diff 56bc728..f6bf760 singer_conjecture_dim4_v2.txt
diff --git a/singer_conjecture_dim4_v2.txt b/singer_conjecture_dim4_v2.txt
index cf87b9a..6dc94f9 100644
--- a/singer_conjecture_dim4_v2.txt
+++ b/singer_conjecture_dim4_v2.txt
@@ -77,7 +77,7 @@ formal dimension four, with arbitrary orientation character. Then
[
b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q) = 0
- for all p geq 0, p neq 2.
+ for all p >= 0, p != 2.
]
@@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ Definition~def:pd-complex below.
[Singer in dimension four]
Let M be a closed connected aspherical topological four-manifold. Then
[
- b_p^{(2)}(widetilde M) = 0 for all p neq 2.
+ b_p^{(2)}(widetilde M) = 0 for all p != 2.
]
@@ -99,7 +99,7 @@ topological spaces that admit no PL triangulation or smooth structure.
%=============================================================
-Let k = mathbb F_2bbF_2 throughout the boundary argument. Fix a finite
+Let k = F_2 throughout the boundary argument. Fix a finite
connected aspherical integral Poincare complex Q of formal dimension
four, with orientation character w : pi_1(Q) to {1,-1}, and write
Gamma = pi_1(Q). We do not fix a particular model; we only use that
@@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ Q is a finite CW complex satisfying Poincare duality.
A finite connected CW complex Q is a Poincare complex of formal
dimension n if there is an orientation character w : pi_1(Q) to
-{1,-1} and a class [Q] in H_n(Q;mathbb Z^w)bbZ^w) (where mathbb Z^wbbZ^w
+{1,-1} and a class [Q] in H_n(Q;Z^w) (where Z^w
is the local system twisting by w) such that cap product with [Q]
gives an isomorphism
[
@@ -117,8 +117,8 @@ gives an isomorphism
H^i(Q;V) → H_{n-i}(Q; w ⊗ V)
]
for every local coefficient system V.
-The ``mathbb Z^w''bbZ^w'' twist only matters when Q is nonorientable; for
-orientable Q we can take w equiv 1. When H_*(Q; mathbb Z^w)bbZ^w)
+The ``Z^w''bbZ^w'' twist only matters when Q is nonorientable; for
+orientable Q we can take w equiv 1. When H_*(Q; Z^w)
vanishes outside the fundamental class, the complex is an
integral Poincare complex.
@@ -133,7 +133,7 @@ those consequences now.
The group Gamma is infinite, finitely presented, and torsion-free.
Moreover, Q is homotopy equivalent to a finite four-dimensional CW
complex, and the augmented cellular chain complex of that model is a
-finitely generated free mathbb ZbbZGamma-resolution of mathbb ZbbZ of
+finitely generated free Z-resolution of Z of
length four.
@@ -143,22 +143,22 @@ complex homotopy equivalent to Q; because Q is finite, we may take
the model finite (the reduced finiteness obstruction is zero for a space
already finitely dominated). Asphericity plus finite four-dimensional
model means the model's universal cover is contractible, so its cellular
-chains give a free resolution of mathbb ZbbZ over mathbb ZbbZGamma of
+chains give a free resolution of Z over Z of
length four.
Torsion-free. Suppose g in Gamma has prime order p. Let
-C = < g > cong mathbb Z/p.bbZ/p. Restrict the resolution just
-described to C. We still have a free mathbb ZbbZ C-resolution of
-mathbb ZbbZ of finite length leq 4. But a cyclic group of prime order
-has 2-periodic cohomology: H^{2j}(C;mathbb Z)bbZ) cong mathbb Z/pbbZ/p
-for every j geq 1. A resolution of length leq 4 cannot possibly
+C = < g > ~= Z/p.bbZ/p. Restrict the resolution just
+described to C. We still have a free Z C-resolution of
+Z of finite length <= 4. But a cyclic group of prime order
+has 2-periodic cohomology: H^{2j}(C;Z) ~= Z/pbbZ/p
+for every j >= 1. A resolution of length <= 4 cannot possibly
give nonzero cohomology in arbitrarily high degrees, so we arrive at a
contradiction. Hence no finite-order element exists.
Infinite. Suppose Gamma finite. By torsion-freeness,
Gamma is trivial, so Q is simply connected and aspherical, hence
contractible. But Poincare duality over k gives
-H_4(Q;k) cong H^0(Q;k) cong k, contradicting contractibility
+H_4(Q;k) ~= H^0(Q;k) ~= k, contradicting contractibility
(a point has no H_4). So Gamma is infinite.
Finitely presented. A finite four-dimensional CW model has
@@ -178,7 +178,7 @@ A compact topological manifold is metrizable and is an absolute
neighborhood retract (ANR): the coordinate neighborhood of any point is
an ANR, and Hanner's locality theorem upgrades this to a global ANR;
see cite[Thms.~3.2--3.3]{Hanner1951}. Its covering dimension is
-leq 4 by the closed-sum theory of dimension; see
+<= 4 by the closed-sum theory of dimension; see
cite[Theorems~1.1.2, 1.5.3, 1.7.7, 1.8.2]{Engelking1978}. West's
homotopy dimension estimate then supplies a finite four-dimensional
simplicial complex F homotopy equivalent to M; see
@@ -188,7 +188,7 @@ a homotopy model.
Transport the fundamental class and orientation character of M to
F. Topological Poincare duality with local coefficients gives
cap-product isomorphisms for every coefficient system on M:
-cite[Theorem~1, with R = mathbb Z]bbZ]{Sun2017}, and see also
+cite[Theorem~1, with R = Z]bbZ]{Sun2017}, and see also
cite[Thm.~10.2, Rem.~10.3]{Spanier1993} and
cite[Thm.~A.16]{FNOP2025}. Transporting along the homotopy equivalence
gives F the PD property. Combined with asphericity of M, this makes
@@ -199,20 +199,20 @@ dimension four.
## What Poincare duality gives us algebraically
The two key algebraic facts are that the group-ring module
-mathbb ZbbZGamma (and its kGamma analogue) has vanishing first and
+Z (and its kGamma analogue) has vanishing first and
second cohomology, and that one can read off good information about
subgroups of Gamma through Shapiro's lemma.
[Group-cohomological vanishing from duality]
-With k = mathbb F_2,bbF_2, the group Gamma satisfies
+With k = F_2, the group Gamma satisfies
[
H^i(Gamma; kGamma) = 0 (i = 1, 2).
]
-Moreover, for every subgroup J leq Gamma there is a natural
+Moreover, for every subgroup J <= Gamma there is a natural
isomorphism
[
- H^1(Gamma; k[Gamma/J]) cong H_3(J; k).
+ H^1(Gamma; k[Gamma/J]) ~= H_3(J; k).
]
In particular this group vanishes if J is finite or two-ended.
@@ -221,16 +221,16 @@ Proof.
The orientation twist of a PD4 complex is invisible over k. Because
Q is aspherical,
[
- H^i(Q; V) cong H^i(Gamma; V)
+ H^i(Q; V) ~= H^i(Gamma; V)
]
for every local system V. Apply Poincare duality (which, over k,
does not see the orientation character) with V a k-vector space:
[
- H^i(Gamma; V) cong H_{4-i}(Gamma; V), 0 leq i leq 4.
+ H^i(Gamma; V) ~= H_{4-i}(Gamma; V), 0 <= i <= 4.
]
-Take V = kGamma to get H^i(Gamma; kGamma) cong H_{4-i}(Gamma; kGamma).
-Taking i = 1 gives H^1 cong H_3, and i = 2 gives
-H^2 cong H_2. The chain complex of Gamma with coefficients in
+Take V = kGamma to get H^i(Gamma; kGamma) ~= H_{4-i}(Gamma; kGamma).
+Taking i = 1 gives H^1 ~= H_3, and i = 2 gives
+H^2 ~= H_2. The chain complex of Gamma with coefficients in
kGamma is just the augmented kGamma-resolution of k tensored
with kGamma, and since that resolution is finite of length four,
H_p(Gamma; kGamma) = 0 for p > 0 (a free resolution of k is
@@ -242,12 +242,12 @@ k[Gamma/J] = kGamma ⊗ _{kJ} k. If R_* is a free right
kGamma-resolution of k then
[
R_* ⊗ _{kGamma} (kGamma ⊗ _{kJ} k)
- cong (R_*|_J) ⊗ _{kJ} k,
+ ~= (R_*|_J) ⊗ _{kJ} k,
]
which is a free kJ-resolution of k. Thus
-H_j(Gamma; k[Gamma/J]) cong H_j(J; k). Combined with
-H^i(Gamma; V) cong H_{4-i}(Gamma; V), this gives (with i = 1)
-H^1(Gamma; k[Gamma/J]) cong H_3(J; k).
