any finite list of negative
-eigenvalues $-k_1^2,\dots,-k_n^2$ with $k_1\ge\dots\ge k_n>0$ and real
+eigenvalues $-k_1^2,...,-k_n^2$ with $k_1\ge...\ge k_n>0$ and real
orthonormal eigenfunctions $\varphi_i$. For $0<\xi<k_n^2$ put
-$\ell_i=(k_i^2-\xi)^{1/2}$ and $K=\diag(\ell_1,\dots,\ell_n)$. There are
+$\ell_i=(k_i^2-\xi)^{1/2}$ and $K=\diag(\ell_1,...,\ell_n)$. There are
real smooth compactly supported orthonormal $u_i$ with form matrix
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:bound:trial}
- \bigl(h_W[u_i,u_j]\bigr)_{i,j=1}^n\le-K^2 .
-\end{equation}
+
+ (h_W[u_i,u_j])_{i,j=1}^n\le-K^2 .
+
Indeed, approximate the $\varphi_i$ in $H^1$ and multiply the family by the
inverse square root of its Gram matrix: the Gram matrix tends to $I_n$ and
-the form matrix tends to $-\diag(k_i^2)$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:spectral}, so an
-operator-norm error below $\xi$ gives \eqref{eq:bound:trial}.
+the form matrix tends to $-\diag(k_i^2)$ by Lemma~lem:spectral, so an
+operator-norm error below $\xi$ gives (eq:bound:trial).
-Let $U$ have rows $u_i$ and let $\Omega$ contain their supports. For every
+Let $U$ have rows $u_i$ and let $Ω$ contain their supports. For every
lower triangular $C$, the $i$th row $a_i$ of $A=CU$ satisfies
\[
h_W[a_i]+\ell_i^2\|a_i\|_2^2
\le\sum_{l\le i}C_{il}^2(\ell_i^2-\ell_l^2)\le0 .
\]
Set $Z=A^TA$. Since $AA^T$ and $Z$ have the same nonzero eigenvalues with
-multiplicity, summing the preceding bound and applying Lemma~\ref{lem:young}
+multiplicity, summing the preceding bound and applying Lemma~lem:young
gives
\[
\mathcal E_K(A)\le\int_\R\{\tr(WZ)-\tr(Z^q)\}\le D_\sigma\int_\R\tr(W^p).
\]
-Theorem~\ref{thm:action}, with its nonnegative defects discarded, gives
+Theorem~thm:action, with its nonnegative defects discarded, gives
$b_\sigma\sum_i\ell_i^{2\gamma}\le D_\sigma\int\tr(W^p)+\eta$ for every
-$\eta>0$. Let $\eta\downarrow0$, then $\xi\downarrow0$, and finally exhaust
+$\eta>0$. Let $\eta↓0$, then $\xi↓0$, and finally exhaust
the negative eigenvalues. The case of empty negative spectrum is immediate.
For complex Hermitian $W=E+iF$ with $E,F$ real, the realification
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:bound:realification}
- \widetilde W=\begin{pmatrix}E&-F\\F&E\end{pmatrix}
-\end{equation}
+
+ \widetilde W=E&-F\\F&E
+
is real symmetric and positive semidefinite; the constant unitary matrix
-$2^{-1/2}\bigl(\begin{smallmatrix}I&iI\\I&-iI\end{smallmatrix}\bigr)$
-conjugates $\widetilde W$ to $W\oplus\overline W$. Hence
+$2^{-1/2}(I&iI\\I&-iI)$
+conjugates $\widetilde W$ to $W ⊕ \overline W$. Hence
$\tr(\widetilde W^p)=2\tr(W^p)$ and
$\Tr(H_{\widetilde W})_-^\gamma=2\Tr(H_W)_-^\gamma$ (conjugation identifies
the spectra of $H_W$ and $H_{\overline W}$). Applying the real inequality
-to $\widetilde W$ and dividing by two proves \eqref{eq:bound:sharp}.
-\end{proof}
+to $\widetilde W$ and dividing by two proves (eq:bound:sharp).
+
% =====================================================================
-\section{From equality to pointwise matrix relations}\label{sec:compact}
+# From equality to pointwise matrix relations
% =====================================================================
We now assume equality holds and extract information. The difficulty is
@@ -1209,218 +1209,218 @@ potential has only $m$ channels. The fixed column count $m$ is what keeps
the tails under control.
Throughout this section $W$ is real symmetric, $W\ge0$ almost everywhere,
-and $0<\int_\R\tr(W^p)<\infty$. Suppose equality holds in the form
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:equality}
+and $0<\int_\R\tr(W^p)<∞$. Suppose equality holds in the form
+
b_\sigma\sum_{i\in\mathcal I}k_i^{2\gamma}
=D_\sigma\int_\R\tr(W^p)\,dx,
-\end{equation}
+
where $-k_i^2$ are the negative eigenvalues of $H_W$, repeated according to
-multiplicity, and $k_1\ge k_2\ge\cdots>0$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:spectral}
+multiplicity, and $k_1\ge k_2\ge...>0$. By Lemma~lem:spectral
the index set $\mathcal I$ is a nonempty finite initial segment of $\mathbb N$
or all of $\mathbb N$, each eigenvalue has finite multiplicity, and $k_i\to0$
in the infinite case. Fix real orthonormal eigenfunctions
$\varphi_i\in H^1(\R;\R^m)$, viewed as row vectors. Write
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:H}
+
\mathscr H=\ell^2(\mathcal I;\R),\quad
- \Lambda=\diag(k_i:i\in\mathcal I),\quad
+ Λ=\diag(k_i:i\in\mathcal I),\quad
\kappa=k_1 .
