editors: nobody
newcommand{src}[1]{parsmallskipnoindent{footnotesize #1}}
parmedskipnoindentStrategy of the proof.
The proof follows one strategy. Fix a hypothetical concentration point
where curvature blows up at T. Successive rescalings produce a finite
tree of Ricci-flat limits; the outermost nonflat limit defines a scale
a(t) that cannot change by any fixed factor on short intervals. On the
corresponding buffered intervals, parabolic rescaling places the Ricci
energy K of the outermost bubble in a limiting spacetime where the
renormalized Einstein--Hilbert functional and the companion tree ineuality
force Kto 0; that pins a(t) and rules out the concentration point.
The mechanics are in four blocks. Block~I (``The spatial curvature
radius'' to ``Buffered intervals'') estimates curvature at all scales,
describes the slice limits, and selects the buffered intervals. Block~II
(``Concentration estimates'' to ``The maximal function'') bounds the Ricci
heat equation and the root energy. Block~III (``Collar extension'')
builds and estimates the analytic exterior from a fixed collar. Block~IV
(``Functional change and the contradiction'' to ``Continuation'') supplies
the lower and upper bounds on the functional variation and closes the
argument. A reader focused on the main idea should read Blocks~I and
IV first, treating Block~III as a black box for the error analysis.
parmedskipnoindentIntroduction.
A Ricci flow is a one-parameter family of Riemannian metrics solving the
heat-type equation
∂_t g=-2Ric(g).
On a closed manifold it exists and is smooth for a short time; the central
question is what makes the maximal smooth existence time T<∞ finite.
The full curvature tensor decides this: if |Rm| stays bounded on [0,T),
the flow continues past T (Hamilton, 1982). The scalar curvature
R=tr_gRic is only a trace, so a bound on R is far weaker; it controls
volume by ∂_t,dmu_g=-R,dmu_g but leaves the full geometry free.
The scalar-curvature extension problem asks whether a uniform bound on R
alone already forbids a finite-time singularity. The answer is affirmative
in real dimension four.
src{pdf: https://doi.org/10.4310/jdg/1214436922}
[Smooth extension]
Let M be a closed connected smooth four-manifold, 0<T<∞, and let
g(t), 0le t<T, be a smooth Ricci flow from smooth initial metric with
sup_{Mtimes[0,T)}|R(g(t))|<∞. Then there are ε>0 and a
smooth Ricci flow widetilde g on M for 0le t<T+ε with
widetilde g(t)=g(t) for all t<T.
Let g(t), 0le t<T<∞, be a smooth Ricci flow on a closed four-manifold
with finite maximal smooth existence time T. Then
limsup_{t↑ T}max_MR(g(t))=+∞.
Proof.
(∂_t-Delta)R=2|Ric|^2ge0 and the maximum principle bound R below
on any finite interval. A finite upper limit would bound |R| near T; since
R is smooth on the compact initial part, Theorem~thm:extension applied
componentwise would contradict maximality of T.
The proof rules out contraction of a specific outermost bubble scale. A
concentration point produces a finite rooted tree of Ricci-flat limits, one for
each scale at which curvature blows up; the outermost nonflat limit has a
length a(t) that is positive before T but tends to zero at the singular
time. On short intervals a cannot change by a fixed factor: rescaling would
freeze the pointed geometry, so any fixed-factor change would contradict the
identity of a fixed limiting tree. Parabolic rescaling on the buffered
intervals therefore produces a limiting spacetime in which the Ricci energy K
of the outermost bubble is comparable from start to end. The renormalized
Einstein--Hilbert functional computed on that scaling, together with a sharp
ineuality from the companion paper, forces Kto0. But Kto0 means
distances are preserved on the concentration scale, which pins a(t) and
contradicts its prescribed finite change. Hence no concentration point exists
and the flow extends smoothly.
parmedskipnoindentThe geometric obstruction.
Hamilton proved short-time existence; v{S}ev{s}um showed a uniform bound on
Ric forces continuation. A scalar
bound is weaker because after rescaling a would-be singularity the scalar
curvature can tend to zero while full curvature stays bounded away from zero.
The limit is then Ricci-flat without being flat, so a scalar bound permits a
whole tree of collapsing Ricci-flat bubbles.
src{pdf: pdf/src-sesum2005.pdf (Curvature tensor under the Ricci flow)}
Bamler--Zhang proved the heat-kernel and curvature estimates under scalar
bounds, including the four-dimensional energy and compactness theory used
below, and obtained smooth extension when H_2(M;F)=0 for all
F, Corollary~1.10 of the first part. Simon continued through the
limiting space by an orbifold flow; Bamler's convergence theory gives smooth
convergence off a codimension-four set; Liu--Simon treat four-dimensional
convergence under scalar-integrability hypotheses. All allow
concentrated curvature and orbifold points; the continuation below instead
keeps the given flow on its original manifold. Blow-up is known for
K"ahler--Ricci flows (Zhang), for global Type~I singularities (Enders,
M"uller and Topping), and for local Type~I points (Buzano and Di Matteo);
no rate is imposed.
src{pdf: pdf/src-bamlerzhang2017.pdf (Bamler and Zhang, Heat kernel and curvature bounds in Ricci flows with bounded scalar curvature)}
src{pdf: pdf/src-bamlerzhang2019.pdf (the same authors, part II)}
src{pdf: pdf/src-simon2020.pdf (Simon, Extending four dimensional Ricci flows with bounded scalar curvature)}
src{pdf: pdf/src-bamler2018.pdf (Bamler, Convergence of Ricci flows with bounded scalar curvature)}
src{pdf: pdf/src-zhang2010.pdf (Zhang, Scalar curvature behavior for finite-time singularity of K"ahler--Ricci flow)}
src{pdf: pdf/src-endersmullertopping2011.pdf (Enders, M"uller and Topping, On type-I singularities in Ricci flow)}
The spatial picture descends from Einstein four-manifold theory: Anderson, Bando (with a correction), Bando--Kasue--Nakajima, and
Cheeger--Tian. The slices below are not Einstein, so the needed
statements are reproved under a scalar bound, retaining the Ricci forcing.
parmedskipnoindentThe outermost scale and the static functional.
Successive rescalings at a concentration point produce a finite rooted tree of
Ricci-flat pieces; the outermost nonflat vertex has a length scale a(t)
described below. The proof rules out contraction of a(t) while
allowing arbitrarily small descendants.
Retain the true metric through an annular collar of radius b=Na (N large,
fixed) and attach an ALE end in Euclidean quotient coordinates. The
renormalized Einstein--Hilbert functional is
[
E(g)=lim_{Dto∞}Big[int_{{r<D}}R,dmu_g-int_{{r=D}}
(∂_jg_{ij}-∂_ig_{jj})n_i,dS_deltaBig],
]
the mass term of Deruelle--Ozuch, Definition~4.2 and Proposition~4.4 of their
paper. It scales by the square of the length unit and its first
variation pairs the velocity with 1/2Rg-Ric. A companion study of path
selection on degenerating Ricci-flat trees proves the sequential ineuality
E=o(M) on each fixed
limiting tree (M the weighted, dimensionless Ricci error). The static input is
recorded below; the argument must verify the hypotheses for flow metrics and compare
the functional variation with spacetime Ricci energy.
src{pdf: pdf/src-deruelleozuch2025.pdf (Deruelle and Ozuch, A Lojasiewicz ineuality for ALE metrics)}
Two estimates drive the argument. On a nearly flat annulus the contracted
Bianchi identity removes the critical radial harmonic mode of Ric, improving
the annular decay beyond the dimensional r^{-2} rate so the loss outside the
collar is small against the energy inside. The exterior beyond the collar is
built as an analytic function of the metric on the one fixed material collar,
with the longer exterior entering only an error estimate; hence the extension
differentiates in time on patches without a smoothly varying tree. This rests
on the Saint-Venant relation of the Calabi complex (Khavkine) and on Korn
control modulo rigid motions (Ciarlet and Ciarlet), both used in the collar
construction below.
src{pdf: pdf/src-khavkine2017.pdf (Khavkine, The Calabi complex and Killing sheaf cohomology)}
parmedskipnoindentProof structure and conventions.
