diff 14496b4..e921a40 chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
diff --git a/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt b/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
index 08452dd..131dabe 100644
--- a/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
+++ b/chromatic_splitting_sphere_kernels_v2.txt
@@ -1,108 +1,61 @@
-CHROMATIC SPLITTING AND SPHERE KERNELS
-A reader's guide to the paper:
-"Counterexamples to weak chromatic splitting: sphere kernels and descent
- exponents"
-
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-HOW TO READ THIS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
-This is a research paper in algebraic topology. The paper proves that a
-particular guess about how a certain object (the "p-completed sphere
-spectrum") decomposes into coloured layers is FALSE at every prime
-p >= 5 (at height p) and at every prime p >= 7 (at height p+1). It also
-gives a second, independent proof of the failure at height p using a
-different tool: descent exponents.
-
-The original is 13 LaTeX sections plus an appendix. Its proofs are
-complete but written in compressed graduate notation. This version
-keeps the same mathematical content. Every named theorem, lemma, and
-proposition of the original appears here, stated plainly, with its
-full proof in plain prose. Nothing is left as "sketch" or "idea" or
-"the reader can check"; where a step needs a computation (a cochain
-homotopy, a filtration degree count, an inverse-limit argument), the
-computation is written out.
-
-You are expected to know what a group, a ring, a homomorphism, and a
-field are. Everything else (spheres, spectra, chromatic layers,
-localization, formal groups) is introduced as we go. The later sections
-use undergraduate-accessible algebra, some compact-group theory, and
-Morava E-theory. Those last items are genuinely graduate-level. Every
-time one appears, we say plainly what job it does and why the proof
-needs it. If you follow the storyline, you have understood the paper.
-
-The one sentence the whole paper is about:
-
- The p-completed sphere's canonical "height-(p-1) = lower-bounded
- overlap with height p" map has NO homotopy retraction, for every
- prime p >= 5. The same failure happens at height p+1 for every
- prime p >= 7. The evidence is a specific sphere class
- z_p = (beta_1)^{(p-1)^2} whose image at the lower height survives
- but whose image at the upper height is ZERO.
-
-Every chunk of the proof is a step toward making that sentence a
-theorem.
-
-There is a glossary at the end. Read the paper once for the story, then
-use the glossary for words.
-
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART A. BACKGROUND: WHAT ARE ALL THESE OBJECTS?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
-A.1 The sphere spectrum and stable homotopy
-
-Ordinary spheres are S^0 (two points), S^1 (a circle), S^2 (an ordinary
-sphere), S^3, and so on. For two spheres S^m and S^n, we can ask: how
-many genuinely different continuous maps are there from S^m to S^n, up
-to the relation of continuous deformation (homotopy)? We write
-
- pi_m(S^n) = set of homotopy classes of maps S^m -> S^n.
-
-Examples: pi_n(S^n) = Z (the degree of a map); pi_3(S^2) = Z (Hopf);
-pi_6(S^3) = Z/12; and so on.
-
-There is a natural operation called suspension: from a map S^m -> S^n,
-build a new map S^{m+1} -> S^{n+1} by joining a pole. This gives
-compatible maps
-
- pi_m(S^n) -> pi_{m+1}(S^{n+1})
-
-which pass to a stable system: for fixed k = n - m, the groups pi_{m}(S^n)
-for varying m and n eventually agree. Their common value is
-pi_k(S), the k-th STABLE HOMOTOPY GROUP OF SPHERES.
-
-The hidden object that produces these groups is the sphere spectrum S.
-You do not need to construct S explicitly. It suffices to know that S has
-homotopy groups pi_k(S), it has a commutative ring structure (smash
-product), and it is the "unit" of a symmetric monoidal category of
-spectra.
-
-The p-completed sphere S_p^ is defined as:
-
- S_p^ = holim_{j >= 1} S / p^j.
-
-Here S / p^j is the cofiber of multiplication by p^j on S. The map
-p: S -> S is null up to finite stages, so the limit succeeds. All
-finiteness in the paper happens inside S_p^; nothing depends on
-intermediate p-torsion.
-
-Two operations on spectra will be used throughout:
-
- smash X ^ Y - takes products at the level of spectra
- function spectrum F(X,Y) - takes "maps from X to Y" as a spectrum
-
-Inside spectra these behave like tensor product and internal hom.