-\end{equation}
+
For operators between real Hilbert spaces the superscript $T$ also denotes
the adjoint.
-\begin{proposition}[Pointwise relations at equality]\label{prop:relations}
+[Pointwise relations at equality]
Under these assumptions there are rows $a_i\in H^1(\R;\R^m)$,
$i\in\mathcal I$, each a finite linear combination of eigenfunctions with
eigenvalue $-k_i^2$, such that
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:roweig}
- -a_i''-a_iW=-k_i^2a_i \quad\text{in distributions.}
-\end{equation}
+
+ -a_i''-a_iW=-k_i^2a_i \quadin distributions.
+
The rows $a_i$ may vanish. On a common set of full measure they define a
Hilbert--Schmidt operator $A(x):\R^m\to\mathscr H$, and there is a bounded
self-adjoint operator $B$ on $\mathscr H$, $\|B\|_{\op}\le\kappa$, with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:limit}
- [B,\Lambda^2]=0,\qquad
- \Lambda^2-B^2=(AA^T)^r,\qquad
+
+ [B,Λ^2]=0,\qquad
+ Λ^2-B^2=(AA^T)^r,\qquad
a_i'(x)=(BA)_{i,\cdot}\quad(i\in\mathcal I).
-\end{equation}
+
Moreover
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:potential}
- W(x)=q\bigl(A(x)^TA(x)\bigr)^r \quad\text{almost everywhere.}
-\end{equation}
+
+ W(x)=q(A(x)^TA(x))^r \quadalmost everywhere.
+
The operator $B$ exists separately at each such point; no measurable choice
is required.
-\end{proposition}
-\subsection{Finite spectral approximations and vanishing errors}
+
+## Finite spectral approximations and vanishing errors
Let $n_j=j$ when $\mathcal I=\mathbb N$ and $n_j=|\mathcal I|$ when
$\mathcal I$ is finite. Choose $0<\xi_j<1/j$ with
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:shift}
+
\ell_{j,i}:=(k_i^2-\xi_j)^{1/2}>0\ (1\le i\le n_j),
\qquad
- \sum_{i\le n_j}\bigl(k_i^{2\gamma}-\ell_{j,i}^{2\gamma}\bigr)<1/j .
-\end{equation}
+ \sum_{i\le n_j}(k_i^{2\gamma}-\ell_{j,i}^{2\gamma})<1/j .
+
The same shift $\xi_j$ is used for every eigenvalue, so the differences of
their squares are unchanged. Set
-$K_j=\diag(\ell_{j,1},\dots,\ell_{j,n_j})$.
+$K_j=\diag(\ell_{j,1},...,\ell_{j,n_j})$.
-By \eqref{eq:bound:trial} we can choose real smooth compactly supported
-orthonormal $u_{j,1},\dots,u_{j,n_j}$ with $H^1$ errors below $1/j$ and
+By (eq:bound:trial) we can choose real smooth compactly supported
+orthonormal $u_{j,1},...,u_{j,n_j}$ with $H^1$ errors below $1/j$ and
form-matrix error below $\xi_j$:
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:form}
+
\|u_{j,i}-\varphi_i\|_{H^1}<1/j,
\qquad
- \bigl(h_W[u_{j,i},u_{j,l}]\bigr)_{i,l=1}^{n_j}\le-K_j^2 .
-\end{equation}
-Let $U_j$ have rows $u_{j,i}$ and choose a bounded interval $\Omega_j$
-containing their supports. Apply Theorem~\ref{thm:action} with
+ (h_W[u_{j,i},u_{j,l}])_{i,l=1}^{n_j}\le-K_j^2 .
+
+Let $U_j$ have rows $u_{j,i}$ and choose a bounded interval $Ω_j$
+containing their supports. Apply Theorem~thm:action with
$K=K_j$, $d=m$, $\kappa=k_1$, and $\eta=1/j$: it gives a lower triangular
$C_j$, a symmetric path $B_j$ with $\|B_j\|_{\op}\le\kappa$, and
-$A_j=C_jU_j$. Extend $A_j$ by zero outside $\Omega_j$ and $B_j$ by $K_j$
-to the left and $-K_j$ to the right; all errors vanish outside $\Omega_j$.
+$A_j=C_jU_j$. Extend $A_j$ by zero outside $Ω_j$ and $B_j$ by $K_j$
+to the left and $-K_j$ to the right; all errors vanish outside $Ω_j$.
The lower triangular form of $C_j$ gives an extra nonnegative error. Put
$Z_j=A_j^TA_j$, an $m\times m$ positive semidefinite matrix. By
-\eqref{eq:comp:form},
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:triangular}
+(eq:comp:form),
+
\mathcal E_{K_j}(A_j)
- \le\int_\R\bigl(\tr(WZ_j)-\tr(Z_j^q)\bigr)\,dx-T_j,
+ \le\int_\R(\tr(WZ_j)-\tr(Z_j^q))\,dx-T_j,
\quad
T_j=\sum_{l\le i\le n_j}(C_j)_{il}^{\,2}(k_l^2-k_i^2)\ge0 .
-\end{equation}
+
Indeed, the $i$th row of $A_j$ is $\sum_{l\le i}(C_j)_{il}u_{j,l}$, whose
quadratic form plus $\ell_{j,i}^2$ times its squared $L^2$ norm is at most
$\sum_{l\le i}(C_j)_{il}^{\,2}(\ell_{j,i}^2-\ell_{j,l}^2)
=-\sum_{l\le i}(C_j)_{il}^{\,2}(k_l^2-k_i^2)$; summing over $i$ and using
that $A_jA_j^T$ and $Z_j$ share nonzero eigenvalues gives
-\eqref{eq:comp:triangular}. The ordering of the $k_i$ makes each summand
+(eq:comp:triangular). The ordering of the $k_i$ makes each summand
of $T_j$ nonnegative.
