diff ee68750..d6cd9da spacetime_penrose_enclosing_area_v2.txt
diff --git a/spacetime_penrose_enclosing_area_v2.txt b/spacetime_penrose_enclosing_area_v2.txt
index e69de29..7ae7158 100644
--- a/spacetime_penrose_enclosing_area_v2.txt
+++ b/spacetime_penrose_enclosing_area_v2.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,571 @@
+Penrose's null shell argument traded a kinematic worry about nascent
+singularities for a numerical inequality between mass and area. Place a
+shell on the verge of collapsing to a black hole. Once it collapses,
+the mass that has fallen in is the mass of the hole; the area that the
+hole takes on must be paid for in mass. The resulting prediction is
+that the ADM energy of any initial data set with a compact weakly
+future trapped boundary is bounded below by a Schwarzschild mass whose
+horizon area equals the boundary area. This prediction, the Penrose
+inequality, has independent significance: a violation would let an
+exterior observer identify a naked singularity through a mismatch
+between the mass observed at infinity and the area of a horizon.
+
+The area in the statement requires care. Ben-Dov constructed
+spherically symmetric data, satisfying the dominant energy condition,
+whose apparent horizon area is too large for the mass bound. Carrasco
+and Mars found a further obstruction for generalized apparent
+horizons, already among data whose outer generalized horizon is
+area-minimizing. Both examples establish that mass-area theorems must
+fix more than a trapping condition: they must also fix an enclosing
+class. The choice adopted below is the infimum of the full area of an
+enclosing cut, meaning the entire intrinsic boundary of a closed outer
+region that contains the whole distant end; every component counts,
+and every portion coinciding with the original boundary counts. This
+is the smallest admissible trap area, and it is the one attained by
+the sharp examples.
+
+./pdfs/0911.0883.pdf
+
+The time-symmetric case, $K=0$, is settled in every dimension. When
+the second fundamental form vanishes and the dominant energy condition
+reads $R_g \ge 0$, Geroch observed that the Hawking mass of a surface
+evolving by inverse mean curvature flow is monotone. Jang and Wald
+related that monotonicity to the Penrose bound, conditional on
+regularity of the flow. Huisken and Ilmanen removed the regularity
+hypothesis with the weak formulation of inverse mean curvature flow:
+jumps are permitted, the monotone behavior of the Hawking mass
+persists across them, and the sharp bound holds for each connected
+component of an outermost minimal boundary. Bray's conformal flow
+gives a different proof that yields the bound for the total area of
+a possibly disconnected horizon. Bray and Lee extended Bray's
+argument through spatial dimension seven by invoking the positive
+mass theorem in those dimensions. Above dimension seven, minimizing
+frontiers can be singular, and Bi and Zhu extended the conformal-flow
+argument to that range by treating the singular set carefully.
+
+./pdfs/math_9906087.pdf
+./pdfs/math_9911173.pdf
+./pdfs/0708.0850.pdf
+./pdfs/2605.00680.pdf
+
+The spacetime case, with $K$ arbitrary, brings a different set of
+difficulties. Neither scalar curvature nor boundary mean curvature
+retains the sign required by Riemannian flow methods. Jang introduced
+a graph equation that deforms the geometry along a graph over the
+initial surface while preserving the dominant energy condition.
+Schoen and Yau combined the graph equation with a conformal
+deformation and a minimal-surface argument, establishing positive
+mass in dimension three. Their scalar-curvature identity isolates a
+nonnegative dominant-energy term plus nonnegative squares plus a
+divergence, but that divergence has no prescribed sign, and a
+Penrose-type bound requires it to be controlled. For the Penrose
+bound the deformation must simultaneously produce a lower bound on
+enclosing area and an upper bound on mass.
+
+Bray and Khuri generalized Schoen and Yau's scalar-curvature identity
+to a warped graph and proposed a coupled system whose divergence has a
+prescribed nonzero source. Han and Khuri proved that the generalized
+Jang equation admits solutions with prescribed warp up to boundary
+blow-up. Jaracz then constructed spherical data for which the
+particular coupling given by generalized Jang with zero divergence
+admits no smooth radial solution with the required positive warp and
+asymptotics; the obstruction is specific to that zero-divergence
+coupling and to the radial solution class, and it does not exclude
+other systems.