The static input is fixed first. The scale estimates, genuine orbifold limits,
finite trees, and the continuous scale a(t) follow, together with buffered
intervals on which a changes by a fixed factor with root length tending to
zero after parabolic normalization. The Ricci-equation estimates come next:
the exterior decay beyond the outermost scale, and the maximal and weighted
interior estimates controlling the root energy. The collar construction then
builds the exterior extension and its error. A final comparison of functional
variation with Ricci energy: an explicit lower bound cK^2 and upper bound
zeta_i(K+1)^2 force Kto0; then distances are preserved so the
curvature-radius maximum defining a is preserved, contradicting its
prescribed change, while absence of a concentration point gives a smooth
terminal metric and continuation on M.
Throughout, Delta=trnabla^2 and |A|_{k,r}=sum_{j=0}^k r^j|nabla^jA| (the
pointwise magnitude unchanged, derivatives scaled). Quotient-chart components
are Cartesian components on the Euclidean cover; constructions are equivariant
and descend. Constants may depend on a fixed finite differentiation order and,
after extraction, on a fixed finite tree; uniformity in a sequence index, length
or collar factor N is stated where needed, and a sequential little-oh is taken
after fixing the parameters in its statement.
parmedskipnoindentThe static input and its normalization.
Theorem~2.2 of the companion study on path selection is recorded here. Constants and small
exponents belong to one fixed limiting tree; no uniform exponent across trees is
needed.
parmedskipnoindentGeometric data and the functional.
Let T be a finite rooted tree of four-dimensional Ricci-flat spaces
(V_v,h_v). A vertex has one exterior end and one punctured end per child.
Every end carries Cartesian coordinates on a Euclidean annulus modulo a finite
subgroup of O(4) acting freely on S^3; the group on a joined end is
nontrivial, and the two groups on an edge are identified with a fixed orthogonal
identification included in the charts. Put tau=log r on an exterior end and
tau=-log r at a puncture. In vertex units,
h_v=delta+O(e^{-mutau})
on joined ends, with scaled derivatives, for some mu>0; the unjoined
exterior end of the root requires h_v-delta=O(r^{-q}) with q>1. Bounds
through order 20 suffice.
For an edge from a parent p to a child c truncate both end coordinates at
tau=L_e and identify the collars by
x_p=e^{-2L_e}x_c, a_c=a_pe^{-2L_e}, a_{root}=1.
The physical radius rho=a_vr agrees in both charts and
tau_p+tau_c=2L_e; the metric in vertex units is multiplied by a_v^2 in
physical units. Gluing the boundary faces with their compatible collars
produces the manifold.
Assume the sequence of metrics has all L_eto∞ and converges to h_v on
compacts of every open vertex, with uniform weighted Ricci control
|rho^2Ric|_jle CM
e^{-mutau},&joined half-ends r^{-q},&root exterior 1,&cores,
j=10,
with Mto0 (tensor magnitude physical; covariant derivatives scaled by powers
of rho). Decreasing mu or q is allowed.
Define, in physical root units,
E(g)=lim_{Dto∞}Big{int_{r<D}R,dmu_g
-int_{r=D}(∂_jg_{ij}-∂_ig_{jj})n_i,dS_deltaBig}.
All chart integrals are quotient integrals.
[Renormalization and first variation]
The functional (eq:E-def) is defined on the preceding metrics. For a
variation with the same root decay,
DE_g(dot g)=intbig<1/2Rg-Ric,dot gbig>_g,dmu_g.
It is invariant under diffeomorphisms isotopic to the identity whose root
displacement, with scaled derivatives along the isotopy, is O(r^{1-q'}),
q'>1. A global scaling by s, with a coordinate dilation restoring
delta, multiplies E by s^2. Under (eq:tree-ricci-error),
|E|le CM.
Proof.
On the root end write g=delta+p. The density obeys
R√(det g)=∂_i(∂_jp_{ij}-∂_ip_{jj})+O(|p||∂^2p|+|∂ p|^2),
the error O(r^{-2q-2}), radially integrable; this proves convergence. The
linear boundary term in the variation cancels the variation of the subtracted
integral, and remaining boundary products are O(D^{2-2q})to0; integration by
parts gives (eq:first-variation). For a Lie derivative the contracted
Bianchi identity kills the interior divergence and the boundary term vanishes by
the displacement decay, so the functional is invariant along the isotopy.
Differentiating the scaling law at s=1 with a compensating dilation (identity
in a fixed outer region, metric varied by 2g inside and O(r^{-q}) on the
tail, paired with an integrable Ric) gives 2|E|le CM, hence E=0 for
Ric=0.
[Static tree ineuality]
This is Theorem~2.2 of the companion study. For the fixed tree and sequences above,
E(g)=o(M),
and for M=0 it means E(g)=0.
parmedskipnoindentSmall-scale geometry and the outermost scale.
Throughout, (M^4,g(t)), 0le t<T, is the closed flow with |R|le C_R.
Constants may depend on the flow, T, and a fixed differentiation order.
parmedskipnoindentThe spatial curvature radius.
For a small cap l_0>0 and a material point x,
l(x,t)=sup{0<rle l_0:sup_{B_t(x,r)}|Rm|le r^{-2}}.
The definition uses the whole spatial ball. Then l is positive, continuous
before T, and 1-Lipschitz: |l(x,t)-l(y,t)|le d_t(x,y) (a ball of radius
r-d_t(x,y) at y lies inside the radius-r ball at x with a larger allowed
bound).
[Scale estimates and degeneration]
For a small cap and all sufficiently late times:
cr^4leVol_t B_t(x,r)&le Cr^4, int_M|Rm|^2,dmu_tle C,
|nabla^kRm|(x,t)&le C_kl^{-2-k},
|nabla^kRic|(x,t)le C_kl^{-1-k}.
The set {l<r} is covered by a bounded number of radius-Cr balls.
Distances converge uniformly to a compact metric quotient Z; off finitely many
concentration points the metric converges smoothly. Small-scale limits are
complete noncollapsed Ricci-flat orbifolds, smooth off finitely many genuine
orbifold points with nontrivial finite group acting freely on S^3; a nonflat
limit has one Euclidean quotient end with nontrivial group, a flat one is a
global Euclidean quotient with at most one exceptional point. Within each
cluster the maximal ineuivalent nonflat limits form a finite rooted tree with a
unique outermost entry, and the joining regions carry quantitative neck charts.
The proof occupies this section.
parmedskipnoindentHeat localization and two-sided persistence of the radius.
Fix the terminal time in the smooth part and use h-dependent conjugate heat
kernels of the fixed metric, then localize them on radius-h balls by a cutoff
chi equal to one on B_t(x,h) and supported in B_t(x,4h) with
|nablachi| and h|∂chi| bounded. The localized flow has bounded
curvature Ch^{-2} and bounded first spatial derivatives, so its kernel obeys
the Gaussian upper and lower bounds and the derivative estimates on the ball; a
conjugate heat function equals a positive multiple of this localized solution,
and continuity plus the terminal value at the pole give
Kle Ch^{-n/2}, Kge c'(s)h^{-n/2} on B_s(x,h), s<h.