-Recall the Young deficit \eqref{eq:youngdefect}; by
-Lemma~\ref{lem:young}, $Y(W,Z)=0$ iff $W=qZ^r$. Combining
-Theorem~\ref{thm:action}, \eqref{eq:comp:equality}, and
-\eqref{eq:comp:triangular},
-\begin{align}
- 0\le T_j+\int_\R\Bigl(
- Y(W,Z_j)+\|A_j'-B_jA_j\|_{\HS}^2+c_*\Phi_{K_j}(A_j,B_j)\Bigr)\,dx
- &\le d_j,\label{eq:comp:vanish}\\
- d_j:=b_\sigma\Bigl(\sum_{i\in\mathcal I}k_i^{2\gamma}
- -\sum_{i\le n_j}\ell_{j,i}^{2\gamma}\Bigr)+1/j
- &\longrightarrow0 .\notag
-\end{align}
+Recall the Young deficit (eq:youngdefect); by
+Lemma~lem:young, $Y(W,Z)=0$ iff $W=qZ^r$. Combining
+Theorem~thm:action, (eq:comp:equality), and
+(eq:comp:triangular),
+
+ 0\le T_j+\int_\R(
+ Y(W,Z_j)+\|A_j'-B_jA_j\|_{\HS}^2+c_*\Phi_{K_j}(A_j,B_j))\,dx
+ &\le d_j,\\
+ d_j:=b_\sigma(\sum_{i\in\mathcal I}k_i^{2\gamma}
+ -\sum_{i\le n_j}\ell_{j,i}^{2\gamma})+1/j
+ &→0 .\notag
+
Here $c_*>0$ is fixed; its independence of $n_j$ is essential. Hence all
integral errors and $T_j$ tend to zero.
A uniform bound on $A_j$ will also be needed. The coercive estimate
-\eqref{eq:youngcoercive} gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:coercivity}
+(eq:youngcoercive) gives
+
Y(W,Z_j)\ge\tfrac12\tr(Z_j^q)-(2^{p-1}-1)D_\sigma\tr(W^p),
-\end{equation}
+
and since $Z_j$ is $m\times m$, scalar H\"older gives
$\|A_j\|_{\HS}^{2q}=(\tr Z_j)^q\le m^{q-1}\tr(Z_j^q)$. With
-\eqref{eq:comp:vanish} this bounds $A_j$ uniformly in $L^{2q}(\R)$ in the
+(eq:comp:vanish) this bounds $A_j$ uniformly in $L^{2q}(\R)$ in the
Hilbert--Schmidt norm, independently of its number of rows.
-\subsection{Convergence of each fixed row}
+## Convergence of each fixed row
For fixed $i\in\mathcal I$, the coefficients $(C_j)_{il}$, $l\le i$, are
-bounded as $j\to\infty$. Choose a bounded interval $J_i$ so large that
+bounded as $j\to∞$. Choose a bounded interval $J_i$ so large that
\[
- \Bigl(\int_{J_i}\varphi_l(x)\varphi_s(x)^T\,dx\Bigr)_{l,s=1}^{i}
+ (\int_{J_i}\varphi_l(x)\varphi_s(x)^T\,dx)_{l,s=1}^{i}
\ge\tfrac34 I_i,
\]
possible because the full Gram matrix is the identity. By
-\eqref{eq:comp:form} the corresponding Gram matrix of the $u_{j,l}$ is at
+(eq:comp:form) the corresponding Gram matrix of the $u_{j,l}$ is at
least $\tfrac12 I_i$ for large $j$, so
\[
\frac12\sum_{l\le i}(C_j)_{il}^{\,2}
\le\int_{J_i}|(A_j)_{i,\cdot}|^2\,dx
- \le|J_i|^{1-1/q}\Bigl(\int_{J_i}\|A_j\|_{\HS}^{2q}\,dx\Bigr)^{1/q},
+ \le|J_i|^{1-1/q}(\int_{J_i}\|A_j\|_{\HS}^{2q}\,dx)^{1/q},
\]
uniformly bounded. Lower triangularity keeps the number of coefficients
in a fixed row finite. A diagonal subsequence makes each $(C_j)_{il}$
converge to a limit $c_{il}$, $l\le i$. From $T_j\to0$ and
-\eqref{eq:comp:triangular},
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:gapsuppress}
- c_{il}=0\quad\text{whenever }k_l>k_i .
-\end{equation}
+(eq:comp:triangular),
+
+ c_{il}=0\quadwhenever k_l>k_i .
+
Define $a_i=\sum_{l\le i}c_{il}\varphi_l$, a finite sum; then
-\eqref{eq:comp:form} gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:rowconv}
- (A_j)_{i,\cdot}\longrightarrow a_i\quad\text{in }H^1(\R;\R^m)
- \quad\text{for every fixed }i.
-\end{equation}
+(eq:comp:form) gives
+
+ (A_j)_{i,\cdot}→ a_i\quadin H^1(\R;\R^m)
+ \quadfor every fixed i.
+
The ordering of the eigenvalues together with
-\eqref{eq:comp:gapsuppress} shows only eigenfunctions with eigenvalue
-$-k_i^2$ occur in $a_i$, proving \eqref{eq:comp:roweig} (the distributional
+(eq:comp:gapsuppress) shows only eigenfunctions with eigenvalue
+$-k_i^2$ occur in $a_i$, proving (eq:comp:roweig) (the distributional
form equation follows by testing against smooth compactly supported
functions; the potential is locally integrable and the rows locally
bounded).