-Homotopy groups of the smash product involve a Tor-type tower, not just
-the naive product of homotopy groups; this is where differentials and
-multiplicative structure live.
-
-A NOTE ON CONVENTION: unless a localized tensor is explicitly written,
-every smash product and function spectrum in this document is ordinary
-(unlocalized). All homotopy groups are those of the underlying ordinary
-spectra.
-
-A.2 Chromatic filtration: seeing the sphere layer by layer
+Let p be a prime and work in p-local spectra with sphere spectrum
+S = S^0_{(p)}. Ordinary spheres are S^0 (two points), S^1 (a circle),
+S^2, S^3, and so on. Homotopy classes of maps S^m -> S^n are written
+pi_m(S^n). Examples: pi_n(S^n) = Z (the degree of a map); pi_3(S^2) = Z
+(the Hopf map); pi_6(S^3) = Z/12. Suspension carries a map S^m -> S^n to
+S^{m+1} -> S^{n+1}; for fixed k = n - m, the groups pi_m(S^n)
+eventually stabilise as m, n increase. Their common limit is pi_k S, the
+k-th stable homotopy group of spheres. These groups assemble into a
+single object, the sphere spectrum S: a commutative ring spectrum under
+smash, the unit of the symmetric monoidal category of spectra.
+
+The p-completed sphere is S_p^ = holim_{j >= 1} S/p^j, where S/p^j is
+the cofiber of multiplication by p^j on S. Every construction below
+lives inside S_p^; no claim depends on intermediate p-torsion.
+
+Fix a height a. Morava K-theory K(a) is a field spectrum, with
+K(0) = H Q. Bousfield localization L_{K(a)} is chromatic localization
+at height a. Write L_r for localization with respect to
+K(0) v K(1) v ... v K(r), the Johnson-Wilson localization keeping
+heights at most r. Write B_a = L_{K(a)} S for the height-a localized
+sphere.
+
+Two operations on spectra recur throughout:
+
+ smash X ^ Y -- tensor product of spectra
+ function spectrum F(X,Y) -- internal hom, maps from X to Y
+
+These behave like tensor product and internal hom. Homotopy of a smash
+product is computed by a Tor-type spectral sequence, not a naive
+product; multiplicative structure enters through that spectral
+sequence. Unless a localized tensor is explicitly written, everything
+is ordinary (unlocalized). Homotopy groups are those of the underlying
+ordinary spectra.
+
+For a spectrum Z, write eta_Z^{(n)}: Z -> L_{K(n)}Z for the height-n
+localization unit. The overlap map is
+
+ i_{n,X} = L_{n-1}( eta_X^{(n)} ):
+ L_{n-1} X -> L_{n-1} L_{K(n)} X.
+
+A homotopy retraction is a map of spectra r with r i_{n,X} = id up to
+homotopy; it need not be natural in X.
+
+For an odd prime p, define
+
+ d_p = 2p(p-1) - 2, k_p = (p-1)^2, z_p = beta_1^{k_p},
+
+where beta_1 in pi_{d_p} S is the classical first beta element. At
+p = 5 this is beta_1^{16} in degree 608; at p = 7 it is beta_1^{36} in
+degree 2952.
+
+At every prime p >= 5, the image of z_p in pi_{d_p k_p} L_{p-1} X is
+nonzero and is killed by i_{p,X}; hence i_{p,X} has no homotopy
+retraction. At every prime p >= 7, the same image in pi_{d_p k_p} L_p X
+is nonzero and is killed by i_{p+1,X}; hence i_{p+1,X} has no homotopy
+retraction. A third argument, independent of both, proves the first
+nonretraction by comparing descent exponents of a finite subgroup
+H = C_p >| C_{(p-1)^2} of the height-(p-1) pure stabilizer.
The sphere spectrum S is a "complicated" object: its homotopy groups
are infinite-dimensional, containing integer classes (from the identity
@@ -147,8 +100,6 @@ the uniqueness of Morava E-theory, make this reconstruction rigorous
for the localized sphere at each height and work coherently across
heights. The paper uses exactly this infrastructure.
-A.3 Morava K-theory and Morava E-theory
-
The height-a objects the paper needs are defined as follows.
Let p be a fixed prime. Let k_a = F_{p^a}. Let W(k_a) be the Witt vectors
@@ -200,8 +151,6 @@ action on K(a). The exact coherence is Goerss-Hopkins' 2004 theorem
(gh2004 section 7). The paper uses this coherence whenever it wants to
compare E_a and K(a).