+
+./pdfs/0910.4785.pdf
+./pdfs/0905.2622.pdf
+./pdfs/2304.09332.pdf
+./pdfs/2405.12249.pdf
+
+Sharp inequalities without symmetry hold in several special regimes.
+For spherically symmetric data, Malec and O Murchadha proved the bound
+under a maximality hypothesis, and Hayward removed that restriction
+using monotonicity of the Misner-Sharp energy in untrapped regions.
+Bryden, Khuri and Sormani extended these methods to spherical symmetry
+in every spatial dimension. Khuri and Kunduri proved a sharp
+spacetime inequality for cohomogeneity-one data of dimension
+$2(\ell+1)$ with $SU(\ell+1)$ symmetry; their cohomogeneity-one result
+is Riemannian. For nonsymmetric asymptotically flat data in dimension
+three, Allen, Bryden, Kazaras and Khuri proved an invariant-mass bound
+with a suboptimal constant; their assumptions include extra decay of
+$tr_g K$ and at least one outermost collection of marginal components.
+Ellithy bounded the total area of outermost future apparent-horizon
+sections under a quasi-final-state condition on the future
+development, with negative ingoing expansion. Dong obtained bounds
+under a pure-trace hypothesis and under a two-convexity hypothesis.
+These results use area and tensor hypotheses different from the
+present ones. Mars surveys the underlying choices.
+
+./pdfs/0906.5566.pdf
+./pdfs/2504.10641.pdf
+./pdfs/2605.18730.pdf
+./pdfs/2605.26504.pdf
+./pdfs/2607.20741.pdf
+./pdfs/gr-qc_9401014.pdf
+./pdfs/gr-qc_9408002.pdf
+
+The theorem proved below is the enclosing-area Penrose inequality for
+smooth one-ended exteriors in every spatial dimension $n \ge 3$,
+under the dominant energy condition, weak future trapping of every
+boundary component, differentiated decay at infinity, and positive
+enclosing area. The bound is sharp in each dimension, and the
+Schwarzschild-Tangherlini exterior attains equality.
+
+The precise statement. Let $\Omega$ be a smooth connected orientable
+$n$-manifold with a nonempty compact smooth boundary $S$, complete
+with $S$ included, and with exactly one end diffeomorphic to the
+exterior of a closed ball in $\mathbb R^n$. Let $g$ be a smooth
+Riemannian metric and $K$ a smooth symmetric covariant two-tensor on
+$\Omega$. Write $\tau = tr_g K$. The constraint densities are
+$$
+2\mu = R_g + \tau^2 - |K|_g^2,
+\qquad
+J_i = div(K - \tau g)_i,
+$$
+and the dominant energy condition is $\mu \ge |J|_g$. The ADM energy
+and momentum are
+$$
+E = \frac{1}{2(n-1)\omega_{n-1}} \lim_{R\to\infty}
+ \int_{|x| = R}
+ (\partial_j g_{ij} - \partial_i g_{jj})\, n^i_\delta\, dA_\delta,
+$$
+$$
+P_i = \frac{1}{(n-1)\omega_{n-1}} \lim_{R\to\infty}
+ \int_{|x| = R}
+ \bigl(K_{ij} - \tau g_{ij}\bigr)\, n^j_\delta\, dA_\delta,
+$$
+where $n_\delta$ and $dA_\delta$ are Euclidean and
+$\omega_{n-1} = |\mathbb S^{n-1}|$. The normal $\nu$ points into
+$\Omega$ on $S$, and the future expansion is
+$\theta_+ = H_S + tr_S K$. The boundary is weakly future outer
+trapped when $\theta_+ \le 0$ on every component. No condition is
+imposed on the other null expansion.