+H_j(Gamma; k[Gamma/J]) ~= H_j(J; k). Combined with
+H^i(Gamma; V) ~= H_{4-i}(Gamma; V), this gives (with i = 1)
+H^1(Gamma; k[Gamma/J]) ~= H_3(J; k).
Vanishing for small J. If J is finite, it is trivial by
Lemma~lem:group-basics, so H_3(J;k) = 0. If J is two-ended,
@@ -255,7 +255,7 @@ it has a finite normal subgroup N with quotient J/N infinite cyclic
or infinite dihedral; this is cite[Lemma~4.1]{Wall1967}. Torsion-freeness
forces N trivial, so J is infinite cyclic (the dihedral case is
impossible because dihedral groups contain involutions). But an infinite
-cyclic group is an iterated extension of the trivial group by mathbb Z,bbZ,
+cyclic group is an iterated extension of the trivial group by Z,
so its integral homology is concentrated in degrees 0 and 1; over
k the same holds, so H_3(J;k) = 0.
@@ -266,13 +266,13 @@ Cayley graph leaves exactly one infinite connected component.
Proof.
-Choose a finite presentation of Gamma and let mathcal CcalC be its
+Choose a finite presentation of Gamma and let C be its
Cayley two-complex (a simply connected 2-complex on which Gamma
acts freely). The corresponding Cayley graph G is locally finite,
since the presentation is finite. The augmented cellular complex of
-mathcal CcalC is exact in degrees zero and one; extending by free modules
+C is exact in degrees zero and one; extending by free modules
in higher degrees gives a free resolution in which each cohomology is
-the same as in mathcal C.calC.
+the same as in C.
Suppose some finite vertex set, when removed from G, leaves two
distinct infinite components. Let f : Gamma to k be the indicator
@@ -327,7 +327,7 @@ If J is finite or two-ended, the Shapiro-based vanishing
c(g) = g v - v for some v in k[Gamma/J]. Hence the coefficient
size of c is bounded:
- |,[o,go] cap E,| leq 2 |supp v|
+ |,[o,go] cap E,| <= 2 |supp v|
(g in Gamma).
@@ -381,7 +381,7 @@ and b_p^{(2)} = 0 for p > 4. A harmonic square-summable
Gamma is infinite, that constant must be zero, so b_0^{(2)} = 0.
For the duality statement we must handle a nontrivial orientation
-character. Let Gamma^+ leq Gamma be the kernel of the orientation
+character. Let Gamma^+ <= Gamma be the kernel of the orientation
character Gamma to {1,-1} and Q^+ to Q the corresponding
two-fold (or one-fold) cover. Its index d = [Gamma:Gamma^+] is
1 or 2. Finite covers of Poincare complexes are again Poincare
@@ -397,31 +397,31 @@ cite[Lemma~1.1]{Wall1967}. In particular, applying duality to the
regular group-ring local system shows that cap product defines a
quasi-isomorphism
[
- C^*(widetilde F; mathbb Z)bbZ) xrightarrow{;cong;}
- C_*(widetilde F; mathbb Z)bbZ)
+ C^*(widetilde F; Z) xrightarrow{;~=;}
+ C_*(widetilde F; Z)
]
-(with degree reversal and a g mapsto g^{-1} twist on the coefficient
+(with degree reversal and a g |-> g^{-1} twist on the coefficient
module). Both sides are bounded complexes of finitely generated free
-mathbb ZbbZGamma^+-modules, so the mapping cone is a bounded acyclic
+Z+-modules, so the mapping cone is a bounded acyclic
complex of free modules. A bounded acyclic complex of free modules
that splits at every surjection is contractible (start in the lowest
degree and split each surjection onto the kernel already obtained).
Hence cap product is a chain homotopy equivalence.
Extending scalars to the group von Neumann algebra
-mathcal N(calN(Gamma^+), homotopies remain homotopies, and finite-matrix
+N(+), homotopies remain homotopies, and finite-matrix
dimension comparison identifies the von Neumann dimensions of the
two complexes. Consequently
[
- b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;mathcal N(calN(Gamma^+))
- = b_{4-p}^{(2)}(widetilde Q;mathcal N(calN(Gamma^+))
- (0 leq p leq 4).
+ b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;N(+))
+ = b_{4-p}^{(2)}(widetilde Q;N(+))
+ (0 <= p <= 4).
]
Finally, finite-index subgroup scaling
cite[Thm.~1.35(9)]{Luck2002} gives
[
- b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;mathcal N(calN(Gamma^+))
- = d cdot b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;mathcal N(calN(Gamma)).
+ b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;N(+))
+ = d · b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;N(
]
Dividing by d gives b_p^{(2)} = b_{4-p}^{(2)} for Q itself.
Taking p = 0 gives b_4^{(2)} = b_0^{(2)} = 0, and taking p = 1
@@ -439,110 +439,110 @@ by finitely supported gradients. Let us set that up.
Choose a finite presentation of Gamma with relators of length at most
three (subdividing longer relators by new generators achieves this; Tietze
transformations preserve all the cohomology we care about). Let
-mathcal CcalC be the Cayley two-complex with graph G; write E(G)
+C be the Cayley two-complex with graph G; write E(G)
for the edge set. As noted in Lemma~lem:group-basics, G is
-connected and locally finite, mathcal CcalC is simply connected, and
+connected and locally finite, C is simply connected, and
each cellular edge belongs to a uniformly bounded number of cell
boundaries. We keep parallel edges and loops as separate cellular edges,
and choose one orientation on each edge.
-For a real function f : Gamma to mathbb RbbR and an oriented edge
+For a real function f : Gamma to R and an oriented edge
e = uv put df(e) = f(v) - f(u). Define the Hilbert spaces
[
- mathcal DcalD =
- {df : f : Gamma to mathbb R,bbR, sum_{e in E(G)} |df(e)|^2 < ∞},
+ D =
+ {df : f : Gamma to R, sum_{e in E(G)} |df(e)|^2 < ∞},
- mathcal D_0calD_0 =
+ D_0 =
overline{{df : f finitely supported}}
]
-where the closure is in ell^2(E(G); mathbb R)bbR) and the sum counts
+where the closure is in ell^2(E(G); R) and the sum counts
each cellular edge once.
[Finite-energy gradients and b_1^{(2)}]
-The space mathcal DcalD is a closed real Hilbert subspace of
-ell^2(E(G);mathbb R)bbR) and mathcal D_0calD_0 ⊆ mathcal D.calD. If
-b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q) > 0 then mathcal D_0calD_0 neq mathcal D.calD.
+The space D is a closed real Hilbert subspace of
+ell^2(E(G);R) and D_0 ⊆ D. If
+b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q) > 0 then D_0 != D.
Proof.
-mathcal DcalD is closed. Write F(mathcal C)calC) for the set of
+D is closed. Write F(C) for the set of
two-cells. The cellular coboundary
[
- d_1 : ell^2(E(G);mathbb R)bbR) to ell^2(F(mathcal C);calC);mathbb R)bbR)
+ d_1 : ell^2(E(G);R) to ell^2(F(C);R)
]
is bounded: each relator has at most three edges (counted with
multiplicities), and edge--cell incidence is uniformly bounded by the
-presentation. An ordinary cellular 1-cocycle on mathcal CcalC is a
+presentation. An ordinary cellular 1-cocycle on C is a
gradient: integrate along edge paths from a fixed base vertex, and
path-independence is exactly the cocycle condition on the simply
-connected mathcal C.calC. Therefore
-mathcal DcalD = ker d_1, which is closed.
+connected C. Therefore
+D = ker d_1, which is closed.
-mathcal D_0calD_0 description. Likewise
-d_0 : ell^2(Gamma;mathbb R)bbR) to ell^2(E(G);mathbb R)bbR) is
+D_0 description. Likewise
+d_0 : ell^2(Gamma;R) to ell^2(E(G);R) is
bounded (bounded vertex degree). Since finite-support functions are
dense in ell^2(Gamma) and d_0 is continuous, the closure of the
image of d_0 is the closure of the image of finitely supported
-functions on ell^2(G). So mathcal D_0calD_0 = im d_0bar;
-in particular mathcal D_0calD_0 ⊆ ker d_1 = mathcal D.calD. Note that
+functions on ell^2(G). So D_0 = im d_0bar;
+in particular D_0 ⊆ ker d_1 = D. Note that
this does not assert im d_0 itself is closed.
