diff 56bc728..f6bf760 hamiltonian_morse_dim22_v2.txt
diff --git a/hamiltonian_morse_dim22_v2.txt b/hamiltonian_morse_dim22_v2.txt
index 25dd564..fd9a5be 100644
--- a/hamiltonian_morse_dim22_v2.txt
+++ b/hamiltonian_morse_dim22_v2.txt
@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ Let W be a connected closed smooth manifold. A smooth Morse function F on Wtimes
For a finitely generated abelian group A let d(A) be its least number of generators. Set r_i(W)=rank H_i(W;mathbf Z),bfZ), t_i(W)=d(Tor H_i(W;mathbf Z)),bfZ)), b(W)=sum_i r_i(W), and
lambda(W)=b(W)+2sum_i t_i(W).
-On the Hamiltonian side let (M,omega) be closed symplectic and H smooth and one-periodic, with vector field omega(X_{H_t},cdot)=dH_t and time-one map phi_H^1. A fixed point x is nondegenerate when 1 is not an eigenvalue of dphi_H^1(x), and contractible when tmapstophi_H^t(x) is null-homotopic in M; whether this holds depends only on x. The set of contractible fixed points is Fix_0(phi_H^1;H).
+On the Hamiltonian side let (M,omega) be closed symplectic and H smooth and one-periodic, with vector field omega(X_{H_t},·)=dH_t and time-one map phi_H^1. A fixed point x is nondegenerate when 1 is not an eigenvalue of dphi_H^1(x), and contractible when t|->phi_H^t(x) is null-homotopic in M; whether this holds depends only on x. The set of contractible fixed points is Fix_0(phi_H^1;H).
For every integer mge1 there exist a simply connected closed Kaehler manifold (M_m,omega_m) of real dimension 22 and a smooth one-periodic Hamiltonian H_m, all of whose fixed points are nondegenerate, such that
SM(M_m)=80+1968m, #Fix(phi_{H_m}^1)=#Fix_0(phi_{H_m}^1;H_m)=80+1952m.
@@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ A>max_{Wtimesoverlineoverline B_B_{R_0}}{|F|,|Q|}, T>R_0, T^2>A.
Put K=Wtimesoverlineoverline B_TB_T and K_pm=Kcap{Flepm A}. Outside the core the two functions coincide; inside it the level -A is empty and the level A contains the whole core. Hence K_pm=Kcap{Qlepm A}.
On the side boundary Wtimes∂ B_T the function equals Q, whose restricted differential vanishes only where u=0 or v=0, at the values pm T^2. Since T^2>A, there are no side-boundary critical points in [-A,A]. A gradient-like field for F on that band may be chosen tangent to the side boundary: take such a field on the boundary where dFne0, extend to a collar, and combine with an interior field by a partition of unity, the inequality dF(V)>0 away from critical points surviving the combination. The Morse attachment theorem then applies on the compact manifold with corners and, relative to K_-, attaches one j-cell for each index-j critical point. Separating coincident critical values by a small perturbation supported in the Morse charts of the critical points does not alter the endpoint pair, the critical points, or the indices. A finite free complex C_* results, with
-sum_jrank C_j=#Crit(F), H_j(C_*)cong H_j(K_+,K_-;mathbf Z).bfZ).
+sum_jrank C_j=#Crit(F), H_j(C_*)~= H_j(K_+,K_-;mathbf Z).bfZ).
-The homotopy (u,v)mapsto(u,(1-s)v) decreases both Q and the Euclidean norm, so by the endpoint identity it deformation retracts the pair onto Wtimes(D_T^d,{uin D_T^d:|u|gesqrt A}). The disk-annulus pair has relative integral homology mathbf ZbfZ in degree d and zero elsewhere, with d=0 giving the pair ({0},∅); both signatures of Q are covered. The relative Kunneth formula, the second factor being torsion-free, then gives H_j(C_*)cong H_{j-d}(W;mathbf Z).bfZ). The chain inequality forces #Crit(F)gelambda(W), and minimising over F gives SM(W)gelambda(W).