+
+A full enclosing cut is the entire intrinsic manifold boundary
+$\partial D$ of a connected smooth codimension-zero submanifold
+$D \subset \Omega$ that is closed in $\Omega$, whose manifold interior
+lies in $\operatorname{int}\Omega$, and that contains the whole
+sufficiently distant part of the end. Its full boundary is required
+to be compact, smooth, embedded, and two-sided. In particular
+$D = \Omega$ is admissible, with $\partial \Omega = S$. The
+enclosing infimum is
+$$
+A_{min}(S) = \inf_D \, \mathrm{Area}_g(\partial D),
+$$
+over full enclosing cuts. Use of the intrinsic boundary counts
+coincident portions of $S$ in the total. The infimum need not be
+attained, and no cut need be connected, trapped, or minimal.
+
+Theorem. Let $n \ge 3$ and let $(\Omega, g, K)$ be a smooth
+connected orientable one-ended exterior as above. Assume
+$\mu, |J|_g \in L^1(\Omega, dV_g)$ with $\mu \ge |J|_g$, assume that
+every component of $S$ is weakly future outer trapped, and assume
+$$
+g - \delta = O_6(r^{-q}),
+\qquad
+K = O_5(r^{-1-q}),
+\qquad
+\frac{n-2}{2} < q < n-2.
+$$
+Assume the ADM limits exist and are finite, that $E > |P|_\delta$,
+and that $A_{min}(S) > 0$. Then
+$$
+\sqrt{E^2 - |P|_\delta^2}
+\ge \frac{1}{2}
+ \left(\frac{A_{min}(S)}{\omega_{n-1}}\right)^{(n-2)/(n-1)}.
+$$
+
+The coefficient and factor are forced by the Schwarzschild-Tangherlini
+exterior in each dimension. Neither outermostness of $S$ nor area
+minimization of $S$ is assumed, the second fundamental form is
+arbitrary, and no spin, vacuum, or interior-topology hypothesis
+enters.
+
+Sharpness. For $m>0$ put $r_m = (2m)^{1/(n-2)}$ and
+$$
+g_m = \left(1 + \frac{m}{2 r^{n-2}}\right)^{4/(n-2)} \delta,
+\qquad
+K_m = 0,
+$$
+restricted to $r \ge r_m$ with the boundary a round sphere of areal
+radius $r_m$. Its ADM energy is $m$, its ADM momentum is zero, and
+its scalar curvature vanishes. Radial projection from any full
+enclosing cut to the boundary sphere is nonexpansive on
+$(n-1)$-tangent directions and has degree one, so every full cut has
+$(n-1)$-volume at least
+$\omega_{n-1} (2m)^{(n-1)/(n-2)}$; the boundary itself attains that
+value. Hence $A_{min}(S) = \omega_{n-1} (2m)^{(n-1)/(n-2)}$ and the
+inequality is an equality for this family.
+
+The time-symmetric example above is the simplest sharp family. Equality
+in the general case requires a separate variational argument, which is
+not the subject of the present text.
+
+The statement carries the hypothesis $E > |P|_\delta$. That
+hypothesis is redundant once $A_{min}(S) > 0$.
+
+Corollary. Assume all hypotheses of the theorem above except
+$E > |P|_\delta$. Then $E > |P|_\delta$ and the inequality holds.
+
+The proof of the corollary is a positive conformal shell
+$g_\lambda = U_\lambda^{4/(n-2)} g$,
+$K_\lambda = U_\lambda^{2/(n-2)} K$ for an appropriate $U_\lambda \ge 1$,
+constant near $S$. The scalar $U_\lambda$ solves
+$-\Delta_g U_\lambda \ge |K|_g |dU_\lambda|_g$ in the sense that
+the right side of the conformal dominant-energy inequality is
+nonnegative, so the condition is preserved. The conformal factor is
+chosen so that $E_\lambda = E + 2\lambda$ and $P_\lambda = P$; because
+$U_\lambda \ge 1$ and is constant near $S$, every full cut has area
+at least as large as the original and the boundary expansion sign is
+preserved. If $E \le |P|_\delta$ and $|P|_\delta$ is finite, take
+$\lambda_j \downarrow 0$ small enough that
+$E_j = |P|_\delta + \varepsilon_j$ is future timelike. The inequality
+applies to each $g_j$ and forces
+$\sqrt{E_j^2 - |P|_\delta^2} \ge \mathrm{const} > 0$ with a
+$\lambda_j$-independent constant, whereas the left side tends to zero.
