diff 04a7cc6..da5d234 logarithmic_brunn_minkowski_v2.txt
diff --git a/logarithmic_brunn_minkowski_v2.txt b/logarithmic_brunn_minkowski_v2.txt
index 52b8e38..f55b8a7 100644
--- a/logarithmic_brunn_minkowski_v2.txt
+++ b/logarithmic_brunn_minkowski_v2.txt
@@ -22,7 +22,9 @@ The reader we have in mind can follow a proof line by line. If you
know what a convex set is, what volume is, and what a derivative is,
you can read this. Formulas use plain ASCII: R^n is n-dimensional
space, <x,u> is a dot product, |K| is the volume of K, and "subset"
-is C. A superscript like h^t means a power.
+is C. A superscript like h^t means a power. A notation table sits at
+the end of Part 1; skim it once and come back whenever a symbol
+surprises you.
A note on honesty. The deep analytic inputs (solving a real
Monge-Ampere equation, elliptic regularity) are genuinely deep. We
@@ -83,14 +85,16 @@ The logarithmic Brunn-Minkowski conjecture, proved here, is:
| W[ h_K^{1-t} h_L^t ] | >= |K|^{1-t} |L|^t . (BM)
-Because the geometric mean is pointwise at most the arithmetic mean,
-the Wulff body sits inside the Minkowski average:
+The Minkowski average has support function (1-t)h_K + t h_L, and the
+geometric mean is pointwise at most the arithmetic mean. The Wulff
+construction is monotone in its bound and satisfies W[h_M] = M, so
- W[ h_K^{1-t} h_L^t ] C (1-t)K + tL .
+ W[ h_K^{1-t} h_L^t ] C W[ (1-t)h_K + t h_L ] = (1-t)K + tL .
-So (BM) asks for the same lower bound on volume but for a smaller
-body. It is strictly stronger than classical Brunn-Minkowski. That is
-why it was a conjecture, and why it is hard.
+So (BM) asks for the same lower bound on volume, but for a body that
+may be strictly smaller than the Minkowski average. That is why it is
+strictly stronger than classical Brunn-Minkowski, why it was a
+conjecture, and why it is hard.
The difficulty in one sentence: the Wulff body is built from a
geometric average of support data, and volume does not behave simply
@@ -111,7 +115,9 @@ constantly, read off from the half-space definition:
Probability measures. For a probability measure mu on R^n write
E_mu f = integral f dmu and Var_mu(f) = E_mu (f - E_mu f)^2.
-If mu has a density we write dmu = rho(x) dx.
+If mu has a density rho we write dmu = rho(x) dx: the mu-mass of a
+tiny box of volume dx around the point x is rho(x) dx. A density is
+just a way of spreading one unit of total mass over space.
Log-concave measure. A nonnegative measure mu is log-concave if
@@ -125,6 +131,28 @@ The objects we work with: a probability measure on the whole space
with a smooth, strictly positive, even density
dmu = Z^{-1} e^{-V(x)} dx, where V is even and strictly convex.
+NOTATION, ALL IN ONE PLACE. Come back here when a symbol surprises
+you; the labels in parentheses say where it first does real work.
+
+ R^n n-dimensional space; <x,u> is a dot product, |x| a length
+ S^{n-1} the unit sphere: all u with |u| = 1
+ K, L origin-symmetric convex bodies; |K| is the volume of K
+ h_K(u) support function: how far K reaches in direction u
+ W[f] Wulff body of a positive function f on the sphere
+ mu, nu probability measures, mu on x-space and nu on z-space
+ V, phi their potentials: dmu = Z^{-1}e^{-V}dx, dnu = e^{-phi}dz
+ x=grad phi the moment map carrying nu onto mu (Part 5)
+ tau=D^2 phi, M=tau^{-1} curvature of phi and its inverse (Part 5)
+ H=D^2 V, H_i=D^2 psi_i Hessians; psi_i=(<p_i,x>/h_i)^q (Part 4)
+ A f x.grad f - tau:D^2 f, the operator of Part 6 (Part 6)
+ Gamma(f,h) grad f . tau grad h, the "energy density" (Part 7)
+ B, W, u B = tau(D^2 f)tau, W = delta_mu B, u = delta_mu W (Part 6)
+
+Two notational habits. Letters in brackets like (VAR) or (hess) name a
+displayed formula so it can be quoted later. A statement "for compact
+smooth f" always means f is smooth and vanishes outside some bounded
+set, so every integration by parts below is legitimate.
+
Moment coordinates. The analytic engine. Given such a mu, we look for
a change of variable x = grad phi(z), where phi is convex and
nu(z) = e^{-phi(z)} dz is a probability measure pushed forward to mu
@@ -304,9 +332,9 @@ dual form is
for every centered even u in L^2(mu). (VAR')
The denominators are positive because p_i != 0 and mu has a positive
-density. (VAR') implies (VAR): apply it to
-u = sum_i b_i psi_i, subtract the mean (this does not change
-variances because of the centering step in the Cauchy-Schwarz below).