+The homotopy (u,v)|->(u,(1-s)v) decreases both Q and the Euclidean norm, so by the endpoint identity it deformation retracts the pair onto Wtimes(D_T^d,{uin D_T^d:|u|gesqrt A}). The disk-annulus pair has relative integral homology mathbf ZbfZ in degree d and zero elsewhere, with d=0 giving the pair ({0},∅); both signatures of Q are covered. The relative Kunneth formula, the second factor being torsion-free, then gives H_j(C_*)~= H_{j-d}(W;mathbf Z).bfZ). The chain inequality forces #Crit(F)gelambda(W), and minimising over F gives SM(W)gelambda(W).
The reverse direction for the manifolds at hand uses Smale's handle theorem. Let W be simply connected closed smooth of dimension Dge9. Then W carries an ordinary Morse function with exactly r_i(W)+t_i(W)+t_{i-1}(W) critical points of index i for every i. The existence is the torsion-inclusive form of Smale's Morse theorem; a self-contained handle-cancellation proof, including the delicate indices 2 and 3, is supplied as part of the proof of the equality theorem. Summing the index counts gives lambda(W) critical points, and since ordinary Morse functions are admissible,
lambda(W)leSM(W)leMorse(W)lelambda(W).
@@ -57,12 +57,12 @@ The blow-up centers are Z_2=S_2 of complex dimension 2 and Z_3=S_3timesCP^1times
Two tools install the centers. First a simultaneous embedding, in the spirit of the secant-and-tangent argument of Hartshorne. Let dge0 and let V_1,...,V_s be smooth complex projective varieties of complex dimension at most d, split into connected components. The disjoint union embeds holomorphically in CP^{2d+1}. To see this, put the components in pairwise disjoint linear subspaces of some CP^D with D>2d+1. For each ordered pair the secant locus is swept by the projectivisation of a rank-two bundle over the pair space, of complex dimension dim V_alpha+dim V_beta+1le2d+1<D, hence of measure zero by Sard's theorem; each embedded projective tangent space is swept in complex dimension 2dim Vle2d<D. Finitely many such sets leave a point q, and projection from q is injective off the secants and has injective derivative off the tangents, so restricts to an embedding. Iterating the projection down to 2d+1 completes the argument.
Second, the integral blow-up formula of Duan-Li. Let A be compact connected Kaehler and Zsubset A a nonempty closed connected complex submanifold of complex codimension cge2. The blow-up pi:widehatwidehat AAto A is compact connected Kaehler, and simply connected when A is, and for every i
-H_i(widehatwidehat A;A;mathbf Z)bfZ)cong H_i(A;mathbf Z)bfZ) ⊕ ⊕_{j=1}^{c-1}H_{i-2j}(Z;mathbf Z).bfZ).
-The exceptional divisor is E_Z=mathbf P(bfP(nu) for the complex normal bundle nu, with tautological bundle mathcal O(-1).calO(-1). For the Kaehler form take pi^*omega_A+εeta with ε small, where eta is the Chern curvature of a positively curved metric on the fibrewise mathcal O(1),calO(1), positive on the kernel directions of pi^*omega_A and bounded on the compact remainder. For simple connectivity, A∖ Z is simply connected by general position in real codimension 2cge4, and a loop in widehatwidehat AA can be pushed off E_Z (real codimension two) and contracted in A∖ Z. For the splitting, the Leray-Hirsch theorem gives H^k(E_Z;mathbf Z)=⊕_bfZ)=⊕_{j=0}^{c-1}h^jrho^*H^{k-2j}(Z;mathbf Z)bfZ) with h=c_1(mathcal O(1))calO(1)) restricting to an integral basis on each fibre; the Gysin pushforward satisfies iota^*iota_*(v)=-hv, so s_j(u)=-iota_*(h^{j-1}rho^*u) lifts the positive powers h^j. Classes restricting to an h^0 term are recognised through the isomorphism (widehatwidehat A,E_Z)A,E_Z)to(A,Z) of relative cohomology, coming from the homeomorphism widehatwidehat A/E_ZA/E_Zcong A/Z, which shows each such class lies in pi^*H^k(A;mathbf Z).bfZ). The map pi^*+sum_j s_j is a bijection over mathbf Z:bfZ: restriction to E_Z kills the positive powers, and pi^* is injective because pi has degree one. Poincare duality converts H^{k-2j}(Z;mathbf Z)bfZ) to H_{i-2c+2j}(Z;mathbf Z),bfZ), and replacing j by c-j gives the homology splitting, torsion included.