The double integral bounds the backward heat flow L^1to L^∞ on
[t-h^2,t] and the forward heat flow L^∞to L^1 on [t,t+h^2] by
Ch^{-n/2}; together with the L^2 contraction and duality,
int v,dmu_tle Cint v,dmu_{t+h^2} for vge0. For nonnegative
u_s(x)=u(s,x) with |nabla u_s|^2le C_s, taking v=(u_s-u_t)_+ gives
int v,dmu_tle Cbig(√(|t-s|)+√(|t-s|),widetilde Cbig)
int|nabla u_{s'}|,dmu_{s'},
the form of Simon's backward uniqueness that needs only local bounds. For
t_0<s<t and u_s(y)=d_t(x,y), this fails unless d_t(x,y)ge c'd(s,y)-r.
Squaring and optimizing in r^2le cs gives spatial persistence
d_t(x,y)ge c'd_s(x,y)quadif d_s(x,y)le c''l_0.
For the effect on the curvature radius fix a coordinate energy e(t,·) for
the covariant components of Rm in a fixed initial normal chart, with
e(0,·)=sum_{jle12}|nabla^jRm|^2. For a small fixed beta>0 the
smoothing estimate sup_{B(x,r/2)}e(t)le C_zeta r^{-6}int_{B(x,r)}e(0)
together with volume and derivative bounds gives e(t)ge|Rm(t)|^2 and
|Rm(g(t))|le C'(sup_{B(x,r)}|Rm_0|^2+r^{-4}).
Applying this to rescaled flows gives the two-sided statement: if a ball has
curvature radius ge r at time t, the earlier slice at distance ge r has
curvature radius ge cr, and conversely (using the backward kernel).
Energy. With C_0 so that 1le R+C_0le C, the quotient evolution
gives (∂_t-Delta)|Ric|^2/(R+C_0)le C|Rm||Ric|^2-c|Ric|^4; the
volume derivative and Young's ineuality give, for
F=int|Ric|^2/(R+C_0), F'le Cint|Rm|^2-c'int|Ric|^4+CF.
Chern--Gauss--Bonnet int|Rm|^2le C+4int|Ric|^2le C+CF
(Chern's intrinsic proof of the theorem, with Simon's integral identity, and an
orientation cover if needed) and Gronwall bound F; this is (geom:volume-energy).
Bad set and fixed energy. If l(y)ge r and r^2|Rm|(y)geε, then the derivative bound gives |Rm|geε/(2r^2)
on B(y,cr) and int_{B(y,c'r)}|Rm|^2ge cε^2r^4; volume comparability upgrades this to a definite Ricci energy e_0>0 on a smaller ball. Now fix small rho and suppose {l<rho} needs more than M radius-Crho balls. Take a maximal family of disjoint unit balls centered at points x_jin{Crhole l<rho} chosen by the primitive x|-> l(x)psi(rho/l(x)); the derivative bound on this primitive gives disjoint definite-energy balls, and the slice energy bound yields Mle Ce_0^{-1}. Hence {l<rho} is covered by boundedly many radius-Crho balls, with the bound independent of rho.
Convergence of distances and volume comparison. For |t-s|le cr^2,
cover the bad set at the first time by bounded radius-Cr balls, replace visits
to enlarged balls by first-to-last visits (boundedly many endpoints, total cost
O(r) by (geom:persistence)), so that on the remaining path the
curvature scale is ge cr and the length changes by a factor 1+Cr since
|R|le C/r. Comparing both ways,
|d_t(x,y)-d_s(x,y)|le Cr(1+d_s+d_t), and taking rasymp√(|t-s|) gives
uniform convergence to a pseudodistance d_T and a compact quotient Z.
The slicewise L^3 bound int_{B(x,h)}|Ric|^3le Ch will also be needed. On
the shell {r_jle lle r_{j-1}}, |Ric|le Cr_j^{-1} and the bad-set
measure bound established just above gives measure le Cr_j^4, contributing
Cr_j. Summing the dyadic shells up to h yields Csum_jr_jle Ch.
In polar coordinates the polar Jacobian P and m=(∂_rlog P-3/r)_+
satisfy (m^5P)'le5|Ric|m^4P-7m^5P/r-(2/3)m^6P, giving
int m^6le Cint|Ric|^3le Ch and hence, since (P/r^3)'le mP/r^3,
(Vol B(x,h))/(h^4)le(Vol B(x,h/2))/((h/2)^4)+Ch^{1/2},
while polar integration including the cut measure gives Delta(d^2/2)le4+dm
weakly. Volume forms at two times differ by e^{pm C_R|t-s|}.
parmedskipnoindentSlice limits, cones, and quantitative necks.
Rescaled slices h_i^{-2}g(t_i) based at x_i with h_ito0, t_i↑ T
are precompact as length spaces (two-sided volume bounds bound the number of
disjoint balls); the bad-set cover has bounded cardinality so a diagonal limit
identifies a finite exceptional set S. Restricted maps are locally
bi-Lipschitz, extend by continuity, and preserve the injectivity radius bound, so
the limit is complete; smooth convergence off S gives a smooth Ricci-flat
metric there, called regular. Ball volumes converge and are regular
Riemannian volume. The polar defect vanishes and Bishop becomes exact on the
regular part of the limit.
The exceptional set cannot separate positive-volume regular components: a
supposed separation by S forces approximating minimizers through thin
neighborhoods; the polar ineuality and Fubini over the passage give
[
crhoVol(U)le CBig(Vol(N_{Crho}(S))+int mBig),
]
first take the sequence limit and then rho↓0 to contradict. Hence
the limit is a complete orbifold, singular only where point-picking gives
nontrivial concentrated curvature.
Write d for distance from a puncture (or a fixed point at infinity). Vanishing
annular energy rules out r^2|Rm|geε in a middle annulus (energy
cε^6 on a ball), and interior stationary estimates give the same for
every fixed scaled derivative. Then (4-Delta)(d^2/2)=0 distributionally with
Delta(d^2/2)=4 and |nabla^2(d^2/2)|=4, so nabla^2(d^2/2)=g and the end is
a cone dr^2+r^2g_L, L=S^3/Gamma for finite Gamma acting freely and
nontrivially (nontrivial group; two-sided volumes bound |Gamma|). Fixed-ratio
annuli are arbitrarily close to round quotient annuli, and overlapping annuli
identify the groups.
[Quantitative neck]
If a nonflat complete Ricci-flat limit with |Rm|le r^{-2} near a marked
point has 0<mu<sigma<1 and r_-<r_+, then for small r_-/r_+ and large
enclosing annulus, after decreasing mu,sigma,
|Rm|(x)le r^{-2}((r/r_+)^sigma+(r_-/r)^sigmabig),
r_-<r<r_+,
through all fixed scaled derivatives.
Proof.
Trim the boundaries by a fixed factor (otherwise a sequence of violating annuli
with escaping ratios contradicts smooth convergence). If the estimate fails,
choose approximate maximizers of r^2|Rm|/w_mu(r), w_mu(r)=(r/r_+)^mu+(r_-/r)^mu,
with ratios Q_ito∞ at s_i; both boundaries escape after dilation by
s_i^{-1}. Dividing the rescaled curvature by A_i=s_i^2|Rm|(s_i)to0 gives a
bounded divided tensor. The second Bianchi identity and
DeltaRm=Rm*Rm+nabla^2Ric* make the divided quadratic term vanish and the
forcing vanish on fixed annuli; interior elliptic estimates yield a nonzero
limiting Cartesian tensor H, harmonic and satisfying the uncontracted Bianchi
identity on the flat punctured cover. Spherical harmonics (radial powers j,
-j-2) and mu<1 leave only H=r^{-2}C for constant C; Bianchi then reads
x_iC_{jkab}+x_jC_{kiab}+x_kC_{ijab}=0 for all x, forcing C_{·· ab}=0,
contradiction. Derivatives follow by interior elliptic estimates; slowly varying
boundary coefficients are absorbed by decreasing mu.
parmedskipnoindentRemoval of punctures.