Comparison with b_1^{(2).} The augmented cellular chains of
-mathcal CcalC are exact in degrees zero and one. Extend to a free
+C are exact in degrees zero and one. Extend to a free
resolution by choosing a free module P_3 mapping onto
-ker(∂_2 : C_2(mathcal C)calC) to C_1(mathcal C)),calC)), then free
+ker(∂_2 : C_2(C) to C_1(C)), then free
modules onto successive kernels. The cellular terms in degrees 0,1,2
are finitely generated free; so the hypothesis of the finite-matrix
comparison (below) is met. The singular chains of widetilde Q are
-free mathbb ZbbZGamma-modules: a deck transformation fixing a
+free Z-modules: a deck transformation fixing a
singular simplex fixes its image points and hence is the identity.
Thus Lemma~lem:found-comparison applies.
-Over mathbb C,bbC, that comparison identifies b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q)
+Over C, that comparison identifies b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q)
with the dimension of
[
ker d_1 ominus im d_0bar.
]
All the matrices involved are real, so this complex Hilbert space is
-the complexification of mathcal DcalD ominus mathcal D_0.calD_0. If
-mathcal DcalD = mathcal D_0,calD_0, its dimension would be zero. Therefore
+the complexification of D ominus D_0. If
+D = D_0, its dimension would be zero. Therefore
b_1^{(2)} > 0 forces strict inclusion.
[Finite-matrix comparison]
-Let Λ be any group and let P_* be a free mathbb ZΛ-resolutionbbZΛ-resolution
-of mathbb ZbbZ whose terms in degrees 0,1,2 are finitely generated.
+Let Λ be any group and let P_* be a free ZΛ-resolutionbbZΛ-resolution
+of Z whose terms in degrees 0,1,2 are finitely generated.
Suppose a contractible space Z has a free Λ-action with free
-singular chains over mathbb ZΛ.bbZΛ. Then
+singular chains over ZΛ.bbZΛ. Then
[
- b_1^{(2)}(Z;mathcal N(Λ))calN(Λ))
- = dim_{mathcal N(Λ)}calN(Λ)
+ b_1^{(2)}(Z;N(Λ))calN(Λ))
+ = dim_{N(Λ)}calN(Λ)
(ker∂_1 cap ker∂_2^*)
]
where the operators on the right act on the Hilbert spaces
-ell^2(Λ) ⊗ _{mathbb ZΛ}bbZΛ P_i. The same space is the
+ell^2(Λ) ⊗ _{ZΛ}bbZΛ P_i. The same space is the
first reduced Hilbert cohomology for d_0 = ∂_1^* and
d_1 = ∂_2^*.
Proof.
Chain-homotopy comparison. The augmented singular chains of
-Z are a free resolution of mathbb Z.bbZ. The comparison theorem for
+Z are a free resolution of Z. The comparison theorem for
free resolutions gives chain-homotopy equivalences with P_*.
Tensoring with the von Neumann algebra preserves chain homotopies, so
it preserves homology, which is what the definition of b_1^{(2)}
-computes. No flatness of mathcal N(Λ)calN(Λ) over mathbb ZΛbbZΛ
+computes. No flatness of N(Λ)calN(Λ) over ZΛbbZΛ
is needed because we only need to preserve homotopy equivalences.
-Dimension comparison. For a matrix over mathcal N(Λ),calN(Λ),
+Dimension comparison. For a matrix over N(Λ),calN(Λ),
the extended von Neumann dimension of the algebraic kernel equals the
trace of the projection onto its Hilbert-space kernel. The dimension
of the algebraic image (taken as von Neumann dimension) equals the
trace of the projection onto the closure of its Hilbert image. By
additivity of dimension,
[
- dim H_1(mathcal NΛcalNΛ ⊗ P_*)
+ dim H_1(NΛcalNΛ ⊗ P_*)
= dim (ker∂_1 ominus im∂_2bar)
= dim (ker∂_1 cap ker∂_2^*).
]
@@ -559,8 +559,8 @@ cite[Lemmas~6.51--6.53]{Luck2002}.
From now on: assume toward contradiction b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q) > 0,
-so mathcal D_0calD_0 ⊊ mathcal D.calD. We have obtained a nonzero
-quotient mathcal D/calD/mathcal D_0,calD_0, together with Gamma being
+so D_0 ⊊ D. We have obtained a nonzero
+quotient D/calD/D_0, together with Gamma being
finitely presented, torsion-free, one-ended, having no splitting over
a finite or two-ended subgroup, and having the group-cohomological
vanishings of Lemma~lem:found-duality. These are the algebraic
@@ -573,7 +573,7 @@ inputs for the rest of the proof.
This is the heart of the proof's constructive core. Our standing
assumption throughout is that b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q) > 0, equivalently
-mathcal D_0calD_0 ⊊ mathcal D.calD. We will use this to build a compact
+D_0 ⊊ D. We will use this to build a compact
metrizable space X = Gamma sqcup B whose "boundary" B is a nice
continuum, and to arrange that vertices approaching the same boundary
point can be joined by graph paths staying close to that point. That
@@ -601,12 +601,12 @@ b ne a, the functional
[
L_b(df) = f(b) - f(a)
]
-is well defined and continuous on mathcal D:calD: a finite path of length
+is well defined and continuous on D:calD: a finite path of length
ell from a to b gives
|L_b(df)| le √(ell), |df|_2 by Cauchy--Schwarz. The functional
is nonzero because if we test it on the gradient of the singleton
indicator mathbf 1_bf1_{{b}}, we get mathbf 1_bf1_{{b}}(b) -
-mathbf 1_bf1_{{b}}(a) = 1 - 0 = 1. Let r_b in mathcal DcalD be the
+mathbf 1_bf1_{{b}}(a) = 1 - 0 = 1. Let r_b in D be the
Riesz representative: L_b(dg) = < r_b, dg>.
Step 2 (min-norm representative). The unique gradient of minimal
@@ -616,11 +616,11 @@ norm satisfying L_b(df_b) = 1 is
]
with potential f_b normalized by f_b(a) = 0.
-Step 3 (some df_b escapes mathcal D_0).calD_0). The vectors r_b span
-a dense subspace of mathcal D:calD: any dg orthogonal to every r_b
+Step 3 (some df_b escapes D_0). The vectors r_b span
+a dense subspace of D:calD: any dg orthogonal to every r_b
would satisfy L_b(dg) = 0 for every b, so the potential g is
constant, so dg = 0. Since b_1^{(2)} > 0, we have
-mathcal D_0calD_0 ⊊ mathcal D,calD, so some df_b notin mathcal D_0.calD_0.
+D_0 ⊊ D, so some df_b notin D_0.
Fix such a b and its minimizer df.
Step 4 (normalize to [0,1]). The map
@@ -635,7 +635,7 @@ Step 5 (no constant at infinity). Suppose f tends to a constant
c outside finite vertex sets. For ε > 0 define
[
u_ε(v) = sgn(f(v) - c)
- cdot max(|f(v) - c| - ε, 0).
+ · max(|f(v) - c| - ε, 0).
]
The support of u_ε is finite by hypothesis (only finitely
many vertices satisfy |f(v) - c| ge ε). The function
@@ -644,7 +644,7 @@ many vertices satisfy |f(v) - c| ge ε). The function
absolute value by |df| and tend pointwise to zero as
ε to 0. By dominated convergence,
d u_ε to df in ell^2. But du_ε has finite
-support, so df in mathcal D_0,calD_0, contradiction.
+support, so df in D_0, contradiction.
Step 6 (lower level sets connected). Fix a regular t in
(0,1). Suppose a component U of {f > t} misses b. Define
@@ -653,7 +653,7 @@ t, so a notin U) and f(b) = 1 (above t, so b notin U).
Internal edge energies inside U drop to zero. On the boundary, some
edge e = uv has u in U and v notin U (because G is connected
and U is a proper subset); on that edge |df'(e)| < |df(e)| strictly.
-So mathcal E(f')calE(f') < mathcal E(f),calE(f), contradicting that f minimizes
+So E(f')calE(f') < E(f), contradicting that f minimizes
energy subject to L_b = 1. Hence every upper component contains b,
and the upper side is connected. The lower side is connected by the
identical argument with a and b interchanged.
@@ -666,7 +666,7 @@ Consider any cell: the signed sum of this restricted cochain around
that cell is either the original zero sum (if the cell's straddling
edges are in C) or an entirely zero sum (if they are not, or if some
are and some are not, but every crossing edge of the cell lies in one
-dual component, so all-or-nothing). Simple connectivity of mathcal CcalC
+dual component, so all-or-nothing). Simple connectivity of C
gives a potential u for the restricted cochain. That potential is
constant on each of the two connected level sides {f>t} and
{f<t}, and it has nonzero difference across every edge of C.
@@ -678,14 +678,14 @@ contradiction). So C = S(f,t): the wall is dually connected.