+H_i(widehatwidehat A;A;mathbf Z)bfZ)~= H_i(A;mathbf Z)bfZ) ⊕ ⊕_{j=1}^{c-1}H_{i-2j}(Z;mathbf Z).bfZ).
+The exceptional divisor is E_Z=mathbf P(bfP(nu) for the complex normal bundle nu, with tautological bundle O(-1).calO(-1). For the Kaehler form take pi^*omega_A+εeta with ε small, where eta is the Chern curvature of a positively curved metric on the fibrewise O(1), positive on the kernel directions of pi^*omega_A and bounded on the compact remainder. For simple connectivity, A∖ Z is simply connected by general position in real codimension 2cge4, and a loop in widehatwidehat AA can be pushed off E_Z (real codimension two) and contracted in A∖ Z. For the splitting, the Leray-Hirsch theorem gives H^k(E_Z;mathbf Z)=⊕_bfZ)=⊕_{j=0}^{c-1}h^jrho^*H^{k-2j}(Z;mathbf Z)bfZ) with h=c_1(O(1)) restricting to an integral basis on each fibre; the Gysin pushforward satisfies iota^*iota_*(v)=-hv, so s_j(u)=-iota_*(h^{j-1}rho^*u) lifts the positive powers h^j. Classes restricting to an h^0 term are recognised through the isomorphism (widehatwidehat A,E_Z)A,E_Z)to(A,Z) of relative cohomology, coming from the homeomorphism widehatwidehat A/E_ZA/E_Zcong A/Z, which shows each such class lies in pi^*H^k(A;mathbf Z).bfZ). The map pi^*+sum_j s_j is a bijection over mathbf Z:bfZ: restriction to E_Z kills the positive powers, and pi^* is injective because pi has degree one. Poincare duality converts H^{k-2j}(Z;mathbf Z)bfZ) to H_{i-2c+2j}(Z;mathbf Z),bfZ), and replacing j by c-j gives the homology splitting, torsion included.
./pdf/duan-li-2009-blowups.pdf
The family of ninefolds follows. Let mge1. The projection with d=4 places m copies of Z_2 and m copies of Z_3 disjointly in CP^9. Blowing up successively, the codimensions are always 7 and 5, and each step preserves compactness, connectedness, a Kaehler form, and simple connectivity, while the complex dimension stays 9. The blow-up formula gives, for the resulting ninefold X_m,
-H_i(X_m;mathbf Z)bfZ)cong H_i(CP^9;mathbf Z)bfZ) ⊕ (⊕_{r=1}^{6}H_{i-2r}(Z_2;mathbf Z))^bfZ))^{ ⊕ m} ⊕ (⊕_{r=1}^{4}H_{i-2r}(Z_3;mathbf Z))^bfZ))^{ ⊕ m}.
+H_i(X_m;mathbf Z)bfZ)~= H_i(CP^9;mathbf Z)bfZ) ⊕ (⊕_{r=1}^{6}H_{i-2r}(Z_2;mathbf Z))^bfZ))^{ ⊕ m} ⊕ (⊕_{r=1}^{4}H_{i-2r}(Z_3;mathbf Z))^bfZ))^{ ⊕ m}.