Work near a punctured orbifold point. A constant rescaling makes g(0)=delta;
(eq:neck-decay) gives |g-delta|=O(r^mu), |Dg|=O(r^{mu-1}),
|D^2g|=O(r^{mu-2}) on the lifted ball. Harmonic coordinates solve
∂_i(A^{ij}∂_jy^a)=0 with A^{ij}=√(det g),g^{ij} and
y^a=x^a on ∂ B_R; coercivity gives a variational solution, and after
rescaling a weak gradient estimate with C^{0,alpha} forcing O(R^mu) gives
|Dy-I|_∞=O(R^mu), so y is a diffeomorphism for small R. Uniqueness
makes it equivariant; recentering and a constant linear normalization give
D^ky=O(r^{1+alpha-k}) for kge2 and the same for the inverse. The
harmonic-coordinate metric obeys G-G(0)=O(r^alpha), DG=O(r^{alpha-1}),
D^2G=O(r^{alpha-2}).
Thus Gin W^{2,p} for all p<4/(2-alpha); take p_0=2+alpha/2>2. No
distributional point defect occurs (integration by parts across ∂ B_rho
has first-derivative O(rho^3) and second-derivative O(rho^{2+alpha})
terms). The harmonic-coordinate Einstein equation holds a.e.,
G^{ab}∂_a∂_bG_{ij}=Q_{ij}(G^{-1},DG,DG),
with Q quadratic in DG, Lemma~4.1 of DeTurck and Kazdan. For 2<p<4,
DGin L^{4p/(4-p)} and elliptic regularity improves the exponent,
p_{k+1}=2p_k/(4-p_k) with 1/p_k=1/2-2^k(1/2-1/p_0), reaching p>4
in finitely many steps; then Gin C^{1,beta}, and Schauder theory with
(eq:weak-einstein) gives smoothness. This fills the orbifold point without
integrability assumptions on Einstein deformations.
A trivial group is impossible: its smooth filling has near-Euclidean volume
ratios, which propagate (via (eq:almost-bishop), error O(h^{1/2})) to a
smaller complete nonflat limit at a point-picked center near the filled center;
letting the start ratio go to Euclidean forces at least Euclidean ratio on fixed
balls of that limit, while Bishop gives the opposite at regular centers and the
radial-Laplacian/Hessian argument forces a smooth flat cone, contradiction. The
end group of a nonflat limit is likewise nontrivial. A complete flat limit
develops to a global Euclidean quotient with at most one tip (finiteness of the
deck group from sheet counting and noncollapse; the only possible singular point
is the tip).
parmedskipnoindentTerminal convergence, empty set, finite trees.
For a compact set K off the finite exceptional set, nested compactness and a
fixed radius r control the whole remaining interval [t_i,T) by spatial
persistence and a finite cover, giving fixed charts, bounded derivatives, and
smooth terminal convergence (local injectivity gives one sheet). If the
exceptional set is empty, finitely many such charts bound curvature globally and
the DeTurck equation continues the flow past T (principal part
g^{ij}∂_i∂_jg after adding L_Wg); so only a genuine
concentration point needs work.
Call two nonflat small-scale limits equivalent if their scales have bounded
ratio and centers are a bounded distance apart in either scale. Each nonflat
limit contains a regular energy ball (orbifold filling, end decay, and the
stationary curvature bound give a ball of energy at least e_1>0). Such balls
for ineuivalent entries are disjoint in the slices; the total energy bounds the
number by C/e_1. Dilating to curvature maximum and ordering give an ancestor
relation with a unique maximal entry; recursively this is the finite rooted tree
of Theorem~thm:degeneration. Intermediate limits between consecutive
entries are flat, so a child is a cone tip; on the flat annuli lge cr and
(eq:ricci-improvement) gives r^2|Ric|_{k,r}le Cr, and
Lemma~geom:neck supplies the necks with positive decay and the matching
quotient groups (end variables tau_p=log(A/r), tau_c=log(r/(Ae^{-2L})),
tau_p+tau_c=2L realize exactly the static half-neck weights).
parmedskipnoindentThe outermost scale.
[A continuous outermost scale]
Fix a small c_*>0 and a bounded continuous psige0 with psi=0 on
[0,c_*], psi>0 on [2c_*,1], and set
a(t)=sup_{yinU},t),psibig(l(y,t)^2|Rm|(y,t)big).
After shrinking U the supremum is attained in the interior at every
late time; a is positive, continuous, and a(t)to0. For every sequence of
late times, a(t) and any maximizer represent the outermost nonflat entry, and
every other nonflat entry has scale at most C a.
Proof.
Normalized regular energy balls detect curvature: at max|Rm|=1 the derivative
bound keeps |Rm|ge1/2 on a fixed ball, and removing tip neighborhoods leaves a
point at positive distance from every tip with curvature radius bounded above
and below, so l^2|Rm|ge2c_* and l is comparable to the vertex scale. Near
the punctures l^2|Rm|<c_*/2 eventually (definite-energy balls would accumulate
against finite energy). Hence the integrand in (eq:root-def) is continuous
on a fixed compact interior set with an interior maximum, positive and continuous
in time; maximizing points go to the concentration point with lto0, so
a(t)to0. At a maximizer lge a/|psi|_∞, l^2|Rm|>c_*, and
lasymp a (else detection at another point forces a larger value). Any listed
nonflat limit has scale le Ca by the same detection, and the maximizing limit
shares its unique outer ancestor with the maximal list, so it is outermost.
parmedskipnoindentMotion on short intervals.
[Curvature radius along minimizing segments]
For any minimizing segment gamma at a late time,
l(gamma(s),t)ge cmin(l_0,s,D-s). Consequently, if d_t(x,y)le Ch,
|∂_t d_t(x,y)|le C'(1+log^+(h/l(x,t))+log^+(h/l(y,t))big).
Proof.
Otherwise centered subsegments of length 2h_i, h_i=√(r_iL_i), rescale
to minimizing segments with an interior point of vanishing curvature radius,
which is a genuine cone vertex with link S^3/Gamma of diameter <pi (two
orbits at distance pi force a singleton, contradicting freeness); blowing up
at the vertex gives chords contradicting minimality. The derivative bound
follows from |∂_td|leint_gamma|Ric|,ds, (eq:ricci-improvement),
and l(gamma(s))ge c(l(x)+s) on the halves.
[Uniform short motion]
Let h_ito0 and intervals J_i of length delta_i=o(h_i) tending to T.
Distances of size O(h_i) change by o(h_i) throughout J_i; a point with
lge ch_i retains lge c'h_i; regular charts at this scale change by
O(delta_i/h_i) with scaled derivatives.
Proof.
Dense retained material set from the summability of
int_Mlog^+(h_i/l) (bounded by Ch_i^4) and the volume bounds; on retained
endpoints (eq:distance-log) integrates to o(h_i) change; a first-crossing
argument keeps ranges bounded. Persistence of regular charts follows from the
two-sided curvature persistence and the metric-difference evolution.
[Time for a fixed scale change]
If a(t_i)/a(s_i)to1 along s_i<t_i<T with log(a(t_i)/a(s_i))to0 while
(t_i-s_i)/a(s_i)^2 stays bounded, then the root scale cannot change by a fixed
factor.
Proof.
Rescale lengths by a(s_i); the duration is o(a), so Lemma~lem:slow-motion
freezes the pointed root metric and its regular curvature. The radius defining
a converges on regular parts to the radius computed in that limit with tips as
stops, maximizers stay in a common bounded root range, and the rescaled supremum
of (eq:root-def) agrees at both times, excluding a fixed-factor change.
parmedskipnoindentBuffered intervals, motion, and exterior geometry.
[Buffered intervals]
Fix u>0 and choose t_0le t_1le...<t_N<T a maximal u-separated
sequence for -log a(t). Then Nto∞ and
theta:=inf_j(t_{j+1}-t_j)/(t_j-t_{j-1})>0.
Proof.