[Coordinate cuts have finitely many dual components]
-Every regular cut of a coordinate in mathcal F_0calF_0 (defined below) has
+Every regular cut of a coordinate in F_0 (defined below) has
finitely many dual components. A nonempty regular cut of a translate
of f is dually connected, and a regular cut of a singleton indicator
is finite.
Proof.
-Enlarge mathcal F_0calF_0 by all translates of f and all singleton
+Enlarge F_0 by all translates of f and all singleton
indicators mathbf 1_bf1_{{v}} (with v in Gamma). A translate of f
also has connected level sides and dually connected cuts (translations
of subgroups preserve the properties of Lemma~lem:potential).
@@ -705,7 +705,7 @@ A box is determined by finitely many conditions
[
O = {(z_F) : a_i < z_{F_i} < b_i, 1 le i le m},
- F_i in mathcal F_0.calF_0.
+ F_i in F_0.
]
Endpoints a_i, b_i are real numbers (possibly outside [0,1]). We
retain the defining inequalities as part of the box data, and we use
@@ -724,7 +724,7 @@ coordinates). A box is good if:
[Good boxes are a basis]
Every good box has finitely many graph components on its vertex set.
The collection of good boxes forms a countable Gamma-invariant
-basis for the base-coordinate cube [0,1]^{mathcal F_0}calF_0.
+basis for the base-coordinate cube [0,1]^{F_0}
Proof.
@@ -767,8 +767,8 @@ bounded by a constant D: bounded cell size and bounded cell
incidence. For finite-energy coordinates F, F', Tonelli's theorem
gives
[
- int_{mathbb R^2}bbR^2 #{(e, e') : e sim e', e in S(F, s), e' in S(F', t)}, ds, dt
- = sum_{e sim e'} |dF(e)| cdot |dF'(e')|.
+ int_{R^2} #{(e, e') : e sim e', e in S(F, s), e' in S(F', t)}, ds, dt
+ = sum_{e sim e'} |dF(e)| · |dF'(e')|.
]
Cauchy--Schwarz bounds this by D |dF|_2 |dF'|_2 < ∞. Thus
almost every pair (s, t) has finitely many interacting pairs
@@ -789,7 +789,7 @@ their translates: still countable, still a basis, and still good
coordinates).
-Fix such an invariant countable basis and call it mathcal O.calO.
+Fix such an invariant countable basis and call it O.
## Coordinates distinguishing box components
@@ -799,7 +799,7 @@ combined). We add localized coordinates that record which
component of a box a vertex lies in.
[Localized coordinate]
-Fix O in mathcal O,calO, with conditions a_i < F_i < b_i for
+Fix O in O, with conditions a_i < F_i < b_i for
1 le i le m. Define the margin function
[
psi_O = max(0, min({1} cup {F_i - a_i : 1 le i le m}
@@ -810,16 +810,16 @@ takes values in [0, 1], and is positive exactly on the interior of
O. For each graph component U of O (there are finitely many by
Lemma~lem:good-boxes), define the localized coordinate
[
- h_{O, U} = psi_O cdot mathbf 1_Ubf1_U
+ h_{O, U} = psi_O · mathbf 1_Ubf1_U
]
-on vertices. Let mathcal FcalF be the family consisting of mathcal F_0calF_0
-and all of these localized coordinates, over all O in mathcal OcalO and
+on vertices. Let F be the family consisting of F_0
+and all of these localized coordinates, over all O in O and
all components U of O.
[Localized coordinates are finite energy with controlled cuts]
-Every member of mathcal FcalF has finite energy. For almost every
+Every member of F has finite energy. For almost every
t in (0, 1),
S(h_{O,U}, t) ⊆
@@ -866,10 +866,10 @@ of t where these coincide with vertex values, we get the inclusion
## The compact space X and its boundary B
We now assemble the compactification. Map each vertex v in Gamma to
-its profile (F(v))_{F in mathcal F}calF in [0,1]^{mathcal F}calF, and let
+its profile (F(v))_{F in F} in [0,1]^{F}, and let
X be the closure of these profiles in the product space
-[0,1]^{mathcal F}calF. The singleton indicators mathbf 1_bf1_{{v}} in
-mathcal FcalF make the profile map injective (the mathbf 1_bf1_{{v}}
+[0,1]^{F} The singleton indicators mathbf 1_bf1_{{v}} in
+F make the profile map injective (the mathbf 1_bf1_{{v}}
coordinate is 1 only at v), so we identify Gamma with its image
in X. They also make each vertex isolated in X: the set
{x in X : mathbf 1_bf1_{{v}}(x) > 1/2} is open in X and equals
@@ -879,15 +879,15 @@ Define the boundary B = X ∖ Gamma. Since Gamma is
open in X (each vertex isolated), B is closed in the compact space
X, hence compact.
-Every coordinate F in mathcal FcalF extends continuously to X (as the
+Every coordinate F in F extends continuously to X (as the
projection). The margin function psi_O also extends, through its
expression in base coordinates. Left translation by Gamma acts on
X by permuting coordinates; this makes the translation a
homeomorphism of X, since X is determined by the invariant family
-mathcal F.calF.
+F.
The metric rho. Enumerate
-mathcal FcalF = {F_1, F_2, F_3, ...} and choose
+F = {F_1, F_2, F_3, ...} and choose
c_j = 2^{-j}/(1 + |dF_j|_2) > 0. Then
sum_j c_j (1 + |dF_j|_2) = sum_j 2^{-j} = 1 < ∞. Define
@@ -899,11 +899,11 @@ The sum converges uniformly, so rho is a continuous metric inducing
the product topology on X. By Minkowski's inequality applied to finite
partial sums, followed by monotone convergence,
- |lambda|_{ell^2(E(G))} leq
+ |lambda|_{ell^2(E(G))} <=
sum_j c_j |dF_j|_2 < ∞.
Consequently, for any fixed ε > 0, only finitely many edges
-have rho-length geq ε (otherwise an infinite number of
+have rho-length >= ε (otherwise an infinite number of
edges each contribute ε^2, contradicting summability).
[The boundary is a nondegenerate continuum]
@@ -916,7 +916,7 @@ Proof.
Nonempty. A closed subset of X contained entirely in the
isolated vertices would be compact and discrete, hence finite. Since
Gamma is infinite, its closure contains points outside Gamma.
-So B neq ∅.
+So B != ∅.
Nondegenerate. If B = {x} for a single point x, then for
each ε > 0 the vertex set {v : |f(v) - f(x)| ge ε}
@@ -943,7 +943,7 @@ infinitely many in N_2.
Only finitely many graph edges join a vertex of N_1 to a vertex of
N_2: if infinitely many did, then infinitely many such edges would
-have length geq delta/2, contradicting (eq:edge-lengths).
+have length >= delta/2, contradicting (eq:edge-lengths).
Delete their vertices together with the finite set F. The remaining
graph has no path between the two sides: any path from N_1 to N_2
would either stay in X ∖ (N_1 cup N_2) (impossible: that
@@ -975,13 +975,13 @@ sup{rho(w, x) : w is a vertex of P_n} to 0.
Proof.
-Component identities. For a good box O in mathcal OcalO with its
+Component identities. For a good box O in O with its
finite component list U_1, ..., U_r, the following identities hold
on vertices:
[
sum_{j=1}^r h_{O, U_j} = psi_O,
- h_{O, U_i} h_{O, U_j} = 0 (i neq j).
+ h_{O, U_i} h_{O, U_j} = 0 (i != j).
]
By continuity they extend to all of X. Consequently, if
psi_O(x) > 0, exactly one component U_O(x) satisfies
@@ -995,7 +995,7 @@ are nonnegative, sum to psi_O).
Choice of a small feature. Shrink W to a neighborhood defined
by finitely many coordinate conditions, each with positive tolerance
around its value at x. The base coordinates give a continuous
-projection X to [0,1]^{mathcal F_0}calF_0. Choose a good basis box O'
+projection X to [0,1]^{F_0} Choose a good basis box O'
about the base profile of x small enough to have three properties,
stated verbatim below as (P1)--(P3):
[label=(Parabic*)]
@@ -1080,7 +1080,7 @@ rho on X and the edge-length function lambda(e) =
rho(e^-, e^+). From (eq:edge-lengths) we know
lambda in ell^2(E(G)).
-Standing notations: for a function F : X to mathbb RbbR and a regular
+Standing notations: for a function F : X to R and a regular
level t, S(F, t) is the set of edges whose endpoints lie on
opposite sides of t. Two edges are near if they are the same
edge or occur together on the boundary of a common 2-cell.
@@ -1117,7 +1117,7 @@ The square-summability controls how the level sets of any base
coordinate behave after translation.