+Contradiction. Hence $E > |P|_\delta$, and the main theorem applies
+to the original data.
+
+Finally, in dimensions three and four only two derivatives of the
+metric and one derivative of $K$ are required.
+
+Theorem. Let $n \in \{3,4\}$. Under all hypotheses of the main
+theorem except the differentiated decay bound, assume only
+$$
+g - \delta = O_2(r^{-q}),
+\qquad
+K = O_1(r^{-1-q}),
+\qquad
+q > \frac{n-2}{2}.
+$$
+Then $A_{min}(S) > 0$, $E > |P|_\delta$, and the inequality holds.
+
+Positive enclosing area and timelikeness are both conclusions there,
+and no decay is imposed on $tr_g K$. The two weaker decay regimes
+require distinct reductions: in three dimensions a full convergence
+of enclosing infima is available, whereas in four dimensions only the
+one-sided comparison needed for the numerical argument survives.
+
+The proof proceeds in stages. First, prepare the end so that the
+second fundamental form has compact support, the dominant energy
+condition is strict, the boundary is strictly trapped, and enclosing
+areas are preserved up to a small multiplicative error. Then introduce
+a filled manifold with no inner boundary and solve a coupled system
+for a graph height and a conformal factor. Use a scalar curvature
+identity to convert the system into a lower bound on the ADM energy
+and a metric-domination statement for areas. Place a minimizing
+enclosure in a fixed compact region by a height barrier and a
+two-density comparison. Apply the sharp Riemannian numerical
+inequality to that enclosure. Let the small parameters tend to zero.
+In dimensions three and four with weaker decay, the preparation is
+more involved but the same final step applies.
+
+The main theorem will be deduced from a sharper statement about a
+class of "prepared" data. An exterior $(\Omega, g_0, K_0)$ is called
+prepared when:
+- $\operatorname{supp} K_0$ is compact;
+- $g_0 - \delta = O_d(r^{2-n})$ for every fixed $d$;
+- $R_{g_0} = O(r^{-n-\beta})$ for some $\beta \in (0, 1)$;
+- $\mu_0 - |J_0|_{g_0} \ge c\, \varrho^{-n-\beta}$ for some
+ $c > 0$ and a smooth radius $\varrho \asymp r$;
+- every component of $S$ has strictly negative future expansion;
+- the ADM momentum vanishes and the ADM energy is $E_0$;
+- $A_{min,g_0}(S) > 0$.
+
+The reduction from arbitrary data subject to the hypotheses of the
+main theorem to prepared data is accomplished by four moves: replace
+the far end by a rest-frame vacuum slice with the same ADM vector;
+bend that rest slice to a static Schwarzschild-Tangherlini slice,
+using the fact that no constraint is created inside a vacuum region;
+repair the small dominant-energy deficit introduced by the gluing with
+a positive conformal factor; and perturb the resulting data by a small
+solution of a scalar drift equation to make the dominant-energy
+inequality strict and the boundary trapping strict. A proper radial
+diffeomorphism protects every full enclosing cut during the end
+replacement, so that no cut loses in its comparison against the
+original area.
+
+The trace of this logic is the following.
+
+Reduction Proposition. Let $(\Omega, g, K)$ be a smooth one-ended
+exterior with
+$$
+g - \delta = O_6(r^{-q}), \quad
+K = O_5(r^{-1-q}), \quad
+\frac{n-2}{2} < q < n-2,
+$$
+integrable constraint densities satisfying $\mu \ge |J|_g$,
+finite ADM limits satisfying $E > |P|$, and $\theta_+(S) \le 0$ on
+every component. Suppose $A_{min,g}(S) = a > 0$ and put
+$m = (E^2 - |P|_\delta^2)^{1/2}$. Then there are prepared data
+$(g_j, K_j)$ on the same exterior, a fixed $\beta \in (0, 1)$,
+numbers $\varepsilon_j \downarrow 0$, and proper diffeomorphisms
+$\Phi_j : \Omega \to \Omega$ that are the identity near $S$, such that
+$$
+P_j = 0, \quad
+E_j \to m, \quad
+\Phi_j^* g \le (1+\varepsilon_j) g_j, \quad
+A_{min,g_j}(S) \ge (1+\varepsilon_j)^{-(n-1)/2} a.