A short-period estimate excludes spurious fixed points. Let V be a smooth vector field on a closed manifold P with flow psi^s. There is tau>0 such that 0<T<tau and psi^T(x)=x force V(x)=0; this is the elementary lower bound on nonconstant periods of Yorke. Cover P by finitely many coordinate balls, each closing inside a larger ball of the same chart; bounds on the coordinate speed and the distances from the smaller balls to the boundaries of the larger ones give eta>0 so that a trajectory leaving a smaller ball stays in its larger ball for time eta, while a common Lipschitz constant L bounds the coordinate field on the larger balls. Suppose psi^T(x)=x with 0<T<eta; write the orbit as y:[0,T]tomathbf R^dbfR^d and the coordinate field as v, and let m=|v(y(t_0))| be the maximum. Since y(T)=y(0), int_0^T v(y(t)),dt=0 and |y(t)-y(t_0)|le Tm, whence
m=Big|frac1Tint_0^Tbig(v(y(t_0))-v(y(t))big),dtBig|lefrac LTint_0^T|y(t_0)-y(t)|,dtle LTm.
@@ -78,16 +78,16 @@ Average a Riemannian metric over {id,g} so that the exponential chart at a fixed
A specific surface carries four fixed curves. Let Y be the blow-up of CP^1timesCP^1 at the four points {0,∞}times{0,∞}. The lifted diagonal circle action preserves a Kaehler form omega_Y and is Hamiltonian, and its half-turn g_Y has fixed locus exactly four exceptional curves E_1,...,E_4, each a CP^1; along each, dg_Y is +id on the tangent bundle and -id on the symplectic normal bundle. The surface Y is simply connected, with
H_i(Y;mathbf Z)bfZ)congmathbf Z,&i=0,4,bfZ,&i=0,4, mathbf Z^6,&i=2,bfZ^6,&i=2, 0,&otherwise.
-In affine coordinates the diagonal action is tcdot(z,w)=(e^{2pi it}z,e^{2pi it}w), which fixes the four centres and lifts holomorphically. Averaging a Kaehler form over the lifted action makes it invariant; Cartan's formula d(omega_Y(V,cdot))=mathcal L_VcalL_Vomega_Y=0 together with H^1(Y;mathbf R)=0bfR)=0 gives a function k with dk=omega_Y(V,cdot), so V=X_k and the autonomous Hamiltonian k/2 has time-one map g_Y. Near a centre write z near 0 or 1/z near ∞ in each factor; the four circle weights are (1,1),(1,-1),(-1,1),(-1,-1), and the induced action on the exceptional line sends [z_1:z_2]mapsto[e^{2pi ialpha t}z_1:e^{2pi ibeta t}z_2], whose value at t=1/2 is the identity in all four cases. In the local model {(ell,v):ellinCP^1, vinellsubsetmathbf C^2bfC^2} the downstairs half-turn is vmapsto-v, so the lift is (ell,v)mapsto(ell,-v), fixing exactly the zero section, with derivative +id on the tangent space and -id on the normal line; that normal space is the negative eigenspace, by orthogonality of the two eigenspaces. The blow-down is an equivariant isomorphism away from the exceptional curves, so no further fixed points occur. Since each blown-up point has complex codimension two, four blow-ups add one free generator in degree two to the ranks (1,2,1) of CP^1timesCP^1, giving the stated homology.
+In affine coordinates the diagonal action is t·(z,w)=(e^{2pi it}z,e^{2pi it}w), which fixes the four centres and lifts holomorphically. Averaging a Kaehler form over the lifted action makes it invariant; Cartan's formula d(omega_Y(V,·))=L_V together with H^1(Y;mathbf R)=0bfR)=0 gives a function k with dk=omega_Y(V,·), so V=X_k and the autonomous Hamiltonian k/2 has time-one map g_Y. Near a centre write z near 0 or 1/z near ∞ in each factor; the four circle weights are (1,1),(1,-1),(-1,1),(-1,-1), and the induced action on the exceptional line sends [z_1:z_2]|->[e^{2pi ialpha t}z_1:e^{2pi ibeta t}z_2], whose value at t=1/2 is the identity in all four cases. In the local model {(ell,v):ellinCP^1, vinellsubsetmathbf C^2bfC^2} the downstairs half-turn is v|->-v, so the lift is (ell,v)|->(ell,-v), fixing exactly the zero section, with derivative +id on the tangent space and -id on the normal line; that normal space is the negative eigenspace, by orthogonality of the two eigenspaces. The blow-down is an equivariant isomorphism away from the exceptional curves, so no further fixed points occur. Since each blown-up point has complex codimension two, four blow-ups add one free generator in degree two to the ranks (1,2,1) of CP^1timesCP^1, giving the stated homology.