Successive gaps d_j satisfy d_j/a_j^2to∞ and d_jge ce^{-2uj} by
Lemma~lem:scale-change-time. A geometric lower bound and the maximality
prevent two consecutive tiny ratios beyond a fixed factor.
On a buffered interval I=[-theta,1+theta]d_j with endpoints t_{j},t_{j+1}
and d_j=t_{j+1}-t_j, in interval units g_{new}=d_j^{-1}g one has
|R_{new}|leε_i^2 with ε_i=√(d_i)to0,
a_i=a(t_j)/ε_ito0 throughout I (up to a fixed factor), and the root
scale at 0 and 1 differs by a fixed factor. By Lemma~lem:slow-motion,
geometry at length hlesssim1 moves negligibly over windows Delta t with
εDelta t/hto0; at root scale centers move O(a_i), at a_ill hlesssim1
by o(h) (a second concentration at separation h would give a larger nonflat
ancestor).
[Uniform exterior geometry]
Fix a high order k_{geo} and 0<mu<sigma<1. There are
N_{geom},C,c_{geom}>0 and R_i^{out}to∞ with
ε_iR_i^{out}to0 such that at every time in I the exterior admits
one equivariant coordinate system with
r^2|Rm|_{k_{geo},r}+|g-delta|_{k_{geo},r}le CΘ_i(r),
Θ_i(r)=(a_i/r)^mu+delta_ir^mu, delta_i=(R_i^{out})^{-mu}to0,
N_{geom}a_ile rle c_{geom}R_i^{out}, covering whole shortened
distance bands, group fixed after subsequence, ε_i=o(delta_i).
Proof.
Choose R_i^{out}to∞ with ε_iR_i^{out}to0. For
r_i/a_ito∞ with ε_ir_ito0 the maximal-tree and root-detection
arguments force a flat quotient annulus limit. This sequential flatness yields
one N_{geom} making all annuli close to flat uniformly. On these annuli
lge cr so r^2|Ric|le Cε_irle Cε_iR_i^{out}(r/R_i^{out})^sigma,
and Lemma~geom:neck with the fixed exponent mu (its constant uniform,
boundaries escaping under normalization) gives (eq:uniform-exterior) on
shortened annuli. Since ε_iR_i^{out}to0 and mu<1,
delta_i/ε_ito∞.
parmedskipnoindentConcentration estimates for the Ricci equation.
Let G=etaRicin C^2_0, eta a spatial cutoff of fixed width, maximal on the
N_1a-ball and supported in the 2N_1a-ball, and
a^4K^2=int_Ieta^2int_{B_t(x_t,N_1a)}|Ric|^2,dmu,dt.
In material coordinates the lower-index Ricci equation, the cutoff equation, and
the divergence constraint read
(∂_t-Delta_g)Ric_{ij}&=2R_{ikjl}Ric^{kl}-2Ric_i{}^kRic_{kj},
(∂_t-Delta_g)G_{ij}&=2R_{ikjl}G^{kl}-2Ric_i{}^kG_{kj}+eta'Ric_{ij},
nabla^ibig(G_{ij}-1/2g_{ij}tr_gGbig)&=0,
the last because eta is spatially constant. On a regular patch set
G_r=r^{-2}Phi_r^*G; then (eq:ricci-improvement) gives
|Ric|_{j,r}le C_jε/r, |r^2eta'Ric|_{j,r}le C_jε r,
so the cutoff source needs no division by eta.
The geometric inputs established above, taken sequentially, are:
(i) on regular charts with lge ch, coefficients move by
O(εDelta t/h) over windows; (ii) centers move O(a) at root scale and
o(h) for a/hto0; (iii) distance annuli Cale rle C' carry the quotient
charts of (eq:uniform-exterior) with error through any finite order bounded
by CΘ, Θ=(a/r)^mu+delta_ir^mu, ε=o(delta).
[Local smoothing with time L^p input]
On a regular parabolic patch normalized to unit radius and duration, with
uniformly elliptic scalar principal part and bounded coefficient derivatives, a
solution U with source F satisfies, for nested cylinders Q'Subset Q with
positive past margin and 1<ple2,
sup_{Q'}sum_{k=0}^j|D^kU|le CBig[(1/{|J|}int_J|U|_{L^2(Ω)}^pBig)^{1/p}
+(1/{|J|}int_J|F|_{H^{j+3}(Ω)}^pBig)^{1/p}Big],
the first input optionally the spacetime L^p norm of U; longer windows follow
by sliding unit cylinders.
Proof.
Spatial cutoff, integration by parts, Young, and pairing the source time-L^1
norm with the time supremum (absorbing half) give the L^2_tau H^{m+1} bound;
differentiating spatially, the top commutator absorbs and lower ones are bounded,
so m=j+3 with H^{j+3}↪ C^j gives exponent two for U and one
for F. The change to L^p_tau uses interpolation of the time L^2 norm
against the supremum plus Young's ineuality with nested margin weights.
Write P for the componentwise spherical average on a lifted quotient annulus
(it commutes with the flat heat operator and preserves equivariance).
[Radial ineuality for the oscillation]
Suppose PZ=Z, Z compactly supported in time, E=(∂_tau-Delta_delta)Z.
For 1<ple2, with z(s)=|,|Z(s,·,tau)|_{L^2(S^3)}|_{L^p_tau},
-z''-3/sz'+(3)/(s^2)zle|,|E(s,·,tau)|_{L^2(S^3)}|_{L^p_tau}.
For p=2 this holds for a Hilbert direct sum over charts/windows with the same
radial variable. Homogeneous comparison powers are s and s^{-3}.
Proof.
With w=|Z|_2, pairing against Z/w and convexity give
w_tau-w_{ss}-3s^{-1}w_s+3s^{-2}wle|E|_2; multiply by w^{p-1}, integrate
in time (boundary term vanishes), and use
int w^{p-1}w_{ss}le z^{p-1}z'' from differentiating
int w^{p-1}w_s=z^{p-1}z' and Cauchy. H"older bounds the source, division
proves the ineuality; zeros are handled by regularization.
L(s^-beta(beta+2))s^{beta-2} has zero exponents 1,-3.
[Control of the mean derivatives]
If T is a spatially constant multiple of Ric and the annular metric is
C^{j+1}-close to delta at scale e, then
sum_{k=1}^j s^k|nabla^kT|le C_jBig(sum_{k=1}^j s^ksup|D^kPT|+esup|T|_{j,s}Big)
on a fixed-width shell, with suprema on a fixed enlargement.
Proof.
The trace-reversal S=T-1/2deltatr_delta T=overlineoverline S(s)+PS;S(s)+PS; the
divergence constraint and flat divergence differ by a term bounded by
esup|T|_{k+1,s}, and radial differentiation of
overlineoverline S'_S'_{ij}n_i=E_j-∂_i(PS)_calE_j-∂_i(PS)_{ij} along coordinate vectors
bounds overlineoverline SS and its radial derivatives, hence the Cartesian derivatives.
Conversion to covariant derivatives adds only metric-error terms.
parmedskipnoindentThe exterior estimate.
For dyadic radii based on a let
A_t(r)={r/2le d_t(x_t,y)le2r} and
A(r)=|sup_{A_t(r)}|G||_{L^2(I)},
V(r)=|sup_{A_t(r)}{j=1}^mr^j|nabla^jG||_{L^2(I)}, m a fixed
high order.
[Exterior concentration bound]
There are fixed N_0gg1, r_0>0, alphain(0,min(mu,1)), and N_1 in
(eq:root-energy) such that
V(r)&le Cbig[(a/r)^{2+alpha}K+widetildedelta_i((a/r)^alpha+r^alpha)big],
A(r)&le Cbig[(a/r)^{2+alpha}K+widetildedelta_ibig],
N_0ale rle r_0, widetildedelta_ito0, widetildedelta_igeε.
Proof.