+$$
+The constants implicit in "prepared" may depend on $j$.
+
+The remainder of the present section proves the reduction.
+
+For a smooth scalar $s$, put $g_s = e^{2s} g$ and $K_s = e^s K$.
+Then the conformal connection formula and scalar-curvature formula
+give
+$$
+e^{2s}\bigl(\mu_s + J_s(v_s)\bigr)
+= \mu + J(v) - k \Delta_g s - \tfrac{k(n-2)}{2} |ds|_g^2
+ + k K(\nabla s, v)
+$$
+for every $g$-unit ball vector $v$; the future expansion transforms as
+$$
+e^s \theta_{+,s} = \theta_+ + k \partial_\nu s,
+$$
+with $\nu$ the inward normal. The scalar curvature transforms as
+$R_{g_s} = e^{-2s}(R_g - 2k \Delta_g s - k(n-2) |ds|_g^2)$.
+Substituting $s = 2 (n-2)^{-1} \log U$ for a smooth positive $U$
+combines the two scalar terms into a single Laplace-type expression.
+
+The next step fixes the model end with which the original data will
+be joined.
+
+Lemma (charges of a boosted Schwarzschild-Tangherlini end). In the
+Schwarzschild-Tangherlini spacetime of geometric mass $M > 0$, let
+$b, y$ be static time and isotropic spatial coordinates. Perform the
+Lorentz change
+$$
+b = \gamma (T + v y^1), \quad
+y^1 = \gamma (y^1 + v T) \text{ written } \gamma (x^1 + v T),
+\quad
+y^a = x^a \ (2 \le a \le n),
+$$
+with $0 \le v < 1$ and $\gamma = (1-v^2)^{-1/2}$. The induced data on
+$T = 0$, oriented by the future normal, have ADM vector
+$$
+E = \gamma M, \quad P_1 = \gamma M v, \quad P_a = 0 \ (a > 1).
+$$
+The metric and second fundamental form have the leading terms
+computed below, with remainders $O_d(r^{-2(n-2)})$ and
+$O_d(r^{-2(n-2)-1})$ for every fixed derivative order $d$.
+
+Proof. The exact isotropic Schwarzschild-Tangherlini metric is
+$$
+\mathbf g = - F^2 db^2 + G^2 |dy|^2,
+\quad
+F = \frac{1 - M / (2|y|^{n-2})}{1 + M / (2|y|^{n-2})},
+\quad
+G = (1 + M / (2|y|^{n-2}))^{2/(n-2)}.
+$$
+Its leading perturbation of Minkowski space is
+$2 M |y|^{-(n-2)} (db^2 + (n-2)^{-1} |dy|^2)$. On $T = 0$ set
+$\rho^2 = \gamma^2 (x^1)^2 + \sum_{a \ge 2} (x^a)^2$ and
+$f = \rho^{-(n-2)}$. The nonzero leading components of the
+perturbation $\mathbf H$ are
+$\mathbf H_{11} = 2 M A f$, $\mathbf H_{aa} = 2 M B f$,
+$\mathbf H_{01} = 2 M C f$ with
+$A = \gamma^2 (v^2 + (n-2)^{-1})$, $B = (n-2)^{-1}$,
+$C = (n-1)(n-2)^{-1} \gamma^2 v$. The energy-flux vector
+$Q_i = \partial_j \mathbf H_{ij} - \partial_i \mathbf H_{jj}$ obeys
+$Q_i = 2 M (n-1) \gamma^2 x_i \rho^{-n}$. The second fundamental form
+on $T = 0$ has the components
+$$
+K_{11} = M \gamma^4 v (2(n-2)+1-(n-2) v^2) x^1 \rho^{-n}, \quad
+K_{aa} = - M \gamma^2 v x^1 \rho^{-n},
+$$
+$$
+K_{1a} = M (n-1) \gamma^2 v x^a \rho^{-n}, \quad
+K_{ab} = 0 \ (a \ne b).