These pieces realise four copies of a Morse problem on C=XtimesCP^1. Let X be connected closed simply connected Kaehler, let omega_X be any Kaehler form, and let (Y,omega_Y) be the surface just described; give M=Xtimes Y the product form and put C=XtimesCP^1. For every smooth Morse function h:Ctomathbf RbfR there is a smooth one-periodic Hamiltonian H on M whose time-one map has only nondegenerate fixed points and
#Fix(phi_H^1)=#Fix_0(phi_H^1;H)=4,#Crit(h).
The pullback of k/2 generates the involution g=id_Xtimes g_Y for the product form, with fixed components Xtimes E_1,...,Xtimes E_4. Pulling h back along isomorphisms E_jcongCP^1 gives Morse functions h_j, each with #Crit(h) critical points; the involution perturbation yields exactly the fixed points counted, all nondegenerate, and simple connectivity of M makes the fixed-point loops contractible.
The integral counts now follow from the homology. Since b(S_2)=b(S_3)=8 and CP^1timesCP^1 has ranks (1,2,1) in degrees (0,2,4), the center Z_3 has b(Z_3)=32, and the blow-up formula gives
-b(X_m)=10+m(6cdot8+4cdot32)=10+176m.
+b(X_m)=10+m(6·8+4·32)=10+176m.
All homology shifts are even, so torsion lies in two parallel lists, in degrees 1+2j and 2+2j. In either list
-Tor H_{1+2j}(X_m;mathbf Z)bfZ)congTor H_{2+2j}(X_m;mathbf Z)bfZ)cong(mathbf Z/2)^bfZ/2)^{ma_j} ⊕ (mathbf Z/3)^bfZ/3)^{mq_j}
+Tor H_{1+2j}(X_m;mathbf Z)bfZ)congTor H_{2+2j}(X_m;mathbf Z)bfZ)~=(mathbf Z/2)^bfZ/2)^{ma_j} ⊕ (mathbf Z/3)^bfZ/3)^{mq_j}
with a=(2,2,2,2,2,2) and q=(1,3,4,4,3,1), indexed from j=1, all other entries zero. The first sequence records the six blow-up shifts of the two copies of mathbf Z/2;bfZ/2; the second is the coefficientwise sequence of
(u+u^2+u^3+u^4)(1+2u+u^2)=u+3u^2+4u^3+4u^4+3u^5+u^6,
where u records a shift by two in homological degree, the four blow-up shifts give u+...+u^4, and the product with CP^1timesCP^1 multiplies by 1+2u+u^2.
@@ -96,11 +96,11 @@ Since d((mathbf Z/2)^abfZ/2)^a ⊕ (mathbf Z/3)^q)=bfZ/3)^q)=max(a,q), generator
C_m 2-primary (2,4,4,4,4,4,2), sum 24; C_m 3-primary (1,4,7,8,7,4,1), sum 32; C_m generators (2,4,7,8,7,4,2), sum 34; M_m 2-primary (2,14,16,16,16,16,14,2), sum 96; M_m 3-primary (1,9,23,31,31,23,9,1), sum 128; M_m generators (2,14,23,31,31,23,14,2), sum 140.
Each list occurs once in odd and once in even degrees, so
-sum_i t_i(C_m)=2cdot34m=68m, sum_i t_i(M_m)=2cdot140m=280m.
+sum_i t_i(C_m)=2·34m=68m, sum_i t_i(M_m)=2·140m=280m.