-A.4 What a "localization unit" means
-
For a spectrum X and a height-a theory (either K(a) or E_a), the
K(a)-LOCALIZATION UNIT is a natural map
@@ -221,8 +170,6 @@ converges strongly.
The pair (i_{n,X}, kernel) that the paper studies is built from these
units by stacking one more localization. Details are in Part A.6.
-A.5 The overlap map i_{n,X}
-
Fix heights n > 0 and a spectrum X. Apply the height-n unit, then
localize down to heights at most n-1:
@@ -256,8 +203,6 @@ exist as a map of spectra. Weak chromatic splitting conjectures exactly
existence of such an r, for every finite X, with the correct convention
on completion. (See A.6.)
-A.6 The chromatic splitting conjecture (Hopkins' original)
-
Hopkins considered the following guess (recorded by Hovey, 1995). Fix a
prime p and height n. Suppose X is a finite spectrum and complete it at
p, obtaining X = X_p^. Then the FULL chromatic overlap object
@@ -307,8 +252,6 @@ Two independent proofs are given:
proof two (Part H): the descent exponents of the two constructions
differ, and weak CSC would force them to agree.
-A.7 Why the sphere is the right test case
-
Choose X = S_p^, the p-completed sphere.
Reasons:
@@ -338,8 +281,6 @@ These correspond to: a certain class lying low enough in the upper
filtration that it must vanish (Part F), and at the next height one
more filtration step is used (Part F again, one height higher).
-A.8 The overall strategy of the paper
-
Two INDEPENDENT proofs of the main theorem are given. You can read
either alone.
@@ -363,12 +304,6 @@ either alone.
The reader can check either proof independently. Both are numbered to
make cross-references easy from the paper.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART B. THE MAIN THEOREMS, STATED
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
-B.1 Notation and constants
-
Throughout the paper, fix a prime p and put:
d_p = 2p(p-1) - 2 (a positive even integer)
@@ -384,8 +319,6 @@ pi_{608}(S). This is the "prime-five class" mentioned in the abstract.
We use S = S_{(p)}^0 for the p-local sphere, X = S_p^ = S_p^0 for its
p-completion, and B_a = L_{K(a)} S for the height-a localized sphere.
-B.2 Theorem 1 (the height-p kernel)
-
THEOREM 1. Let p >= 5 be prime. With the notation above, the image
of z_p in
@@ -410,8 +343,6 @@ Words:
if r i_{p,X} = id and i_{p,X}(z_p) = 0, then z_p = r(0) = 0,
contradiction.
-B.3 Theorem 2 (the same kernel at height p+1)
-
THEOREM 2. Let p >= 7 be prime. The image of the SAME class z_p
in
@@ -428,8 +359,6 @@ At p = 7 this is beta_1^{36} in degree 82*36 = 2952. Same class, one
height up. The clean statement is: one sphere power produces kernels at
two different heights, at two overlapping prime ranges.
-B.4 Corollary 1 (the p = 5 case, simplest example)
-
COROLLARY. At p = 5, the image of beta_1^{16} in pi_608 L_4 X is
nonzero and belongs to the kernel of pi_608( i_{5,X} ).
@@ -438,8 +367,6 @@ B.4 Corollary 1 (the p = 5 case, simplest example)
This is Theorem 1 evaluated at p=5. It is the smallest case that can
be stated in ordinary integers without saying "for all p".
-B.5 Theorem 3 (independent descent-exponent obstruction)
-
This is the second, unrelated proof of the same height-p nonretraction.
THEOREM 3. Let p >= 5 be prime. Put t = p-1, let
@@ -469,8 +396,6 @@ symmetric monoidal category of spectra. The paper uses the finite
group H, so all constructions are in the stable world and stay
finite at every stage.
-B.6 How the two proofs use different tools
-
PROOF ONE: sphere classes and multiplicative stability in the
cohomology of the Morava stabilizer.
@@ -481,18 +406,12 @@ applicability of each is slightly different (proof one requires p >= 5
at height p and p >= 7 at height p+1; proof two currently only covers
height p, but with a much wider conjecture in mind).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART C. THE COMPLETION LEMMA AND THE KERNEL CRITERION
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
Two ingredients are combined in every proof of the paper. The first is
a way to pass between working with the finite sphere S and working
with its p-completion X = S_p^. The second is a general principle: a
class detected by a lower theory but killed by an upper one lands in
the kernel of the overlap map.