[Translated cut lengths]
-For every base coordinate F in mathcal F_0calF_0 and every g in Gamma,
+For every base coordinate F in F_0 and every g in Gamma,
int_0^1 sum_{e in S(F, t)} sum_{e' near e}
lambda(ge') , dt
@@ -1128,7 +1128,7 @@ constant C, independent of g, F, t, such that for every dually
connected set D of edges,
diam_rho {gv : v is an endpoint of an edge of D}
- leq C sum_{e in D} sum_{e' near e} lambda(ge').
+ <= C sum_{e in D} sum_{e' near e} lambda(ge').
Moreover the sum of these diameter bounds over distinct dual components
is bounded by the same expression with their union in place of D.
@@ -1145,13 +1145,13 @@ Finiteness and vanishing. Define
a(e') = sum_{e : e' near e} |dF(e)|. Bounded incidence of
``near'' (uniformly in either variable, because each cell has bounded
size and bounded cell incidence) makes a in ell^2(E(G)) (Cauchy-Schwarz
-against the ell^2 function e mapsto |dF(e)| over the uniformly
+against the ell^2 function e |-> |dF(e)| over the uniformly
bounded neighborhoods). The right side of (eq:dyn-length) is
sum_{e'} a(e')lambda(ge'), finite by Cauchy-Schwarz. To see it
tends to zero as g to ∞, approximate a and lambda in
ell^2 by finitely supported functions: for finitely supported
a_0, lambda_0, the pairing sum_{e'} a_0(e')lambda_0(ge')
-vanishes for large g (the supports of a_0 and g cdot supp(lambda_0)
+vanishes for large g (the supports of a_0 and g · supp(lambda_0)
are eventually disjoint), and Cauchy-Schwarz controls the error.
Diameter bound (eq:dyn-dual-diameter.) Fix a dually
@@ -1172,7 +1172,7 @@ with C = C'. Summing over dual components gives the last claim.
[Collapse of translated cuts]
-Suppose g_n to a in B. Given finitely many coordinates from mathcal F,calF,
+Suppose g_n to a in B. Given finitely many coordinates from F,
there is a subsequence such that, for almost every level of each
coordinate, all endpoints of the g_n-translated straddling set tend
uniformly to a. If also g_n^{-1} to b in B, the subsequence can
@@ -1395,7 +1395,7 @@ and cancels its finite coboundary there.
## Thin walls and covering dimension
-For a coordinate F in mathcal FcalF and a regular level t, let
+For a coordinate F in F and a regular level t, let
P(F,t) be the set of endpoints of edges in S(F,t), and put
[
E(F,t) = P(F,t)bar cap B.
@@ -1404,9 +1404,9 @@ In words: E(F,t) is the part of B near which the cut S(F,t)
accumulates. All closures and diameters use the metric rho on X.
[Walls have measure zero]
-For every coordinate F in mathcal F,calF, the compact set E(F,t) has
-mathcal H^1_calH^1_rho-measure zero for almost every t in (0,1); here
-mathcal H^1_calH^1_rho is one-dimensional Hausdorff measure with respect
+For every coordinate F in F, the compact set E(F,t) has
+H^1_-measure zero for almost every t in (0,1); here
+H^1_ is one-dimensional Hausdorff measure with respect
to rho.
@@ -1441,7 +1441,7 @@ accumulation. The sum of their diameters is at most
→ 0.
]
So the maximum diameter tends to zero, and these finite covers prove
-mathcal H^1_calH^1_rho(E(F,t)) = 0.
+H^1_,t)) = 0.
Localized coordinates. A localized coordinate's straddling set
is contained in a finite union of base-coordinate walls at the shifted
@@ -1454,7 +1454,7 @@ preserve null sets. The result follows.
[Covering dimension at most one]
-The boundary B has covering dimension dim B leq 1: it admits
+The boundary B has covering dimension dim B <= 1: it admits
arbitrarily fine finite open covers of multiplicity at most two.
@@ -1462,11 +1462,11 @@ Proof.
Choose a finite grid of levels in finitely many coordinates, each level
avoiding vertex values and satisfying Lemma~lem:topo-thin-walls.
Let E = ∪ E(F_i, t_i) be the union of the corresponding wall
-accumulation sets. It is compact and has mathcal H^1_calH^1_rho-measure
+accumulation sets. It is compact and has H^1_-measure
zero.
E has small clopen partitions. Fix x in E. The distance map
-y mapsto rho(x,y) is Lipschitz, so its image on E has Lebesgue
+y |-> rho(x,y) is Lipschitz, so its image on E has Lebesgue
measure zero. Hence there are arbitrarily small positive radii r
with the sphere of radius r about x disjoint from E. The sets
E cap B_rho(x,r) are then clopen (both closed and open) in E.
@@ -1501,7 +1501,7 @@ sign-tuple sets are disjoint from each other and from a neighborhood
of E near each point of E): so the cover has multiplicity at most
two. A Lebesgue number for any prescribed finite open cover shows that
a sufficiently fine cover of this form refines it. This is exactly
-dim B leq 1.
+dim B <= 1.
## Cech cohomology vanishes
@@ -1513,7 +1513,7 @@ replace Cech cohomology by singular cohomology on the possibly
nonlocally-connected boundary.
[Cech cohomology vanishes]
-With coefficients k = mathbb F_2bbF_2 one has
+With coefficients k = F_2 one has
check H^1(B; k) = 0.
@@ -1531,7 +1531,7 @@ rho(b(u), x) le 2rho(u,x) to 0, so all labels occurring
sufficiently near x contain a fixed neighborhood of x in B.
Step 2 (cellular cochain). Define a cellular 1-cochain on
-mathcal CcalC by
+C by
[
alpha(uv) = d_{i(u) i(v)}
]
@@ -1550,8 +1550,8 @@ no difficulty: the identity is a cellular sum, and d_{ii} = 0.
Step 3 (group-ring cocycle). We explain why omega represents
a group 2-cocycle. Start a free kGamma-resolution with the
-cellular chains of mathcal CcalC through degree two. This is possible
-because mathcal CcalC is simply connected: choose a free module mapping
+cellular chains of C through degree two. This is possible
+because C is simply connected: choose a free module mapping
onto ker ∂_2, then free modules onto successive kernels. For
any finite-support scalar cellular cochain omega, the formula
[
@@ -1572,7 +1572,7 @@ ker ∂_2 and is a cocycle on the extended free resolution.
Lemma~lem:found-duality gives H^2(Gamma; kGamma) = 0, so
there is a module 1-cochain whose coboundary is Phi_omega. Taking
identity coefficients gives a finite-support scalar 1-cochain eta
-with deta = dalpha. Ordinary simple connectivity of mathcal CcalC
+with deta = dalpha. Ordinary simple connectivity of C
then supplies a scalar function l on its vertices with
[
alpha - eta = dl.
@@ -1606,7 +1606,7 @@ cocycle is the coboundary of the assignment a to the corresponding
cover member. Its Cech class vanishes.
-We have shown dim B leq 1 and check H^1(B; k) = 0. These alone
+We have shown dim B <= 1 and check H^1(B; k) = 0. These alone
do not ensure local connectivity. The next steps isolate a continuum
L subset B without cut points carrying the same properties, and then
prove local connectivity by pushing graph paths toward the boundary.
@@ -1855,7 +1855,7 @@ sim_beta-class of x is invariant, contradicting minimality of
alpha.
Higher successor case. Suppose alpha = beta + 1 with
-beta geq 1. Let Xi subset Phi be an invariant
+beta >= 1. Let Xi subset Phi be an invariant
sim_alpha-class. Its sim_beta-classes form a simplicial tree
Σ = Xi / sim_beta. The action on this tree has no fixed
vertex by minimality of alpha.
@@ -1879,12 +1879,12 @@ x = med(p, y, gamma y). Fullness gives x in [y,gamma y]
subset U; both x and gamma x lie in the linearly ordered interval
[p,gamma y]. If x = gamma x, done. Otherwise, replacing
(gamma, x) by (gamma^{-1}, gamma x) if necessary, we get
-x in (p, gamma x). The intervals [p, gamma^n x], n geq 0, are
+x in (p, gamma x). The intervals [p, gamma^n x], n >= 0, are
then strictly increasing. Their union is a full directed arc with
first point p and no last point. Completeness gives an endpoint z
with
- ∪_{n geq 0} [p, gamma^n x] = [p, z).
+ ∪_{n >= 0} [p, gamma^n x] = [p, z).
The endpoint is unique in a median pretree
cite[Lemma~3.13]{Bowditch1999Treelike}. The union in
@@ -1923,15 +1923,15 @@ assertion of the lemma.
[Tree of cut points]
Let (Gamma 0)--(Gamma 3) hold and suppose P ne ∅.