+$$
+Euclidean trace reversal gives
+$$
+\pi_{1j} = M (n-1) \gamma^2 v x_j \rho^{-n}, \quad
+\pi_{a1} = M (n-1) \gamma^2 v x^a \rho^{-n},
+$$
+$$
+\pi_{ab} = - M (n-1) \gamma^4 v x^1 \rho^{-n} \delta_{ab}.
+$$
+The ellipsoid
+$\{|\operatorname{diag}(\gamma, 1, \dots, 1) \theta| < 1\}$ has
+$(n-1)$-volume $\omega_{n-1} / (n\gamma)$. Polar integration therefore
+gives
+$\int_{\mathbb S^{n-1}} |\operatorname{diag}(\gamma, 1, \dots, 1) \theta|^{-n} d\theta = \omega_{n-1} / \gamma$.
+Substitution into the ADM formulas gives $E = M \gamma$ and
+$P_1 = M \gamma v$; transverse rows integrate to zero by reflection.
+The remainders are computed from the next orders in the isotropic
+expansion. This proves the lemma.
+
+Fix $M = m$, $v = |P| / E$, and rotate the first axis into the
+direction of $P$ (or leave the boost parameter $v=0$ when $P=0$).
+The lemma then supplies a model end
+$(g^{(b)}, K^{(b)})$ with $E^{(b)} = E$ and $P^{(b)} = P$.
+
+The compact-inverse step replaces the off-annulus linear-constraint
+error with a compactly supported correction. On Euclidean tensors
+define
+$$
+\mathsf S(h) = \partial_i \partial_j (h_{ij} - (tr_\delta h) \delta_{ij}),
+\qquad
+\mathsf D(b)_i = \partial_j (b_{ij} - (tr_\delta b) \delta_{ij}).
+$$
+Their formal adjoint kernels on compactly supported tensor fields are,
+respectively, affine scalar functions and Euclidean Killing fields.
+
+Lemma (compact right inverses). Let $\mathcal A \subset \mathbb R^n$ be
+a bounded connected Euclidean annulus and fix a compact subset $Q$ of
+its interior. Smooth scalar sources $f$ supported in $Q$ with
+$\int f = 0$ and $\int x^i f = 0$ admit smooth symmetric $h$ with
+$\mathsf S(h) = f$ and support in a fixed larger compact subset of
+$\mathcal A$, and with
+$\|h\|_{W^{d+2, a}} \le C_{d,a} \|f\|_{W^{d,a}}$ for every $d \ge 0$,
+$1 < a < \infty$. Smooth vector sources $F$ supported in $Q$ with
+$\int F \cdot Y = 0$ for every Euclidean Killing field $Y$ admit
+smooth symmetric $b$ with $\mathsf D(b) = F$ and support in a fixed
+larger compact subset of $\mathcal A$, and
+$\|b\|_{W^{d+1,a}} \le C_{d,a}\|F\|_{W^{d,a}}$. For arbitrary sources,
+the same conclusions hold after subtracting fixed smooth moment bumps
+whose coefficients are bounded by the respective absolute moments.
+
+Proof. On a ball, choose a unit-integral smooth $\eta$ supported in a
+smaller concentric ball, and set
+$$
+(\mathcal B f)(x)
+= \int f(y) (x-y) \int_1^\infty \eta(y + t (x-y)) t^{n-1} dt\, dy.
+$$
+Distributional differentiation gives
+$\operatorname{div} \mathcal B f = f - \eta \int f = f$ when $\int f = 0$.
+For compactly supported $f$ the union of segments occurring in the
+integral is contained in a fixed compact set, and the kernel is a
+Calderon-Zygmund kernel of order $1-n$ with the usual cancellation,
+so the $W^{d,a} \to W^{d+1,a}$ mapping estimate holds. Cover the
+prescribed support by finitely many balls compact in $\mathcal A$,
+connect them along a finite overlapping chain, and use a partition of
+unity with means transferred along the chain by unit-integral bumps in
+the overlaps.