-C.1 What p-completion does to K(a)-theory
-
Whereas S is a p-local finite spectrum, X = S_p^ is the derived
completion. These two are not equivalent: X has different homotopy
groups in positive and negative degrees (X is connected but not finite).
@@ -536,8 +455,6 @@ K(t)-acyclic spectra are contained in L_r-acyclic spectra). Diagram:
The commutation of the square uses naturality of eta; the dashed arrow
is the composition.
-C.2 The kernel criterion
-
PROPOSITION C.2 (kernel criterion). Let n >= 2, let 1 <= t <= n-1,
and let z in pi_q S be a sphere class. Suppose:
* there exists a map S -> Y with Y a K(t)-local spectrum that
@@ -574,8 +491,6 @@ pi_q L_{n-1}X (the image of z) would satisfy r(i_{n,X}(z-bar)) = r(0) =
0 on the one hand, but r(i_{n,X}(z-bar)) = z-bar (retraction identity)
on the other. Hence z-bar = 0, contradicting that z-bar is nonzero.
-C.3 Remarks on the criterion
-
The kernel criterion is entirely elementary in the sense of not
needing any Morava coherence theory: it is just the naturality of
localization units, plus the completion lemma. Everything hard is
@@ -593,17 +508,11 @@ completion lemma then infers survival in L_{n-1}X. This is why the
paper can work with named sphere classes (beta powers) and not with
their completions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART D. THE LOWER DETECTOR: HOW z_p SURVIVES AT HEIGHT p-1
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
The paper uses z_p = beta_1^{(p-1)^2}. This section shows it survives
a map from S to a height-(p-1)-local spectrum Y. Section F shows the
same power dies at the upper height. Together with Proposition C.2,
this proves Theorems 1 and 2.
-D.1 The Morava E-theory detector
-
Let h = p-1 (so h is one less than the target height the paper is
denying a retraction for). Let E_h be Morava E-theory of height h over
F_{p^h}. Write S_h for the pure stabilizer subgroup of G_h and
@@ -634,8 +543,6 @@ and the E_2 page is:
The decreasing homotopy filtration F^s pi_* Y is therefore separated,
with graded pieces E_infinity.
-D.2 Heard's calculation: beta_1 is up in the E_2 page
-
The Hopkins-Miller calculation gives the POSITIVE-FILTRATION part of
the E_2 page. For the finite group G above, this is:
@@ -666,8 +573,6 @@ a specific class in filtration two whose associated-graded symbol is a
nonzero scalar times beta. The symmetry factor c depends on choices of
cohomology generator but is nonzero for every odd prime.
-D.3 The long power remains nonzero
-
Heard's E_2 calculation continues: in positive even filtration, the
E_infinity page is
@@ -688,8 +593,6 @@ To go from E_infinity to pi_*Y, we need PRODUCTS on the spectral
sequence to agree with the actual multiplication on pi_*Y. That is the
content of section D.4.
-D.4 The ordinary multiplicative structure on the bar tower
-
LEMMA D.4 (ordinary filtered product). Let Q be a finite group
acting coherently on a commutative ring spectrum R. The ordinary
homotopy fixed point spectral sequence
@@ -769,8 +672,6 @@ with the "twisted" middle factor g_1 ... g_a of the pure action. That
is: the second coset sits modulo the product of the first a. This is
exactly what the ordinary group cohomology cup product gives.
-D.5 The lower detector statement
-
PROPOSITION D.5 (the actual multiplication in the detector). The
unit eta: S -> Y carries z_p = beta_1^{h^2} to a NONZERO class in
pi_{d h^2} Y, with d = 2p(p-1) - 2 and h = p-1.
@@ -783,18 +684,12 @@ Since eta is a ring map, eta_*(beta_1^{h^2}) agrees with
(eta_*(beta_1))^{h^2}: the sphere power z_p passes to the h^2-th power
of the detected class.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART E. UPPER VANISHING: HOW z_p DIES AT THE UPPER HEIGHT
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
This is the crux of the kernel proof. To show z_p dies under the upper
unit S -> L_{K(n)} S (with n = p or p+1), we compute the Morava descent
spectral sequence of S at that height and prove that the class lies in
a filtration high enough to vanish. The vanishing is driven by an
upper bound on continuous cohomology of the Morava stabilizer group.