Then there is a nontrivial minimal simplicial Gamma-tree
-mathcal TcalT with no edge inversions and finite quotient, such that:
+T with no edge inversions and finite quotient, such that:
[label=(roman*)]
P is an invariant subset of its vertices, and every edge has
one endpoint in P and one outside;
- mathcal TcalT is spanned by P; its other vertices have degree
+ T is spanned by P; its other vertices have degree
at least two;
every edge stabilizer is infinite;
if a, b, q in P and q separates a and b in B, then
- q in [a,b]_{mathcal T}calT.
+ q in [a,b]_{T}
Every point of P is fixed by an infinite-order parabolic element.
@@ -1951,24 +1951,24 @@ sides are nonempty open subsets, so each meets Gamma p. For orbit
points a,b on opposite sides, separation gives q in [a,b]_Phi.
Since C is full, q in C.
-mathcal TcalT spanned by P. Let mathcal TcalT be the subtree of
+T spanned by P. Let T be the subtree of
C spanned by P (union of intervals between points). Its intervals
agree with those of Phi, so it retains the separation compatibility
(iv). Adjacency in Proposition~prop:pret-package(i) gives the
bipartition P, and forbids edge inversions. A vertex outside P
cannot be a leaf of a tree spanned by P.
-Minimality. Let mathcal ScalS subset mathcal TcalT nonempty
+Minimality. Let S subset T nonempty
invariant subtree. A single vertex would be a fixed point of Phi,
-excluded. Otherwise mathcal ScalS contains an edge, hence a point of P.
-Its orbit is again dense; separation gives P subset mathcal S.calS.
-So mathcal ScalS = mathcal T.calT.
+excluded. Otherwise S contains an edge, hence a point of P.
+Its orbit is again dense; separation gives P subset S.
+So S = T.
Finite quotient. Choose a base vertex o and a finite
generating set S for Gamma. The union of the finite paths
[o,so], s in S, is a finite subtree after adjoining o. Its
translates form a connected invariant subtree, hence cover
-mathcal TcalT by minimality. So the quotient has finitely many vertex
+T by minimality. So the quotient has finitely many vertex
and edge orbits.
Infinite edge stabilizers. If an edge had finite stabilizer,
@@ -1985,7 +1985,7 @@ The parabolic assertion is Lemma~lem:pret-parabolic-cuts.
%=============================================================
-We have seen that B always has dim leq 1 and
+We have seen that B always has dim <= 1 and
check H^1 = 0 (Propositions~prop:topo-dimension,
prop:topo-cech). We now show that B always contains a
nondegenerate subcontinuum L without cut points that retains
@@ -1993,25 +1993,25 @@ these two properties, is a retract of B, and comes equipped with the
graph-theoretic structure needed for path pushing.
If B has no cut points, we just take L = B; the case is simple.
-Otherwise we use the tree mathcal TcalT from Section~sec:pretree
+Otherwise we use the tree T from Section~sec:pretree
to extract one of its "leaf blocks".
## The setup
Assume P ne ∅ for the rest of this subsection. The tree
-mathcal TcalT from Proposition~prop:pret-tree is bipartite between
+T from Proposition~prop:pret-tree is bipartite between
P and the remaining vertices; every edge has a P-endpoint and a
-non-P-endpoint. Choose any vertex r in mathcal TcalT ∖ P
+non-P-endpoint. Choose any vertex r in T ∖ P
and set
[
- R = {p in P : p is adjacent to r in mathcal TcalT},
+ R = {p in P : p is adjacent to r in T},
- H = Gamma(r) leq Gamma.
+ H = Gamma(r) <= Gamma.
]
Here Gamma(r) is the stabilizer of r.
-Since mathcal TcalT is spanned by P, a non-P vertex cannot be a leaf,
-so |R| geq 2. For distinct a,b in R, the tree interval is a - r -
+Since T is spanned by P, a non-P vertex cannot be a leaf,
+so |R| >= 2. For distinct a,b in R, the tree interval is a - r -
b. By Proposition~prop:pret-tree(iv), no cut point of B
separates a and b.
@@ -2024,7 +2024,7 @@ a - r - b for any two distinct a, b in R.
[Graph on P]
There is a connected Gamma-graph K^* with vertex set P and
finitely many edge orbits such that the endpoints of every edge have
-tree-distance two in mathcal T.calT. The graph K obtained by
+tree-distance two in T. The graph K obtained by
restricting K^* to R is connected with finitely many H-orbits of
vertices and edges.
@@ -2036,7 +2036,7 @@ of K is infinite.
Proof.
-Constructing K^*. The finite quotient of mathcal TcalT
+Constructing K^*. The finite quotient of T
(Proposition~prop:pret-tree) gives finitely many Gamma-orbits
in P. Choose representatives p_0, ..., p_k of P-orbits and a
finite symmetric generating set S of Gamma. Start with the graph
@@ -2050,18 +2050,18 @@ p_0. It has finitely many edge orbits.
Replace each edge by the consecutive pairs of P-vertices along
the tree interval between its endpoints. These tree intervals are
-finite (they are between P-points in mathcal T).calT). The replacement
+finite (they are between P-points in T). The replacement
is equivariant. So the resulting K^* is still connected, has finitely
many edge orbits, and the endpoints of every edge are at tree-distance
two.
Projection properties. Let a s b be an edge of K^* with
-midpoint s (so a, s, b are collinear in mathcal TcalT and s is the
+midpoint s (so a, s, b are collinear in T and s is the
midpoint of the interval a-b). Two cases:
s = r: then a, b in R and pi(a) = a, pi(b) = b — the
edge is fixed by pi.
s ne r: then a and b lie in the same component of
- mathcal TcalT ∖ {r}, so they have the same neighbor on the
+ T ∖ {r}, so they have the same neighbor on the
path to r, i.e. pi(a) = pi(b) — the edge collapses.
This shows: projecting a path between two members of R and deleting
@@ -2143,9 +2143,9 @@ the identity on L. Moreover:
[
L is a nondegenerate continuum without cut points,
- dim L leq 1,
+ dim L <= 1,
- check H^1(L; mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0.
+ check H^1(L; F_2) = 0.
]
@@ -2188,14 +2188,14 @@ continuity it contains (q,q) for every q in L).
Continuum properties. B is connected and L is its
continuous image, so L is connected. R has at least two points,
so L is nondegenerate. Since L is closed in the compact metric
-space B, it is compact metric, and dim L le dim B leq 1.
+space B, it is compact metric, and dim L le dim B <= 1.
Čech cohomology of L. Let i : L ↪ B be the
inclusion. Then mathfrak rfrakr circ i = id_L. Functoriality of
Čech cohomology gives i^* mathfrak r^*frakr^* =
-id_{check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)}bbF_2). So mathfrak r^*frakr^* injects
-check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) into check H^1(B;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0.
-Thus check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0.
+id_{check H^1(L;F_2)} So mathfrak r^*frakr^* injects
+check H^1(L;F_2) into check H^1(B;F_2) = 0.
+Thus check H^1(L;F_2) = 0.
L has no cut points. Suppose toward contradiction that q in L
is a cut point of L: L ∖ {q} = U sqcup V with U, V
@@ -2230,13 +2230,13 @@ that the path-pushing argument uses. In the P = ∅ case we
just take L = B and the original graph.
[Setting for path pushing]
-There are a subgroup H leq Gamma, a compact space
+There are a subgroup H <= Gamma, a compact space
Y = H sqcup L (with the metric rho inherited from X), and a
connected H-graph K with vertex set I ⊆ Y, such that:
[label=(arabic*)]
Y = Hbar^{,X}; the points of H are isolated in Y;
L is a nondegenerate continuum without cut points satisfying
- dim L leq 1 and check H^1(L; mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0.
+ dim L <= 1 and check H^1(L; F_2) = 0.
If h_n to a in L and h_n^{-1} to b in L, then h_n
converges to the constant map a, uniformly on compact subsets of
Y ∖ {b}.
@@ -2333,8 +2333,8 @@ Standing assumptions from Proposition~prop:block-setting: we
have a compact metric space Y = H sqcup L (with metric rho), a
group H acting on Y by homeomorphisms extending left multiplication,
H-points isolated, and L a nondegenerate continuum without cut
-points satisfying dim L leq 1 and check H^1(L;k) = 0, where
-k = mathbb F_2.bbF_2. The action satisfies the convergence action
+points satisfying dim L <= 1 and check H^1(L;k) = 0, where
+k = F_2. The action satisfies the convergence action
property (2). We also have a connected H-graph K with vertex set
I ⊆ Y, where I = H or I ⊆ L, with finitely many
H-orbits of vertices and edges, satisfying the near-path property
@@ -2488,12 +2488,12 @@ sigma_n uses distinct annuli. A chain goes from F to E if
F ⊆ sigma_1^- and E ⊆ sigma_n^+.