+
+Apply this compact primitive twice: to a scalar source $f$ with all
+affine moments zero, obtaining $\partial_i v_i = f$; compact support of
+$v$ gives $\int v_i = -\int z_i f = 0$, so each $v_i$ admits a further
+compact primitive $T_{ij}$. Then $Q = (T + T^{\mathsf t})/2$ satisfies
+$\partial_i \partial_j Q_{ij} = f$, and
+$h = Q - (tr_\delta Q) \delta / (n-1)$ has trace reversal $Q$, so
+$\mathsf S(h) = f$.
+
+For a vector source $F$, first solve $\partial_j B_{ij} = F_i$
+row-by-row. Then rotation-moment orthogonality gives
+$\int (B_{ij} - B_{ji}) = 0$; setting
+$A_{ij} = (B_{ij} - B_{ji})/2$ and solving
+$\partial_l D_{ijl} = -A_{ij}$ with $D_{ijl} = -D_{jil}$ allows
+defining
+$E_{ij} = \partial_l (D_{ijl} - D_{ilj} - D_{jli})$
+and $C_{ij} = B_{ij} + E_{ij}$; index interchange verifies that $C$ is
+symmetric and $\partial_j C_{ij} = F_i$. Finally
+$b = C - (tr_\delta C) \delta / (n-1)$ proves the assertion with the
+stated derivative counts.
+
+For moment bumps: a nonnegative smooth bump $\omega$ on a compact
+ball inside $\mathcal A$ has positive-definite Gram matrix
+$(\int \omega p_a p_b)$ of the affine functions restricted to the
+support, and positive-definite Gram matrix
+$(\int \omega Y_a \cdot Y_b)$ of the Euclidean Killing fields.
+Multiplying the basis elements by $\omega$ and the appropriate
+inverse Gram matrix produces fixed dual moment bumps, whose
+subtraction removes the affine or Killing moments with the stated
+bounds. This proves the lemma.
+
+Two further inputs remain: a control of the moments that cannot be
+removed this way, and the actual cutoff argument. For the first, on
+the far end put $h = g - \delta$, $\pi = K - (tr_\delta K) \delta$,
+and expand about $(\delta, 0)$:
+$$
+\mathsf S(h) = 2\mu + O(r^{-2q-2}),
+\qquad
+\mathsf D(K) = J + O(r^{-2q-2}).
+$$
+The remainders come from $h D^2 h$, $(D h)^2$, $K^2$, and $h D K$,
+$D h\, K$ respectively, using exactly the derivatives available in the
+decay hypothesis, and $2q + 2 > n$ makes them integrable.
+
+Lemma (sublinear first moments). Let $h$, $h^{(b)}$, $b = K$,
+$b^{(b)} = K^{(b)}$ be the fields defined above, put
+$H = h - h^{(b)}$, $B = K - K^{(b)}$, and let $\chi_L(x) = \chi(x/L)$
+be a smooth cutoff equal to one near the inner sphere of the annulus
+$\mathcal A_L = \{L < |x| < 4 L\}$ and zero near the outer sphere. Then
+the rescaled commutators
+$$
+\widehat C_L(z) = L^2 \bigl(\mathsf S(\chi_L H) - \chi_L \mathsf S(H)\bigr)\big|_{x = Lz},
+\quad
+\widehat F_L(z) = L^2 \bigl(\mathsf D(\chi_L B) - \chi_L \mathsf D(B)\bigr)\big|_{x = Lz}
+$$
+obey, for every fixed affine scalar $a$ and every fixed Euclidean
+Killing field $Y$,
+$$
+\int_{\mathcal A} a\, \widehat C_L \, dz = o(L^{2-n}),
+\qquad
+\int_{\mathcal A} Y^i \widehat F_{L,i} \, dz = o(L^{2-n}).