Fix a large dyadic H then T_0; use annuli of radii in [1/(cH),cH]r and
windows T_0r^2. The motion error at the smallest comparable radius is
Cε T_0Hrle C_{H,T_0}Θ(r), so metric error through all required
orders is C_{H,T_0}Θ on the window. Applying Lemma~lem:local-smoothing
on bounded-width patches and sliding windows bounds true-field derivatives by
C_{H,T_0}(max_{rhoasymp r}A(rho)+ε r) in L^2. On fixed-width
middle patches (past margin inside chi_elleuiv1), integrating z^2 against
s^3ds on a larger middle annulus and summing squares gives
V(r)le Cbig[H^{-3}V_*(r/H)+H^{-1}V_*(Hr)big]+(C_H)/(T_0)max_{rhoasymp r}V(rho)
+C_{H,T_0}big[Θmax_{rhoasymp r}A(rho)+ε rbig],
with V_* over fixed neighbors. Joining shells by paths of length Crho and
integrating nabla G telescopes:
A(r)le Csum_{rlerhole r_0}V(rho)+Cε, and boundary ranges have
A+Vle C_{H,r_0}ε (outer) and A+Vle C((a/r)^2K+ε r) (inner,
N_1 chosen to include the patches). The metric terms in the weighted sum use
Θ(r)/((a/r)^alpha+r^alpha)le(a/r)^{mu-alpha}+delta_ir^{mu-alpha};
increase N_0 for the first, then take late index for delta_ir^{mu-alpha},
absorbing into M/4. Choices are made in order H,T_0,N_0, late index; then
Mle C+M/2 proves (eq:exterior-v) and (eq:exterior-a).
parmedskipnoindentThe maximal function controlling the root.
Define the centered maximal function of f=eta|Ric|_{j+2,a} (with
f^p for 1<ple2): H_*(t)=(iint_{B_t(x_t,D_1a)}f^p)^{1/p} over the past
window, so that
H_*(t)le C_pBig[a^2big(int_Ieta^2int_{B_t(x_t,D_1a)}|Ric|_{j+2,a}^2big)^{1/2}+εBig]
le C_p(K+ε),
using |f|_2le C(K+o_i(1)) from the energy ball and the shell decay
(eq:exterior-a), and the weak-L^1 bound plus extrapolation
|Mv|_q^qle C_qint v^q (v=f^p, q=2/p).
[Interior estimate with a neck weight]
Extract a tree at times with eta(t)ne0. On its true compact and half-neck
pieces in B_t(x_t,D_0a), r the local regular length in I-units, for each
fixed order j,
(r/a)^2|G|_{j,r}(t)le C(H_*(t)+ε)e^{-nu D},
where D=0 on compact pieces and on a joining neck D is the minimum of the
logarithmic distances to the two ends; constants may depend on the tree.
Proof.
Compact/bounded-depth: apply Lemma~lem:local-smoothing over a past window
cr^2, L^2 input bounded by Cf, source le Cε; no exponential.
Deep neck: put h=e^{-4lambda D}, B=e^{lambda D}; the metric error through
all orders is e_D=Ce^{-delta D}, delta>3lambda (choose lambda with
min{mu(1-4lambda),1-6lambda,3-3lambda}>3lambda). Write
T_1=(r/a)^2G, Q=H_*+ε; sliding-window integration gives
sup_s|T_1|_{J,s}(t)le CQs^{-2} and the forcing at all orders. Applying
Lemma~lem:radial to Z=chi PT_1 with a large-window cutoff, the operator
and curvature error costs CQe^{-delta D}s^{-4} and the cutoff CQB^{-2}s^{-2};
the barrier CQ(e^{-delta D}s^{-4}+B^{-2}s^{-2}) gives the bound, and radial
integration of the first Cartesian derivative from B/4 plus the four positive
D-exponents 2lambda,(4-2/p)lambda,(2-2/p)lambda,delta-(2/p)lambda yield
(eq:interior-weighted) with nu below their minimum. The uncut bound
r^2|Ric|_{j,r}le Cε rle o_i(1)e^{-nu D} holds with nu<1.
parmedskipnoindentAn exterior extension determined by a fixed collar.
An exterior is attached to the true metric on a fixed annular collar, defined as
an analytic function of the collar data. Smoothness in the collar metric lets
the extension be differentiated in time without choosing a smoothly varying
tree; the far exterior enters the error estimate only.
All lengths are in collar units; C_1={1le|x|le2}/Gamma,
E={|x|ge1}/Gamma, Gammasubset O(4) finite acting freely on
S^3. For a fixed-ratio shell use
|v|_{H^s(r)}^2=sum_{j=0}^sr^{2j-4}int|∂^jv|^2 and
|v|_{C^s,r}=sum_{j=0}^sr^jsup|∂^jv|, and
|v|_{H^s_beta(E)} r^beta|v|_{H^s(r)} (filling a ball on
filled Euclidean space). Shells range over finitely many neighbors, with width
chosen once independent of the outer radius R.
[Collar extension]
There are sigma_*>0, R_*<∞, C<∞ such that for sigmalesigma_*,
Rge R_* there is a metric barbar hh on E with
|barbar h-h-delta|_{H^k_q}le C|g-delta|_{H^k(C_1)},
|g-barbar hh|_{H^k(C_1)}+|Ric(barbar h)h)|_{H^{k-2}_{q+2}}le Cm_1.
The map g|_{C_1}|->barbar h-h-delta is real analytic on a fixed neighborhood
of zero in collar H^k, with uniformly bounded first derivative into H^k_q,
independent of R, the weights, and the exterior. There is also an analytic
extension hathat hh equal to g near the inner boundary with the same bounds.
parmedskipnoindentLocal linear estimates.
With Sv,K(v) the flat linearizations of Ricci and Riemann curvature
and Bv=∂^iv_{ij}-1/2∂_jtr_delta v,
Sv=-1/2Delta v+1/2L_{(Bv)^sharp}delta, BSv=0,
DeltaK(v)= T(∂^2Sv),T(∂^2Sv),
SL_V K(K(L_V
[Local potential and Korn]
On a fixed Euclidean annulus/ball/overlap there is bounded linear
v|-> Pvin H^{k+1} with
|v-L_{Pv}delta|_{H^k}le C|K(v)|_{H^{k-2}},
|Pv|_{H^{k+1}}le C|v|_{H^k},
and for vector fields,
inf_{Wine(4)}e(4)|V-W|_{H^{k+1}}le C|L_V|_{H^k},
e(4)=e(4)={x|-> Ax+b:A^t=-A}. Choices are linear, normalized modulo
rigid motions, and equivariant; after dilation the first right side is multiplied
by r^2 and vector norms divided by r.
Proof.
Regard the linearized connection C^a_{ij}=1/2(∂_ip_{ja}+∂_jp_{ia}-∂_ap_{ij})
as a one-form in i (fixed a,j) with curl K(v); the Neumann gradient
projection writes it as dV^a_j plus an H^{k-1} error controlled by K(v);
symmetry in i,j and a second projection give C(v)-D^2V bounded in H^{k-1}
by C|K(v)|_{H^{k-2}}; then ∂_i(v_{aj}-(L_V{aj})=C^a_{ij}+C^j_{ia}
controls D(v-L_V, and Poincar'e plus an affine field of half a
constant symmetric matrix completes the estimate. For Korn,
2∂_i∂_jV_a=∂_ie_{ja}+∂_je_{ia}-∂_ae_{ij} with
e=S V controls second and higher derivatives; Poincar'e controls V modulo an
affine map whose symmetric part is controlled, leaving exactly e(4),e(4),
fixed linearly. Gamma-averaging preserves the bounds.