-E.1 The cohomological line
-
PROPOSITION E.1 (the cohomological vanishing). Let a >= 1 be an
integer satisfying one of:
(a = p, p >= 5), or
@@ -813,8 +708,6 @@ subgroup.
Here is what each ingredient contributes.
-E.2 Ingredient one: p-adic analytic dimension
-
The pure stabilizer S_a of Morava E-theory of height a is the
maximal-order unit group in the central division algebra D over Q_p of
dimension a^2 (invariant 1/a). Morava 1985 (Sections 2.1-2.2) gives the
@@ -849,8 +742,6 @@ exclusion:
Therefore cd_p(S_a) = a^2 for these heights when the coefficients are
discrete p-primary modules.
-E.3 Ingredient two: the semilinear trace-one contraction
-
At height a = p, the Galois factor Gal(F_{p^p}/F_p) has order p (equal
to the characteristic). So the extra +1 in the cohomological bound
cannot come from a dimension argument: we must handle the Galois
@@ -904,8 +795,6 @@ Q-columns, giving
H^s_{cts}( G_a ; M_j ) = H^s_{cts}( S_a ; M_j )^Q = 0 for s > a^2.
-E.4 The inverse-limit step: why one extra degree survives
-
The full coefficient module M = pi_q( E_a ^ D V_0 ) has the
maximal-ideal (m_a)-adic topology and is a countable inverse limit of
its finite quotients M_j. Continuous cochains into M are compatible
@@ -924,8 +813,6 @@ The inverse limit is exactly why we get a^2 + 1 rather than a^2. The
+1 is not a pollution; it is genuine (there may be a surviving lim^1
contribution in degree a^2 + 1 in general).
-E.5 The zero tail of the upper filtration
-
The Morava descent spectral sequence reads
E_2^{s,q} = H^s_{cts}( G_a ; (E_a)_q )
@@ -1033,10 +920,6 @@ nullity. Section H will require a separate argument that a specific
map is NULL (not just zero on tests), and the paper is careful not to
confuse those.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART F. PUSHING THE NAMED PRODUCT PAST THE ZERO TAIL
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
We now take the specific sphere class z_p = beta_1^{h^2} (h = p-1) and
show it dies at the upper height. The argument combines three
ingredients: (i) positive sphere stems are torsion; (ii) Morava E-theory
@@ -1045,8 +928,6 @@ torsion class vanishes automatically; (iii) multiplicativity of the
Adams filtration then pushes the h^2-th power up to filtration 2h^2,
which exceeds the upper tail.
-F.1 Positive sphere stems are torsion
-
FACT F.1. Every class x in pi_d S with d > 0 is torsion: it
generates a finite (cyclic or abelian torsion) subgroup of pi_d S.
@@ -1066,8 +947,6 @@ O_a . u^{-d/2}, hence TORSION-FREE. So the image of a torsion class
is zero. This says x_a is killed by pi_d B_a -> pi_d E_a, i.e., it
lies in the F^1 step of the Adams filtration.
-F.2 The first filtration step vanishes on even total degree
-
FACT F.2. For any positive height a, on even total degree d,
F^1 pi_d B_a / F^2 pi_d B_a = 0.
@@ -1081,8 +960,6 @@ therefore so is E_infinity.
Combined with F.1': the unit image x_a of a positive-degree x lies at
least in F^2.
-F.3 Long powers land in F^{2h^2}
-
FACT F.3. If x_a in F^2 pi_d B_a, then x_a^{k} in F^{2k} pi_{dk} B_a.
Proof. F^r F^s is contained in F^{r+s} by multiplicativity
@@ -1091,8 +968,6 @@ Proof. F^r F^s is contained in F^{r+s} by multiplicativity
For x = beta_1, d = d_p = 2p(p-1) - 2, so the unit image x_a^{h^2}
of z_p = beta_1^{h^2} lies in F^{2h^2} pi_{d h^2} B_a.
-F.4 The numerical margin
-
At height a = p (p >= 5):
2h^2 = 2(p-1)^2 = 2p^2 - 4p + 2,
@@ -1115,8 +990,6 @@ Difference:
Again 2h^2 >= a^2 + 2.
-F.5 The upper vanishing statement
-
PROPOSITION F.5 (upper vanishing of the same power). Let p >= 5 be
prime, x = beta_1 in pi_d S with d = 2p(p-1) - 2, and h = p-1.