+$$
+
+Proof. Integrability of $\mu, J$ on the end and the remainder orders
+give $\mathsf S(H), \mathsf D(B) \in L^1$ on the end. The elementary
+sublinear-first-moment estimate: for any integrable $f$ on the end,
+$\int_{R_0 < r < 4L} r |f| dx = o(L)$, obtained by splitting the
+integral at a fixed $R_1$ and letting $L \to \infty$ with $R_1$
+afterwards. Define the Green flux pairings
+$$
+\mathcal B_a(R) = \int_{S_R} \bigl(a \partial_j Q_{ij} \nu^i_\delta
+- (\partial_i a) Q_{ij} \nu^j_\delta\bigr) dA_\delta,
+\quad
+Q = H - (tr_\delta H) \delta,
+$$
+and
+$$
+\mathfrak G_Y(R) = \int_{S_R} Y_i Q'_{ij} \nu^j_\delta \, dA_\delta,
+\quad
+Q' = (K - K^{(b)}) - (tr_\delta(K - K^{(b)})) \delta.
+$$
+Integration by parts between spheres gives
+$\mathcal B_a(R) - \mathcal B_a(R_0) = \int_{R_0 < r < R} a \mathsf S(H)$
+and $\mathfrak G_Y(R) - \mathfrak G_Y(R_0) = \int_{R_0 < r < R} Y^i \mathsf D(K)_i$.
+For $a = 1$ the flux difference vanishes since the ADM energies agree;
+for $a = x^i$ the sublinear-first-moment estimate gives
+$\mathcal B_{x^i}(R) = o(R)$. For $Y = e_i$ the momentum agreement
+gives $\mathfrak G_{e_i}(R) \to 0$; replacing geometric by Euclidean
+trace reversal costs $O(R^{n-2-2q})$, which vanishes; for
+$Y$ = rotational Killing field the same sublinear estimate gives
+$\mathfrak G_Y(R) = o(R)$.
+
+Under $x = Lz$, the fields $h$ and $K$ rescale to $h(Lz)$ and
+$LK(Lz)$; both flat sources have scale factor $L^2$. A constant
+moment already integrated over $\mathcal A_L$ therefore carries an
+$L^{2-n}$ weight, and a linear moment carries an additional
+$L^{-1}$. The preceding $o(1)$ and $o(R)$ bounds then read
+$o(L^{2-n})$ for the rescaled affine and Killing moments. This proves
+the lemma.
+
+Now perform the actual joining. On the fixed annulus
+$\mathcal A_L = \{L < |x| < 4 L\}$, interpolate between the original
+and model fields with a smooth cutoff $\chi_L$ that is one near the
+inner sphere and zero near the outer sphere. The interpolated
+constraint densities differ from the cutoff interpolation of the
+exact constraint densities by the commutators
+$C_L = \mathsf S(\chi_L H) - \chi_L \mathsf S(H)$ and
+$F_L = \mathsf D(\chi_L B) - \chi_L \mathsf D(B)$, supported in a
+fixed compact subannulus. By the compact right-inverse lemma, after
+removing moment bumps, one can subtract compactly supported corrections
+cancelling $C_L$ and $F_L$; the corrections have size
+$O(L^{-q})$ in $C^{2,\alpha}$ and $C^{1,\alpha}$ for any
+$0 < \alpha < 1 - n/a$. The moment bumps contribute $o(L^{2-n})$
+in physical units by the sublinear-moment lemma, so the resulting
+data $(\widetilde g_L, \widetilde K_L)$ agree with the original for
+$r \le L$ and with the model for $r \ge 4 L$, and satisfy
+$$
+\widetilde \mu_L - |\widetilde J_L|_{\widetilde g_L}
+\ge -d_L L^{-n} \mathbf 1_{\{L < r < 4L\}}, \quad d_L \to 0.
+$$
+The verification of the unit-ball estimates uses only that the
+interpolated metric, the original metric, and the Euclidean metric
+differ by $O(L^{-q})$ on the annulus and that the cutoff is a convex
+combination, so transporting a unit vector between the three balls
+changes the pairing with the interpolated $J$ by $O(L^{-2q})$.