[Annulus system]
-There is a set mathcal AcalA of annuli invariant under H and under
+There is a set A of annuli invariant under H and under
interchange of the two sides, with:
- For every delta > 0, only finitely many annuli in mathcal AcalA
+ For every delta > 0, only finitely many annuli in A
have both sides of diameter at least delta.
For every closed F ⊆ Y, every x in L ∖ F, and
-every integer n geq 1, there is a chain of n annuli in mathcal AcalA
+every integer n >= 1, there is a chain of n annuli in A
from F to some neighborhood of x in Y.
@@ -2532,7 +2532,7 @@ L is at distance ge diam(L)/2 from some point of
L (extreme points of a diameter). The sides cannot cover L: their
nonempty closed intersections with L would disconnect it.
-Let mathcal AcalA consist of all distinct translates of these annuli and
+Let A consist of all distinct translates of these annuli and
their reversals.
Diameter bound. A ball of radius r_i/4 cannot meet both sides
@@ -2567,11 +2567,11 @@ neighborhood of x. Repeating gives any prescribed finite length.
## Depth
-Fix such an annulus system mathcal A.calA. For F ⊆ Y and
+Fix such an annulus system A. For F ⊆ Y and
v in Y, define
[
- D(F, v) = sup{n geq 1 :
- a chain of length n in mathcal AcalA
+ D(F, v) = sup{n >= 1 :
+ a chain of length n in A
goes from F to {v}},
]
with D = 0 if no such chain exists. In general D in {0, 1, 2,
@@ -2585,8 +2585,8 @@ For g in H, F ⊆ Y, and v in Y,
]
If F contains a point of H and v in H, then D(F, v) is finite.
When it is positive, a chain attains this maximum. If F is closed,
-x in L ∖ F, and N geq 1, then there is a neighborhood
-V_N of x in Y with D(F, v) geq N for every v in V_N.
+x in L ∖ F, and N >= 1, then there is a neighborhood
+V_N of x in Y with D(F, v) >= N for every v in V_N.
Proof.
@@ -2598,7 +2598,7 @@ closed and does not contain h or v (points of H are not in L),
the number delta = min{dist(h, L),
dist(v, L)} is positive. Throughout a chain from F
to v: every negative side contains h and meets L, every positive
-side contains v and meets L. So both sides have diameter geq
+side contains v and meets L. So both sides have diameter >=
delta. Lemma~lem:ann-system(1) supplies only finitely many such
annuli, and a strict chain cannot repeat an annulus. So D(F, v) is
finite.
@@ -2619,7 +2619,7 @@ resulting terminal neighborhood of x.
We work in the setting of Proposition~prop:block-setting: a
compact metric space Y = H sqcup L, an H-graph K on I
-⊆ Y, and the annulus system mathcal AcalA from
+⊆ Y, and the annulus system A from
Lemma~lem:ann-system. Our goal: prove L is locally connected.
The idea: fix a closed set A containing 1 and avoiding L, and
@@ -2638,12 +2638,12 @@ ne ∅. Write
[
d_0 = dist(1, L) > 0,
- N(a, b) = #{sigma in mathcal AcalA :
+ N(a, b) = #{sigma in A :
diamsigma^- ge a,
diamsigma^+ ge b},
]
which is finite by Lemma~lem:ann-system(1). Any side containing
-1 has diameter geq d_0 (every side meets L).
+1 has diameter >= d_0 (every side meets L).
[Shrinking toward the boundary]
Let g_n in H satisfy D(A, g_n) to ∞ and set F_n =
@@ -2693,7 +2693,7 @@ F_n and a point outside U, so has diameter ge r/2. Its positive
side has diameter ge d_0. There are at most N_- = N(r/2, d_0)
such annuli. Because negative sides increase along a chain, those
form a terminal segment. Remove that segment and one further annulus.
-The retained initial chain has geq ell - N_- - 1 members. The
+The retained initial chain has >= ell - N_- - 1 members. The
negative side of the next annulus lies in U, so the last retained
positive side contains Y ∖ U. In particular, the retained
chain already ends on the side containing any b under consideration.
@@ -2706,7 +2706,7 @@ distance le 2r from q, hence diameter ge r. Every negative
side contains 1, hence diameter ge d_0. So at most N_+ =
N(d_0, r) positive sides fail to lie in V; those form an initial
segment. If t > N_+ + 1, remove this initial segment and one further
-annulus. The retained final chain has geq t - N_+ - 1 members, and
+annulus. The retained final chain has >= t - N_+ - 1 members, and
its first negative side contains Y ∖ V.
Concatenate. Since U cap V = ∅, the last positive
@@ -2729,10 +2729,10 @@ contains b_n, so D({1}, b_n) to ∞.
Choose one representative p_i for each H-orbit in I; when I=H,
use only p_1 = 1. For u in the orbit of p_i, define its set of
representatives C(u) = {g in H : g p_i = u}. For integers
-m geq 0 define the deep vertex set
+m >= 0 define the deep vertex set
I_m = {u in I ∖ A :
- min_{g in C(u)} D(A, g) geq m}.
+ min_{g in C(u)} D(A, g) >= m}.
Each depth in the minimum is a finite nonnegative integer (by
Lemma~lem:ann-depth: A contains 1 in H, so there is a
@@ -2757,7 +2757,7 @@ this label. For every finite E subset I, one has E cap I_m =
Proof.
No accumulation. For m=0, the assertion follows from
-I_0 = I ∖ A. Suppose m geq 1 and distinct u_n in
+I_0 = I ∖ A. Suppose m >= 1 and distinct u_n in
I ∖ I_m to x in L ∖ A. Eventually u_n notin A,
so choose a_n in C(u_n) with D(A, a_n) < m. Since there are only
finitely many orbit representatives and u_n are distinct, a_n
@@ -2777,13 +2777,13 @@ from I_m.
[Translated deletions stay bounded]
-Let m_n to ∞ and D(A, g_n) geq m_n. Pass to a subsequence
+Let m_n to ∞ and D(A, g_n) >= m_n. Pass to a subsequence
with F_n = g_n^{-1} A to {q}, q in L.
For every compact E subset Y ∖ {q} there is a finite
S_E subset I and an index n_E with
[
E cap g_n^{-1}(I ∖ I_{m_n + 1}) ⊆ S_E
- (n geq n_E).
+ (n >= n_E).
]
@@ -2799,7 +2799,7 @@ orbit representative, w_n = b_n p_i. Distinctness forces b_n to
escape finite sets, and comparison gives b_n to z ne q.
Lemma~lem:push-depth-comparison then yields
[
- D(F_n, b_n) geq m_n + D({1}, b_n) - C > m_n + 1
+ D(F_n, b_n) >= m_n + D({1}, b_n) - C > m_n + 1
]
for large n, contradiction.
@@ -2819,7 +2819,7 @@ Choose a neighborhood O of z in Y whose closure misses q.
Apply Lemma~lem:push-translated-deletions to the compact
E = overlineoverline O.O. There are finite S subset I and index n_0 with
T = (I cap O) ∖ S satisfying g_n T ⊆ I_{m_n+1}
-for all n geq n_0. The deleted vertices I ∖ T have no
+for all n >= n_0. The deleted vertices I ∖ T have no
distinct accumulation at any point of O cap L.
Lemma~lem:ann-component gives a neighborhood V_z subset O cap L
on which the component of K[T] approached by vertices is constant;
@@ -2896,7 +2896,7 @@ j to +∞.
Fix the threshold M from Lemma~lem:push-majority for this list.
[Refinement does not split labels]
-For every m geq M and all x, y in L ∖ A,
+For every m >= M and all x, y in L ∖ A,
Q_m(x) = Q_m(y) ⇒ Q_{m+1}(x) = Q_{m+1}(y).
@@ -2910,7 +2910,7 @@ g in C(v),
J_m(g) = Q_{m+1}(v).
Let v = g p_i. For every j ge 0, g h_i^j in C(v). The minimum
-in (eq:push-deep-vertices) gives D(A, g h_i^j) geq m for every
+in (eq:push-deep-vertices) gives D(A, g h_i^j) >= m for every
j. The move h_i in S and Lemma~lem:push-majority give
[
J_m(g) = J_m(g h_i) = J_m(g h_i^2) = ....