The free ranks are b(C_m)=2b(X_m)=20+352m and b(M_m)=8b(X_m)=80+1408m, whence
lambda(C_m)=20+488m, lambda(M_m)=80+1968m.
-The total multiplicity at each prime is four times larger for M_m, but the degreewise maximum adds 2m generators per parity for C_m and 12m for M_m, a surplus of (12-4cdot2)m=4m per parity. With the two parities and the factor two in lambda,
-lambda(M_m)-4lambda(C_m)=2(280-4cdot68)m=16m.
+The total multiplicity at each prime is four times larger for M_m, but the degreewise maximum adds 2m generators per parity for C_m and 12m for M_m, a surplus of (12-4·2)m=4m per parity. With the two parities and the factor two in lambda,
+lambda(M_m)-4lambda(C_m)=2(280-4·68)m=16m.
To finish, fix mge1, choose any Kaehler form on X_m, give M_m=X_mtimes Y the product with the invariant form on Y, and put C_m=X_mtimesCP^1. Both C_m and M_m are closed, simply connected, of real dimension 20 and 22, so Smale's theorem gives SM(M_m)=lambda(M_m)=80+1968m and supplies an ordinary Morse function h_m on C_m with lambda(C_m)=20+488m critical points. The product realisation applied to X_m and h_m yields a smooth one-periodic H_m on M_m with exactly 4#Crit(h_m)=80+1952m fixed points, all nondegenerate, and contractible fixed-point loops, so that #Fix(phi_{H_m}^1)=#Fix_0(phi_{H_m}^1;H_m)=80+1952m. Then
frac{SM(M_m)-#Fix(phi_{H_m}^1)}{SM(M_m)}=(16m)/(80+1968m)=(m)/(5+123m)gefrac1{128},
@@ -125,7 +125,7 @@ Arrange that the pair meets in exactly one geometric point. Suppose first that i
When one sphere has dimension two, reverse the decomposition if necessary so that i=2; the level L is then the boundary after attaching the 2-handles to the single 0-handle. Write the belt spheres as B_1,...,B_h and put V=L∖∪_j B_j. A pair of opposite-sign intersections is removed by moving a small disk of A into V. The boundary L comes from S^{D-1} by surgery on the attaching circles: each surgery replaces S^1times D^{D-2} by D^2times S^{D-3}, and removing its belt sphere leaves (D^2∖{0})times S^{D-3}, which retracts onto S^1times S^{D-3}. Thus V has the homotopy type of the exterior of the original circles in S^{D-1}, and that exterior is simply connected because loops and disks can be pushed off the codimension-two circles; hence pi_1(V)=pi_1(L)=0.
Choose two opposite-sign intersections of the attaching sphere Acong S^2 with one belt sphere. A thin disk Deltasubset A around an arc between the two points contains just these two intersections and misses the other belt spheres; its boundary and an exterior collar in A lie in V. The oriented normal bundle of each belt sphere has rank two, so excision and the Thom isomorphism give
-H_2(L,V;mathbf Z)bfZ)cong⊕_{j=1}^hmathbf Z,bfZ,
+H_2(L,V;mathbf Z)bfZ)~=⊕_{j=1}^hmathbf Z,bfZ,
with coordinates the intersection numbers with the B_j. All coordinates of [Delta] vanish, so [Delta]=0. This gives a relative homotopy: the exact sequences of the pair, together with pi_1(V)=pi_1(L)=0 and the degree-two Hurewicz isomorphisms for V and L, identify
pi_2(L,V)congcoker(pi_2(V)topi_2(L)), H_2(L,V;mathbf Z)bfZ)congcoker(H_2(V;mathbf Z)bfZ)to H_2(L;mathbf Z)).bfZ)).
Hence Delta can be homotoped into V through maps whose boundary stays in V. Extending the boundary motion across the exterior collar and fixing its outer edge produces a homotopy of A, supported in the disk and collar, that removes the chosen pair and preserves the other intersections with the belt spheres.