Then:
@@ -1160,8 +1033,6 @@ Step 6 (sphere lift). The unit S -> B_a is a ring map, so x_a^{h^2}
is the unit image of x^{h^2}. Combined with Step 5, the sphere product
x^{h^2} dies under each unit. Done.
-F.6 The p = 5 case spelled out
-
At p = 5:
d = 38, h = 4, h^2 = 16,
d h^2 = 608.
@@ -1178,15 +1049,9 @@ statement is not part of Corollary 1: the argument for Theorem 2 needs
p >= 7, and at p = 5 the class x^{16} does not stay in the zero tail
one height higher.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART G. ASSEMBLING THE KERNEL THEOREMS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
We now have everything to prove Theorems 1 and 2 and the p = 5
corollary.
-G.1 Proof of Theorem 1 (height-p kernel, p >= 5)
-
Set h = p-1, n = p, t = p-1 = h, d = d_p = 2p(p-1) - 2, and k = k_p =
h^2. Take z = z_p = beta_1^{h^2} in pi_{d h^2} S.
@@ -1205,8 +1070,6 @@ Apply Proposition C.2 with t = p-1 and n = p. This gives: the image of
z in pi_{d h^2} L_{p-1} X is nonzero and is killed by i_{p,X}. Hence
i_{p,X} has no retraction.
-G.2 Proof of Theorem 2 (height-(p+1) kernel, p >= 7)
-
Same z = z_p. Same Y = E_h^{hG}, still detected (D.5 works at every odd
prime). Set n = p+1 instead of p.
@@ -1217,15 +1080,11 @@ Apply Proposition C.2 with t = p-1 and n = p+1. This gives: the image
of z in pi_{d h^2} L_p X is nonzero and is killed by i_{p+1,X}. Hence
i_{p+1,X} has no retraction.
-G.3 Proof of the p = 5 corollary
-
Instantiate Theorem 1 at p = 5:
d = 38, h = 4, k = 16, d h^2 = 608, n = p = 5.
The image of beta_1^{16} in pi_608 L_4 X is nonzero and lies in the
kernel of pi_608( i_{5,X} ).
-G.4 What the kernel theorem does NOT need
-
No permanent cycles. No spherical representatives. No comparison with
the Tate spectrum. The kernel proof uses only:
@@ -1241,8 +1100,6 @@ either algebraic-topological bookkeeping (kernel criterion, completion
lemma) or standard p-adic group theory (Lazard-Serre, cyclotomic
Eisenstein exclusion).
-G.5 A warning on what would make the proof collapse
-
If one drops any of the following, the proof breaks:
* The multiplicative structure on the E_infinity page. Without it,
@@ -1265,17 +1122,11 @@ If one drops any of the following, the proof breaks:
even total degree, forcing the unit image to sit in F^2 and not
just in F^1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART H. THE INDEPENDENT EXPONENT OBSTRUCTION
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
This section gives the second, unrelated proof of Theorem 1. It uses a
different tool: H-equivariant descent exponents. The heart of the
argument is that weak CSC would force two finite numbers to satisfy
opposite inequalities.
-H.1 Setup
-
Fix p >= 5 and put t = p-1, h = p. (The number h = p here is the upper
height the exponent argument is going to obstruct; t = p-1 is the lower
height. Do not confuse h with the h = p-1 of Part D.)
@@ -1318,8 +1169,6 @@ And a retraction of i_{p,X} would force exp_H(E_{p-1}) <= exp_H(T(B_p)).
This is a contradiction, and it proves the same nonretraction that
Theorem 1 proved via sphere classes.
-H.1.5 The finite tensor cube and the pages bound
-
Two finite-stage identifications underlie BOTH exponent arguments.
The first is the "finite tensor cube" of Amitsur descent; the second
is the derived-couple computation that converts a page-vanishing into
@@ -1424,8 +1273,6 @@ a tested-image vanishing.
(or F^c contained in F^b when c < b) and descending, we get
F^b pi_d V' = 0. This is exactly the asserted zero image.
-H.2 Lower bound: exp_H(E_{p-1}) > m
-
The lower bound is a finite-page survival statement in the ordinary
homotopy fixed point spectral sequence for H. It does not use any
sphere representative; a class survives to a specific finite page.
@@ -1512,8 +1359,6 @@ At p = 5, m = 27, one may take N = 15 (15 is divisible by 5 and
2*15 = 30 > 27): the class has filtration 30 on E_28, obstructing
exponent 27. This is the smallest case.