Using the continuous, locally absolutely continuous representatives and
-$H^1(\R)\subset C_b(\R)$, \eqref{eq:comp:rowconv} also gives pointwise
+$H^1(\R)\subset C_b(\R)$, (eq:comp:rowconv) also gives pointwise
convergence at every $x$. Passing to a further subsequence we may arrange
-that the integrals of the nonnegative integrand in \eqref{eq:comp:vanish}
+that the integrals of the nonnegative integrand in (eq:comp:vanish)
are summable and that, for every fixed $i$, the squared $L^2$ errors of
-the derivatives in \eqref{eq:comp:rowconv} are summable (a diagonal choice
+the derivatives in (eq:comp:rowconv) are summable (a diagonal choice
successively takes the first $j$ available derivative errors and the
integral error below $2^{-j}$). Consequently, on a common set of full
measure,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:pointwise}
+
Y(W,Z_j)\to0,\quad
\|A_j'-B_jA_j\|_{\HS}\to0,\quad
\Phi_{K_j}(A_j,B_j)\to0,\quad
- (A_j')_{i,\cdot}(x)\to a_i'(x)\ \forall i .
-\end{equation}
+ (A_j')_{i,\cdot}(x)\to a_i'(x)\ ∀ i .
+
We also exclude the null set where $W$ is not a finite positive semidefinite
matrix.
-\subsection{Tail control in the row-index space}
+## Tail control in the row-index space
Pad $A_j,B_j,K_j$ with zeros in the unused coordinates of $\mathscr H$, so
$A_j:\R^m\to\mathscr H$ and $B_j,K_j$ are self-adjoint finite-rank operators.
Since the omitted $k_i$ tend to zero,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:diagonal}
- \|K_j^2-\Lambda^2\|_{\op}
- \le\max\{\xi_j,\sup_{i>n_j}k_i^2\}\longrightarrow0 .
-\end{equation}
-Fix $x$ in the full-measure set of \eqref{eq:comp:pointwise} and suppress
+
+ \|K_j^2-Λ^2\|_{\op}
+ \le\max\{\xi_j,\sup_{i>n_j}k_i^2\}→0 .
+
+Fix $x$ in the full-measure set of (eq:comp:pointwise) and suppress
it. Write $\rho_j=A_jA_j^T$. Convergence of $\Phi$ to zero gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:algebraerr}
+
\|[B_j,K_j^2]\|_{\op}\to0,
\qquad e_j:=\|K_j^2-B_j^2-\rho_j^r\|_{\op}\to0 .
-\end{equation}
+
For $h\ge1$ let $P_h$ project onto the first $h$ coordinates, $Q_h=I-P_h$,
and $s_h=\sup_{i>h}k_i^2\to0$. For unit $v$ in the range of $Q_h$,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:tailquad}
- \|B_jv\|^2+\langle v,\rho_j^rv\rangle\le s_h+e_j .
-\end{equation}
+
+ \|B_jv\|^2+< v,\rho_j^rv>\le s_h+e_j .
+
By Jensen for the spectral measure of $\rho_j$ ($r>1$),
-$\langle v,\rho_jv\rangle^r\le\langle v,\rho_j^rv\rangle$, so
+$< v,\rho_jv>^r\le< v,\rho_j^rv>$, so
$\|Q_h\rho_jQ_h\|_{\op}\le(s_h+e_j)^{1/r}$. Although $\mathscr H$ may be
infinite dimensional, $Q_h\rho_jQ_h$ has rank at most $m$ because $A_j$ has
$m$ columns; its trace is at most $m$ times its operator norm. Hence
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:tailbounds}
+
\|Q_hA_j\|_{\HS}^2\le m(s_h+e_j)^{1/r},
\qquad
\|B_jQ_h\|_{\op}\le(s_h+e_j)^{1/2}.
-\end{equation}
+
The first bound converts decay of the eigenvalue parameters into decay of
the total mass of all omitted rows, with factor the fixed physical
dimension $m$ rather than the number of retained eigenfunctions.
For fixed $h$ the first $h$ rows of $A_j$ converge by
-\eqref{eq:comp:rowconv}; \eqref{eq:comp:tailbounds} makes the remaining rows
+(eq:comp:rowconv); (eq:comp:tailbounds) makes the remaining rows
uniformly small by taking $h$ large then $j$ large. Thus $A_j$ is Cauchy in
Hilbert--Schmidt norm and converges to an operator $A:\R^m\to\mathscr H$
whose rows are the $a_i(x)$:
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:comp:HSlimit}
- A_j\longrightarrow A\quad\text{in Hilbert--Schmidt norm.}
-\end{equation}
+
+ A_j→ A\quadin Hilbert--Schmidt norm.
+
This holds for the whole already-chosen subsequence and needs no further
choice depending on $x$.
For $B_j$ only pointwise compactness is needed. Finite compressions
$P_hB_jP_h$ are bounded in finite-dimensional spaces, so a diagonal
subsequence makes them converge for every $h$; self-adjointness and the
-second bound in \eqref{eq:comp:tailbounds} give
+second bound in (eq:comp:tailbounds) give
$\|B_j-P_hB_jP_h\|_{\op}\le2\|B_jQ_h\|_{\op}\le2(s_h+e_j)^{1/2}$. The
subsequence converges in operator norm to a self-adjoint $B$,
$\|B\|_{\op}\le\kappa$ (possibly depending on $x$).
@@ -1428,113 +1428,113 @@ $\|B\|_{\op}\le\kappa$ (possibly depending on $x$).