+density. (VAR') implies (VAR): apply it to u = sum_i b_i psi_i minus
+its mean, which is centered and even, and then finish as at the end
+of Part 9, with the Cauchy-Schwarz step for the pairing u |-> E u psi_i.
Why (VAR) gives volume. Suppose the p_i span R^n and the widths are
positive. For t in [0,1] set
@@ -395,9 +423,15 @@ is an even phi in C^infinity(R^n) such that
phi(z) >= c|z| - b for some c > 0, b < infinity.
(The lower bound D^2 phi > 0 is pointwise positivity, not a uniform
-lower bound.) Write x = grad phi(z). The last-but-one line is the
-pushforward equation: the change of variables x = grad phi turns
-e^{-phi(z)} dz into e^{-V(x)} dx / Z.
+lower bound.) Write x = grad phi(z). Two of the displayed lines say
+the same thing. The third,
+(grad phi)_# nu = mu, is the pushforward statement: the measure nu is
+carried onto mu by the map grad phi. The fifth,
+
+ log det D^2 phi = V(grad phi) + log Z - phi ,
+
+is that statement written as a change of variables: substituting
+x = grad phi(z) turns e^{-phi(z)} dz into e^{-V(x)} dx / Z.
Idea of the proof (the full argument, with the imported tools named).
@@ -725,9 +759,21 @@ So, apart from the nonnegative R term, the integrand
2||S||^2 + 4<S,J> + ||J||^2 + <J, J^{(12)}> .
-Now symmetrize J: (Sym J)_{ijk} = (J_{ijk} + J_{jik} + J_{kij})/3.
-Its norm satisfies ||Sym J||^2 = (||J||^2 + 2<J,J^{(12)}>)/3 and
-<S, Sym J> = <S,J>. Therefore the displayed integrand equals
+Now fully symmetrize J: average over all six ways of ordering the
+three indices,
+
+ (Sym J)_{ijk} = (J_{ijk} + J_{ikj} + J_{jik}
+ + J_{jki} + J_{kij} + J_{kji}) / 6 .
+
+Because J is symmetric in its last two indices, this average obeys
+
+ <S, Sym J> = <S,J> (S is fully symmetric) ,
+ ||Sym J||^2 = (||J||^2 + 2<J,J^{(12)}>)/3 ,
+
+and both are checked by writing out the six terms. (The three-term
+cyclic average (J_{ijk}+J_{jik}+J_{kij})/3 does NOT satisfy the second
+line; use the six-term average.) Therefore the displayed integrand
+equals
2 || S + Sym J ||^2 + (1/6) || J - J^{(12)} ||^2 >= 0 . (squares)
@@ -926,120 +972,57 @@ REFERENCES
============================================================
The proof above follows the structure of the original manuscript and
-its sources. Listed roughly by order of use.
+its sources. What follows is the part of the original bibliography
+that the proof and the appendix actually use.
K. J. Boroczky, E. Lutwak, D. Yang, G. Zhang, "The log-Brunn-Minkowski
-inequality", Advances in Mathematics 231 (2012), 1974-1997. (Statement
-of the conjecture; planar case.)
+inequality", Adv. Math. 231 (2012), 1974-1997. (The conjecture.)
C. Saroglou, "Remarks on the conjectured log-Brunn-Minkowski
-inequality", Geometriae Dedicata 177 (2015). (Unconditional bodies.)
+inequality", Geom. Dedicata 177 (2015), 353-365. (Unconditional
+bodies.)
C. Saroglou, "More on logarithmic sums of convex bodies", Mathematika
-62 (2016). (The transfer theorem from volume to even log-concave
+62 (2016), 818-841. (Transfer from volume to even log-concave
measures; the (B)-corollary.)
-C. Borell, "Convex measures on locally convex spaces", Arkiv for
-Matematik 12 (1974), 239-252. (Characterization of log-concave
-measures.)
+C. Borell, "Convex measures on locally convex spaces", Ark. Mat. 12
+(1974), 239-252. (Log-concave measures are affine images of densities.)
R. J. Berman, B. Berndtsson, "Real Monge-Ampere equations and
-Kahler-Ricci solitons on toric log Fano varieties", Annales de la
-Faculte des Sciences de Toulouse 22 (2013). (Real Monge-Ampere moment
-theorem.)
+Kahler-Ricci solitons on toric log Fano varieties", Ann. Fac. Sci.
+Toulouse 22 (2013), 649-711. (Moment theorem; appendix A1.)
-D. Cordero-Erausquin, B. Klartag, "Moment measures", Journal of
-Functional Analysis 268 (2015), 3834-3866. (Moment measures.)
+D. Cordero-Erausquin, B. Klartag, "Moment measures", J. Funct. Anal.
+268 (2015), 3834-3866. (Moment measures.)
B. Klartag, "Logarithmically-concave moment measures I", arXiv
-1309.2767 (2013). (The Hessian estimate 4/eps.)
+1309.2767 (2013). (The 4/eps Hessian bound; appendix A2.)
-M. Fathi, "Stein kernels and moment maps", Annals of Probability 47
-(2019). (The operator A as a moment-map Stein kernel.)
+M. Fathi, "Stein kernels and moment maps", Ann. Probab. 47 (2019),
+2172-2185. (The operator A as a moment-map Stein kernel.)