[Newton estimates]
For 0<q<2, Delta^{-1}:H^{k-2}_{q+2}(R^4)to H^k_q(R^4) is bounded. For
1<q<2, if hin H^{k-3}_{q+3} has int h=0 componentwise then
|Delta^{-1}h|_{H^{k-1}_{q+1}}le C|h|_{H^{k-3}_{q+3}},
and on an annulus of outer radius O(R), if Delta W=H, boundary strips control
W in scaled H^{k-2} by b_0, c_r=r^2|H|_{H^{k-4}(r)}, then
sup_r|W|_{H^{k-2}(r)}le CBig(b_0+sum_rc_rBig),
independent of the number of shells.
Proof.
Weighted Newton estimates for shell-supremum norms (compare Theorem~1.7 of Bartnik's paper on the mass of an asymptotically flat
manifold): split the kernel integral into inner, middle,
outer parts; the scaled interior estimate for Delta u=f gives all orders. For
(eq:zero-mass-newton) the zero integral permits the subtracted kernel and
q>1. For (eq:green-sum) the Dirichlet Green function obeys
|G(x,y)|le C|x-y|^{-2}; one shell contributes at most Cc_r everywhere, so the
maximum principle and local estimate give the shell-uniform bound.
parmedskipnoindentA filled-space inverse and the analytic map.
Let E_0 contain the exterior and the filled unit ball with one smooth
metric piece; if R is the outer radius use larger balls as needed. For
qge0 let |v|_{H^s_q(E_0)}{rge1}r^q|v|_{H^s(r)}, and set
X={vin H^k_q(E_0):v=E_0):v=L_V near the inner
boundary for some vector V},
Y={(v_1,f):Sv=f on C_1, Bf=0}.
The filling identifies X with the H^k collar modulo rigid motions,
and Bf=0 is imposed in the specified function spaces.
Define A:X, v|->(v|_{C_1},Sv), and the analytic
piecewise map Q: on |x|<1 take an inward harmonic extension f=Sw and its
Newton potential; on C_1 interpolate between Sp_1 and f with a fixed cutoff;
outside use the Newton potential; then replace the vector contribution by the
harmonic choice of Lemma~collar:potential and an analytic quadratic
correction. Q is real analytic and Q^2=Q, and
ALA=A,
where L:Y XcalX is the following bounded linear operator. On
the filled unit ball f^#=S(Ev_1), on C_1
f^#=chi Sv_1+(1-chi)f, outside f^#=f; set
u=Delta^{-1}(-2f^#) (Newton, Lemma~collar:newton),
Ld=u|_{E}+L_{V_d}delta with V_d from
Lemma~collar:potential applied to v_1-u|_{C_1} and extended linearly; it is
bounded, with
|v_1-(Ld)|_{C_1}|_{H^k}le C|K(v_1-u)K(v_1-u)|_{H^{k-2}(C_1)},
S(Ld)=Su.
For (eq:generalized-inverse) take d=Av, fill v by the same inward
extension to V on all of R^4. Then f^#=SV, Bf^#=0, so Bu=0 and
Su=f^#; K(V-u)K(V-u) is entire harmonic and decaying, hence
K(v-u)=0calK(v-u)=0 on C_1, giving (Ld)|_{C_1}=v and S(Ld)=Sv. Filling the
hole is essential (a decaying harmonic field on the punctured exterior need not
vanish).
Set Q=LA; (eq:generalized-inverse) gives Q^2=Q and AQ=A, and a
linear operator A':imQtoX with A'Q=1 identifies
imQ with X, transporting A and the real analytic Q
to A and a real analytic B with AB=1, imB=ker A=imQ.
A bounded linear N:N:E XcalX with
Nv=P_V( v) for a fixed compactly supported phiequiv1 on
C_1 and the H^k collar projection makes a small closed metric family
solvable, real analytic in the data. The metric barbar h=(1-Bh=(1-BN)
depends analytically on the collar data with the stated bounds, and the extension
is independent of the exterior realizing the collar.
parmedskipnoindentA comparison gauge and the residual.
For tensors on 1le|x|le R there are linear P_0, Dz= L_calL_{P_0z}delta,
zero on C_1, with
|z-Dz|_{H^k(r)}le CBig(r^2max_{rhoasymp r}|K(z)|_{H^{k-2}(rho)}
+mathbf1_bf1_{rle C_0}|z|_{H^k(C_1)}Big),
C_0 a fixed width. On roomy dyadic overlaps Lemma~collar:potential gives
local v_j; on overlaps v_{j+1}-v_j=A_jx+w_j with A_j skew, Gamma-commuting,
|w_j| controlled by the local errors; there is no equivariant translation.
For a radial partition the strain has only neighboring differences, so P_0z has
length-independent bounds; D^2= DcalD and D is bounded
for the weight n(z)=sup_rtheta_r^{-1}|z|_{H^k(r)}. One may write
P_0z=J(x)x+U(x), J^t=-J, Jgamma=gamma J, J=U=0 on C_1, with
sup|J|le Csigma n(z) and |J|, r^{-1}|U| controlled by theta_rn(z).
Using this gauge (a comparison device only) the metric is close to Euclidean,
with p:=F^*g-barbar hh satisfying Dp=0, p|_{C_1}=p_1, and
[
Y:=sup_{rle R}r^{-2}|p|_{H^k(r)}le C(e+X),
X:=sup_{rle R}|K(p)|_{H^{k-2}(r)}.
]
The coordinate Ricci formula and the gauge give
Sp=T-Ric(barbar h)+E_2=T+f+E_2h)+E_2=T+f+E_2 with |E_2|_{H^{k-2}(r)}le Ctheta_rY
(nonlinear terms |N(v)-N(w)|le Cr^{-2}(|v|+|w|)|v-w|, both first
factors O(theta_r), last r^2Y), giving the residual bound
|T|_{H^{k-2}(C_1)}+sum_{rle R}sum_{j=1}^{k-2}|r^j∂^jT|_{H^0(r)}
le Cbig(m_1+sigma N_0+R^{-q-2}big).
Run L on d_1=(p_1,f), e=|d_1|_{Y}; ALd_1=0. It remains to show
d_1-ALd_1 is small. With u=Delta^{-1}(-2f^#),
|Bu|_{H^{k-1}_{q+1}}le CD_0 (D_0=m_1+sigma e), and
Su-f^#=1/2L_{(Bu)^sharp}delta gives
|Su-f|_{H^{k-2}_{q+2}(E)} CD_0.
Fill p by Ep_1 to P on the full ball and let W=K(P-u);K(P-u); on the
filled inner ball SP-f^#=0, on the collar bounded by CD_0, so the shell sum
of Delta W=T(∂^2S(P-u))T(∂^2S(P-u)) is le C(m_1+sigma e), with the
filled ball contributing one fixed term. At radius R,
|W|_{H^{k-2}(R)}le C(m_1+eR^{-q-2}), and the filled-ball Green sum with the
fixed-scale estimate near C_1 gives
|K(p_1-u)K(p_1-u)|_{H^{k-2}(C_1)}le Cbig(m_1+(sigma+R^{-q-2})ebig),
with no inner boundary term proportional to e. Combining with
(eq:L-residual) and ALd_1=0,
|d_1-ALd_1|_{Y} C(m_1+(sigma+R^{-q-2})e); choosing sigma_*
small and R_* large makes the e-coefficient at most one half, hence
ele Cm_1 with length-independent constants, proving (eq:collar-extension).
An interpolation hathat h=h=barbar h+h+zeta(g-barbar h)h) with a fixed radial zeta
gives the analytic extension hathat h.h.
parmedskipnoindentFunctional change and the contradiction.
Apply the results to a buffered interval I=[-theta,1+theta] in rescaled
time, ε_i=√(d_i), a=a_ito0; the root scale is comparable to a
on I and its values at 0 and 1 differ by a fixed factor. |R|le Cε_i^2.
Fix the small collar tolerance and a large fixed dyadic Ngg N_1, b=Na; all
limits are with N fixed. Constants multiplying N^{-2alpha}K^2 are
independent of N; those multiplying o_i(1) may depend on N.