Now pass to all products. Hilbert--Schmidt convergence of $A_j$ implies
operator-norm convergence of $A_jA_j^T$ and $A_j^TA_j$; continuous
functional calculus for nonnegative operators gives convergence of their
-$r$th powers. With \eqref{eq:comp:diagonal} and
-\eqref{eq:comp:algebraerr} this proves
-$[B,\Lambda^2]=0$ and $\Lambda^2-B^2=(AA^T)^r$. Also
+$r$th powers. With (eq:comp:diagonal) and
+(eq:comp:algebraerr) this proves
+$[B,Λ^2]=0$ and $Λ^2-B^2=(AA^T)^r$. Also
$B_jA_j\to BA$ in Hilbert--Schmidt norm; taking the $i$th row and using the
derivative convergence and the first-order error in
-\eqref{eq:comp:pointwise} gives $a_i'(x)=(BA)_{i,\cdot}$ for every $i$.
+(eq:comp:pointwise) gives $a_i'(x)=(BA)_{i,\cdot}$ for every $i$.
Finally continuity of the finite-dimensional Young deficit and
-$Y(W,A_j^TA_j)\to0$ give $Y(W,A^TA)=0$, and Lemma~\ref{lem:young} gives
+$Y(W,A_j^TA_j)\to0$ give $Y(W,A^TA)=0$, and Lemma~lem:young gives
$W=q(A^TA)^r$.
All statements hold on one common set of full measure. No function
$x\mapsto B(x)$ is selected; only the existence of a suitable operator at
-each such point enters later. This proves Proposition~\ref{prop:relations}.
+each such point enters later. This proves Proposition~prop:relations.
% =====================================================================
-\section{Fixed channels and the equality profiles}\label{sec:rigid}
+# Fixed channels and the equality profiles
% =====================================================================
-The pointwise relations of Proposition~\ref{prop:relations} involve an
+The pointwise relations of Proposition~prop:relations involve an
auxiliary operator $B$ that may depend on $x$. We now show the channel
subspaces are constant, so that on each channel $B$ becomes a fixed matrix
-obeying an ODE whose solutions are the profiles of \eqref{eq:profile}.
+obeying an ODE whose solutions are the profiles of (eq:profile).
-\subsection{The channel subspaces are constant}
+## The channel subspaces are constant
Assume first that $W$ is real and is a nonzero equality potential. Use the
-rows $a_i$, the numbers $k_i$, and $\Lambda=\diag(k_i)$ from
-Proposition~\ref{prop:relations}. For each distinct value $\alpha>0$ among
+rows $a_i$, the numbers $k_i$, and $Λ=\diag(k_i)$ from
+Proposition~prop:relations. For each distinct value $\alpha>0$ among
the $k_i$, let $n_\alpha$ be its finite multiplicity and let $G_\alpha$ be
the $n_\alpha\times m$ matrix whose rows are the $a_i$ with $k_i=\alpha$;
each entry is in $H^1(\R)$ and we use its continuous representative.
-At every point of the common full-measure set of Proposition~\ref{prop:relations}
+At every point of the common full-measure set of Proposition~prop:relations
choose one of the operators $B$ it supplies. Since $B$ commutes with
-$\Lambda^2$ it preserves each eigenspace, and
-$AA^T=(\Lambda^2-B^2)^{1/r}$ commutes with $B$ and $\Lambda^2$. Writing
+$Λ^2$ it preserves each eigenspace, and
+$AA^T=(Λ^2-B^2)^{1/r}$ commutes with $B$ and $Λ^2$. Writing
$B_\alpha$ for the block on the $\alpha^2$-eigenspace,
-\begin{align}
+
G_\alpha G_\beta^T&=0\quad(\alpha\ne\beta),
- \label{eq:rig:orthogonal}\\
+ \\
G_\alpha'&=B_\alpha G_\alpha,
& [B_\alpha,G_\alpha G_\alpha^T]&=0\nonumber\\
\alpha^2I-B_\alpha^2&=(G_\alpha G_\alpha^T)^r,
& \|B_\alpha\|_{\op}&\le\kappa .
- \label{eq:rig:blocksquare}
-\end{align}
+
+
These hold almost everywhere with no compatibility between the choices of
$B$ at different points.
-\begin{lemma}\label{lem:right}
+
For every $\alpha$ the subspace $\mathcal R_\alpha=(\ker G_\alpha(x))^\perp
\subset\R^m$ is independent of $x$. The nonzero $\mathcal R_\alpha$ are
mutually orthogonal and
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:rig:dimbound}
+
\sum_\alpha\dim\mathcal R_\alpha\le m .
-\end{equation}
+
In particular only finitely many $G_\alpha$ are nonzero. The potential $W$
has a continuous representative, equal to zero on the orthogonal complement
of the $\mathcal R_\alpha$ and to $q(G_\alpha^TG_\alpha)^r$ on
$\mathcal R_\alpha$. With this representative every $G_\alpha$ is $C^2$.
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
-Fix $v\in\R^m$. From \eqref{eq:rig:blocksquare},
+
+Proof.
+Fix $v\in\R^m$. From (eq:rig:blocksquare),
$\|(G_\alpha v)'\|\le\kappa\|G_\alpha v\|$ almost everywhere, and $G_\alpha v$
is locally absolutely continuous. If it vanishes at $x_0$, integration and
Gronwall's inequality, first right and then left of $x_0$, show it vanishes
everywhere; hence $\ker G_\alpha(x)$ is constant, including off the original
full-measure set.