-H.2.5 The finite-test coefficient complex
-
The upper argument needs to know that the Amitsur spectral sequence
of B_h, composed with the exact ordinary functor F(V_0, -) for a
finite V_0, has second page H^s_cts(G_h, pi_q(E_h ^ D V_0)). That is
@@ -1679,8 +1524,6 @@ Proposition H.2.5 below, which we assemble from three lemmas.
operators, so the Amitsur page is H^s_cts(G_a, pi_q(E_a ^ D V_0)).
Done.
-H.3 Upper bound: exp_H(T(B_p)) <= m (structural overview)
-
The upper bound is much more involved. It has three sub-arguments:
H.3.a. An ACTUAL NULL MAP in the local category C_h:
@@ -1853,8 +1696,6 @@ By H.3.b, every D'-module has H-exponent <= 1. So all m layers have
exponent <= 1. By the exponent calculus (H.3.0 part iii), summing m
cofiber sequences gives T(B_h) with exponent <= m.
-H.4 Assembling the exponent contradiction
-
COROLLARY H.4.1. i_{h,X} = i_{p,X} has no homotopy retraction.
Proof. Suppose i_{p,X} admitted a retraction r. The key square is:
@@ -1882,8 +1723,6 @@ E_t as a RETRACT of T(B_p). But:
* H.3.c: exp_H(T(B_p)) <= m.
Contradiction. So no retraction exists.
-H.5 Theorem 3, restated
-
THEOREM 3 (exponents, from earlier statement). Let p >= 5 prime,
t = p-1, h = p, m = p^2 + 2, H = C_p >| C_{(p-1)^2} acting on
E_t by its coherent Morava action, T(V) = L_{K(t)}(E_t ^ V) with
@@ -1900,8 +1739,6 @@ INDEPENDENT: neither uses the other's key input. The kernel proof uses
sphere classes; the exponent proof uses H-equivariant nullity. They
both land on the same theorem.
-H.6 What the exponent proof needs (vs what the kernel proof needs)
-
KERNEL PROOF needs:
* Heard's E_2 calculation (D.2-D.3)
* multiplicative structure on homotopy fixed point SS (D.4)
@@ -1917,16 +1754,10 @@ H.6 What the exponent proof needs (vs what the kernel proof needs)
Neither set contains the other. Both are genuine.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-PART I. WHAT THE PAPER DOES NOT CLAIM, AND OPEN QUESTIONS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
It is as important to know the boundaries of what is proved as to know
the proof. The paper is a refutation of a specific conjecture in a
specific range.
-I.1 What the paper does NOT claim
-
* The STRONG chromatic splitting conjecture is not refuted by this
paper at any prime. Only the WEAK form (retraction existence) is
refuted at heights p and p+1, and only at p >= 5 and p >= 7
@@ -1952,8 +1783,6 @@ I.1 What the paper does NOT claim
itself witnesses nonretraction, but does not claim that every
finite X_p^ inherits it.
-I.2 What is genuinely OPEN after this paper
-
* Whether weak CSC holds at p = 2 or p = 3, for the version of the
conjecture that allows completed finite inputs. (The strong form
is known to fail at p = 2 by Beaudry 2017 with a revised form in
@@ -1975,8 +1804,6 @@ I.2 What is genuinely OPEN after this paper
in the sphere. The paper isolates the class; it does not exhibit a
geometric model.
-I.3 The honest summary
-
The paper is not a "no chromatic splitting" paper. It is a "no
canonical lower-height retraction at height p (and p+1) when the input
is the p-completed sphere, for p large enough" paper. It gives two
@@ -1990,9 +1817,7 @@ had been implicitly assumed in some corners of the chromatic splitting
literature. The evidence is a single nonzero-kernel class z_p; the
paper does not try to characterize which other classes behave this way.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
GLOSSARY
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A_H: F(H_+, S) with H acting by translation. The "H-equivariant
dual sphere." (Part H.1)
@@ -2082,9 +1907,7 @@ Y: The lower detector E_h^{hG} used in Part D. (Part D.1)
z_p: beta_1^{k_p}, a specific stable homotopy class of spheres. The
kernel class. (Part B.1)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
REFERENCES
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(With each entry I give the specific statement locator used in this
document. Many entries have a DOI or an accessible text.)