[Position of a controlled material collar]
Choose small sigma_0>0 and large fixed N. Choose an exterior annular chart
at scale b with domain {1/8<|x|<16}/Gamma near suppeta and keep its
material map and group fixed. For late i, throughout any interval on which its
metric stays within sigma_0 of flat through the required order: every
shortened collar is at distance comparable to b from x_t; its middle bands
cover the shortened distance annuli; and the inner side of a middle sphere
contains B_t(x_t,N_1a) and lies in B_t(x_t,Cb).
Proof.
Initial properties hold by annular convergence. Suppose the positional assertion
fails for small tolerances and large N. Then
there are late times, tolerances tending to zero and numbers Nto∞ along
which the fixed chart violates it, and the chart still lies near the same
isolated point of Z. At scale b, Theorem~thm:degeneration
gives a complete flat quotient limit (a nonflat limit at this large scale would
contradict outermostness); smooth compactness extracts the chart maps into its
regular part and a limiting local flat isometry. Groups are fixed after passing
to a subsequence (close orthogonal representations are conjugate by averaging and
a polar factor), the source group is nontrivial and free, the target is a global
Euclidean quotient with at most one tip, lifting to Euclidean covers gives a
rigid motion whose translation vanishes by the nontrivial free spherical action.
There is no multiplicity (two interior points would have an o(b) path). The
tip must be o(b) from x_t; otherwise the separation-scale limit has two
genuine tips at distance one, hence is nonflat at scale h_i/a_ito∞,
contradicting outermostness. Crossing the radial bands and a fixed outward
material point identify the geometric and material inner components.
At each time complete exterior coordinates agree with the fixed chart on C_1;
the transmission with the fixed chart has weight theta_rle C((sigma_0+N^{-mu})r^{-mu}+delta_i(rb)^mu),
1le rle4R, Rbasymp r_*, with the first dyadic sum small and the second
tending to zero. Coordinates outside C_1 are used only for the error.
A bound B_1(t) for |Ric|_{k+4,b} on a fixed ample band around x_t (chart
independent by suprema over choices) defines
u(t)=int_{t_*}^t(1+B_1)ds and, by first exit,
|g(t)-g(s)|_{C^{k+3}}le Cint_s^tB_1. A smooth partition in u gives
sum_jchi_j=1 near suppeta with sum_j|chi_j'|le C(1+B_1) a.e. On
each patch, retain the true metric inside and extend by Theorem~thm:collar-extension;
the extension hathat g_jg_j has functional E_j.
[Time-integrated collar error]
The residual is bounded by a common m(t) with
sup_{suppeta}m=o_i(1),
b^{-2}|eta m|_{L^2(I)}+|eta B_1|_{L^2(I)}le Cbig[(a/b)^{2+alpha}K+rho_ibig],
rho_ito0.
Proof.
In collar units (eq:ricci-improvement) bounds Ricci and scaled derivatives
on the radius-r shell by Cε b/r; the r^{-1} sum is bounded, weights
theta_r are summable, and theta_R/R^2to0. For the L^2 bound, V(rho)
and theta_rA(rho) control the terms and the leading energy sums give
C(a/b)^{2+alpha}K with the stated errors.
[Positive variation]
[
sum_jint_Ieta^2chi_jE_j',dtge2a^4K^2-a^4big[CN^{-2alpha}K^2+o_i(1)(K+1)^2big].
]
Proof.
On the retained true part
<1/2Rg-Ric,∂_tg>=2|Ric|^2-R^2, containing
B_t(x_t,N_1a) of volume at most Cb^4, so the scalar-square loss is
o_i(a^4). On the collar and end Ric(hathat g_j)g_j) and ∂_thathat g_jg_j obey
the collar weights; normalizing the collar multiplies the covariant tensor by
b^{-2}, giving the tail bound Cb^2mB_1int_1^∞ r^{1-2q}drle Cb^2mB_1
(here q>1 is used). Summing against chi_j and Cauchy--Schwarz,
[
Cb^2|eta m|_2|eta B_1|_2le Cb^4big[(a/b)^{2+alpha}K+rho_ibig]^2,
]
whose leading factor is b^4(a/b)^{4+2alpha}=a^4N^{-2alpha}; the rest is
o_i(a^4)(K+1)^2. The positive core term is at least 2a^4K^2 by
(eq:root-energy).
[Uniform functional smallness]
For fixed N there are zeta_ito0 with
|eta(t)E_j(t)|lezeta_ia^4big[H_*(t)+1+a^{-2}eta(t)m(t)big]
at every time in every active patch.
Proof.
Verify the static hypotheses after choosing t_i with eta>0 and active j_i,
rescaling by a_i. Theorem~thm:degeneration and
Proposition~prop:root-scale extract a finite rooted tree (all smaller
concentrations lie inside the collar, else a larger nonflat entry), and
Theorem~thm:tree-ineuality applies: compact and joining regions have the
sequential identifications with one-sided half-neck weights, and the new root
exterior has uniform O(r^{-q}) control with q>1. Let M_i bound the weighted
Ricci error; choosing the internal weight exponent below both the half-neck and
(eq:interior-weighted) exponents makes M_ito0 without eta. Elsewhere
(eq:interior-weighted) gives
eta(t_i)M_ile C_{ext}a_i^2(H_*(t_i)+ε_i)+C_{ext}eta(t_i)m(t_i).
Then |E_i^{root}|=o(M_i), E_{j_i}(t_i)=a_i^2E_i^{root}, and
[
frac{|eta E_{j_i}|}{a_i^4[H_*+1+a_i^{-2}eta m]}le C_{ext}frac{|E_i^{root}|}{M_i}to0.
]
A uniform failure of (eq:functional-littleoh), with active times, would give
the opposite on a subsequence, contradiction.
Along the buffered intervals, K_ito0.
Proof.
Each eta^2chi_j has compact support in its patch, so integration by parts
gives sum_jinteta^2chi_jE_j'=-sum_jint(2etaeta'chi_j+eta^2chi_j')E_j,
bounded by Czeta_ia^4int[H_*+1+a^{-2}eta m][|eta'|+eta(1+B_1)]. With
a^{-2}=N^2b^{-2}, Minkowski and (eq:maximal-ricci),(eq:collar-time-bound)
bound this by o_i(a^4)(K+1)^2. Fix N with CN^{-2alpha}<1; then
K_i^2legamma_i(K_i+1)^2, giving K_ile√(gamma_i)/(1-√(gamma_i))to0,
and boundedness of K in passing.
parmedskipnoindentSmall energy fixes the root geometry.
With K_ito0, the pointed root geometry is preserved: for x,y in a small
neighborhood of the concentration point and d_t(x,y)le Ca, integration of
a^{-1}|∂_td_t|le CQ_*[1+a/l(x,t)+a/l(y,t)] (from the geodesic
curvature-radius estimate and (eq:interior-weighted)) over the interval
shows the scaled distance changes by o(a) (a first-crossing argument keeps
bounded ranges). Thus the rescaled distance functions converge, and the
curvature-radius maximum defining a is preserved across I, contradicting the
prescribed factor change. Hence a buffered interval with fixed-factor change
cannot exist, so no concentration point survives.
parmedskipnoindentContinuation.
Absence of a concentration point gives a smooth limiting metric on M at T
(finitely many curvature-bounded charts, the DeTurck principal part, and the
metric/connection evolution), and the DeTurck equation started there continues the
flow on M past T with matching spatial derivatives. Retaining the given flow
for t<T and this solution for tge T produces a smooth Ricci flow
widetilde g on Mtimes[0,T+ε) with widetilde g=g for t<T,
proving Theorem~thm:extension. The argument uses arbitrary smooth initial
data in real dimension four and continues on the original manifold, not an
orbifold.