-The products in \eqref{eq:rig:orthogonal} are continuous, so their
+The products in (eq:rig:orthogonal) are continuous, so their
almost-everywhere vanishing is everywhere; thus the constant row spaces
$\mathcal R_\alpha$ are mutually orthogonal, giving
-\eqref{eq:rig:dimbound} and finiteness of the nonzero blocks. On the
+(eq:rig:dimbound) and finiteness of the nonzero blocks. On the
full-measure set, $A^TA=\sum_\alpha G_\alpha^TG_\alpha$ with only finitely
many nonzero summands, each acting on its own $\mathcal R_\alpha$, so
-\eqref{eq:comp:potential} gives
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:rig:contpot}
- W=q\sum_\alpha(G_\alpha^TG_\alpha)^r \quad\text{almost everywhere}.
-\end{equation}
+(eq:comp:potential) gives
+
+ W=q\sum_\alpha(G_\alpha^TG_\alpha)^r \quadalmost everywhere.
+
The right side is continuous; we use it as the representative of $W$. The
-row equation \eqref{eq:comp:roweig} then reads
+row equation (eq:comp:roweig) then reads
$G_\alpha''=\alpha^2G_\alpha-G_\alpha W$ in distributions, whose right side
is continuous; integrating twice, $G_\alpha$ is $C^2$.
-\end{proof}
+
The row spaces split $\R^m$ into finitely many constant channels. To find
the potential on one channel we also need a constant range for $G_\alpha$ in
the eigenfunction index space.
-\begin{lemma}\label{lem:left}
+
For $\alpha$ with $\ell:=\dim\mathcal R_\alpha>0$, the range of
$G_\alpha(x)$ in $\R^{n_\alpha}$ is independent of $x$. In constant
orthonormal bases of this range and of $\mathcal R_\alpha$ the restriction
of $G_\alpha$ is an invertible $C^2$ matrix $D:\R\to\R^{\ell\times\ell}$, and
$B_0=D'D^{-1}$ is $C^1$ with, everywhere,
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:rig:active}
+
B_0=B_0^T,\qquad
\alpha^2I-B_0^2=(DD^T)^r>0,\qquad
B_0'=r(B_0^2-\alpha^2I).
-\end{equation}
-\end{lemma}
-\begin{proof}
+
+
+Proof.
Choose a constant orthonormal basis of $\mathcal R_\alpha$ and let $E(x)$ be
the matrix of $G_\alpha(x)$ restricted to it; it has full column rank $\ell$
everywhere. Its range projection is $P=E(E^TE)^{-1}E^T$. The commutator in
-\eqref{eq:rig:blocksquare} shows $B_\alpha$ preserves the range of
+(eq:rig:blocksquare) shows $B_\alpha$ preserves the range of
$G_\alpha G_\alpha^T$, which is the range of $E$; thus $E'=B_\alpha E$ has
columns in this range almost everywhere. Differentiating $P$ gives
$P'=(I-P)E'(E^TE)^{-1}E^T+E(E^TE)^{-1}(E')^T(I-P)=0$ almost everywhere,
@@ -1543,10 +1543,10 @@ and since $P$ is $C^1$ it is constant.
With constant orthonormal bases of both spaces, $D$ is invertible $C^2$ and
$D'D^{-1}$ is, almost everywhere, the restriction of $B_\alpha$ to its
invariant range. Then the symmetry and the square identity in
-\eqref{eq:rig:active} hold almost everywhere and extend by continuity;
+(eq:rig:active) hold almost everywhere and extend by continuity;
positivity is strict because $D$ is invertible. On $\mathcal R_\alpha$,
-\eqref{eq:rig:contpot} makes the potential $q(D^TD)^r$, so
-\eqref{eq:comp:roweig} becomes $D''=\alpha^2D-q(DD^T)^rD$ (using a
+(eq:rig:contpot) makes the potential $q(D^TD)^r$, so
+(eq:comp:roweig) becomes $D''=\alpha^2D-q(DD^T)^rD$ (using a
singular-value decomposition for the second form). Differentiating
$B_0=D'D^{-1}$ with $q=r+1$,
\[
@@ -1554,164 +1554,164 @@ $B_0=D'D^{-1}$ with $q=r+1$,
=\alpha^2I-q(\alpha^2I-B_0^2)-B_0^2
=r(B_0^2-\alpha^2I).
\]
-\end{proof}
-\subsection{The matrix Riccati equation separates the profiles}
+
+## The matrix Riccati equation separates the profiles
Fix a nonzero block and the matrix $B_0$. Orthogonally diagonalise the
symmetric $B_0(x_*)$ at one point. The right side of the Riccati equation is
a polynomial in $B_0$, so uniqueness of the matrix ODE preserves the
-diagonal form. The strict inequality in \eqref{eq:rig:active} places each
+diagonal form. The strict inequality in (eq:rig:active) places each
initial diagonal entry $b_j(x_*)$ in $(-\alpha,\alpha)$, and the scalar
equation $b_j'=r(b_j^2-\alpha^2)$ has the unique solution with that value
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:rig:tanh}
- b_j(x)=-\alpha\tanh\!\bigl(r\alpha(x-y_j)\bigr),\qquad 1\le j\le\ell,
-\end{equation}
+
+ b_j(x)=-\alphatanh\!(r\alpha(x-y_j)),\qquad 1\le j\le\ell,
+
for a unique centre $y_j$. The diagonal matrix with these entries solves the
same initial-value problem as $B_0$ on all of $\R$, so uniqueness gives
equality everywhere.
-Now \eqref{eq:rig:active} shows $DD^T$ is diagonal in these coordinates.
+Now (eq:rig:active) shows $DD^T$ is diagonal in these coordinates.