A. Kolesnikov, G. Livshyts, L. Rotem, "On p-Brunn-Minkowski and
Brascamp-Lieb inequalities", arXiv 2507.12099 (2026). (Transport-
-Hessian Bochner formulas underlying (hess) and the tensor estimate.)
+Hessian Bochner formulas.)
X. Fernandez-Real, X. Ros-Oton, "Regularity Theory for Elliptic PDE",
-arXiv 2301.01564 (2023). (Evans-Krylov and Schauder estimates in the
-form used.)
+arXiv 2301.01564 (2023). (Evans-Krylov and Schauder; appendix A5.)
Y. Wang, "On the C^{2,alpha}-regularity of the complex Monge-Ampere
-equation", Math. Res. Lett. 19 (2012). (Nonhomogeneous Evans-Krylov.)
+equation", Math. Res. Lett. 19 (2012), 939-946. (Nonhomogeneous
+Evans-Krylov.)
S. Dyatlov, "18.155 lecture notes: distributions, elliptic regularity",
-2026. (Interior elliptic regularity as invoked in Part 7.)
-
-W. J. Firey, "p-Means of convex bodies", Math. Scand. 10 (1962).
-(Origin of the L_p interpolation.)
-
-E. Lutwak, "The Brunn-Minkowski-Firey theory I", J. Differential Geom.
-38 (1993). (L_p mixed volumes.)
-
-K. J. Boroczky, E. Lutwak, D. Yang, G. Zhang, "The logarithmic
-Minkowski problem", J. Amer. Math. Soc. 26 (2013). (Cone-volume
-measures; context.)
-
-D. Cordero-Erausquin, M. Fradelizi, B. Maurey, "The (B)-conjecture for
-the Gaussian measure of dilates of symmetric convex sets", J. Funct.
-Anal. 214 (2004). (Predecessors of the (B)-statement.)
-
-A. Colesanti, G. Livshyts, A. Marsiglietti, "On the stability of
-Brunn-Minkowski type inequalities", J. Funct. Anal. 273 (2017).
-(Local second-variation formulation.)
-
-A. Kolesnikov, E. Milman, "Local L^p-Brunn-Minkowski inequalities for
-p<1", Memoirs AMS 277 (2022). (Spectral formulation of the local
-problem.)
-
-S. Chen, Y. Huang, Q.-R. Li, J. Liu, "The L_p-Brunn-Minkowski
-inequality for p<1", Advances in Mathematics 368 (2020). (Global L_p
-for p close to 1.)
-
-E. Putterman, "Equivalence of the local and global versions of the
-L^p-Brunn-Minkowski inequality", J. Funct. Anal. 280 (2021).
-
-R. van Handel, "The local logarithmic Brunn-Minkowski inequality for
-zonoids", GAFA Seminar Notes 2327 (2023).
-
-E. Milman, "Centro-affine differential geometry and the log-Minkowski
-problem", J. Eur. Math. Soc. 27 (2025). (Isomorphic log-Minkowski;
-centro-affine operator.)
-
-L. Rotem, "A letter: the log-Brunn-Minkowski inequality for complex
-bodies", arXiv 1412.5321 (2014).
-
-X. Lu, "Logarithmic Brunn-Minkowski under n-2 reflection symmetries",
-arXiv 2608.20730 (2026).
-
-L. Iffland, "The local logarithmic Brunn-Minkowski inequality for
-bodies of revolution", arXiv 2602.17912 (2026).
-
-D. Xi, "A very short unified proof of Dar's conjecture and
-log-Brunn-Minkowski in the plane", arXiv 2609.08495 (2026).
-
-A. Stancu, "A PDE approach to geometric inequalities", Oberwolfach
-Reports 15 (2018). (Announced the all-dimensional inequality.)
+2026. (Interior elliptic regularity; appendix A5.)
H. J. Brascamp, E. H. Lieb, "On extensions of the Brunn-Minkowski and
-Prekopa-Leindler theorems", J. Funct. Anal. 22 (1976). (Variance
-inequalities for log-concave measures.)
+Prekopa-Leindler theorems", J. Funct. Anal. 22 (1976), 366-389.
+(Variance inequalities for log-concave measures.)
D. Bakry, M. Emery, "Diffusions hypercontractives", Seminaire de
-Probabilites XIX (1985). (Bochner/curvature method.)
+Probabilites XIX (1985), 177-206. (Bochner/curvature method.)
============================================================
END.
============================================================
-
-This document proves the even logarithmic Brunn-Minkowski conjecture
-in every dimension, together with the symmetric L_p inequality and the
-(B)-conjecture for even log-concave measures. The proof is the three
-steps of Part 3: reduce volume to a variance inequality (Part 4),
-build moment coordinates (Part 5), and prove the variance inequality
-through the operator A (Parts 6-9). Every display is either elementary
-or a named imported tool from the appendix. The single idea to carry
-away is this: in the right coordinates the relevant diffusion has
-nonnegative Hessian energy as an explicit sum of squares, and that is
-exactly the curvature needed for log-concavity of volume.