@@ -2933,7 +2933,7 @@ Q_{m+1}); a path in that component proves
Case 2: I = H. Only one representative p_1 = 1, and
C(v) = {v}. The finite edge moves and Lemma~lem:push-majority
imply J_m is constant along paths of K[I_m]. For x in L
-∖ A and m geq M fixed, claim that J_m(g) = Q_{m+1}(x)
+∖ A and m >= M fixed, claim that J_m(g) = Q_{m+1}(x)
for all group vertices g sufficiently near x. These vertices lie
in I_m when sufficiently near x by
Lemma~lem:push-component-labels. If the claim fails, take
@@ -2996,7 +2996,7 @@ If C were disconnected, write it as a disjoint union of nonempty
compact C_0, C_1 with distance delta > 0. For large m, P_m
lies in the disjoint union of delta/3-neighborhoods of C_0, C_1
and meets both. A path in these vertices then has two consecutive
-vertices in different neighborhoods, at distance geq delta/3.
+vertices in different neighborhoods, at distance >= delta/3.
This contradicts the mesh assertion. So C is connected.
Conclusion. C is a connected subset of overlineoverline OO cap L
@@ -3012,17 +3012,17 @@ is local connectivity.
%=============================================================
We now have: a nondegenerate compact metric continuum L that is
-locally connected, has dim L leq 1, and has
-check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0. This section extracts a contradiction.
+locally connected, has dim L <= 1, and has
+check H^1(L;F_2) = 0. This section extracts a contradiction.
-The idea: locally connected + dim leq 1 + no circle forces L to be
+The idea: locally connected + dim <= 1 + no circle forces L to be
a dendrite; every nondegenerate dendrite has a cut point; but L has
none. Contradiction.
## Two lemmas we need
[Cohomology of closed subsets]
-If Z is a compact metric space with dim Z leq 1, A subset Z
+If Z is a compact metric space with dim Z <= 1, A subset Z
closed, and k is an abelian coefficient group, then restriction
induces a surjection
[
@@ -3034,18 +3034,18 @@ Proof.
Represent a class on A by a cocycle d on the nerve of a finite
relative open cover {V_i} of A. Choose open sets W_i subset Z
with W_i cap A = V_i. The cover {W_i} cup {Z ∖ A} of
-Z has a finite open refinement mathcal UcalU of multiplicity at most
-two (that's dim Z leq 1). Its nerve N(mathcal U)calU) is therefore a
+Z has a finite open refinement U of multiplicity at most
+two (that's dim Z <= 1). Its nerve N(U) is therefore a
graph.
-Restrict mathcal UcalU to A: keep the indices of the cover members,
+Restrict U to A: keep the indices of the cover members,
even if two restrictions coincide. After empty restrictions are
-discarded, the nerve N(mathcal U|_A)calU|_A) is a subgraph of
-N(mathcal U).calU). A refinement map pulls the original cocycle d back
+discarded, the nerve N(U|_A)calU|_A) is a subgraph of
+N(U). A refinement map pulls the original cocycle d back
to a 1-cochain on this subgraph.
Extend that 1-cochain by zero on every remaining edge of
-N(mathcal U).calU). Since N(mathcal U)calU) is a graph (a 1-dimensional
+N(U). Since N(U) is a graph (a 1-dimensional
complex, no 2-simplices), the extension is automatically a
1-cocycle. Its Čech class in check H^1(Z;k) restricts to the
prescribed class on A.
@@ -3076,30 +3076,30 @@ a in W_1, b in W_m, and W_i cap W_{i+1} ne ∅. We
may arrange m ge 2 by repeating a member.
Iterative subdivision. Starting with [0,1], U, and endpoints
-a, b, construct finite interval partitions mathcal P_ncalP_n as follows.
-For each I in mathcal P_n,calP_n, associate a connected open set V_I
+a, b, construct finite interval partitions P_n as follows.
+For each I in P_n, associate a connected open set V_I
containing its already-assigned endpoint values, with
-diam V_I leq 2^{-n} (for n geq 1). Inside V_I,
+diam V_I <= 2^{-n} (for n >= 1). Inside V_I,
take the finite chain above with closures in V_I and diameters
-leq 2^{-(n+1)}. Subdivide I into m equal pieces and associate
+<= 2^{-(n+1)}. Subdivide I into m equal pieces and associate
these to the chain members. At each new division point assign a point
of the corresponding consecutive intersection. Keep the old endpoint
values. Successive assignments agree at shared endpoints, and both
endpoints of every child interval lie in its associated set.
Construction. Every subdivision has at least two children, so
-mesh(mathcal P_n)calP_n) leq 2^{-n}. The set D of all
+mesh(P_n) <= 2^{-n}. The set D of all
partition endpoints is therefore dense in [0,1], and the compatible
assignments define f:D to L. Nesting ensures f(D cap I) subset
-V_I for every I in mathcal P_n.calP_n.
+V_I for every I in P_n.
Uniform continuity. For fixed n ge 1, let delta_n be the
-minimum length of a cell of mathcal P_n.calP_n. If s, t in D and
+minimum length of a cell of P_n. If s, t in D and
|s - t| < delta_n, they lie in the same or adjacent cells. Both
cases give d(f(s), f(t)) le 2^{1-n}. So f is uniformly continuous
and extends continuously to [0,1] by completeness of L.
-Path stays in U. For each cell I in mathcal P_1,calP_1, the
+Path stays in U. For each cell I in P_1, the
extended image lies in V_Ibar subset U. The full path
therefore lies in U, and its endpoints are a, b.
@@ -3111,7 +3111,7 @@ therefore lies in U, and its endpoints are a, b.
Every nondegenerate locally connected compact metric continuum L
with
[
- dim L leq 1, check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0
+ dim L <= 1, check H^1(L;F_2) = 0
]
has a cut point.
@@ -3120,9 +3120,9 @@ Proof.
L contains no embedded circle. Suppose C subset L were an
embedded circle S^1. It is closed in L. Lemma~lem:end-restriction
gives a surjection
-check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) to check H^1(C;mathbb F_2).bbF_2). But the left
-side is zero while the right side is mathbb F_2bbF_2 (a circle has first
-Čech cohomology mathbb F_2).bbF_2). Contradiction.
+check H^1(L;F_2) to check H^1(C;F_2). But the left
+side is zero while the right side is F_2 (a circle has first
+Čech cohomology F_2). Contradiction.
Choose an arc. A locally connected compact metric continuum is a
Peano continuum. The theory of Peano continua (via Moore's
@@ -3149,15 +3149,15 @@ Proof. [Proof of Theorem~thm:main]
Suppose b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q) > 0. By the finite-energy construction
(Sections~sec:compactification--sec:dynamics) and the
boundary topology (Section~sec:boundary-topology) we have built a
-nondegenerate compact metric continuum B with dim B leq 1 and
-check H^1(B;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0.
+nondegenerate compact metric continuum B with dim B <= 1 and
+check H^1(B;F_2) = 0.
If B has no cut points, set L = B; the reduction of
Proposition~prop:block-setting (with P = ∅) applies
directly. Otherwise, use Section~sec:pretree and
Section~sec:blocks to isolate a subcontinuum L subset B without
-cut points, still nondegenerate, still with dim L leq 1 and
-check H^1(L;mathbb F_2)bbF_2) = 0. In both cases,
+cut points, still nondegenerate, still with dim L <= 1 and
+check H^1(L;F_2) = 0. In both cases,
Proposition~prop:push-local-connected gives local connectivity of
L.
@@ -3171,7 +3171,7 @@ Therefore b_1^{(2)}(widetilde Q) = 0. Lemma~lem:found-reduction
gives b_0^{(2)} = b_4^{(2)} = 0, b_3^{(2)} = b_1^{(2)} = 0, and
vanishing in all degrees above four. Its duality argument includes
nontrivial orientation characters. Consequently
-b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;mathcal N(calN(Gamma)) = 0 for every p ge 0
+b_p^{(2)}(widetilde Q;N( = 0 for every p ge 0
with p ne 2.
@@ -3226,8 +3226,8 @@ chi = 4(g-1)(h-1) > 0. On the other hand the four-torus is a flat
aspherical four-manifold with chi = 0.
For an oriented closed four-manifold M, let sigma(M) be the
-signature of the intersection form on H^2(M;mathbb R)bbR) (equivalently,
-on H_2(M;mathbb R)bbR) via Poincaré duality).
+signature of the intersection form on H^2(M;R) (equivalently,
+on H_2(M;R) via Poincaré duality).
[Euler-signature inequality]
Every closed connected oriented aspherical topological four-manifold
@@ -3262,7 +3262,7 @@ finite-index normal subgroups with ∩_i Gamma_i = {1}. Let
Q_i to Q be the associated finite covers. For every p ge 0,
[
lim_{i to ∞}
- (b_p(Q_i;mathbb Q))/([bbQ))/([Gamma : Gamma_i])
+ (b_p(Q_i;Q))/([bbQ))/([Gamma : Gamma_i])
=
chi(Q), & p = 2,
0, & p ne 2.