Since $D'=\diag(b_j)D$, each row of $D$ is a positive scalar multiple of its
value at $x_*$; the rows are nonzero and mutually orthogonal (as $DD^T$ is
diagonal). Taking their normalised directions as a constant orthonormal
basis of $\mathcal R_\alpha$ makes $D$ diagonal with positive entries. The
potential in this fixed basis is diagonal, with entries
-\begin{equation}\label{eq:rig:profiles}
- q\bigl(\alpha^2-b_j(x)^2\bigr)
- =(r+1)\alpha^2\,\sech^2\!\bigl(r\alpha(x-y_j)\bigr).
-\end{equation}
+
+ q(\alpha^2-b_j(x)^2)
+ =(r+1)\alpha^2\,\sech^2\!(r\alpha(x-y_j)).
+
Combining these bases over the finitely many nonzero $\mathcal R_\alpha$ and
adding a basis of their orthogonal complement gives, for real $W$, the form
-\eqref{eq:classification} with at most $m$ nonzero profiles by
-\eqref{eq:rig:dimbound}. The zero potential corresponds to $k=0$.
+(eq:classification) with at most $m$ nonzero profiles by
+(eq:rig:dimbound). The zero potential corresponds to $k=0$.
-\subsection{Complex Hermitian potentials}
+## Complex Hermitian potentials
For a complex Hermitian $W$, take the realification $\widetilde W$ from
-\eqref{eq:bound:realification}, which is equivalent to $W\oplus\overline W$
+(eq:bound:realification), which is equivalent to $W ⊕ \overline W$
by a constant unitary matrix, with both $\int\tr(W^p)$ and the negative
moment doubled. Equality for $W$ implies equality for the real
$\widetilde W$, so the real result gives a constant unitary $V$ with
\[
- W(x)\oplus\overline W(x)
- =V\diag(f_1(x),\dots,f_{2m}(x))V^*
- \quad\text{almost everywhere,}
+ W(x) ⊕ \overline W(x)
+ =V\diag(f_1(x),...,f_{2m}(x))V^*
+ \quadalmost everywhere,
\]
-each $f_j$ a profile \eqref{eq:rig:profiles} or zero. Let $P$ be the
+each $f_j$ a profile (eq:rig:profiles) or zero. Let $P$ be the
projection onto the first summand and $\widehat P=V^*PV$. Since $P$
-commutes with $W\oplus\overline W$, we have
+commutes with $W ⊕ \overline W$, we have
$(f_i-f_j)\widehat P_{ij}=0$ almost everywhere, so $\widehat P_{ij}=0$
whenever $f_i,f_j$ are not equal almost everywhere. Partition the indices
into groups of identical functions (including the zero function). On each
group the diagonal potential is a scalar multiple of the identity, so any
constant orthonormal basis of the intersection of that coordinate group with
-$\operatorname{ran}\widehat P$ diagonalises it. Transporting these bases by
+$ran\widehat P$ diagonalises it. Transporting these bases by
$V$ gives a constant unitary basis of $\C^m$ in which $W$ has the asserted
profiles. This proves necessity for complex Hermitian $W$.
-\subsection{Every listed potential attains equality}
+## Every listed potential attains equality
It remains to verify attainment directly. Fix $a>0$ and $x_0\in\R$ and set
\[
- V(x)=(r+1)a^2\sech^2\!\bigl(ra(x-x_0)\bigr),
- \qquad H=-\partial_x^2-V .
+ V(x)=(r+1)a^2\sech^2\!(ra(x-x_0)),
+ \qquad H=-∂_x^2-V .
\]
-Put $w(x)=a\tanh\bigl(ra(x-x_0)\bigr)$ and $Q=\partial_x+w$ on
+Put $w(x)=atanh(ra(x-x_0))$ and $Q=∂_x+w$ on
$H^1(\R)$. Since $w,w'$ are bounded, direct differentiation gives
-\begin{align}
+
Q^*Q&=H+a^2,
- \label{eq:rig:factor}\\
- QQ^*&=-\partial_x^2+a^2+(r-1)a^2\sech^2\!\bigl(ra(x-x_0)\bigr)\ge a^2,
- \label{eq:rig:partner}
-\end{align}
+ \\
+ QQ^*&=-∂_x^2+a^2+(r-1)a^2\sech^2\!(ra(x-x_0))\ge a^2,
+
+
the last inequality because $r>1$. The equation $Q\psi=0$ has the
one-dimensional $L^2$ solution space
\[
- \ker Q=\operatorname{span}\bigl\{\sech^{1/r}(ra(x-x_0))\bigr\},
+ \ker Q=span\bigl\{\sech^{1/r}(ra(x-x_0))\bigr\},
\]
-so $-a^2$ is a simple eigenvalue of $H$, and \eqref{eq:rig:factor} excludes
+so $-a^2$ is a simple eigenvalue of $H$, and (eq:rig:factor) excludes
eigenvalues below it. If $H\phi=\lambda\phi$ with $-a^2<\lambda<0$, put
$\mu=\lambda+a^2>0$, $g=Q\phi$; then $\|g\|_2^2=\mu\|\phi\|_2^2>0$,
-$Q^*Q\phi=\mu\phi\in\operatorname{Dom}Q$, so $g\in\operatorname{Dom}(QQ^*)$
-and $QQ^*g=\mu g$, contradicting \eqref{eq:rig:partner} because $\mu<a^2$.
+$Q^*Q\phi=\mu\phi\inDomQ$, so $g\inDom(QQ^*)$
+and $QQ^*g=\mu g$, contradicting (eq:rig:partner) because $\mu<a^2$.
Hence $-a^2$ is the only negative eigenvalue.
-Finally $2p-1=2\gamma$ and the substitution $s=\tanh y$ give
-\begin{align*}
+Finally $2p-1=2\gamma$ and the substitution $s=tanh y$ give
+
\int_\R V(x)^p\,dx
- &=\frac{(r+1)^p}{r}a^{2\gamma}\int_\R\sech^{2p}y\,dy\\
- &=\frac{(r+1)^p}{r}a^{2\gamma}\int_{-1}^{1}(1-s^2)^{p-1}\,ds
- =\frac{b_\sigma}{D_\sigma}a^{2\gamma},
-\end{align*}
+ &=((r+1)^p)/(r)a^{2\gamma}\int_\R\sech^{2p}y\,dy\\
+ &=((r+1)^p)/(r)a^{2\gamma}\int_{-1}^{1}(1-s^2)^{p-1}\,ds
+ =(b_\sigma)/(D_\sigma)a^{2\gamma},
+
using $(r+1)^p/r=D_\sigma^{-1}$ and $p-1=\sigma$. Therefore
$\Tr(H)_-^\gamma=a^{2\gamma}=C_\gamma\int_\R V^p$. The zero potential
contributes zero to both sides; finite orthogonal direct sums add both
spectral moments and trace integrals, and constant unitary conjugation
-changes neither. So every potential listed in Theorem~\ref{thm:main}
+changes neither. So every potential listed in Theorem~thm:main
attains equality, completing the proof.
% =====================================================================
-\begin{thebibliography}{99}
+{99}
\raggedright
\bibitem{AizenmanLieb1978}
Michael Aizenman and Elliott H. Lieb,
-\emph{On semi-classical bounds for eigenvalues of Schr\"odinger operators},
-Physics Letters A \textbf{66} (1978), no.~6, 427--429.
+On semi-classical bounds for eigenvalues of Schr\"odinger operators,
+Physics Letters A 66 (1978), no.~6, 427--429.
\bibitem{BenguriaLoss2000}
Rafael Benguria and Michael Loss,
-\emph{A simple proof of a theorem of Laptev and Weidl},
-Mathematical Research Letters \textbf{7} (2000), no.~2--3, 195--203.
+A simple proof of a theorem of Laptev and Weidl,
+Mathematical Research Letters 7 (2000), no.~2--3, 195--203.
\bibitem{FrankGontierLewin2025}
Rupert L. Frank, David Gontier and Mathieu Lewin,
-\emph{Optimizers for the finite-rank Lieb--Thirring inequality},
-American Journal of Mathematics \textbf{147} (2025), no.~2, 503--560.
+Optimizers for the finite-rank Lieb--Thirring inequality,
+American Journal of Mathematics 147 (2025), no.~2, 503--560.
\bibitem{HLW2000}
Dirk Hundertmark, Ari Laptev and Timo Weidl,
-\emph{New bounds on the Lieb--Thirring constants},
-Inventiones Mathematicae \textbf{140} (2000), no.~3, 693--704.
+New bounds on the Lieb--Thirring constants,
+Inventiones Mathematicae 140 (2000), no.~3, 693--704.
\bibitem{HLT1998}
Dirk Hundertmark, Elliott H. Lieb and Lawrence E. Thomas,
-\emph{A sharp bound for an eigenvalue moment of the one-dimensional
-Schr\"odinger operator},
-Advances in Theoretical and Mathematical Physics \textbf{2} (1998),
+A sharp bound for an eigenvalue moment of the one-dimensional
+Schr\"odinger operator,
+Advances in Theoretical and Mathematical Physics 2 (1998),
no.~4, 719--731.
\bibitem{Keller1961}
Joseph B. Keller,
-\emph{Lower bounds and isoperimetric inequalities for eigenvalues of the
-Schr\"odinger equation},
-Journal of Mathematical Physics \textbf{2} (1961), no.~2, 262--266.
+Lower bounds and isoperimetric inequalities for eigenvalues of the
+Schr\"odinger equation,
+Journal of Mathematical Physics 2 (1961), no.~2, 262--266.
\bibitem{LaptevWeidl2000}
Ari Laptev and Timo Weidl,
-\emph{Sharp Lieb--Thirring inequalities in high dimensions},
-Acta Mathematica \textbf{184} (2000), no.~1, 87--111.
+Sharp Lieb--Thirring inequalities in high dimensions,
+Acta Mathematica 184 (2000), no.~1, 87--111.
\bibitem{LiebThirring1975}
Elliott H. Lieb and Walter E. Thirring,
-\emph{Bound for the kinetic energy of fermions which proves the stability
-of matter},
-Physical Review Letters \textbf{35} (1975), no.~11, 687--689.
+Bound for the kinetic energy of fermions which proves the stability
+of matter,
+Physical Review Letters 35 (1975), no.~11, 687--689.
\bibitem{LiebThirring1976}
Elliott H. Lieb and Walter E. Thirring,
-\emph{Inequalities for the moments of the eigenvalues of the Schr\"odinger
-Hamiltonian and their relation to Sobolev inequalities},
-in \emph{Studies in Mathematical Physics: Essays in Honor of Valentine
-Bargmann}, Princeton University Press, 1976, 269--303.
+Inequalities for the moments of the eigenvalues of the Schr\"odinger
+Hamiltonian and their relation to Sobolev inequalities,
+in Studies in Mathematical Physics: Essays in Honor of Valentine
+Bargmann, Princeton University Press, 1976, 269--303.
\bibitem{MLT}
-\emph{Sharp one-dimensional Lieb--Thirring inequalities for matrix
-potentials}, companion preprint, 2026.
+Sharp one-dimensional Lieb--Thirring inequalities for matrix
+potentials, companion preprint, 2026.
\bibitem{Sard1942}
Arthur Sard,
-\emph{The measure of the critical values of differentiable maps},
-Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society \textbf{48} (1942),
+The measure of the critical values of differentiable maps,
+Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society 48 (1942),
883--890.
-\end{thebibliography}
-\end{document}
+
+